Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3302 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(SPecial Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE SIXTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K. SARATH
WRIT PETITION NO: 30845 0F 2025
Between:
Mannem Jhansi, D/o. M.Veera Reddy, Age 38 years, Occ' Un employee,
R/o. 'l-9-135, Housing Board, Miryalaguda, Nalgonda District.
...PETITIONER
AND
The State of Telangana,, Rep. by its Chief Secretary to Government General
Administration Oep?rtment, Dr.B.R. Ambedkar Telangana State Secretariat,
Hyderabad.
The Telangana State Public Service Commission', Rep. by its Secretary'
Nampally, Hyderabad.
..,RESPQNDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be
pleased to issue a writ order or direction especially one in the nature of writ of
mandamus declaring that a) the action of the 2nd Respondent in not including the
Hall Ticket number of the Petitioner (H.T.No.240905843)in the result Notification of
Group-|, daled 24.09.2025 is illegal, arbitrary and unreasonable and is violative of
Article '14, 16 and 21 of constitution of lndia. b) further declare that, inclusion of
the Hall Ticket numbers of less meritorious candidates among those selected
under E.w.s. reservation while omitting to including the Hall Ticket number of the
Petitioner is illegal, arbitrary and unreasonable c) further declare that as the
Petitioner has applied in pursuance of Notification No.412022, dated 26.04.2022
and Notification No.212024, dated 19.02 2024 and her Hall Tickets clearly show
that she applied for and claimed E.W.S. reservation and as the Petitioner
produced relevant lncome/ E.W.S Certificate at the time of verification' she was
lw
t
entifled to be considered and selected for appointment in preference to the
candidates who seems lesser marks or merit and non-consideration of her
candrdature in the selection process after the certificate verification stage is illegal,
arbit6ty and unreasonable and, therefore, violation of Article 14, 16 and 21 of the
Constitutron of lndta d) declare that Petitioner is entitled to be setected and
appointed to the posts in one of the Grade-l service based on her merit/ rank/
marks as an E.W S. candrdate e).
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Sectron 15'1 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavrt filed rn support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the 2nd Respondent to forthwith forward the selection of the Petitioner to the .lst
Respondent for appointment to one of the Grade-l posts based on her merit/ rank/
marks among the E W.S candtdates if any persons scoring less than her was
included rn the result Not fication dated 2410912025, pending disposal of the Writ
Petitron.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI M. SURENDER RAO, SENTOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI RAMA RAO KILARU
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SMT. M. SHALINI, GP FOR SERVICES ll
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRI P.S. RAJA SEKHAR, SC
The Court made the following: ORDER
-;a:;
j,-
SK,.]
W. P. No.308.+5 of 2O25
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SARATH
W.P.No.3O845 of 2025
Date:
.03.2o26
Be tu'een
Mannem.Jhansi
..
Petitioner
And
Ttrc State of Telangana and another.
...
Respondents
ORDER:
This writ petition is hled questioning the acLion of
the rcspondent No.2 in not including the petitioner's name
in thc sclection list under Economicalh, Wcaker Scction
quota in pursuance to the Group-l Notification vide
Notillcation No.2/2024 dated 19.O2.2024 and inclusion
Icss meritorious candidates as iilegal and arbitrary and
declare that the petitioner is entitled to be selected and
appointed to the posls in 6ne of thc Graclc-l scrvice based
on her mcrit/rank/marks as an E.W.S candidate
*.t.*..aUrO,
2.
F{cari1 Sri M. Surcnder Rao,
"r35)i
learned Senior Corrnscl
lor Sri *arner *.o Iiilirru. learned cour-rscl
lirr the petitioncr.
Smt M. Slralini. lcar-necl Governmsnt pleadcr
for thc r-csp()n(l(,,r1 No. 1 and Sri I,
-
for Serwices_ll
S.Raja Sckhar, learncd
Standing Corrnst_.I lrtr thc rospondent
No.2.
CONTENTIO NS OF THE PETITI ONER
3.
Lcarrrc<l S<rnior Counsei lor the petitioncr
submits
that thc p<:tirionc,r is a post Graduate and belongs
to O.C
Catcgotv arr<l I:,r:or-rr,- i.ullv Wcaker Scction (for
brr:r,it,y
'trWSJ. I)ur.su:r nr to the Notification No.4/2022
26.O4.2O22 issur.cl br the respondent No.2
datcd,
inviting online
applications ll-orrr tlrc <1ualified applicants to
the post of
Group-l sor\.r(.es ir-r the State of Telangana, the
petitioner
made onliltc appltcartion under reservation of
Economically
Weakr:r S.cti.,s a,rl r_rpl,adccl hcr certificate
mentioncd at
Clause XV of' sr. b.l)at.a 10 ol para IV apart
certificates. Shc has appcared for preliminary
16 lO,2022 ar.r<l thc same was cancelled
from other
test held on
due to leakage of
papcr. ()r'r instrur:tions of the respondent
No.2. thr:
SK, J
W. P.No.30845 ot 2025
pctitioncr has again appeared for the preliminaqr test.
Subsequcntlr,, Lhe respondent No.2 has cancelled
Notilication No.4 12022 and issued fresh Notification
No 212024 dated 19.02.2024. In responst: to Lhe same the
pctitroncr madc online application undcr trconomically
Weaker Sections, appeared lor preliminary test and
qualiliecl lor main examination and
in the main
cxarninaLion sccured a general rank of 4l8 and securcd
458.500 out of 900 marks. The respondent No.2 issued
Notification for verification of certihcates and the narne of
thc pt--titioncr w'as figured in thc said Notitication and the
petitioner has submitted an attestation form on 15.04.2025
arrd also submitted basic information data (checklist) on
16.0,4.2025 and thc acknowledgment indicated thal she
has submitted all the certificates
Lcarncd Se nior Counsel lor ttrc pctitioncr further
submits lhal- the respondent No.2 publishcd a resuit
notification on its website ol 24.09.2025 containing the
I'lalt TickeL numbers of 562 candidates, but the Hall Ticket
SK..]
W.l'.No 30845 oi 202 5
number ()f petitrorler does not figure in the said
Nolification. F{r' strbrnits that as the petitioner applied lor
Group I Sclviccs undcr E.W.S. reservation, qualified for the
ccrtificatcs ,,,crilictrtion and
produccd relevant
Incomc/l!.W.S c:e rtificatc at thc timc of verilication, sl-rc is
er-ititled to bc r.or-rsidcrcd for appointment in prelcrcncc to
the canclidirtcs ri.ho soctms lesscr mzrrks or mcrit and non_
considerittlon of hcr candidature in the selection proccss
alter cer.tificat<:. r,erification stage as illegal and arbitrary
and requ<:sted r.o allou' the writ petition.
CONTENTIONS OF THE RESPONDENTS
5.
l,curncd St:rncling Counsel for the respondent No.2
basing orr tltc coLlntcr submits that as per thc impugncd
rccruitmc.t Nr>til'ic:rti.n Nct.2/ 2024, the Incomc certificatc
lor thc firra'rcia1 r'ear prior to the 1,ear of application issucd
b-r, the revcnu(. authorittr:s
.ot belo*, the ralk of Tahsildar
v,orking ur-rclcr 'Ir:langana Governmcnt in the namc
candidarc u'ith totar income or the famil! berora, g
claiming liWS rcscrvdtion r.rras lcrr the year
o[ thc
lakhs ror
2022-23 and
)
SK, J
W.l' No.30845 of 2025
valid for the year 2023-24, but the petitioncr has submitted
IIWS Certificatc issued for the ycar '2021'2022 obtained
thorough Mcc Scva and lurthcr sht: has submittcd
manually issued trWS Certificate for the ,vear 2022-2023 at
the timt: o[ certilicate vcrilicalion, r,t'hicl-r arc noL rn
accordance u,ith the Government ordcrs and failed to
submit appropriate certificate lor EWS category as
prescribcd in thc Notification. Thc FIWS Ccrtilicate
produced by thc pctitioncr is in conl-ravcntion of lhe
prevailing policy of thc Govcrnment as communicated vide
Memo No. I 1793/Scr.lllA1 12024 datcd lO.0(t.2024 ol the
Principal Sccretary Rcvenuc
6.
The learned Standing Counsel further submits that
the pctitioner [ras mcnl-iotlcd in ht:r applications undcr
EWS Column as YE,S' but she has lailcct Lo posscss EWS
Mee Seva Certilicat.e at
application
AS
the timc of submission o[
rcquired u nder para 7 ol thc Notification
under the heading of 'How to Apply' in point 7.2(dl. The
OC candidates who have clairned rescn,ation under EWS ir-l
B
SK. J
\Ar.l'] No.3O845 of 2025
the applicatior-r :rn<r ,ro'ision?rlh s.rc.ted
certifir:alr:s havc ,O sultr-nit EWS Ce
Yczn- 2O2).1.3 ar:c.l rLrc pr:titiorrcr
r.tiiicate lbr thc Financial
or-rght to have taken the
trWS ccrlific.irt(, ;)1 1l.rr, tirnr: of submission
follon,ing thc dir.cLi.,s issucd i.
,br vcrification of
of application by
thr: Notifir:ation aL para 7
of 7.2(dl urrdcr' 'llorr. to appll,, T6c pctitioner
obtaining
suc^ ccrtifir':rtt' irfl r'r- il,rounccm<:nt .f (ic,eral
Merit List
and at th<. tirnc oi l)oc:untcnt \.crrficiLLion
which is contrary
to tl-re Rurlcs :rn d hr:r candidaturc was not
considered
against EWS rlrrol,r
l,ca.rrcrl Sitarrrrli'g Cotr,sr:i fi-rrthr:r
submits that the
data of a c:rndidrrtc Iikc Namc. I)atc of. birth,
etr;.. u,rll lrc r:x lt.,rc.tccl Iiom tht. ().1 lt Ibrm
candidatr-_ ltas ro llll onlv
reservation
onl_y and Lhc
thc ltartir:ul:rrs pcrtaining to a
particular post dctails in his/her respective
application.
and 1i-rc cirnclicl:rr,, lrrs lo uploircl tl_rc rclcvant
documents.
'rhc (gmmissjorr ri ril corrsidcr
thc apprication data at the
initial stagc, l) u r la t cr at the time of process
of certificate
'crilicaliott. tlrc rla1,, of thc :r1;plication is checkcd with the
S K, .,'
W.l'. No.30845 of 2O2 5
I
I
I
original certificates and then only accepl the candidates
I
candidatur(:. Irt vie',r'oI thc szrrnc, pl-oviding rcscrvations l-o
the candidates is lhe policl'dccision ol Lhc (]ovcrnment and
TGPSC being a recruitment agency fbllows scrupulously
the GOs/Guidelines etc issued by the Government from
time to time in the rccruit.mcnt proccss rrnd'l'(iPSC cannot
act contrary to thc policl' decisions o[ tht: Govcrnmcnt and
the Commission Lakcs up rccruitmcnls as por lhe terms
and conditions of the Notrtlcation and as pcr Lhc rclcvant
GOs/Circulars/Guidelincs issued by thc (]ovcrnmcnt from
time to time. The respondents rightly rcjecLcd the case ol
the petitioner and requ('srcd to dismiss Ihc writ petition'
il
Lcarned Stancling Counscl has rclicd on the
following .Iudgmcnts;
rl
7. Divga Vs. (Jnion of Indiat '
2. union Public Service Commission us. Gaurau Singhz
3. K. Thirupati Vs. The State of Telangana3
\ ('2021) | SCC ,148
! l'2o241 2 SCC 605
r 2025 (3) r\L'l (NRC) I7 I (l).lJ)
SK .i
\{, l, No.it0il 15 of 20 2 5
co r.rslpEB4Tro N Ai\lD FrNlrNGs
Altt:r lrerring both sides and perusing
on recorcl. this (,lorrrt is of thc considercd
pursuance to th,' r.cr:ruitmcnl Notification
the material
vienr that in
No.2 12024 dated
19.O2.2021 issr-rt:d l>r, the respondcnr
No.2. the petitioner
participated i. th. s<'rct'tio, proccss f.r
Group_r Serwices.
1O.
'l'hr' gricvarrcc ol thc pctitioncr
rs that her
candidatrtrc u,.as, ilol cr;nsidcreci lr-r, thc respondent
No.2
under thc r:atcqor-r ol EWS in spitr: of submitting
rr:lr:r'a.t .c1.1 ifi(.ir.l (. lrr, Itcr ar.rd ap,ointccl
the
t'c candidates.
u'ho havc sc(.ur-(.-l lcssr:r- marks lhan hc,r
11.
'l'ltc crrrr:i:rl
1;oirrl for consir.lcr:rtiorr tn t hc instant
u'rtl p<.tltiotr is. rrlrr,tl-rcr- thc IiWS c<:rtificate produced
by
the pctitroncr ts irr consonance u,ith the impugned
Notrlication or n(_jt ?
SK,.J
W.I']. No.30845 ol 202 5
L2.
The contention o1 the respondcnts
IS
that at the
time of submitting application, rhe pctiLioner claimed trWS
but failed to upload the relevant documcnt as mandated in
the impugned Notification. As pcr rhc documcnts filed by
the petitioner along with thc u,rit ailldarrir, it shows that in
pursuance to the earlier recruitment Notification No,.4 of
2022 da|ed 26.O4.2022, th<: pcrir.ioner submitl<:d C)ne Time
Registration Form dated 14.O1.20'22, r,,,,trich is at page
No. 120 of the writ material papers, u,herein the petitioner
slated against thc Column i.e. 'Do vor_r Claim ,EWS', she
stated as 'No'. In thc appJir::rtion submitted b_v thc
petitioner in pursuance to said Notilication, the petitioner
claimed as 'EWS' and sl'rc also uploadcd the document
But when the petitione r submitlcd application
on
29.04.2024, in pursuance Lo the Norilication No.O2 ol
2O24, dated 19.02.2024, agair-rst thc column
Do you
Claim EWS, she satcd'Yes', rvhich is iilcd at Page No.130
of the Writ material papers. In thc SATT)C applical.ion aL
Pagc No.l3l, in Lhe Column of 'Othcr Details,, i.e. ,Do you
SK, J
w l'. No.3O8.15 of 2025
have II\[/S <rcrtilicaic issucd b1. thr: competent aulhority
'l'ciangana St:rtc:'. s1-rc stated ycs,,
of
but .rot uplo:tdecl thc
dor:umcnt
13.
'l'1-r<: ccr-rtcnl ion of thc
petitioner ls that, the
petiLioner bclorrgs to trWS categor.y and the
compctent
authorit-r. also issucd trWS certificate lor the financial
year
2022-2023 as thc gross annual income ot. hcr familv
is
bclorr. [is.8 t,akhs
14. On tl-rc oLhcr hand, the contenticn ol- the learned
Standing Couns,cl for the responclents
IS
ce rtilicert.c prodlrcr:rl b-r, the pctitionr:r is
nol rrr consonance
that. the EWS
rvith the Para No.7 (2) ol the Notification No.4 of
15. Tht' i)ar:r Nos.zl and 7 ol ttrc impugnccl Notilication
dcals r.r,itlt llc sc rr,,:r ior-r a,d LIort, to applr,. l.l,rc rcle
portions of titr: s:rid paras arc extractecl as under.
11484 Ne.4 - RESERVATToN
xxx
vant
SK, .J
W. P. No.30845 of 2025
4. 10. Econr;micallv Weake r Sctcltons (liWS) reservatton ts
applicable as per G.().ms.No 2'l ) and '244, (iA (St'lR.D)
Department dated 2.1.08. 202 1
xxxx
4.L2.
lncome ccrtilicatc lor l ttc l'in:rnci:rl Ycar prior t-, r
year
ol applrcation issrrr:cl bv thc Rcvcrtuc Authorities
the
not below thc rank of Tahsildar, r,r'orkrng undcr Tclangana
Government in the narne ol thc candidate u ith total
incomc of the family lor r:[aimitrg I']WS re se rv;rtii-rrt.
PARA No.7 - HOW TO APPLY
7. 1 HOW TO UPLOAD THE APPLICATION FORM:
7.2 Those Candidates who have applicd e:rrlit'r'lbr (iroup I Serviccs
vide Notification No. 04 /2O22 Dt. 26 l 04,/ 2O22 (nor.t, canct llcd) NElit)
TO LOGIN and RE-APPLY for this Notrliclrtiorr ,\l'RI'lSl L Other\\'ise
their candidature will not be r:onsrciurcrl lirr tl'ris Notificntion. Further,
they need not pay any fcc again, :rs tltt:r h:tvc already paid
previously.
Step- 1:
a)
xxx
b)
xxx
c) The applicant is advised to update all thc Iatcst dctails in thc OTR
before filling up the Application.
d) The candidates while filling ltp thc applicrrtion, :rrc adviscd to
upload all the required ccrtilicatcs. (l Iotr cr t t , or-igirral <:crtificatcs
have to be produced for ve rillcation .rt tllr llnr(' ol' scrutinl' bclore
finalizing the selection list).
xxx
xxx
Step-II:-
i!
I
I
I
I
I
a)
xxx
rI
l4
SK, .I
W P. No.308-15 of 2025
l;) ApPlrcirnt lras 1,, rcr:ir Ihc dcrails [<.rc.lr<:cl fr-,rnr ()TIl cl:rt.rb:rsc
p('l tarnirl!l [() I'lantt,, D:rtc of lJirrh. rcoLtisit(,
F)cltrr.atiOna]
Qutrlil ir::rt ic,ns. (iom nt u rr i t.v, Gcnclt.r, Dis,r bility. Ex Serviccmen &
Sprtrts r:i<:.. drsltl;tr t.cl on the screen.
xxxxx
7.6 lnconrlticrr' ulc()rrcct application lbrrn will be rc,jcctt,ci. .l.hc
i'lirrni;rri.. rr :rrrr irr.rslr.d br thr: applir.ant srrbsr:r1uc.llr i.r i*rr
iorrn rr ill rror ltc cntcr tained bl th" Commrssi.rn ,,,,t". .,,ri
, jr, urrrsr;rnc-r rn jess specificalh.
callcd lor Ul rt" C,,.nnri=_,.,n.
Applic:rnt shoulrl bc carc[ul in lilting_up the application ftrrm and
sultmrssion. II rrnr lapsc is derecicd clurrng thc
scrulr.r...'r, criltci.tio.r oI certificatcs, thr: canclidarturc \r.ill
bc
.cj.ctcrl r"".c. thouglr h<:/shc c:omes thr-,ugh tltc [inal sragc oI
rccruilrlcnt llro( ('ss or crren at a lzrlcr stagc.
xxxx
16. Thc abovr. r.cftrrred conditions stated in thc impugned
Notificatio. clearly shows that the candidates who claims
an! bcnc[it har',. to upload the relcvant documents along
\\iLh thc :rpplication Form. As per para No.4.l2 of the
impLrnged Notification dated 19.O2.2024, the income
ce
rlificat. lor tli. Irinancial year prior to the _\rear of
applicatio. issrrcd bv the Revenue Authorities not belo\ r
the rzrnk of' l'ahsilcl:rr working under Telangana
(iovt:rnrncrrt in thc narnc of thr: cancliclate r,r,itlt
toLal incomc
SK..-'
\\' l' N0 308.15 ol 2025
of the familv claiming EWS Reservation i.c. lor Lhe year
2022 23
17.
There is no dispute with regar<i to clearing of the
preliminary examination by the petitioncr zrnd in the main
examination she secured a general riltrk ol' 418 and got
458.500 out of 9O0 marks and the petitiorlcr also appeared
for certificate verification, during u'hictr tirnt: thc petitioner
liled EWS certiflcatc issued by thc 'lzrl-isilrlar manuaily lor
the
lrnancial year 2022-2023 vide
certificate
No.Dl/967 12025, dated: 19.O4.2025 r.r'hii:h is filed at Page
No. i33 in the writ material Papers
18.
Admittedly, the petitioner has not uploaded thc
lncome cerlihcate along with the applicartion. but submitted
the income certificate for thc hnanciaI r"car' 2022 23 issued
by the Tahsildar, Miryalaguda Mandal vidc Ccrtificate
No.D1 /96712025 dated 19-O4.2025 at the time of
verihcation of certilicates i.c. after publishrng the mcrit list
It clearly shows that the petitiorlcr \t':rs tlot lraving ['-WS
certificate lor the I'inanciaI year 2O')'2 2.] at tl.rc timc of
1rj
sK..l
W.I'j. No.30845 ot 20 2.r
submitting tlr<, :ryrltlication ar-rd obtained only after the
cleclzrration ol tlrc rnct-it Iist
L9.
'fl-rc oLhr:r contt:ntion of the
learned Counsel for the
rcspondcnt No.2 is that the pe titioner has to submit EWS
certificatc clul-r' issr.rcd by the Mee-Seva. In [act, in the
impugncd NoLrlic:tLion there is no mention that the
applicants l-rrrrc to submit Income Certificatcs issued by
Mec-Seta orrh .
In thc Notilication at para No.4. I O
mentioncd that 1l're trWS is applicable as per
G.O Ms No.2,13 r:r'rc1 )44, GA (StrR.D) Department dated
24.Oa.2021 . Ir. rs perlincnt to mention that the petitioner
lilecl Irrcontc (lcrri[i<:atc lor the financial year 2O2l-22 and
'2O2.+ 2r obt:rin<.rI through
thc Mee Seva, which are filed at
Pag<: Nos. 1,38 :ur,l I 89 of the rvrit material papers. In the
Notilication. thcr,. is no me ntion with regard to issuance ol
c('rtifical(,s tlrlougl I N4cc-Seeva or Manually. In vieu. the
s:rme . thr: ('ontcnlirtn of the learned Standing Counsel lor
the respondcnt No.2 that the petitioner has to submit EWS
t7
SK, J
W .l'. No .108
certilicate duly issued by Mee-Seva portal ,
l5 of 2025
cannot be
acceptable.
20.
The learned Standing Counscl lor the rcspondent
No.2 relied on the Judgment in Diuga Vs. Union of India
(s-upra7), wherein the Honble Supreme Court of lndia, held
as under
"45. is uery clear that on EWS candidate acqutred eligibility to
be an DWS candidate for the purpose oJ CSE 2022 only if the
candidate met the cileion prescribecl b tl llp CentrctL
Couernment and is in pos.ses.sion of the reqrtrsrt<t l&A(' bctsecl ort
the income for the F.Y. 2020-2021. Reacl tuillt Rttle 28, the
candidate shouLd otso be in possessiorr ol' tlrc cefliJicafe rrs orl
22.02.2022. So it is beyond cauil that one caruTol decide Jbr
oneself that the candidate is an E l,{/S candicla|e arti ortLy ort lle
fulftlment of the citerio and the is-suartce of tlte ccrtificttte before
22.02.2022 utitl tle eligibiltty as an IiWS c:ancltclale, etttre to tlte
benefit of the candidate for the CSE-2O22. The argutnent of Shn
K. Parameshu.tar, leamed counsel, that beiry fronr llle "EWS'
cotegory is a status and the I&AC to be' procluced s ortl4 a proof
trnd as such the I&AC cart be produced Qt tLtJ stuqe t ctrrrtol be
accepted in the teeth of the clear pre-scri1-ttiort itr the Oflice
Memoranda read with the CSE- 2o22 Rules. Fttfther, as
required under Rule 13, ot the stage oJ'I)AI" I tlrc tlocrtrnent had
Lo lte submittecl on-hne beJbre the prescriltt'd dttle (ut llre ltreser
case for CSE-2022 the date tua:; l5.O /.2O)-11 urul tlttrt cLrty delay
1B
SK, J
W. t'. No..108-+5 oi 2025
irr.srrbrnis.srorr oI DAF-l or document beyond the prescibed. d.ate
rIrAs rrr)l cr ot,'erl . '[-lpse clear stipLLlations run counler to the
.srr1-lrrrr.s.slorr.s
of lertttterl corrrrsel that on the. rectifical[on of a
cetltltcul. i/ ,,.r.r/r,.s lttLc.k to tlt? dute o[ tlrc cen tft.ate.
49. IrL Cort ro , .slligli s ca-se /supra ). it hc.s been categoicaLLg
lLeld tl-tat .r.s.s.,r.s for the pafticular Financial year, pior to tlrc
ycttr. of sulttrtt.is to,l. ./oe.s to the root rf eligibititg of the candidate
irt tltr. L)WS (,tte.tot.tt. lt has lteen Jirrlher held therein t.hat the
ccutrlidotes tlit.)s(, /d,,/1(:..i are nol. Ln csrder tlid not haue any Legal
nqht to lrc cotsiclered. It hc.s also been heLd that no candidate
can ciaint rtrtt, lecJctl nght for reconstderation of the candidature
bq stttllrtttnct rt [rc:sh cefti,fico.te and/or a rectified certiJicote.
50, Ilrut is tl r, ltuttkunentul clistitction betuteen the Charles ,L
Skarrrr /-suTrltr I lulc, o.f case,s arrd lhe crrses at hand. As pointed
out ertrLier. tlu' eltqibilitu .for beitg categori-z,ed. as EWS candid,ate
crrlstrtllues otrlr1 tllten th.e I&AC is issued and, in lhjs case, as
rerltttrecl urtcltt iltr. r-ulr:s, lt ucts to be issued and po-ssessed bu
llu: r'rtrLclidtttt, ltcl'ctre )2 O2.2022.
2L.
l'hr- above fincling of the Honble Supreme Court
squarel\. appl\ to lhe ir-rstant case, as the petitioner failed
to obtai.r.rl li\\'S <.r:rt ifi<)ate for the relevant year at the time
of strbmission or- :rpplication, but obtained subsequently
a,d in 'i<.r.r .[ lhe samc, the certihcate filed bv the
petrtr()n(,r fbr rlrc' flr-rarrcial .\,car 2022_23 issued
Talrasildar cl;r Lccl I 9.O4.2025 carrnot be acceptable
bv thc
SK,.]
\V.l) No 308.15 oi 2025
22.
The Hontrle Supreme Court in
Bedanga
Talukdar Vs. SaiJudaulla Khan and. other{, held as
under
*29. We houe considered the entire matter in detatl. In our
opirtion, it is too well settled to need ang further reiteration that
all appointments to public offtce haue to be mctd"e in cutfonnity
wtth Article l4 of the Constitution of Indla. ltt other uords, there
must be no arbitrainess resulting from anq urtdue fctu<tLLr benrg
shoun to any candidate. Therefore, the selection proc:ess has lc.t
be conducted strtctly in accordance with the stipuLated seLectiort
procedure.
Consequently, when a particular schedule is rrtetttroned ir
an aduertisernen| the same hcts to be scrupulousLg mauiained.
There can not be any relaxation in the tenns and cortditions of
the oduertisernent unless such a power is spectJicaLlg reserued.
Such a pouter coulrl be reserued in the releuartt Statutory Rules.
Euen if pouer of relaxotion is prouided in lhe ruLes, it rrru.sl .stil/
be menttoned in the adueflisemenl. It1 the absence of sut'lt p<tu,er
irt the Rules, it could still be prouided tn the aduerlisement.
Hotueuer, the pouter of relaxation, tf exeraised has lo be giuerL
due publicity. Thts utould be necessary to erLsure thQL those
candidates tuho become eligibLe due to Lhe relaxat[on, are
afforded an equal opportunitg to applg ancl corrLpete. ReLaxatton
of any condition in aduertisement Luithoul due publicatiort tlould
be contrary to the mandate of quality contained ln Articles 14
and 1 6 of the Constitulion of India.
' (2011) 12 scc 85
SK, J
W.t']No.30845 ot 2025
xxxx
xxxx
32. ttt tlu: [acr: of srlch conclusions, we haue llttle hesitatton tn
conclLtdlng lltot the conclusion recorded bg the High Coutl is
contran/ to tlt( fects and mateials on the record. lt is settled lau
that tlrcre con be no relaxatLott in the terms and conditions
conlainerl it lirc ad u<:rtiserrlent unless the poloer of reLaration is
duly rcsr:ruecl ut the releuarLt ntl.es and/ or in the adueftisement.
Euen if I herc i.s e poltter of relaxation ln the ntles, the same
tuould still hriL'e to be speciJicaLltl incitcated in the aduertisement.
In. lh€ present L-.i.se. ,io srtch ntle has been brought to our notice.
Ir't .srrc/r cirrtur,sloru'.e-s, the High Coutl t:ould not haue issued the
im.pttgtted tli-e'ctrcn to consider the cLatm of respondent No.1 on
the bctsis o.f tdent.ity card submttted a.fter the seLection process
u)as ouer, u,itlr the publication of the seLect list".
(Bmpha.sis added)
23.
[r-r anothor similar casc, the Honble Supreme
Court ol lr-Ldia in State of Bihar a.nd other Vs., Madhu
Kant Ranjan ctnd anothers held that a candidate has to
comply q-ith all thc conclitions as per the Notilication before
the cut-off date. 'lhe relevant portion of the said Judgment
is extracterl .ts utldcr:
' 1zozrl tz scc r+r
2r
SK,.J
\\'.l' No.308lJ ol 202 J
" 1 7. ..tt pcr lhe .teltletl proprt.sition of ltrr . u (utklrtl(tt(' ttpplitunl hu.t trt
compll tith ull the atndit ionsid igihili4 ttitcriu u.s 1tcr rh,:
adt,erlisenanl be.lort tha cut-ol/ dote mcntionatl thcrcin unlt.t.s exlentltl
h1, lhe recruitittg uuthoritr Also, onb: lhosc tktcumenl.y, v,hich ure
submitted uktnSn ith the application J'orm. v,hic.h ura required to b,:
.suhmittatl u.: ptr lht udvcrtiscmcnt hut'r: to ha cnnsidcrcd T hcrefora
v'hen tht rt:lxtnlcttt \o I
ythotctcttl;.t ol the \( (
rtriginal r'rit pctitu,nL'r dil tutt ltn ucc tltt'
l) ct,rtificutc ulongrrith tltt oriT4inul upplication
us per lht,ucltattisctrcnt unLl thc santt ttctt .strbntittt'd u/icr u pcriotl o1
thrce 1'eur.s .ffutm lha (ut-olJ'dute and that too ulicr the phy:t'ul le sl, ht
fus not (tltitlcd lo tht utlclitirtttul fite nLu.ks ol tfu \'( ( l] trrtt/itut,:
ln thcsa tit tuntsturttts. tltt I)ivi.tion llttrh tt/ tht llrglt ( our t hus arrtd
in dirctting lhe appt'llunl.s to uppoint lhr: rr:.:lxtndcnl ,\,io. I
originul writ
pelitionar on the posl o/' Constoble tonsidering the .seletl list dat
()8 09 200: und allotring./ivc udditional mark.s ol NC(' 'B' cerrificate"
(Emphasis ddded)
\
24.
The hnding of the above ..ludgments squarel)
apply to the facts of the instant case, as the petitioner
laited l-o comply tht: conditions mcntioned in Para
No.7.2 (b) of the impunged Notification and the petitioner
not having the EWS certificate at the time of submission ol
f
application and obtaincd subsequently and submitted at
the time of certiflcate verification. In view o[ thc same, the
petitioner has 11C) right to claim lor considcration of her
{
SK,.J
w. P No.30845 of 2025
candidature un.lcr. EWS categorv. The respondent No.2
has rrghll\ r.('1.(.lc(l tl,rc clairn ol- the pctitioner for
considcration ol' h('r car.rdidature under EWS quota and
thc'c :rrc rt. mr.r-its :r.d the *,rit p.lition is liable to be
disn-rissed
25,
In vicu' of thc above finding. this writ petition is
dismisscd :is drrr oicl cf mcrits. No order as to costs.
l\4iscclla rrcotrs pctitions, perrding if an-1,, shall
stand
clo scd.
SD/-P. PONNA KRISHNA
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY/I
/;
V
SECTION OFFICER
One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble Sri Justice K.SARATH
(For His Lordships kind perusal)
To,
1 11 LR Copres
2 The Under Secretary, Union of lndia. Ivlinistry of Law, Justice and Company
Affairs, New Delhi
3. The Secretary, Telangana Advocates Association, Library, High Court
Buildings, Hyderabad
4. One CC to Sri Rama Rao Kilaru, Advocate [OPUC]
5. Two CCs to GP for Services ll, High Court for the State of Telangana, at
Hyderabad [OUT]
6. One CC to Sri P.S Raja Sekhar, SC [OPUC]
TJ
IJS
7. Two CD Copies
f'
HIGH COURT
DATED:0610312026
( oR
ORDER
WP.No.30845 of 2025
oo
iHE S
2 4 t{AR 2tl2fi
t
*
S
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
CU
a
t
z
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review