Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~17 & 18
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of decision: 18th March 2026.
+
MAC.APP. 618/2018
THE ORIENTAL INSURNACE CO LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Abhishek Gola, Mr. Anshul
Mehral, Advocates.
versus
+
MANISH MADAN @ MUNISH MADAN & ORS .....Respondents
Through: Ms. Vaishalee Mehra, Advocate.
Mr. Kapil Jain, Advocate for R-3.
MAC.APP. 956/2018
MANISH MADAN @ MUNISH MADAN
Through:
.....Appellant
Ms. Vaishalee Mehra, Advocate
versus
THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO LTD & ORS .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Abhishek Gola, Mr. Anshul
Mehral, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J: (ORAL)
1.
These cross-appeals have been filed by the Insurance Company and
claimant assailing the impugned award dated 02nd June 2018, passed by the
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Rohini Court [‘MACT’] in MAC.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:46:41
MAC APP 618/2018 & MAC APP 956/2018
Petition No. 334/2007, whereby compensation of Rs. 22,78,100/- along
with 9% per annum was awarded.
2.
MAC APP. 618/2018 has been filed by the Insurance Company,
seeking reduction of the compensation awarded, and MAC.APP. 956/2018
has been filed by claimant seeking an enhancement thereof.
Compensation awarded
3.
The accident occurred on 06th April 2007, when the offending truck
bearing registration no. HR-46-9482 [‘offending vehicle’], driven rashly and
negligently, collided with claimant’s vehicle, resulting in above-elbow
amputation of his right upper limb and permanent disability. MACT held
that accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the driver of
the offending vehicle and fastened liability upon respondents, with the
Insurance Company being directed to satisfy the award with right of
recovery from the owner, on account of permit violation.
4.
While assessing compensation, MACT took claimant’s age as about
32 years, his occupation as an ‘electrical contractor’, and his income on the
basis of Income Tax Returns at Rs.10,346/- per month, and assessed
functional disability at 70% despite disability certificate stating 85% in
relation to the right upper limb. Applying multiplier of ‘16’ and granting
40% addition towards future prospects, MACT computed loss of earning
capacity at Rs.19,46,649/-, along with other pecuniary and non-pecuniary
damages including pain and suffering, loss of amenities, special diet,
conveyance, attendant charges, and loss of income during treatment period.
5.
Accordingly, MACT awarded a total compensation of Rs.22,78,100/-
along with interest at 9% per annum from the date of filing of the petition
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:46:41
MAC APP 618/2018 & MAC APP 956/2018
till realization, directing Insurance Company to deposit the awarded amount
within the stipulated period, with liberty to recover the same from the
owner of the offending vehicle in accordance with law.
Analysis
6.
Mr. Abhishek Gola, counsel for Insurance Company, assails the
award on three counts; first, that the functional disability was assessed at
70% despite permanent disability being certified at 85%, which was
disproportionate considering that there was only disfigurement and
amputation of right upper limb and vocation of claimant was that of a
contractor for household electrical work and did not involve his own
physical involvement; second, that since it was a head-on collision,
contributory negligence ought to have been fastened upon claimant who
was driving an Esteem Car on 06th April 2007 [date of the accident] and
collided with the offending vehicle; thirdly, that the interest granted at 9%
is also disproportionate.
7.
For the purpose of assessment of functional disability, the principles
enunciated in Raj Kumar and Ajay Kumar, (2011) 1 SCC 343 by the
Supreme Court shall be adhered to. In Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar (supra),
the Supreme Court held that MACT must assess not merely the extent of
permanent disability but its actual impact on the claimant’s earning
capacity, which may differ from the medical percentage of disability. This
requires evaluating the claimant’s pre-accident vocation, the functions
affected, and whether livelihood can still be earned despite the disability.
The Court emphasised that disability and loss of earning capacity are
distinct concepts, except in cases where evidence shows they coincide.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:46:41
MAC APP 618/2018 & MAC APP 956/2018
Relevant paragraphs are extracted as under:
“11. What requires to be assessed by the Tribunal is the
effect of the permanent disability on the earning capacity
of the injured; and after assessing the loss of earning
capacity in terms of a percentage of the income, it has to
be quantified in terms of money, to arrive at the future
loss of earnings (by applying the standard multiplier
method used to determine loss of dependency). We may
however note that in some cases, on appreciation of
evidence and assessment, the Tribunal may find that the
percentage of loss of earning capacity as a result of the
permanent disability, is approximately the same as the
percentage of permanent disability in which case, of
course, the Tribunal will adopt the said percentage for
determination of compensation. (See for example, the
decisions of this Court in Arvind Kumar Mishra v. New
India Assurance Co. Ltd. [(2010) 10 SCC 254 : (2010) 3
SCC (Cri) 1258 : (2010) 10 Scale 298] and Yadava
Kumar v. National Insurance Co. Ltd. [(2010) 10 SCC
341 : (2010) 3 SCC (Cri) 1285 : (2010) 8 Scale 567] )
12. Therefore, the Tribunal has to first decide whether
there is any permanent disability and, if so, the extent of
such permanent disability. This means that the Tribunal
should consider and decide with reference to the
evidence:
(i) whether the disablement is permanent or temporary;
(ii) if the disablement is permanent, whether it is
permanent total disablement or permanent partial
disablement;
(iii) if the disablement percentage is expressed with
reference to any specific limb, then the effect of such
disablement of the limb on the functioning of the entire
body, that is, the permanent disability suffered by the
person.
If the Tribunal concludes that there is no permanent
disability then there is no question of proceeding further
and determining the loss of future earning capacity. But if
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:46:41
MAC APP 618/2018 & MAC APP 956/2018
the Tribunal concludes that there is permanent disability
then it will proceed to ascertain its extent. After the
Tribunal ascertains the actual extent of permanent
disability of the claimant based on the medical evidence,
it has to determine whether such permanent disability has
affected or will affect his earning capacity.
13. Ascertainment of the effect of the permanent disability
on the actual earning capacity involves three steps. The
Tribunal has to first ascertain what activities the claimant
could carry on in spite of the permanent disability and
what he could not do as a result of the permanent
disability (this is also relevant for awarding
compensation under the head of loss of amenities of life).
The second step is to ascertain his avocation, profession
and nature of work before the accident, as also his age.
The third step is to find out whether (i) the claimant is
totally disabled from earning any kind of livelihood, or
(ii) whether in spite of the permanent disability, the
claimant could still effectively carry on the activities and
functions, which he was earlier carrying on, or (iii)
whether he was prevented or restricted from discharging
his previous activities and functions, but could carry on
some other or lesser scale of activities and functions so
that he continues to earn or can continue to earn his
livelihood.”
(emphasis added)
In Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar (supra), the Court summarized the principles,
which are extracted as under:
“19. We may now summarise the principles discussed
above:
(i) All injuries (or permanent disabilities arising
from injuries), do not result in loss of earning
capacity.
(ii) The percentage of permanent disability with
reference to the whole body of a person, cannot be
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:46:41
MAC APP 618/2018 & MAC APP 956/2018
assumed to be the percentage of loss of earning
capacity. To put it differently, the percentage of loss
of earning capacity is not the same as the percentage
of permanent disability (except in a few cases, where
the Tribunal on the basis of evidence, concludes that
the percentage of loss of earning capacity is the
same as the percentage of permanent disability).
(iii) The doctor who treated an injured claimant or
who examined him subsequently to assess the extent
of his permanent disability can give evidence only in
regard to the extent of permanent disability. The loss
of earning capacity is something that will have to be
assessed by the Tribunal with reference to the
evidence in entirety.
(iv) The same permanent disability may result in
different percentages of loss of earning capacity in
different persons, depending upon the nature of
profession, occupation or job, age, education and
other factors.”
(emphasis added)
8.
The Apex Court has laid down the principles of assessment, which
involve three steps; firstly, as to what activities the claimant could carry on
despite permanent disability, secondly, claimant’s vocation or profession
and nature of work, and thirdly, whether injured/claimant is totally disabled
from carrying on activities and/or can still carry out some functions.
9.
From the testimony of the claimant Manish Madan [PW-1], he states
that he undertaking contracts for electrification and wiring of houses on a
large scale. His visiting card has been appended as Exhibit PW-1/4. The
visiting card shows that he was running an entity by the name of “JR
Electricals, Engineers and Contractors from Vikas Puri”.
10.
Though this does show that he was the proprietor of an agency and,
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:46:41
MAC APP 618/2018 & MAC APP 956/2018
therefore, could carry on the work of a contractor, considering his right
hand was amputated above elbow, it would have seriously impeded him
from doing numerous activities involved in the work that he was
contracting.
11.
Being a contractor naturally does not mean that one only has office
related responsibilities but involves engagement with workers and clients.
Considering that this would involve a host of activities requiring
functionality of claimant, in the opinion of this Court, the assessment by the
MACT cannot be said to be amiss.
12.
On the issue relating to contributory negligence, Mr. Abhishek Gola,
relies on the site map, which shows that the accident occurred in the middle
of the road. However, there is absolutely no other evidence led by the
Insurance Company or on behalf of the driver and owner before MACT
which would establish any element of contributory negligence on part of
the claimant who was the driver of the Esteem car.
13.
There is nothing on record to suggest that the claimant was driving
his car negligently in the middle of the road, purposefully or without due
care and, thereby invited head-on collision by the truck in front of him.
Having not availed of the opportunity to lead evidence, the plea of
contributory negligence cannot be sustained.
14.
As regards the issue of interest at 9%, the Court takes note of the fact
that many compensation awards of similar periods have been granted
interest at 9% and the same have been upheld up to the Supreme Court.
15.
As far as non-pecuniary damages are concerned, Ms. Vaishalee
Mehra, counsel for the claimant, states that non-pecuniary damages
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:46:41
MAC APP 618/2018 & MAC APP 956/2018
awarded are abysmally inadequate, particularly with pain and suffering
being awarded at Rs. 1,00,000/-, loss of amenities of life at Rs. 1,00,000/and no amount being awarded towards disfigurement. The loss towards
pain and suffering and trauma, as per Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar (supra),
would include disfigurement as well and, therefore, same is enhanced to Rs.
3,00,000/-, and the loss of amenities is also enhanced to Rs. 3,00,000/considering the circumstances.
16.
Ms. Vaishalee Mehra, counsel for the claimant, further states that
MACT has also failed to grant any compensation under the head of loss of
earning inconvenience, hardships, disappointment, frustration, mental
stress, dejection and unhappiness in future life; as per Raj Kumar v. Ajay
Kumar (supra) [particularly in paragraph 5, 6 and 15], compensation to
this head cannot be awarded under a separate head as these elements are
already subsumed within the recognised heads of pain and suffering and
loss of amenities of life.
17.
As regards the submission made by the counsel for claimant that
deduction of income tax at 10% ought not to have been made from the
assessed income, the said contention is well-founded. MACT assessed
claimant’s annual income at Rs.1,24,152/- on the basis of the Income Tax
Return for the Assessment Year 2006–2007 [Exhibit PW3/1 (colly)],
which reflected a taxable income of Rs.99,862/- i.e. below the taxable limit
applicable at the relevant time. It is settled law in terms of Sarla Verma v.
DTC (2009) 6 SCC 121 [particularly in paragraphs no. 20 & 24] and
reiterated in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC
680 [particularly in paragraphs no.44, 59.3 and 59.4] that deduction
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:46:41
MAC APP 618/2018 & MAC APP 956/2018
towards income tax is warranted only where the income falls within the
taxable range. Since the claimant’s income was below the taxable limit, no
deduction on this account was liable to be made. Further, the monthly
income taken by MACT at Rs.10,346/- was correctly derived from the
annual income reflected in the Income Tax Returns and warrants no
interference.
18.
Accordingly, the compensation would stand recomputed as under:
SR.
NO.
HEADS
AWARDED BY
THE
TRIBUNAL
AWARDED BY
THIS COURT
PECUNIARY LOSS
1.
Expenditure on treatment (A)
Nil
Nil
2.
Expenditure on conveyance (B)
Rs.25,000 /-
Rs.50,000/-
3.
4.
Expenditure on special diet (C)
Cost of nursing / attendant (D)
Rs. 25,000/Rs.40,000 /-
Rs.50,000/Rs.40,000 /-
5.
Loss of earning capacity (E)
Rs.19,46,649 /-
Rs.19,46,649 /-
6.
Loss of income (F)
Rs.41,384 /-
Rs.41,384 /-
[Rs.10,346 x 4]
[Rs.10,346 x 4]
7.
Any other loss which may require
any special treatment or aid to the
injured for the rest of his life (G)
Nil
Nil
8.
Future Medical Expenses
Nil
NON PECUNIARY LOSS
Nil
9.
Compensation for mental and
physical shock (H)
Nil
Nil
Rs.1,00,000 /Rs.1,00,000 /-
Rs.3,00,000 /Rs.3,00,000 /-
12. Disfiguration (K)
Nil
13. Loss of marriage prospects (L)
Nil
Included with
pain and suffering
Nil
10. Pain and suffering (I)
11. Loss of amenities of life (J)
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:46:41
MAC APP 618/2018 & MAC APP 956/2018
14. Loss of earning, inconvenience,
Nil
Nil
hardships, disappointment,
frustration, mental stress, dejectment
and unhappiness in future life etc.
(M)
DISABILITY RESULTING IN LOSS OF EARNING CAPACITY
15. Percentage of disability assessed and
85%
85%
nature of disability as permanent or
temporary
16. Loss of amenities or loss of
expectation of life span on account of
disability
Included
Included
70%
70%
Rs.19,46,649 /-
Rs.19,46,649 /-
[Rs.10,346 +40% x
[Rs.10,346 +40% x
12 x 16 x 0.70]
12 x 16 x 0.70]
TOTAL COMPENSATION
Rs.22,78,100/-
Rs.27,28,033/-
INTEREST AWARDED
[Rounded off to
Rs.22,78,033/-]
9%
9%
17. Percentage of loss of earning
capacity in relation to disability
18. Loss of future income (Income X%
Earning capacity x Multiplier)
19.
For the aforesaid reasons, the award of the MACT is enhanced by
Rs.4,49,933/-.
20.
Enhanced compensation along with 9% interest per annum from the
date of filing the petition shall be deposited before MACT within a period
of four weeks.
21.
It is directed that a lump sum amount of Rs. 1,50,000/- shall be
released to the claimant within a period of two weeks thereafter. The
remaining amount, along with accrued interest, shall be kept in Fixed
Deposit Receipts (FDRs) of Rs. 25,000/- each for periods of 1 month, 2
months, 3 months and so on, in succession as maybe calculated. The
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:46:41
MAC APP 618/2018 & MAC APP 956/2018
interest accruing on the said FDRs shall be credited to the designated
Savings Bank Account of the claimant. The amount of FDRs on maturity
would be released to the Savings Bank Account of claimant upon due
verification.
22.
Counsel for owner of the offending vehicle argues against right of
recovery; however, these points have neither been assailed in any appeal
nor any plea which has been filed. Accordingly, the same cannot be
considered on an oral submission.
23.
Ms. Mehra, counsel for the claimant, states that they were proceeded
ex parte by order dated 17th August 2017, which was subsequently assailed
before MACT , and, therefore, the said challenge was also dismissed.
24.
This Court vide order dated 10th July 2018 in MAC APP. 618/2018
directed Insurance Company to deposit the entire originally awarded
compensation before the MACT. Subsequently vide order dated 21st
February 2019 in CM APPL 8473/2019 [MAC APP 618/2018], the Court
directed release of 50% of amount in favour of claimant.
25.
Accordingly, the originally awarded compensation shall be disbursed
as per the directions passed by the MACT in the impugned award.
26.
Accordingly, the appeals are disposed of.
27.
Pending applications if any, shall rendered as infructuous.
28.
Statutory Deposit (if any) shall be refunded to Insurance Company.
29.
Judgement be uploaded on the website of this Court.
ANISH DAYAL
(JUDGE)
MARCH 18, 2026/RK/tk
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
12:46:41
MAC APP 618/2018 & MAC APP 956/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review