Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 22.04.2026
+
W.P.(C) 5429/2026
MANISH KUMAR UPADHYAY
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Bhanu Gupta, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms Shivani Luthra Lohiya, Mr.
Nitin Saluja, Ms. Vasudha
Singh, Advs. with Mr. Ajay Pal,
Law Officer, Insp Athurv and
Mr. Ramniwas Yadav, CRPF.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
J U D G M E N T (ORAL)
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
1.
The present Petition has been filed assailing the impugned
orders dated 22.03.2024, 22.02.2025 and 23.09.2025, passed during
the disciplinary proceedings conducted against the Petitioner herein,
vide which he was held guilty of the charges imposed and
consequently removed from service.
2.
Succinctly stated, the Petitioner was appointed in the Central
Reserve Police Force (‘CRPF’) on 25.08.2011 to the post of
Constable/GD.
3.
On 01.06.2023, the Petitioner was arrested in FIR No. 256/2023
registered at Police Station Chaubepur, Varanasi, under section 302 of
the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and was sent to judicial custody. Hence,
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 5429/2026
16:59:53
on 02.09.2023, the Commandant-70 BN CRPF, proposed to initiate
inquiry against the Petitioner and a memorandum of charge was issued
upon him, details of which are reproduced herein below: “Details of the charges levelled against
Bal no 110727137 Constable Manish
Kumar Upadhyay (G/70 Bn)
Item – ONE
That Bal No 110727137 Constable
/Manish Kumar Upadhyay (G/70 Bn),
while working as a Constable/GD in the
CRPF, being a member of the Force Under
Section 11(1) of the CRPF Act 1949, has
committed disobedience of orders/neglect
of his duty/laxity in the discharge of his
duty/other misconduct or misbehavior. In
this, form 06/04/2023 until now, he has
remained absent from duty of his own
volition without the permission of any
competent authority, misguided the force
by giving wrong information to the
department and submitting an application
for extension of leaves on the basis of false
facts, which is against the good
conduct/behavior of the force as a
disciplined force member.
Item – TWO
That Bal No Constable/GD Manish Kumar
Upadhyay (Gn/70 Bn), while working as a
Constable/GD in the CRPF being a
member of the Force Under Section 11 (1)
of the CRPF Act 1949, has committed
disobedience of orders/neglect of his
duty/laxity in the discharge of his
duty/other misconduct or misbehavior. The
personnel has been informed under letter
number
Reader/SHO
(Prosecution
Sanction)/2023 dated 01/08/2023 from the
office of Police Station- Chaubepur
Commissioneraate Varanasi that he has
been arrested under registered Case Crime
No 256/2023 Under Section 302 at the
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 5429/2026
16:59:53
local police station and sent to judicial
custody. The personnel did not inform the
force about the arrest and concealed the
facts from the department. Due to this act of
the personnel, the image of the force has
been tarnished. This unseemly act is against
the good conduct/behavior of the force as a
disciplined force member.
(Tashi Gayalik) Commandant-70 Battalion
CRPF”
4.
The “details of accusation of disobedience/neglect of duty/laxity
in performance of duty or other misconduct as a member of the
force”, issued upon the Petitioner are reproduced herein below: “Discription of the imputation of
misconduct or misbehaviour in support of
the charges leveled against Bal No
110727137 Constable/GD/10 Bn
Item- ONE
That is to say that Bal No. 110727137
Constable/GD Manish Kumar Upadhyay
(GD/10 Bn) while working as a
Constable/GD being a member of the Force
under Section 11(1) of the CRPF Act 1949,
committed disobedience of orders/neglect
of his duty/laxity in the discharge of his
duty/other misconduct or misbehavior Bal
No.110727137 Constable/GD Manish
Kumar Upadhyay was on 15 days casual
leave from 16/03/2023 to 05/04/2023
(including permission dated 30/03/2023 &
04/04/2023,GH
22/03/2023
,
RA
19/03/2023, 28/03/2023 & 02/04/2023 and
Sunday ). After the leave expired, the
personnel did not report for duty in the
office and was absent from leave since
06/04/2023. Thereafter, the personnel
submitted
another
application
on
15/05/2023 stating that he would report for
duty on 16/05/2023, but the personnel did
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 5429/2026
16:59:53
not report for duty on 16/05/2025.
Subsequently, the personnel submitted
another application on 19/05/2023 stating
that he would report for duty on
25/05/2023. In this regard, the competent
authority had extended the personnel’s
leave till 26/05/2023. After this, the
personnel did not report for duty on
26/05/2023 either, and on 26/05/2026, he
submitted another application stating that
the personnel would report by 28/05/2023,
but the personnel did not report for duty
even after 28/05/2023 had passed.
Accordingly, an arrest warrant was also
issued against the personnel by this office
on 30/05/2023. Meanwhile, it came to the
knowledge of this office through the
online news portal www.jagran.com dated
02/06/2023 that the personnel had been
arrested by the Civil Police, Mata Shri
Varanasi, (Uttar Pradesh) on 01/06/2023.
The personnel did not report for duty and
repeatedly misled this office by requesting
extension of leave, which is against the
good conduct/behavior of a disciplined
Bal member.
Item- TWO
That Bal No. 110727137 Constable
GD/Manish Kumar Upadhyay (G/70 Bn),
while working as a Sub- Inspector/GD,
being a member of the CRPF under Section
11(1) of the CRPF Act 1949, committed
disobedience of orders/neglect of his
duty/laxity in the discharge of his
duty/other misconduct or misbehavior.
Information was sought from the office of
Police
Station-Chaubepur
Commissionerate Varanasi under letter no.
G-69 SHO (Prosecution Permission)/2023
dated 01/08/2023 regarding Manish Kumar
Upadhyay S/O Anil Upadhyay resident of
Phulwaria Post-Samudpur, Police StationBalua, District Chandauli. In this regard,
it is informed that the name of accused
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 5429/2026
16:59:53
Manish Kumar Upadhyay S/O Anil
Upadhyay resident of Phulwaria, postSamudpur, Police Staion-Balua, DistrictChadauli has come to light in case file no.
256/2023 under Section 302 IPC
registered at the local police station. He
has been arrested on 01/06/2023 and sent
to judicial custody. In this sequence, 95 Bn.
Sent its wireless no. eight-01/2023-95-sthaTwo dated 09/06/2023, this office was
informed that a special representative from
their Battalion was sent to Police Station –
Chaubepur, Varanasi (Uttar Pradesh) on
09/06/2023, and they orally informed that a
case is registered against an unknown
person under Section 302, Case No.256/2023, and the scence of the incident is
Bhagatuwa Chauraha , P.S. – Chaubepur,,
Varanasi (Uttar Prades). The case is
registered against an unknown person, and
the personnel has been arrested based on
identification because the motorcycles was
seized at the scene of the incident based on
its registration on 01/06/2023. The
Commandant- 70 Battalion was informed
about the said case against Bal No
110727137 Constable/GD Ganesh Kumar
Upadhyay through the police. The
personnel did not inform the department
about the arrest and concealed the facts
from the department. Due to this act of the
personnel, the image of the force has been
tarnished. This indecent act,as a member
of a disciplined force, is against the good
conduct/behavior of the force.
(Tashi
Gyalik)
Battalion,CRPF”
Commandant-70
(emphasis supplied)
5.
After conducting a detailed departmental inquiry and giving the
Petitioner an opportunity to defend his case, the Assistant
Commandant/Inquiry Officer submitted the Inquiry Report before the
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 5429/2026
16:59:53
Disciplinary Authority and held the Petitioner guilty of both
Items/Charges One and Two, by observing that the information about
the Petitioner’s arrest was received from the civil police and the
Petitioner had sent false information to the department regarding his
absence.
6.
The Disciplinary Authority, after considering the Reply of the
Petitioner, upheld the observations of the Inquiry Officer, concluded
that the Petitioner is guilty of serious misconduct and thus, imposed a
penalty of “removal from service” upon the Petitioner on 22.03.2024.
7.
The Petitioner, who was released on Bail on 28.11.2024, filed
an Appeal against the above order, which was dismissed by the
Appellate Authority on 22.02.2025, with observations that the penalty
imposed by the Disciplinary Authority is proportionate to the offense
committed by the Petitioner, all the grounds raised by the Petitioner
have already been dealt with by the competent authorities and no new
ground for interference has been brought forth.
8.
Aggrieved by the Orders of the Disciplinary and Appellate
Authority, the Petitioner further preferred a Departmental Revision,
which was dismissed by the Revisional Authority, on 23.09.2025, by
observing that firstly, the Departmental Enquiry was conducted
strictly in accordance with Rules and regulations by giving ample
opportunities to the petitioner; secondly, the Petitioner has deliberately
concealed the material fact of his involvement in a criminal case and
failed to report the matter to the department, thereby violating the
principles of discipline and transparency expected of a member of the
Force in CRPF; and thirdly, the penalty of "Removal from Service" is
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 5429/2026
16:59:53
commensurate with the gravity of misconduct on the part of the
Petitioner. The relevant extract is reproduced herein below: “5. AND WHEREAS, the undersigned has
gone through the Revision Petition dated
25/03/2025 and after careful examination
of this revision petition dated 25/03/2025
submitted by the Petitioner, with the
relevant records and DE proceedings, it
has been observed that the petitioner was
sanctioned 15 days casual leave from
16/03/2023 to 05/04/2023 with permission
to avail 30/03/2023, 04/04/2023 G.H.,
22/03/2023
R.H.
and
19/03/2023,
26/03/2023 and 02/04/2023 being Sundays.
He was due to report back for duty on
05/04/2023 in the evening roll call, but he
failed to do so and overstayed from leave
w.e.f.
06/04/2023
without
any
permission/prior sanction of leave from
the Competent Authority.
6 Despite several directives from the
Company Commander, G/70 Bn, vide
letters dated 15/04/2023, 24/04/2023 and
02/05/2023, the petitioner neither reported
for duty nor communicated with the unit
with supported documents. However,
petitioner submitted requests for extension
of leave citing an accident and also failed
to report on the dates as assured by him.
Based on his persistent absence and
misleading department, a warrant of arrest
was issued on 30/05/2023. The petitioner
deliberately concealed the material fact of
his involvement in a criminal. case and
failed to report the matter to the
department,
thereby
violating
the
principles of discipline and transparency
expected of a member of the Force in
CRPF.
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 5429/2026
16:59:53
7. AND WHEREAS, on 10/06/2023, a
communication from SHO,PS Baluwa,
Chandauli (U.P.) revealed that a criminal
case (FIR No.256/2073 under Section 302
IPC) had been registered against him at
PS-Chaubepur, Varanasi, and petitioner
was arrested on 01/06/2023 and remained
in Judicial custody at District Jail,
Varanasi. The petitioner was placed under
deemed suspension w.e.f. 01/06/2023 under
Rule 10(2) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965,
vide order dated 21/06/2023. The civil
police later confirmed sufficient evidence
was found during investigation under FIR
No. 256/2023. In view of his unauthorized
absence, deliberate misrepresentation, and
involvement in a serious criminal offence,
the Disciplinary Authority initiated
Departmental Action against the petitioner
and Memorandum of Charges was framed
vide letter No.P.VIII01/2023-70-EC-II
dated 02/09/2023. Every members of the
force are expected to have the core values
of discipline, integrity, and public trust.
The petitioner was to maintain exemplary
conduct and discipline at all times,
whether on duty or off duty. The act of
misconduct of the petitioner is wholly
incompatible with the ethical standards of
the disciplined force. The petitioner's
involvement in a grave and heinous
criminal case has severely undermined the
image and reputation and also detrimental
to the dignity and credibility of the Force.
AND WHEREAS, the Departmental
Enquiry was conducted strictly in
accordance with Rules and regulations by
giving ample opportunities to the
petitioner in jail at every stage of enquiry
to defend himself, but he failed to submit
any evidence/documents in support of his
defence. Further, petitioner also refused to
avail services of Defence Assistant during
the preliminary bearing. The memorandum
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 5429/2026
16:59:53
of charges were served on the petitioner
with the charges of overstaying from leave
and for not informing department about his
involvement in criminal cases as well as on
his arrest by the Civil Police. The statement
of petitioner in his revision petition dated
25/03/2025 that he was falsely implicated
in a FIR vide case crime No 256 of 2023
lodged against him cannot be taken into
consideration since it is subjudice.
9 As regards non-conducting of DE in Jail
also refuted since no such request put
forth by the petitioner during enquiry.
Petitioner's claim that he was pot provided
with documents is also refuted, since he
had himself admitted that he has received
all connected documents in questionnaire
dated 26/10/2023. Further petitioner also
denied availing facility of defence assistant
during proceedings.
Further, the Petitioner, in his present
revision petition dated 25/03/2025 has not
submitted any new fact or evidence in
support of his request to set aside/ to
interfere with the orders passed by the
Disciplinary Authority or the Appellate
Authority. The penalty of "Removal from
Service" with effect from 22/03/2024 (AN)
imposed
upon
the
petitioner
is
commensurate with the gravity of
misconduct on the part of the petitioner.
NOW THEREFORE, by virtue of powers
vested in Rule 29 of CRPF, Rules 1955, 1,
after considering the petition and applying
my mind judiciously, find no cogent reasons
to interfere with the penalty imposed upon
the Petitioner vide order No.P.VIII-2/2024EC-11
dated
22/03/2024
of
the
Commandant 70 Bn CRPF and punishment
upheld by the DIGP, Range, CRPF,
Gandhinagar vide order No.R.XIIISignature Not Verified
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 5429/2026
16:59:53
70/2025-EC-3-Range
GNR
dated
22/02/2025. The penalty of "Removal from
Service" awarded to No.110727137 ExCT/GD Manish Kumar Upadhyay of 70 Bn.
CRPF, is found to be just, fair, and
proportionate to the gravity of the
misconduct committed by the Petitioner.
Given the seriousness and recurring
nature of the indiscipline, the punishment
awarded is appropriate and warranted in
the interest of maintaining the standards
of discipline and integrity within the force.
Accordingly. the revision petition dated
25/03/2025 preferred by the petitioner is
hereby rejected. being devoid of merit.
(Virendra Agrawal) Inspector General”
(emphasis supplied)
9.
Hence, the Petitioner has approached this Court, by way of the
present petition.
10.
The learned Counsel for the Petitioner has essentially submitted
that mere registration of an FIR, without an order of conviction, ought
not to have resulted in Petitioner's removal from service and even
otherwise, the penalty imposed is not commensurate with the charges
issued. It is further urged that no proper opportunity was awarded to
him to defend his case, which is in violation of principles of natural
justice.
11.
Per Contra, the learned Counsel for the Respondents
vehemently submit that the present petition is liable to be dismissed as
the Petitioner had himself accepted guilt of the charges imposed
during the preliminary hearing and the findings arrived by the above
Authorities are duly supported by material placed on record.
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 5429/2026
16:59:53
12.
It is further submitted that the misconduct is grave in nature,
involving breach of discipline by a member of the forces and that the
punishment imposed is justified.
13.
Submissions heard and the record of has been perused by this
Court.
14.
It is well settled that the scope of judicial review in matters
arising out of disciplinary proceedings, particularly by the armed
forces, is well circumscribed. This Court cannot sit as an appellate
authority over disciplinary proceedings and interference is warranted
only in cases of procedural illegality, perversity, or violation of
principles of natural justice. It is also no more res-integra that
adequacy of evidence or reappreciation thereof is not within the
domain of judicial review.
15.
Now, adverting to the facts of the instant case, the argument
that the Petitioner has been dismissed from service merely on
registration of an FIR, is highly misconceived, as the charge does not
merely pertain to registration of the FIR, but is of deliberate
concealment and non-disclosure of his arrest in the an FIR registered
for a serious charge of murder and of furnishing of false information
before the department for seeking unauthorised leaves in lieu of his
arrest.
16.
Suppressing a material fact such as involvement in a criminal
case has a clear bearing on the character, conduct and antecedents of
an employee and if it is found that the employee has given false
information in relation to his suitability to the post then the order for
his termination cannot be faulted.
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 5429/2026
16:59:53
17.
Additionally, the Inquiry Officer, the Disciplinary Authority,
the Appellate Authority as well as the Revisional Authority, have
already passed detailed orders holding the Petitioner guilty, already
covering all the grounds raised by the Petitioner herein, which can be
summarized as under: a)
The Petitioner was sanctioned only 15 days casual
leave but he overstayed from leave without any
permission/prior sanction of leave from the Competent
Authority;
b)
Despite several directives from the Company
Commander, the petitioner neither reported for duty nor
communicated with the unit with supported documents;
c)
The Petitioner submitted requests for extension of
leave citing several reasons such as an accident etc. and
deliberately
concealed
the
material
fact
of
his
involvement in a criminal. Case;
d)
The Petitioner submitted a false medical document
dated 13.05.2023 along with the application for extension
of leave and it was found that the name of the patient
mentioned in the said advice slip is Manoj Upadhyay
(who is the brother of the Petitioner);
e)
Hence, for furnishing false information/documents,
an arrest warrant was issued against the Petitioner, by the
Commandant- 70 BN CRPF, and it was only during the
execution of the warrant it was revealed by the concerned
SHO that the Petitioner has been arrested in the criminal
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 5429/2026
16:59:53
case and is in judicial custody. This proved that he was
hiding information of his arrest;
f)
During the proceedings, it has been admitted that
the documents inter alia witness statements, reports,
orders etc. have been supplied to the Petitioner and he
had been given the opportunity to give his statement of
defence, reply to charges, take a defence assistant, crossexamine witnesses, which he himself did not avail.
18.
Manifestly, such conduct of the Petitioner misleading the
Department amounts to a serious breach of discipline and a conscious
compromise of the trust reposed in a member of a force and removal
of the Petitioner from service does not appear to be a disproportionate
penalty.
19.
Even otherwise, during the preliminary hearing, the Inquiry
Officer has recorded the statement of the accused employee regarding
acceptance of guilt/non-acceptance of guilt and the accused employee
has accepted his guilt on the charges levelled against him in items one
two and merely stated that he did not know that the department had to
be informed. The same is reproduced herein below: “Question:- 2 After the statements,
questions and answers, and crossexamination of all prosecution
witnesses, do you still accept the
charges leveled against you under
Memo No. P-Eight-01/2023-Estt Two70 dated 02/09/2023, Article-1 &
Article-2?
Answer:- Sir, I accept the charges
leveled in Article-One, and I also
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 5429/2026
16:59:53
accept the charges leveled in ArticleTwo, but I did not know that the
department had to be informed about
the arrest either in written or oral
form.”
(emphasis supplied)
20.
Once such charges, which strike at the core of integrity, have
been admitted by the Petitioner and there is evidence supporting the
same, the quantum of punishment imposed would lie primarily within
the domain of the Competent Authority and unless the punishment is
shown to be shockingly disproportionate to the gravity of the
misconduct or suffers from arbitrariness, this Court, in exercise of its
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, should refrain from
re-opening concluded proceedings on any hyper-technical grounds.
21.
In view of the foregoing, this Court is of the considered view
that no ground for interference has been made out with the penalty
imposed.
22.
The present petition is accordingly dismissed, along with
pending application(s), if any.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
APRIL 22, 2026
Jan
Signed By:HARMINDER
KAUR
W.P.(C) 5429/2026
16:59:53
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review