Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
REPORTABLE
SHAMURAILATPA SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL
M SUSHIL SHARMA SHARMA
Date: 2026.08.14 10:43:02 +05'30'
2026:MNHC:172-DB
Suppl.-1, Sl. Nos. 1-2, 3-4 & 5-6
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WA No. 19 of 2026
Ref:- WP(C) No. 474 of 2023
The
Manipur
Public
Service
Commission,
represented by the Secretary, North A.O.C., DM
Road, Imphal – 795001.
….. Appellant
-Versus1. The
Manipur
represented
Information
Commission,
the
Information
by
Chief
Commissioner, Secretariat North Block, Ground
Floor behind western Block Imphal Manipur795001.
2. Kh. Robindro Singh, aged about 41 years, S/o Kh.
Ibomcha Singh, r/o Ward No. 5, near Public
School, Ningthoukhong, Manipur – 795001.
..... Respondents
With
MC(WA) No. 51 of 2026
Ref:- WA No. 19 of 2026
The
Manipur
Public
Service
Commission,
represented by the Secretary, North A.O.C., DM
Road, Imphal – 795001.
….. Applicant
-Versus1. The
Manipur
represented
by
Information
Commission,
the
Information
Chief
Commissioner, Secretariat North Block, Ground
Floor behind western Block Imphal Manipur795001.
2. Kh. Robindro Singh, aged about 41 years, S/o Kh.
Ibomcha Singh, r/o Ward No. 5, near Public
School, Ningthoukhong, Manipur – 795001.
..... Respondents
With
WA No. 20 of 2026
Ref:- WP(C) No. 476 of 2023
The
Manipur
Public
Service
Commission,
represented by the Secretary, North A.O.C., DM
Road, Imphal – 795001.
….. Appellant
-Versus1. The
Manipur
represented
Information
Commission,
the
Information
by
Chief
Commissioner, Secretariat North Block, Ground
Floor behind western Block Imphal Manipur795001.
2. Nawaj Sharif, aged about 30 years, S/o Md. Abdul
Latif, R/o Lilong Haoreibi Lou Manga, P.O. & P.S.
Lilong, Thoubal District, Manipur – 795130.
..... Respondents
With
MC(WA) No. 52 of 2026
Ref:- WA No. 20 of 2026
The
Manipur
Public
Service
Commission,
represented by the Secretary, North A.O.C., DM
Road, Imphal – 795001.
….. Applicant
-Versus1. The
Manipur
represented
by
Information
Commission,
the
Information
Chief
Commissioner, Secretariat North Block, Ground
Floor behind western Block Imphal Manipur795001.
2. Nawaj Sharif, aged about 30 years, S/o Md. Abdul
Latif, R/o Lilong Haoreibi Lou Manga, P.O. & P.S.
Lilong, Thoubal District, Manipur – 795130.
..... Respondents
With
WA No. 21 of 2026
Ref:- WP(C) No. 475 of 2023
The
Manipur
Public
Service
Commission,
represented by the Secretary, North A.O.C., DM
Road, Imphal – 795001.
….. Appellant
-Versus1. The
Manipur
represented
Information
Commission,
the
Information
by
Chief
Commissioner, Secretariat North Block, Ground
Floor behind western Block Imphal Manipur795001.
2. Begun Khaleda Bogie, aged about 29 years, W/o
Mohd. Ayub Khan, R/o Lilong Tamya Sumang,
P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Thoubal District, Manipur –
795130.
..... Respondents
With
MC(WA) No. 53 of 2026
Ref:- WA No. 21 of 2026
The
Manipur
Public
Service
Commission,
represented by the Secretary, North A.O.C., DM
Road, Imphal – 795001.
-Versus-
….. Appellant
1. The
Manipur
represented
by
Information
Commission,
the
Information
Chief
Commissioner, Secretariat North Block, Ground
Floor behind western Block Imphal Manipur795001.
2. Begun Khaleda Bogie, aged about 29 years, W/o
Mohd. Ayub Khan, R/o Lilong Tamya Sumang,
P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Thoubal District, Manipur –
795130.
..... Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For
Appellants/Applicants
Mr. Rarry Mangsatabam, learned senior counsel
instructed by Ms. Nikita Mangsatabam, learned
counsel on record
Date of Judgment and 12.08.2026
Order
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(ORAL)
[M. Sundar, CJ]
[1]
The following abbreviations/short forms are used in this
order for the sake of brevity/convenience and clarity:
Sl. Abbreviations/
No. Short Forms
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
WA
WAs
MC
MCs
MPSC
RTI
RTI Act
SPIO
MIC
said examination
Full Form/Expansion
Writ Appeal
Writ Appeals
Miscellaneous Case
Miscellaneous Cases
Manipur Public Service Commission
Right to Information
The Right to Information Act, 2005 (22 of 2005)
State Public Information Officer
Manipur Information Commission
Manipur Civil Services Combined Competitive
(Main) Examination, 2016
11.
12.
CPC
Impugned order
13.
Queriests
14.
15.
16.
17.
R1
R2
WP
said Rules
[2]
The Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908)
common order dated 21.07.2026 made by
Hon’ble Single Bench in WP(C) Nos. 474, 475
and 476 of 2023
2nd Respondents in captioned 3 WAs and 3
MCs
1st respondent
2nd respondent
Writ Petition
The Right to Information Rules, 2012
Subject matter of captioned WAs is Manipur Civil Services
Combined Competitive (Main) Examination, 2016 held by MPSC which
is being referred to as ‘said examination’.
[3]
3 (three) aspirants who sat for said examination (after
clearing preliminary examinations) were unsuccessful and they made
an application under RTI Act to SPIO of MPSC requesting for photo
copies/certified copies of their answer sheets in all papers as well as the
interview marks. This Court is informed that there were 8 (eight) papers
in all qua said examination. This application was received by MPSC on
08.12.2022 and SPIO of MPSC responded vide a communication/order
dated 23.12.2022 bearing reference No. 6/44/2022-MPSC(RTI) (original
order) informing the querists about marks secured by them in interview
but not acceding the request for copies of answer sheets by stating that
MPSC has made a policy decision to not to furnish answer scripts
mechanically for descriptive type papers under normal circumstances.
This original order of SPIO was assailed by the 3 (three) queriests by
way of appeals under Section 19(1) of the RTI Act and these appeals
were negatived by the first appellate authority (to be noted, Secretary,
MPSC who is senior in rank qua SPIO is first appellate authority) in and
vide an order dated 24.02.2023 bearing reference No. 6/44/2022-MPSC
(RTI) inter-alia on the ground that MPSC does not provide answer
scripts of descriptive type papers and this is not an extreme policy as
contended by queriests. The queriests carried the matter to MIC by way
of a further appeal under subsection (3) of Section 19 of RTI Act and
the MIC in and by an order dated 28.04.2023 in Appeal Case Nos. 16,
19 and 22 of 2023, responding to the plea of the queriests in the appeal
that they be permitted to peruse i.e., inspect their answer sheets,
disposed of the appeals by directing MPSC to allow the 3 (three)
queriests to inspect their answer sheets qua said examination within 4
(four) weeks from the date of the order. This order of MIC was assailed
by MPSC by way of 3 (three) writ petitions viz., WP(C) Nos. 474, 475
and 476 of 2023, all 3 (three) writ petitions were taken up by a Hon’ble
Single Bench, which after full contest, dismissed the writ petitions by a
common order dated 21.07.2026 affirming the order of MIC and
directing MPSC to comply with the orders of MIC within a period of 30
(thirty) days from the date of receipt of a copy of the order (to be noted,
receipt of copy order of Hon’ble Single Bench which is being referred to
as ‘impugned order’ in instant order) leaving the parties to bear their
own costs.
[4]
Assailing the impugned order, three intra-court appeals
i.e., captioned 3 (three) WAs have been filed by MPSC along with MCs
thereat.
[5]
In the Admission Board today, Mr. Rarry Mangsatabam,
learned senior advocate instructed by Ms. Nikita Mangsatabam, learned
counsel on record for appellant/MC applicant (MPSC) in all three
WAs/MCs is before this Court.
[6]
Notwithstanding myriad grounds raised in memoranda of
appeals in captioned WAs, learned senior counsel predicated his
campaign against the impugned order on 3 (three) points and the 3
(three) points are as follows :
(i) MIC, dealing with the second appeals has modified the
order of the first appellate authority without a specific
prayer in this regard and that too, without setting aside
the order of the first appellate authority. According to
learned senior counsel, this is impermissible as Section
19 and more particularly, subsection (3) of Section 19
of RTI Act is appellate jurisdiction which is in the nature
of a second appeal;
(ii) the queriests originally sought for photo copies/certified
copies of answer papers and in the light of the language
in which subsection (8) of Section 19 of RTI Act is
couched, the power is qua furnishing what has been
sought for ‘in a particular form’ but MIC has permitted
perusal of answer papers while what was sought for by
queriests is certified copies/photocopies of answer
sheets;
(iii) the policy decision of MPSC that copies of answer
scripts will not be given under normal circumstances is
under challenge at the instance of 10 (ten) individuals
vide WP(C) No. 312 of 2022, the same is pending
before this Division Bench but the impugned order has
sustained the order of MIC after noticing pendency of
WP(C) No. 312 of 2022.
[7]
This Court carefully considered the afore-referred 3
(three) points on which learned senior counsel predicated his campaign
against the impugned order, in the light of case file, case laws pressed
into service by learned senior counsel and detailed submissions of
learned senior counsel.
This Court now proceeds to set out its discussion and
dispositive reasoning on the three points and an adumbration of the
same is as follows :
(i) as regards the first point, it turns on MIC being
a second appellate authority. In this regard, Section
19 of RTI Act to the extent relevant is as follows :
‘19. Appeal.
(1) …………….
(2) ………………
(3) A second appeal against the decision under
sub-section (1) shall lie within ninety days
from the date on which the decision should
have been made or was actually received,
with the Central Information Commission
or the State Information Commission:
Provided
that
the
Central
Information Commission or the State
Information Commission, as the case may
be, may admit the appeal after the expiry of
the period of ninety days if it is satisfied that
the appellant was prevented by sufficient
cause from filing the appeal in time.
(4) ………………
(5) In any appeal proceedings, the onus to
prove that a denial of a request was justified
shall be on the Central Public Information
Officer or State Public Information Officer,
as the case may be, who denied the request.
(6) ………………
(7) ………………
(8) In its decision, the Central Information
Commission
or
State
Information
Commission, as the case may be, has the
power to,—
(a) require the public authority to take any
such steps as may be necessary to secure
compliance with the provisions of this Act,
including—
(i)
by providing access to information, if
so requested, in a particular form;
(ii) by appointing a Central Public
Information Officer or State Public
Information Officer, as the case may
be;
(iii) by publishing certain information or
categories of information;
(iv) by making necessary changes to its
practices in relation to the
maintenance,
management
and
destruction of records;
(v) by enhancing the provision of training
on the right to information for its
officials;
(vi) by providing it with an annual report
in compliance with clause (b) of subsection (1) of section 4;
(b) require the public authority to compensate
the complainant for any loss or other
detriment suffered;
(c) impose any of the penalties provided under
this Act;
(d) reject the application.
(9) ………………
(10) The Central Information Commission or
State Information Commission, as the case
may be, shall decide the appeal in
accordance with such procedure as may be
prescribed.’
(ii)
as regards second appeal point, from the
statutory and legal architecture of RTI Act and
more particularly Section 19 of RTI Act, it is
clear as daylight that a second appeal under
Section 19(3) of RTI Act is not akin to a second
appeal under Section 100 of CPC. The reason is,
a second appeal under Section 100 of CPC turns
only on a ‘substantial question of law’ and the
first appellate court under Section 96 of CPC is
the last court on facts. That is not the scenario
here considering the architecture of RTI Act
more particularly, the language in which Section
19 is couched. To be noted, Section 19 of RTI
Act sets out the hierarchy, mechanism and
methodology of drill at various tiers. In this
regard, learned senior counsel pressed into
service a judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Chief
Information
Commissioner
and
another Vs. State of Manipur & Another
reported in (2011) 15 SCC 1. In this CIC case,
on facts, the queriests filed an application under
Section 6 of RTI Act for obtaining information
from State Information Officer relating to
magisterial enquiries initiated by Government of
Manipur from 1980 to 2006, as there was no
response,
the
State
Chief
Information
Commission was approached under Section 18
of RTI Act and the Commission directed the
Information Officer to furnish the information
sought for within 15 (fifteen) days and this was
challenged by State by filing a writ petition in
High Court of Gauhati, Imphal Bench. The writ
petition was dismissed by a Single Bench and in
the intra-court appeal a Division Bench held that
the direction to furnish information is without
jurisdiction and directed the Commission to
dispose of the complaints in accordance with
law. This order was challenged by Chief
Information Commissioner and the matter thus
travelled to Hon’ble Supreme Court. In this
factual matrix, after examining Section 19 of RTI
Act, Hon’ble Supreme Court held that an appeal
is always a creature of statute and therefore, the
right of appeal is a right of entering a superior
forum for invoking the same and interposition to
correct errors of the lower forum. Hon’ble
Supreme Court also held that this is a valuable
right and such a right of appeal conferred by
State must be exercised by a person who is
aggrieved by reason of refusal to be furnished
with the information. According to learned
senior
counsel,
this
Chief
Information
Commissioner case, inter-alia, adverts to
subsection (8) of Section 19 of RTI Act and
therefore, what can be considered by the
superior forum is only information sought for ‘in
a particular form’. To put it differently, in the
case at hand, the queriests have sought for
photo copies/certified copies of answer scripts
and therefore, MIC, exercising jurisdiction under
Section 19(3) of RTI Act in a second appeal
ought not to have directed perusal of answer
scripts is his say. This Court carefully considered
this submission. As already alluded to supra, an
appeal under Section 19(3) of RTI Act though a
second appeal is not akin to a second appeal
under Section 100 of CPC. Therefore, an appeal
under Section 19(3) does not turn only on
substantial questions of law. To be noted, the
expression ‘substantial question of law’ has
been
elucidatively
explained
by
Hon’ble
Supreme Court in a long line of authorities
starting from Sir Chunilal V. Mehta and
Sons, Ltd. Vs. Century Spinning and
Manufacturing Co. Ltd. reported in 1962
SCC OnLine SC 57 through Hero Vinoth
(Minor) Vs. Seshammal reported in (2006)
5 SCC 545 and subsequent judgments. Unlike
Section 100 CPC, 19(3) of RTI Act does not
restrict a second appeal to questions of law
much
less
substantial
questions
of
law.
Therefore, Chief Information Commissioner
case law pressed into service by learned senior
counsel does not come to his aid as the said case
law does not say that the powers under Section
19(3) of RTI Act are narrowed down in any
manner. On the contrary, a careful and
respectful perusal of the case law, more
particularly paragraph 49 and 50 thereat make
it clear that the powers of the appellate forum
are plenary and the rights vested in a citizen in
this regard are valuable rights. Paragraphs 49
and 50 of Chief Information Commissioner
case law read as follows :
‘49. There is another aspect also. The procedure
under Section 19 is an appellate procedure. A
right of appeal is always a creature of statute. A
right of appeal is a right of entering a superior
forum for invoking its aid and interposition to
correct errors of the inferior forum. It is a very
valuable right. Therefore, when the statute confers
such a right of appeal that must be exercised by a
person who is aggrieved by reason of refusal to be
furnished with the information.
50. In that view of the matter this Court does not
find any error in the impugned judgment of the
Division Bench. In the penultimate paragraph the
Division Bench has directed the Information
Commissioner, Manipur to dispose of the
complaints of the respondent 2 in accordance with
law as expeditiously as possible.’
Therefore, by respectfully applying the very case law
pressed into service by learned senior counsel, this Court has no
hesitation in coming to the conclusion that there is no error either in
the procedure resorted to by MIC in considering and disposing of three
second appeals vide common order dated 28.04.2023 in Appeal Case
Nos. 16, 19 and 22 of 2023 or in applying the substantive law. Another
buttressing point in this regard is, subsection (10) of Section 19 makes
it clear that a State Information Commission (MIC in this case) shall
decide a second appeal in accordance with such procedure as may be
prescribed. Procedure has been prescribed vide Rule 11 of said Rules
[to be noted, said Rules is a piece of subordinate legislation made by
Appropriate Government in exercise of Rule making powers vide Section
27 of RTI Act and Rule 11 is traceable to 27(2)(e)]. Rule 11 reads as
follows :
‘11. Procedure for deciding appeals.—The Commission, while
deciding an appeal may.—
(i) receive oral or written evidence on oath or on
affidavit from concerned or interested person;
(ii) peruse or inspect documents, public records or
copies thereof;
(iii) inquire through authorised officer further details
or facts;
(iv) hear Central Public Information Officer, Central
Assistant Public Information Officer or the First
Appellate Authority, or such person against whose
action the appeal is preferred, as the case may be;
(v) hear third party; and ,
(vi) receive evidence on affidavits from Central Public
Information Officer, Central Assistant Public
Information Officer, First Appellate Authority and
such other person against whom the appeal lies or
the third party.’
Rule 11 brings to light that MIC is not denuded of powers
to modify an order under appeal and/or mould the relief. In instant
case, MIC has modified the order of first appellate authority and
moulded the relief. To further contend that order of first appellate
authority has not been set aside is no argument as even on a demurer
this Court finds this to be too hypertechnical a point and it does not cut
ice with us.
(iii) This takes this Court to second point urged by
learned senior counsel. The second point is while
queriests sought for photocopies/certified copies of
answer sheets, MIC has permitted the queriests to
peruse the answer sheets which according to learned
senior counsel is impermissible. In this regard,
learned senior counsel pressed into service and
placed
reliance
on
Union
Public
Service
Commission and others Vs. Angesh Kumar and
others reported in (2018) 4 SCC 530. Angesh
was rendered by Hon’ble Supreme Court on
20.02.2018. On facts, Angesh is a case where IAS
aspirants who were unsuccessful in the preliminary
examinations approached the Union Public Service
Commission (UPSC) to disclose details of marks (raw
and scaled) awarded to them in the Civil Services
(Prelims) Examination. Further information in the
form of cut-off marks for every subject, scaling
methodology, model answers and complete result of
all candidates were also sought. In this factual
backdrop, in Angesh, Hon’ble Supreme Court held
that furnishing raw marks will cause problems as
pleaded by UPSC and that the same will not be in
public interest. However, Hon’ble Supreme Court
also made it clear that where a Court finds that public
interest requires furnishing of information, the Court
is certainly entitled to order so in a given fact
situation. To be noted, in Angesh, Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that direction to furnish the details sought
for have been given without considering these
parameters. Learned senior counsel draws our
attention to paragraph 9 of Angesh and the same
reads as follows :
‘9. Weighing the need for transparency and
accountability on the one hand and requirement of
optimum use of fiscal resources and confidentiality of
sensitive information on the other, we are of the view
that information sought with regard to marks in Civil
Services Exam cannot be directed to be furnished
mechanically. Situation of exams of other academic
bodies may stand on different footing. Furnishing
raw marks will cause problems as pleaded by b the
UPSC as quoted above which will not be in public
interest. However, if a case is made out where the
Court finds that public interest requires furnishing of
information, the Court is certainly entitled to so
require in a given fact situation. If rules or practice
so require, certainly such rule or practice can be
enforced. In the present case, direction has been
issued without considering these parameters.’
(iv) Be that as it may, prior to Angesh, in 2011 Aditya
was rendered by Hon’ble Supreme Court and Aditya
is reported in (2011) 8 SCC 497 {Central Board
of Secondary Education and another Vs.
Aditya Bandopadhyay and others}. Aditya was
rendered by Hon’ble Supreme Court on 09.08.2011.
In Aditya, students who sat for Central Board of
Secondary Education (CBSE) Examination sought
inspection and re-evaluation of answer scripts. This
was negatived by CBSE by resorting to Section
8(1)(e) of RTI Act inter-alia by saying that CBSE has
a fiduciary relationship with the examiners. In this
context, Hon’ble Supreme Court sustained and
affirmed an order of High Court directing examining
bodies to permit examinees to have inspection of
their answer books after making clarifications
regarding the scope of RTI Act and the safeguards
and conditions subject to which information should
be furnished. This is captured and elucidatively set
out in paragraphs 65 and 66 of Aditya and the same
reads as follows :
‘65. The power under section 19(8) of the Act
however does not extend to requiring a public
authority to take any steps which are not required
or contemplated to secure compliance with the
provisions of the Act or to issue directions beyond
the provisions of the Act. The power under section
19(8) of the Act is intended to be used by the
Commissions to ensure compliance with the Act, in
particular ensure that every public authority
maintains its records duly catalogued and indexed
in the manner and in the form which facilitates the
right to information and ensure that the records are
computerized, as required under clause (a)
of section 4(1) of the Act; and to ensure that the
information enumerated in clauses (b) and (c)
of sections 4(1) of the Act are published and
disseminated, and are periodically updated as
provided in sub-sections (3) and (4) of section 4 of
the Act. If the “information” enumerated in clause
(b) of section 4(1) of the Act are effectively
disseminated (by publications in print and on
websites and other effective means), apart from
providing transparency and accountability, citizens
will be able to access relevant information and
avoid unnecessary applications for information
under the Act.
66. The right to information is a cherished right.
Information and right to information are intended to
be formidable tools in the hands of responsible
citizens to fight corruption and to bring in
transparency and accountability. The provisions
of RTI Act should be enforced strictly and all efforts
should be made to bring to light the necessary
information under clause (b) of section 4(1) of the Act
which relates to securing transparency and
accountability in the working of public authorities
and in discouraging corruption. But in regard to
other information,(that is information other than
those enumerated in section 4(1)(b) and (c) of the
Act), equal importance and emphasis are given to
other public interests (like confidentiality of sensitive
information, fidelity and fiduciary relationships,
efficient operation of governments, etc.).’
(v)
In Aditya, Hon’ble Supreme Court went into the
issue
with regard to revealing the identities of
examiners. Post Angesh, Mradul Mishra was
rendered by Hon’ble Supreme Court on 16.07.2018
and Mradul Mishra is reported in 2018 SCC
OnLine SC 3993 (Mradul Mishra Vs. Chairman,
U.P. Public Service Commission, Allahabad
and another). In Mradul Mishra, facts to the
extent as can be culled out from the order of Hon’ble
Supreme Court is that the examinees wanted to see
their answer sheets in an examination in which they
participated and the examination was conducted by
Uttar Pradesh State Public Service Commission. In
Mradul Mishra rendered by Hon’ble Supreme Court
on
16.07.2018,
Aditya
and
Angesh
were
considered. After considering Aditya and Angesh,
Hon’ble Supreme Court held that Angesh does not
detract from the view already taken by Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Aditya. In Mradul Mishra,
Hon’ble Supreme Court also made it clear that
permitting a candidate to inspect answer sheets does
not involve any public interest and it does not affect
efficient operation of the Government. It was also
held that issues of confidentiality and disclosure of
sensitive information that may arise have been taken
care of in Aditya where it has been held that identity
of the examiners cannot be disclosed for reasons of
confidentiality. Relevant paragraphs in Mradul
Mishra are paragraphs 12, 13 and 16 and the same
read as follows :
‘12. Learned counsel for the respondents has
drawn our attention to a decision of this
Court in Union Public Service Commission
v. Angesh Kumar [Civil Appeal Nos. 61596162 of 2013] decided on 20th February,
2018.
13. We have considered the decision rendered
in the aforementioned case, but find that it
does not detract from the view already
taken by this Court in Aditya
Bandopadhyay (supra).
16. In our opinion, permitting a candidate to
inspect the answer sheet does not involve
any public interest nor does not affect the
efficient operation of the Government.
There are issues of confidentiality and
disclosure of sensitive information that may
arise, but those have already been taken
care of in the case of Aditya Bandopadhyay
where it has categorically been held that
the identity of the examiner cannot be
disclosed for reasons of confidentiality.’
(vi) To be noted, the afore-referred paragraphs are
paragraphs as extracted and reproduced from the
SCC OnLine report. It has become necessary to
mention this as sometimes paragraph numbers vary
depending on the journal and it sometimes varies as
between regular and OnLine versions also. In this
regard, learned senior counsel also pressed into
service Prashant Ramesh rendered on 20.02.2013
and reported in (2013) 12 SCC 489 {Prashant
Ramesh Chakkarwar Vs. Union Public Service
Commission and others}. This case law, as
reported in SCC is a record of proceedings and it is
evident that on facts, Prashant Ramesh is one
where pursuant to an advertisement issued by UPSC,
application for recruitment for Indian Administrative
Service and Allied Services were made and a
candidate who cleared Preliminary Examinations
held in 2007, 2008 and 2009 but did not succeed in
the Main Examination (Written Test and Interview),
filed an application and questioned the method of
moderation adopted by the Commission. In this
context, in Prashant Ramesh, it was held that the
mere fact that some of the candidates like the
petitioners thereat who cleared the preliminary
examinations could not cross the hurdle of main
examination cannot lead to an inference that the
method of moderation adopted by UPSC is faulty. To
be noted, the prayer in Prasant Ramesh has been
extracted and set out by Hon’ble Supreme Court in
paragraph No. 5 and we respectfully refer to
paragraph No. 5 of Prasant Ramesh and the same
reads as follows:
‘5. In response to the advertisements issued by the
Union Public Service Commission (for short “the
Commission”), petitioner, Dr Prashant Ramesh
Chakkarwar
submitted
applications
for
recruitment to Indian Administrative Services and
other Allied Services. He cleared the preliminary
examinations held in 2007, 2008 and 2009 but did
not succeed in the main examinations (written test
and interview). After seeking some information by
invoking the provisions of the Right to Information
Act, 2005, the petitioner filed an application under
Section 19 of the Act and questioned the method of
moderation adopted by the Commission and
prayed as under:
“(i) Direct the respondent to produce all the records
relating to the case including attendance
sheets/Pro forma F containing details of
supplements taken, the answer books of the
applicants in all the subjects and verify the
irregularities committed by the respondent in the
evaluation of the answer books;
(ii) Direct the respondent to produce attendance
sheets/Pro forma F containing details of
supplements used) of all applicants to verify the
number of extra sheets used by them and verify the
irregularities committed by the respondent;
(iii) Direct the respondent to produce raw and
moderated marks of applicants and all other
candidates in the Civil Services (Main)
Examination, 2008 to verify justness of the
moderation system;
(iv) To strike down the system of moderation/scaling
applied by UPSC after asking UPSC to explain the
system;
(v) Direct the respondent to bring uniformity in the
system of awarding marks in personality test by
reducing excessive subjectivity;
(vi) Permit the applicants to carry out the inspection
of the answer books in the Court;
(vii) Direct the respondent to re-examine and reevaluate the answer books of the applicants where
the irregularities are found to be existing in the
evaluation process of the Civil Services (Main)
Examination, 2008; and
(viii) Direct the respondent to declare the
applicants pass in the Civil Services (Main)
Examination, 2008 if after revaluation and proper
valuation they get more marks than the mark
achieved by the last candidate in the result who
was called for interview and consider them for
appointment.’
Hon’ble Single Bench, in the impugned order has referred
to Angesh and Mradul Mishra and held that the latter will apply.
Relevant portion is contained in paragraph 17 of impugned order and
the same reads as follows :
‘[17] ……….. The decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of Mradul Mishra (supra) will be
applicable in the present case. After considering the
catena of cases including Angesh Kumar and Aditya
Bandopadhyay, Hon’ble Supreme Court held that
allowing the candidate to inspect their evaluated answer
script will be in the interest of transparency and will not
violate any public interest.’
(vii) One other aspect of the matter is, learned
senior
counsel submitted that a review was filed in Angesh
Kumar and review was disposed of by Hon’ble
Supreme Court on 06.09.2018. Learned senior counsel
further submitted that disposal of the review petition in
Angesh Kumar on 06.09.2018 is post Mradul Mishra
(to be noted, Mradul Mishra was rendered on
16.07.2018) and therefore, Angesh Kumar would
prevail. We respectfully and carefully perused the order
of Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 06.09.2018 as placed
before this Court and scanned reproduction of the same
reads as follows:
(viii) It is clear that the review petition has been
dismissed and in the review order Mradul Mishra
has not been adverted to. Paragraph No. 9 of
Angesh Kumar has been set out and reiterated in
the review and we have respectfully extracted and
set out paragraph No. 9 of Angesh Kumar
elsewhere supra in instant order. A careful perusal of
the line of authorities adverted to thus far brings to
light that in Mradul Mishra both Angesh Kumar
and Aditya Bandopadhyay have been considered
and Hon’ble Supreme Court has come to the
conclusion that Angesh Kumar does not detract
from Aditya Bandopadhyay and the safety valve
put in place in Aditya Bandopadhyay as regards
non-disclosure of the identity of the examiners is
good enough. Therefore, the dismissal of the review
petition in Angesh Kumar without adverting to
Mradul Mishra, makes it clear that Mradul Mishra
continues to hold the field. To put it differently,
Mradul
Mishra
which
reiterates
Aditya
Bandopadhyay and holds that Angesh Kumar
does not detract from Aditya Bandopadhyay,
binds us as dismissal of the review in Angesh
Kumar post Mradul Mishra but without referring
to Mradul Mishra does not alter the position if well
settled principle qua law of precedents is respectfully
applied. We deem it appropriate to write that it is
also a matter of judicial discipline that principles of
law of precedents is respectfully applied. Another
buttressing point in this regard is, a careful
examination of the language in which Section
19(8)(a)(i) is couched makes it clear that MIC has
ample and adequate powers to provide access to
information, ‘if requested’ and the expression ‘in a
particular form’ qualifies the form in which access to
information is to be provided. Therefore, this court is
unable to find any infirmity in MIC providing access
to information by permitting perusal of answer
papers and Hon’ble Single Bench sustaining the
same vide impugned order. In this regard, it is to be
noticed that definition of ‘right to information’ vide
Section 2(j) of RTI Act makes it clear that it includes
right to inspect documents, records and Section 2(f)
of RTI Act to the extent relevant reads as follows :
‘2. Definitions.—In this Act, unless the context
otherwise requires,—
(a) ……..
(b) ……..
(c) ……..
(d) ……..
(e) ……..
(f) ……..
(g) ……..
(h) ……..
(i) ………
(j) “right to information” means the right to
information accessible under this Act
which is held by or under the control of any
public authority and includes the right to—
(i) inspection of work, documents, records;
(ii) ………
(iii) ………
(iv) ………’
In this regard, for completion of facts, it is
necessary to capture another facet of argument made by learned senior
counsel.
Learned
senior
counsel
submitted
that
Aditya
Bandopadhyay is a case pertaining to students taking school
examinations namely, CBSE whereas Prashant Ramesh, Angesh
Kumar and Mradul Mishra are cases pertaining to recruitment
conducted by Public Service Commission.
(ix) This Court is of the considered view that in Mradul
Mishra,
Angesh
Kumar
and
Aditya
Bandopadhyay are ratios on same subject directly
on the point and as Hon’ble Supreme Court in Mradul
Mishra has applied Aditya and Angesh without
construing the same to be distinguishable on facts as
a matter of judicial discipline, we cannot countenance
the argument that Aditya is factually distinguishable
by making a distinction between student examinees
and job aspirants. This puts an end to the second
point urged.
(x)
This takes this Court to the third point urged by
learned senior counsel. The third point turns on policy
decision of MPSC and the same being under challenge
in this Court vide W.P.(C) No. 302 of 2002. Hon’ble
Single Judge in the impugned order has noticed the
obtaining position that policy decisions of MPSC is
under challenge and writ petition is pending before
Division Bench in this Court. The policy decisions of
MPSC have been placed before this Court. The policy
decisions are vide decisions taken by MPSC in full
commission meetings held on 28.10.2022 and
04.05.2022. In 28.10.2022 full commission meeting it
was Agenda No. 4 and in 04.05.2022 full commission
meeting it was Agenda No. 2 and decisions as placed
before this Court are as follows:
‘DECISION OF THE FULL COMMISSION MEETING HELD ON
04.05.2022
Agenda No. 2: Providing certified copy of evaluated answer scripts
to RTI applicant in connection with Limited
Qualifying Speed Test Examination for Stenographer
Grade – I, 2021.
Decision:
The Commission decided to uphold the existing decision
of the Ful Commission dated 28/10/2020. The decision
of the Full Commission dated 28/10/2020 is reiterated
below:
“Commission minutely discussed the
matter and considered the issues in providing
evaluated answer books to the candidates. In the
case of Civil Appeal No.(s) 6159-6162 of 2013,
Union Public Service Commission, etc. -vs
Angesh Kumar & Ors with C.A. No. 5924/2013,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court had referred to the
problems enumerated in showing evaluated
answer sheets to candidates, in the Counter
affidavit as recorded in Prashant Ramesh
Chakkarwar vs. UPSC – “Final awards
subsume earlier stages of evaluation. Disclosing
answer books would reveal intermediate states
too, including the so-called ‘raw marks’ which
would have negative implications for the
integrity of the examination system”. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court was of the view that
information sought with regard to marks in Civil
Services Examination cannot be directed to be
furnished mechanically.
As the problem enumerated by UPSC in
providing evaluated answer books to candidates
is also similar for MPSC. Commission has
decided not to furnish evaluated answer books
for descriptive type papers to candidates under
normal circumstances.”
Further, the appellant has already been provided
with an opportunity to inspect his answer booklet.
Sd/Secretary/MPSC’
‘DECISION OF THE FC MEETING HELD ON 28.10.2020
Agenda No. 4:
Applications received for furnishing evaluation
answer books to the candidates.
Decision:
Commission minutely discussed the matter and
considered the issues in providing evaluated
answer books to the candidates. In the case of Civil
Appeal No. (s) 6159-6162 of 2013, Union Public
Service Commission etc. vs Angesh Kumar & Ors
with C.A. No. 5924/2013, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court had referred to the problems enumerated in
showing evaluated answer sheets to candidates, in
the counter affidavit as recorded in Prashant
Ramesh Chakkarwar v. UPSC1 – “Final awards
subsume earlier stages of evaluation. Disclosing
answer books would reveal intermediate stages too,
including the so-called ‘raw marks’ which would
have negative implications for the integrity of the
examination system”. The Hon’ble Supreme Court
was of the view that information sought with regard
to marks in Civil Services Examination cannot be
directed to be furnished mechanically.
As the problems enumerated by UPSC in providing
evaluated answer books to candidate is also similar
for MPSC, Commission has decided not to furnish
evaluated answer books for descriptive type papers
to candidates under normal circumstances.
Sd/Secretary’
(xi)
A careful perusal of the resolutions of MPSC make it
clear that the resolutions are to the effect that
‘providing
evaluated
answer
books’
in
descriptive type papers to candidates is something
which
cannot
be
furnished
‘under
normal
circumstances’. Hon’ble Single Bench in the
impugned order has made it clear that the policy
decision of the MPSC is only with regard to ‘not
providing copies of evaluated answer sheets’ and it
does not deal with ‘perusal of answer sheets’. We
find no reason to disagree with the considered view
taken by Hon’ble Single Bench in the impugned
order.
[8]
Before concluding, this Court deems it appropriate, for the
purpose of completion of facts and for the purpose of capturing
comprehensively what unfurled in the Admission Board that learned
senior counsel adverting to the impugned order of Hon’ble Single Bench,
submitted that the learned Single Bench has noticed that the policy
decision of MPSC is under challenge but has proceeded to return a
verdict that directions of MIC to permit perusal of answer scripts should
be complied. In the light of the clear distinction drawn by Hon’ble Single
Bench, between ‘furnishing copies’ and ‘permitting perusal’ we find this
argument pales into insignificance To put it differently, it does not cut
ice with this Court. However, we make it clear that when the WP
assailing the policy decision is heard out, instant order will neither
impede nor impel the legal drill before Division Bench.
[9]
As a last part of his effort, learned senior counsel
requested for enlargement of 30 days time frame fixed by Hon’ble
Single Judge for complying with the order of MIC (which has been
affirmed and a direction has been given to MPSC to comply). A careful
perusal of the impugned order brings to light that Hon’ble Single Bench
has made it clear that the order of MIC being order 28.04.2020 in appeal
case Nos. 16, 19 and 22 of 2023 should be complied within 30 days
from the date of receipt of the impugned order of Hon’ble Single
Bench. Learned senior counsel very fairly submits that this 30 days time
frame has not yet elapsed and it is running. Therefore, we find no
reason to enlarge the time frame provided by Hon’ble Single Judge and
therefore, this last part of the effort of learned senior counsel for the
protagonist of intra-court appeal also does not find favour with us.
[10]
Ergo, the sequitur is, captioned 3 WAs fail, i.e., fail to pass
muster in the Admission Board and the same are dismissed.
Consequently, captioned MCs thereat also perish with the WAs and
captioned 3 MCs are also dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil/Bipin
P.S. I : Upload forthwith
P.S. II : All concerned will stand bound by instant order vide web
copy uploaded in High Court website inter-alia as the
same is QR coded.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review