Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
UKHC010103892026
2026:UHC:5564-DB
Judgment Reserved on: 18.06.2026
Judgment Pronounced on: 08.07.2026
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
JUSTICE SHRI MANOJ KUMAR TIWARI
AND
JUSTICE SHRI PANKAJ PUROHIT
Writ Petition (S/B) No.344 of 2026
Mangal Singh Mandrawal
…Petitioner
Versus
State of Uttarakhand & another
…Respondents
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------Presence:Mr. Rajendra Dobhal, Senior Advocate, assisted by Mr. Shubhang Dobhal and Ms.
Saloni Bitthal, Advocates for the petitioner.
Mr. SS Chaudhary, Brief Holder for the State of Uttarakhand
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Justice Sri Manoj Kumar Tiwari)
Petitioner is a Government Servant, who is
holding the position of Registrar in Kumaon University.
After completing more than 30 years of service on
12.02.2026, he gave a notice for voluntary retirement
to the Appointing Authority under Fundamental Rule
56(c) of Financial Handbook, Volume-II, Part II-IV. The
said notice was forwarded by the Vice Chancellor on the
same day with the endorsement that petitioner can be
relieved after March 31, 2026. Petitioner thereafter
UKHC010103892026
2026:UHC:5564-DB
submitted a reminder on 12.05.2026, however, decision
taken was not communicated to him till expiry of notice
period of three months.
2.
State
communication
Government
on
thereafter
29.05.2026
issued
informing
the
one
Vice
Chancellor of Kumaon University that it is not possible
to grant voluntary retirement to the petitioner due to
shortage of personnel in the cadre of Registrar. Copy of
said communication was addressed to the petitioner
also.
Thus,
feeling
aggrieved,
petitioner
has
approached this Court seeking the following reliefs:“”(i) Issue a writ order or direction in the
nature of certiorari to call for record and quash the
impugned order dated 29.05.2026 (Annexure No. 6
Page no. 27) passed by respondent rejecting the
application for Voluntary Retirement of the
petitioner.
(ii) Issue any order, writ or direction of
mandamus directing the respondents to treat the
petitioner voluntary retired since 12/05/2026”.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits
that there is no disciplinary proceeding pending or
contemplated against petitioner; he has put in more
than 30 years of service and he was more than 57
years of age, as such, was eligible for voluntary
retirement, thus, there was no occasion for the State
Government to turn down the request for voluntary
UKHC010103892026
2026:UHC:5564-DB
retirement made by petitioner.
4.
Clause (c) of Fundamental Rule 56 provides
that a Government servant, may by notice to the
Appointing Authority voluntarily retire at any time after
attaining the age of 45 years or after he has completed
qualifying
service
of
years.
Clause
(d)
of
Fundamental Rule 56 provides that period of notice for
voluntary retirement shall be three months. Clause (c)
and (d) of Fundamental Rule 56 are extracted below:“(c) Notwithstanding anything contained in clause (a) or
clause (b), the appointing authority may, at any time, by
notice to any Government servant (whether permanent or
temporary), without assigning any reason, require him to
retire after he attains the age of fifty years or such
Government servant may by notice to the appointing
authority voluntarily retire at any time after attaining the
age of forty-five years or after he has completed
qualifying service of twenty years.
(d) The period of such notice shall be three
months:
Provided that—
(i) any such Government servant may by order of
the appointing authority, without such notice or
by a shorter notice, be retired forthwith at any
time after attaining the age of fifty years, and on
such retirement the Government servant shall be
entitled to claim a sum equivalent to the amount
of his pay plus allowances, if any, for the period
of the notice, or as the case may be, for the
period by which such notice falls short of three
months, at the same rates at which he was
drawing immediately before his retirement;
(ii) it shall be open to the appointing authority to
allow a Government servant to retire without any
notice or by a shorter notice without requiring
the Government servant to pay any penalty in
lieu of notice:
Provided further that such notice given by the
Government servant against whom a disciplinary
proceeding is pending or contemplated, shall be effective
only if it is accepted by the appointing authority, provided
that in the case of a contemplated disciplinary proceeding
UKHC010103892026
2026:UHC:5564-DB
the Government servant shall be informed before the
expiry of his notice that it has not been accepted:
Provided also that the notice once given by a Government
servant under clause (c) seeking voluntary retirement
shall not be withdrawn by him except with the permission
of the appointing authority.”
5.
The
moot
question,
which
falls
for
consideration of this Court, is whether a notice for
voluntary retirement becomes automatically effective
upon expiry of notice period of three months or
whether
consent/acceptance
of
the
Appointing
Authority would be necessary for such notice to become
effective.
6.
Rule 56 inter alia, deals with voluntary
retirement. Clause (c) of Rule 56 is in two parts, the
first
part
enables
the
Appointing
Authority
to
compulsorily retire a Government Servant after he
attains the age of 50 years. The second part enables a
Government
servant
to
give
notice
for
voluntary
retirement to the Appointing Authority, upon attaining
age of 45 years or upon completing qualifying service
of 20 years. Thus, any Government servant, who has
attained 45 years of age or has completed qualifying
service of 20 years, can give notice for voluntary
retirement to the appointing authority. The period of
such notice is three months.
UKHC010103892026
2026:UHC:5564-DB
7.
Second proviso to Clause (d) of Rule 56
ordains that notice given by a Government servant
against whom disciplinary proceeding is pending or
contemplated, shall become effective only when it is
accepted
by
the
Appointing
Authority.
It
further
provides that in case disciplinary proceeding is in
contemplation against the Government servant, then
he shall be informed before expiry of notice period that
it has not been accepted.
8.
Clause (c) of Rule 56 do not contemplate
consent of or acceptance by the Appointing Authority
and it creates a right in favour of a Government
servant,
who
meets
the
eligibility
voluntarily
retire
from
service.
retirement
is
akin
to
not
conditions,
Thus,
resignation
to
voluntary
in
which
acceptance by the Appointing Authority is needed.
Moreover, in case of resignation, a Government servant
may forfeit his right to get pension, but it is not so in
case of voluntary retirement
9.
Second proviso to Clause (d) of Rule 56
provides that acceptance of the notice for voluntary
retirement by the Appointing Authority would be
needed only in a case where disciplinary proceeding is
UKHC010103892026
2026:UHC:5564-DB
pending or contemplated against the Government
servant. This leads to the irresistible conclusion that
acceptance by the appointing authority to the notice for
voluntary retirement would not be necessary in other
cases. Thus, what is implicit in Clause (c) is made
explicit by second proviso to clause (d) of Rule 56.
10.
The latter half of second proviso to clause (d)
indicates that the rule making authority was alive to
the
consequence
of
Appointing
Authority
not
responding to the notice within notice period, therefore
in the rules it was provided that in case disciplinary
proceeding is contemplated, then the Government
servant has to be informed about the same before
expiry of notice period. This also indicates that in a
case where disciplinary inquiry is not pending, but is in
contemplation,
unless
the
Government
servant
is
informed about the said fact within the notice period,
the notice would become effective upon expiry of three
months.
11.
Third proviso to Clause (d) of Rule 56
provides that notice for voluntary retirement, once
given cannot be withdrawn, except with permission of
the Appointing Authority. Thus, the statutory right to
UKHC010103892026
2026:UHC:5564-DB
give notice, once exercised binds the Government
servant and it cannot be revoked thereafter, without
consent of the Appointing Authority. This shows that
once notice is given under clause (c) of Rule 56, it sets
the process of voluntary retirement in motion and the
Government servant is not at liberty to withdraw the
same. Since the notice binds the Government servant,
therefore, it is equally binding upon the Appointing
Authority, who has to take decision within the window
period of three months. Decision, if any, taken upon
expiry of notice period is, thus of no avail as the notice
becomes
effective
and
the
employer-employee
relationship comes to an end.
12.
In the present case, the notice was given by
petitioner on 12.02.2026, which was forwarded by the
Vice Chancellor to the State Government the same day
with his recommendation. It is the case of the
petitioner that notice was served upon Secretary,
Higher Education on 12.02.2026. The three months
notice period thus expired on 11.05.2026.
13.
Petitioner earlier filed Writ Petition (S/B) No.
292 of 2026 on 21.05.2026, which was withdrawn with
liberty
to
file
fresh
with
better
particulars.
On
UKHC010103892026
2026:UHC:5564-DB
29.05.2026, Joint Secretary, Higher Education issued
the
impugned
Chancellor
that
communication
petitioner’s
informing
request
for
the
Vice
voluntary
retirement cannot be accepted due to shortage of
personnel in the cadre of Registrar.
14.
Since
Clause
(c)
of
Rule
creates
a
statutory right in favour of a Government servant to
voluntarily retire from service and there was no
disciplinary
proceeding
pending
or
contemplated
against the petitioner, therefore, conjoint reading of
clause (c) and second proviso to clause (d) of Rule 56
leads to the irresistible conclusion that the notice given
by him became effective upon expiry of notice period
and formal acceptance by the Appointing Authority was
not needed at all. Thus, the decision of the State
Government dated 29.05.2026 of not accepting the
notice given by petitioner is inconsequential, as the
notice became effective by operation of law and
relationship of employer-employee came to an end
upon expiry of period of notice.
15.
For the aforesaid reasons, the writ petition
stands allowed. Petitioner shall be treated to be
voluntarily retired from service upon expiry of notice
UKHC010103892026
2026:UHC:5564-DB
period of three months. He shall be entitled to
retirement benefits, as per applicable rules.
(Pankaj Purohit, J.)
(Manoj Kumar Tiwari, J.)
08.07.2026
Navin
NAVEEN CHANDRA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH COURT OF
UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=3be23325146e76a0642bdf4943fb9046f487df006da82a131bb4e4403d
3c0a15, postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=18167EEFB5CA8CFFD421A103819DA875643AF56D653D095C6E
D9A86DAAB21CE5, cn=NAVEEN CHANDRA
Date: 2026.07.08 19:29:54 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review