Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:HON’BLE JUSTICE CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS.
CRR 3828 OF 2023
MANDAKINI BANDOPADHYAY @ BANERJEE & ORS.
VS
THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL & Ors.
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. Kallol Mondal, Adv.
Mr. Krishan Ray, Adv.
Mr. Souvik Das, Adv.
Mr. Anamitra Banerjee, Adv.
Mr. Akbar Laskar , Adv.
Mr. Sreyash Kumar Singh, Adv.
Ms. Moupiya Chakraborty, Adv.
For the State
:
Mr. Debasish Roy, Adv.
Mr. Koushik Kundu, Adv.
For the respondent
No. 2
:
Mr. Chittapriya Ghosh, Adv.
Mr. Somesh Kr. Ghosh, Adv.
Ms. Priyanka Saha, Adv.
Ms. Tulika Bag, Adv.
Last heard on
:
26.02.2026
Judgement on
:
26.02.2026
Uploaded on
:
27.02.2026
CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS:1. This revisional application is filed for quashing of a proceeding pertaining to G.
case no. 122 of 2019 dated January 27, 2019 under Section 498A A/406/34
of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 read with Section 3/4 of the dowry provision
act, now pending before the Court of learned Judicial Magistrate, 2nd court,
Arambagh, Hooghly.
Case of the petitioner
2. The petitioner no. 3 is the husband of the Opposite Party no. 2 and works as a
lecturer, Education Department of Steel Authority of India, IISCO steel plant,
Burnpur. Petitioner no. 1 and 2 are the mother-in-law and father-in-law of the
Opposite Party no. 2. The love affair embroiled between petitioner no. 3 and
the Opposite Party no. 2 culminated into marriage, solemnised on October 21,
2003 under Special Marriage Act and they suppressed such fact from their
respective families for several years because of the dislike by the father of the
opposite party no.2 and subsequently, the social marriage took place on
February 15, 2006. They lead conjugal life for long nine years after which they
were blessed with a male child in the year 2009, who is a patient of cerebral
Palsy.
3. The marital discord started since after birth of such child as he had to undergo
several treatments and needed to attend neurology OPD at regular intervals for
follow-up treatment and every year he is to attend NIMHANS for his check-up.
The petitioner gradually found the behavioural changes of Opposite Party no.
2, as she became reluctant towards continuing the matrimonial tie and on
asking the reason she along with her family members, became infuriated and
insulted the petitioner number 3 and did not allow him to enter their house.
They even restrained him from meeting with his own minor son. Such
intention of the Opposite Party no. 2 and her apathy towards her husband and
differently able child was clear from the fact stated by the Opposite Party no. 2
in connection with a proceeding filed before the court of District Judge, at
Asansol, where the petitioner no.3 had prayed for custody of his minor son
and the Opposite Party no. 2 wanted to give the custody of a her minor to her
husband.
4. Several litigation arose by and between the parties and in the above factual
backdrop, the Opposite Party no. 2 lodged the complaint against the
petitioners alleging misbehaviour with her and her differently able child
resulting had to suffering of mental abuse and on January 10,, 2019, her
husband in an inebriated state of condition inhumanly, tortured her and
threatened to kill her. That apart on January 25, 2019, the petitioners
threatened to kill her along with her son and forced her to write on paper of
her immoral relationship and threw them out of our matrimonial house.
Further alleges they took away all her articles while driving hr out.
5. On completion of investigation, the charge-sheet was submitted under Section
498/406/34 of the Indian Penal Code. The petitioners then preferred an
application under Section 239 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 before
the learned court which was rejected by order dated September 5, 2023
against which this revisional application has been filed.
Submissions
6. The learned Advocate representing the petitioner would submit that the
marriage is of long 12 years when they lead their conjugal life without any
disturbances and resided together at different places of work of the petitioner
no. 3 and at no point of time she lodged any complaint against the petitioner
no. 3 or her in-laws alleging any misbehaviour with her or demand of dowry.
The Opposite Party no. 2 on January 26, 2019 left the matrimonial home,
completely on her own volition
after admitting her extramarital relationship
with one Anshuman Chakraborty, who is also a colleague of the petitioner no.
3 herein. The Opposite Party no. 2 herein vengefully had initiated the instant
case against the petitioners as she was reluctant to continue her marital tie
with the present petitioner no.3.
7. It is further argued that the complaint is completely silent about the role
attributed by the present petitioner no. 1 and 2 who are aged and ailing
persons. The allegations against the petitioners are improbable and blatant
lies, and initiated the case out of vindictiveness and maliciousness as a
weapon to be the petitioners to her desires. The bear reading of the written
complaint would showcase that it was made upon lies and has no factual
basis. It is further argued that any further continuance of the instant
proceeding is an absolute abuse of the process of law and should forth with be
quashed.
8. The learned Advocate relied upon the decision of Preeti Gupta and another
vs state of Jharkhand and another1 , Dara Lakshmi Narayana and
(2010)7 SCC 667
others versus State of Telangana and another2 in order to substantiate
that FIR lodged with ulterior motives to settle personal scores and grudges
against the husband and his family members, making vague and omnibus
allegations without mentioning any specific details, including date, time, place,
or manner of commission of alleged occurrence to be quashed.
9. Per Contra The learned advocate representing the opposite party strenuously
argued that the petitioners have come before this court at post investigation
stage when the charge-sheet has been submitted. In course of investigation,
the investigating officer collected the materials, recorded the version of various
witnesses under section 161 of the code of criminal procedure and prima facie
found the allegations
made by the opposite party no.2 ,established .In order
to buttress the argument of the petitioner the learned Advocate has relied
upon the decision reported in State of Tamil Nadu by Ins of police,
vigilance and anticorruption versus N. Suresh Rajan3, where it was held
that while considering a petition under Section 227 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, the Court has to see whether from material on record it could be
said that accused might have committed offence. It did not hold mini trial and
come to conclusion that material produced warrant conviction. The learned
Advocate further relied upon the decision reported in State of Rajasthan
versus Ashok Kumar Kashyap4, where also the same principal was
reiterated that at this stage of framing of charge and considering discharge
application, mini trial is not permissible.
(2025) 3 SCC 735
AIR 2014 SC (supp) 1982
AIR online 2021 SC 210
10.
Learned Advocate, representing the State placed the case diary and the
relevant statements recorded which primarily supports the case of the
prosecution and hence argued that the petitioners should have faced the trial.
It is further submitted that in course of investigation, the articles were seized
as claimed by the Opposite Party no. 2, and hence the petitioners can be
discharged from the charge under Section 406 of IPC.
Analysis
11. Heard the submissions .The above mentioned factual matrix, coupled with
the submissions advanced by the learned counsels representing the respective
parties and the pleadings discloses that in the year 2003, both the petitioner
no. 3 and the Opposite Party no. 2 being students of Bardhaman University
entered into a relation and got married socially on February 15, 2006. The
claim of the petitioner of their being married under Special Marriage Act in the
year 2003 is not been admitted by the Opposite Party no. 2 and such veracity
cannot be tested before this court ,however the marriage is not disputed .
Admittedly, they lead conjugal life for a considerable period till 2019, when a
proceeding was initiated on behalf of the Opposite Party no. 2, under Section
125 CRPC being, Misc. 15 of 2019, for getting maintenance from the petitioner
no. 3 /husband. It can be further seen that they were blessed with a male
child on January 10, 2009, but since birth, the child was a patient of Cerebral
Palsy and as a Special child, he required special treatments and therapist on
regular interval.
The materials further revealed that gradually, the marital
relationship between the parties got deteriorated and it went to lodging of an
FIR before the Officer-in-Charge Goghat Police Station on January 27, 2019
against the present petitioners alleging of demand of dowry and mental torture
inflicted on her as she gave birth to a specially abled child, and subsequently
suffered a miscarriage. Her allegation further disclosed instigation on her of
committing suicide by the petitioners .Further an amount of Rs.1, 00,000/was taken as a loan from her mother by the husband and pressurised her to
have her father‘s property, and despite her best effort to keep the matrimonial
relation intact, she continued with such relation. She further mentioned about
an incident happened when she was inflicted with physical and mental torture
by the petitioner
no.3 in
inebriated condition on January 10, 2019 and
threatened her not to keep relation with parents but she did not lodge any
complaint even after such incident . After that on January 25, 2019, she and
her special able child were driven out by the petitioners after compelling her
to write about an immoral relationship of her and with a threatening of dire
consequences in case of intimating anyone about such threat. So prima facie
there is an admission about her extra marital relationship however the veracity
of such document whether procured forcefully or not cannot be ascertained by
this court.
12. She also alleged that all her articles and her personal belongings, and the
handicapped certificate of her minor child and medical papers were kept by the
petitioners and hence she compelled to lodge such complaint. The lists of
articles kept by the petitioners were annexed with the petition. On the basis of
such complaint, the investigation started and on completion of such
investigation charge sheet was submitted by the investigating officer and also
seized the articles along with the academic certificate and returned the same to
the complainant as per Zimmanama.
13. The petitioners appeared before the court and filed an application on June
23, 2023 praying for discharge from this case. The learned Court, considering
the submissions advanced took note of the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in state of Karnataka versus M.R Hiremath5 where it was held by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court that it is settled principle of law that at the stage of
considering an application for discharge, the court must proceed on the
assumption that the material which has been brought on the record by the
prosecution is a true and evaluate the material in order to determine whether
facts emerging from the material taken on their face value, disclose the
existence of the ingredients necessary to constitute the offence. The Learned
Court also was of the view that the statement recorded under 161 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure by the Investigating Officer consist of not only interested
persons of the case, but also that of the neighbour of both the de-facto
complainant and the petitioners and the veracity of the said witnesses cannot
be looked at this stage, and as a prime facie case has been made out by the
complainant and hence refuse such prayer of discharge.
14. In the charge-sheet, the Investigating Officer recorded the statement of
seven witnesses and cited them in order to establish the case of the
prosecution which included the brother and uncle of the complainant and two
neighbours of both Opposite Party no. 2, and the petitioner no. 3. On close
scrutiny of the content of the written complaint as well as on perusal of the
statement of the witnesses, no specific date, year, months can be found in
respect of the torture as alleged. No description of torture also can be found in
inflicted upon the Opposite Party no. 2 by the petitioner no. 1 & 2 being the
(2019) 7 SCC 515
parents-in-law. In the case of Dara Lakshmi Narayana (Supra) the
allegations made in the FIR were vague and omnibus. No specific details or
described any particular instance of harassment and also the time, date, place,
or manner in which the alleged harassment occurred were also not mentioned
and the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that FIR lacks concrete and precise
allegations. It was observed that:‘a mere reference to the names of family members in a
criminal case arising out of a matrimonial dispute, without
specific allegations, indicating their active involvement
should be nipped in the bud. It is well recognised fact,
born out of judicial experience, that there is often tendency
to implicate all the members of the husband’s family.
Domestic disputes arise out of a matrimonial discord. Such
generalised and sweeping accusations and supported by
concrete evidence or particularised allegations cannot form
the basis for criminal prosecution. Court must exercise
caution in such cases to prevent miss use of legal
provisions and the legal process and avoid unnecessary
harassment of innocent family members.’
15. In the case of Preeti Gupta and another (Supra) the Hon’ble
Supreme
Court observed and held that genuine cases of dowry harassment is a matter
of serious concern, but exaggerated version of small incidence should not be
reflected in the criminal complaints.
16. The observations made in the above were in the petition under Section 482
Cr.P.c for quashing of the entire proceeding, and the instant case is been filed
for discharge which was turned down. It is settled law that the probative value
of the material should not be gone into while considering discharge application
and the Court is not expected to go deep into the matter and to hold that the
materials would not warrant conviction, but it needs to be considered where
there is a ground for presuming that the offence has been committed and in
case from materials on record and on its probative value, the court things that
the accused might have committed the offence. It can frame the charge.
17. In the case of Neelu Chopra & Anr. vs Bharti6 the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held that when the complaint is sadly vague, it does not show as to which
accused has committed what offence and what exact role played by the
Appellant in commission of offence under such circumstances, it would be an
abuse of the process of law to allow the prosecution to continue against the
agent parents on the basis of such vague and general complaint.
18. In another decision of Kahkashan Kausar versus state of Bihar7, where
also the general allegations were levelled against the applicant without specific
and distinct allegations made against either of the appellant and none of the
appellants have been attributed any specific role and that leads to a situation
where one fails to ascertain the role played by each accused in furtherance of
the offence, and it was held that the allegation made against being general and
omnibus do not warrant prosecution.
19.
In the present case also on the face of the complaint, it manifest that since
after marriage in the year 2006, till 2019, the Opposite Party no. 2 had no
occasion to file any complaint before any authority, intimating any torture,
either mental or physical inflicted on her by her husband or parents-in-law on
demand of dowry. It can be gathered further that the custody of the child is
(2009) 10 SCC 184
(2022) 6 SCC 599
with the father on consent of the opposite party no 2.The petitioner no.1 and 2
being the parents-in-law, hardly resided with the Opposite Party no. 2 , since
she mostly resided with her husband at his place of work at various places of
the state.
20.
In the case of Preeti Gupta (Supra) Hon’ble Supreme Court held the courts
have to be extremely careful and cautious in dealing with these complaints
and must take pragmatic realities into consideration while dealing with
matrimonial cases.
21. Section 498A deals with offences committed by the husband or relatives of
the husband subjecting cruelty towards the wife. The said provision reads as
follows.
498A. Husband or relative of husband of a woman
subjecting her to
cruelty.—
Whoever, being the husband or the relative of the husband
of a woman, subjects such woman to cruelty shall be
punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend
to three years and shall also be liable to fine.
Explanation: — For the purpose of this section, “cruelty” means—
(a)any wilful conduct which is of such a nature as is likely
to drive the woman to commit suicide or to cause grave
injury or danger to life, limb or health (whether mental or
physical) of the woman; or
(b)harassment of the woman where such harassment is
with a view to coercing her or any person related to her to
meet any unlawful demand for any property or valuable
security or is on account of failure by her or any person
related to her to meet such demand.
In the present case nothing is available to constitute the offence of either the
part (a) or (b) of the above provision against the present petitioners. In the case
of Sanjay Kumar Rai vs State of U.P8, it was held by the Hon’ble Apex Court
that “it is well settled that the trial court while considering the discharge
application is not to act as a mere post office. The Court has to shift through the
evidence in order to find out whether there are sufficient grounds to try the
suspect. The Court has to consider the board probabilities, total effect of
evidence and document produced and the basic infirmities appearing in the case
and so on Union of India vs Prafulla Kumar Samal9.”
Conclusion
22. On close scrutiny of the entire facts and circumstances of the case it
transpires that the written complaint suffers from material particulars and the
role attributed by the present petitioner no. 1 and 2, the senior citizens and
septegerian persons, in respect of the allegations levelled against them. The
learned Magistrate, despite being duly apprised of the contents of the written
complaint and the materials collected during investigation- which
disclose
only general and omnibus allegations against the petitioner no. 1 and 2 and
are conspicuously silent as to any role attributed to them and lacks specific
details about the date and manner of torture inflicted upon her by the present
petitioner no. 1and 2 , refused their prayer for discharge along with
the
husband on the ground that the court cannot hold a mini trial. This court is
2015 SCC Online SC 367
(1979) 3 SCC 4
not agreeable with such observation as the complaint itself and the materials
collected during investigation are conspicuously silent about their specific role
as discussed above and no occasion arose to hold a mini trial. Therefore the
said order is liable to be set aside so far the petitioner No 1 and 2 are
concerned. However this court fully endorse the view so far the petitioner no 3,
the husband is concerned.
23. Hence, this revisional application stands allowed in part.
24. The order refusing to discharge the petitioner no. 1 and 2 is here by set
aside. The petitioner no. 1 and 2 are here by discharged from the charges
levelled against them.
25. So far, the petitioner no. 3 is concerned, the order passed by the Learned
Magistrate is here by affirmed.
26. All connected applications stands disposed of.
27. No order as to cost.
28. Urgent certified copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied expeditiously
after complying with all necessary legal formalities.
(CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS,J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review