Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgement reserved on: 17.12.2025
Judgement delivered on: 09.01.2026
+
LPA 652/2019, CM APPL. 53990/2023 (Seeking to call for the
record of W.P.(C) 9567/2023) & CM APPL. 54198/2023
(Direction)
MANAGING COMMITTEE OF VIDYA BHAWAN GIRLS
SENIOR SECONDARY SCHOOL & ANR.
.....Appellants
Through:
Mr. Rakesh Tiku, Senior
Advocate along with Mr.
Ashish and Mr. Monu Kumar,
Advocates with Appellants in
persons.
versus
LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR OF NATIONAL CAPITAL
TERRITORY OF DELHI AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through:
Mr. Sameer Vashisht, Standing
Counsel (Civil) GNCTD for R-l
and R-3 to R-5.
Ms. Deepti Verma, Ms.
Hitanshi and Mr. Ravi,
Advocates for R-6/Mr. Manish
Gupta (in person).
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN
SHANKAR
JUDGMENT
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
1.
By way of the present Appeal, filed under Clause 10 of the
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:36:07
LPA 652/2019
Letters Patent, the Appellants assail the Judgment dated 11.09.20191
rendered by the learned Single Judge of this Court in W.P.(C) No.
1239/2016, titled ‘Managing Committee of Vidya Bhawan Girls
Senior Secondary School through its Manager & Anr. v. Lt. Governor
of the National Capital Territory of Delhi & Ors.’.
2.
The writ petition before the learned Single Judge arose out of a
challenge to two administrative orders, namely, the Orders dated
16.02.2015 and 27.01.2016.
3.
The Order dated 16.02.2015, passed by the learned Special
Commissioner of Industries/ Registrar of Societies2, was assailed to
the extent that it recorded a finding that there had been no
amalgamation between Vidya Bhavan Girls School, Delhi Society3
and Vidya Bhavan Girls Education Society4, and that the said
societies were distinct and independent entities.
4.
The other Order dated 27.01.2016, passed by the Hon‟ble
Lieutenant Governor of Delhi5, insofar as it handed over the
management of Vidya Bhavan Girls School6 to the 1948-Society
through its Secretary, Shri Manish Gupta, was also assailed.
BRIEF FACTS:
5.
The School came to be established in the year 1942. Following
the same, the 1948- Society came to be established and registered with
the registrar of Joint Stock Companies, under the name of “Vidya
Bhawan Girls School, Delhi”.
Impugned Judgement
ROS
1948-Society
VBGES
LG
School
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:36:07
LPA 652/2019
6.
The Land and Development Office allotted land for the running
of the School to the 1948-Society on 23.12.1960, 13.07.1971 and
09.03.1978.
7.
In the interregnum, the Assistant Director of Education, Delhi,
on 09.12.1950 granted the School recognition under the Scheme of
management of the School, and on 09.05.1975, the School was duly
approved by the Directorate of Education7 in accordance with the
Delhi School Education Act, 19738.
8.
Thereafter, VBGES also came to be registered with the learned
ROS on 31.08.1978.
9.
Learned ROS, vide letter dated 13.11.1982 drawn by the Deputy
Education Office, was apprised of the fact that VBGES was receiving
95% grant-in-aid from the DoE, and that there was a dispute as
regards the membership of VBGES. In view of the same, the Deputy
Education Officer called upon the learned ROS to supply certified
copies of certain documents.
10.
Thereafter, the DoE issued a Show Cause Notice dated
23.07.2010, calling upon the Management/Principal of the School in
light of various complaints received against the management of the
School alleging irregularities/malpractices and as to why an action
should not be taken against the School in terms of the provisions of
Section 24(4) read with Section 20 of the DSE Act. Pursuant to the
aforenoted Show Cause Notice, the DoE also conducted an inspection
of the School and the report of the same was communicated to the
Manager of the School on 31.07.2010.
11.
In the interregnum, it is stated that consequent to a proper
DoE
DSE Act
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:36:07
LPA 652/2019
election, a new governing body of the VBGES, and a new Managing
Committee of the School took over and commenced functioning.
12.
Due to the existence of the competing managements, the
learned Single Judge of this Court, in a connected Writ Petition
[W.P.(C) 4241/2012], directed consideration of the takeover of the
School. The Hon‟ble LG vide Order dated 26.06.2012 granted
approval for taking over the School. Following thereafter, vide Order
dated 20.07.2012 of the Special Director of Education, the DoE took
over the management of the School in exercise of powers conferred
under Section 20(1) of the DSE Act.
13.
Shri P.S. Pabbi, thereafter, while purportedly representing the
Managing Committee of the School, preferred an appeal before the
Hon‟ble LG, challenging the Order dated 20.07.2012.
14.
The Hon‟ble LG upheld the takeover and the Order dated
20.07.2012, holding that the DoE would continue to manage the
School until the dispute regarding the rightful society/management
was decided by a competent court.
15.
Parallelly, various correspondences were addressed to the
learned ROS, wherein the 1948-Society alleged that VBGES was a
fraudulent body, while VBGES claimed that the 1948-Society had
been amalgamated into it.
16.
By a detailed order dated 16.02.2015, learned ROS held that the
1948-Society and VBGES are separate and distinct entities, and that
no amalgamation had taken place in accordance with Section 12 of the
Societies Registration Act, 1860. The learned ROS expressly declined
to decide the issue of restoration of management of the School.
17.
Following the Order passed by the learned ROS, both the 1948-
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:36:07
LPA 652/2019
Society and VBGES made repeated representations to the DoE
seeking restoration of the School‟s management. The DoE extended
the period of takeover up to July 2016 and rejected the claim of
VBGES for restoration.
18.
Three separate appeals thereafter came to be filed before the
Hon‟ble LG challenging various orders relating to the takeover and its
extension. By a common order dated 27.01.2016, the Hon‟ble LG set
aside the takeover and directed that the management of the School be
restored to the 1948-Society through its Secretary, Shri Manish Gupta,
relying primarily on the findings of the learned ROS.
19.
Aggrieved by the Order dated 27.01.2016 passed by the
Hon‟ble LG, as also the Order of the learned ROS dated 16.02.2015,
two Writ Petitions came to be preferred challenging the two
Administrative Orders.
20.
The Appellants preferred W.P.(C) 1239/2016 inter alia seeking
quashing and setting aside of the Order dated 27.01.2016 passed by
the Hon‟ble LG, to the extent that it handed over the management of
the School to the 1948 Society through Shri Manish Gupta and
holding the 1948 Society as the rightful owner of the School and
sought directions against the DoE to the extent that the management of
the School be handed over to the Appellants herein. The Appellants
further sought quashing of the Order dated 16.02.2015 passed by the
learned ROS.
21.
The learned Single Judge, by way of the Judgement impugned
herein, upheld both the Orders and rejected the Petition preferred by
the Appellants herein and put a caveat to the same stating that the
decision of the learned Single Judge vide the Impugned Judgement
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:36:07
LPA 652/2019
would be subject to the outcome of adjudication, if any, by a
competent civil court, on the competing claims, to management of the
School, as ventilated by the 1948-Socity and the VBGES.
22.
Aggrieved by the Judgement impugned, passed by the learned
Single Judge in W.P.(C) 1239/2016, the Appellants have preferred the
present Appeal.
ANALYSIS:
23.
We have heard the learned Senior Counsel for the Appellants as
well as the learned Counsel for the Respondents, and with their able
assistance, perused the Impugned Judgement as well as the Orders
passed by the learned ROS and Hon‟ble LG, along with all the
relevant material on record.
24.
With respect to the challenge raised to the Order of learned
ROS dated 16.02.2015, which is now before us, the learned Single
Judge upheld the said Order in its entirety. The relevant portions of the
said Judgment qua this question read as follows:“55. The ROS has, in his Order dated 16th February, 2015 supra,
proceeded on the premise that the requisites of Section 12 of the
Societies Registration Act, which deals, inter alia, with
amalgamation of societies, were not fulfilled, in the present case,
so as to make out a case of amalgamation of the 1948-Society with
the VBGES. Section 12 of the Societies Registration Act reads as
under:
“12. Societies enabled to alter, extend or abridge their
purposes. – Whenever it shall appear to the governing
body of any society registered under this Act, which has
been established for any particular purpose or purposes,
that it is advisable to alter, extend or abridge such purpose
to or for other purposes within the meaning of this Act, or
to amalgamate such society either wholly or partially with
any other society, such governing body may submit the
proposition to the members of the society in a written or
printed report, and may convene a special meeting for the
consideration thereof according to the regulations of the
society;
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:36:07
LPA 652/2019
but no such proposition shall be carried into effect
unless such report shall have been delivered or sent by
post to every member of the society ten days previous to
the special meeting convened by the governing body for
the consideration thereof, nor unless such proposition shall
have been agreed to buy the votes of three-fifth of the
members delivered in person or by proxy, and confirmed
by the votes of three-fifths of the members present at the
second special meeting convened by the governing body at
an interval of one month after the formal meeting.”
56.
Clearly, Section 12 of the Societies Registration Act
contemplates the following steps, to be carried out and completed,
before one society can amalgamate with another:
(i) submission, by the governing body of the society, of the
proposition to the members of the society in a written or
printed report,
(ii) convening of a special meeting for the consideration of the
proposition, according to the regulations of the society,
(iii) delivery, or dispatch, by post, of the report, to every
member of the society, at least ten days prior to the aforesaid
special meeting,
(iv) agreement, to the proposition, by the votes of three-fifths
of the members, delivered in person or by proxy, and
(v) confirmation, thereof, by the votes of three-fifth of the
members present at the second special meeting convened by
the governing body, one month after the 1st special meeting.
57.
Though Section 12 of the Societies Registration Act uses
the word “may”, it has been held in, inter alia, State of U.P. v.
Joginder Singh, AIR 1963 SC 1618 and Textile Commission of
Govt of India v. Shri Jagdish Process Pvt Ltd, (1977) 2 SCC 579,
that, where the discretion conferred by the use of the word “may”,
on a public authority, is coupled with an obligation, the discretion
should be construed to mean a command. Applying this principle,
the process and procedure, stipulated by Section 12 of the Societies
Registration Act, for amalgamation of societies, has strictly to be
followed. It is also trite that, where the law prescribes a particular
manner in which an act is to be done, that act has to be done in that
manner, or not done at all. [Ref. Taylor v. Taylor, (1875) 1 Ch. D.
426 and Nazir Ahmed v. King Emperor, L.R. 63 I.A. 372] Sans
implicit compliance, with the procedure stipulated in Section 12 of
the Societies Registration Act, therefore, there can be no
amalgamation of societies, as correctly held by the ROS in the
Order, dated 16th February, 2015 supra.
58.
It may be noted, here, that, in Anil Nanda v. Escorts Ltd,
(2009) 156 DLT 697 (DB), a Division Bench of this Court held
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:36:07
LPA 652/2019
that, as, against an order of amalgamation of societies, passed
under Section 12 of the Societies Registration Act, no remedy was
available, under the said Act, any party, aggrieved by such order,
would have to file a civil suit. I see no reason why the same
principle would not apply, where the decision of the competent
authority – the ROS, in the present case – is that no amalgamation
had taken place. It appears difficult, to me, for a writ court to
examine whether amalgamation of two societies had, or had not,
taken place, the exercise necessarily involving exhaustive and
comprehensive analysis of evidence.
59.
Insofar as the challenge, by the VBGES, to the Order, dated
16 th February, 2015 supra, of the ROS, is concerned, suffice it to
state that there is no averment, either in the writ petition filed by
the VBGES [W.P. (C)1239/2016], or in the written submissions
filed consequent to the conclusion of hearing in court, to the effect
that the procedure, contemplated by Section 12 of the Societies
Registration Act, was followed, so as to result in amalgamation of
the 1948-Society with the VBGES. Nor, it may be noted, is there
any document, or other material, on record, evidencing any
intention or animus, on the part of the 1948-Society, to amalgamate
with the VBGES, so as to result in transfer of the entrustment of
the management of the School, hithertofore being managed by the
1948-Society, to the VBGES.
60.
I see no reason, therefore, to interfere with the Order, dated
16 th February, 2015 supra, passed by the ROS, which holds,
correctly, that there is no evidence of amalgamation, at any point of
time, of the 1948-Society with the VBGES. The said decision is,
therefore, upheld in its entirety.”
25.
The second challenge, which is now before us, that pertained to
the Order dated 27.01.2016 passed by the Hon‟ble LG, was also
upheld by the learned Single Judge in its entirety in the following
manner:“61. The only issue that survives for consideration is whether the
Hon‟ble LG was justified in handing over the management of the
School to the 1948-Society through its Secretary Shri Manish
Gupta, in the Order dated 27th January, 2016. As already noted
hereinabove, the competing claims, of the 1948-Society, vis-à-vis
the VBGES, would have to be thrashed out, in appropriate civil
proceedings, which are necessary, if a definitive and final decision,
regarding the Managing Committee, or society, which is duly
competent and authorised to administer the affairs of the School, is
to be arrived at. Having held that there was no necessity of
continuing the decision to take over the management of the School,
the Hon‟ble LG decided to hand over the management of the
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:36:07
LPA 652/2019
School to the 1948-Society, through its Secretary Manish Gupta. It
is important to note that the impugned Order, dated 27th January,
2016, does not hand over the management of the School to Manish
Gupta in his personal capacity, but has directed handover of the
School to the 1948-Society, acting through its Secretary Manish
Gupta. This is a subjective decision, arrived at, by the Hon‟ble LG,
and cannot be said to suffer from arbitrariness or perversity, in any
manner.
62.
It cannot be said that there was no material, before the
Hon‟ble LG, on the basis whereof it was possible for him to arrive
at a subjective decision that Manish Gupta was, in fact, the
Secretary of the 1948-Society, or that the reins of the school could
be handed over to the 1948-Society, acting through him as its
secretary. A reading of the Order, dated 16th February, 2015, of the
ROS, indicates that Manish Gupta was the authorised signatory,
competent to act as Secretary, on behalf of the 1948-Society and
operate its Bank account. Reference has also been made, in the said
order, to the minutes of the meeting, dated 24th December, 2011,
of the 1948-Society, authorising Manish Gupta to act as its
Secretary. Additionally, the list of members of the Managing
Committee of the School, dated 21st December, 2012 and
countersigned by the Education Officer, Zone-28, also indicated
Manish Gupta to be the Manager in the Managing Committee of
the School. The complaint, dated 8th August, 2014, whereupon the
ROS passed the Order dated 15th February, 2015 supra, was also
addressed by Manish Gupta as Secretary of the 1948-Society. The
invitation, dated 28th December, 2012, to the DoE, to visit the
School, was also addressed by Manish Gupta, as authorised
signatory of the School. The Inspection Report, dated 12th March,
2013, issued by the inspecting committee of the DoE, indicated
that, on 24th January, 2013, when the school was inspected,
Archana Tuli was present in the school as its HOS. This fact,
viewed in conjunction with the letter dated 15th November, 2011,
addressed by Archana Tuli, to the Education Officer, indicated
Archana Tuli to be the head of the School, and Manish Gupta to be
its Manager, also indicates that Manish Gupta was, at the time, the
Manager of the School. Three specimen signatures, each, of
Archana Tuli, as the HOS, and of Manish Gupta, as the Manager of
the School, were also enclosed with the said letter. The letter, dated
25th May, 2015, addressed to the Secretary (Education), GNCTD,
for restoration of the School to the 1948-Society was also
addressed by Manish Gupta, as Secretary of the said Society, on
the letterhead of the Society.
63.
There was, therefore, ample material on record, on the basis
whereof the decision, of the Hon‟ble LG, to hand over the
management of the School to the 1948-Society, through its
Secretary Manish Gupta, could be justified. While this Court
reiterates that, in entering these observations, it is not intending to
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:36:07
LPA 652/2019
pronounce, definitively or finally, on the merits of the competing
entitlements, of the 1948-Society, vis-à-vis the VBGES, to manage
the School, it is clear that the decision, of the Hon‟ble LG, to hand
over the reins of the School to the 1948-Society, through Manish
Gupta, as its Secretary, cannot be said to be suffering from any
such manifest arbitrariness, irrationality, illegality or perversity, as
would warrant interference by this Court, in exercise of the
extraordinary and discretionary jurisdiction, vested in it by Article
226 of the Constitution of India.
64.
Before parting with this judgement, I deem it appropriate to
allude to the written submissions, filed by the DoE before the
Hon‟ble LG, on which the VBGES places great reliance. The
following averments find place therein:
“Till 2010 Vidya Bhawan Girls Education Society was
running the School smoothly. 2010 became the turning
point in the history of the School and Vidya Bhawan was
never the same again, all due to one and only one
mastermind, courtesy Ms Archana Tuli (Suspended HOS),
who manipulated people and situations only to fulfil her
selfish motives.
*****
It is also important to note that the internal conflict
between the so-called authentic Society VBGS (S-341) is
more than evident by the chairperson and the Secretary
has filed separate Appeals each claiming the right for
restoration or is this too is a result of connivance that the
chances of winning had doublefaulted and the existence of
VBGES (S-341) was more than evident? One is a
complete loss of words to the extent of cunningness and
shrewdness of all the people involved is concerned. But
one thing is for sure that as per the information in the
Directorate is concerned Amrit Mohini Suri or Manish
Gupta or Amit Rana who have been the faces of VBGS
(S341) during the last year are all outsiders and have been
planted by Ms Archana Tuli who in her sheer desperation
to ensure the return to the school, hatched a plot straight
out of a potboiler thriller.”
(Emphasis supplied)
The italicized portion of the written submissions of the DoE, supra,
denude the stand of the DoE, in these proceedings, of all
credibility. I say no more.
65. The challenge, to the decision of the Hon‟ble LG, in the
impugned Order, dated 27th January, 2016, to hand over the
management of the School to the 1948-Society, through its
Secretary Manish Gupta, therefore, fails. Needless to say, however,
this decision would remain subject to the outcome of adjudication,
if any, by a competent civil court, on the competing claims, to
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:36:07
LPA 652/2019
management of the School, as ventilated by the 1948-Society and
the VBGES.”
26.
A reading of Para 65 of the Judgment impugned would herein
reveal that the learned Single Judge has, while upholding the decision
of the Hon‟ble LG, made it subject to the outcome of any adjudication
of the competing claims as to the management of the School as
between the 1948-Society & VBGES by a competent Court of
jurisdiction.
27.
Upon a pointed query as to whether any such proceeding had
been initiated for the purpose of determining the competing claims as
between the 1948-Society & VBGES, the learned Senior Counsel for
the Appellants would submit that no such proceedings have been
preferred.
28.
We deem it appropriate to extract the relevant portions of the
Order dated 10.10.2019 passed by this Court in the present Appeal,
which read as under: “C.M. No.44432/2019 (exemption)
Allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
LPA 652/2019 & C.M. No.44431/2019 (stay)
1.
The appellant [petitioner in W.P. (C) No.1239/2016] is
aggrieved by the common judgment dated 11.9.2019, passed by the
learned Single Judge disposing of two writ petitions. The grievance
of the appellant is qua the findings returned by the learned Single
Judge in respect of an order dated 27.1.2016, passed by the
Lieutenant Governor, GNCTD directing that the management of
Vidya Bhavan Senior Secondary School be handed over to Vidya
Bhawan Girls School, Delhi established in the year 1948 (in short
„1948 Society‟) and not to the appellant/Society, namely, Vidya
Bhavan Girls Education Society established in the year 1978 (in
short „1978 Society‟), while making it clear that the inter se
disputes between the two Societies can only be adjudicated by a
competent civil court.
2.
By the impugned judgment, amongst others, the learned
Single Judge has upheld the aforesaid order and clarified that the
directions issued vide order dated 27.1.2016, are only an interim
arrangement till the rival claims of both the Societies are settled on
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:36:07
LPA 652/2019
adjudication by a competent civil court.
3.
Mr. Tiku, learned Senior Advocate appearing for the
appellant submits that while there is no quarrel with the fact that
convoluted disputed questions of facts cannot be decided in writ
proceedings and both the Societies i.e., 1948 Society and 1978
Society ought to be relegated to civil remedies for proper
adjudication of their inter se disputes after a full-fledged trial is
conducted and evidence led, but the grievance of the
appellant/Society is that by virtue of the impugned judgment, the
management of the school has been handed over to the 1948
Society through its Secretary, Mr. Manish Gupta (respondent
No.6). He submits that as an ad-interim arrangement, the
Department of Education ought to continue managing the affairs of
the school, as was being done during the pendency of the writ
petition. He clarifies that the affairs of the school were being
managed by the appellant/Society till it was taken over by the
Department of Education in December, 2012.
4.
We have enquired from Mr. Devesh Singh, learned ASC
appearing for respondents No.1-5 as to whether the school is being
managed by the Department of Education on the strength of any
interim order passed in the writ proceedings or on the basis of an
administrative order issued by the Department of Education. He
states that he may be permitted to obtain instructions in this regard.
5.
At the request of the counsel for the respondents No.1-5,
list on 24.10.2019. In the meantime, learned counsel for the
appellant shall give a written intimation of the next date of hearing
alongwith a complete set of paper book to the respondents No. 6
and 7 directly also through the counsel appearing for them in writ
proceedings.
Dasti to counsel for the respondents No.1 to 5.”
29.
As is apparent from Para 3 of the aforenoted Order, the
Appellants herein have, in fact, admitted that the internecine disputes
between the parties could not form the subject matter of an
adjudication under Article 226 of the Constitution of India and would
have to necessarily be the subject matter of an appropriate civil
proceeding.
30.
In fact, at the very outset, the learned Senior Counsel for the
Appellants had stated that the only issue that he sought to press in the
present Appeal is with respect to the management of the School not
being handed over to the said Shri Manish Gupta, and for the same to
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:36:07
LPA 652/2019
vest with the DoE.
31.
We also take note of the subsequent proceedings in the present
matter and, in particular, the Order dated 24.10.2019 wherein this
Court records that the School was continuing to be run by the DoE on
the strength of the administrative order issued by the Hon‟ble LG in
the year 2012, and the same has continued till date.
32.
The Order dated 24.10.2019 also records the existence of an
administrative Order dated 07.10.2017, which forms the basis of the
management of the School being under the control of the DoE.
33.
Subsequent thereto, the Order dated 06.09.2022 of this Court
would make it apparent that the initial takeover of the School by the
DoE in December, 2012, had been extended from time to time and
also alludes to an Order dated 08.10.2021 passed by the Hon‟ble LG,
wherein the Hon‟ble LG has directed that the said takeover shall
continue till the dispute inter se the two societies are concluded.
34.
The Order dated 17.10.2023 would further reveal that state of
affairs as respects the management of the School underwent a change
pursuant to an Order dated 21.06.2023 passed by the Hon‟ble LG and
by which Order, the management came to be restored to the Managing
Committee of the Vidya Bhavan Girls School/1948-Society.
35.
A perusal of the aforenoted record would make it apparent that,
as things stand today, the original challenge to the Order of the
Hon‟ble LG, purportedly vesting the management of the School with
Shri Manish Gupta, and which became the basis for the lis was never
effectuated on the ground.
36.
As a matter of fact, even the Judgment impugned herein,
whereby the learned Single Judge clarified that the handover of the
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:36:07
LPA 652/2019
management to Mr. Manish Gupta was only an interim arrangement
and would be subject to the outcome of any civil proceedings for
resolution of the dispute regarding the society entitled to manage the
affairs of the School, never came to be implemented, as the
management of the School continued to vest with the DoE from 2012
up to 2023. Consequently, the entire premise of the challenge stood
eroded.
DECISION:
37.
Keeping in view the fact that, despite the direction passed by
the learned Single Judge caveating the decision to hand over the
management of the School to the 1948-Society through its Secretary,
Shri Manish Gupta, to the outcome of adjudication by a competent
civil court, no such proceedings have been initiated to date; that the
foundational challenge to the order dated 27.01.2016 never really
came into effect; and that a fresh order is presently in existence which,
despite being within the knowledge of the Appellants at least since
17.10.2023, has not been challenged, we find no merit in the attempt
of the Appellants to keep the pot boiling. The present Appeal is,
therefore, dismissed.
38.
Accordingly,
the present
Appeal,
along
with
pending
application(s), if any, is disposed of.
39.
No Order as to costs.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
JANUARY 09, 2026/tk/va
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
17:36:07
LPA 652/2019
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review