Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT
SHIMLA
OMP No. 1386 of 2025 in Civil
Suit No. 69 of 2024
Reserved on:
28.04.2026
Date of decision: 14.05.2026
________________________________________________
Mamta & another
…..Non-applicants/plaintiffs.
Versus
Ashok Kumar
……Applicant/defendant.
________________________________________________
Coram
The Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sushil Kukreja, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?
Yes.
For the non-applicants/
plaintiffs:
Mr. Mohit Jaitak, Advocate
(through video conferencing)
and Mr. Abhishek Nagta,
Advocate.
For the applicant/defendant: Mr. Ajay Sharma, Senior
Advocate, with Mr. Surya Bhan
Singh, Advocate.
Sushil Kukreja, Judge.
The instant application has been preferred by the
applicant (defendant) under Order 39, Rules 1 & 2) of the
Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) with the prayer to stop and
restrain the non-applicants/plaintiffs from carrying out any
commercial activity of any kind, whatsoever, in the suit
premises and suit land during the pendency of the suit.
2.
It is averred in the application that Civil Suit No.
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
69 of 2024 has been filed by the non-applicants/plaintiffs
claiming decree of specific performance in sequel to
agreement to sell, dated 17.02.2020. The perusal of the said
agreement would demonstrate that at the time of entering
into the agreement, the possession of the suit premises and
suit land was given only for the purpose of cleaning, leveling
and raising boundary wall on the suit land. As per the
applicant/defendant, the dispute arose between the parties
when non-applicants/plaintiffs put the suit premises and suit
land for commercial use without first getting the sale deed
registered and further in view of the fact that valuation of the
premises and suit land was not being got correctly assessed.
The applicants averred that the suit land is being used as a
warehouse for storing various items with respect to which the
non-applicants are in business. It has been further averred
that the suit land has been put to commercial use by the nonapplicants w.e.f. 17.02.2020, the date of agreement to sell,
and now when the suit is filed by them, the applicant has
raised counter claim under Order 8, Rule A CPC to the tune
of Rs.63,00,000/- assessed upto 17.02.2025 alongwith
interest with further prayer for damages/compensation to the
applicant after 17.02.2025 also upto the date of payment at
the rate of Rs.1,00,000/- per month alongwith interest @ 9%
per annum.
2(a).
The non-applicants filed written statement to the
counter claim wherein it was averred that they had affixed
machinery by spending Rs.75,00,000/-.
It has also been
averred that the statements made on oath by the nonapplicants show that they have admitted that the suit
premises and suit land has been put to commercial use and
the non-applicants are earning handsome amount per
month. As per the applicant, the above act on the part of the
non-applicants is beyond the contract, i.e., agreement to sell,
dated 17.02.2020 and, in fact, the same is the main reason
and cause of filing of the present suit. It has been averred
that if the non-applicants are not restrained from carrying out
any commercial activity in the suit premises and the suit
land, during the pendency of the instant suit, then irreparable
loss and injury will be caused to the applicant, which will not
be compensated in terms of money and conversely the nonapplicants will not suffer any loss.
2(b).
The applicant averred that there exists a prima
facie case in his favour and in case prayer, as made through
this application, is not granted, irreparable loss and injury will
be caused to the applicant.
Lastly, it is prayed that the
instant
allowed
application
be
and
the
non-
applicants/plaintiffs be restrained from carrying out any
commercial activity, whatsoever, in the suit premises and suit
land during the pendency of the suit henceforth, in the
interest of justice.
3.
The non-applicants/plaintiffs filed reply to the
application, wherein preliminary objection of maintainability
of the application was raised and it was averred that since in
the counter claim relief of injunction was not sought, thus the
interim relief of injunction cannot be granted. The counter
claim is for recovery, therefore, the relief of temporary
injunction cannot be granted and counter claimant can be
compensated in terms of money, in case he succeeds in the
counter claim. On merits, it has been averred the applicant
after receiving a hefty amount now cannot resile from the
terms of the agreement, as the agreement was signed out of
free will and volition of the applicant.
Subsequently, the
agreement was extended from time to time, thus it cannot be
said that the terms of the agreement were not correctly
recorded and the value of the land has not been correctly
assessed.
The non-applicants further averred that the
possession of the suit land was handed over by the applicant
and there is no negative covenant or recital in the agreement
which bars the non-applicants from running their business.
As per the non-applicants, the applicant did not raise this
issue before filing the instant suit and the non-applicants had
also sent a legal notice to the applicant, but the same was
not replied.
3(a).
The non-applicants averred that the applicant
cannot take benefit of his own wrong. The mutation of above
said property was yet to be sanctioned in favour of the
applicant, as he had purchased it in an auction, the applicant
had promised to get mutation entered and sanctioned in his
name and thereafter get the sale deed executed and
registered in favour of the non-applicants by 16.08.2020 and
in case of refusal, the non-applicants can get the sale deed
executed through competent court and also the applicant will
pay Rs.60,00,000/- to the non-applicants.
3(b).
The non-applicants averred that as the deed of
sale certificate and mutation of the aforesaid property could
not be sanctioned in favour of the applicant, thus the
applicant extended the date for execution and registration of
sale deed for 30.06.2021, but he could not get the deed of
sale certificate and mutation sanctioned in his favour by
30.06.2021. On 24.06.2021 the applicant again extended
the date for execution and registration of sale deed by
30.12.2023. The non-applicants further paid Rs.20,00,000/to the applicant, out of the sale consideration, i.e.,
Rs.10,00,000/- from the account of Shri Ashok Kumar (nonapplicant No. 2) and Rs.10,00,000/- from the account of Smt.
Mamta (non-applicant No. 1). Thus, a sum of Rs.50,00,000/has been paid to the applicant. However, on 30.12.2023 the
non-applicants remained waiting for the applicant in the
premises of Sub-Registrar, Dulehar, for execution and
registration of sale deed, but he did not turn up and
ultimately on that day the non-applicants got an affidavit
attested from the Executive Magistrate-cum-Naib Tehsildar,
Dulehar for marking their presence.
3(c).
The non-applicants averred that in furtherance of
the agreement of sale, non-applicant No. 2 also paid to the
applicant Rs.25,00,000/-, vide cheque No. 000002.
They
(non-applicants) made improvements in the aforesaid land
and also affixed machinery by spending Rs.75,00,000/-. As
per the non-applicants, there is no violation of the
agreement, as alleged by the applicant. On the one hand,
the applicant is relying on the agreement to sell and on the
other hand in the written statement he is alleging the
agreement to sell is wrong.
3(d).
The non-applicants averred that the applicant
does not have any prima facie case or balance of
convenience and no irreparable loss will be caused to him,
as the relief sought by him in the counter claim is for
recovery, therefore, in any case, if the counter claim
succeeds, the applicant can be compensated in terms of
money.
Lastly, the non-applicants prayed that the instant
application be dismissed.
4.
The
learned
Senior
Counsel
for
the
applicant/defendant contended that at the time of entering
into the agreement to sell, the possession of the suit land
and suit premises was given to the non-applicants/plaintiffs
only for the purpose of cleaning, leveling and raising
boundary wall, but despite that they have put the suit land
and suit premises for commercial use without first getting the
sale deed registered. He further contended that there exists
a prima facie case in favour of the applicant/defendant and in
case the prayer made in the application is not granted and if
the non-applicants/plaintiffs are not restrained from carrying-
out any commercial activity on the suit land/suit premises,
irreparable
loss
and
injury
will
be
caused
to
the
applicant/defendant.
5.
Conversely, the learned counsel for the non-
applicants/plaintiffs
contended
that
since
the
applicant/defendant has not sought the relief of injunction in
the counter-claim and the same only being filed for the
recovery, therefore, relief of temporary injunction cannot be
granted to him.
He further contended that the non-
applicants/plaintiffs are always ready and willing to perform
their part of the contract and had also paid major portion of
the amount to the applicant/defendant, besides they had
spent an amount of Rs.75,00,000/- for affixing the machinery,
therefore, the applicant/defendant has not made-out any
case in his favour for granting the relief of injunction.
6.
I have heard the learned Senior Counsel for the
applicant/defendant,
learned
counsel
for
the
non-
applicants/plaintiffs and carefully examined the records.
7.
The power to grant a temporary injunction lies
with the discretion of the Court. The Court while granting or
refusing injunction shall exercise sound, judicious discretion
to find the amount of substantial mischief or injury which is
likely to be caused to the parties if the injunction is refused
and compare it with that it is likely to be caused to the other
side if the injunction is granted. However, the discretion
should be exercised reasonably, judiciously and on sound
legal principles. It is a settled position of law that for an
applicant to be entitled to the relief of injunction, he has to
satisfy three basic ingredients. The applicant has to show
strong prima facie case for grant of injunction, balance of
convenience should also be in his favour and finally it should
be shown that in case an injunction is not granted, he will
suffer
irreparable
loss
and
injury,
which
cannot
be
compensated in terms of money.
8.
For grant of interim injunction, being an equitable
relief, the Court must keep in mind all the equitable
considerations. Further, grant of interim injunction depends
upon the facts and circumstances of each case as no straitjacket formula can be laid down. The aforesaid principles
have also been followed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in its
various decisions. In Gujarat Bottling Co. Ltd. & others vs.
Coca Cola Co. & others, reported in 1995 (5) SCC 545, it
has been held as under:
“43. The grant of an interlocutory injunction during the
pendency of legal proceedings is a matter requiring the
exercise of discretion of the Court. While exercising
the discretion the court applied the following tests – (1)
whether the plaintiff has a prima facie case; (ii) whether
the plaintiff would suffer an irreparable injury if his
prayer for interlocutory injunction is disallowed. The
decision whether or not to grant an interlocutory
injunction has to be taken at a time when the existence
of the legal right assailed by the plaintiff and its alleged
violation are both contested and uncertain and remain
uncertain till they are established at the trial on
evidence. Relief by way of interlocutory injunction is
granted to mitigate the risk of injustice to the plaintiff
during the period before that uncertainty could be
resolved. The object of the interlocutory injunction is
to protect the plaintiff against injury by violation of his
right for which he could not be adequately
compensated in damages recoverable in the action if
the uncertainty were resolved in his favour at the trial.
The need for such protection has, however, to be
weighed against the corresponding need of the
defendant to be protected against injury resulting from
his having been prevented from exercising his own
legal rights for which he could not be adequately
compensated. The court must weigh one need against
another and determine where the “balance of
convenience” lies. [See: Wander Ltd. v. Antox India (P)
Ltd. (1990 Supp SCC 727)(SCC at pp. 731-32)]. In order
to protect the defendant while granting an interlocutory
injunction in his favour the court can require the
plaintiff to furnish an undertaking so that the defendant
can be adequately compensated if the uncertainty were
resolved in his favour at the trial.”
9.
In Colgate Palmolive (India) Ltd. vs. Hindustan
Lever Ltd., reported in AIR 1999 SC 3105, in para 24 it has
been held as under:
“24. We, however, think it fit to note hereinbelow certain
specific considerations in the matter of grant of
interlocutory injunction, the basic being nonexpression of opinion as to the merits of the matter by
the Court, since the issue of grant of injunction usually,
is at the earliest possible stage so far as the time-frame
is to weigh with the Court hearing the application or
petition for the grant of injunctions are as below:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
Extent of damages being an adequate
remedy;
Protect the plaintiff’s interest for
violation of his rights though however
having regard to the injury that may be
suffered by the defendants by reason
therefor;
The Court while dealing with the matter
ought not to ignore the factum of
strength of one party’s case being
stronger than the others;
No fixed rules or notions ought to be
(v)
(vi)
(vii)
10.
The Apex
had in the matter of grant of injunction
but on the facts and circumstances of
each case – the relief being kept
flexible;
The issue is to be looked from the point
of view as to whether on refusal of the
injunction the plaintiff would suffer
irreparable loss and injury keeping in
view the strength of the parties’ case;
Balance
of
convenience
or
inconvenience ought to be considered
as an important requirement even if
there is a serious question or prima
facie case in support of the grant;
Whether the grant of refusal of
injunction will adversely affect the
interest of general public which can or
cannot be compensated otherwise.”
Court
in
Narendra
Kante
vs.
Aanuradha Kante & others, (2010) 2 SCC 77, opined that,
while considering an application for grant of injunction, the
Court has not only to take into consideration the basic
elements regarding existence of a prima facie case, balance
of convenience and irreparable injury, it has also to take into
consideration the conduct of the parties since grant of
injunction is an equitable relief. The relevant para of the
aforesaid judgment is as under:
“28. Now, coming to the question of balance of convenience
and inconvenience and irreparable loss and injury, it
has to be kept in mind that Respondent 10 has already
acquired rights in respect of the share of Respondents
8 and 9 to the suit property and in the event an interim
order is passed preventing development of the portion
of the property acquired by him, he would suffer
irreparable loss and injury since he would not be able
to utilize the property till the suit is disposed of, which
could take severable years at the original stage, and,
thereafter, several more years at the appellate stages.”
11.
In Zenit Mataplast Private Ltd. v. State of
Maharashtra & others, (2009) 10 SCC 388, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court considered the principles for grant of interim
relief and held as under:
"30. Interim order is passed on the basis of prima facie
findings, which are tentative. Such order is passed as a
temporary arrangement to preserve the status quo till
the matter is decided finally, to ensure that the matter
does not become either infructuous or a fait accompli
before the final hearing. The object of the interlocutory
injunction is, to protect the plaintiff against injury by
violation of his right for which he could not be
adequately compensated in damages recoverable in the
action if the uncertainty were resolved in his favour at
the trial. (vide Anand Prasad Agarwalla v. Tarkeshwar
Prasad ((2001) 5SCC 568), and State of Assam v. Barak
Upatyaka D.U. Karmachari Sanstha ((2009) 5 SCC 694).
31.
12.
Grant of an interim relief in regard to the nature and
extent thereof depends upon the facts and
circumstances of each case as no strait-jacket formula
can be laid down. There may be a situation wherein the
defendant/ respondent may use the suit property in
such a manner that the situation becomes irretrievable.
In such a fact situation, interim relief should be granted
(vide M. Gurudas & Ors. v. Rasaranjan ((2006) 8 SCC
367) and Shridevi v. Muralidhar ((2007) 14 SCC 721.
Grant of temporary injunction is governed by three
basic principles, ie. prima facie case; balance of
convenience; and irreparable injury, which are required
to be considered in a proper perspective in the facts
and circumstances of a particular case. But it may not
be appropriate for any court to hold a mini trial at the
stage of grant of temporary injunction (Vide S.M.
Dyechem Ltd. v. M/s Cadbury (India) Ltd. ((2000) 5 SCC
573 and Anand Prasad Agarwalla ((2001) 5 SCC 568."
In the instant case, the non-applicants/plaintiffs
have filed a suit for specific performance of the agreement to
sell dated 17.02.2020 against the applicant/defendant
directing him to execute and get the sale-deed registered in
his favour. As per the non-applicants/plaintiffs they had paid
a sum of Rs.50,00,000/- on 17.02.2020 and it was agreed
that the remaining sale consideration would be paid at the
time of execution and registration of the sale-deed.
It is
further case of the non-applicants/plaintiffs that the sale
certificate was registered by the bank on 22.03.2022 in
favour of the applicant/defendant and since the mutation of
the property was yet to be sanctioned in favour of the
applicant/defendant, he promised to get the mutation entered
and sanctioned in his name and thereafter get the sale deed
registered in favour of the non-applicants/plaintiffs by
16.08.2020, which date was further extended till 30.12.2023.
It is further case of the non-applicants/plaintiffs that on
30.12.2023
they
remained
waiting
for
the
applicant/defendant in the premises of Sub Registrar Dulehar
for execution and registration of the sale deed, but the
applicant/defendant did not turn up.
Then the non-
applicants/plaintiffs
contacted
made
enquiry
and
the
applicant/defendant so as to know the reasons for his
absence on the promised date.
The applicant/defendant
asked the non-applicants/plaintiffs to pay Rs.25,00,000/-.
The non-applicants/plaintiffs in furtherance to the request of
the applicant/defendant and also in furtherance of the
agreement
of
sale
paid
Rs.25,00,000/-
to
the
applicant/defendant. The further case of the plaintiffs is that
the mutation No. 1244 was sanctioned in favour of the
applicant/defendant on 30.01.2024 but instead of executing
and registering the sale-deed, he started blackmailing the
non-applicants/plaintiffs. The non-applicants/plaintiffs further
averred that they have made improvements in the aforesaid
land and have also affixed machinery by spending
approximately Rs.75,00,000/-.
13.
Thus the perusal of the record prima facie
reveals that the non-applicants/plaintiffs had paid major
portion of the sale consideration to the defendant and also
had made improvements in the suit property besides had
affixed
machinery
by
spending
huge
amount.
The
possession of the suit land was admittedly handed over by
the applicant to the plaintiffs and there is no negative
covenant or recital in the agreement which bars the nonapplicants from carrying-out any commercial activity on the
suit land/suit premises. Therefore, at this stage, the
applicant/defendant has failed to show any prima facie case
in his favour. The balance of convenience also does not lie in
favour of the applicant/defendant as greater inconvenience is
likely to be caused to the plaintiffs/non applicants by granting
injunction in favour of the applicant/defendant. As the relief
sought for by the applicant/defendant in the counter-claim is
only for the recovery, therefore, no irreparable loss and injury
will be caused to the applicant/defendant, as in case the
counter-claim succeeds, the applicant/defendant can always
be compensated in terms of money and in case injunction is
granted, the non-applicants/plaintiffs would suffer irreparable
loss and injury since they would not be able to utilize the
property till the final disposal of the suit. Thus, the
applicant/defendant has failed to satisfy all the three
ingredients for the grant of injunction.
14.
Hence, in view of what has been discussed
hereinabove, the instant application, which sans merits,
deserves dismissal and is accordingly dismissed.
15.
Be it stated that any expression of opinion given
in this order does not mean an expression of opinion on the
merits of the case and the same has been given only for the
purpose of deciding the present application. The application
stands disposed of.
14th May, 2026
(virender)
( Sushil Kukreja )
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review