Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRM-M-73642--2025 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH
H
COURT OF PUNJAB
JAB A
AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
ARH
(129)
CRM-M-73642-2025 (O&M)
M)
Date of decision : 10.03.2026
MALKEET SING
SINGH @ SAMAR
... Petitioner
oner
Versus
STATE OF PUNJAB
PUNJ
...Respondent
dent
CORAM: HON'BLE
HON
MRS. JUSTICE MANIS
ANISHA BATRA
Present:
Mr. Akhilesh Vyas, Advocate for
or the petitioner
Ms. Ruchika
R
Sabherwal, Sr. DAG,
G, Pu
Punjab
****
MANISHA BATR
BATRA, J. (ORAL)
1.
The instant petition has been prefe
preferred by the petitioner under
nder
Section 483 of Bharatiya
Bh
Nagarik Surakshaa Sanh
Sanhita, 2023 (for short “BNSS”))
for grant of regular
regul bail in case arising out
ut of F
FIR No.217 dated 28.10.2023
registered under
nder Sections
S
302, 34 of IPC and
nd Se
Section 25 and 27 of Arms Act
(Section 379(b)(2
9(b)(2) and 120B of IPC added
ed late
later on) at Police Station Civil
Lines, District
ict Police
Pol Commissionerate Amritsar.
ritsar.
2.
The aforementioned FIR was reg
registered on the basis of the
statement got
ot recorded
reco
by the complainantt Avin
Avinash Malhotra alleging that
at on
27.10.2023, he alongwith
alo
his friend Rakeshh Kum
Kumar was going to attend some
Jagran at Dayanan
ayanand Nagar, Fatehgarh Churian
rian R
Road on the Activa vehicle
le of
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.10 16:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-73642--2025 (O&M)
Rakesh Kumar.
ar. H
He was the pillion rider andd was carrying a black coloured bag
with him. When
hen they reached near Anand Avenu
Avenue Turn, they were intercepted
pted
by 03 youthss who came riding on a motorbike
bike fr
from the backside. The pillion
illion
rider pounced
ed over
ove the bag of the complainant
inant and snatched the same. The
complainantt raise
raised alarm but the driver off the m
motorbike fired a shot with
ith a
weapon which
ich he was carrying in his right hand. The bullet hit his companion
nion
Rakesh Kumar
ar wh
who had fallen down with thee Acti
Activa vehicle. On clamour being
eing
raised by thee complainant,
com
some persons hadd reac
reached there. The assailants fled
away. The victim Rakesh Kumar was rushedd to th
the hospital but had succumbed
bed
to the fire arm
rm inju
injury. After registration of FIR, iinvestigation proceedings were
initiated. One
ne empty
em
cartridge case .32 bore
ore wa
was recovered from the spot
ot of
occurrence. Post
Post-mortem of the dead body was conducted and one lead bullet
ullet
was recovered
ed fro
from the same. During investigat
estigation, the complainant recorded
rded
his supplementary
entary statement to the effect that
hat at time of incident, the wallet
et of
the victim was
as in his
h bag which was snatched byy tthe assailants since on the way
they had gott fuel
fue filled in their Activa vehicle
icle an
and at that time, the wallet was
given by the victim to him.
3.
As per
pe the further allegations, the acc
accused Rajinder Singh @ Ashu,
shu,
Suraj and Danish
anish Gill, who were arrested in ssome other case bearing FIR
No.216 dated
ed 28.
28.10.2023 registered at Police
olice S
Station Civil Lines, Amritsar
ritsar
suffered disclosure
closure statements on 03.11.20233 adm
admitting their involvement in this
case and were
ere no
nominated as accused in this ca
case. After being joined into
investigation,
n, the accused Suraj suffered disclosu
isclosure statement wherein besides
sides
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.10 16:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-73642--2025 (O&M)
admitting his
is invo
involvement in this case, he disclos
isclosed that the pistol used by him
in commission
ion of murder of the victim hadd been given to him by the present
esent
petitioner and one
ne Sarabjit Singh @ Sonu Cylind
ylinder and it was on the asking
g of
them, that hee alongwith
alon
the co-accused Rajinder
inder S
Singh @ Ashu had committed
itted
the subject offence.
offence The said pistol already stood recovered in case bearing FIR
No.216 dated
d 28.10.2023.
28.1
The petitioner and co--accused Sarabjit Singh @ Sonu
Cylinder were nominated
no
as additional accused
ccused.
The complainant Avinash
inash
Malhotra identifie
entified the accused Rajinder Singh
ngh @ Ashu, Suraj and Danish Gill.
He also identified
ntified the wallet of the deceasedd whic
which was recovered from the co-accused. Thee petitioner
peti
and co-accused Sarabjit
abjit S
Singh @ Sonu Cylinder were
re in
custody in some other case bearing FIR No.184
o.184 of 2023 registered at Police
olice
Station Civill Line
Lines, Amritsar, their presencee was secured in this case by way
ay of
issuance of produc
roduction warrants and they were
ere for
formally arrested on 09.11.2023.
023.
They were interro
interrogated and admitted thatt one countrymade pistol had been
provided by them to accused Suraj who had asked for the same. Offences under
nder
Section 379(b)(2)
(b)(2) read with Section 120B off IPC aand Section 29(2) of Armss Act
were added.. Inve
Investigation now stands completed
pleted and the petitioner alongwith
with
the co-accused
ed are facing trial for the commission
ission of aforementioned offences.
4.
It is argued by learned counsell for tthe petitioner that he has been
falsely implicated
licated in this case on the basiss of th
the disclosure statement of co-accused Suraj
raj which
wh
cannot be considered to be admissible in evidence. The
only role that
at has been attributed to him is of supplying a pistol to the co-accused Suraj.
j. There
Th
is no allegation that hee had any hand in the murder off the
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.10 16:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-73642--2025 (O&M)
victim. Thee complainant
com
Avinash Malhotra
ra alre
already stands examined and had
identified the co--accused Suraj, Rajinder Singh
ingh @ Ashu and Danish Gill ass the
assailants. He had not uttered anything against
inst th
the petitioner. The petitioner
er is
in custody since long.
l
The trial will take consid
considerable time to conclude. His
further incarcerati
rceration would not serve any useful purpose. His involvement
nt in
other two cases
ases ca
cannot be considered to be a reas
reason for denying benefit of bail
to him. Thee co-accused
co
Suraj and Danishh Gill have already been extended
nded
benefit of bail.
ail. On parity, he too deserves too be ex
extended the same benefit. It is,
therefore, argued
gued tthat the petition deserves too be al
allowed.
5.
Per contra,
c
learned State counsel
nsel ha
has argued that the allegations
tions
against the petitioner
petitio
are quite serious in nature,
ature, as he had provided the pistol
istol
used by the co-acc
accused Suraj in commission of off
offence of committing murder
er of
the victim Rakesh
akesh, while snatching the bag of the complainant. The co-accused
used
Suraj had disclose
isclosed that the subject offences
ces we
were committed by him on the
direction of the pr
present petitioner. Taking into co
consideration the gravity off the
allegations, it is argued that the petitionerr does not deserve to be extended
nded
benefit of bail.
6.
This Court
C
has heard the rival submis
ubmissions made by learned counsel
unsel
for the parties at considerable
co
length.
7.
The petitioner is alleged to havee prov
provided a pistol to the co-accused
used
Suraj. The same pistol
p
had allegedly been used
sed at the time of commission off the
subject offences
nces b
by the above-said accused, who hhad fired a shot with the same,
ame,
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.10 16:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-73642--2025 (O&M)
thereby causing
sing h
homicidal death of the victim-Ra
Rakesh Kumar. The said pistol
istol
has been recovere
covered at the instance of the co-acc
accused only. The petitioner was
not named in the FIR and has been involved
ved in this case on the basis off the
disclosure stateme
tatement of the co-accused Suraj.
raj. The petitioner has placed
d on
record copy of sworn
sw
deposition of the complai
mplainant. A perusal of the samee
reveals that he did not say anything about the
he pres
present petitioner. Though ass per
the allegations,
ns, the
th accused Suraj disclosed that iit was on asking of the present
esent
petitioner and
nd the
t
pistol being provided to hi
him, the occurrence had been
committed alongw
alongwith the co-accused Danishh Gill and Rajinder Singh @ Ashu,
shu,
however, at this st
stage, there is no material on rec
record to show that the petitioner
ioner
had any motive
tive to get the victim killed or it was aat his instance that the offences
nces
were committed
itted b
by the co-accused Suraj, Danis
Danish Gill and Rajinder Singh
h @
Ashu. The role aattributed to the petitioner prima facie appears to be limited
ed to
facilitating supply of a fire arm and no commiss
mmission of the principal homicidal
cidal
act and as such
uch it is distinct from the offence
ce of m
murder. The linkage sought
ht to
be established
ed bet
between the petitioner and the act of supply of arms, primarily
arily
rests on the disclosure
disclo
statement of the co-accused
ccused and circumstantial inferences
nces
is that of a condu
conduit or a facilitator in the purpor
purported procurement of fire arms
which is a distinc
istinct and remote offence from the ddirect commission of offences
nces
punishable under Section
S
302 of IPC. This Court is conscious that the provision
ision
is serious, however,
howev
in present purposes,, the Court must test whetherr the
material against
inst the
th petitioner justifies continued
tinued pre-trial incarceration bearing
aring
nature of evidenc
vidence and the progress of the
he tria
trial. Since the case againstt the
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.10 16:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-73642--2025 (O&M)
petitioner rests
sts on disclosure statement of the co
co-accused, this is a matter best
left for triall whet
whether the burden of proof and sstandard of evidence shall
ll be
applied rigorously
orously. The petitioner is in custod
custody since 11.11.2023 and the
conclusion of the trial in the near future are bbleak as only 05 prosecution
ution
witnesses have
ave been
be examined so far. In view of the foregoing discussion,
sion,
particularly the limited
lim
role is prescribed too the ppetitioner, this Court is off the
considered opinion
pinion that the continued detention
tion of the petitioner would not serve
the ends of justic
justice. Accordingly, the petition
ion is allowed and the petitioner
er is
ordered to bee released
relea
on bail subject to his furnis
furnishing personal as well as surety
urety
bonds to the satisfaction
satisf
of learned trial Court/CJM
rt/CJM/Duty Magistrate concerned
8.
It is, however, clarified that thee obse
observations made above shalll not
be construed
d as an expression of opinion of this C
Court on the merits of the case
and shall nott influ
influence the outcome of the trial
ial in aany manner.
9.
Since the main petition has been al
allowed pending application,
n, if
any, is rendered
ered in
infructuous.
(MA
(MANISHA BATRA)
JUDGE
10.03.2026
Amit Sharma
AMIT SHARMA
2026.03.10 16:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
Whether speaking/reasoned:- Yes
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review