Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010709592022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3458]
TUESDAY,THE TWENTY THIRD DAY OF JUNE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE KIRANMAYEE MANDAVA
WRIT PETITION NO: 41879/2022
Between:
...PETITIONER(S)
Makkena Nagarathnam and Others
AND
The State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. RAJA REDDY KONETI
2. .
3. V V LAKSHMI NARAYANA
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. THOTA RAMAKOTESWARA RAO
2. GP FOR HOME
3. INAKOLLU VENKATESWARLU
4. P SUBASH
5. GP FOR REVENUE
6. RAJA REDDY KONETI
7. GP FOR GENERAL ADMINISTRATION
8. SIVA SANKARA RAO BORRA
9. NIMMAGADDA REVATHI
10. GP FOR MINES AND GEOLOGY
11. G VIVEKANAND
...RESPONDENT(S)
WRIT PETITION NO: 7632/2023
Between:
Jammalamadaka Punna Rao and Others
...PETITIONER(S)
AND
The State Of Ap and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. V V LAKSHMI NARAYANA
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR HOME
2. INAKOLLU VENKATESWARLU
3. GP FOR REVENUE
4. SIVAPRASAD REDDY VENATI
5. RAJA REDDY KONETI
6. GP FOR GENERAL ADMINISTRATION
7. SIVA SANKARA RAO BORRA
8. YELISETTI SOMARAJU STANDING COUNSEL APPCB
9. NIMMAGADDA REVATHI
10. GP FOR MINES AND GEOLOGY
11. Mattegunta.Sudhir,Standing Counsel For Z.P.Ps,M.P.Ps,Gram
Panchayats
The Court made the following:
COMMON ORDER:-
Heard Sri V.V.Lakshmi Narayana, learned counsel for the
petitioners, Sri T.Sreedhar, learned Senior Counsel and learned Government
Pleader for Mines and Geology.
2.
Challenging the proceedings of the 9th respondent granting No
Objection Certificate for grant of quarry lease in favour of the 12th to 15th
respondents, over an extent of Ac.21.50 cents in Sy.Nos.33/3A to 33/3J and
33/1A to 33/1J, 552/C3N and 552/C3O and 549, situated at Murikipudi Village,
Chilakaluripet Mandal, W.P.No.7632 of 2023 has been filed.
3.
Challenging the proceedings of the 9th respondent granting No
Objection Certificate for granting quarry lease in favour of the 10th to 15th
respondents, over an extent of Ac.90.00 cents in Survey Nos.33/IA to Z11,
547-1A to 547-Z, 38-1A and 38-1B, situated at Murikipudi Village,
Chilakaluripet Mandal, Palnadu District, W.P.No.41879 of 2022 has been filed.
4.
The petitioners in W.P.No.41879 of 2022 contend that the
predecessors of the petitioners were in possession and enjoyment of the
subject land for the last 40 years. After their lifetime, the petitioners have
come into possession of the subject land. In recognition of their possession
and occupation, the petitioners were granted B-Form pattas.
5.
The petitioners in writ petition (W.P.No.41879 of 2022) claim to
have occupied the following respective extents of land on the basis of B-Form
pattas alleged to have been issued in their favour by the Tahsildar,
Chilakaluripet Mandal.
Petitioner(s)
Village
No.
1.
Murikipudi Village
Survey No.
Extent
547-1A-II
Ac.0.60 Cts
Year of
Assignment
2.
Murikipudi Village
38-1A
Ac.1.51 Cts
3.
Murikipudi Village
33/1E
Ac.2.00 Cts
4.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11
Ac.1.00 Cts
5.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11C
Ac.1.00 Cts
6.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11I
Ac.1.00 Cts
7.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11I
Ac.1.00 Cts
8.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11L
Ac.1.00 Cts
9.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11C
Ac.1.00 Cts
10.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11
Ac.1.00 Cts
11.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11
Ac.1.00 Cts
12.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11
Ac.1.00 Cts
13.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11D
Ac.1.00 Cts
14.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11U
Ac.1.00 Cts
15.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11T
Ac.1.00 Cts
16.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11 ID
Ac.1.00 Cts
17.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11 IT
Ac.1.00 Cts
18.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11N
Ac.1.00 Cts
19.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11X
Ac.1.00 Cts
20.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11Y
Ac.1.00 Cts
21.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11M
Ac.1.00 Cts
22.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11IW
Ac.1.00 Cts
23.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11 IT
Ac.1.00 Cts
24.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11 IR
Ac.1.00 Cts
25.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11 IX
Ac.1.00 Cts
26.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11 IB
Ac.1.00 Cts
27.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11
Ac.1.00 Cts
28.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11U
Ac.1.00 Cts
29.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11W
Ac.1.00 Cts
30.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11 IA
Ac.1.00 Cts
31.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11Z
Ac.1.00 Cts
32.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11Z
Ac.1.00 Cts
33.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11-IV
Ac.1.00 Cts
34.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11-2A
Ac.1.00 Cts
35.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11
Ac.1.00 Cts
36.
Murikipudi Village
33/1Z11
Ac.1.00 Cts
37.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1A
Ac.0.60 Cts
38.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1B
Ac.0.60 Cts
39.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1J
Ac.0.60 Cts
40.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1S
Ac.0.60 Cts
41.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1L
Ac.0.60 Cts
42.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1D
Ac.0.60 Cts
43.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1C
Ac.0.60 Cts
44.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1K
Ac.0.60 Cts
45.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1E
Ac.0.60 Cts
46.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1W
Ac.0.60 Cts
47.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1Q
Ac.0.60 Cts
48.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-2A
Ac.0.60 Cts
49.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-IT
Ac.0.60 Cts
50.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1R
Ac.0.60 Cts
51.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1F
Ac.0.60 Cts
52.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1H
Ac.0.60 Cts
53.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1U
Ac.0.60 Cts
54.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1Z
Ac.0.60 Cts
55.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1Y
Ac.0.60 Cts
56.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1G
Ac.0.60 Cts
57.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1X
Ac.0.60 Cts
58.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1M
Ac.0.60 Cts
59.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1N
Ac.0.60 Cts
60.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1P
Ac.0.60 Cts
61.
Murikipudi Village
33/1211G
Ac.0.60 Cts
62.
Murikipudi Village
33/1211K
Ac.0.60 Cts
63.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A-1D
Ac.0.60 Cts
64.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A
Ac.0.60 Cts
65.
Murikipudi Village
547-1A
Ac.0.60 Cts
6.
It is contended that the 9th respondent and the Assistant Director
of Mines and Geology have issued NOCs in favour of the 10th to 15th
respondents for quarry lease without considering the claim of the petitioners. It
is contended that the 10th to 17th respondents are politically influential families
and with their clout, they have managed to get the NOCs from the 9 th
respondent-Tahsildar,
for
issuance
of
quarry
lease.
The
9th respondent, despite being aware of the occupation and cultivation of the
petitioners, under the influence of the political bosses, granted NOCs. Thus,
the petitioners sought set aside of the NOCs, granted by the Tahsildar.
7.
The 9th respondent filed counter affidavit stating that as per the
records, no B-Memorandum were issued in favour of the petitioners, the
alleged B-Forms are forged and fabricated and further states that the alleged
B-Form pattas are not in the prescribed format, and that the Tahsildar has no
jurisdiction to permit the petitioners to raise crops.
It is further stated that
G.O.Ms.No.163, Industries and Commerce (Mines-II) Department, dated
16.11.2017, prescribes the guidelines for disposal of the mineral concession
applications.
As per the said G.O., the Assistant Director of Mines and
Geology, immediately on receipt of valid application on an area, should send a
copy of plan along with details of the area applied for, without intimating the
name of the applicants duly mapping existing lease area to the Tahsildar
concerned to report the classification/category and availability of the land for
grant of lease. The Tahsildar concerned shall send his report to the Assistant
Director within a period of 20 days from the date of receipt of intimation from
the Assistant Director concerned in respect of the area sought for NOC. If the
proposed application is with respect to Assigned land / Patta land, the
Tahsildar shall indicate the names of the Assignees / Pattadars based on the
latest land records for obtaining consent from them. In the backdrop of the
procedure prescribed, the 9th respondent was called upon to enquire and
submit a report for granting quarry license. After receiving the application from
the Assistant Director of Mines and Geology vide order dated 06.03.2018, the
Tahsildar had called for report from the Mandal Revenue Inspector,
Chilakaluripet.
It is reported by the Mandal Revenue Inspector that the
subject land is classified in revenue records as Vagu Poramboke. However,
the Vagu Poramboke is not in existence, therefore, the land has been
converted into Assessed Waste Dry.
It is further stated that the Executive
Engineer of the Irrigation Department dated 25.10.2019 submitted his report to
the 9th respondent stating that there are no traces of water course passing
through the proposed land. The said land was found to be vacant on ground.
Therefore, NOCs for granting of quarry lease were issued. After receipt of the
said report, the 9th respondent called for objections vide notice in Form- A1.
8.
It is contended that the 10th respondent had applied for quarry
lease over an extent of Ac.12.06 cents in Sy.Nos.547-1 and 547-2 of
Murikipudi Village, Chilakaluripeta Mandal for a period of 20 years. Upon
receipt of the said application, after calling for report from the Revenue and
Irrigation Departments and after issuance of A1 notice inviting objections, the
9th respondent has issued NOC in favour of the 10threspondent. Similarly, in
respect of the other extents of land, the Tahsildar, after following due
procedure as stated supra has issued NOCs.
9.
Learned counsel for the petitioner (W.P.No.41879 of 2022)
Sri V.V. Lakshmi Narayana would submit that without cancelling the B-Form
pattas issued in favour of the petitioners, the respondents have granted
mining lease in favour of the 10th to 15th respondents.
10.
Learned Government Pleader appearing for the respondents
would submit that the subject B- Form pattas relied upon by the petitioners are
forged. It is contended that having regard to the classification of the land, No
Objection Report from the Irrigation Department was also obtained before
issuing NOC. It is further argued that if the petitioners are in possession of the
subject land, they have to approach the Civil Court seeking relief in the said
regard.
11.
Sri T.Sreedhar, learned Senior counsel appearing for the
petitioners in W.P.Nos.16180, 16182 and 16184 of 2024 contends that though
unofficial respondents 10 to 13 and 15 have filed counter affidavit, they have
withdrawn the same stating that they were not properly arrayed in the writ
petition. Therefore, any directions in the said writ petition (W.P.No.41879 of
2022) would not bind them.
12.
Considered the rival submissions.
13.
The contention of the petitioners is that the subject lands in both
the writ petitions i.e., W.P.Nos.7632 of 2023 and 41879 of 2022 are assigned in
favour of the respective petitioners vide proceedings of the Tahsildar,
Chilakaluripet and that the property is not suitable for quarrying since the same
is located near the dwelling areas, and further for the reason that the subject
land has been classified in the revenue records as Vagu Poramboke, without
changing the classification of the subject land, it cannot be used for quarrying
as the same would hamper the water resources. The Executive Engineer,
Irrigation Department, vide his report dated 26.05.2021 has reported that, as
per the village map, a vagu runs through land in Sy.No.547-1A along north to
south direction. Two 1st order streams are passing through Sy.No.547 and
confluencing into one 2nd order stream and the 2nd order stream flows through
the proposed land from the water received from the adjacent Sy.Nos.90, 92
and 82. And as per the ground condition, there are no traces of water course
passing through the proposed land in Sy.No.547. He further observed that that
the rain water is being received in the 1storder stream from the self catchment
area and there is no water flows from the upstream of the proposed land
except 2nd order stream. It is also observed that the land is vacant on the
ground. In view of the above, it is opined by him that it is necessary to provide
a drain of 10 mts width throughout the length of the vagu course in the North
side of Survey No.547-1A to avoid obstructions for free flow of rain water from
upstream side to down streamside of the stream. Hence, granting of quarry
lease to an extent of Ac.12.06 Cents in Survey No.547/1 and 547/2 of
MurikipudiVillage in Chilakaluripet Mandal will not affect free flow of rain
water.Similarly, in respect of other survey numbers, the Irrigation Department
has issued clarification recommended for the issuance of quarry lease.
After
the said approvals, the 9th respondent issued A1 notice calling for objections
and after following the due procedure, issued No Objection Certificate.
14.
Pursuant to the directions of this Court dated 19.08.2025, the
Committee of Chief Engineers has submitted their report stating that the
Committee conducted a site inspection on 07.10.2025 and has reported that:
“A major stream (Vagu) is passing through Sy.No. 38, with the
upstream reach in Sy.No.33 and downstream in Sy.No.552.As per the
Murikipudi village map, another branch of the stream originates from
Sy.No.21 and joins the major stream in Sy.No.552.A "Kunta" (tank/pond)
is marked in Sy.No.38 near Sy.No.552. However, neither the Kunta nor
the branch from Sy.No.21 was traceable on the ground during the visit;
their presence is apparent only in cadastral/village maps and not in field
conditions as on the date of visit.The Tahsildar's certification affirms that
the land in Sy.Nos.38, 552, etc., is categorically entered as "Vagu" in
revenue records, and this aligns with historical mapping.The Executive
Engineer's report dated 30.11.2020 states that according to the map, a
stream marked as "Vagu" runs through these lands, including a first order
and second order confluence. However, on physical inspection at that
time, no defined watercourse or Kunta existed in the locality-the stream
bed receives direct rainfall runoff, with upstream inflow only for the
second order stream in specific Sy.Nos. (4, 9, 13, 25, 27, 35). The report
recommends maintaining a 10mts wide buffer as drainage on the east
side to prevent obstruction to surface runoff.The main concern is whether
quarry operations would obstruct or alter the natural flow of water or
impact
any
existing
water
bodies.Official
mapping
and
site
reconnaissance confirm that the land is classified as a stream in official
records but lacks a perennial, defined watercourse or tank on the surface
as of the latest field inspection except a major stream towards eastern
edge of Sy.No.38.If a drainage buffer is not maintained in the streams
passing through the Sy.No.38, Quarry operations would obstruct
upstream-to-downstream water movement in the catchment.In light of the
above, quarrying in these specific survey numbers, without adherence to
buffer stipulations for water flow may adversely affects the hydrological
regime.”
15.
In view of the contention of the respondents (W.P.No.41879 of
2022) that the B-Memorandums are fake and forged, the District Collector was
directed vide directions of this Court dated 19.08.2025 to submit a report, a
cause enquiry into the issue. The District Collector has submitted his report.
The gist of the report of the Collector in respect of Sy.No.33 is that:
As per RSR, the Sy.No.33 measuring Ac.128.72 cents has been classified as
Government Poramboke-stream. As per MSR, the same has been
subdivided into Sy.No.33-1 to 33-8. There is no change in the classification of
Sy.No.33-1 from Government-Poramboke (Vagu) to Ayan (AW) has been
effected.
As per FMB, in Sy.No.33-1 measuring Ac.101.69 cents, no subdivision has
been effected. However, in the webland adangal, notional sub-division of the
Sy.No.33-1 was effected and has also been placed under prohibited category
under Section 22 A (1) (a) of the Registration Act, 1908.
As per adangals of Fasli 1397 (1987-88), Sy.No.33-1 has been subdivided into
Sy.No.33-1A to 33-1Z10, in the name of the respective pattadar/enjoyer vide
separate Khata numbers. As per current Fasli 1435, the same sub-division
reflects in the name of respective assignees in respect of Sy.No.33-1A to
Sy.No.33-1Z10. However, the report of the District Collector reports that as
per available records, no assignment has been made in Sy.No.33-1
measuring Ac.101.69 cents and Sy.No.33-3 measuring Ac.9.55 cents of
Murikipudi Village.
Sy.No.38: The report of the District Collector states that the extent in
Sy.No.38 is Ac.24.37 cents classified as Government Poramboke-stream.
As per MSR, it is subdivided into Sy.No.38-1 to 38-3 and its classification
has not been changed from Gayalu to AWD. As per adangal of Fasli 1397
and the current Fasli 1435, Sy.No.38-1 has been subdivided into
Sy.No.38-1A to 38-1L and is in the name of respective pattadars/enjoyers.
And he further reported that as per available records, no assignments have
been made.
Sy.No.547: As per RSR of Murikipudi Village Sy.No.547 admeasuring to an
extent of Ac.32.44 cents is classified as Government Poramboke-stream.
As per MSR, it is subdivided into Sy.No.547-1A to 547-4, and its
classification has never been changed from Vagu to AWD. As per adangal
for Fasli1410(2000-01), it is subdivided as 547-1A to 547-4 admeasuring to
Ac.32.44cents is subdivided and an extent of Ac.24.04 cents in
Sy.No.547-1A, and an extent of Sy.No.547-1B over an extent of Ac.0.75
cents is reflecting in the name of Government and the current Fasli 1435
the survey number is subdivided and the respective pattadars names are
recorded except Ac.24.04 cents in Sy.No.547-1A, and an extent of
Ac.547-1B over an extent of Ac.0.75 cents, which is in the name of
Government. And he further reported that as per available records, no
assignments have been made. He accordingly concluded that as per the
report of the Tahsildar, the Sy.No.33-1Z11 measuring Ac.63.63 cents,
Sy.No.547-1A measuring Ac.22.04 cents and Sy.No.38-1A measuring
Ac.1.51 cents of Murikipudi village are government lands as per revenue
records. As per 4C Register, the 65 writ petitioners have not been shown
as encroachers in Sy.No.33-1Z11, Sy.No.547-1A, and Sy.No.38-1A and the
respective B-Forms claimed by the petitioners herein are all not genuine.
16.
Accordingly, the Collector concludes that:
“7.
In the instance case, the B-Form Memorandum enclosed
by the petitioners in support of their Affidavit in WP.No.41879/2022 is in
Appendix XXX, without any opinions, signatures of VRO, Murikipudi&
MRI, Chilakaluripet and without any date of notice to the occupiers under
section 7 of Act III of 1905. As per Board of Standing Order 24, Paragraph
12, Appendix XXX is a Form for exemption of land from payment of
Revenue. From the above, it reveals that, the B-Form Memorandums
which are enclosed in support their affidavit is not in prescribed format
and not issued by the O/o. Tahsildar, Chilakaluripet.
Finally, the Tahsildar, Chilakaluripet has reported that, the BMemorandums which are enclosed in support of their affidavit in WP
No.41879/2022 all are forged and not genuine.
In view of the above, on perusal of Connected records and as per
the report of the Tahsildar, Chilakaluripet, it reveals that,
1. The Sy.Nos 33-1Z11 measuring Ac.63.63 cts, Sy.No. 547-1A measuring
Ac.22.04 cts& 38-1A measuring Ac.1.51cts of Murikipudi Village all are
Governments lands as per Revenue records.
2. As per 4C Register, the 65 writ petitioners have not been recorded as
encroachers in Sy. Nos 33-1211, 547-1A and 38-1A of Murikipudi Village.
3. On perusal of B- memorandums which are enclosed in support their
affidavit,
i.
As per BSO, B-memorandum consists of 18 columns, but as per
evidence of the petitioner, it consists of 16 columns.
ii.
As per BSO, B-Memorandum is a form in Appendix 50-A, but as
per evidence of the petitioner, it is in Appendix 30. As per
BSO-24, Paragraph 12, Appendix XXX is a form for exemption of land
from payment of Revenue.
iii.
As per BSO, B-Memorandum, 12th column contains Village
Officers Opinion, 13 column contains Revenue Inspectors remarks with
signatures. But, as per evidence of the petitioner, B-memorandum was in
without signatures of VRO, MRI.
iv.
As per BSO, B-Memorandum, 15th column contains date of notice
to the occupiers under section 7 of Act III of 1905. But, as per evidence of
the petitioner, B-Form case is not mentioned and noticed date was not
mentioned.
v.
The B-Memorandum which are enclosed in support their affidavit
are not in prescribed format and the same has been confirmed by the
then Tahsildar, Chilakaluripet who was worked in the period 2007-2009
and by the present Tahsildar also.
4.
In this connection, on perusal of connected records and as per the
reports of the Revenue Divisional Officer, Narasaraopet and the Tahsildar,
Chilakaluripet, it is submitted that, the B-memorandums said to have been
granted in respect of the petitioners in W.P.No.41879 of 2022 are not genuine.”
The report further states that the assignment records pertaining to
Murikipudi Village for the year 1974 are not available in the office of the
District Collector, Guntur.
17.
The report of the District Collector reflects that, as per the
available records, no assignments have been made and the B-Form Pattas
produced by the petitioners are not in the prescribed format and that the
Tahsildar who was discharging the duties of the Tahsildar at the relevant
period had reported that he never issued any such B-Memorandums.
18.
Further the NOCs of the Tahsildar reports that:
“Application for grant of quarry lease to an extent of Ac.12.06 cents in
Sy.No.547/1A
and
547/2
of
Murikipudi
village,
is
classified
as
vaguporamboke. As per the web land adangal, it is assigned in favour of
the assignees. The assignees have given NOCs by way of an unregistered
document dated 29.04.2021”.
19.
With regard to Sy.No.33-3, the quarry lease application has
been filed for Ac.9.55 cents, which has been subdivided into 33-3A to
33-3J, the same is classified as DKT patta land. The Tahsildar has stated
in his No Objection Certificate that the assignees have given their consent
through an unregistered document.
In respect of Sy.Nos.549 & 41: The Tahsildar has stated in his No
Objection Certificate dated 05.06.2021 that the assignees have given their
consent through an unregistered document dated 29.04.2021.
20.
On verification of the Web land adangal for Fasli - 1430, it is
noticed that, the proposed Sy.Nos.33-1U, 33-1W, 33-1X, 33-1Y, 33-1Z1,
33-1Z4, 33-1Z5, 33-1Z7, 33-1Z8, 33-9, 33-10 & 33-11 measuring Ac.10.70
cents were classified as "DK Pattas". The assignees have given consent
through un-registered document dated 04.06.2021 for a period of 99 years
to mining purpose. It is further submitted that on verification of prohibited
properties list Section 22- A (1) (a), it is noticed that, Sy.Nos.33-1U, 33-1W,
33-1X, 33-1Y, 33-1Z1, 33-1Z4, 33-1Z5, 33-1Z7, 33-1Z8, 33-9, 33-10 &
33-11 with total extent of Ac.10.70 cents classified as "DK Patta" as
Government Land assigned after 1954.
21.
Having regard to the contentions advanced, as the B-Form pattas
are found be bogus and as the assignees in respect of D-Form pattas have
given their consent for quarry lease through an unregistered document, I do
not find any merit in the contentions of the petitioners. Accordingly, the writ
petitions are dismissed. However, the respondents-Mines Department shall
ensure that the quarry lease holders maintain the 10 meters wide buffer zone
as opined by the Irrigation Department. There shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel, interlocutory applications, pending if any, shall stand
closed.
______________________________
JUSTICE KIRANMAYEE MANDAVA
Date:23.06.2026
ANI
THE HON’BLE SMT. JUSTICE KIRANMAYEE MANDAVA
WRIT PETITION Nos.41879 of 2022 and 7632 of 2023
Date:23.06.2026
ANI
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review