Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 22nd January, 2026
Date of upload: 27th January, 2026.
W.P.(C) 5617/2016&CM APPL. 23344/2016, CM APPL.
9938/2017, CM APPL. 9954/2017, CM APPL. 9955/2017, CM
APPL. 10330/2017, CM APPL. 10662/2017, CM APPL.
14376/2017, CM APPL. 22153/2017, CM APPL. 24416/2018, CM
APPL. 36496/2018, CM APPL. 46804/2018
MAHILA HAWKER WELFARE ASSOCIATION.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Kamlesh Kr Mishra, Mr. Swagata
Gupta, Ms. Renu, Ms. Kavita & Ms.
Mansi, Advs. (M:8013313825)
versus
DISTRICT MAGISTRATE, SHAHDRA & ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Ms Avni Singh, Panel CounselGNCTD with Ms. Vaibhav
Sharma,Adv.
Mr. Rajan Tyagi, Standing Counsel
with Ms. Vijeta Mukherjee and Samar
Partap Singh Advs. and Sudershan
Kumar,
AO
from
MCD.
(M:9958523388)
Inspector Sandeep Kumar and SI
Anshul, PS PIA.
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
Prathiba M. Singh, J. (Oral)
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
2.
The present writ petition was filed by the Mahila Hawkers Welfare
Association through its President, seeking issuance of appropriate directions
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
to the Respondents to allow the vendors of the Petitioner Association to vend
peacefully near the Anand Vihar Bus Stand.
3.
The petition consists of an annexed list of members marked as
‘Annexure P-1’, which includes names of 114 vendors from the National
Hawkers Federation.
4.
The case of the Petitioner is that they have been squatting near the
Anand Vihar Bus Stand for several years and that they ought not to be
disturbed from their respective vending spots.
5.
In the present case, notice was issued by the Court on 10th June, 2016,
and it was directed that the Respondent No.3– MCD, would not take any
coercive measures against the members of the Petitioner association, as listed
in ‘Annexure P-1’. Thus, protection was granted to the 114 hawkers who
formed the part of the list annexed as ‘Annexure P-1’.
6.
Further, it was clarified in the said order itself that the interim
protection being granted shall only be available to street vendors and not to
vendors who were hawking on the foot over bridge. The said interim order
dated 10th June, 2016 is relevant and is set out below:
“The petitioner has filed this petition claiming
benefit of Section 3 of the Street Venders (Protection
of Livelihood and Regulation of Street Vending) Act,
2014. It is contended that the members of the
petitioner/Association shown in Annexure P-I are
street vendors/hawkers and have been vending at
the respective spots for several years. It is
contended that the respondents are threatening to
evict the petitioner without complying with the
provisions of Section 3 of the said Act.
Reliance is placed on the judgment dated
20.08.2014 in W.P.(C) No.4303/2014 (National
Association of Street Vendors of India versus South
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
Delhi Municipal Corporation & Others), wherein
the Division Bench of this Court had noted that the
provisions of Section 3 of the Act provide that no
street vendors shall be evicted till the survey is
completed by the Town Vending Committee. Since
there is no Town Vending Committee in place, the
survey could not take place. Let counter-affidavit be
filed within two weeks. Rejoinder-affidavit, thereto,
if any, be filed within one week thereafter.
Renotify before the roster bench on 03.08.2016: In
the meanwhile, the respondent shall not take any
coercive steps against the members of the
petitioner/association listed in Annexure P-I.
Learned counsel for the respondent submits that
some of the hawkers/vendors are hawking on the
foot over bridge. It is clarified that the interim
protection shall not be available on the foot over
bridge and shall be only available only to the
street-vendors.
Dasti under signatures of the Court Master.”
7.
The said direction that the interim protection granted to the street
vendors vide order dated 10th June, 2016 would not provide any protection to
the hawkers hawking on the footover bridge was reiterated by the Court on
3rd August, 2016 as well.
8.
On 31st January, 2017, it was brought to the notice of the ld. Single
Judge, who was dealing with this writ petition, that an order was passed by
the Division Bench of this Court in WP(C) 1346/2015 titled Court on its own
motion (Air Pollution in Delhi) vs. Union of India & Ors., on 12th January,
2017, wherein it was directed that the roads at the concerned area ought to be
repaired by the MCD and kept free from encroachment.
9.
However, on 31st January, 2017 itself, it was further submitted on
behalf of MCD that due to the previous order passed by the ld. Single Judge
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
dated 10th June, 2016 in the present petition, they were unable to give effect
to the order of the Division Bench dated 12th January, 2017. Accordingly, on
31st January, 2017, the following order was passed in the present petition:
“CM No.3777/2017
This is an application filed on behalf of the East
Delhi Municipal Corporation seeking recall of
order dated 10.06.2016, whereby, protection was
granted to the members of the petitioner
association.
It is contended that, by order dated 12.01.2017 in
WP(C) No.1346/2015 titled Court on its own
motion (Air Pollution in Delhi) vs. Union of India
&Ors., the Division Bench has directed the East
Delhi Municipal Corporation to ensure that the
roads which fall under their jurisdiction are
repaired and kept free from any encroachment so
that there is free flow of traffic. Steps have to be
taken by the East Delhi Municipal Corporation and
the status report filed before the Division Bench
before the next date of hearing i.e. 02.02.2017.
Learned counsel appearing for the East Delhi
Municipal Corporation submits that, on account of
the order dated 10.06.2016, the respondent -East
Delhi Municipal Corporation is not in a position to
comply with the orders passed by the Division
Bench of keeping the area free from any
encroachment.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
submits that the members of the petitioner
association are not, in any manner, obstructing the
road or footpath and are squatting on PWD land
and the road and footpath are free and are not being
used by any of the members of the petitioner
association. The petitioner, alongwith the petition,
has filed a rough sketch plan as Annexure - P3,
which is extracted herein under:
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
With reference to the above rough sketch plan, it is
submitted by counsel for the petitioner, that the
place where the members of the petitioner
association claim to be, is shown as black dots in the
area described as "P.W.D. kiJagahDukandaar".
In view of the statement made by the learned counsel
for the petitioner, it is clarified that the interim
order dated 10.06.2016 would not ensure to the
benefit of any of the members of the petitioner
association who are squatting either on the 60 feet
road, 26 feet service road, 5 feet footpath or 6 feet
footpath or the foot over bridge shown in the rough
sketch plan hereinabove.
The respondent - East Delhi Municipal
Corporation is free to take action against any
squatter,hawker, encroacher, on the 60 feet road,
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
26 feet service road, 5 feet footpath or 6 feet
footpath or the foot over bridge, in terms of orders
of the Division Bench.
The interim application is, accordingly, disposed of.
Dasti under the signatures of the Court Master.”
10.
As per the above order dated 31st January, 2017, MCD was permitted
to take action against squatters, hawkers, encroachers on the 60 feet road, 26
feet service road and the other footpath. However, the protection provided to
the Petitioner vide the previous order dated 10th June, 2016, was continued.
11.
Thereafter, on 10th March, 2017, another application was filed on behalf
of the National Hawkers Association consisting of 126 members, claiming
that they were also hawking outside Anand Vihar for several years. Out of
the said 126 members, challans were filed for 72 members.
12.
On the ground that the 72 members whose challans were filed had been
vending for several years and that they should not be disturbed from their
vends, the Court accepted the said challans and directed that the said 72
members would not be disturbed from vending, in terms of order dated 10th
June, 2016. The following paragraphs of the said order dated 10th March,
2017 are relevant and are set out below:
“Since the applicant has shown prima facie
evidence with regard to only 72 of the members, it
is directed that, till the next date of hearing, said
72 members of the applicant association would be
entitled to the benefit of Section 3 of the Street
Vendors Policy (Protection of Livelihood &
Regularization of Street Vending) Act, 2014.
Similar protection will be granted to them as has
been granted to the petitioners vide order dated
10.06.2016.
It is noticed that the interim order dated
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
10.06.2016 itself records that the interim
protection shall not be available on the foot over
bridge and shall be available only to the street
vendors. It may further be noted that on
31.01.2017, this court had clarified that the
interim order dated 10.06.2016 would not enure
to the benefit of any of the members of the
petitioner either on the 60 feet road, 26 feet
service road, 5 feet footpath or 6 feet footpath or
the foot over bridge as shown in the rough sketch
plan extracted in the said order. That restriction
would also apply qua the members of the
applicant association.”
13.
Thus, vide the orders discussed above, dated 10th June, 2016, 31st
January, 2017 and 10th March, 2017, the Court had clarified that the MCD
can take action against any squatters and hawkers on the 60 feet road, 26 feet
service road, 5 feet footpath or 6 feet footpath, as also the ones hawking on
the footover bridge. It was also clarified that the street vendors would not be
entitled to set up any structures. The said interim protection is continuing till
date.
14.
Thereafter, the matter has been adjourned from time to time. On 13th
January, 2026, an adjournment was sought on behalf of the Petitioner which
was opposed by ld. Counsel for the MCD on the ground that there are various
orders which are passed by other Benches of the Court which have directed
that the congestion on the footpath at ISBT Anand Vihar ought to be cleared.
15.
Today, Mr. Tyagi, ld. Counsel has also informed the Court that the
survey in the said area, that was to be conducted by the Town Vending
Committee in accordance with The Street Vendors (Protection of livelihood
and Regulation of street vending) Act, 2014, has also now been conducted.
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
16.
Upon conclusion of the said survey, it has been ascertained that out of
all the vendors vending at the Anand Vihar Bus Stand area, there are only 105
vendors who have a provisional Certificate of Vending (hereinafter, ‘COV’)
for temporary vending.
17.
It is further submitted by Mr. Tyagi, ld. Counsel, that the vendors have
created proper permanent structures and are the cause of enormous congestion
outside the ISBT Anand Vihar Station, which is causing extreme difficulties
to the passengers, tourists etc., who come from different cities. Some
photographs have also been handed over by Mr. Tyagi, ld. Counsel, depicting
the said position.
18.
On the other hand, Mr. Mishra, ld. Counsel for the Petitioner submits
that the hawkers who are part of the Petitioner Association do have COVs,
and they have been hawking for a long time, but he does not dispute the
position that the permanent structures could not have been created by the
hawkers.
19.
The Court has heard the matter at length today.
20.
The ISBT Anand Vihar Terminal renders an extremely crucial essential
service area for passengers who use the said bus terminal. Lakhs of
passengers, as also the Indian Railways, DMRC operate from the said area
and hence, the area sees a large footfall on a daily basis. The Kaushambi Bus
Stand, which connects several passengers from Delhi to Uttar Pradesh, is also
stated to be in the nearby neighbourhood itself.
21.
The Court has also perused the photographs which have been handed
over today by Mr. Tyage, ld. Counsel. The said photographs are taken on
record and are extracted below:
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
22.
The pictures extracted above clearly show that most of the hawkers
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
have created permanent vends and they are no longer merely hawkers, since
they have put up their outlet-like small shops, covering large areas including,
pedestrian pathways.
23.
The COVs which are provisional in nature clearly incorporate a
condition that hawkers cannot have permanent structures. The said
provisional COVs also consist of a category ‘others’ and one of the conditions
therein is that the vendors have to be mobile vendors.
24.
Clearly, the hawkers at the Anand Vihar Bus Stand area are not
adhering to the conditions of the COVs issued to them. Moreover, any main
road of this nature is a non-hawking area in terms of the policy of the MCD,
which describes “non-hawking area” as under:
“All approved commercial areas, VIP roads, main roads
and areas shown under squatting area”
25.
The clear position that emerges from the facts and submissions made
today is that the congestion in the Anand Vihar Bus Stand area deserves to be
removed.
26.
In addition, the Court is of the view that the MCD ought to be permitted
to beautify the area, by creating a service road where passengers who come in
three-wheelers, cabs, auto rickshaws or other transports can easily alight,
before entering the railway station or bus stand.
27.
There ought to be free space for movement of the public. Beautification
and development of the area is also required, so that the passengers and
tourists can enjoy a comfortable experience while visiting a bus stand or the
nearby railway station.
28.
The manner in which hawking is presently being done is completely
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
impermissible as it also encroaches upon the area created for easy movement
of the public.
29.
Thus, the entire area deserves to be properly re-planned, laid out,
landscaped and tiled. As part of this process, some shops, cafes, resting areas,
sanitation facilities, etc., ought to be created for the passengers in a manner
so as to not impede their free movement.
30.
Under these circumstances, the present position cannot continue. The
hawkers deserve to be removed and only the 105 hawkers, as recognized
during the survey, should be permitted to use mobile vends for selling their
wares in an allocated manner. No permanent structure can be allowed to be
created by the 105 recognized vendors as well.
31.
The MCD shall, accordingly, take steps, along with the SHO or the
DCP of the concerned area, to remove all the vendors. However, adequate
time shall be given of at least five to six days for the vendors to remove their
wares. Hence, the MCD is granted time till 30th January, 2026 to take
appropriate steps to inform the vendors of the directions of this Court.
Thereafter, from the weekend commencing on 31st January, the removal of
the vends shall commence.
32.
No person shall obstruct or create any impediment in the removal of
these vends. After the said removal, the recognised vendors shall be permitted
to approach the Assistant Commissioner, MCD, who shall then guide the 105
recognised vendors as to the manner in which they can put up their carts and
vends in the area, in compliance with the conditions enumerated in the
provisional COVs issued to them.
33.
The MCD shall also prepare, with the help of an architect, a proper plan
for beautification of the area and for allocation of proper spaces for eating
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
outlets, sanitation facilities and for some shops, as directed above. The said
plan shall also be placed on record before the Court by 10th March, 2026.
34.
The MCD is free to take the assistance of any Architect in PWD in this
regard including Ms. Sabita Sahoo, Architect, PWD (+91 7205532243), in the
entire process of preparing the architectural plan, as stated above. Further, the
PWD shall also assist the MCD in creating a plan for beautification of this
area so that the work can commence on an early date, upon the plan being
placed before this Court.
35.
By 10th March, 2026, the MCD shall place on record the said plan, both
in electronic form and in a hard copy.
36.
With the present order being passed, all previously granted interim
orders stand modified in terms thereof. Insofar as the applications filed by
other hawkers and vendors for directions are concerned, except for the 105
hawkers recognized during the survey, in terms of the list handed over today,
no other vendor shall be permitted to vend in this area.
37.
All encroachments and any other shops, carts, vends, etc., are also
permitted to be removed. The list of the 105 vendors recognized by the TVC
during its survey has been handed over to the Court today and is taken on
record. The said list is attached with the present order and is marked as
‘Annexure A-1’.
38.
Additionally, it is directed that if there are any other vendors who
participated in the survey conducted by TVC and were found eligible in terms
of the said survey shall be permitted to vend their wares, only if the
provisional COVs have been issued to them by the TVC.
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
39.
The petition is disposed of in these terms. Pending applications, if any,
are also disposed of.
40.
List for compliance on 30th March, 2026.
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
MADHU JAIN
JUDGE
JANUARY 22, 2026
dj/ss
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
Annexure A-1
List of vendors to whom COV/survey has been approved (Old
Ward No. 18E/New No. 206) Anand Vihar
SNo URI Number
Vendor Name
Fathers Name
3345515
3524910
2087553
8736689
8473428
9279037
8064639
1262116
6127818
3263656
9814624
7217232
4265812
6544622
1374186
2017315
3896020
6506473
5312561
7179268
7583084
2884525
2561747
2685713
1550575
9240082
1583725
6466665
1949522
3138300
3257136
8082612
7442310
Brijesh
Netrapal
Bhrampal
Santosh Kumar
Munesh
Faisal
Neeraj Kumar
Arjun Singh
Zafar Khan
Rajeev Jaiswal
Harihar Prasad
Ram Vichar Sah
Briz Kishor Pandey
Pintu Gupta
Rakesh Kumar Sah
Rahat Khan
Omendra Kumar
Subodh Bhagat
Aram Singh
Ram Lakhan
Anil Rawat
Shyam Jeet Kumar
Shanta
Aslam
Munna Singh
Umesh Kumar Singh
Rajesh Kumar Singh
Neeraj Gupta
Ranjeet Kumar Sah
Santosh Sah
Sanjay Prasad
Umashanker Prasad
Sonu Kumar Gupta
4740415
2316626
8107054
7061747
Dheeraj Kumar
Om Prakash Singh
Chhedi Singh
Shyam Kumar
Sh. Sateesh
Sh. Vishnu Dayal
Sh. Hans Raj
Sh. Heera
Sh. Chandra Koshika
Sh. Rahat Ali
Sh. Virendra Prasad
Sh. Mange Ram
Sh. Sabuddin
Sh. Keshan Kumar
Sh. Dhura Batur
Sh. Gorakh Sah
Sh. Sri Ram Pandey
Sh. Keshav Gupta
Sh. Sri Ram Vichar Shah
Sh. Nawab Ali
Sh. Virendra Singh
Sh. Tunatun Bhagat
Sh. Hans Raj
Sh. Nanku Lal
Sh. Shiv Prasad Ravat
Sh. Jogindra Sah
Late Sh. Ram Asray
Sh. Majeed
Late Sh. Chandira Singh
Sh. Chandrika Singh
Sh. Chandrika Singh
Sh. Shanti Swaroop Gupta
Sh. Seeta Ram Sah
Sh. Seeta Ram Sah
Sh. Prithvi Nath Prasad
Sh. Sheetal Prasad
Sh. Ghanshyam Prasad
Gupta
Sh. Hari Prasad Gupta
Sh. Ram Lakhan Singh
Sh. Ram Lakhan Singh
Sh. Ganesh Shah
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
3851182
5688064
3250684
3527744
1484265
4377623
5245864
9916853
9294548
8453681
2441228
4947691
8605699
7691914
6844379
2596593
1771982
6538293
4917146
3139911
1184555
4927493
1289859
4457301
3342505
7713243
2837216
4752021
8040786
7168941
4450295
7510750
2674581
Mohd Nazim
Mo Aslam
Chandrama Ram
Mantu Ram
Hari Prasad Gupta
Vishwa Karma Ram
Jainul Basher
Ram Kishan
Dharam Veer
Vicky
Praveen
Anil Kumar Porwal
Suresh Gupta
Deenanath Gupta
Mithun
Dharamveer Sah
Ranjeet Sah
Manoj Kumar
Maheswar Kumar
Chandrakesh
Ram Swaroop
Rohit
Md Motiur Rahmen
Rajesh Kumar Sah
Dinesh Chander
Soni 41
Nandan Singh
Mohd Mujammil
Nand Kishor
Vikram Singh
Bantu
Govind
Pramod Kumar Rathor
Sh. Kamruddin
Sh. Kamruddin
Sh. Amerika Ram
Sh. Amerika Ram
Sh. Bhola Prasad Gupta
Sh. Chanderika Ram
Sh. Samso Kamar
Sh. Roshan Lal
Sh. Roshan Lal
Sh. Gangaram
Sh. Bal Mukund
Sh. Chhote Lal
Sh. Bhola Prasad Gupta
Sh. Munne Lal
Sh. Sudama Singh
Sh. Sudama Sah
Sonelal Sah
Sh. Sudama Sah
Sh. Babbu Pandit
Sh. Badan Singh
Sh. Chhote Lal
Sh. Ramswaroop
Sh. Samshera
Sh. Seeta Ram Sah
Sh. Sone Lal
Sh. Mehesh Chandra
Sh. Jaya Singh
Sh. Rafi Ujamma
Sh. Ram Vikas
Sh. Ganga Ram
Sh. Mahesh Chandra
Sh. Sukhveer
Sh. Gaya Prasad
6887686
7022244
2461416
5098588
1466180
Mahesh Chand
Sh. Sone Lal
Chhote Lal
Naresh Chand
Dalveer Singh
Ajeet Mishra
Sri Kalyan Singh
Sri Sonelal
Sri Babu Ram
Sri Seshnath Mishra
8385548
8852433
3383229
2627940
3004291
Chandrana Sah
Santosh Saah
Manish Kumar
Bheem Gupta
Sunil Ravat
Ranajatan Sah
Sri Jogendra Saah
Sri Suresh Kumar
Sri Shami Gupta
Sri Shiv parsad Ravat
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
3463111
4604945
1438569
1265224
8420085
3511554
6400330
5171304
5758849
90 8604386
8852589
7934532
1899261
8622776
5577047
2606359
3132791
5546128
5075743
2601233
3596890
9626118
7360086
1177948
6868634
Radhey Shyam
Abdul Mazeed
Ramu Gupta
Matiulla
Sandeep
Shammu Chauhan
Mukesh Kumar
Bajarangi Gupta
Swatantra Kumar
Thakur
Sudher Rai
Sri Narayan Chowdhari
Sri Rahmaat Ali
Sri Ganesh Sah
Sri Khatyi
Sri Rasham
Ram Avatar
Sri Ramnarayan
Sri Harigware Gupta
Sri Ramsuresh Thakur
Ramesh Kumar
Raguveer
Guddu Bharti
Sri Hari
Sri Sundari
Bilas Bharti
Sh. Ganga Ram
Sh. Ajeem Alam
Sh. Bhagwan Dass
Sh. Vijay Shah
Sh. Amit
Sh. Jitender Gupta
Sh. Hakim Singh
Sh. Atul
Ch. Rohtash Singh
Sh. Raju Mishra
Sh. Omveer
Sh. Rinku
Sh. Gurman
Sh. Akhmaz Israil Alam
Sh. Roshan Lal
Sh. Vishava Nath Shah
Sh. Hakim
Sh. Hari Prasad Gupta
Sh. Kedar Singh
Sh. Hakim Singh
Ch. Fateh Singh
Sh. Rambushan Mishra
Sh. Mangat Singh
Sh. Ramesh Chandra
Sri Upendra Kumar
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
16:39:09
W.P.(C) 5617/2016
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review