Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.A No.1962 of 2025
In the matter of an appeal under Section-10 of the Letters
Patent of Patna High Court read with Article-4 the Orissa
High Court Rules, 1948 from a common order dated
05.12.2025 passed by the Single Judge in W.P.(C) Nos. 31617
& 32188 of 2024.
---….
Maheswar Jena
Appellant
-versusMadhusudan Dalai & Others
….
Respondents
Advocates Appeared in this case
For Appellant
M/s. Pratik Nayak, B. Mishra, A.
Mishra & P. Patnaik, Advocates
For Respondents -
M/s.Millon Kumar, A.
Khandelwal &P. Khandewlwal,
Advocates [R-1]
Smt.Suman Pattanayak,
Addl. Govt. Advocate
[R-2 to 4]
---
CORAM :
MR. JUSTICE DIXIT KRISHNA SHRIPAD
MR. JUSTICE CHITTARANJAN DASH
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing & Judgment : 15.01.2026
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------PER KRISHNA S. DIXIT,J.
Appellant's membership of Grama Panchayat having been terminated
on the ground of disqualification because of having more than two children,
as provided under Section 25(1)(v) of the Odisha Grama Panchayats Act,
1964, is in question and his challenge to the same having been negatived,
this intra-court Appeal is presented against a learned Single Judge's order
dated 05.12.2025, whereby his WP(C) Nos.31617 & 32188 of 2024 have
been dismissed.
2.
Learned counsel for the Appellant vehemently argues that his client
is entitled to protection under the Proviso to Clause (v) of Sub-Section (1)
of Section 25 of the 1964 Act and this aspect having not been duly
considered, there is error apparent on the face of the record warranting
interference of this Court. Learned AGA appearing for the State and learned
Advocates appearing for the private parties on caveat vociferously resist the
appeal making submissions in justification of the impugned order and the
reasons on which they have been constructed.
3.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and having perused the
appeal papers, this Court declines indulgence in the matter broadly agreeing
with the view of learned Single Judge and also for the following reasons:
3.1.
AS TO THE SCOPE OF PROTECTIVE PROVISO TO
SECTION 25(1)(V) OF THE ACT:
3.1.1. Learned counsel for the Appellant strenuously argues that although
his client begot the 3rd child on 11.03.1993 and 4th on 06.11.1994, he enjoys
protection under the Proviso to Clause (v) of Sub-Section (1) of Section 25
of the 1964 Act. Let us examine this aspect of the matter. Sub-Section (1)
of Section 25 enlists as many as 23 circumstances, each one of them being a
ground for disqualification from being elected or nominated as a Sarpanch
or any other member of Grama Panchayat. Relevant to our discussion is
Clause (v) of Sub-Section (1) of Section 25, of course, the Proviso to the
Clause being inclusive. The same has following text:
“25. Disqualification for membership of Grama Panchayat-(1) A
person shall be disqualified for being elected or nominated as, a
Sarpanch or any other member of the Grama Panchayat constituted
under this Act, if hexx
xx
xx
xx
xx
(v) has more than two children:
xx
“Provided that the disqualification under Clause (v) shall not apply to
any person who has more than two Children on the date of
commencement of the Orissa Grama Panchayats (Amendment) Act,
1994 or, as the case may be, within a period of one year of such
commencement, unless he begets an additional child after the said
period of one year...”
3.1.2. The Constitution (Forty-Second Amendment) Act, 1976 introduced
Entry-20A 'Population Control & Family Planning' to the Concurrent List
in the Seventh Schedule with effect from 03.01.1977. This introduction is
not without significance. It was made in the wake of rapidly growing
population in the country so that Center & States can devise policies to
control the growth rate. The Proviso to Clause (v) to Sub-Section (1) of
Section 25 of the Act is one small measure in that direction. It came to be
introduced by way of Amendment w.e.f. 18.04.1994, as on which date the
Appellant had the 3rd child born (11.03.1993) and the 4th (06.11.1994). The
Panchayat elections were admittedly held in the year 2022. Thus, the said
Proviso was already in force since the preceding 18 years or so. Thus, the
case of Appellant is one of Text Book for attracting the disqualification
clause, the protective Proviso remaining miles away. The finding recorded
by the learned Single Judge and by the Court below, in this regard, is thus
unassailable.
3.2.
A FRAGMENT ON THE LAUDABLE POLICY OF FAMILY
PLANNING & ITS DIRE NEED:
3.2.1. Section 25(1)(v) of the Act enacts a State Policy of diminishing the
exponential population growth. Sir Winston Churchill (1874-1965) is said
to have said "India is not a nation, but mere population". This was long
before the Partition, when the then population of undivided India was about
30 Crores or so. What caustic comment he would have made, had he been
alive today, will drive one to wild imagination. The Punjab & Haryana
High Court in Fazru v. State of Haryana1, while repelling challenge to the
validity of similar provision observed as under:
“16. It is observed that the Government is spending huge amount in
propagating Family Planning, In the recent years, the growth of
population in the country is alarming. The Government in order to
check the same has introduced various Projects to Implement the
Family Planning which have been entrusted to various agencies one of
which is Gram Panchayat. It is expected from the Panches and
Sarpanches to set good examples and they are supposed to maintain
norm of two children. If they themselves violate the same, what
examples they can set before the public. The population can be checked
by adopting the Family Planning Measures. If the same are not
adopted, then the Nature takes its own turn i.e. people die by natural
calamities. In the case in hand, the State Government has put a
condition that he who violates Section... will be disqualified. Right to
contest election is not a fundamental right. The petitioner was aware of
Section... and he has not intentionally complied with the Rules and
Regulations. We are not oblivious of the fact that Nation's interest is
supreme. Growing population is the greatest problem which the country
is facing. It will not only be desirable but absolutely essential for every
.AIR 1998 P&H 133.
country to see that the Family Planning Programme is maintained at
sufficient levels so as to meet the danger of over-population which, if
not controlled, may lead to serious social and economic problems
throughout the country. No enactment which promotes social and
economic justice can be held to be ultra vires. No doubt, every citizen
has a right to live with human dignity. But, how one can expect citizens
of this country to live with human dignity and social equality when the
population goes on increasing by leaps and bounds. If the existing rate
of growth of population is allowed to continue it is bound to take the
country to a dangerous stage where persons may die of hunger and may
not have a roof over their heads to live.”
3.2.2. The United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) India Policy, for the
year 2023-2027 enlists four States, namely, Bihar, Madhya Pradesh,
Rajasthan & Odisha as priority provinces for addressing population growth
rate. It mentions that population of Odisha is 3.32% of nation's population,
and it is a vibrant mix of traditions, languages & communities 2. According
to UN World Health Organization, Health Data Overview 2023, India's
population was about 1.43 billion. Obviously, now it has crossed that
figure. It is projected to increase to 1.7 billion by 2050, the growth rate
being 17% for the period3, if not Malthusian Thumb Rule of 100% hike
once in 25 years. This is alarming, to say the least. It was Bertrand Russell
(1872-1970), a British Philosopher & Nobel Awardee (1950), who
measuredly said "Population explosion is more dangerous than hydrogen
bomb".
3.2.3. The policy makers, more particularly the Political Executives, do not
appear to have duly adverted to the warning of Thomas Robert Malthus
(1766-1834) administered in his poignant write up "An Essay on the
Principle of Population" published in 1798. It is relevant to extract his view:
. UNFPA in India, Country Programme – 10 (2023-2027)
. WHO Data, Health data overview for the Republic of India.
"...The ratio of increase, though short of utmost power of the
population, yet as the result of actual experience, we will take as our
rule, and say, that population, when unchecked, goes on doubling itself
every twenty-five years or increases in a geometrical ratio…”
The UNFPA in its report on Population Projection has said as under:
"It took hundreds of thousands of years for the world population to
grow to one billion- then in just in another two hundred years or so, it
grew sevenfold. In 2011, it reached eight billion. This dramatic growth
has been driven largely by increasing numbers of people surviving to
reproductive age, and has been accompanied by major changes in
fertility rates, Increasing urbanization and large-scale migration. These
trends will have far-reaching implications for generations to come...”4
The gigantic population of the Country, it is obvious, is coming in the way
of implementation of several socio-welfare schemes. Memory has not faded
about the difficulties which people of the Country faced during Covid-19
pandemic because of space constraint when they were asked to maintain
safe distance. The value & dignity of individuals, even in any civilized
jurisdiction, which our Constitution and the Courts so jealously seek to
cherish & protect, would diminish in their content as against the increase in
population. This needs no research for affirmation. It is high time that
'powers that be' turn the pages of this Essay before the 'population
explosion' happens in the Country.
3.2.4. A collegium of 11000 World Scientists' Warning inter alia as to
population growth & its ill effects is pertinent to reproduce:"…profoundly troubling signs from human activities include sustained
Increases in both human and ruminant livestock populations, per capita
meat production, world gross domestic product, global tree cover loss,
. UNFPA, World population trends, Megatrends.
fossil fuel consumption, the number of air passengers carried, carbon
dioxide (CO2) emissions…"5
The UN Secretary-General Javier Perez de Cuellar expressed concern as to
over growing population as a global phenomenon in the following words:“If rapid population growth in the developing nations is left unchecked,
it will evidently undermine all efforts for economic and social
development and could easily lead to widespread depletion of each
nation’s resources.”
Human overpopulation in the globe is a major driver of biodiversity loss &
proves to be a key obstacle to fairly sharing habitat and essential resources
with other species. Failure to address the root causes of biodiversity loss,
one of them being rapid growth of population will doom conservationists'
efforts.
4.
Overpopulation which is a complex and multifaceted issue presents a
mammoth challenge to the delicate balance of our only planet and its
limited resources, the unchecked population growth places immense strain
on environmental, societal and economic systems. There is almost a global
unanimity
of
opinion
that
overpopulation
causes
environmental
degradation, resource scarcity and intensified societal challenges. It is not
in the domain of Court to enlist all other disastrous consequences of rapid
population growth in general and the demographic changes associated with
such growth, in particular. People are degrading ecosystems so thoroughly
that future generations likely will have a hard time living decent lives.
More is not necessary to specify and less is insufficient to leave it unsaid.
. William J. Ripple, Christopher Wolf, Thomas M. Newsome, Phoebe Barnard, William R. Moomaw,
and 11,258 scientist signatories from 153 countries World Scientists’ Warning of a Climate
Emergency, available at: Bioscience by Oxford University Presses, published: 5 th Nov. 2019.
5.
We have made the above observations to express our deep concern as
to the imminent population explosion, and to stress the dire need for
devising appropriate policies on war footing to halt the same. It is
appreciable that the Parliament decades ago sensed the danger and brought
about the Forty-Second Amendment to the Constitution introducing Entry20A to the Concurrent List as already mentioned above. This was to enable
the promulgation of policy, legislative or otherwise. However, we are
constrained to observe that the measures hitherto taken to retard population
growth rate, are far from satisfactory. It is high time that the Constitutional
Institutions and the Civil Society do something in the matter. Lord Byron
(1788-1824) in his poem 'Childe Harold's Pilgrimage' prophetically says:
“A thousand years scarce serve to form a State; an hour may lay it in
the dust.”
In the above circumstances, this Appeal being devoid of merits is
liable to dismissed and accordingly it is, costs having been made easy.
We place on record our deep appreciation for the able research and
assistance rendered by Law Clerk-cum-Research Assistant-Mr. Mohammed
Nihad Sharief.
Registry to send a copy of this judgment to the Hon’ble Chairman,
Law Commission of India, New Delhi.
(Dixit Krishna Shripad)
Judge
(Chittaranjan Dash)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
Digitally Signed
th Day of January, 2026/A.K. Pradhan
The 15
Signed by: ANANTA
KUMAR
PRADHAN
Designation: Senior Stenographer
Reason: Authentication
Location: HIGH COURT OF ORISSA
Date: 20-Jan-2026 16:30:18
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review