Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:2280
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
S. A. No. 228 of 2023
1. Maheshwar Mahto, aged about 42 years, son of Late Babulal
Mahto
2. Phani Mahto, aged about 55 years, son of Late Kharia Mahto
3. Anil Mahato, aged about 53 years, son of Late Kharia Mahto
4. Dinesh Mahto @ Dinesh Kumar Mahto, aged about 41 years, son
of Paltu Mahto
5. Srikanta Mahto, aged about 38 years, son of Late Sadanand Mahto
All residents of Village- Barpokhar, P.O.- Kura, P.S.- Pindrajora,
District- Bokaro
…
…
Plaintiffs 1st set/Appellants/Appellants
Versus
1. Chhutia Devi, wife of Late Guhi Ram Mahto
2. Bhagirath Mahato, son of Guhi Ram Mahto
Both residents of Village- Barpokhar, P.O.- Kura, P.S.- Pindrajora,
Dist.-Bokaro
3. Kavita Devi, D/o Late Guhi Ram Mahto, W/o Bhikhan Mahato,
R/o Village- Kura, Tola- Purandih, P.O.- Kura, P.S.-Pindrajora,
Dist.-Bokaro
4. Anita Devi, D/o Late Guhi Ram Mahto, W/o Adu Mahto, R/o
Village- Bharsundha, P.O. & P.S.- Chas, Dist.- Bokaro
5. Urmila Devi, D/o Late Guhi Ram Mahto, R/o Barpokhar, P.O.Kura, P.S.- Pindrajora, District- Bokaro
6. Janki Devi, D/o Late Guhi Ram Mahto, R/o Village- Bhandro,
Tola- Santhaldih, P.O.- Kura, P.S.- Pindrajora, District-Bokaro
7. Tarani Mahto S/o Late Barju Mahto
8. Kamla Devi, W/o Late Chinibas Mahto
9. Murlidhar Mahto
10. Pabar Kumar, both sons of Late Chinibas Mahto
No.7 to 10 R/o Village- Barpokhar, P.O.- Kura, P.S.- Pindrajora,
District- Bokaro
11.Suma Devi, D/o Late Chinibas Mahto, W/o Anil Mahto, R/o
Village- Solagidih, P.O. & P.S.- Chas, District- Bokaro
12.Kristomani Mahatain, D/o Late Barju Mahto
13.Mutka Mahto
14.Mukta Mahato
15.Uday Mahto
13, 14, 15 all sons of Late Putra @ Haradhan Mahato
16.Sishir Mahto
17.Mihir Mahto
18. Gopal Mahto
All sons of late Haripada Mahto
19. Santosh Mahto
20. Kunta Devi, W/o Late Kisto Mahto.
21. Santosh Mahto
22. Prakash Mahto
2026:JHHC:2280
23. Vikash Mahto
All sons of Late Kisto Mahto
24. Jhuna Mahatain, D/o Late Dukhu Mahto
25. Gour Mahto, S/o Late Baleshwar Mahto
26. Negibala @ Nemi Bala Devya, D/o Late Baleshwar Mahto, W/O
Arjun Mahto
27.Debi Bala Devi, W/o Jagal Mahto, R/o Village- Baradih, P.O.Bandhdih, P.S.- Jaridih, District- Bokaro
28.Chhabi Bala Devi, W/o Sadanand Prajapati, R/o Village- Baradih,
P.O.- Bandhdih, P.S.- Jaridih, District- Bokaro.
29.Kunti Mahatain, D/o Late Mohan Mahto
30.Sri Mati Mahatain, D/o Late Mohan Mahto
All residents of Village- Borpokhar, P.O.- Kura, P.S. Pindrajora,
District- Bokaro
31.Dhananjay Mahto, S/o Late Dina Mahto, R/o Village- Purandih,
P.O.- Kura, P.S.- Pindrajora, District-Bokaro
... ...
Defendants/Respondents/Respondents
32.Lekho Mahato, S/o Late Umesh Mahato
33.Dhani Ram Mahto
34.Falender Mahto
All sons of Late Umesh Mahto
35.Tunulal Mahto
36.Chetlal Mahto, Both sons of Late Rupan Mahto
37.Bhola Mahto, son of Late Shambhu Mahto
38.Manilal Mahto
39.Ganesh Mahto
40.Baijal Mahto
41.Deo Narayan Mahto
All sons of Late Manglu @ Dhanu Mahto, all R/o VillageBarpokhar, P.O.- Kura, P.S. Pindrajora, District-Bokaro, A/P
residing at Village- Nawadih, Tola- Narayanpur, P.S.- Nawadih,
District- Bokaro, Jharkhand
... ...
Plaintiffs 2nd set/Respondents/Respondents
--CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--For the Appellants
: Mr. Pankaj Srivastava, Advocate
--14/29.01.2026
1.
Heard the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellants.
2.
This second appeal has been filed against the Judgment dated
22.07.2023 (Decree signed on 28.07.2023) passed by learned District
Judge-IV, Bokaro in Civil Appeal No. 34 of 2017, affirming the
Judgment dated 31.08.2017 (Decree signed on 11.09.2017) passed by
learned Additional Munsif, Bokaro in Title Suit No.66 of 2001.
2026:JHHC:2280
3.
The title suit was dismissed by the learned trial court and the
judgment and decree passed in title suit was affirmed by the learned
1st appellate court. Consequently, the plaintiffs 1st set are the
appellants before this Court.
4.
The learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that there
were two sets of plaintiffs. The plaintiffs 2nd set had sold the suit
property to the plaintiffs 1st set vide two sale deeds both dated
25.07.1990 which were exhibited as Exhibit-1 and Exhibit-1/a. The
plaintiffs 2nd set claimed to be the descendants of the recorded tenant
and the plaintiffs 1st set were purchasers from the plaintiffs 2nd set.
The plaintiffs 1st set are the appellants before this Court. The learned
counsel submitted that the defendants had claimed that they had
purchased the property by registered sale deed of the year 1932
(Exhibit-G). The learned counsel submitted that the learned court has
wrongly dismissed the suit on the point of limitation. The learned
counsel also submitted that the defendants had claimed that they had
acquired the property by way of auction sale (Exhibit-A). The learned
counsel further submitted that the sale deed executed in the year 1932
(Exhibit-G) was never acted upon. He submitted that the learned court
has held that the plaintiffs 2nd set came to know about the sale deed
of the year 1932 (Exhibit-G) on 02.06.1990 and 12.06.1990 and
thereafter, sold the property to plaintiffs 1st set vide registered sale
deed dated 25.07.1990. He submitted that the suit cannot be barred
against the plaintiffs 1st set. The learned counsel also submitted that
the plaintiffs 2nd set had filed the suit way back in the year 1992
challenging the sale deed dated 20.05.1932, but the same was
dismissed for default and the restoration application in connection
with the same was also dismissed and ultimately the plaintiffs 2nd set
joined with the plaintiffs 1st set to file a fresh suit in the year 2001.
The learned counsel submitted that the suit was wrongly held to be
barred by limitation and the point of limitation was wrongly decided
against the plaintiffs 1st set, who are the appellants before this Court.
2026:JHHC:2280
5.
After hearing the learned counsel for the appellants, this Court
finds that the plaintiffs 1st set and plaintiffs 2nd set have joined
together to file a suit for declaration of right, title and interest over the
suit property mentioned in Schedule-A with a prayer
that the
defendants have not acquired any right, title and interest over the
property.
6.
The plaintiffs further prayed for declaration that the purchased
deed in the name of predecessors of the defendant be declared as
invalid, forged, manufactured and have never been acted upon and not
binding upon the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs also prayed for decree for
confirmation of possession of the ancestors of the plaintiffs 2nd set
and subsequently, plaintiffs 1st set as per the Sale Deed No. 7361 and
7362 over the suit property and if the plaintiffs are found
dispossessed, a prayer was also made for recovery of possession.
7.
The plaintiffs claimed that the plaintiffs 2nd set are the
descendants of the recorded tenant and the genealogy of the recorded
tenant was mentioned in the schedule-B of the plaint. Further case of
the plaintiffs was that after demise of the ancestors of the plaintiffs
2nd set, they inherited the property and came in possession and they
were living outside the village. They had given the property to the
plaintiffs 1st set on sharing basis and had appointed one Niranjan Nag
as their caretaker and the cultivation was being performed by the
plaintiffs 1st set. Subsequently, the plaintiffs 1st set proposed to
purchase the portion land under Khata No.261 and 262 to which the
plaintiffs 2nd set agreed and by virtue of two sale deeds being Sale
Deed Nos. 7361 and 7362 both dated 25.07.1990, the plaintiffs 2nd
set sold 1.60 acres of land out of area 2.28 acres under Khata No. 261
and 40 decimals out of 1.02 acres i.e. 1/3rd shares of the total area
3.06 acres and delivered the possession to the plaintiffs 1st set.
8.
When the co-sharer came to know about it, they tried to take
forcible possession of the lands. Thereafter in 1990, Plaintiff No.11
went to the Circle Office and informed that the defendants are
claiming the said lands as their purchased lands and the defendants for
2026:JHHC:2280
the first time in 1990 revealed the fact of having purchased the lands.
The plaintiffs further asserted that the defendants have produced a
collusive registered sale deed executed by the owner of Khata No.4
and 5 who are the immediate landlords of the occupancy raiyats. The
ancestors of the plaintiffs 2nd set who have accepted rent from the
said raiyats and granted rent receipts and the vendors of the
defendants have also admitted that the ancestors of the plaintiffs 2nd
set as permanent raiyats under them. It was asserted that the sale deed
was a mere paper transaction, not meant to be acted upon and is
collusive, without consideration and bogus.
9.
A title suit being Title Suit No.15 of 1992 was filed by the
plaintiffs 2nd set against the defendants making the plaintiffs 1st set
as proforma defendants. The prayer of Title Suit No.15 of 1992 has
also been quoted in the title suit judgment.
10.
It was asserted that the Title Suit No.15 of 1992 was dismissed
for default on 13.04.1993 for which a Misc. Case No.14 of 1993 was
filed, but the said Misc. Case No.14 of 1993 was also dismissed for
default on 06.09.1993 and thereafter another Misc. Case No.26 of
1993 was filed which too was dismissed for default on 01.12.1998.
11.
It was asserted that there were some material defects and some
facts were omitted in the plaint and the purchasers were not fully and
appropriately made parties and hence, a fresh suit was required to be
filed.
12.
It was also asserted that the cause of action for the present suit
arose on and from the first date revealing the claim of defendants on
02.06.1990 and 12.06.1990 when the plaintiffs obtained the certified
copy of the registered Sale Deed No.2117 dated 20.05.1932 and
subsequently on 11.02.1991 when the Anchal Adhikary refused to
accept rent and lastly, on 04.12.1998 when the Misc. Case No. 26 of
1993 for restoring the Title Suit No.15 of 1992 was dismissed for
default.
13.
The suit was contested by the Defendant Nos.1, 2, 3, 8a, 8b, 8e,
10 ad 12, who asserted that the suit is barred by the law of limitation,
2026:JHHC:2280
the suit is not maintainable in its present form and the suit is bad for
non-joinder of necessary parties. The defendants had further asserted
that the plaintiffs 2nd set never possessed the property in suit, nor
acquired any right, title, interest and possession over the same.
14.
It was asserted that the property was possessed by Golam
Mahato and the property was sold in auction. Dhananjoy Mahato
purchased the property in auction in Rent Decree Execution Case
No.1157 of 1919/20 and obtained Sale Certificate from the Deputy
Collector, Puruliya on 30.07.1920 and thereafter, Golam Mahato
and/or his descendants ceased to have any right, title, interest and
possession over any portion of the properties. The sale was effected
immediately preceding the C.S. Operation and accordingly, the entries
in the C.S. Record of Right with respect to C.S. Khatian No.261 and
262, the properties sold in auction, were erroneously prepared in the
names of the descendants of Golam Mahato. Subsequently, the record
was duly prepared in the name of the auction purchaser Dhananjoy
Mahato and his brothers and they were in possession of the properties.
It was asserted that after acquiring the property through auction sale,
Dhananjoy Mahato and his brothers transferred the property in favour
of the predecessors-in-interest of the defendants by registered Sale
Deed dated 20.05.1932.
15.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the learned trial
court framed the following issues:
1. Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form?
2. Whether the plaintiff has got valid cause of action to bring
this suit?
3. Whether the suit is barred by limitation and principle of
waiver, estoppel and acquiescence?
4. Whether the suit is barred by principles of sub- judicata?
5. Whether the defendants and their predecessor have acquired
valid right, title, interest and possession over the suit
property by virtue of Regd. Patta Dt. 20.05.1932?
6. Whether the plaintiff second set has valid right, title, over the
suit property on 25.06.90 and when they sold the same to
the plaintiff first set?
2026:JHHC:2280
16.
7. Whether the plaintiff first set acquired valid right, title and
possession over the suit property by virtue of sale deed dt.
25.07.90?
8. Whether the plaintiff are entitled for the relief or reliefs as
claimed in this suit?
The parties lead both oral and documentary evidences. The
point of limitation was taken by the learned trial court in Paragraph5.1 and the learned trial court by referring Article 59 of the Limitation
Act and by referring to the cause of action as pleaded in the plaint
ultimately held that the suit is barred by limitation. The findings of the
learned trial court is as follows:“Section 3 of the Limitation Act lays down that the plaintiffs
have taken a plea that the cause of action of the arose on
02.06.1990 and 12.06.1990 when they got the certified copy of
the deed No. 2117 dated 20.05.1932 and had sought
declaration for the right, title, interest and also to declare that
the sale deed is invalid and never been acted upon and also
for the decree of confirmation of the possession of the suit
land.
The plaintiffs plea is that the plaintiffs 2 nd set sold lands
from plot No. 261 and 262 to the plaintiffs 1st set vide sale
deed No. 7361 and 7362 dated 26.06.1990. The land sold was
1.60 acres out of 2.28 from Khata No. 261 and 1.02 acres
from 40 acres from 262 being 1/3rd share from 3.06 acres.
When the defendants came to know they tried to take forcible
possession of the lands. Plaintiffs No.11 went to the CO Office
and came to know that the lands have been sold by collusion
to the defendants other set. The defendants had obtained the
mutation for the land and hence the plaintiff Nos. 11 and 12
had filed appeal before the LRDC being mutation appeal no.
1/1991 against the mutation case no. 1(IX) 1991. In the
mutation appeared case the LRDC had made an observation
that since TS No. 15 of 1992 is pending between parties and
hence no finding were given. The LRDC after perusal of the
LCR had dismissed the appeal on 11.02.1991.
As per the pleadings of the plaintiffs, the plaintiffs came
to know about the sale of 1932 in the year 02.06.1990 and
12.06.1990.
In TS 15 of 1992 the plaintiffs filed suit against the
defendants and plaintiffs 2nd set were made proforma
defendants. In the TS 15 of 1992 the plaintiffs had prayed for
decree of declaration for the suit property. The suit was
2026:JHHC:2280
17.
dismissed for default on 13.04.1993. Thereafter, for the
restoration of the suit Misc Case No. 14 of 1993 was filed
which was dismissed for default on 06.09.1993. Thereafter, for
restoration of the same Misc Case No. 26 of 1993 was filed
and the same was again dismissed for default on 01.12.1998.
This suit was filed on 07.12.2001 exactly after 3 years 6 days,
even considering that Misc Case is a continuation of the suit.
The plaintiffs as relief has prayed that the documents of the
predecessors of the defendants are made up and are collusive
and hence the same is not binding upon the plaintiffs.
Article 59 of the Limitation Act clearly states that to
cancel to set aside an instrument the period of limitation is 3
years and the period of computation starts when the facts
entitling the plaintiff to have the instrument or decree
cancelled or set aside or the contact rescinded first become
known to him.
In the case of Mangra Dhobi and another v Khendua
Baraiuk and others AIR 2006 Jhar 16, in this case the apex
court had held that the suit filed beyond the three years from
the date of knowledge of sale deed was held barred by
limitation.
The defendants have taken the plea that the suit is
barred by principles of waiver, estoppel and acquiescence but
the defendants have not led any evidences in support of the
pleadings. Hence this part of issue is decided against the
defendants.”
Thereafter, the learned trial court took the issue regarding
legality and validity of registered sale deed dated 20.05.1932 and
observed as follows:“This issue as it appears is by way of counterclaim. Whenever
the defendants claim any relief by way of counterclaim and
not as a defence, then advoleram court fee is to be paid by the
defendants seeking relief on the same. In this case the
defendants have not paid any advoleram court fee and hence
this issue cannot be decided in this suit.”
18.
The learned trial court in Paragraph-5.3 considered the Issue
No. 6 and 7 together and recorded that the plaintiffs has failed to
prove their right, title and interest over the property and decided the
issues against the plaintiffs. The learned trial court recorded that from
the documentary evidences, it is clear that the plaintiffs did not have a
clear title over the property as the property was transferred to the
2026:JHHC:2280
defendants’ ancestors and was earlier conveyed back in the year 1932
which cannot be cancelled being absolutely barred by limitation. The
plaintiffs 2nd set did not have any interest over the suit land in the
year 1990 which they have conveyed to the plaintiffs 1st set. The
findings are recorded as under:-
19.
“5.3.............................................................................................
...........................Hence the documentary evidence it is clear
that the plaintiffs did not have a clear title, interest over the
property as the property had been transferred to the
defendants ancestors. Also as earlier the conveyance of 1932
cannot be cancelled being hopelessly barred by Limitation the
plaintiffs 2nd set did not have any interest even the suit land in
the year 1990 which they could have conveyed to the plaintiffs
1st set. The oral evidences of both parties are no aid to the
pleadings of the plaintiffs since all of them have denied the
sale of 1932 and P.W. 4 have denied T.S. 11 of 1992 against
him which was exhibited by the defendants as Exhibit-5.
Which shows P.W.4 as the defendants 3 in that case. They
have only supported the transfer of 1990 in favour of the
plaintiffs 1st set. Hence in my view the plaintiffs have failed to
prove their right, interest, title over the suit property by the
evidences led by them and hence these both issues are decided
against them.”
Thereafter, the learned trial court considered Issue No.4 with
regard to the point of res-judicata and the learned trial court held that
the suit is barred by the principles of res-judicata. The learned trial
court considered the Issue No.2 in Paragraph-5.6 of its judgment
which is quoted as under:“5.6 Coming to the next issue whether:
2. Whether the plaintiff has got valid cause of action to bring
this suit?
As already discussed the plaintiffs suit is barred by limitation.
Cause of action are those bundle of facts which the party
seeking relief as to prove before the court. The plaintiffs have
taken a plea that cause of action arose on 02.06.1990 and
12.06.1990 when they had obtained the cc of the sale deed No.
2117 dated 20.05.1932 and came to know about the earlier
sale. In spite having the knowledge regarding an earlier sale
the plaintiffs 2nd set had transferred the suit lands to the
plaintiffs 1st set vide registered sale deed No. 7361 and 7362
dated 25.07.1990. The transfer was done almost after 1 month
2026:JHHC:2280
when the transfer of 1932 coming known to the plaintiffs 2 nd
set. The plaintiffs have not challenged the auction sale or the
registered sale deed of 1932. Its only that they have prayed for
cancellation of the deed. Hence the act of the plaintiffs appear
that to be an attempt to get the deed of 1932 cancelled which
was barred by both res-judicata and limitation.”
20.
The learned trial court recorded that the plaintiffs have failed to
prove their pleadings by way of both documentary and oral evidences
and dismissed the suit.
21.
The learned 1st appellate court also considered the materials on
record and ultimately recorded findings against the plaintiffs and
dismissed the appeal.
22.
The learned 1st appellate court recorded that the suit was barred
by limitation and by the principle of res-judicata.
23.
This Court finds that both the courts have considered the
materials on record and have given concurrent findings. After auction
sale, the suit properties stood already transferred in favour of the
predecessors-in-interest of the defendants which was sold to the
ancestors of the defendants in the year 1932 and thereafter, the
recorded tenants had no surviving interest in the suit property. No
perversity in the matter of appreciation has been pointed out by the
learned counsel for the appellants.
24.
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this Court is
of the considered view that no question of law, much less any
substantial question of law is involved in this second appeal.
25.
This second appeal is accordingly dismissed.
26.
Pending interlocutory application, if any, is dismissed as not
pressed.
27.
Let a copy of this order be communicated to the concerned
courts through “Fax/e-mail”.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
29.01.2026
Rakesh/Uploaded on:-12th March, 2026.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review