Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 9355/2016
MAHESH NATH SINGH
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Kuriakose Varghese, Mr. Akshat
Gogna, Mr. C. Ruby Thomas,
Advocates.
versus
NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR SCHEDULED CASTES & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Shaurya Banshtu, Advocate for
Respondent No. 1, 3 & 4.
Ms. Ishita, Advocate for R-2.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
ORDER
10.02.2026
%
1.
This petition has been filed by the Petitioner, who belongs to the
Scheduled Caste (<SC=) category, assailing his non-selection pursuant to
advertisement dated 1st June, 2013 issued by Respondent No. 2, Indian
Statistical Institute (<ISI=), for filling reserved backlog vacancies under a
special recruitment drive for the post of Assistant Professor.
2.
The Petitioner contends that despite fulfilling the eligibility criteria
and being called for a seminar/presentation, his candidature was rejected
arbitrarily and on discriminatory considerations.
Background
3.
The Petitioner submitted his application/resume in June 2013. ISI
processed
the
application
through
its
Divisional
Committee.
W.P.(C) 9355/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/02/2026 at 11:10:49
By
communication dated 12th November, 2013, the Petitioner was invited to
deliver a seminar on 25th November, 2013. The said communication
recorded that ISI could not offer the post of Assistant Professor to a
candidate who had not completed three years after Ph.D., and that such
candidates would be considered for Lectureship, if found suitable.
4.
Thereafter, a Selection Committee was constituted by Office Order
dated 28th August, 2014 to consider, inter alia, the Petitioner’s candidature.
In its meeting held on 1st September, 2014, the Selection Committee did not
recommend the Petitioner. This decision was conveyed to the Petitioner
through a letter dated 12th January, 2016, which also referred to
developments concerning a subsequent recruitment drive advertised in
December 2014.
Contentions
5.
Mr. Kuriakose Varghese, counsel for the Petitioner, makes the
following submissions in support of the petition:
5.1.
The Petitioner belongs to the SC category, and he applied pursuant to
the advertisement dated 1st June, 2013 issued by ISI. He fulfilled the
advertised eligibility conditions, possessed a Ph.D. in the relevant discipline,
had a consistent academic record, and possessed post-doctoral research and
teaching experience. The CV filed with the petition, and the publications
listed therein, indicate that the Petitioner satisfied the prescribed threshold
and was entitled, at the very least, to be considered on merits in a fair and
transparent selection process. The advertisement itself contemplated
relaxation wherever applicable.
5.2.
Despite satisfying eligibility and being processed through successive
stages of evaluation, the Petitioner’s candidature was rejected without any
W.P.(C) 9355/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/02/2026 at 11:10:49
cogent basis and without any contemporaneous, reasoned communication.
The ISI, being an institution of national importance and <State= within the
meaning of Article 12, is obliged to conduct recruitment in a manner that is
transparent, non-arbitrary and consistent with Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution. Where an eligible reserved-category candidate is screened out
without disclosed reasons, the process becomes opaque and constitutionally
suspect and the authority must disclose the basis of exclusion.
5.3.
The Petitioner’s application was not rejected at the threshold. On the
contrary, he was called upon by the competent functionary to appear for a
seminar and presentation. The Institute thereby represented, at least
implicitly, that he had crossed the preliminary eligibility scrutiny. Having
subjected him to evaluation, ISI could not thereafter rely upon vague
assertions of non-recommendation without disclosing the basis. The process,
as applied to him, lacked procedural fairness as he was neither informed of
any deficiency in eligibility nor informed of any assessed shortcomings.
5.4.
The communication dated 12th January, 2016 records that a
Divisional Committee had recommended his CV for further processing and
that a Selection Committee later did not recommend him. The
communication itself is symptomatic of arbitrariness as it does not disclose
why he was found unsuitable, what criteria were applied, or whether the
reserved vacancy was filled. The record reflects internal inconsistencies in
the chronology and appears to have been retrofitted to justify an outcome
already decided. Further, the decision was never communicated for nearly
two years and was disclosed only during proceedings before NCSC.
5.5.
The Petitioner pursued the matter by way of representations and by
approaching the NCSC. ISI attempted to explain the subsequent standstill by
W.P.(C) 9355/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/02/2026 at 11:10:49
attributing it to an <embargo= imposed by the NCSC on recruitment and
promotions. However, the Commission’s stated position is that no such
embargo was ever imposed and the same was a convenient afterthought.
5.6.
On discrimination, the Petitioner was effectively excluded from
consideration and the reserved vacancy remained unfilled. The increase in
backlog between the 2013 and 2014 drives and continued vacancy shows
absence of genuine effort to fill reserved posts.
5.7.
The Petitioner met with hostile treatment in the way he was handled
in comparison to others. He was singled out on grounds extraneous to merit.
In that context, institutional preferences, including linguistic and regional
affinity, operated to his detriment and he was unfairly treated because he
does not belong to the local Bengali-speaking milieu. Even if such bias is
not apparent, the absence of disclosed reasons and the contradictory
justifications offered over time lend credibility to such apprehensions.
5.8.
Once the Petitioner was called to present and was processed through
the selection pipeline, he had a legitimate expectation that his candidature
would be evaluated on declared criteria and that the outcome would not be
arbitrary or inscrutable. The refusal to furnish any meaningful reasons for
his non-selection defeats transparency and makes it impossible to test the
fairness of the process.
5.9.
On relief, the decision is sought to be quashed insofar as it rejected his
candidature without cogent reasons, and a direction to ISI to reconsider his
candidature in accordance with the advertisement and constitutional norms.
In the alternative, appropriate directions are sought to fill the reserved
backlog vacancy through a lawful and transparent process, with due regard
to the mandate of equality of opportunity in public employment.
W.P.(C) 9355/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/02/2026 at 11:10:49
6.
Ms. Ishita, counsel for the ISI, opposes the petition and submits:
6.1.
The Petitioner was not eligible for appointment as Assistant Professor
under the 2013 advertisement because he did not meet the mandatory
requirement of three years’ post-doctoral research/teaching experience after
Ph.D. The same was communicated to the Petitioner at the threshold in the
letter dated 12th November, 2013, and he was considered only for
Lectureship, subject to suitability.
6.2.
The
Divisional
Committee
processed
the
application
and
recommended it for further consideration. A duly constituted Selection
Committee assessed suitability on academic merit including publications,
teaching experience and institutional requirements and did not recommend
him. The selection followed the governing recruitment rules and guidelines
applicable to ISI and cannot be termed arbitrary.
6.3.
Recruitment rules governing reserved category selection were
available and known to the Petitioner and were duly followed. Nonrecommendation represents an expert academic assessment and is not
subject to judicial re-evaluation absent proven mala fides.
Analysis
7.
The settled limits of judicial review in matters of academic
recruitment must be borne in mind. A writ court examines legality,
procedural fairness and adherence to the governing framework; it does not
sit in appeal over the expert assessment of suitability nor re-weigh the
relative merits of candidates. Interference is warranted only where the
process is vitiated by illegality, material procedural irregularity, or mala
W.P.(C) 9355/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/02/2026 at 11:10:49
fides.1 Further, even a candidate who has participated in the selection
process, or whose candidature has been considered, does not acquire an
indefeasible right to appointment merely because vacancies exist or he was
found fit to be considered; a recruitment notification is only an invitation to
apply and the employer is not bound to fill all notified vacancies, though its
decision must be bona fide and non-arbitrary.2
8.
The Petitioner’s central premise that he was eligible for appointment
as Assistant Professor under the 2013 advertisement is not borne out from
the material on record. The letter dated 12th November, 2013 expressly
recorded that ISI could not offer the post of Assistant Professor to
candidates who had not completed three years after Ph.D., and that
Lectureship would instead be considered if found suitable. The Petitioner
participated in the process with this position clearly communicated to him.
In these circumstances, he cannot assert an enforceable right to be
considered for appointment as Assistant Professor, much less a right to
appointment.
9.
The Petitioner’s attempt to characterise his non-selection as a
rejection without reasons also does not carry the matter further. Nonrecommendation by a Selection Committee in an academic recruitment,
where suitability is assessed holistically, does not ordinarily require the
employer to furnish comparative reasons to an unsuccessful candidate in the
manner of a quasi-judicial order. In the absence of a statutory rule
mandating disclosure of detailed reasons or marks, a writ court does not
compel a selection body to justify its expert assessment unless the record
Dalpat Abasaheb Solunke & Ors. v. Dr. B.S. Mahajan & Ors. (1990) 1 SCC 305.
See: Shankarsan Dash v. Union of India. (19910 3 SCC 47.
W.P.(C) 9355/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/02/2026 at 11:10:49
discloses demonstrable arbitrariness, bias or procedural illegality. The delay
in communicating the outcome, by itself, does not establish arbitrariness
once the decision is shown to have been taken by the competent expert
body.
10.
The allegations of discrimination are, in substance, unsupported by
material particulars. The plea that the Petitioner was excluded because he is
from Uttar Pradesh or because he is not Bengali-speaking is not supported
by contemporaneous material or any identifiable act attributable to the
Selection Committee. The law requires pleadings of mala fides and bias to
be specific and substantiated, not conjectural. Courts do not infer
discrimination in public employment based on suspicion or perception.
11.
The Petitioner’s reliance on the NCSC’s stand that it did not impose
an <embargo= also does not advance the core claim for appointment. Even
assuming that ISI’s reference to an <embargo= was misplaced, that
circumstance does not convert the Petitioner’s non-recommendation by the
Selection Committee into a constitutional wrong warranting a writ of
mandamus for appointment. At the highest, it reflects a controversy relating
to subsequent administrative developments and does not establish that the
Petitioner was unlawfully denied selection in the 2013 process.
12.
The plea of legitimate expectation is equally unavailing. The act of
calling a candidate for a seminar/presentation or processing a candidature
through internal committees creates an expectation of fair consideration in
accordance with the declared procedure; it does not create a right to
selection or appointment, particularly where the employer had expressly
indicated non-eligibility on an essential criterion.
13.
The Petitioner has also urged that backlog vacancies have remained
W.P.(C) 9355/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/02/2026 at 11:10:49
unfilled. Filling reserved backlog vacancies is undoubtedly a constitutional
obligation to be pursued with seriousness. At the same time, the existence of
vacancies does not confer a right to appointment, nor can a mandamus be
issued directing appointment of a particular candidate who does not
establish an enforceable legal right. The remedy, if at all, lies in ensuring
that recruitment is carried out lawfully and expeditiously, not in directing
appointment contrary to the recruitment norms and suitability assessment.
14.
In sum, the Petitioner has not demonstrated that the selection process
was vitiated by illegality, material procedural irregularity, mala fides or
arbitrariness warranting judicial interference. The writ jurisdiction under
Article 226 cannot be invoked to convert dissatisfaction with a nonrecommendation into a merits appeal over academic suitability.
15.
For the foregoing reasons, the writ petition is dismissed. Pending
applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
FEBRUARY 10, 2026/ab
W.P.(C) 9355/2016
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/02/2026 at 11:10:49
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review