Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL MISC. APPLICATION (FOR QUASHING & SET
ASIDE FIR/ORDER) NO. 6539 of 2015
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. M. RAVAL
================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
√
================================================
MAHENDRABHAI CHANDUBHAI PATEL & ANR.
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT & ORS.
================================================
Appearance:
MR RR MARSHALL, SR ADVOCATE with ADITYA R
PARIKH(8769) for the Applicant(s) No. 1,2
MR VIRAT G POPAT(3710) for the Respondent(s) No. 3
MR KM ANTANI, APP for the Respondent(s) No. 1,2
================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. M. RAVAL
Date : 28/09/2026
ORAL JUDGMENT
1.
Invoking jurisdiction of this Court under Section 482 of
Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (the Code) by this application, the
applicants have prayed to quash the FIR being C.R. No. I-158 of
2012, dated 09.10.2012, lodged before Olpad Police Station, Dist.:
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
Surat (Rural) for the offences punishable under Sections 465, 467,
468, 471, and 114 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC).
2.
The prosecution case, as narrated in the FIR, is that
complainant’s father namely Kalidas Laljibhai Patel's mother,
Dahiben Laljibhai Patel held ancestral land at Village Sosank,
Taluka: Olpad.
Dahiben's father, Vallabhbhai Hansjibhai, had
three children: 1) Jagjivan Vallabh, 2) Lallu Vallabh, and 3)
Dahiben Vallabh. That, Dahiben, received Block No. 72, located at
Sosank Village as a tenant share (Ganot hak) from her elder
brother Jagjivanbhai. By Revenue Entry No. 468 in 1957, Dahiben
Vallabh Hansji’s name was entered as a protected tenant.
Subsequently, via Revenue Entry No. 495 dated 30.09.1959, the
land of Block No. 72, Village: Sesak, Taluka: Olpad, District Surat,
was transferred to Dahiben Vallabh Hansji’s name as a new tenure
land (Navi Sharat). Since then, possession remained with her.
Dahiben
passed
away
while
residing
with
the
original
complainant at Adajan, Surat. In the land bearing Block No. 72
which was belonging to Dahiben, which remained under her
lawful possession, one Mahendrabhai Chandubhai Patel and his
wife
Sulochanaben
Mahendrabhai
Patel
created
a
forged
panchnama. In it, they falsely represented Dahiben and Kamuben
as the two daughters of Vallabh Hansji, falsely claimed
Sulochanaben
to
be
Kamuben's
daughter,
and
entered
Sulochanaben's name as a co-owner/niece (bhanej) via Revenue
Entry No. 1152 dated 19.01.1987. It is stated that the claim in that
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
forged panchnama that Kamuben was Dahiben’s sister is
completely false as in fact, Kamuben was the daughter of
Dahiben's brother, Jagjivanbhai Vallabhbhai and thus, Dahiben
would be her paternal aunt, Foi-Bhatriji. It is furtehr alleged that
the panchnama falsely showed Kamuben as deceased at that time,
whereas she actually passed away in the year 2005. It is also
alleged that Sulochanaben is not Kamuben's daughter, which is
supported by a Pedigree (Pedhinama) and the Death Certificate of
Kamuben, both of which were attested by Mahendra Chandubhai
Patel himself as a witness, and produced with the FIR in question.
Furthermore, when Jagjivan Vallabhbhai Patel died on 27.11.1983,
his heirship entry was entered into Block Nos. 90 and 125 of
Sosank Village via Revenue Entry No. 1356, showing Kamuben as
his only legal heir by preparing a Pedigree (Pedhinama) and the
same was also signed by Mahendra Chandubhai Patel as a
witness. Thus, Mahendrabhai was fully aware that Kamuben was
Jagjivanbhai's daughter and not Dahiben's sister. Despite such
knowledge, he forged documents showing Kamuben as Dahiben’s
sister and his wife Sulochanaben as Kamuben's daughter to
unlawfully insert his wife's name into the revenue records of Block
No. 72.
Subsequently, a Revenue Entry No. 1277 came to be
posted to delete the name of Dahiben as she died on 13.08.1988
without direct descendants (nirvansh), on the basis of the Death
Certificate,
panchnamas.
Panchnama
and
recording
statements,
and
This was allegedly orchestrated solely so that
Sulochanaben Mahendrabhai Patel, entered via Entry No. 1152,
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
would emerge as the sole surviving owner on record. This entry is
fraudulent as Dahiben's direct lineal descendants viz. the father of
the de facto complainant and his sisters, and their families, are very
much alive. Consequently, the de facto complainant challenged
that fraudulent transfer before the District Collector, Surat by Suo
Motu Revision Application No. 22 of 2011. Upon hearing the
matter, the District Collector cancelled Entry No. 1152 dated
19.01.1987 and ordered the entry of the genuine direct legal heirs
of Dahiben Vallabh onto Block No. 72. The said order is also
submitted with the FIR. Sulochanaben Mahendrabhai Patel
appealed
to
the
Special
Secretary,
Revenue
Department,
Ahmedabad, seeking an interim stay against the District
Collector's order, but her stay application was rejected, copy of
which was also enclosed. Thus, Mahendrabhai Chandubhai Patel
and Sulochanaben Mahendrabhai Patel fabricated false Pedigrees
and forged panchnamas, falsely claiming Sulochanaben to be a
niece of Dahiben, falsely declared Dahiben as having died
issueless, and illegally usurped Block No. 72, thereby cheating the
rightful heirs out of their lawful property, for which the FIR in
question came to be filed.
3.
Heard, learned senior advocate Mr. R. R. Marshall appearing
with learned advocate Mr. Aditya Parikh for the applicants,
learned Additional Public Prosecutor Mr. K. M. Antani for the
respondent No. 1 – State and learned advocate Mr. Virat Popat for
the respondent No. 3 - de facto complainant, at length.
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
3.1
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
The bone contention of the learned senior advocate for the
applicants is two fold: firstly, he vehemently argued that the FIR in
question suffers from exorbitant delay inasmuch as, for the
revenue entry, which was carried out in the year 1987, to be
precise, Revenue Entry No. 1152 dated 19.01.1987, whereby, the
name of the applicant No. 2 came to be mutated in the revenue
record with respect to the land bearing Block No. 72 situated at
Village: Sosank, Taluka: Olpad, District: Surat; and secondly, the
dispute is purely of civil nature for which criminal machinery is
motioned after so many years and thus, he has argued that only on
these grounds, the FIR in question requires to be quashed.
3.2
It is submitted the even otherwise the ingredients of the
offence alleged against the present applicants are not at all
satisfied inasmuch as, the applicants are in continuous possession
of the land in question by virtue of the Revenue Entry in their
favour.
3.3
It is submitted that after about 24 years, the District
Collector, issued a show-cause notice with respect to the Entry No.
1152 dated 19.01.1987 in suo motu revision proceedings, which was
duly resisted by the applicants.
However, vide order dated
14.09.2011 cancelled such entry, which was challenged before the
Secretary (Appeals) being Revision Application No. 201 of 2011,
wherein, stay was also sought of the order dated 14.09.2011, who
refused to extend stay pending revision by an order dated
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
01.05.2012. The said order came to be challenged before this Court
by way filed Special Civil Application No. 8318 of 2012 wherein,
notice came to be issued and interim stay came to be granted.
However, it is submitted that the Deputy Mamlatdar, in violation
of the order passed by this Court, certified the mutation entry in
favour of the de facto complainant and therefore, a Civil
Application No. 6660 of 2013 was filed challenging the said
mutation entry, wherein, by an order dated 13.08.2013, this Court
set aside the certification of mutation entry in favour of the de facto
complainant.
3.4
It is submitted that the applicant No. 2 has also filed a Special
Civil Suit No. 434 of 2011 before the competent Civil Court at Surat
for declaration and permanent injunction.
3.5
The learned senior advocate for the applicants would submit
that the de facto complainant has kept conspicuous silence over the
fact of execution of a Consent Deed dated 17.01.1987 of Dahiben,
his grandmother and thus, present FIR is nothing but an attempt
to procure more money by using pressure tactic.
3.6
It is submitted that none of the heirs except the present
respondent No. 3 - de facto complainant has come forward to
challenge the entry in question and/or has taken any objection and
that too, after so many years, and accordingly, making such
submissions, he submitted that civil dispute has been given
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
criminal colour and accordingly, when civil suit is already filed, it
is urged that present FIR and the consequential proceedings qua
the applicants may be quashed and set aside as no prima facie case
is made out against the present applicants.
3.7
In support, the learned senior advocate for the applicants has
relied upon following decisions of the coordinate Bench of this
Court in: i) Vasudevbhai Kedarmal Agrawal amd 3 Others v. State
of Gujarat and Another, 2017 SCC OnLine Guj 2706, and ii)
Madhavbhai Babubhai Matiya v. State of Gujarat and Others,
2019 SCC OnLine Guj 3337.
4.
Conversely, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the
State as well as the learned advocate for the respondent No. 3 - de
facto complainant, at the very outset, would submit that earlier the
applicants had preferred a quashing application being Criminal
Misc. Application No. 15732 of 2012 for quashment of the present
FIR only, which came to be withdrawn vide order dated 30.01.2013
with a view to pursue the remedy before the trial Court.
Accordingly, this application, which is filed with the same prayer,
is not maintainable under the law and accordingly, it is requested
that this Court may not entertain this second application.
4.1
Nonetheless, while opposing this application on merits, the
learned advocates for the respondents would submit that the
applicants cannot simply shirk from their criminal liability only by
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
saying that it is a civil wrong inasmuch as, by showing false
relationship viz. Kamuben, who is the daughter of the brother of
Dahiben (grandmother of the de facto complainant) was shown as
the sister and thereby, preparing false Pedigree and the
Panchnama in which, said Kamuben was shown as ‘deceased’,
Entry of the year 1987 came to be recorded and though, said
Kamuben died in the year 2005 only (on 22.09.2005), meaning
thereby, she was very much alive at the time of execution of the
Consent Deed, directly, the name of present applicant No. 2 came
to be mutated in the revenue record and accordingly, a clear case
of cheating and forgery having been made out, the matter requires
test of trial Court.
4.2
It is submitted that the documents themselves speak for
themselves inasmuch as, on one side, in the year 1987, the
applicants show Dahiben as having no progeny and Kamuben as
her sister and present applicant No. 2 as her daughter in the
Pedigree, however, in the suit filed by the applicant No. 2, she
produces another Pedigree, which shows that Kamuben had no
daughter namely Sulochanaben i.e. the present applicant No. 2. It
is further on record that Dahiben had three children i.e. two
daughters namely Jayantiben Lalbhai Patel and Divaliben Lalbhai
Patel and one son namely Kalidasbhai Lalbhai Patel who is the
father of the de facto complainant. Thus, they would submit that a
clear case is made out as alleged in the FIR.
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
4.3
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
It is submitted that during the investigation, statements of
various witnesses, have been recorded, a perusal of which reveal
that clear case, as alleged in the FIR, is made out against the
present applicants as witnesses have supported the case of the
prosecution and thus also, the matter requires full-fledged trial.
4.4
The learned advocates for the respective respondents would
submit that District Collector, by an order dated 14.09.2011
cancelled the said entry of 1987, and thereafter, in appeal, the
Secretary (Appeals) has declined to extend stay vide order dated
01.05.2012 and it is only after moving this Court, the Court granted
interim stay, however, the said fact cannot brush aside the crime
that is committed by the applicants.
4.5
Inviting the attention of the Court to the plaint of Special
Civil Suit No. 434 of 2011 filed by the present applicant No. 2, the
learned advocates would submit that the applicant No. 2 herself
has admitted the fact of grabbing the land in question prior to
about two years of the land was mutated in her name on
19.01.1987 and taking possession and cultivating the land.
4.6
So far as delay is concerned, it is submitted that is for the
first time upon suo motu revenue proceedings came to be initiated,
the de facto complainant complainant immediately swung into
action and filed the FIR in question and thus, it cannot be said that
there is exorbitant delay and thereby, the proceedings cannot be
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
quashed merely on that ground when prima facie case is made out.
4.7
It is submitted that the fact of false documents itself proves
mala fide intention and ulterior motive of the applicants and in the
circumstances, it cannot be said that this is a civil dispute being
given a criminal colour and they submit that the matter needs a
thorough test of trial so as to churn out the truth.
4.8
The learned advocate for the de facto complainant would
submit that the applicants have not approached the Court with
clean hands and thereby, misguided the Court.
5.
The learned Additional Public Prosecutor as well as the
learned advocate for the de facto complainant would further submit
that as per the settled law of the land, inherent powers under
Section 482 of the Code should be used sparingly and with a view
to curb the abuse of process of law. It is submitted that in the case
on hand, a prima facie case is made out against the applicants and
hence, they requested that it is ultimately a matter of trial after
which, the truth could be churned out and hence, these
applications may not be entertained and they urged to be
dismissed.
6.
Heard and considered the submissions advanced by learned
advocates for the parties and carefully gone through the material
placed on record as well as the papers of investigation.
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
7.
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
Prior to assessing the factual matrix on the touchstone of
criminal jurisprudence, it is apposite to reinforce the settled legal
position governing the scope, ambit, and limits of the inherent
jurisdiction vested under Section 482 of the Code. The
jurisprudential
parameters
regulating
the
exercise
of
this
extraordinary power have been authoritatively catalogued by
Hon’ble Supreme Court in a long line of precedents, chief among
them being the authoritative in the case of State of Haryana v.
Bhajan Lal [AIR 1992 SC 604]. Therein, Hon’ble Supreme Court
crystallized seven distinct, illustrative categories of cases where
judicial intervention under Section 482 of the Code or Article 226
of the Constitution is necessitated to secure the ends of justice and
clip any abuse of the process of Court. The relevant portion of
Paragraph 102 of the said judgment is extracted below:
“102. In the backdrop of the interpretation of the various relevant
provisions of the Code under Chapter XIV and of the principles of
law enunciated by this Court in a series of decisions relating to the
exercise of the extraordinary power under Article 226 or the
inherent powers under Section 482 of the Code which we have
extracted and reproduced above, we have given the following
categories of cases by way of illustration wherein such power could
be exercised either to prevent abuse of the process of any court or
otherwise to secure the ends of justice, though it may not be
possible to lay down any precise, clearly defined and sufficiently
channelised and inflexible guidelines or rigid formulae and to give
an exhaustive list of myriad kinds of cases wherein such power
should be exercised.
(1) Where the allegations made in the first information
report or the complaint, even if they are taken at their face
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
value and accepted in their entirety do not prima facie
constitute any offence or make out a case against the
accused.
(2) Where the allegations in the first information report
and other materials, if any, accompanying the FIR do not
disclose a cognizable offence, justifying an investigation by
police officers under Section 156(1) of the Code except under
an order of a Magistrate within the purview of Section
155(2) of the Code.
(3) Where the uncontroverted allegations made in the FIR
or complaint and the evidence collected in support of the
same do not disclose the commission of any offence and make
out a case against the accused.
(4) Where, the allegations in the FIR do not constitute a
cognizable offence but constitute only a non-cognizable
offence, no investigation is permitted by a police officer
without an order of a Magistrate as contemplated under
Section 155(2) of the Code.
(5) Where the allegations made in the FIR or complaint
are so absurd and inherently improbable on the basis of
which no prudent person can ever reach a just conclusion
that there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the
accused.
(6) Where there is an express legal bar engrafted in any of
the provisions of the Code or the concerned Act (under which
a criminal proceeding is instituted) to the institution and
continuance of the proceedings and/or where there is a
specific provision in the Code or the concerned Act,
providing efficacious redress for the grievance of the
aggrieved party.
(7) Where a criminal proceeding is manifestly attended
with mala fide and/or where the proceeding is maliciously
instituted with an ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance on
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
the accused and with a view to spite him due to private and
personal grudge.”
7.1
Evaluating the present applications on the anvil of the
principles enunciated in Bhajan Lal (supra), this Court has to
determine whether the allegations in the FIR, even when accepted
at face value, satisfy the essential statutory ingredients of Sections
465, 467, 468, 471, and 114 of the IPC. This Court must ensure that
criminal machinery is not permitted to degenerate into an engine
of harassment where liability under criminal law is completely
absent.
The FIR reveals that the accused created false and
fabricated documents viz. Pedigree and Panchnama and thereby,
mutated the land in question in the name of the present applicant
No. 2.
7.2
To understand when these Sections (465, 467, 468, 471) of the
IPC are legally attracted, the prosecution must satisfy specific,
distinct components known as essential ingredients. Here is the
structured breakdown of the necessary ingredients for each section
as mentioned in the FIR:
7.2.1 Section 465: Punishment for Forgery:
This is the basic
offense of making a false document as defined under Sections 463
and 464. The ingredients are: i) creation of a false document or
false electronic record (or part of one), and ii) intent must be to
cause damage/injury to the public or any person, support a false
claim/title, cause anyone to part with property, or commit fraud.
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
7.2.2 Section 467: Forgery of Valuable Security, Will, etc.: This is a
severe, highly punishable form of forgery due to the nature of the
document involved.
The ingredients are: i) elements of basic
forgery (Section 465) must be present; and ii) forged document
must explicitly purports to be a valuable security, a will, an
authority to adopt, or a document giving authority to receive
money, principal, interest, or goods (e.g., forging a land Sale Deed
or a bank cheque).
7.2.3 Section 468: Forgery for Purpose of Cheating:
The
ingredients are: i) accused committed forgery, and ii) accused did
so with the specific intent that the forged document would be used
to cheat someone. However, the actual cheating does not need to
be completed; the mere act of creating the fake document with the
intent to cheat attracts this section.
7.2.4 Section 471: Using as Genuine a Forged Document: This
section punishes the use of the fake document rather than its
creation. The ingredient are: i) fraudulent or dishonest use of a
document as genuine, and ii) the accused must have knowledge or
a definitive reason to believe that the document was actually
forged. It is attracted, if one knowingly hands a fake land entry or
certificate to a government officer to claim an advantage, it
triggers Section 471.
7.3
In the backdrop aforesaid, it is clear that to invoke the
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
aforesaid sections, ingredients of forgery are required to be
satisfied. Accordingly, if the definition of Forgery, as provided in
Section 463 of the IPC is seen, it states:
“463. Forgery.—Whoever makes any false document or false
electronic record or part of a document or electronic record, with
intent to cause damage or injury, to the public or to any person, or
to support any claim or title, or to cause any person to part with
property, or to enter into any express or implied contract, or with
intent to commit fraud or that fraud may be committed, commits
forgery.”
7.4.
Since Section 464 of the IPC co-relates, the same is also
extracted hereunder:
“464. Making a false document.—A person is said to make a false
document or false electronic record—
First.—Who dishonestly or fraudulently—
(a) makes, signs, seals or executes a document or part of a
document;
(b) makes or transmits any electronic record or part of any
electronic record;
(c)
affixes any electronic signature on any electronic record;
(d) makes any mark denoting the execution of a document or the
authenticity of the electronic signature, with the intention of
causing it to be believed that such document or part of
document, electronic record or electronic signature was made,
signed, sealed, executed, transmitted or affixed by or by the
authority of a person by whom or by whose authority he
knows that it was not made, singed, sealed, executed or affixed;
or
Secondly.—Who
without
lawful
authority,
dishonestly
or
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
fraudulently, by cancellation or otherwise, alters a document or an
electronic record in any material part thereof, after it has been
made, executed or affixed with electronic signature either by
himself or by any other person, whether such person be living or
dead at the time of such alteration; or
Thirdly.—Who dishonestly or fraudulently causes any person to
sign, seal, execute or alter a document or an electronic record or to
affix his electronic signature on any electronic record knowing that
such person by reason of unsoundness of mind or intoxication
cannot, or that by reason of deception practised upon him, he does
not know the contents of the document or electronic record or the
nature of the alteration.”
7.5
It is well settled that a person does not commit forgery
merely by executing a document asserting ownership or a right
over a property, even if such claim is legally incorrect, disputed or
ultimately found to be unsustainable. What is required is that the
execution of the document itself must be fraudulent or dishonest.
To constitute forgery, a person must dishonestly or fraudulently
make, sign or execute a false document with the intention of
causing it to be believed that the document was made, signed or
executed by another person or under the authority of another
person. A person signing a document in his own name, even while
asserting an incorrect claim, does not thereby create a false
document so as to attract the offence of forgery;
7.6
In the decision in Sheila Sebastian v. R. Jawaharaj and
Another etc., (2018) 7 SCC 581, more particularly, in paragraph 26
the Apex Court Court held:
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
“26. The definition of “false document” is a part of the
definition of “forgery”. Both must be read together. ‘Forgery’
and ‘Fraud’ are essentially matters of evidence which could
be proved as a fact by direct evidence or by inferences drawn
from proved facts. In the case in hand, there is no finding
recorded by the trial Court that the respondents have made any
false document or part of the document/record to execute mortgage
deed under the guise of that ‘false document’. Hence, neither
respondent No.1 nor respondent No.2 can be held as makers of the
forged documents. It is the imposter who can be said to have made
the false document by committing forgery. In such an event the
trial Court as well as appellate Court misguided themselves by
convicting the accused. Therefore, the High Court has rightly
acquitted the accused based on the settled legal position and we
find no reason to interfere with the same.”
7.7
In Mohd. Ibrahim v. State of Bihar, reported in (2009) 8 SCC
751, the Court held that, where a person executes a document
claiming a property as his own, though such claim may ultimately
be found to be incorrect, he is neither claiming to be someone else
nor claiming to be authorized by another person. Therefore,
execution of such a document, purporting to convey a property of
which he is not the owner, does not amount to execution of a false
document within the meaning of Section 464 IPC. If what is
executed is not a false document, there is no forgery. If there is no
forgery, the provisions of Sections 467 and 471 of the IPC would
also not be attracted.
8.
In the aforesaid backdrop, when the factual matrix of the
case is tested against the established legal principles, the following
aspects weigh decisively with this Court:
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
i)
the
applicant
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
No.
prepared
a
false
Panchnama
incorporating a fabricated Pedigree of late Dahiben, the
grandmother of the de facto complainant;
ii)
in the said Panchnama and Pedigree, late Vallabhbhai
Hansjibhai was falsely depicted as having had only two daughters,
namely Dahiben and Kamuben;
iii)
in reality, Dahiben had three direct lineal descendants and
Kamuben was not amongst them, establishing that Kamuben was
deliberately and falsely projected as an heir of Dahiben;
iv)
the Panchnama and Pedigree were attested by applicant No.
1 as a subscribing witness, despite his full knowledge that Dahiben
had no daughter named Kamuben;
v)
on the strength of the said fabricated Panchnama and
Pedigree, Revenue Entry No. 1152 dated 19.01.1987 was mutated
in the revenue records in favor of Sulochanaben, who was falsely
portrayed as the daughter of Kamuben;
vi)
in point of fact, Kamuben was the daughter of Dahiben’s real
brother, Jagjivanbhai. Furthermore, the documentary record
reveals that Kamuben had no daughter named Sulochanaben, in
whose favor the subject land was mutated under the aforesaid
entry;
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
vii)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
the disputed mutation entry, depicting Kamuben as
Dahiben’s sister and Sulochanaben as Dahiben’s niece (daughter of
Kamuben), was effected in 1987 during the lifetime of Kamuben,
who actually passed away much later, on 22.09.2005;
viii) indisputably, Sulochanaben (applicant No. 2), in whose
favor the land was mutated in 1987, is the lawful wife of applicant
No. 1 (Mahendrabhai Chandubhai Patel);
ix)
the record further establishes that neither applicant No. 2
nor her husband (applicant No. 1) bear any blood relation to
Dahiben. Thus, the Pedigree set out in the Panchnama prepared by
applicant No. 1 is entirely fictitious, compounded by the false
declaration that Kamuben was deceased in 1987 (when she
survived until 22.09.2005) and showing applicant No. 2 as her
daughter;
x)
the material collected during investigation indicates that a
stamp paper of Rs. 10/- was procured to execute the alleged
Consent Deed of Dahiben. This was done despite the presence of
Dahiben's living direct lineal descendants, aiming to transfer the
land to Applicant No. 2 based on a fabricated pedigree that falsely
designated Kamuben as Dahiben’s sister and Applicant No. 2 as
Kamuben’s daughter;
xi)
the material on record prima facie demonstrates that
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
applicant No. 2 was set up as the sole beneficiary of the subject
property through these fabricated familial links, despite possessing
no lawful blood relationship or right of inheritance over Dahiben’s
estate;
xii)
the de facto complainant has further alleged that the
applicants have adopted a similar modus operandi to unlawfully
acquire other land parcels as well;
xiii) while this Court is mindful not to conduct a mini-trial at the
stage of considering a quashing application, a perusal of the
investigation papers reveals that statements of independent
witnesses—including subscribing witnesses to the Consent Deed,
Panchnama, and Pedigree—have been recorded. These witnesses
explicitly state that they executed the documents at the instance of
applicant No. 1, thereby prima facie substantiating the
prosecution’s version;
xiv) the alleged Consent Deed dated 17.01.1987 bears only the
thumb impression of Dahiben, establishing that she was illiterate
and incapable of reading or writing, and thus prima facie unaware
of the contents and import of the instrument. The said Consent
Deed recites that applicant No. 2 (Sulochanaben) is her sister’s
daughter and entitled to a share in Block No. 72.
In reality,
Dahiben had no such sister, applicant No. 2 was not her niece and
Dahiben’s own living direct descendants were bypassed. Because,
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
Dahiben was illeterate and deceived into thumb-impressioning a
documents containing false recitals, the Deed purports to be an
authorized disposition of rights by a real person who never
authorized those contents. This directly attracts Section 464 IPC
(Clauses Firstly and Thirdly);
xv)
the Panchnama invented a fictitious sisterly relationship
between Dahiben and Kamuben and falsely positioned applicant
No. 2 as Kamuben’s daughter (Dahiben’s niece) to engineer a nonexistent right of inheritance. The Panchnama declared Kamuben
as deceased in 1987 to facilitate the immediate mutation of
Revenue Entry No. 1152, whereas, official records establish that
Kamuben survived until 22.09.2005. Falsely depicting a living
person as dead in a legal Pedigree to substitute them with a fake
heir constitutes creating a false document in the name
of/pertaining to a fictitious legal entity under Explanation 2 to
Section 464 IPC;
xvi) regarding the argument on delay, while an unexplained
delay in registering an FIR may be adverse to the prosecution, a
plausible explanation on record negates such an objection. In the
present case, the de facto complainant was unaware of the
fraudulent mutation effected in applicant No. 2’s favor through
fabricated records. Immediately upon discovering the fraud during
the suo motu revenue proceedings in 2011, the complainant lodged
the FIR. Consequently, the authorities cited by the applicants offer
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
them no assistance;
xvii) Section 463 IPC defines 'Forgery' as the making of a false
document with intent to cause damage or injury, support a claim
or title, or commit fraud, with the creation of a 'false document'
under Section 464 IPC being its foundational prerequisite. The
applicants did not merely execute a deed asserting an unfounded
claim of ownership in their own right. Rather, they actively
fabricated a Pedigree (Pedhinama) and Panchnama, falsified a
living person’s legal timeline by projecting Kamuben as dead in
1987 when she survived until 2005, and created fictitious family
relationships. Falsifying Pedigree to create non-existent legal
entities and identities constitutes the making of a false document
under Section 464 IPC, placing the act at the very core of forgery;
xviii) It is also pertinent to note that a previous application seeking
quashment of the impugned FIR (Criminal Misc. Application No.
15732 of 2012) was unconditionally withdrawn by the applicants
on 30.01.2013 to pursue remedies before the trial Court. A
successive petition under Section 482 of the Code without any
change in circumstances is impermissible.
8.1
From the above, it appears that there is ample material
demonstrating criminality involved in the case on hand, attracting
provisions of 465, 467, 468, 471, and 114 of the IPC, and hence, the
case on hand does not fall into any of the parameters as laid down
R/CR.MA/6539/2015(GJHC240502992015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 28/09/2026
in the case of Bhajan Lal (supra).
9.
In view of aforesaid discussion, this application fails and is
hereby dismissed. Rule is discharged. Interim relief is vacated,
forthwith.
9.1
It goes without saying that above observations are made for
deciding the present application only, which shall have no bearing
on any other litigation between the parties and the same shall be
decided on its own merits.
[ P. M. Raval, J. ]
Further Order:
After the above judgment and order is passed, learned senior
advocate for the applicants requests to extend the interim relief
which was granted earlier so as to enable the applicants to move
the Apex Court challenging the aforesaid judgment and order.
Considering the fact that the FIR is of 2012 and this matter is
of 2015 wherein, stay was granted on 15.04.2015 which is operative
till date, in the interest of justice, as the applicants want to move
the Apex Court against the present judgment and order, the
request is acceded to.
Accordingly, the interim relief granted
earlier to continue for a period of 08 (eight) weeks from today.
[ P. M. Raval, J. ]
hiren/3tss28926+
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review