Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3300 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY,THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND N/VENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO: 28982 OF 2025
Between:
Mahanandhi Builders, A Proprietary Concern, Rep, by its_.Proprietor,..Eppa
Suwarana, D/o. Eppa.Ramulu, havlng its Office at H.No.9-153V' Gayatri Nagar,
Meerpet, Saroornagar, Ranga ReddY.
...PETITIONER
AND
Telangana Rajiv Swagruha Corporation Limite-4-[Rsqf )'. Rgp, 9y^ its Vice
Chairiran and Managlng Directbr, Having its Office at H-No.3-6-184, 1st
Floor, TGHCL Building,Etreet No.17, Himayathnagar, Hyderabad.
Managi ng Director and Vice Ch airm a n,- Te] qn gqll.Raj iv-Slyggfula.. ..
CorpoTation Limited (TRSCL), H No 3-6-184. 1St Floor. TGHCL Building,
Street No.1 7, Himayathnagar, Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
ciriumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, Order or direction, preferably a Writ in the nature of Writ of
Mandamus declaring a) the proceeding of the first Respondent in Lr. No
04/TGRSCLIEM/A02 Unfinished Towers/PCHRM/2023, Dated 21-01-2025
cahcelling the allotment of A02 Tower by forfeiting the token advance and first
installments of Rs.3,O5,1O,OOO/- as illegal, null, void and arbitrary- b) to cancel the
proposal to sell the semi finished flats in tower A02 in Sadbhavana Township,
Pocharam Municipality, Ghatkesar, Medchal Malkajgiri District which was
published in the brochure Dated 10-09-2025. c) and consequentially direct the
respondents to renew the time for completion of the project for a period of 6
months in tower AO2 in Sadbhavana Township, Pocharam Municipality,
Ghatkesar, Medchal Malkajgiri District.
lA NO: I Ot:2025
Petiticn under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavil filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the proceeding of the 1st respondent in Lr. No 04/TGRSCLIEM1AO2
Unfinished fowers/PCHRM/2023, Dated 21-01-2025 cancelling the allotment of
A02 Tower by forfeiting the token advance and a first installments of Rs
3,05,10,000/- as illegal and arbitrary, pending disposal of the above Writ Petition.
lA NO: 2Ol:2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay
all further [rroceedings in pursuance of the proposal of the first respondent as
stated in thr: Brochure to sell the semi-finished Flats in Tower A02 in Sadbhavana
Township, Pocharam Municipality, Ghatkesar, Medchal Malkajgiri, pending
disposal of the above Writ Petition.
lA NO: 3 Ol:2025
BETWEEN
1. Telarrgana Rajiv Swagruha Corporation Limited (TRSCL). Reo. bv its Vice
. chairman and ltlarrgging-street
Direct6r, Having its offi'ce at H.irlo.3lo-t'g+, tst
Floor, TGHCL Building,
No. 1 7, Hiirayathnagar, Hyderaoao.sooozg.
2. Manurging Director and vice chairman, Telangana Rajiv swagruha
corpcration_Limited (TRSCL), H No 3-6-184. Ist Ftoo'r. TGHeL Buitding,
Streert No. 1 7, Himayathnagai, Hyderabad.500029.
... Petitioners/Respondents
AND
Mahana'rdhi Builders,j Pfoplietary .conc-ern, Rep. by its proprietor, Eppa
suwararra, D/o. Eppa Ramulu, having its office at H.tto.g-1s3v, Gayatri'NAgli
Meerpet, Saroornagar, Ranga Reddy...
RespondenVpetitioner
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to
vacate the interim order dated 22.0.9.2025'in WPNo . 28982 of ZOZS and dismiss
the above Writ Petition
lA NO: 4 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
permit the Petitioner to Amend the Prayer in the Writ Petition as under : Hon'bte
Court may be pleased to lt is therefore prayed that this Hon'ble Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, Order or Direction, preferably a Writ in the nature of Writ
of Mandamus declaring:- a) the proceeding of the first Respondent in Lr. No
04/TGRSCL/EM/A02 Unfinished Towers/PCHRM/2023, Dated 21-01-2o2s
cancelling the allotment of A02 Tower by forfeiting the token advance and a first
installments of Rs. 3,05,10,000/-. as illegal, null, void and arbitrary. b) to cancel
the proposal to sell the semi finished flats in tower A02 in Sadbhavana Township,
Pocharam Municipality, Ghatkesar, Medchal Malkajgiri District which was
published in the brochure Dated 10-Q9-2O25. c) and consequentially direct the
respondents to renew the time for completion of the project for a period of 6
months in tower AO2 in Sadbhavana Township, Pocharam Municipality,
Ghatkesar, Medchal Malkajgiri District d) to declare the action of the Respondents
in not granting NOC to the Petitioner despite the requests made by the Petitioner
though such an NOC was granted to other allottees of other Towers at Pocharam
Village, as arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of lndia.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI VEDULA SRINIVAS,
SENIOR COUNSEL ASSISTED BY SMT CHITRALEKHA
Counselfor the Respondents: SRI A. SUDHERSHAN REDDY,
THE ADVOCATE GENERAL
The Court made the following: ORDER
I
l
I
I
I
i
i
I
I
i
I
*^-'
t.a
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OI.
TELANGANA
HONBLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION N o.28982 OF 2ol25
o,9.o\.20/26
Between:
Mahanandhi Builders
Petitioner
And
Telangana Rajiv Swagruha Corporation Limited (TRSCL),
Rep. by its Vice-Chairmair and Managing Director
& another
Respondents
ORDER:
Chatlenging the proceedings of Respondent No.1 -
Telangana Rajiv Swagruha Corporation Limited (Corporation)
dated 21.O1.2025 cancelling allotment of AO2 Tower to
petitioner, this Writ Petition is filed. Petitioner seeks to cancel
the proposal of the Corporation to sell the semi-finished flats in
Tower AO2 in Sadbhavana Township, Pocharam Municipality,
Ghatkesar, Medchal-Malkqjgiri District which was published in
the Broacher dated 1O.O9.2O25 and consequently direct
respondent - Corporation to renew the time for completion of
the project for a period of six months in Tower A02.
=
2.
Subsequently, petitioner liled I.A. No. 4 of 2025
seeking t,: amend the prayer by adding a new prayer to declare
the action of Respondents in not granting NOC to Petitioner
despite tre requests made by them though such an NOC was
granted l.o other allottees of other Towers at Pocharam Village,
as arbitrary and violative of Article 154 of the Constitution of
India.
3.
The undisputed factual matrix of the case is that
Respond,=nt-Corporation invited Applications in respect of
unfinishr:d towers at Pocharam for completing the work.
Petitioner was allotted AO2 Tower at Pocharam uide proceedings
Lr.No. O4lTRSCLLEM/Unfinished Towers/2023 07.06.2023;
they pai,l EMD and also paid part of balance amount, but did
n6t com'rlete the work of construction within the permitted time
of four months. Petitioner therefore, is stated to have made
Application dated O4.1O.2O24 for extension of time and
accordir:.gly, time was extended up
to O5.OI.2O25 by
Corporation's letter dated 17.LO.2O24. However, since
petitiont:r failed to pay the amounts within time, the
Corporation passed the impugned order of cancellation dated
21.OL.21)25 cancelling the allotment and forfeiting the token
advance' and first installment amount of Rs. 3,O5,1O,0OO/-.
/
a'
9*""9
I
J
,t"(,
Petitioner approached the Corporation and submitted letter
dated 24.03.2025 for issuance of 'NOC'for completing the work,
however, NOC was not given. The Corporation also issued
communication to petitioner calling upon to pay Rs. 29.5L
Crores. Petitioner submitted a list of 40 members who are ready
to purchase the Flats, but 'NOC'was not given. The Corporation
brought a proposal to sell the semi-finished flats in Tower AO2
at Pocharam uide its broacher and Notification No.
17ITGRS CL IEM lUnfinished Towers/ 2025dated 1O.O92025.
Issuance of NOC by the respondent-Corporation is a must for
the builder (petitioner) to obtain loans from the Banks to finish
the project. If the respondent-Corporation refuses to give NOC,
according to petitioner, it will cause irreparable loss and
prejudice to the builder (petitioner) and also to the buyers who
purchased Flats through him.
3.1-
It is further stated, the Corporation terrninated the
contract and issued fresh communication that the tower would
be re-allotted to some other builder. Therefore, some of the
buyers approached this Court and filed Writ Petition'No. 28502
t
of 2O2lwherein this Court granted. interim order.
4.
Respondent Corporation filed counter mainly
contending that the Writ Petition is not maintainable since the
)
dispute is a commercial/contractual one. It is stated that the
Governmr:nt has decided to sell the unfinished towers of the
Corporation in 'as is where is' basis and invited bids. As stated
above, petitioner was allotted A02 unlinished tower at Pocharam
for completion of the work, however, Petitioner failed to make
- prompt F,ayments and hence his allotment was cancelled. They
approached this Court challenging that cancellation with an
inordinal,e delay of Eight Months from the date of cancellation
letter dated 2L.O 1.2025.
5.
Heard Sri Vedula Srinivas, learned Senior Counsel
assisted by Smt. Vedula Chitralekha, learned counsel for
:
petitioner and Sri A. Sudhershan Reddy, learned Advocate
,I
I
I
General for the Respondent Corporation.
6.'
From a perusal of the material on record, it is
evident that petitioner while admitting its default in making
::
!ii
li
prompt payments within the time stipulated in the contract,
contend,:d that cancellation of allotment by the Corporation is
ti
arbitranr.
7.
The core contention of Respondent Corpbration is
that the lis is a commercial/contractual dispute and hence, no
Writ of lvlandamus is maintainable. Reliance for this proposition
I
T
is pla,:ed on Monarch Infrastntcture (/
Ltd.
a.
I
i
!
i
i
I
I
l,
o
Commissioner, Ulhasnagar Municipal CorTtorationl:'
Michigan Rubber (India) Ltd. us Sifcte of Karnata.ka2 and
G.P. Medical Stores jWMS, rep bg its Pgrtner S.Mohith a
Stc:te of Telanganq. rep. bg its Principal Secretary, Medical
and Heo.lth Departments. The principle in
these
pronouncements is that Government and their undertakings
must have a free hand in setting terms of the tender and only if
they are arbitrary, discriminatory, mala fide is actuated by bias,
would Courts interfere. Otherwise, the Courts, normally, would
not interfere in contractual/commercial disputes,
8.
:
Per contra, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
petitioner placed reliance on the judgment of the Hon'ble
l
i
Supreme Court in Subod h Kumar Songh Rathour a tlu Chief
I
.
i
I
Executiue OfJicer (Civil Appeal No. 674L of 2024,
dt.Og.O7.2O24) reported in MANU/SCl0585/2024. In this case,
t
i
:
petitioner, who was the successful bidder, was given
Memorandum of tender for work. Tn'ereafter, respondent issued
a notice to the appellant stating that tender for work of
maintenance had been cancelled on account of technical fault in
tender. Applying the principle of doctrine of legitimate
t:
I
I
i
i
'lzoooys scc 287
21zotzy 8 scc 216
' IZOZ+1SCC Online TS 3321
\
\
expectati()n in public law founded on the principles of fairness
-
and non-arbitrariness in Government dealing with individuals,
the Hon'ble Supreme Court allowed the appeal holding as
under:
"
I30. We are of the considerecl opinion that the litigation at
hand is rothing but a classic text book case of an arbitrary exercise of
powers try the Respondent in cancelling the tender that was issued in
favour ol'the appellant and that too at the behest of none other than the
concern€:d Minister-ln-charge and there b1, rendering the Notice of
Cancellation dt.O7 .O2.2023 illegal. "
8. 1.
This judgment is of no help. The facts in the case on
hand are different from the facts of the said case. In the extant
case, a(lmittedly, petitioner failed to make payments as
stipulated in the terms of contract, in spite of extension of time,
within the stipulated time. Therefore, Respondent Corporation
was corrstrained to cancel the allotment. There is neither
ri
t.
arbitrariness nor it was done at the behest of any person. Once
lri
iti
the allotment is cancelled, respondent-Corporation would
It
naturalllr sell the unfinished flats. Further, in the case relied on
by petition6r, a judicial review of the act of the respondent (writ
!l
I
of certiorari) was sought for, but not a Mandamus. [n the case
I
I
I
I
i
on hancl, a writ of Mandamus is sought. Time and again the
Hon'ble Apex Court is sensitizing that the High Courts should
n-l
I
i
i
I
t
I
I
{
o
not interfere with the disputes of commercial/contractual in
nature unless such disputes are the result of
arbitrariness/unfairness etcetera on the part of the state or
Instrumentalities of the state. Such disputes have to be decided
by the Commercial Courts.
g.
In contractual agreement, by defaulting in making
payments within the time agreed to in the agreement, petitioner
committed breach of contract, as such, respondent-corporation
has acted upon by issuing the impugned order. In this set of
facts, what is the right, much less fundamental/statutory right,
of petitioner that was infringed for invoking Article 226 of the
constitution is not pleaded or established. It is not even the
case of petitioner that respondent Corporation has no
competency or authority to pass the impugned order. No public
interest element is involved for issuance of a writ of Mandamus
under Art. 226 of the Constitution even.
10.
,
For the above reasons, the Writ Petition fails and
the same is liable to be dismissed.
1.
The Writ Petition is accordingly dismissed. Since,
Writ Petition itself is dismissed, I.A.No.4 of 2O2S seeking
amendment of prayer, also stands dismissed. No costs.
)
12.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
any shall stand closed.
.C. SU LEKHA DEVI
REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
'O,,,. ONE CC tO SRI VEDULA CHITRALEKHA' AdVOCAIE TOPUCI
2.TwoCCstoADVo-CATEGENERAL,HighCourtfortheStateofTelangana
at H)rderabad' [OUT]
3. fvv6, CD CoPies
DAN
BS
/a:\
Ii
-T*.
-- --,i--
, F
HIGH COURT
)
DATED:09/01 12026
ORDER
S
WP.No.,28982 ot 2025
i()
[ 2 1::i]
\1
*
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
Ks
,l4u
I
I
ii
E
i:
z.
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review