Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 13th April, 2026
Pronounced on: 28th April, 2026
%
+
W.P.(C) 19358/2025
MAHANADI EXPORTTEK PRIVATE LIMITED
HAVING ITS OFFICE AT:
FLAT NO. 701, 7TH FLOOR,
SAHYOG BUILDING,
NEHRU PLACE MARKET ROAD
NEW DELHI – 110019
Email: mahanandaexporttek@gmail.com
.....PETITIONER
Through: Mr. Prakash Shah, Sr. Adv. with Mr.
Jay Savla, Sr. Adv., Mr. Mihir Mehta,
Mr. Mohit Rawal, Mr. Suyog Bhave,
Mr. Jas Sanghavi, Mr. Jasdeep Singh
Dhillon, Mr. Rajpal Singh, Mr.
Aditya Bajaj, Advs.
versus
Signed By:ANKITA RAI
18:29:25
1.
UNION OF INDIA
THROUGH THE REVENUE SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF FINANCE,
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE,
NEW DELHI-110001
Email: uoidhc@gmail.com
.....RESPONDENT NO.1
2.
COMMISSIONER OF CGST (EAST) DELHI
C.R. BUILDING, I.P. ESTATE,
NEW DELHI – 110002
Email: commr-cexdel2@nic.in
.....RESPONDENT NO.2
3.
ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF
CGST DIVISION – NEHRU PLACE,
W.P.(C) 19358/2025
DELHI EAST COMMISSIONERATE
14-15, 5TH FLOOR,
FARM BHAVAN, NEHRU PLACE,
NEW DELHI – 110019
Email: gstdelhieast.legal@gmail.com
.....RESPONDENT NO.3
4.
ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER
OF CENTRAL TAX, APPEALS – I, DELHI
C.R. BUILDING, I.P. ESTATE,
NEW DELHI – 110002
Email: pcco.legaldelhicgst@gov.in
legal.cgstdelhieast@gov.in
.....RESPONDENT NO.4
Through: Ms. Sangita Malhotra, SPC for
R-1/UOI.
Mr. Akash Panwar, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY DIGPAUL
JUDGMENT
AJAY DIGPAUL, J.
1.
The present writ petition assails the impugned order in appeal dated
22.08.2025 passed by Respondent No. 4, dismissing the petitioner’s appeals
against the two orders in original passed by Respondent No. 3 dated
22.11.2024 and order in original dated 05.12.2024 seeking refund of ₹4,10,
37,815, ₹23,68,800 and ₹12,90,899 respectively.
2.
The petitioner is a company incorporated under the Companies Act,
2013, and is engaged in the business of export of mobile phones, desktops,
laptops and other electronic items, and is duly registered with the GST
framework as GSTIN 07AARCM3030A1ZV.
Signed By:ANKITA RAI
18:29:25
W.P.(C) 19358/2025
3.
In response to the petitioner’s applications for refund under Section
54 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, (hereinafter CGST
Act) dated 20.09.2024, 21.09.2024 and 19.10.2024, Respondent No. 3
issued three show cause notices, two on 15.10.2024 and one on 04.11.2024,
inter-alia proposing rejection of the refund applications on account of
failure to submit shipping bills, bank statements, bank realization
certificates, reconciliation of GSTR-1, GSTR-2B and GSTR-3B, etc. The
petitioner was afforded an opportunity of 10 days to file a reply to the show
cause notices, and a further opportunity of personal hearing on the date of
choice of the petitioner was given.
4.
In response thereto, the petitioner submitted three replies; two on
26.10.2024 and one on 21.11.2024 submitting the requisite documents, and
further stating that the physical copies of the bills and other documents had
been given to the CGST inspector upon his physical examination of the
petitioner’s office. Furthermore, the petitioner opted to appear through their
authorized representative on 28.10.2024 for the physical hearing.
5.
The petitioner’s three applications for refund came to be rejected vide
two orders in original dated 22.11.2024 and order in original dated
05.12.2024. Respondent no. 3 inter-alia noted that there were DGARM
Alerts issued against some of the petitioner’s suppliers as their GST
registration had been cancelled on account of suspicious transactions and
lack of verification.
6.
Aggrieved, the petitioner preferred three appeals under Section 107 of
the CGST Act read with Section 109 of the CGST Rules bearing No.
587/2024, 588/2024 and 52/2025 against two orders in original dated
22.11.2024 and one order in original dated 05.12.2024 respectively.
Signed By:ANKITA RAI
18:29:25
W.P.(C) 19358/2025
7.
The petitioner was afforded an opportunity of personal hearing on
07.04.2025, 09.04.2025, 16.04.2025 and 24.04.2025. The petitioner
appeared for personal hearing on 24.04.2025 through his Chartered
Accountant and stated that in two out of the three cases, there are only 3-4
suppliers, and in the third case, there are approximately 37 suppliers,
however, the DGARM alert has been issued against only one supplier.
8.
The appeals came to be dismissed vide the impugned order in appeal
dated 22.08.2025 passed by Respondent No. 4, which is presently under
challenge before this court. Respondent No. 4 noted that in absence of any
cogent evidence supplied by the petitioner, there were credible reasons to
doubt the veracity of the transactions of the petitioner.
Submissions by Petitioner
9.
Mr. Shah, learned senior counsel for the Petitioner, has submitted that
the Orders-in-Original are vitiated as the rejection of refund is founded on
material not disclosed in the show cause notices issued in Form GST RFD08. It is stated that the notices merely sought documents and reconciliation
statements and did not contain any allegation regarding DGARM alerts,
Anti-Evasion communications, or the involvement of L1/L2 suppliers with
cancelled or suspended registrations. However, the Orders-in-Original and
the impugned Order-in-Appeal rely upon such DGARM inputs and AntiEvasion communications alleging suspicious suppliers and wrongful
availment of input tax credit, without furnishing the underlying material to
the Petitioner or incorporating these allegations in the show cause notices,
thereby rendering the impugned orders beyond the scope of the notices and
in violation of the principles of natural justice.
Signed By:ANKITA RAI
18:29:25
W.P.(C) 19358/2025
10.
Mr. Shah has further submitted that the Orders-in-Original have been
passed without granting any opportunity of personal hearing to the
petitioner, in complete disregard of the proviso to Rule 92(3) of the CGST
Rules. It is urged that in response to the show cause notices dated
15.10.2024, the petitioner had specifically requested that a personal hearing
be granted on 28.10.2024. Further, in respect of the show cause notice dated
04.11.2024, a personal hearing was designated for 11.11.2024. It is
submitted that neither the requested hearing dated 28.10.2024 nor the
designated hearing dated 11.11.2024 was granted or conducted by the
adjudicating authority. Thus, the impugned Orders-in-Original are in clear
breach of the principle of Audi alteram partem.
11.
Mr. Shah has further placed reliance on Krishnadatt Awasthy v. State
of Madhya Pradesh & Ors., (2025) 7 SCC 545 and Institute of Chartered
Accounts of India v L.K Ratna & Ors. (1986) 4 SCC 537, to contend that
the principle of audi alteram partem constitutes a fundamental facet of the
justice delivery system. Furthermore, a defect arising from failure to grant
an opportunity of hearing at the initial stage is not ordinarily curable at the
appellate stage. It is further stated that even where the appellate authority is
vested with the requisite jurisdiction, the settled position is to relegate the
matter to the original authority for fresh adjudication after affording an
opportunity of hearing.
12.
Mr. Shah has submitted that the statutory remedy under Section 112
of the CGST Act is not efficacious, as the Goods and Services Tax
Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) is not fully functional and there is considerable
delay in hearing matters; it is urged that in such circumstances, relegating
the petitioner to the appellate forum would cause prejudice. It is further
Signed By:ANKITA RAI
18:29:25
W.P.(C) 19358/2025
stated, placing reliance on Krishnadatt Awasthy v. State of Madhya
Pradesh & Ors., (2025) 7 SCC 545, in a situation where the GSTAT is not
effectively functioning, the matter ought to be remanded to the original
authority for fresh adjudication after affording due opportunity of hearing.
13.
Mr. Shah has also submitted that the impugned order in appeal is
vitiated on account of non-consideration of the material placed on record by
the petitioner and proceeds on findings which are factually incorrect. It is
urged that the petitioner had furnished bank statements, invoice-wise details,
e-way bills, shipping bills and reconciliation statements during the course of
proceedings.
14.
In spite of the same, the appellate authority has recorded that the
petitioner failed to submit concrete bank statements and transaction-level
details, and has reiterated findings relating to mismatch of addresses in eway bills and deficiencies in transportation documents. It is submitted that
the impugned order neither examines the documents placed on record nor
records any finding on the explanations furnished by the petitioner, and
instead proceeds on assumptions derived from departmental inputs, thereby
rendering the order unreasoned and contrary to the principles of natural
justice.
15.
Mr. Shah has further submitted that the present case concerns refund
of tax already deposited by the Petitioner, and therefore, no adverse
consequence would ensue. It is also urged that the amount in question is not
a case of potential tax evasion but of refund entitlement, and the revenue’s
interests remain adequately safeguarded. In such circumstances, it is
submitted that retention of the amount or sustaining the impugned order
cannot be justified on considerations of revenue protection alone.
Signed By:ANKITA RAI
18:29:25
W.P.(C) 19358/2025
Submissions of respondent
16.
Mr. Panwar, learned counsel appearing for the respondents has, at the
outset, submitted that the present writ petition is not maintainable in view of
the availability of an alternative and efficacious statutory remedy. It is urged
that the Petitioner, being aggrieved by the impugned Order-in-Appeal dated
22.08.2025, has the remedy of preferring a further appeal under Section 112
of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 before the learned Goods
and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT). In the absence of any
exceptional circumstance warranting interference under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, the Petitioner ought to be relegated to the said
statutory remedy.
17.
Mr. Panwar has further submitted that the Petitioner’s plea of
violation of principles of natural justice on account of absence of personal
hearing is misconceived. Show cause notices in Form GST RFD-08 dated
15.10.2024 and 04.11.2024 were issued, calling upon the Petitioner to
furnish requisite documents and reconciliation statements. In respect of the
notices dated 15.10.2024, the petitioner was given the option to choose a
date for personal hearing, while for the notice dated 04.11.2024, the hearing
was designated on 11.11.2024. The petitioner, in fact, filed replies dated
26.10.2024 and 21.11.2024 along with supporting documents. It is thus
stated that adequate opportunity, both to file replies and avail personal
hearing, was afforded and considered, thereby satisfying the requirements of
principles of natural justice
18.
Mr. Panwar further submitted that the grievance of non-consideration
of documents is factually incorrect. It is stated that the Orders-in-Original
Signed By:ANKITA RAI
18:29:25
W.P.(C) 19358/2025
dated 22.11.2024 and 05.12.2024, as well as the impugned Order-in-Appeal
dated 22.08.2025, record specific findings on the material placed by the
Petitioner, including invoices, e-way bills and transactional details. The
authorities have also noted deficiencies such as absence of verifiable bank
statements, lack of transaction-level details, and inconsistencies in supplier
information, which impeded verification of the transactions. It is thus
submitted that the impugned orders are reasoned and based on consideration
of the material on record, and mere disagreement with the findings cannot be
construed as non-consideration or violation of principles of natural justice
Analysis
19.
The Petitioner has assailed the impugned Order-in-Appeal dated
22.08.2025 primarily on the ground of violation of the principles of natural
justice, contending that no effective opportunity of personal hearing was
granted at the stage of passing of the orders in original. It is further urged
that the impugned order, passed against the petitioner’s appeals under
Section 107 of the CGST Act, 2017, fails to consider the replies and
documentary material placed on record by the Petitioner and proceeds on
findings which are factually incorrect.
20.
This Court considers it apposite, at the outset, to examine whether the
Orders-in-Original and the impugned Order-in-Appeal suffer from a lack of
jurisdiction or merely involve an exercise of jurisdiction alleged to be
erroneous. For this purpose, it is necessary to advert to certain decisions of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court which delineate the distinction between absence
of jurisdiction and errors committed while exercising jurisdiction, and the
legal consequences flowing therefrom.
Signed By:ANKITA RAI
18:29:25
W.P.(C) 19358/2025
21.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Nusli Neville Wadia v Ivory
Properties & Ors. (2020) 6 SCC 557 has inter-alia noted that –
“37. There is a difference between the existence of jurisdiction and the
exercise of jurisdiction. In case jurisdiction is exercised with material
irregularity or with illegality, it would also constitute jurisdictional error.
However, if a court has jurisdiction to entertain a suit but in exercise of
jurisdiction, a mistake has been committed though it would be a
jurisdictional error, but not lack of it. It may be a jurisdictional error open
for interference in appellate or revisional jurisdiction.” (emphasis
supplied)
22.
Similarly, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Asma Lateef & Anr. v
Shabbir Ahmad & Ors. (2024) 4 SCC 696 has stated that –
“46. The essence really is that a court must not only have the jurisdiction
in respect of the subject matter of dispute for the purpose of entertaining
and trying the claim but also the jurisdiction to grant relief that is sought
for. Once it is conceded that the jurisdiction on both counts is available, it
is immaterial if the jurisdiction is exercised erroneously. An erroneous
decision cannot be labelled as having been passed “without jurisdiction”.
It is, therefore, imperative that a distinction between a decision lacking in
inherent jurisdiction and a decision which suffers from an error committed
in the exercise of jurisdiction is borne in mind.” (emphasis supplied)
23.
This Court, upon consideration of the above principles, finds that a
clear distinction must be maintained between lack of jurisdiction and errors
committed in the exercise of jurisdiction. It is only in cases of inherent lack
of jurisdiction that interference under Article 226 is warranted; in all other
cases involving improper exercise of jurisdiction, the party should
preferably be relegated to the statutory remedy. It is relevant to mention that
this Court in a writ jurisdiction is not an appellate court, and presides in a
supervisory jurisdiction. Thus, it’s interference under Article 226 is
warranted only when exceptional or extraordinary circumstances are shown,
Signed By:ANKITA RAI
18:29:25
W.P.(C) 19358/2025
and in the present case, no such circumstances have been shown by the
petitioner.
24.
In the present case, it becomes apparent that pursuant to the show
cause notices dated 15.10.2024 and 04.11.2024, the Petitioner was not only
called upon to furnish replies but was also afforded the opportunity of
personal hearing. The notices dated 15.10.2024 provided the Petitioner the
option to indicate a convenient date for personal hearing, which was chosen
as 28.10.2024, while the notice dated 04.11.2024 designated the date of
personal hearing as 11.11.2024. The Petitioner thereafter submitted replies
dated 26.10.2024, 26.10.2024 and 21.11.2024 along with supporting
documents. The Orders-in-Original dated 22.11.2024 and 05.12.2024 reflect
that the adjudicating authority has taken note of the replies and the material
placed on record and has recorded findings thereon. The sequence of events
demonstrates that the Petitioner was put to notice, afforded an opportunity to
respond, and its submissions were available for consideration at the stage of
adjudication.
25.
At the appellate stage as well, the impugned order records that the
Petitioner was afforded personal hearings on 07.04.2025, 09.04.2025,
16.04.2025 and 24.04.2025, all of which were attended by its authorised
representative. The order further notes the submissions advanced on behalf
of the Petitioner, including those made through its Chartered Accountant
during the personal hearing dated 24.04.2025, and proceeds to deal with the
same while affirming the findings recorded in the Orders-in-Original. The
grievance, therefore, is not of absence of opportunity, but of non-acceptance
of the submissions.
Signed By:ANKITA RAI
18:29:25
W.P.(C) 19358/2025
26.
Insofar as the reliance placed by the Petitioner on Krishnadutt
Awasthy v. State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors., (2025) 7 SCC 545 is
concerned, the principle that a defect arising from absence of hearing at the
original stage may not be cured at the appellate stage is well settled.
However, the applicability of the said principle is premised on a situation
where it is demonstrated that no opportunity of hearing was afforded at the
stage of adjudication. In the present case, the Petitioner has participated in
the proceedings, furnished replies, was afforded opportunity of personal
hearing at the original stage, and has also availed the opportunity of personal
hearing at the appellate stage. In such circumstances, even assuming that any
deficiency is sought to be pointed out in the manner of consideration of the
Petitioner’s case, it would not be a case of complete absence of opportunity
of hearing at the original stage so as to attract the said principle.
27.
The petitioner’s contention that the remedy under Section 112 of the
CGST Act is inefficacious due to non-functionality of the GSTAT is without
merit. This Court, in its order dated 16.02.2026 in Rajesh Khanna v. Office
of the Commissioner of Central Tax Appeals–I, Delhi & Ors., W.P.(C)
No. 81/2026, while permitting recourse to Section 112, took note of the
sworn affidavit of the Joint Secretary, Ministry of Finance, recording that
requisite IT infrastructure is in place enabling virtual hearings and that the
GSTAT has commenced scrutiny of appeals. It is thus a matter of record that
the GSTAT is functional and constitutes an efficacious statutory remedy.
28.
The further submission of the Petitioner that the matter pertains to
refund of tax already deposited and, therefore, no prejudice would be caused
to the revenue if relief is granted, also does not persuade this Court to
exercise writ jurisdiction. The entitlement to refund and the sufficiency of
Signed By:ANKITA RAI
18:29:25
W.P.(C) 19358/2025
material in support thereof are matters falling within the domain of statutory
adjudication. Such contentions, including those relating to equities, are open
to be urged before the appellate forum and cannot be a ground to bypass the
statutory remedy.
29.
In view of the above, this Court is unable to accept the contention that
the impugned orders suffer from a jurisdictional infirmity on account of
violation of principles of natural justice. The Petitioner has been afforded
opportunity at both stages as the challenge essentially pertains to the
correctness of the findings recorded. The appropriate remedy, therefore, lies
in availing the statutory appeal under Section 112 of the CGST Act before
the learned GSTAT. This court makes it clear that it has not appreciated the
merits of the case, and all rights and contentions are left open.
30.
The petition is disposed of in these terms. All pending applications, if
any, are also disposed of.
AJAY DIGPAUL
(JUDGE)
NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE
(JUDGE)
APRIL 28, 2026/AS/sg
Signed By:ANKITA RAI
18:29:25
W.P.(C) 19358/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review