Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S/L 16
14.10.2026
Court No.24
SD
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
WPA 30292 of 2026
Mahamud Hossain
Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
Mr. Siddhartha Goswami
Ms. Upasana Shaw
… for the Petitioner.
Mr. Dwijadas Chakraborty
Mr. Prodyat Saha
Mr. Sunit Kumar Roy
1.
… for the Union of India.
… for the National Medical Commission.
As per direction of the Court, Mr. Sunit Kumar
Roy, learned advocate who is present in Court and
usually appears on behalf of the National Medical
Commission, has entered appearance on behalf of the
Commission and made submission. The Commission is
directed to regularise his engagement.
2.
The petitioner participated in NEET (UG) 2026
Examination in the category of Persons with Benchmark
Disabilities (PwBD). His all India NEET rank in the said
category is 358.
3.
In
support
of
his
benchmark
disability,
the
petitioner relies on the Unique Disability ID issued by
the
competent
authority
on
December
26,
mentioning the petitioner’s percentage of disability as
50% and the nature of disability as permanent. The
petitioner is suffering from locomotor disability in both
the upper limbs. He has been diagnosed with Sequelae
of Epilleptic Seizure.
4.
As per the guidelines on assessment of persons
with benchmark disabilities for admission to the MBBS
course, 2026, a candidate is required to produce a
disability certificate issued by the Medical Assessment
Board. The candidate has to be functionally competent
for being admitted in the said course.
5.
The
petitioner
appeared
before
the
Medical
Assessment Board and on assessment the petitioner’s
percentage of benchmark disability has been reduced to
on August 8, 2026. However, the petitioner did not
receive the report of the Medical Assessment Board.
Challenging the assessment of the Medical Assessment
Board, the petitioner preferred an appeal before the
Appellate Authority which re-assessed the disability of
the petitioner and on 13th September 2026 concluded
that the percentage of disability is zero thus, rendering
the petitioner ineligible for reservation for benchmark
disability as per the latest notified guidelines.
6.
Both the authority found that the candidate
demonstrated
functional
competency.
There
is
no
requirement of providing assistive or other support
means. He has the ability to successfully complete the
MBBS course and acquire the prescribed competencies
and he did not pose any risk to patient’s safety.
7.
The petitioner is aggrieved by the act of the Medical
Assessment Board and the Appellate Authority in
reassessing the quantum of his disability. It has been
submitted that the Medical Assessment Board does not
have the authority to re-assess the quantum of
disability of a candidate. The Medical Assessment Board
is only required to verify and evaluate the functional
capability of the candidate to pursue the course.
8.
In support of such submission, the guidelines
published by the National Medical Commission have
been relied upon.
9.
Reliance has also been placed on the judgment
delivered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of
Om Rathod v. Director General of Health Services
reported in 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3130.
10. Reliance has also been placed on the judgment
passed by a Coordinate Bench of this Court in the
matter of Mitadru Sau v. State of West Bengal & Ors.
reported in 2024 SCC OnLine Cal 10317 wherein the
Court, relying on Om Rathod (supra), was pleased to
direct the respondent authorities to act in terms of the
directions passed in the matter of Om Rathod (supra)
and to treat the disability of the candidate as per the
UDID card.
11. It has been submitted that the All India ranking of
the petitioner in the PwBD category is such that he
ought to get admission in a Government Medical
College.
12. Learned advocate representing the respondent no.
1 submits that the petitioner ought to report before the
Appellate Authority for assessing his functionality to get
admitted and to complete the subject course. It has
been submitted that the Assessment Board ought to
verify and evaluate the eligibility of the candidate in
accordance
with
the
guidelines
published
by
the
Commission. The nature and extent of the disability of
the candidate has to be verified.
13. Upon hearing the submissions made on behalf of
the parties and on perusal of the documents placed
before this Court, it appears that the quantum of
disability of the petitioner has already been ascertained
and certified in the disability certificate issued by the
District
Hospital
–
Suri,
Suri
Laldighipara,
Suri,
Birbhum, West Bengal, 731101 on December 26, 2025
in accordance with the provisions of the Rights of
Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016.
14. The Unique Disability ID card has been issued by
the authority under the Department of Empowerment of
Persons with Disabilities, Ministry of Social Justice and
Empowerment, Government of India. Relying on such
Unique Disability ID card, the petitioner submitted the
self-assessment certificate and declared himself to be
eligible for reservation as a disabled candidate with
benchmark disability.
15. The Medical Assessment Board re-assessed the
quantum of disability of the candidate and reduced the
percentage of the same. The assessment of the Medical
Assessment Board was affirmed by the Appellate
Authority and the disability of the petitioner was found
to be only zero percent making him ineligible to fall
within the bracket of benchmark disability. On account
of
reduction
of
the
percentage
of
disability,
the
petitioner is unable to get the benefit of reservation
under the category of benchmark disability.
16. As per Section 2(r) of the Rights of Persons with
Disabilities
Act,
2016,
“person
with
benchmark
disability” means a person with not less than forty
percent of a specified disability where specified disability
has not been defined in measurable terms and includes
a person with disability where specified disability has
been defined in measurable terms, as certified by the
certifying authority.
17. The Unique ID for Persons with Disabilities project
has been implemented to create a national database of
Persons with Disabilities (PwDs) and issue a Unique
Disability Identity Card (UDID) to each individual. The
percentage of disability is determined upon assessment
by competent authorities under the department of
Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities, Ministry of
Social Justice and Empowerment, Government of India.
18. Once the quantum of disability is assessed and
UDID card issued reflecting such quantum, there is
hardly any scope to reassess the same by any other
authority not prescribed by law.
19. The submission of the respondents that they have
the authority to assess the disability in accordance with
the guidelines does not appear to be the proper
approach.
The
act
of
ascertaining
percentage
of
disability afresh by the Medical Assessment Board or
the Appellate authority to ascertain whether a candidate
can get the benefit of reservation in PwBD category is
directly contrary to the Act which in no unclear terms
lays down that a person who has more than forty
percent disability will fall under PwBD category. The
provision of the Act will always prevail over any
guidelines issued by the authority.
20. Moreover, it cannot be that a person will fall under
PwBD category under the Act and will not fall under the
said category in terms of the Guidelines. There cannot
be two separate criteria to identify benchmark disability
of a person. The very purpose, aim and object of
granting reservation to a candidate suffering from
benchmark disability will be frustrated and defeated if
such dual stand is adopted by the authority only for
ascertaining the percentage of disability.
21. The position of law as settled by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in this regard is very clear. The
quantum of disability is to be assessed only by the
authority prescribed under the provisions of the Rights
of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 which issues the
disability certificate and the Unique Disability ID. The
quantum of disability cannot be re-assessed by the
Medical Assessment Board or the Appellate Authority.
The aforesaid authorities are only required to assess the
functionality of the candidate as to whether the
candidate is in a position to take admission in the
subject course.
22. For ascertaining the functionality of the candidate,
the Medical Assessment Board assessed the functional
competency, the reasonable accommodation, ability to
complete the MBBS course and the patient’s safety
assessment and found the same to be in favour of the
petitioner. After the Medical Assessment Board decides
all the above points in favour of the petitioner, the
Medical Assessment Board could not have re-assessed
the quantum of disability of the candidate and reduce
the same from the percentage as disclosed in the
disability certificate followed by the UDID card.
23. In view of the above, the Court is of the considered
opinion that the conclusion of the Medical Assessment
Board affirmed by the Appellate Authority that the
petitioner is ineligible for PwBD reservation cannot be
sustained in the eye of law. Such conclusion of the
authority stands set aside.
24. The quantum of the benchmark disability as
assessed by the Competent Authority and reflected in
the UDID card has to be taken as final.
25. As the Medical Board has found the petitioner to
have
successfully
passed
the
functionality
test,
accordingly, the petitioner shall be provided the benefit
as meant for the PwBD candidates.
26. A fresh eligibility certificate shall be issued by the
IPGME&R, Kolkata in favour of the petitioner strictly
relying upon the quantum of disability as mentioned in
the Unique Disability ID of the petitioner at the earliest
but positively by 15th October, 2026.
27. The petitioner will be entitled to participate in the
next round of counselling relying on the fresh eligibility
certificate that will be issued relying upon the Unique ID
of the petitioner.
28. The writ petition stands disposed of.
29. All parties shall act on the basis of a server copy of
this order duly downloaded from the official website of
this Court.
30. Urgent photostat certified copy of the server copy of
this order, if applied for, be supplied to the parties on
compliance of all requisite formalities.
(Amrita Sinha, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review