Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 17TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 2461 OF 2011 (PAR)
BETWEEN:
MAHADEVAPPA
DEAD BY LRS
1.
SMT. YELLAMMA
W/O MAHADEVAPPA
AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS
UDRI VADDIGERE VILLAGE
SORABA TALUK, SHIMOGA DISTRICT.
2.
HANUMANTHAPPA
S/O MAHADEVAPPA
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS
UDRI VADDIGERE VILLAGE
SORABA TALUK, SHIMOGA DISTRICT.
3.
SMT. SHANTHAMMA
W/O VIRUPAXAPPA
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
KONDOJI VILLAGE, HANGAL TALUK
HAVERI DISTRICT.
4.
SMT. SHARADA
W/O KRISHNAPPA
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS UDRI WADDIGERE VILLAGE
SORABA TALUK, SHIMOGA DISTRICT.
5.
SMT. VANAJAKSHI
W/O VASAPPA
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
SUTHUKOTAI VILLAGE, SORABA TALUK
SHIMOGA DISTRICT.
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-2-
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
6.
SMT. PARVATHI
W/O BASAVANAPPA
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS
MANCHIKOPPA VILLAGE
SORABA TALUK, SHIMOGA DISTRICT.
7.
BHARMAPPA
S/O HANUMANTHAPPA
AGED 58 YEARS
8.
MARIYAPPA
S/O HANUMANTHAPPA
AGED 50 YEARS
9.
BHEEMAPPA
S/O HANUMANTHAPPA
AGED 48 YEARS
10. ESHWARAPPA
S/O HANUMANTHAPPA
AGED 47 YEARS
11. SIDDARAMAPPA
S/O HANUMANTHAPPA
AGED 43 YEARS
12. CHANDRAPPA
S/O HANUMANTHAPPA
AGED 30 YEARS
R7 to R10 AND R12 ARE R/AT
UDRI WADDIGERE VILLAGE
SORABA TALUK, SHIMOGA DISTRICT.
R11 IS R/AT SAGAR TOWN, SHIMOGA DIST.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. H.K. BASAVARAJ, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
SRI RAMAPPA
S/O HANUMANTHAPPA
AGED 61 YEARS
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-3-
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
2.
LAKSHMANAPPA
S/O HANUMANTHAPPA
AGED 60 YEARS
3.
BHARAMAPPA
S/O HANUMANTHAPPA
AGED 54 YEARS
4.
YALLAPPA
S/O HANUMANTHAPPA
AGED 48 YEARS
5.
LOKAPPA
S/O HANUMANTHAPPA
AGED 45 YEARS
6.
YALLAMMA
W/O MARIYAPPA
AGED 40 YEARS
7.
RAJAPPA S/O MARIYAPPA
AGED 19 YEARS
8.
DEVENDRAPPA
S/O MARIYAPPA
AGED 17 YEARS,
MINOR REP BY GUARDIAN YELLAMMA(R-6)
R1 TO R8 ARE R/O
UDRI VODDIGERE VILLAGE
SORAB TALUK, SHIMOGA DISTRICT
PIN-577 429.
SAVITHRAMMA W/O BHEEMAPPA
DECEASED BY LRS
9.
PUTTAMMA W/O BANGARAPPA
AGE 39 YEARS
R/O UDRI VODDIGERE VILLAGE
SORAB TALUK, SHIMOGA DISTRICT.
10. BHARAMAKKA
W/O YALLAPPA
AGE 59 YEARS
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-4-
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
R/O CHIKKAIDAGODU VILLAGE
ANAVATTI HOBLI, SORAB TALUK.
11. JAYAMMA
W/O PARAMESHWARA
AGE 57 YEARS
R/O JEEVAGATTA VILLAGE
TALAGUNDA HOBLI, SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577 427.
12. YELLAPPA
S/O BHEEMAPPA
AGE 57 YEARS, AGRICULTURIST
13. HANUMANTHAPPA
S/O BHEEMAPPA
AGE 55 YEARS,
ANANDAPPA S/O BHEEMAPPA
SINCE DECEASED BY LRS
14. SHIVAMURTHY S/O ANANDAPPA
AGE: 16 YEARS,
MINOR REP BY GUARDIAN MOTHER
RESPONDENT NO.17
KAMALAMMA
15. SHASHI S/O ANANDAPPA
AGED 18 YEARS
16. RAVI
S/O ANANDAPPA
AGE: 20 YEARS
17. KAMALAMMA
W/O ANANDAPPA
AGE: 39 YEARS
R12 TO R17 ARE R/AT
UDRI VADDIGERE VILLAGE
SORAB TALUK, SHIMOGA DISTRICT-577 429.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. H. DAYANANDA SARASWATHI, ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO
R6, R10 TO R13, R16 AND R17;
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-5-
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
R8 IS MINOR REP. BY R6; R14 IS MINOR REP. BY R17;
V/O DATED 07.09.2023 APPEAL AGAINST R9 STANDS
ABATED;
NOTICE
TO
R7
AND
R15
ARE
SERVED
AND
UNREPRESENTED)
THIS RSA IS FILED UNDER SEC.100 OF CPC., AGAINST
THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 9.8.2011 PASSED IN
R.A.NO.24/2008 ON THE FILE OF THE SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE &
JMFC., SORABA, DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND CONFIRMING
THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 22.1.2008 PASSED IN
O.S.NO.146/2003 ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE (JR.DN) &
JMFC., SORAB.
THIS RSA HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR
JUDGMENT ON 15.09.2026, THIS DAY JUDGMENT WAS
PRONOUNCED THEREIN, AS UNDER:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
CAV JUDGMENT
The captioned second appeal is by the unsuccessful
plaintiffs questioning the judgment and decree passed by
the Court of first instance in O.S.No.146/2003, whereby
the suit for partition came to be dismissed, which
judgment and decree has been affirmed by the appellate
Court in R.A.No.24/2008.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties shall
be referred to as per their rank before the Trial Court.
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-6-
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
3.
The plaintiffs instituted the suit for partition
specifically contending that they represent the branch of
Bharmappa @ Bheema, whereas the defendants represent
the branch of Sanna Bheemappa, and that both branches
constitute an undivided Hindu joint family. It is the specific
case of the plaintiffs that the suit schedule properties are
the ancestral joint family properties and that the plaintiffs’
branch is entitled to one-half share therein. It is further
pleaded that despite repeated demands for effecting
partition by metes and bounds, the defendants declined to
effect partition, compelling the plaintiffs to institute the
present proceedings.
4.
The
defendants,
on
service
of
summons,
entered appearance and filed their written statement,
specifically disputing the very foundation of the suit. They
contended that the plaintiffs and defendants do not
constitute an undivided Hindu joint family and that there
had already been a severance in status and partition in the
family. It was further contended that the suit schedule
properties
had
been
dealt
with
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
separately
by
the
-7-
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
respective branches. In particular, the defendants asserted
that the properties were sold as far back as on 19.03.1946
by the father of defendants 1 to 5 and the father of
defendants 10 to 12 and were thereafter repurchased on
22.04.1948.
On
these
pleadings,
the
defendants
maintained that there was no subsisting joint family or
joint family property available for partition.
5.
On the basis of the rival pleadings, the Trial
Court framed the requisite issues. The parties were
permitted to lead oral and documentary evidence. On
appreciation of the entire material on record and on
consideration of the pleadings and evidence, the Trial
Court answered issue Nos.1 and 2 in the negative and held
that the plaintiffs had failed to establish that they
continued to constitute an undivided Hindu joint family
with the defendants and had further failed to establish that
the suit schedule properties continued to retain the
character
of
joint
family
ancestral
Consequently, the suit came to be dismissed.
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
properties.
-8-
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
6.
The plaintiffs, being aggrieved by the judgment
and decree of the Trial Court, preferred R.A.No.24/2008.
The appellate Court, being the final fact-finding Court,
independently
documentary
re-appreciated
evidence.
While
the
entire
doing
so,
oral
it
and
attached
considerable significance to the admissions made by PW.1
in cross-examination. The appellate Court noticed that the
plaintiffs had candidly admitted that the plaintiffs and
defendants had been residing separately for nearly seven
decades and that they had been cultivating and enjoying
their respective lands separately for the same length of
time. Having regard to these admissions, the appellate
Court concluded that the plaintiffs had failed to establish
the continued existence of a joint Hindu family or joint
possession of the suit schedule properties. The appeal was
accordingly dismissed. It is these concurrent findings
which are called in question in the present second appeal.
7.
Heard the learned counsel appearing for the
plaintiffs and the learned counsel appearing for the
defendants.
This
Court
has
bestowed
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
its
anxious
-9-
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
consideration on the concurrent findings recorded by the
Courts below and has also examined the material placed
before this Court.
8.
The principal contention urged by the learned
counsel for the plaintiffs is that there is a presumption in
Hindu law that a Hindu family is joint and that the burden
was therefore on the defendants to establish disruption of
the joint family. There can be no quarrel with the broad
proposition that Hindu law recognizes a presumption of
jointness in a Hindu family. However, the presumption
cannot be divorced from the facts and circumstances of
each case. More importantly, where the evidence discloses
prolonged
separate
residence,
separate
possession,
separate cultivation, separate enjoyment and independent
dealings with the properties over several decades, the
presumption cannot be mechanically invoked to resurrect
a joint family which the evidence demonstrates had long
ceased to exist in fact.
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 10 -
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
9.
The principles stated by Mulla on Hindu Law are
apposite in this regard. The normal condition of a Hindu
family is jointness. The presumption of jointness, however,
is essentially a presumption arising from the normal state
of affairs and is not an immutable rule of evidence. The
further the members are removed from the common
ancestor and the longer the period during which they have
lived and dealt with their properties separately, the
weaker the presumption becomes. In other words, the
presumption of jointness is not of uniform strength
irrespective of the degree of relationship. It becomes
progressively weaker as the relationship becomes remote,
particularly
when
the
dispute
is
between
members
belonging to the third generation or beyond and the
surrounding circumstances establish prolonged separation
in residence, possession and enjoyment.
10.
The
principle
assumes
significance
in
the
present case. The genealogy produced by the plaintiffs
themselves demonstrates that the contest is no longer
between the sons or even immediate descendants of a
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 11 -
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
common ancestor. The plaintiffs represent the branch of
Bharmappa @ Bheema, whereas the defendants represent
the branch of Sanna Bheemappa. The contest is between
descendants of the respective branches extending into the
third generation. Thus, this is not a case where two
immediate branches of a recently deceased common
ancestor are asserting their rights against each other. The
relationship has become considerably remote.
11.
The
distinction
presumption of
weaker
and
is
important
jointness, though
weaker
with
the
because
the
available, becomes
remoteness
of
the
relationship. The law does not presume perpetual jointness
merely because persons can trace their descent to a
common ancestor. If such a proposition were accepted, a
Hindu family could be treated as joint in perpetuity
notwithstanding
generations
of
separate
residence,
separate possession, separate cultivation and independent
dealings with properties. Such a conclusion would be
contrary to both the principles of Hindu law and ordinary
human experience.
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 12 -
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
12.
In the present case, the weakening of the
presumption is not founded merely upon the fact that the
parties belong to the third generation. There is substantive
evidence which displaces whatever initial presumption of
jointness may have existed. PW.1 himself has admitted
that the plaintiffs and defendants have been residing
separately for approximately seven decades and that they
have been cultivating their respective lands separately for
the same period. These admissions are of considerable
significance. A period extending over nearly seventy years
cannot be brushed aside as a temporary arrangement or
mere separate residence without severance of status.
13.
establish
Separate residence by itself may not necessarily
partition.
Likewise,
separate
cultivation
or
separate enjoyment of a particular property may, in an
appropriate
case,
be
referable
to
convenience
or
arrangement amongst family members. But when these
circumstances
continue
uninterruptedly
for
several
decades and are coupled with independent possession and
enjoyment of the properties and separate dealings with
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 13 -
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
the properties as owners, they constitute compelling
circumstances against the continued existence of a joint
family.
14.
The
documentary
evidence
noticed
by
the
Courts below further reinforces this conclusion. The record
discloses
that
the
properties
had
been
dealt
with
independently by the respective branches. The transaction
dated 19.03.1946 and the subsequent repurchase dated
22.04.1948 were also relied upon by the defendants to
demonstrate the manner in which the properties had
ceased to be treated as joint family properties. These
transactions, read along with the long-standing separate
possession and enjoyment admitted by PW.1, constitute
circumstances which cannot be ignored while determining
whether the plaintiffs have discharged the burden of
establishing subsisting jointness.
15.
It is necessary to bear in mind the distinction
between the initial presumption of jointness and the
ultimate burden of establishing a subsisting right to
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 14 -
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
partition. A plaintiff who approaches the Court seeking
partition cannot succeed merely by establishing that the
parties have a common ancestor. The plaintiff must
establish the existence of a joint family property available
for partition and a subsisting right therein. Where the
defendants specifically plead prior partition or severance
and place material before the Court showing long-standing
separate possession and enjoyment, the plaintiff cannot
rest his case merely on the abstract presumption of
jointness.
16.
The present case is therefore not one where the
Courts below have ignored the presumption recognized
under Hindu law. On the contrary, the Courts below have
examined whether that presumption stands displaced by
the conduct and admissions of the parties. Having regard
to the admitted position that the two branches have been
living separately and cultivating their respective lands
separately for nearly seventy years, coupled with the
documentary evidence showing independent dealings with
the
properties,
the
Courts
below
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
were
justified
in
- 15 -
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
concluding that the plaintiffs had failed to establish
subsisting jointness.
17.
There is another important aspect. The plaintiffs
themselves have placed reliance upon the genealogy to
establish their relationship with the defendants. That very
genealogy demonstrates that the parties are now in the
third generation from their respective branch ancestors.
The further the parties move away from the common
ancestor, the less tenable becomes an assumption that the
family continued joint merely because there was no formal
registered partition deed. Hindu law does not insist that
disruption of the joint family status must, in every case,
be evidenced by a registered instrument. Severance may
be established from the conduct of the parties and the
attendant
circumstances.
unequivocal
separate
Long,
possession
continuous
and
enjoyment
and
are
material circumstances in determining such severance.
18.
In the case on hand, the plaintiffs have failed to
establish any circumstance which would explain away the
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 16 -
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
admitted position of separate residence and separate
cultivation
for
nearly
seven
decades.
No
convincing
material is placed before the Court to demonstrate that
notwithstanding such prolonged separation, the parties
continued
to
possess
the
suit
properties
jointly
as
members of one undivided Hindu family. The mere
assertion in the plaint that the properties are ancestral
cannot substitute proof of their continued joint character.
19.
It is also trite that the expression “ancestral
property” cannot, by itself, establish that the property is
presently joint family property. A property may have an
ancestral origin, but the question for determination in a
partition suit is whether the property retained its character
as joint family property and continued to be jointly held by
the parties at the time when the suit was instituted. That
essential fact has not been established by the plaintiffs.
20.
The appellate Court has carefully considered the
admissions of PW.1 and the documentary evidence and
has recorded a categorical finding that the plaintiffs failed
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 17 -
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
to prove the existence of a joint Hindu family and joint
possession of the suit schedule properties. Such a finding
is essentially one of fact. Both Courts have concurrently
arrived at the same conclusion upon appreciation of the
evidence.
21.
This Court, in exercise of jurisdiction under
Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 cannot
interfere with concurrent findings of fact merely because
another
view
of
the
evidence
may
be
possible.
Interference would be warranted only where the findings
are shown to be perverse, contrary to the evidence on
record, or otherwise give rise to a substantial question of
law. No such infirmity is demonstrated in the present case.
22.
On an overall consideration of the matter, this
Court is of the considered opinion that the plaintiffs have
failed to establish the foundational facts necessary for
maintaining a suit for partition. They have failed to
establish that the plaintiffs’ branch and the defendants’
branch continued to constitute an undivided Hindu joint
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 18 -
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
family; they have failed to establish that the suit schedule
properties continued to retain the character of joint family
properties;
and
they
have
failed
to
establish
joint
possession and enjoyment.
23.
The long duration of separate residence and
separate cultivation, extending to nearly seven decades,
assumes particular significance when viewed against the
genealogy produced by the plaintiffs themselves, which
places
the
dispute
at
the
third
generation.
The
presumption of jointness recognized in Hindu law becomes
progressively
weaker
with
the
remoteness
of
the
relationship, and where such weakened presumption is
met by clear and consistent evidence of long-standing
separation and independent enjoyment, the Court cannot
continue to presume jointness in the teeth of the evidence.
24.
Consequently, the findings recorded by the Trial
Court and affirmed by the First Appellate Court are neither
perverse nor contrary to the settled principles of Hindu
law. The Courts below have correctly appreciated the
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 19 -
RSA No. 2461 of 2011
evidentiary value of the admissions made by PW.1 and the
circumstances emerging from the documentary record.
No
substantial
question
of
law
arises
for
consideration in the present second appeal.
25.
Accordingly, the second appeal stands
dismissed. The judgment and decree passed by the Court
of first instance in O.S.No.146/2003 and affirmed by the
appellate Court in R.A.No.24/2008 are hereby confirmed.
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
(SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM)
JUDGE
ALB
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review