The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. Therefore, the present writ petition is disposed of, directing the respondents to consider the case of the petitioner by reckoning the past service prior to his regularization for the purpose of pensionary benefits only without monetary benefits and arrears of pay, within a period of two (02) months from the date of receipt of copy of this order.
12. Consequently, miscellaneous applications pending if any, shall stand dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
WRIT PETITION No.38674 OF 2022
ORDER:
1.
This writ petition is filed under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India claiming the following relief:
“to issue writ of mandamus
(A) By declaring the action of the respondents in not
considering the genuine claim of the petitioner for
retrospective regularization i.e w.e.f the date of
completion of five years of service or on or before
25.11.1993 for the purpose of his pension and
pensionary benefits in terms of Judgment of Honble
Apex court decided between B.Srinivasulu Vs Nellore
Municipality rendered in Civil Appeal No 6318 of
2015 dt 17.08.2015 r/w Reported Judgment of
Division Bench in 2020 6 ALD 349 AP DB and recent
Judgment dt 30.09.2022 rendered in W.P No.43482
of 2018 of High Court of Andhra Pradesh and
regularizing only with prospective effect vide G.O Rt
No.615 Revenue CT III Dept dated 18.07.1995 is as
highly illegal and contrary to the above judicial
pronouncements if necessary to set-aside the same
in so far as the petitioner is concerned
(B) And consequently to direct the respondents to
consider the case of the petitioner for extending the
benefit of past service rendered by him prior to his
regularization orders issued in G.O.Rt No.615
Revenue CT-III Dept dated 18.07.1995 for the
purpose of pension and pensionary benefits in terms
of Judgment of Honble Apex court decided between
B Srinivasulu Vs Nellore Municipality rendered in
Civil Appeal No 6318 of 2015 dt 17.08.2015 r/w
Reported Judgment of Division Bench in 2020 6 ALD
349 AP DB and recent Judgment dt 30.09.2022
rendered in W P No 43482 of 2018 of High Court of
Andhra Pradesh”
NV,J
W.P.No.38674 of 2022
2.
The brief facts of the case are that, the petitioner was
appointed as NMR Daily wage employee on 08.02.1988 and posted
in the office of CTO, Brodipet, Guntur. The services of the petitioner
were regularized vide G.O.Rt.No.615 dated 18.07.1995 in terms of
G.O.Ms.No.212 F & P (PC.III) Department dated 22.04.1994 with
prospective effect i.e. from the date of issuing the order instead of
regularizing his services from the date of appointment. The
petitioner retired from service on 30.06.2021 on attaining the age of
superannuation. The petitioner filed the present writ petition to
count his past service rendered prior to his regularization i.e.
retrospective regularization, for the purpose of pension and
pensionary benefits.
2.
Respondent No.3 – Joint Commissioner, Guntur-I Division,
filed counter affidavit stating that, the petitioner was not initially
appointed against clear vacancy. There are no such sanctioned
posts in the name of NMR Daily wage employee in the subordinate
offices of Commercial Taxes Department. When there were no
sanctioned posts, there will be no vacancies. Moreover, the
petitioner
was
initially
appointed
as
unskilled
labourer
on
08.02.1988 and later absorbed as Attender w.e.f 01.08.1995 in
terms of G.O.Ms.No.212 dated 22.04.1994 and G.O.Rt.No.615
NV,J
W.P.No.38674 of 2022
dated 18.07.1995. the petitioner services in the cadre of Attender
freshly start with effect from the date of jointing as Attender and that
he had no right to claim the service rendered by him till the date of
orders. The appointment of the petitioner is not similar to that of the
appointments of incumbents vide G.O.Rt.no.3072 Finance (AdmnIII)
Department
dated
03.07.2010,
as
the
incumbents
in
G.O.R.t.No.3072 dated 03.07.2010 were initially appointed as
L.D.As in the actual vacancies and subsequently regularized as
Junior Accountants, whereas the petitioner in the present writ
petition was appointed as unskilled labour which was not a post
sanctioned by the Government. There are no such sanctioned posts
in the name of NMR Daily wage employee in the subordinate offices
of Commercial Taxes Department and when there were no
sanctioned pots, there will be no vacancies. Hence, the petitioner
was not eligible for regularization in the cadre of Attender w.e.f the
initial appointment as unskilled labourer on daily wage basis. As per
the executive instructions under Rule 14 of the A.P. Revised
Pension Rules, 1980 vide Govt. memo No.573/225/A3/PC.III/97
dated 01.09.1997, counting of service rendered prior to the effective
date of regularization cannot be entertained for pension and any
other purposes as per the conditions laid down by the Government,
including regularization of services of daily wage employees/NMR
NV,J
W.P.No.38674 of 2022
employees only from the date of issue of such order making with
prospective.
3.
During the course of hearing, learned counsel for the
petitioner contends that the action of the respondents in not
reckoning the service rendered by the petitioner prior to
regularization for the purpose of pension and pensionary benefits is
arbitrary and unsustainable. It is submitted that the petitioner had
rendered long and continuous service and that denial of the benefit
of such past service for pensionary purposes is unjust. Learned
counsel therefore submits that the service rendered prior to
regularization ought to be taken into account while computing the
qualifying service and prays for a direction to the respondents to
count the said service for the purpose of pension and other retiral
benefits. In support of his contentions, learned counsel placed
reliance upon the judgments of Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court
in Government of Andhra Pradesh vs. N. Venkaiah1 and State of
A.P vs. L.B.M. Krishna2 and would contend that past service of the
employee are to be reckoned for the purpose of pension and
pensionary benefits only.
2018 (4) ALD 590 DB
2020 (6) ALD 349 (AP) DB
NV,J
W.P.No.38674 of 2022
4.
On the other hand, learned Government Pleader for
Services–I submits that the petitioner has no legal right to seek
reckoning of the service rendered prior to the date of regularization
for pensionary benefits. It is contended that the petitioner was not
appointed against any sanctioned post or clear vacancy and was
only engaged as an unskilled labourer on daily wage basis; hence,
such service cannot be treated as qualifying service. It is further
submitted that the petitioner was absorbed into regular service only
pursuant to the relevant Government Orders and that such
regularization was granted with prospective effect. Consequently,
the petitioner’s service can be reckoned only from the date of such
absorption. Learned Government Pleader also submits that the
judgments relied upon by the petitioner are distinguishable, as
those appointments were made against sanctioned vacancies.
Learned
counsel
drawn
placed
reliance
on
the
executive
instructions issued under Rule 14 of the A.P. Revised Pension
Rules, 1980 and contended that service rendered prior to the
effective date of regularization of daily wage/NMR employees
cannot be counted for pension or any other purpose. The claim of
the petitioner is therefore liable to be rejected. He further submits
that in State of A.P. vs. L.B.M. Krishna, the petitioners therein
were initially appointed as Vocational Instructors and were later
NV,J
W.P.No.38674 of 2022
appointed against sanctioned posts after the Government created
1030 posts of Vocational Instructors and selections were made
through Selection Committees/Employment Exchanges. In contrast,
the petitioner in the present case was engaged only as an unskilled
labourer on daily wage basis on part-time basis and not against any
sanctioned post. Since the petitioner had not rendered service in
the cadre of Attender prior to his absorption, the said judgment is
not applicable to the facts of the present case and is of no
assistance to the petitioner and requested to dismiss the writ
petition.
5.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned
Government Pleader Services-I and perused the material available
on record.
6.
It is an admitted fact that the petitioner was appointed as
NMR Daily Wage Employee on 08.022.1988.
Since then the
services of the petitioner were continued as NMR/Daily Wage
Employee till his services were regularized vide G.O.Rt.No.615
dated 18.07.1995 in terms of G.O.Ms.No.212 dated 22.04.1994.
The first respondent issued G.O.Ms.No.212 dated 22.04.1994
directing all the departments to regularize the services of
NV,J
W.P.No.38674 of 2022
NMR/Daily Wage Employees/temporary employees who are eligible
and completed the continuous service for more than five years on
or before 25.11.1993, if they are eligible for regularization in terms
of G.O.Ms.No.212 dated 22.04.1994.
In the instant case, the
petitioner admittedly was appointed as NMR/Daily Wage Employee
on 08.02.1988, therefore, the petitioner completed five years of
service by 07.02.1993, therefore, the petitioner is entitled for
regularization of services in view of G.O.Ms.No.212 dated
22.04.1994 from 25.11.1993 but not from 18.07.1995. Therefore,
the action of the respondents in not completing the past services of
the petitioner before regularization is contrary to the ratio laid down
by the Hon’ble Apex Court in B. Srinivasulu vs. Nellore Municipal
Corporation [Civil Appeal No.6318 of 2015 dated 17.08.2015],
Government of Andhra Pradesh vs. N. Venkaiah (supra), State
of A.P vs. L.B.M. Krishna (supra).
7.
The contention of the learned Government Pleader that, in
the present case, there were no sanctioned or vacant posts for
appointing the petitioner as an NMR or daily wage employee, and
that he was initially engaged as an unskilled labourer on
08.02.1988, thereby disentitling him from regularization from the
date of his initial appointment and limiting such entitlement only
NV,J
W.P.No.38674 of 2022
from the date his services were regularized vide G.O.Rt. No. 615
dated 18.07.1995, is not valid and cannot be sustained.
8.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in B. Srinivasulu vs. Nellore
Municipal Corporation held as follows:
“The question of the State Exchequer being saddled with
additional expenditure in relation to such regularisation does
not arise, as the relief already granted to some of the
employees in the cases on hand is to reckon their services
upon completion of five years on or before 25.11.1993 only
for the purpose of their pension and pensionary benefits.
They are not to be given any monetary benefits in the form
of arrears of pay or otherwise. Similar relief would have to
be extended to those employees who were non-suited by
the Tribunal and are before this Court. As all of them served
the State or its instrumentalities for decades together,
extending to them the benefit of such service only for the
purpose of pension and pensionary benefits can hardly be
said to be an onerous burden either on the State or the
State Exchequer. Having utilised their services all along, the
State and its instrumentalities cannot now turn their back on
the loyal services rendered by these employees.
The learned Government Pleader would also point out that
some of the O.A.s/writ petitions were filed with substantial
delay after the regularization orders were passed, giving the
benefit of G.O.Ms.No.212 with effect from the stipulated
dates therein prospectively. She would assert that such
settled matters should not be unsettled merely because the
NV,J
W.P.No.38674 of 2022
Supreme
Court
passed
the
subsequent
order
in
B.SRINIVASULU. It may however be noticed that the
trajectory
of
developments
since
the
issuance
of
G.O.Ms.No.212, as set out hereinbefore, demonstrates that
there was no consistency even in the orders passed by the
Tribunal and this Court. Identically situated people were
treated differently. The narration supra in relation to this very
batch of cases demonstrates that the Tribunal gave the
benefit of B.SRINIVASULU to some and denied it to others.
In such a fluid and uncertain situation, an employee cannot
be blamed for seeking relief even after lapse of some years
as there was no clarity as to the legal position. As the
Supreme Court has now settled the same by way of its
decision in B.SRINIVASULU, employees who completed
five years of service on or before 25.11.1993 and were
already regularised in service with prospective effect cannot
be found fault with for approaching this Court with some
delay so as to seek the benefit of their past service in terms
of G.O.Ms.No.212 at least for the limited purpose of their
pension and pensionary benefits.
9. On the above analysis, the writ petitions are disposed of
directing the authorities concerned to extend the benefit of
B.SRINIVASULU to the employees in this batch of cases by
reckoning their services from the date of completion of five
years in service, on or before 25.11.1993, for the purposes
of their pension and pensionary benefits. They shall
however not be entitled to actual monetary benefits for the
said period, in the form of arrears of pay or allowances.”
NV,J
W.P.No.38674 of 2022
10.
In the above judgment, the Hon’ble Division Bench of this
Court directed the authorities concerned to extend the benefit of
B.SRINIVASULU to the employees by reckoning their services from
the date of completion of five years in service, on or before
25.11.1993, for the purposes of their pension and pensionary
benefits, however, they shall not be entitled to actual monetary
benefits for the said period, in the form of arrears of pay or
allowances.
11.
Therefore, the present writ petition is disposed of, directing
the respondents to consider the case of the petitioner by reckoning
the past service prior to his regularization for the purpose of
pensionary benefits only without monetary benefits and arrears of
pay, within a period of two (02) months from the date of receipt of
copy of this order.
12.
Consequently, miscellaneous applications pending if any,
shall stand dismissed.
_____________________________________
JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
Date: 16.02.2026
SP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review