Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:4898
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND
AT NAINITAL
Writ Petition No. 937 of 2025 (SS)
Mrs. Sudha Pandey and others
…Petitioners
Versus
State of Uttarakhand and others
…Respondents
With
WPSS No. 773 of 2025
WPSS No. 662 of 2025
WPSS No. 673 of 2025
WPSS No. 681 of 2025
WPSS No. 682 of 2025
WPSS No. 725 of 2025
WPSS No. 737 of 2025
WPSS No. 828 of 2025
WPSS No. 855 of 2025
WPSS No. 941 of 2025
Advocates :
Mr. C.D. Bahuguna, Senior Advocate assisted by Mr. Chandra
Shekhar Dalakoti, Advocate for petitioners
Mr. Narayan Dutt, Standing Counsel for the State
Mr. K.P. Upadhyay, Senior Advocate assisted by Mr. Paritosh
Dalakoti, Advocate for the petitioners in WPSS No. 773 of 2025.
Mr. Dinesh Gahatori, Ms. Vandana Singh Mehra and Mr. Deep
Prakash Bhatt, Advocate for the petitioners in other connected
writ petitions.
Mr. Narayan Dutt, Standing Counsel for the State.
Reserved on :03.06.2026
Delivered on :16.06.2026
Hon’ble Manoj Kumar Tiwari, J.
1.
Since common questions of law and fact are involved
in these petitions, therefore they are heard together and
are being decided by a common judgment. However, for
the sake of brevity, facts of Writ Petition No. 937 of 2025
(SS) alone are being considered and discussed.
2.
2026:UHC:4898
Petitioners were appointed to the post of Health
Worker (Female) in Medical and Health Department of
the State in different years, after selection held pursuant
to advertisements issued in the years 2016, 2018, 2022
and 2024.
3.
In
the
advertisements,
pursuant
to
which
petitioners applied, it was clearly mentioned that the
post of Health Worker carries Pay Scale of Rs. 520020200, (Pay Band-1) Grade Pay Rs. 2000/-.
4.
Petitioners were offered appointment as Health
Worker in the pay scale mentioned in the advertisement.
According to them, after serving as Health Worker in the
department for few years, they realised that few persons
serving as Health Worker are getting salary in Grade Pay
of Rs. 2800/- and upon enquiry, it was revealed that
only those who were appointed as Health Worker upto
2013, are getting Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/- and others
who were appointed after enforcement of Recruitment
Rules in 2016, are getting salary in Grade Pay of Rs.
2000/-.
5.
According to petitioners, as they possess same
qualification
and
are
discharging
similar
duties
as
discharged by Health Workers appointed upto 2013,
therefore there is no reason whatsoever for paying
lesser Grade Pay to them. It is further contended that
State Government cannot create a sub class within a
class unless there is a rational, justifiable basis for
providing different Grade Pay to Health Workers.
6.
2026:UHC:4898
Reliefs sought by petitioners in Writ Petition (SS)
No. 937 of 2025 are extracted below:
“I. Issue an order or direction summoning the relevant records
from the office of the respondent no.1; and issue a writ in the
nature of Mandamus declaring the Government order dated 0205-2013 as also serial nos. 1 & 2 of the Appendix-'Kha' of Rule 21
(2) of the Service Rules, 2016, as arbitrary and illegal and
violative of Article 14, 16, 38 (2) and 39 (d) of the Constitution of
India, contained in Annexure no. 1 & 6-A to this writ petition.
II. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of Certiorari
quashing the impugned order dated 02-05-2013, issued by the
respondent no. 1, contained in Annexure-1 to this writ petition.
III. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of Mandamus,
declaring that the petitioners are legally entitled to get the pay
scale of Rs.5200-20200 with Grade pay of Rs. 2800/- from the
date of their initial appointment on the post of Health worker
(Female).
IV. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of Mandamus,
declaring that the action of the respondent no.1, namely, Principal
Secretary, Department of Medical, Health and Family Welfare of
the State not to grant grade pay of Rs.2800/- to the petitioners
amounts to hostile discriminations against the petitioners, which
is violative of Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.”
7.
Petitioners have thrown challenge to Government
Order
dated
02.05.2013
and
Appendix-B
of
the
Recruitment Rules applicable for the post of Health
Worker/Health
Supervisor,
notified
on
26.07.2016,
which are enclosed as Annexure-1 and Annexure-6A
respectively to the writ petition.
8.
Perusal of Government Order dated 02.05.2013
reveals that Health Workers serving in erstwhile State of
Uttar Pradesh filed Writ Petition No. 15904 of 1983 (Shiv
Charan Lal Kushwaha and another Vs. State of U.P. and
others), claiming revision of pay scales and that writ
petition was decided in their favour. In terms of
judgment rendered in that writ petition, pay scale of
Health Worker was revised vide Government Order
dated
16.07.2010.
Thereafter,
another
Government
Order
was
issued
on
02.05.2013
2026:UHC:4898
whereby
earlier
Government Order was modified and approval of the
State Government was granted for releasing difference
of salary to persons who were covered by aforesaid
judgment; however, in the last sentence of para 2 of
Government Order dated 02.05.2013, it was provided
that revised scales shall be given to them as personal
pay and further appointments on the post of Health
Worker shall be made in the scale of Rs. 5200-20200,
Grade Pay Rs. 2000/-.
9.
Government
Order
dated
02.05.2013
further
provides that in terms of judgment rendered by Hon’ble
Allahabad High Court, revised pay scale shall be given
notionally to holders of the post of Health Workers
between 01.05.1995 to 30.06.2010 and arrears of salary
for the said period shall not be paid to them; however,
revised scale shall be given to them w.e.f. 01.07.2010
as personal pay.
10. Petitioners have challenged Appendix-B to the
Recruitment Rules applicable for the post of Health
Worker which provides that post of Health Worker shall
carry scale of Rs. 5200-20200, Grade Pay Rs. 2000/while the post of Health Supervisor which is the next
higher post, will carry scale of Rs. 5200-20200, Grade
Pay Rs. 2800/-.
11. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner submits
that in terms of direction issued by Hon’ble Allahabad
High Court, which was affirmed by Hon’ble Supreme
Court, a Pay Anomaly Committee was constituted by
2026:UHC:4898
State Government and on the recommendation of Pay
Anomaly Committee, pay scale admissible for the post of
Health Worker was revised, therefore, benefit of pay
revision made vide Government Order dated 16.07.2010
can not be denied to petitioners, merely because they
were appointed after 02.05.2013.
12. In the counter affidavit filed by Dr. Sunita Tamta,
on behalf of respondent No. 2, it is stated that
petitioners applied for the post of Health Worker,
knowing fully well that they would get Grade Pay of Rs.
2000/- after appointment, therefore they cannot now
raise grievance regarding pay scale which is given to
them. It is further stated that Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/claimed by petitioners is admissible for the post of
Health Supervisor, which is promotional post available to
Health Workers and Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/-, if given to
petitioners, will create problem.
13. A supplementary counter affidavit is also filed in
reply to the amended writ petition in which it is
contended that after having applied for the post of
Health Worker, knowing fully well that it carries Grade
Pay of Rs. 2000/- and after serving on the post for 9
long years, petitioners cannot question the pay scale
given to them.
14. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners relies
upon the judgment rendered by Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the case of Dhirendra
Chamoli and another Vs.
State of U.P. reported as (1986) 1 SCC 637 for
contending
that
different
pay
scales
cannot
prescribed for persons performing same duties.
be
2026:UHC:4898
15. He also relies upon another judgment rendered by
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Mew Ram
Kanojia Vs. All India Institute of Medical Sciences
and others reported as (1989) 2 SCC 235 for
contending that when not only duties and functions
performed
by
petitioners
are
similar
to
the
one
performed by other set of persons, but their educational
qualifications are also the same, then there cannot be
any difference in pay scales.
16. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners relies
upon the judgment dated 10.03.2025 rendered by
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Anurag Krishna
Sinha Vs. State of Bihar and Another in Civil
Appeal No. 13581 of 2025 in support of his contention
that Article 14 of the Constitution mandates that State
shall not deny to any person equality before law or equal
protection of law within the territory of India. Thus is
contended
that
unequal
treatment
meted
out
to
petitioners in the matter of Grade Pay is unsustainable.
17. Learned counsel for the petitioners further submits
that once Government decided to upgrade the pay scale
of Health Workers and to grant them Grade Pay of Rs.
2800/- vide G.O. dated 16.07.2010, then it is incumbent
upon the Government to extend benefit of said decision
to all persons serving as Health Worker. He thus submits
that petitioners have a legitimate expectation of getting
Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/-.
18. Learned State Counsel per contra submits that pay
scale of Health Workers, who were party to the writ
2026:UHC:4898
petition had to be upgraded in deference to the decision
of Hon’ble Allahabad High Court in Writ Petition No.
15904 of 1983; however, keeping in view the huge
financial burden involved, State Government provided in
Government Order dated 02.05.2013 that only existing
members of service would get Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/as personal pay and those appointed after issuance of
that Government Order, shall be given Grade Pay of Rs.
2000/-.
This,
according
to
State
Counsel
was
necessitated because of :
(i)
Financial constraint, as huge financial
burden would have befallen upon the State
in passing on benefit of pay upgradation
even to persons who were to be appointed
in future as there are as many as 2306
sanctioned posts of Health Worker (Female)
and 855 posts of Health Worker (Male) and
members of other services would have
claimed parity with Health Workers.
(ii)
Scale of Rs. 5200-20200, Grade Pay Rs.
2800/- is payable to Health Supervisor
(Male/Female), which is promotional post
available to Health Worker (Male/Female),
and difference in pay scale has to be
maintained between feeder post and
promotional post, as such while upgrading
pay scale of existing employees serving on
the post of Health Worker in terms of
judgment, State Government decided not to
extend benefit of pay up-gradation to future
appointees.
19. Learned
State
Counsel
Government
Order
dated
relies
on
para
of
02.05.2013,
where
it
is
provided that revised scale shall be given to existing
employees as personal pay. Thus it is contended that
after pay revision, post of Health Worker (Male/Female)
carries pay scale of Rs. 5200-20200, Grade Pay Rs.
2026:UHC:4898
2000/-; however, Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/- is payable as
personal pay to those who were serving on the date of
issuance of Government Order dated 02.05.2013, in
deference
to
the
judgment
rendered
by
Hon’ble
Allahabad High Court, which attained finality. Thus he
contends that there is rationale for paying Grade Pay of
Rs. 2800/- to persons who were covered by the
judgment.
20. Learned State Counsel submits that petitioners are
wrongly invoking principle of ‘equal pay for equal work’,
as pay scale prescribed for the post of Health Worker is
Rs. 5200-20200/-, Grade Pay Rs. 2000/- which is paid to
petitioners also; there is a small group of persons
serving on the post of Health Worker who are being paid
Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/- as personal pay, in view of
decision of Hon’ble Allahabad High Court. Thus it is
contended that petitioners cannot claim parity with
Health Workers, who were serving on 02.05.2013 when
impugned Government Order was issued.
21. Learned State Counsel thus submits that petitioners
are not entitled to claim parity with persons who are
covered by the judgment rendered by Hon’ble Allahabad
High Court in Writ Petition No. 15904 of 1983.
22. It is contended by learned State Counsel that
Article 14 provides that equals should be treated
equally, therefore treating unequals as equal would be
viloative of Article 14. He submits that persons who
were party to the writ petition decided by Hon’ble
Allahabad
High
Court
constitute
a
separate
class,
therefore, persons appointed as Health Worker after
2026:UHC:4898
02.05.2013, who are not protected by that decision
constitute a separate class and they do not have a
vested right to get the same Grade Pay which is granted
as special pay to persons who are covered by the
judgement He submits that grant of Special Pay to those
who are covered by decision of Court is justified as they
deserved to be treated differently and State is not bound
to extend the same benefit to all Health Workers.
23. Learned State Counsel thus contends that law
permits differential treatment if the two groups are
inherently different and the classification in such cases is
reasonable. He submits that Special Pay is given to an
employee due to some reason which distinguishes him
from other members of service. Thus according to him,
claim staked by petitioners for Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/which is given as Special Pay, is unsustainable.
24. Learned State Counsel relies upon the judgment
rendered by Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Punjab State Electricity Board and Another Vs.
Thana Singh and Others, reported as (2019) 4 SCC
113 for contending that decision regarding revision or
equation of pay scales has to be taken by the executive
alone and there is no scope for judicial review in such
matters.
25. Learned
State
Counsel
also
relies
upon
the
judgment rendered by Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of S.C. Chandra and others Vs. State of
Jharkhand and others reported as (2007) 8 SCC 279
for contending that while fixing pay scales, executive
has to bear in mind various aspects, viz its financial
2026:UHC:4898
capacity, duty, responsibility, educational qualification,
mode of appointment for the post, therefore Court
should exercise judicial restraint. Para 20, 21, 26,27,28,
33, 34, 35 and 36 of the said judgment are reproduced
below:
“20. After going through the order of the Division Bench we are
of opinion that the view taken by the Division Bench of the
High Court is correct. Firstly, the school is not being managed
by BCCL as from the facts it is more than clear that BCCL was
only extending financial assistance from time to time. By that it
cannot be saddled with the liability to pay these teachers of the
school as being paid to the clerks working with BCCL or in the
Government of Jharkhand. It is essentially a school managed by
a body independent of the management of BCCL. Therefore,
BCCL cannot be saddled with the responsibilities of granting
the teachers the salaries equated to that of the clerks working in
BCCL.
21. Learned counsel for the appellants have relied on Article
39(d) of the Constitution. Article 39(d) does not mean that all
the teachers working in the school should be equated with the
clerks in BCCL or the Government of Jharkhand for application
of the principle of equal pay for equal work. There should be
total identity between both groups i.e. the teachers of the school
on the one hand and the clerks in BCCL, and as such the
teachers cannot be equated with the clerks of the State
Government or of BCCL. The question of application of Article
39(d) of the Constitution has recently been interpreted by this
Court in State of Haryana v. Charanjit Singh [(2006) 9 SCC
321 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 1804] wherein Their Lordships have put
the entire controversy to rest and held that the principle, “equal
pay for equal work” must satisfy the test that the incumbents are
performing equal and identical work as discharged by
employees against whom the equal pay is claimed. Their
Lordships have reviewed all the cases bearing on the subject
and after a detailed discussion have finally put the controversy
to rest that the persons who claimed the parity should satisfy the
court that the conditions are identical and equal and same duties
are being discharged by them. Though a number of cases were
cited for our consideration but no useful purpose will be served
as in Charanjit Singh [(2006) 9 SCC 321 : 2006 SCC (L&S)
1804] all these cases have been reviewed by this Court. More
so, when we have already held that the appellants are not the
employees of BCCL, there is no question seeking any parity of
the pay with that of the clerks of BCCL.
26. Fixation of pay scale is a delicate mechanism which requires
various
considerations
including
financial
capacity,
2026:UHC:4898
responsibility, educational qualification, mode of appointment,
etc. and it has a cascading effect. Hence, in subsequent
decisions of this Court the principle of equal pay for equal work
has been considerably watered down, and it has hardly ever
been applied by this Court in recent years.
27. Thus, in State of Haryana v. Tilak Raj [(2003) 6 SCC 123 :
2003 SCC (L&S) 828] it was held that the principle can only
apply if there is complete and wholesale identity between the
two groups. Even if the employees in the two groups are doing
identical work they cannot be granted equal pay if there is no
complete and wholesale identity e.g. a daily-rated employee
may be doing the same work as a regular employee, yet he
cannot be granted the same pay scale. Similarly, two groups of
employees may be doing the same work, yet they may be given
different pay scales if the educational qualifications are
different. Also, pay scale can be different if the nature of jobs,
responsibilities, experience, method of recruitment, etc. are
different.
28. In State of Haryana v. Charanjit Singh [(2006) 9 SCC 321 :
2006 SCC (L&S) 1804] discussing a large number of earlier
decisions it was held by a three-Judge Bench of this Court that
the principle of equal pay for equal work cannot apply unless
there is complete and wholesale identity between the two
groups. Moreover, even for finding out whether there is
complete and wholesale identity, the proper forum is an expert
body and not the writ court, as this requires extensive evidence.
A mechanical interpretation of the principle of equal pay for
equal work creates great practical difficulties. Hence in recent
decisions the Supreme Court has considerably watered down
the principle of equal pay for equal work and this principle has
hardly been ever applied in recent decisions.
33. It may be mentioned that granting pay scales is a purely
executive function and hence the court should not interfere with
the same. It may have a cascading effect creating all kinds of
problems for the Government and authorities. Hence, the court
should exercise judicial restraint and not interfere in such
executive function vide Indian Drugs & Pharmaceuticals
Ltd. v. Workmen [(2007) 1 SCC 408 : (2007) 1 SCC (L&S)
270] .
34. There is broad separation of powers under the Constitution,
and the judiciary should not ordinarily encroach into the
executive or legislative domain. The theory of separation of
powers, first propounded by the French philosopher
Montesquieu in his book The Spirit of Laws still broadly holds
the field in India today. Thus, in Asif Hameed v. State of
J&K [1989 Supp (2) SCC 364 : AIR 1989 SC 1899] a three-
2026:UHC:4898
Judge Bench of this Court observed (vide paras 17 to 19): (SCC
pp. 373-74)
“17. Before adverting to the controversy directly involved in
these appeals we may have a fresh look at the inter se
functioning of the three organs of democracy under our
Constitution. Although the doctrine of separation of powers has
not been recognised under the Constitution in its absolute
rigidity but the Constitution makers have meticulously defined
the functions of various organs of the State. Legislature,
executive and judiciary have to function within their own
spheres demarcated under the Constitution. No organ can usurp
the functions assigned to another. The Constitution trusts to the
judgment of these organs to function and exercise their
discretion by strictly following the procedure prescribed therein.
The functioning of democracy depends upon the strength and
independence of each of its organs. Legislature and executive,
the two facets of people's will, they have all the powers
including that of finance. Judiciary has no power over sword or
the purse nonetheless it has power to ensure that the aforesaid
two main organs of State function within the constitutional
limits. It is the sentinel of democracy. Judicial review is a
powerful weapon to restrain unconstitutional exercise of power
by the legislature and executive. The expanding horizon of
judicial review has taken in its fold the concept of social and
economic justice. While exercise of powers by the legislature
and executive is subject to judicial restraint, the only check on
our own exercise of power is the self-imposed discipline of
judicial restraint.
18. Frankfurter, J. of the U.S. Supreme Court dissenting in the
controversial expatriation case of Trop v. Dulles [2 L Ed 2d 630
: 356 US 86 (1958)] observed as under: (US pp. 119-20)
‘All power is, in Madison's phrase, “of an encroaching nature”.
… Judicial power is not immune against this human weakness.
It also must be on guard against encroaching beyond its proper
bounds, and not the less so since the only restraint upon it is
self-restraint. …
Rigorous observance of the difference between limits of power
and wise exercise of power—between questions of authority
and questions of prudence—requires the most alert appreciation
of this decisive but subtle relationship of two concepts that too
easily coalesce. No less does it require a disciplined will to
adhere to the difference. It is not easy to stand aloof and allow
want of wisdom to prevail, to disregard one's own strongly held
view of what is wise in the conduct of affairs. But it is not the
business of this Court to pronounce policy. It must observe a
fastidious regard for limitations on its own power, and this
precludes the Court's giving effect to its own notions of what is
wise or politic. That self-restraint is of the essence in the
observance of the judicial oath, for the Constitution has not
2026:UHC:4898
authorised the judges to sit in judgment on the wisdom of what
Congress and the Executive Branch do.’
19. When a State action is challenged, the function of the court
is to examine the action in accordance with law and to
determine whether the legislature or the executive has acted
within the powers and functions assigned under the Constitution
and if not, the court must strike down the action. While doing so
the court must remain within its self-imposed limits. The court
sits in judgment on the action of a coordinate branch of the
Government. While exercising power of judicial review of
administrative action, the court is not an appellate authority.
The Constitution does not permit the court to direct or advise
the executive in matters of policy or to sermonise qua any
matter which under the Constitution lies within the sphere of
legislature or executive, provided these authorities do not
transgress their constitutional limits or statutory powers.”
(emphasis supplied)
35. In our opinion fixing pay scales by courts by applying the
principle of equal pay for equal work upsets the high
constitutional principle of separation of powers between the
three organs of the State. Realising this, this Court has in recent
years avoided applying the principle of equal pay for equal
work, unless there is complete and wholesale identity between
the two groups (and there too the matter should be sent for
examination by an Expert Committee appointed by the
Government instead of the court itself granting higher pay).
36. It is well settled by the Supreme Court that only because the
nature of work is the same, irrespective of educational
qualification, mode of appointment, experience and other
relevant factors, the principle of equal pay for equal work
cannot apply vide Govt. of W.B. v. Tarun K. Roy [(2004) 1 SCC
347 : 2004 SCC (L&S) 225] .”
(emphasis supplied)
26. It
is
thus
contended
that
within
its
limited
resources it was not possible for the State Government
to grant Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/- to future appointees as
well, therefore State Government, while upgrading the
Grade Pay indicated in its decision that upgraded Grade
Pay shall not be admissible to Health Workers who are
appointed in future. Thus it is contended that petitioners
do not have any vested right to get the higher Grade
Pay which was given as personal pay to Health Workers
2026:UHC:4898
covered by the judgment. It is further contended that
petitioners are entitled to the pay scale as mentioned in
the Recruitment Rules, which is being paid to them.
27. Learned State Counsel also relies upon judgment
rendered by Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State
of Madhya Pradesh Vs. R.D. Sharma and others,
reported as (2022) 13 SCC 320. Para 17 and 18 of the
said judgment is reproduced below:
“17. It may be noted that this Court has
consistently held that the equation of post and
determination of pay scales is the primary
function of the executive and not the judiciary and
therefore ordinarily courts will not enter upon the
task of job evaluation which is generally left to
the expert bodies like the Pay Commissions. This
is because such job evaluation exercise may
include various factors including the relevant data
and scales for evaluating performances of
different groups of employees, and such
evaluation would be both difficult and time
consuming,
apart
from
carrying
financial
implications. Therefore, it has always been held to
be more prudent to leave such task of equation of
post and determination of pay scales to be best
left to an expert body. Unless there is cogent
material on record to come to a firm conclusion
that a grave error had crept in while fixing the
pay scale for a given post, and that the court's
interference was absolutely necessary to undo the
injustice, the courts would not interfere with such
complex issues. A beneficial reference of the
observations made in this regard in Secy.,
Finance
Deptt. v. W.B.
Registration
Service
Assn. [Secy., Finance Deptt. v. W.B. Registration
Service Assn., 1993 Supp (1) SCC 153 : 1993
SCC (L&S) 157] be made. As held in State of
Haryana v. Haryana Civil Secretariat Personal
Staff Assn. [State of Haryana v. Haryana Civil
Secretariat Personal Staff Assn., (2002) 6 SCC 72
: 2002 SCC (L&S) 822] “equal pay for equal work”
is not a fundamental right vested in any
employee, though it is a constitutional goal to be
achieved by the Government.
18. Pertinently the Administrative Tribunal after
considering the relevant factual and legal aspects
2026:UHC:4898
had rightly rejected the claim of Respondent 1 for
granting the apex scale on the basis of “equal pay
for equal work” in the OA filed by him. The said
well-considered, just and proper order of the
Tribunal was wrongly set aside by the High Court
on extraneous grounds applying the principle of
“equal pay for equal work”, while exercising the
power of superintendence under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India. It is well-settled legal
position that the power under Article 227 is
intended to be used sparingly and only in
appropriate cases for the purpose of keeping the
subordinate courts and tribunals within the
bounds of their authority and not for correcting
mere errors. In the instant case, the Tribunal had
not committed any jurisdictional error, nor any
failure of justice had occasioned, and hence the
interference of the High Court in the order passed
by the Tribunal was absolutely unwarranted.”
28. Learned
State
Counsel
further
submits
that
petitioners were appointed after 2018 and in the
advertisements, in response to which they applied, it
was clearly mentioned that upon appointment, they shall
get salary in the scale of Rs. 5200-20200, Grade Pay Rs.
2000/-. Thus it is submitted that petitioners’ claim for
higher pay scale is without any substance and is barred
by
principle
of
estoppel
and
acquisance,
as
they
accepted the appointment, without demur when it was
offered to them.
29. Learned State Counsel submits that petitioners
were given appointment in the pay scale indicated in the
advertisement; therefore, it cannot be contended that
their condition of service was altered or they were
offered appointment on a pay scale lower than what was
indicated in the advertisement. Thus, it is contended
that none of the vested or accrued right of the
petitioners is violated and petitioners are getting salary
strictly as per the scale indicated in the advertisement
2026:UHC:4898
and the Recruitment Rules applicable to the post of
Health Worker (Male/Female).
30. Learned State Counsel further submits that “equal
pay for equal work” is not a fundamental right vested in
an employee, although it is a constitutional goal to be
achieved by the Government, as held by Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of State of Madhya Pradesh
Vs. R.D. Sharma (supra).
31. Learned State Counsel also relied upon the law
declared by Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case Punjab
State Electricity Board and Another Vs. Thana
Singh and Others, reported as (2019) 4 SCC 113.
Para 10, 11 and 12 of the said judgment are reproduced
below:
10. It is fairly well settled that equation of pay scales
must be left to the Government and on the decision of
the experts and the Court should not interfere with it.
Observing that equation of pay scales of posts must be
left
to
the
Government
and
the
experts,
in SAIL v. Dibyendu
Bhattacharya [SAIL v. Dibyendu
Bhattacharya, (2011) 11 SCC 122 : (2011) 2 SCC (L&S)
192] , this Court held as under: (SCC p. 133, para 26)
“26. In Union of India v. S.L. Dutta [Union of India v. S.L.
Dutta, (1991) 1 SCC 505 : 1991 SCC (L&S) 406] , Union of
India v. N.Y. Apte [Union of India v. N.Y. Apte, (1998) 6 SCC
741 : 1998 SCC (L&S) 1673] , State of U.P. v. J.P.
Chaurasia [State of U.P. v. J.P. Chaurasia, (1989) 1 SCC 121 :
1989 SCC (L&S) 71] and Kshetriya Kisan Gramin Bank v. D.B.
Sharma [Kshetriya Kisan Gramin Bank v. D.B. Sharma, (2001)
1 SCC 353 : 2001 SCC (L&S) 1000] , this Court held that the
determination that two posts are equal or not, is a job of the
Expert Committee and the court should not interfere with it
unless the decision of the Committee is found to be
unreasonable
or arbitrary or made
on extraneous
considerations. More so, it is an executive function to fix the
service conditions, etc. and lies within the exclusive domain of
the
rule-making
authority.
(See
also T.
Venkateswarulu v. Tirumala
Tirupathi
Devasthanams [T.
Venkateswarulu v. Tirumala Tirupathi Devasthanams, (2009)
1 SCC 546 : (2009) 1 SCC (L&S) 202] .)”
2026:UHC:4898
11. In S.C.
Chandra v. State
of
Jharkhand [S.C.
Chandra v. State of Jharkhand, (2007) 8 SCC 279 :
(2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 897] , observing that the grant of
pay scales is a purely executive function and the court
should not interfere with the same, this Court held as
under: (SCC pp. 292-94, paras 33 & 35)
“33. It may be mentioned that granting pay scales is a purely
executive function and hence the court should not interfere
with the same. It may have a cascading effect creating all
kinds of problems for the Government and authorities. Hence,
the court should exercise judicial restraint and not interfere in
such executive function vide Indian Drugs & Pharmaceuticals
Ltd. v. Workmen [Indian
Drugs
&
Pharmaceuticals
Ltd. v. Workmen, (2007) 1 SCC 408 : (2007) 1 SCC (L&S)
270] .
***
35. In our opinion fixing pay scales by courts by applying the
principle of equal pay for equal work upsets the high
constitutional principle of separation of powers between the
three organs of the State. Realising this, this Court has in
recent years avoided applying the principle of equal pay for
equal work, unless there is complete and wholesale identity
between the two groups (and there too the matter should be
sent for examination by an Expert Committee appointed by
the Government instead of the court itself granting higher
pay).”
(emphasis in original)
12. Observing that granting parity in pay scales depends
upon the comparative evaluation of job and equation of
posts,
this
Court,
in SAIL [SAIL v. Dibyendu
Bhattacharya, (2011) 11 SCC 122 : (2011) 2 SCC (L&S)
192] , held as under: (SCC pp. 133-34, para 30)
“30. … the law on the issue can be summarised to the effect
that parity of pay can be claimed by invoking the provisions of
Articles 14 and 39(d) of the Constitution of India by
establishing that the eligibility, mode of selection/recruitment,
nature and quality of work and duties and effort, reliability,
confidentiality, dexterity, functional need and responsibilities
and status of both the posts are identical. The functions may
be the same but the skills and responsibilities may be really
and substantially different. The other post may not require
any higher qualification, seniority or other like factors.
Granting parity in pay scales depends upon the comparative
evaluation of job and equation of posts. The person claiming
parity must plead necessary averments and prove that all
things are equal between the posts concerned. Such a
complex issue cannot be adjudicated by evaluating the
affidavits filed by the parties.”
2026:UHC:4898
32. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners however
contends that once State Government accepted the
report submitted by the Committee and decided in 2010
to upgrade the scale to Rs. 5200-20200 Grade Pay Rs.
2800/-, in respect of existing members of service, then
pay scale for the post of Health Worker (Male/Female)
should have been revised and benefit of pay revision
could not have been limited to persons who were serving
as Health Worker and were party to Writ Petition No.
15904 of 1983.
33. Learned State Counsel contends that while taking
decision regarding pay revision, State Government has
to consider various aspects, including financial capacity.
He submits that there are 2306 sanctioned post of
Health Worker (Female), 855 sanctioned post of Health
Worker (Male) besides 897 post of Health Supervisor
(Male/Female),
therefore,
having
regard
to
huge
financial burden which would have befallen upon the
State by upgrading pay scale to Rs. 5200-20200 Grade
Pay Rs. 2800/-, it was decided to grant benefit of the
judgment rendered by Hon’ble Allahabad High Court by
upgrading Grade Pay of persons who were party to Writ
Petition No. 15904 of 1983 and for others, who were to
be appointed in future, it was provided that they shall
get salary in the pay scale of
Rs. 5200-20200, Grade
Pay Rs. 2000/-.
34. Learned State Counsel contends that petitioners do
not have any vested or legally enforceable right to get
salary in the pay scale of 5200-20200 Grade Pay Rs.
2800/-, when the advertisement and Service Rules
2026:UHC:4898
clearly provide that they shall get salary in the pay scale
of Rs. 5200-20200, Grade Pay of Rs. 2000/-.
35. Learned State Counsel further submits that a
Government servant, upon appointment, acquires a
status and his/her service conditions can then be altered
by State Government by amending the Service Rules. In
reply to challenge to Appendix-B of the Service Rules,
learned State Counsel relies upon para 18, 19 and 20 of
the judgment rendered by Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of Union of India and others Vs. Arun Kumar
Roy reported as (1986) 1 SCC 675. Para 18, 19 and
20 of the said judgment are reproduced below:
“18. The question whether the terms embodied in the order
of appointment should govern the service conditions of
employees in government service or the Rules governing
them is not an open question now. It is now well settled
that a government servant whose appointment though
originates in a contract, acquires a status and thereafter is
governed by his service rules and not by the terms of
contract. The powers of the government under Article 309
to make rules, to regulate the service conditions of its
employees are very wide and unfettered. These powers can
be exercised unilaterally without the consent of the
employees concerned. It will, therefore, be idle to contend
that in the case of employees under the government, the
terms of the contract of appointment should prevail over
the Rules governing their service conditions. The origin of
government service often times is contractual. There is
always an offer and acceptance, thus bringing it to being a
completed contract between the government and its
employees. Once appointed, a government servant
acquires a status and thereafter his position is not one
governed by the contract of appointment. Public law
governing service conditions steps in to regulate the
relationship between the employer and employee. His
emoluments and other service conditions are thereafter
regulated by the appropriate statutory authority
empowered to do so. Such regulation is permissible in law
unilaterally without reciprocal consent. This Court made
this clear in two judgments rendered by two Constitution
Benches of this Court in Roshan Lal Tandon v. Union of
India [AIR 1967 SC 1889 : (1968) 1 SCR 185] and
in State of J&K v. Triloki Nath Khosa [(1974) 1 SCC 19 :
2026:UHC:4898
1974 SCC (L&S) 49 : AIR 1974 SC 1 : (1974) 1 SCR 771]
.
19. Thus it is clear and not open to doubt that the terms
and conditions of the service of an employee under the
government who enters service on a contract, will once he
is appointed, be governed by the Rules governing his
service conditions. It will not be permissible thereafter for
him to rely upon the terms of contract which are not in
consonance with the Rules governing the service.
20. The powers of the government under Article 309 of the
Constitution to make rules regulating the service
conditions of the government employees cannot, in any
manner, be fettered by any agreement. The respondent
cannot, therefore, succeed either on the terms of the
contract or on the notification on which the High Court has
relied upon. Nor can he press into service the Rule of
estoppel against the government.”
36. Learned State Counsel relies upon the judgment
rendered by this Court in Writ Petition (SB) No. 297 of
2020 where it was held that Government can alter the
conditions of service of its employees unilaterally and
consent of the Government employees is not a pre
requisite
for
validity of the rules of service,
the
contractual origin of the service notwithstanding. Para 6
and 7 of the said judgment are reproduced below:
“6. It is well settled that though employment under the
Government like under any other master may have a
contractual origin, the Government servant acquires a
status' on appointment to his office. As a result, his rights
and obligations are liable to be determined under statutory
or constitutional authority which for, its exercise, requires
no reciprocal consent. The Government can alter the terms
and conditions of its employees unilaterally and though in
modern times consensus in matters relating to public
services is often attempted to be achieved, consent is not a
pre-condition for the validity of rules of service, the
contractual origin of the service notwithstanding. Where a
party seeks to impeach validity of a rule made by a
competent authority on the ground that the rules offend
Article 14, the burden is on him to plead and prove the
infirmity. There is always a presumption in favour of the
constitutionality of an enactment and the burden is upon
him who attacks it to show that there has been a clear
transgression of the constitutional principles. The burden
2026:UHC:4898
thus, is on the petitioners to set out facts necessary to
sustain the plea of discrimination and to adduce "cogent and
convincing evidence" to prove those facts for "there is a
presumption that every factor which is relevant or material
has been taken into account by the rule making authority
while framing the Rules. Unless the classification is unjust
on the face of it, the onus lies-upon the party attacking the
classification to show by pleading the necessary material
that the said classification is unreasonable and violative of
Article 16 of the Constitution.
7. In the case of The State of Jammu & Kashmir vs Shri
Triloki Nath Khosa & others, reported in 1974 (1) SCC 19,
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that “discrimination is the
essence of classification and does violence to the
constitutional guarantee of equality only if it rests on an
unreasonable basis. It was, therefore, incumbent on the
respondents to plead and show that the classification of
Assistant Engineers into those who hold diplomas and those
who hold degrees is unreasonable and bears no rational
nexus with its purported object. Rather than do this, the
respondents contented themselves by propounding an
abstract theory that educational qualifications are germane
at the stage of initial recruitment only. Omission to furnish
the necessary particulars was construed by this Court in two
cases as indicating that the plea of unlawful discrimination
had no basis. Such an infirmity in pleadings led this Court in
State of Madhya Pradesh v. Bhopal Sugar Industries Ltd. to
remand the matter to the High Court in order to enable the
petitioner therein to amend its petition. Mr. Garg asked for a
remand so that the respondents could have an opportunity
to plead the necessary facts but we declined to do so as we
did not propose to allow the appeal on the narrow ground
that the respondents' plea of discrimination was
inadequate.”
37. Learned State Counsel submits that there is no
change or alteration in the service conditions or pay
scale of the petitioners after their appointment. He
submits that Service Rules were enforced in 2016 and
petitioners
were
appointed
thereafter
and
in
the
advertisement, the same pay scale was mentioned which
is being paid to the petitioners.
38. This Court finds substance in the contentions raised
by learned State Counsel.
2026:UHC:4898
39. Even though Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/- as Special
Pay was given to Health Workers, who were appointed
before reorganisation of the State, in terms of judgment
rendered by Hon’ble Allahabad High Court; however, it
was a special benefit given to them for historical
reasons. It is not in dispute that pay scale of Health
Workers was fixed as Rs. 5200-20200, Grade Pay Rs.
2000/-, therefore, claim of petitioners for same Grade
Pay, as was given to other set of persons as Special Pay,
is unsustainable for the following reasons:
i.
Petitioners cannot claim parity with others
who on the strength of judgment rendered by
Hon’ble Allahabad High Court were given
Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/- as personal pay.
Petitioners were appointed after 02.05.2013
when it was decided that appointments in
future shall be made in the pay scale of Rs.
5200-20200, Grade Pay of Rs. 2000/- and as
per the Recruitment Rules framed in 2016,
Grade Pay of Rs. 2000/- is payable for the
post of Health Worker.
ii.
Petitioners participated in the selection held
pursuant to advertisements issued in the year
2016 and thereafter, and the pay scale
applicable for the post of Health Worker was
clearly mentioned as Rs. 5200-20200, Grade
Pay Rs. 2000/- in those advertisements.
iii.
Petitioners applied in response to such
advertisements with eyes wide open and the
pay scale mentioned in the advertisement is
being paid to them, therefore they cannot
have any grievance that they are being paid
salary on a lower pay scale. Moreover, they
were offered appointment in the same pay
scale which they accepted without any demur,
thus they cannot now contend that they are
being treated unfairly.
iv.
It is not their case that their pay scale has
been reduced after appointment. The decision
to grant higher grade pay as personal pay to
2026:UHC:4898
existing members of service was taken much
before petitioners’ selection and appointment,
thus they cannot now question the decision
taken by Government after so many years of
service.
40. Even though, petitioners are serving as Health
Worker and their duties and responsibilities may be
similar to those discharged by the other set of persons;
however, difference in their pay scale is due to historical
reasons.
Other group of persons are covered by the
judgment rendered by Hon’ble Allahabad High Court
which led to revision of their Grade Pay, however,
petitioners are differently situate. State Government
decided to grant Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/- to other group
of persons as personal pay, appointments on the post of
Health Worker were to be made in Grade Pay of Rs.
2000/-. Thus it is not a case of hostile discrimination as
alleged.
41. State Government has to consider various aspects
while determining pay scales and the first and foremost
consideration is financial capacity of the State. As per
Recruitment Rules, there are 2306 sanctioned post of
Health Worker (Female) and 855 posts of Health Worker
(Male)
besides
(Male/Female).
Having
posts
regard
of
to
Health
Supervisor
large
number
of
employees serving as Health Worker, State Government
decided to grant Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/- as Special Pay,
only to existing members of service. However, for
persons who were to be appointed as Health Worker in
future, decision was taken that they shall get salary in
the pay scale of Rs. 5200-20200, Grade Pay Rs. 2000/-.
2026:UHC:4898
42. Since salary has to be paid by State Government
from its limited resources and giving Grade Pay of Rs.
2800/-
to
all
Health
Workers,
including
future
appointees, would have fastened huge financial liability
upon the State, therefore, Government in its wisdom
took the decision as is contained in Government Order
dated 02.05.2013.
43. Interference with the decision taken by State
Government would not be proper in view of the law
declared by Apex Court that determination of pay scales
is primary function of the executive and while exercising
power of judicial review, Courts should not enter upon
the task of fixation of pay.
44. Article 14 of the Constitution of India provides that
equals cannot be treated unequally; however, it also
ordains that unequals cannot be treated equally. Health
Workers who were in service before 02.05.2013 were
given Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/- as Special Pay pursuant
to judgment rendered by Hon’ble Allahabad High Court.
Petitioners are not protected by that judgment; State
Government decided to fix pay scale for the post of
Health Worker as Rs. 5200-20200, Grade Pay Rs. 2000/Since there are two set of persons, one which is covered
by judgment and the other is not covered by the
judgment. State Government decided to give Grade Pay
of Rs. 2800/-, as personal pay, to the first set of persons
and for others, it was decided that they shall be entitled
to scale of Rs. 5200-20200, Grade Pay Rs. 2000/-.
45. Even though at first blush, difference in pay scale
between two group of persons discharging similar duties
2026:UHC:4898
appears to be unreasonable; however, upon deeper
scrutiny, one finds that there is intelligible differentia
and grant of Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/- as personal pay to
the persons who are covered by judgment cannot be
termed as unreasonable. Thus the classification has
reasonable nexus with the object sought to be achieved.
46. The argument of hostile discrimination could be
sustained, only if State Government made classification
amongst
persons
serving
as
Health
Worker
on
02.05.2013. The Government Order treats all serving
Health Workers as forming one homogeneous class by
providing them Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/- as personal pay.
The said Grade pay, however, is not payable to persons
who are appointed in future. The grant of Grade Pay of
Rs. 2800/- as personal pay to persons who were in
service on 02.05.2013 cannot be said to be arbitrary as
it was given to them pursuant to a judgment. Thus the
challenge thrown by petitioners to Government Order
dated
02.05.2013
is
without
any
force.
Similarly,
challenge thrown by petitioners to Appendix-B of the
Recruitment Rules which lays down the scales admissible
for the post is also unsustainable. The said Rules were
famed much before petitioners were appointed.
47. Appendix-B does not make any distinction amongst
Health Workers and Pay Scale of Rs. 5200-20200, Grade
pay Rs. 2000/- is admissible across the board for the
post of Health Worker. Health Workers who were
appointed before 02.05.2013, however, are to be given
Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/- as personal pay, while pay scale
mentioned in the Rules is admissible for the post of
Health
Worker.
In
the
advertisement,
whereby
2026:UHC:4898
applications were invited, the pay scale as mentioned in
the Rules was indicated. It is nobody’s case that
appointment was offered to the petitioners on a lower
scale or their scale was reduced after appointment.
48. After applying for the post of Health Worker
pursuant to the advertisement, in which pay scale was
mentioned
and
after
having
accepted
offer
of
appointment in the pay scale of Rs. 5200-20200, Grade
Pay Rs. 2000/-, claim staked by petitioners for Grade
Pay of Rs. 2800/-, is unsustainable.
49. Thus, the reliefs claimed by petitioners cannot be
granted. Writ petitions fail and are dismissed.
(Manoj Kumar Tiwari, J.)
16.06.2026
Mahinder/
MAHINDER SINGH
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=da6212e6e78d94ed3134842bc6a8d6ca168979ca7b8c2f031a92d1a18b08923c,
postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=AB77B7C5B240908B392BE84F5CDD4C2AF35DC4626D305B1BC9EA4BABA4
3D2B8F, cn=MAHINDER SINGH
Date: 2026.06.16 19:59:41 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review