Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:1369-DB
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Writ Petition Service Bench No.342 of 2020
26 February, 2026
Madan Mohan Singh Pundir and Ors.
--Petitioners
Versus
State Public Service Tribunal Uttarakhand and Ors.
--Respondents
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Presence:
Mr. M.C. Pant, learned counsel for petitioners.
Mr. Rajeev Singh Bisht, learned Additional C.S.C. for the State
of Uttarakhand.
Mr. Sagar Kumar, learned counsel holding brief of Mr. Harendra
Belwal, learned counsel for respondent Nos.4 to 21.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Coram: Hon’ble Manoj Kumar Tiwari, J. (Oral)
Hon’ble Pankaj Purohit, J.
Petitioners have challenged the judgment and
order dated 30.09.2020 rendered by Uttarakhand Public
Services Tribunal in Claim Petition No.31/DB/2019
Madan Mohan Singh Pundir and Others Vs. State of
Uttarakhand and Others, whereby, their claim petition
challenging Final Seniority List of Assistant Engineers
issued on 08.05.2018, was dismissed.
2.
Learned Tribunal held that Rule 8 of the
Uttarakhand Government Servants Seniority Rules, 2002
(hereinafter to be referred as ‘the Seniority Rules 2002’)
would be applicable and as the private respondents were
recommended for promotion to the post of Assistant
Engineer
in
substantive
earlier
selection
and
appointment/promotion
order
of
to
post
the
their
of
Assistant Engineer was also issued earlier, therefore,
they cannot be treated as junior to the petitioners.
3.
The facts on which there is no dispute is that
petitioners possess Diploma in Engineering and they
were appointed as Junior Engineer (Civil) by separate
orders issued in the year 1985, while private respondents
2026:UHC:1369-DB
were appointed as Junior Engineer (Civil) and Junior
Engineer (Technical) in later years.
4.
State Government has framed separate Rules
for regulating mode of appointment to the post of Junior
Engineer (Civil), while appointment to the post of
Assistant Engineer (Civil), is governed by Uttaranchal
Public Works Department Assistant Engineer (Civil)
Service Rules 2003, as amended from time to time.
5.
Under the Rules applicable for the post of
Assistant Engineer (Civil), Junior Engineer (Civil), who
possess B.E./B.Tech or equivalent qualification are given,
separate quota for promotion to the post of Assistant
Engineer (Civil) to the extent of 8.33%, similarly, Junior
Engineer (Technical) possessing bachelors degree in
Engineering are also entitled to separate quota for
promotion to the extent of 1.67%.
6.
Since, private respondents possess B.Tech. or
equivalent qualification, therefore, they were considered
for promotion against degree holders quota posts and
they were given accelerated promotion to the post of
Assistant Engineer (Civil) in 2010.
7.
It is not in dispute that private respondents
were considered for promotion to the post of Assistant
Engineer
against
qualification
the
holders
posts
and
earmarked
they
were
for
higher
promoted
as
Assistant Engineer vide order dated 30.11.2010, while
petitioners were promoted as Assistant Engineer under a
separate quota only on 13.08.2013. In other words,
private respondents were promoted as Assistant Engineer
during Recruitment Year 2010-11 while petitioners were
so promoted during Recruitment Year 2013-14.
8.
Learned Tribunal held that petitioners were
2026:UHC:1369-DB
promoted to the post of Assistant Engineer in subsequent
selection; the post of Assistant Engineer is a separate
service governed by different set of Rules, therefore,
petitioners
who
were
considered
and
promoted
in
subsequent Recruitment Year cannot be treated as senior
to the private respondents, who were promoted in 2010.
9.
As per Rule 5 of Uttaranchal Public Works
Department Assistant Engineer (Civil) Service Rules,
2003, as amended from time to time, there are following
sources of recruitment for the post of Assistant Engineer:
a) 40%
by
direct
recruitment
through
the
commission.
b) 45% by promotion based on seniority of Junior
Engineer (Civil) who have completed 7 years of
satisfactory service as such.
c) 8.33% by promotion of Junior Engineers (Civil)
who have completed 5 years of satisfactory service
and who possess educational qualification as
mentioned in Rule 8.
d) 5% by promotion based on seniority of Junior
Engineers
(Technical/Computer)
who
have
completed 7 years of satisfactory service.
e) 1.67% by promotion amongst Junior Engineers
(Technical/Computer) who have competed 5 years
of
satisfactory
service
and
who possess
educational qualification as mentioned in Rule 8.
10.
Thus, it is apparent that there are five different
sources of recruitment for the post of Assistant Engineer
(Civil). Petitioners were promoted under 45% quota
available to diploma holder Junior Engineers; while
private respondents were promoted under the quota
meant for Junior Engineers, who possess B.Tech or
equivalent qualification.
11.
Petitioners were promoted under Rule 5(b)
while private respondents were promoted under Rule 5(c)
and 5(e) of the Rules. Rule 5(a) provides for direct
recruitment to the post of Assistant Engineers, therefore,
2026:UHC:1369-DB
learned Tribunal rightly held that Rule 7 of the Seniority
Rules 2002 will not have any application to the facts of
the present case, as the said Provision would apply to
cases where promotion is the only mode of appointment.
Admittedly, 40% post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) are
required to be filled by direct recruitment through Public
Service Commission, therefore, learned Tribunal was
right in holding that Rule 8 of the Seniority Rules 2002
would be attracted.
12.
Learned counsel for petitioners then submitted
that Rule 8(2)(b) of the Seniority Rules 2002 incorporates
the principal of catching up by referring to Rule 6 and 7,
thus, anyone who is senior in the feeding cadre will
regain his seniority upon promotion to the post of
Assistant Engineer. Thus, he submits that petitioners will
regain seniority upon promotion as Assistant Engineer
and this aspect was overlooked by learned Tribunal.
13.
The submission made by learned counsel for
petitioners is unsustainable for the following reasons:1) Rule
8(1)
of
the
Seniority
Rules
contemplates a situation where appointments to a
post are to be made both by promotion as well as
by direct recruitment and provides that seniority
of persons appointed on different dates shall be
determined with reference to the date of order of
their substantive appointment; however if two or
more persons are appointed by a common order,
then the order in which their names are arranged
in the appointment order shall determine their
inter
se
seniority.
In
the
present
case,
appointments to the post of Assistant Engineer
(Civil) are required to be made both by direct
recruitment and by promotion, therefore, Rule
8(1) would be attracted as it provides that inter se
2026:UHC:1369-DB
seniority of petitioners and private respondents
will be determined based on the date of order of
their substantive appointment to the post of
Assistant Engineer. Admittedly, petitioners were
promoted as Assistant Engineer on 13.08.2013
while private respondents were promoted as
Assistant Engineer on 30.11.2010, therefore,
private respondents will be treated as senior on
the promoted post of Assistant Engineer as order
of their substantive appointment was issued
nearly three years earlier.
2) Situation
contemplated
in
first
and
second
proviso to Rule 8(1) is not present in the present
case, therefore, the provisos are not attracted to
the facts of the present case.
3) Rule 8(2) of the Seniority Rules 2002 is attracted
when two or more persons are appointed to a post
on the result of the same selection. In the present
case, petitioners were promoted as Assistant
Engineer pursuant to a selection held in 2013
while private respondents were so promoted on
recommendation of a selection committee which
met in 2010. Thus, by no stretch of imagination,
it can be argued that petitioners and private
respondents
were
appointed
as
Assistant
Engineer on the result of the same selection.
Thus, Rule 8(2) does not have any application to
the facts of the case.
14.
Learned counsel for the petitioners placed heavy
reliance upon Rule 8(2)(b) of the Seniority Rules 2002, which
is not applicable for reason indicated above. Contentions
raised by learned counsel for petitioners, if taken on face
value, also do not support the case of the petitioners.
Although, Rule 8(2)(b) provides that if two or more persons
are appointed by promotion to a post on the result of ‘any one
selection’, then their inter se seniority shall be determined as
2026:UHC:1369-DB
per the principles laid down in Rule 6 and Rule 7 of the
Seniority Rules 2002. Rule 6 of the Seniority Rules 2002
applies only when appointment are made only by promotion
from a single feeding cadre, which is not the case here. Rule 7
deals with a situation where appointment to a post has to be
made only by promotion, but from more than one feeding
cadres, and provides that inter se seniority of persons
appointed to that post ‘on the result on any one selection’
shall be determined according to the dates of order of their
substantive appointment in their respective feeding cadres.
Although, Rule 7 incorporates catching up rule and provides
that one who is senior in the feeding cadre, may regain
seniority on the promoted post, however, condition precedent
for application of catching up rule is that two or more persons
are promoted to a post on the result of the same selection.
Thus, Rule 8(2)(b) does not apply to the facts of the present
case and Rule 7, even if assumed to be applicable, do not
support the contention of the petitioners.
15.
From the aforesaid discussion, it is apparent that
there is no provision in the Seniority Rules 2002 which
supports the contention raised by the petitioners for claiming
seniority over the private respondents. Rule 8(2)(b) would
have been attracted if petitioners and private respondents
were promoted as Assistant Engineer in the same selection,
which is not the case. Rule 7 of the Service Rules is not
applicable because appointment to the post of Assistant
Engineer is made by direct recruitment also. Moreover, Rule 7
also contemplates appointment/promotion of two or more
persons on the result of same selection. Thus, the judgment
rendered by learned Tribunal, whereby claim petition filed by
the petitioners was dismissed, cannot be faulted.
16.
Learned
for
counsel
private
respondents
submits that earlier on 17.09.2013, a seniority list was
published in which petitioners were treated as junior to
the private respondents, however, petitioners woke up
2026:UHC:1369-DB
for challenging the seniority list only in 2019. He thus
submits that settled seniority cannot be unsettled after
long lapse of time and thus the claim petition was liable
to the dismissed at the threshold stage itself and the writ
petition also deserves to be dismissed on the issue of
delay in challenging the seniority list.
17.
Since learned Tribunal has not gone into the
question of delay/latches while deciding the claim
petition, therefore, we are not inclined to go into that
question at this belated stage. Since we have held that
seniority list was prepared as per the principles laid
down by the Seniority Rules 2002, therefore, any
interference with the impugned judgment would be
unwarranted.
18.
Accordingly, the present writ petition fails and
is dismissed.
19.
Pending application(s), if any, also stand
disposed of.
(Pankaj Purohit, J.)
PN/-
(Manoj Kumar Tiwari, J.)
26.02.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review