Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page |1
Date of reserved for orders : 08.09.2026
Date of pronouncement
: 28.09.2026
Date of uploading
: 29.09.2026
APHC010612912023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE 28th DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BALAJI MEDAMALLI
WRIT PETITION NO: 31588 OF 2023
Between:
1. M.Samuyelu,, S/o Late M.V.Raghavulu,
aged about 47 years,
No.950096926, Occ- Ex-Constable, Border Security Force, R/o H.No.3-102,
Samathanagar, Nuzividu, Eluru District - 521 201, A.P.
...Petitioner
AND
1. Union of India, rep by the Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs, North Block,
New Delhi - 110 003.
2. The Director General, Border Security Forces
Block No. 10, CGO
Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi - 110 003
3. The Inspector General, STC,
Border Security force, Kharkan Camp,
Hoshiarpur, Hoshiarpur District, (Punjab) -146 110
4. The SecondinCommand Welare, BSF Head quarters. Block No. 10, CGO
Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi - 110 003
...Respondents
Counsel for the Petitioner: RAMA KRISHNA A
Page |2
Counsel for the Respondents: NARASIMHARAO GUDISEVA (CENTRAL
GOVT COUNSEL)
Page |3
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BALAJI MEDAMALLI
WRIT PETITION NO: 31588 OF 2023
O R D E R:
This writ petition is filed seeking the following relief:
“…to issue an appropriate writ order or direction more particularly
one in the nature of Writ of mandamus to declare the action of the
2nd Respondent in rejecting petitioners claim of pro-rata pension
and other financial benefits by passing impugned proceedings
No.26001/Adm Dte (EOP Sec(1/573/2022 (23)/-1234-1300 dt.1210-2023 as illegal, arbitrary and violative of Articles 14, 16 and 21
of the constitution of India and contrary to the BSF Act, 1968 and
Rules thereunder and CCS Pension Rules 1972 and against the
principles of natural justice and consequently, set aside the same
and direct the 2nd Respondent to grant Pro-rata Pension on the
ground of Voluntary Retirement and having service of 12 years 2
months 26 days as per rules and decisions of Honble Apex court in
the interest of justice …”
2.
Brief facts of the case are that:
i.
Petitioner was initially appointed as a Constable, vide Regimental
No.950096926, on 16.02.1995 in the Border Security Force at Bangalore. He
underwent training at STC Takanpur, Gwalior, Madhya Pradesh, in Batch
No.62 from 16.02.1995 to March, 1996. Thereafter, he was posted to the 33rd
Battalion, Bandipur Sector, Jammu & Kashmir, where he served from March,
1996 to March, 1998. Subsequently, he was posted to STC, BSF, Kharkan,
Punjab, where he continued to serve up to 12.05.2007.
ii.
While so, on 12.05.2007, petitioner resigned from service on
account of ill health of his father. Subsequently, due to the death of his father,
he had the responsibility of looking after the welfare of his family comprising
Page |4
four sisters, one brother and his mother. In view of his financial constraints, he
sought voluntary retirement and his application was considered for voluntary
retirement under Rule 19 of the Border Security Force (BSF) Rules, 1969 and
the Border Security Force Act, 1968.
iii.
To overcome his financial difficulties, petitioner, under the bona
fide impression that the Government of India Circular dated 27.12.1995
provides pension to those who resigned from or voluntarily retired from service
in the Para-Military Forces, sought voluntary retirement. As on the date of his
resignation, petitioner had completed 12 years, 2 months and 26 days of
service. However, except GPF amount of Rs.60,000/-, no other amount was
paid to him. It was also stated that petitioner had subscribed to the Seema
Prahari Yojana Scheme and pension payable scheme.
iv.
Aggrieved by it, petitioner submitted a representation dated
19.05.2017 to the 2nd respondent seeking payment of pension admissible to
him on account of his having completed more than 10 years of continuous
qualifying service, or, in the alternative, to reinstate him into service in the BSF
in the event of any difficulty in sanctioning pension, so as to enable him to
rejoin duty. Though he submitted various representations thereafter, his case
was not considered. Subsequently, the 2nd respondent issued proceedings
dated 12.10.2023, rejecting his case stating that there was no provision under
the CCS (Pension) Rules for grant of pension to Government employees who
had resigned from service before completion of 20 years of qualifying service.
Page |5
3.
Aggrieved by that, present writ petition is filed.
4.
Respondents filed counter-affidavit denying the averments made in the
affidavit filed in support of the writ petition and contended that, under Rule 49
of the CCS (Pension) Rules, a member of the BSF who has resigned from
service after completing more than 10 years of qualifying service, but less
than 20 years, is not eligible to receive pensionary benefits and, as such,
petitioner is not entitled to the same. Though several other grounds were
raised in the counter-affidavit, learned counsel for the respondents placed
reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Union of India v.
Rakesh Kumar 1 and contended that the Hon’ble Apex Court, in the said
judgment, held that employees who have not completed the qualifying service
of 20 years are not entitled to pensionary benefits. Therefore, as the petitioner
admittedly had completed only 12 years of service, as stated above, he is not
entitled to pensionary benefits. Accordingly, his case was considered and
rejected. It is further contended by the respondents that Rule 49 of the CCS
(Pension) Rules only prescribes the
procedure for calculation and
quantification of the pension amount. Therefore, the case of petitioner was
rightly rejected by the respondents and no interference is warranted by this
Court.
5.
Denying the averments made in the counter affidavit, petitioner filed a
reply affidavit and submitted that the Hon’ble Apex Court in D.S.Nakara v.
(2001) 4 SCC 309
Page |6
Union of India2 held that pension is neither a bounty nor a matter of grace
depending upon the sweet will of the employer and pension is not an ex gratia
payment but it is a payment for the past service rendered, and it is a social
welfare measure rendering social-economic justice to those who in the heyday of their life ceaselessly toiled for the employer. It is further submitted that
judgment relied upon by the respondents in Union of India v. Rakesh
Kumar’s case (cited supra) is not applicable to the petitioner as the
directions issued therein would apply only in case of superannuation and
subsequently, the Hon’ble Apex Court rendered several other judgments
contrary to the proposition in the above said judgment of Rakesh Kumar’s
case.
6.
Heard Sri S.S.Gill, learned counsel representing Sri A.Rama Krishna,
learned counsel for petitioner and Sri T.Bhargav, learned counsel representing
Sri Narasimharao Gudiseva, learned Central Government Counsel for
Respondents.
7.
The contention of learned counsel for petitioner is that Rule 19 of the
BSF Rules empowers the authorities to allow a person to leave the BSF in
special circumstances before completing such number of years of service as
may be necessary for retirement or superannuation. The respondents have
accepted the application filed by the petitioner for voluntary retirement, but
have rejected his case for granting pension stating that qualifying service of 20
years is required for granting pension. There was no stipulation to the effect
(1983) 1 SCC 305
Page |7
that the minimum qualifying service for pension was fixed at 20 years. As the
petitioner had completed more than 10 years of qualifying service, he is
entitled to pension even as per the rules prevailing at the relevant point of
time. The minimum qualifying service for grant of gratuity or pension under
Rule 49 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, clearly prescribes 10 years as the
qualifying service. The expression ‘qualifying service’ is defined under Rule
3(1)(q), which states that qualifying service means service rendered while on
duty or otherwise, which shall be taken into account for the purpose of
pensions and gratuities admissible under the said Rules. Therefore, 10 years
is the minimum qualifying service prescribed under Rule 49 of the Pension
Rules. Therefore, the order passed by the respondents is contrary to the
Rules
8.
Learned counsel for petitioner placed reliance on the judgment of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in DTC v. Balwan Singh3, wherein the relevant portion
reads as under:
5. It appears that considerable litigation ensued in respect of both these
aspects, on various accounts, inter alia on the issue of the eligibility for
pension for persons who had put in 10 years or more of qualifying service, but
less than 20 years. All these different issues have been settled in proceedings
before the Delhi High Court or before this Court. Suffice to say that there is no
controversy now, in view of the judicial pronouncements that there is no
embargo in the Pension Rules that an employee having put in more than 10
years of service but less than 20 years would earn pro rata pension if he avails
of the VRS.
9.
Placing reliance on the above judgment, learned counsel submitted that
there is no embargo in the Pension Rules that an employee having put in
(2019) 18 SCC 126
Page |8
more than 10 years of service, but less than 20 years would earn pro rata
pension if he avail of the VRS.
10.
Learned counsel for petitioner also placed reliance on the judgment of
the Hon’ble Apex Court in State of Odisha v. Manju Naik 4, wherein the
relevant portion reads as under:
20. The above view of ours is supported by the ratio in Union of India v.
Bashirbhai R. Khiliji [Union of India v. Bashirbhai R. Khiliji, (2007) 6 SCC 16 :
(2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 292] , where this Court was considering claim for invalid
pension for an armed constable in the CRPF who suffered from pyrogenic
meningitis and neurosensory deafness (bilateral). In that case, the CRPF
personnel was declared unfit for active duty, and he was invalidated from
service. He applied to authorities for invalid pension but that was rejected on
the ground that he had not completed the qualifying service of 10 years.
Instead, he was paid service gratuity. The High Court in Bashirbhai R. Khilji v.
Union of India [Bashirbhai R. Khilji v. Union of India, 2004 SCC OnLine Guj
258 : (2004) 1 GLH 738] however, took the view that since the CRPF
Constable's invalidity was 100 per cent, he was entitled to invalid pension and
the stipulation of 10 years of qualifying service could not be invoked to deny
him the invalid pension. However, A.K. Mathur, J. speaking for a two-Judge
Bench of this Court while interpreting similar provisions in the applicable
Rules, negated the High Court's view and pronounced on the issue of
qualifying service for invalid pension, in the following [Union of India v.
Bashirbhai R. Khiliji, (2007) 6 SCC 16 : (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 292] manner:
(SCC pp. 20-21, paras 9-10)
“9. We are presently concerned with two provisions of the Rules i.e. Rules
38 and 49. Rule 38, as reproduced above, contemplates the invalid
pension. The procedure has been mentioned therein i.e. in case an
incumbent retires from service on account of bodily or mental infirmity
which permanently incapacitated him for the service, then a medical
certificate of incapacity shall be given by the authorities concerned and in
particular Form 23 the same may be applied before the competent
authority. It is true that the qualifying service is not mentioned in Rule 38
but Rule 49 which deals with the amount of pension stipulates that a
government servant retiring in accordance with the provisions of these
Rules before completing qualifying service of ten years, the amount of
service gratuity shall be calculated at the rate of half month's emoluments
for every completed six-monthly period of qualifying service. Therefore, the
minimum qualifying service of ten years is mentioned in Rule 49. The word
“qualifying service” has been defined in Rule 3(1)(q) of the Rules which
read as under:
(2020) 11 SCC 809
Page |9
„3. (1)(q) “qualifying service” means service rendered while on duty or
otherwise which shall be taken into account for the purpose of pensions
and gratuities admissible under these Rules;‟
10. Therefore, the minimum qualifying service which is required for the
pension as mentioned in Rule 49, is ten years. The qualifying service has
been explained in various memos issued by the Government of India from
time to time. But Rule 49 read with Rule 38 makes it clear that qualifying
service of pension is ten years and therefore, gratuity is determined after
completion of qualifying service of ten years. Therefore, for grant of any
kind of pension one has to put in the minimum of ten years of qualifying
service. The respondent in the present case, does not have the minimum
qualifying service. Therefore, the authorities declined to grant him the
invalid pension. But the amount of gratuity has been determined and the
same was paid to him.”
11.
Placing reliance on the above judgment, learned counsel submitted that
minimum qualifying service of 10 years is mentioned in Rule 49 and the
expression ‘qualifying service’ has been defined under Rule 3(1)(q), which
means service rendered while on duty or otherwise, which shall be taken into
account for the purpose of pensions and gratuities admissible under the
Rules. Thus, under Rule 49 of CCS (Pension) Rules, petitioner is entitled for
pension on pro rata basis.
12.
Learned counsel for petitioner also placed reliance on the judgment of
the Hon’ble Apex Court in D.S. Nakara v. Union of India’s case (cited
supra), wherein the relevant portion reads as under:
20. The antequated notion of pension being a bounty, a gratuitous
payment depending upon the sweet will or grace of the employer not
claimable as a right and, therefore, no right to pension can be enforced
through Court has been swept under the carpet by the decision of the
Constitution Bench in Deokinandan Prasad v. State of Bihar [(1971) 2
SCC 330 : AIR 1971 SC 1409 : 1971 Supp SCR 634 : (1971) 1 LLJ 557]
wherein this Court authoritatively ruled that pension is a right and the
payment of it does not depend upon the discretion of the Government but
is governed by the rules and a government servant coming within those
rules is entitled to claim pension. It was further held that the grant of
pension does not depend upon anyone's discretion. It is only for the
P a g e | 10
purpose of quantifying the amount having regard to service and other
allied matters that it may be necessary for the authority to pass an order
to that effect but the right to receive pension flows to the officer not
because of any such order but by virtue of the rules. This view was
reaffirmed in State of Punjab v. Iqbal Singh. [(1976) 2 SCC 1 : 1976 SCC
(L&S) 172 : AIR 1976 SC 667 : (1976) 3 SCR 360]
31. From the discussion three things emerge: (i) that pension is
neither a bounty nor a matter of grace depending upon the sweet will of
the employer and that it creates a vested right subject to 1972 Rules
which are statutory in character because they are enacted in exercise of
powers conferred by the proviso to Article 309 and clause (5) of Article
148 of the Constitution; (ii) that the pension is not an ex gratia payment
but it is a payment for the past service rendered; and (iii) it is a social
welfare measure rendering socio-economic justice to those who in the
hey-day of their life ceaselessly toiled for the employer on an assurance
that in their old age they would not be left in lurch. It must also be noticed
that the quantum of pension is a certain percentage correlated to the
average emoluments drawn during last three years of service reduced to
10 months under liberalised pension scheme. Its payment is dependent
upon an additional condition of impeccable behaviour even subsequent to
retirement, that is, since the cessation of the contract of service and that it
can be reduced or withdrawn as a disciplinary measure.
13.
Placing reliance on the above judgment, learned counsel submitted that
pension is neither a bounty nor a matter of grace depending upon the sweet
will of the employer and it creates a vested right. Pension is not an ex gratia
payment, but it is a payment for the past service rendered and it is a social
welfare measure rendering socio-economic justice to those who in the heyday of their life ceaselessly toiled for the employer.
14.
Learned counsel for petitioner also placed reliance on the judgment of
the Hon’ble Apex Court in Raj Kumar v. Union of India5, wherein the relevant
portion reads as under:
17. We find that the cases before us can be divided into the following
categories:
(2006) 1 SCC 737
P a g e | 11
(A) Pre-circular. Personnel who resigned and were granted pension
for special reasons, even prior to the circular dated 27-12-1995.
(B) Post-circular. Personnel who resigned pursuant to the circular
dated 27-12-1995. These persons can be further divided into two subcategories.
(i) Personnel who retired in 1996, were sanctioned pension and were
therefore asked vide letter dated 31-10-1998 not to report for reinduction.
Their pension has been stopped pursuant to the judgment in Rakesh
Kumar [(2001) 4 SCC 309 : 2001 SCC (L&S) 707] . These persons can
be further divided into two sub-categories:
(a) those who are in a position to be reinducted into service even now;
and
(b) those who cannot be reinducted into the service as a result of
being age-barred or due to being medically or physically unfit.
(ii) Those who retired subsequent to 1996, were not sanctioned
pension, and were directed to report for reinduction into service or to
forfeit pension benefits by virtue of the circular dated 17-10-1998 and the
individual letters.
18. Having considered the peculiar facts arising in each of these
groups, we make the following orders:
1. The personnel falling in category (B)(ii) i.e. those persons who had
retired subsequent to 1996 pursuant to the circular dated 27-10-1995 and
had not been sanctioned pension, but who have been directed to report
for reinduction in service shall necessarily have to forfeit their pension, if
they have not reported for service by virtue of the circular dated 17-101998. If, however, they have reported for service then there is no question
of any relief in their case.
2. In the case of persons falling in category (B)(i), they shall also be
given the option of reinduction into service, and those falling in category
(B)(i)(a) shall be so reinducted, subject to the conditions stipulated in the
circular dated 17-10-1998 and on condition that they shall refund GPF
and pension amounts drawn by them till reinduction. The authorities shall
indicate the deadline by which such persons shall offer themselves for
reinduction.
3. In the case of persons who shall fall in category B(i)(b) i.e. persons
who had retired in 1996, were sanctioned pension but who cannot be
reinducted today as they are age-barred or physically or medically unfit or
for any other reason including their inability to return the amount of GPF,
pension drawn or other dues, there shall be no question of continuing
payment of pension which shall be liable to cease as a result of the
decision in Rakesh Kumar [(2001) 4 SCC 309 : 2001 SCC (L&S) 707] .
We are however of the view that equity demands that in such cases there
shall be no recovery of the pension amounts already paid to them.
4. In cases which fall under category (A) i.e. personnel who had
resigned prior to the circular dated 27-12-1995 and had been granted
pension for special reasons and continued to draw it till the stoppage of
pension as a result of the judgment in Rakesh Kumar [(2001) 4 SCC 309 :
2001 SCC (L&S) 707] we think that irrespective of the position in law,
equity demands that, as they have drawn their pension for long periods,
P a g e | 12
they shall not be asked to refund their drawn pension amounts, nor shall
their pension be stopped now.
15.
Placing reliance on the above judgment, learned counsel submitted that
referring to the judgment of Rakesh Kumar’s case (cited supra), Hon’ble
Apex Court categorised the persons who retired subsequent to the year 1996,
were not sanctioned pension and were, therefore directed to report for reinduction into service and such persons would necessarily have to forfeit their
pension if they failed to report for re-induction and there is no embargo with
regard to the application of 20 years of service for claiming pension.
16.
Learned counsel for petitioner also placed reliance on the judgment of
the Hon’ble Apex Court in Union of India v. Satish Kumar 6, wherein the
relevant portion reads as under:
12. So long as it is an admitted position that Rule 49 governs,
payment of pension in all these cases, could only be as per the Rules.
When there is no challenge to the Rule and there is no ground of
discrimination taken in any of the petitions the Rule cannot be bypassed.
17.
Placing reliance on the above, learned counsel submitted that Rule 49
governs, payment of pension in all the cases, could only be as per the Rules
and the Rule cannot be bypassed, so long as there is no challenge to the Rule
on the ground of discrimination.
18.
Learned counsel for petitioner also placed reliance on the judgment of
High Court of Rajasthan in Banwari Lal v. Union of India 7 , wherein the
(2006) 1 SCC 360
2025:RJ-JD:47020
P a g e | 13
Hon’ble High Court of Rajasthan allowed the petition holding that in the light of
Rule 49(2)(b) of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, petitioner having completed
more than 10 years of qualifying service prior to his voluntary retirement, is
entitled to proportionate pension and all consequential pensionary benefits. In
the above said judgment, learned judge considered the case law cited therein
apart from considering the provisions of Rules 49 and Rule 19 of BSF Rules.
The relevant portion of the judgment reads as under:
5.6. A bare perusal of Rule 49 reinforces this legal position, as it clearly
envisages grant of proportionate pension to those who have completed at
least ten years of qualifying service. The issue has now attained finality
and is no longer res integra, the same having been comprehensively
examined by a larger Bench of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Delhi
Transport Corporation v. Balwan Singh and others (2019) 18 SCC 126
wherein it was reaffirmed that pension is a deferred right earned through
qualifying service and cannot be arbitrarily withheld once the statutory
threshold of ten years is met. The relevant Para No.5 is being reproduced
as under:5. It appears that considerable litigation ensued in respect of both
these aspects, on various accounts, inter alia on the issue of the
eligibility for pension for persons who had put in 10 years or more
of qualifying service, but less than 20 years. All these different
issues have been settled in proceedings before the Delhi High
Court or before this Court. Suffice to say that there is no
controversy now, in view of the judicial pronouncements that there
is no embargo in the pension rules that an employee having put in
more than 10 years of service but less than 20 years would earn
pro rata pension if he avails of the VRS.
As is evident from the communication dated 23.08.2001, the petitioner‟s
pension had been duly sanctioned and was being regularly disbursed in
accordance with the relevant service regulations. The said communication
clearly reflects that the petitioner was in receipt of pensionary benefits for
a period of about four years. However, the payment of pension was
subsequently discontinued solely on the ground that, in the case of Union
of India v. Rakesh Kumar, certain observations were made to the effect
that a member of the Border Security Force who resigns from service after
completing ten years but before twenty years of qualifying service would
not be entitled to pension.
P a g e | 14
6. In view of the foregoing discussion and in light of Rule 49(2) (b) of the
CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, the petition is accordingly allowed. It is held
that the Petitioner, having completed more than ten years of qualifying
service prior to his voluntary retirement, is entitled to proportionate pension
and all consequential pensionary benefits as envisaged under the said
Rules.
19.
Learned counsel for petitioner also placed reliance on the judgment of
Delhi High Court in Kuldip Singh v. Union of India8, wherein it was held that
Rule 49 of CCS (Pension) Rules permits payment of pension after completion
of 10 years of qualifying service. Accordingly, as the petitioner therein had
rendered more than 11 years of service, he was held entitled for pension.
20.
Per contra, learned Central Government Counsel for respondents
placed reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Union of India
v. Rakesh Kumar’s case (cited supra), wherein the relevant portion reads
as under:
12. A bare reading of Section 8 of the Act makes it clear that no member
of BSF will have right to resign except with the prior permission in writing
of the prescribed authority. The language is prohibitory and the member of
BSF is not having liberty to resign from his appointment during the term of
his engagement, however, the prescribed authority may permit the
member of BSF to resign in certain special circumstances. Rule 19 does
not create any right to pension. It is intended to enable members of BSF to
resign from the Force without attracting any penal consequences. For that,
Rule 19 provides that the Central Government having regard to the special
circumstances of any case may permit any officer of the Force to resign
before the attainment of the age of retirement or before putting in such
number of years of service as may be necessary under the Rules to be
eligible for retirement. Discretionary powers are given to the authority to
accept or reject the resignation. Proviso to Rule 19(1) empowers the
Central Government, while granting permission to resign, to require the
officer to refund to the Government such amount as would constitute the
cost of training given to that officer. Further, if the officer is eligible to get
pension or other retirement benefits, the Rules empower the Government
to make reduction in the pension or other retirement benefits.
1995 SCC OnLine Del 595
P a g e | 15
13. The next step is — once it is accepted that members of BSF are
governed by the CCS (Pension) Rules, then the question is — whether a
member is entitled to get pension on his resignation before the compulsory
age of retirement or 20 years of service or if he retires or is retired at the
age of 30/33 years of qualifying service. The scheme of the said Rules
provides that normally a government servant is entitled to get pensionary
benefits after he retires at the age of superannuation. There are
exceptions for grant of pensionary benefits in cases where a government
servant voluntarily retires after completing 20 years of qualifying service
and also retires after completing 30/33 years of qualifying service, invalid
pension or compensation pension or on compassionate grounds etc.
Chapter V. deals with grant of pensions and the conditions for such grants.
As per Rule 35 superannuation pension is to be granted to a government
servant who retires on his attaining the age of compulsory retirement.
Retiring pension is further given to a government servant who retires or is
retired in advance of the age of compulsory retirement in accordance with
the provisions of Rule 48 after completing 30 years of qualifying service or
Rule 48-A of the CCS (Pension) Rules or Rule 56 of the Fundamental
Rules or Article 459 of the Civil Services Regulations. Rule 48-A provides
for voluntary retirement after completion of 20 years of qualifying service
after giving three months' notice in writing to the appointing authority and if
such notice is accepted he would get retiring pension. Thereafter, Rule 49
provides for method of calculation of amount of pension to such
government servant. Relevant parts of the CCS (Pension) Rules for grant
of pension are as under:
“35. Superannuation pension.—A superannuation pension shall be
granted to a government servant who is retired on his attaining the
age of compulsory retirement.
36. Retiring pension.—A retiring pension shall be granted—
(a) to a government servant who retires, or is retired, in advance of
the age of compulsory retirement in accordance with the provisions
of Rule 48 or 48-A of these Rules, or Rule 56 of the Fundamental
Rules or Article 459 of the Civil Services Regulations; and
(b) to a government servant who, on being declared surplus, opts
for voluntary retirement in accordance with the provisions of Rule
29 of these Rules.
***
48. Retirement on completion of 30 years' qualifying service.—(1)
At any time after a government servant has completed thirty years'
qualifying service—
(a) he may retire from service, or
P a g e | 16
(b) he may be required by the appointing authority to retire in the
public interest,
and in the case of such retirement the government servant shall be
entitled to a retiring pension:
Provided.…
48-A. Retirement on completion of 20 years' qualifying service.—(1)
At any time after a government servant has completed twenty years'
qualifying service, he may, by giving notice of not less than three
months in writing to the appointing authority, retire from service.
Provided….”
(emphasis supplied)
21. Learned counsel for the respondents submitted that on the basis of the
GO, a number of persons are granted pensionary benefits even though
they have not completed 20 years of service, and, therefore, at this stage,
the Court should not interfere and see that the pensionary benefits granted
to the respondents are not disturbed and are released as early as
possible. In our view, for grant of pension the members of BSF are
governed by the CCS (Pension) Rules. The CCS (Pension) Rules
nowhere provide that a person who has resigned before completing 20
years of service as provided in Rule 48-A is entitled to pensionary benefits.
Rule 19 of the BSF Rules also does not make any provision for grant of
pensionary benefits. It only provides that if a member of the Force who
resigns and to whom permission in writing is granted to resign then the
authority granting such permission may reduce the pensionary benefits if
he is eligible to get the pension. Therefore, by erroneous interpretation of
the Rules if pensionary benefits are granted to someone it would not mean
that the said mistake should be perpetuated by direction of the Court. It
would be unjustifiable to submit that by appropriate writ, the Court should
direct something which is contrary to the statutory rules. In such cases,
there is no question of application of Article 14 of the Constitution. No
person can claim any right on the basis of decision which is dehors the
statutory rules nor can there be any estoppel. Further, in such cases there
cannot be any consideration on the ground of hardship. If the Rules are
not providing for grant of pensionary benefits it is for the authority to
decide and frame appropriate rules but the Court cannot direct payment of
pension on the ground of so-called hardship likely to be caused to a
person who has resigned without completing qualifying service for getting
pensionary benefits. As a normal rule, pensionary benefits are granted to
a government servant who is required to retire on his attaining the age of
compulsory retirement except in those cases where there are special
provisions.
P a g e | 17
21.
Placing reliance on the above judgment, learned counsel for
respondents submitted that the scheme of the said Rules provides that,
normally, a Government servant is entitled to pensionary benefits upon
retirement on attaining the age of superannuation. There are exceptions for
grant of pensionary benefits in cases where a Government servant voluntarily
retires after completing 20 years of qualifying service. He further submitted
that Rule 19 does not create any right to pension, but is intended to enable
members of the BSF to resign from the Force without attracting any penal
consequences. As such, the period of 10 years prescribed under Rule 19
cannot be treated as qualifying service under Rule 49 of the CCS (Pension)
Rules, as the two provisions operate in distinct fields. It is further submitted
that Rule 49 prescribes the procedure for calculation and quantification of the
pension amount and does not confer any additional right to pension on BSF
employees.
22.
Considered the submissions made on either side and perused the entire
material on record.
It is appropriate to extract Rule 19 of BSF rules, 1969 and Rule 49 of
CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972:
19. Resignation.-(1) The Central Government may, having regard to the
special circumstances of any case, permit any officer of the force to resign
from the force before the attainment of the age of retirement or before
putting in such number of years of service as may be necessary under the
rules to be eligible for retirement:
Provided that while granting such permission the Central Government
may:
P a g e | 18
(i) require the officer to refund to the Government such amount as would
constitute the cost of training given to that officer [or three months pay and
allowances, whichever is higher] or provided further that an officer of the
force tendering resignation, for accepting a job under Central or State
Governments or local bodies, after having been granted cadre clearance
for the same [or who has completed 10 years of service] shall not be
required to refund the sum as provided here in above.
(2) The Central Government may accept the resignation under sub-rule (1)
with effect from such date as it may consider expedient.
(3) The Central Government may refuse to permit an officer to resign:(a) if an emergency has been declared in the Country either due to internal
disturbances or external aggression; or
(b) if considers it to be inexpedient so to do 26[due to exigencies of
service] or in the interests of the discipline of the force; or
(c) if the officer has specifically undertaken to serve for a specified period
and such period has not expired.
(4) The provisions of this rule, shall apply to and in relation to subordinate
officer and enrolled persons as they apply to and in relation to any officer
of the force and the powers vested in the Central Government under subrules (1) and (2) shall be exercised in the case of a Subordinate Officer by
a Deputy Inspector General and in the case of an Enrolled Person by a
Commandant.
Rule 49- Amount of Pension
(1) In the case of a government servant retiring in accordance with the
provisions of these rules before completing qualifying service of ten years,
the amount of service gratuity shall be calculated at the rate of half
month's emoluments for every completed six monthly period of qualifying
service.
(2) (a) In the case of a Government servant retiring in accordance with the
provisions of these rules after completing qualifying service of not less
than thirty-three years, the amount of pension shall be calculated at fifty
per cent of average emoluments, subject to a maximum of four thousand
and five hundred rupees per mensem.
(b) In case of a government servant retiring in accordance with the
provisions of these rules before completing qualifying service of thirtythree years, but after completing qualifying service of ten years, the
amount of pension shall be proportionate to the amount of pension
admissible under clause (a) and in no case the amount of pension
shall be less than Rupees three hundred and seventy-five per
mensem
P a g e | 19
(c) Notwithstanding anything contained in Clause (a) and Clause (b)
the amount of invalid pension shall not be less than the amount of
family pension admissible under sub-rule (2) of Rule 54”
23.
A conjoint reading of the above rules makes it clear that, Rule 19 of the
BSF Rules, 1969 prescribes the minimum age for permitting an employee to
resign from service before retirement upon completion of 10 years of service
in the force, whereas Rule 49 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, prescribes the
qualifying service of 10 years for payment of gratuity at the rate of half month’s
emoluments for every completed 6 monthly period of qualifying service. Under
Rule 49(2)(a), an employee who had completed 33 years of qualifying service
is entitled for full pension. However, the persons who had completed 10 years
of qualifying service are also entitled for the proportionate pension admissible
under clause (a) of Rule 49(2). The expression ‘qualifying service’ mentioned
in the aforesaid rules is defined under Rule 3(1)(q), which reads as under:
“Qualifying service means service rendered while on duty or
otherwise, which shall be taken into Account for the purpose of
pension and gratuities admissible under these rules.”
24.
A bare perusal of all the above provisions makes it clear that an
employee who has rendered more than ten years of qualifying service is
entitled for proportionate pension as per Rule 49(2) of CCS (Pension) Rules.
Admittedly, petitioner had put in more than 10 years of qualifying service (i.e.,
12 years 2 months and 26 days). As such, he is entitled for pro-rata pension/
proportionate pension as was held by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the
judgments of DTC v. Balwan Singh’s case (cited supra), State of Odisha
v. Manju Naik’s case (cited supra) and Hon’ble High Court of Rajasthan in
P a g e | 20
the judgment of Banwari Lal v. Union of India’s case (cited supra) and
Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the judgment of Kuldip Singh v. Union of India
(cited supra). Moreover, pension is a right and it is neither a bounty nor an ex
gracia payment, but it is a payment of past service rendered and the same is
not a matter of grace depending upon the sweet will of the employer as was
held by the Hon’ble Apex Court in D.S. Nakara v. Union of India’s case
(cited supra). Therefore, in view of the above facts and circumstances of the
case, this Court is of the considered opinion that petitioner is entitled for pro
rata/ proportionate pension, as such, the impugned proceedings is liable to be
set aside.
25.
In view of the foregoing reasons, this writ petition is allowed.
Consequently, the impugned proceedings dated 12.10.2023 is hereby set
aside. Respondents are directed to fix the proportionate pension of the
petitioner depending upon the length of service and pay the same within a
period of four (4) months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
As a sequel, miscellaneous applications, pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
__________________________
JUSTICE BALAJI MEDAMALLI
Date: 28.09.2026
Dvs
P a g e | 21
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BALAJI MEDAMALLI
WRIT PETITION NO: 31588 OF 2023
Date: 28.09.2026
Dvs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review