Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CWP-36319-2025
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
CWP-36319-2025
Date of Decision :03.07.2026
M/S. YAMUNA FILLING STATION
VERSUS
.....Petitioner
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
.....Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE KULDEEP TIWARI
Present :
Mr. Ashwani Talwar, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Gandharv Malhotra, Advocate,
Ms. Vaishnavi Sikka, Advocate,
Mr. Nikhil, Advocate and
Mr. Deepak Goyat, Advocate,
for the petitioner.
Mr. Sharad Aggarwal, Addl.A.G., Haryana
for respondents no.1 to 3 and 9.
Mr. M.S.Rana, Advocate for
Mr. Ashish Kapoor, Advocate,
for respondent no.4.
Mr. Baldevraj Mahajan, Sr. Advocate with
with Ms. Nikita Goel, Advocate,
Mr. Mohit Kumar Sharma, Advocate,
for respondents no.5, 6 and 7.
Mr. Amit Jhanji, Sr. Advocate with
Dr. Eliza Gupta, Advocate,
for respondent no.8.
KULDEEP TIWARI, J.(Oral)
1.
Through the instant petition, cast under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, legality of the order dated 18.10.2024 (Annexure P23), whereby, the Deputy Commissioner, Panipat (respondent no.3),
DHARAM VIR
2026.07.09 09:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-36319-2025
-2-
granted NOC for setting up of a petrol station at Plot No.O-32, Old
Industrial Area, Panipat, which is abutting the road maintained by the
Haryana State Industrial and Infrastructure Development Corporation,
(HSIIDC), has been put to challenge. The petitioner has also challenged
the order dated 11.10.2024 (Annexure P-31), passed by respondent no.3,
in pursuance of a direction issued by this Court vide order dated
12.02.2024 (Annexure P-18).
2.
The petitioner is a proprietorship firm, having its petrol
pump situated near the petrol pump installed by respondent no.8.
3.
The main grievance of the petitioner, which is operating a
petrol station at O-31, Industrial Area, Panipat, is that, a site for setting up
of another petrol station has been allotted, which is at less than 300 meter
distance, and the same is against the instructions/notification issued by
the Haryana Public Works Department (PWD) (Annexure-9), as well as,
the policy/instructions dated 04.09.2020 (Annexure P-54), as issued by
the Principal Secretary to Government of Haryana, Town and Country
Planning Department, for establishment of Retail Outlets CNG/PNG
stations and petrol pumps.
4.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner, at the outset, draws
attention of this Court towards the notification issued by the Haryana
Public Works Department on 27.10.2020 (Annexure P-9), to submit that
the restrictions of maintaining 300 meter distance between two petrol
stations, has been floated, and the Deputy Commissioner (respondent
no.3), who was duty bound to ensure the compliance of such instructions,
DHARAM VIR
2026.07.09 09:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-36319-2025
-3-
as contained in notification (supra), has failed to take into consideration
the same.
5.
He further submits that there are specific instructions in the
aforesaid notification dated 27.10.2020, which makes it mandatory that
the distance of 300 meters has to be maintained between two petrol
pumps.
6.
Next argument, raised by him is, that in case, this Court
comes to a conclusion that the notification (supra), is not applicable to
the instant matter, as the site is situated within the HSIIDC area, then the
guidelines issued by the NHAI, PWD and the Department of Town and
Country Planning, would be a guiding principle for the Deputy
Commissioner concerned, while granting NOC, and in order to examine
the safety of the public.
7.
He further placed reliance upon a judgment rendered by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in “Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. vs. Arti Devi
Dangi”, 2016 (15) SCC 480, to submit that in absence of any specific
guidelines, the general guidelines of IRC would prevail.
8.
No other argument was raised on behalf of the petitioner.
9.
Per contra, Mr. Baldevraj Mahajan, Sr. Advocate, learned
counsel for respondents no. 5 to 7, put a fierce defence, and raised
following objections, to the submissions, as made on behalf of the
petitioner.
DHARAM VIR
2026.07.09 09:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-36319-2025
10.
-4-
He submits that the notification issued by the Haryana Public
Works Department (PWD) on 27.10.2020 (Annexure P-9), is not
applicable at all, to the site, where the said petrol pump has now been
established by respondent no.8. It is also contended that the guidelines
contained in the notification (supra), governs setting up of roadside fuel
stations in the State of Haryana, on State Highways (SHs), Major District
Roads (MDRs), Other District Roads (ODRs), and Village Roads,
whereas, in the instant case, however, the petrol pump is installed on the
land allotted by the HSIIDC, and the Change of Land Use (CLU), from
that of industrial to commercial use, was granted in favour of respondent
no.8 way back in the year 2009. The petrol pump is abutting to the road
which is maintained by HSIIDC, and Haryana Public Works Department
has never issued any notification declaring the road in question as 'Other
District Road' (ODR).
11.
He next submits that even the second notification dated
04.09.2020 (Annexure P-54), issued by the Town and Country Planning
Department, is equally inapplicable. He draws the attention of this Court
towards the applicability clause of the said notification and submits that it
is applicable only where the authority concerned has to allot land for a
Retail Outlet. In the instant case, it is not a case of allotment of land;
rather, the land had been allotted much prior to the date when the policy
came into existence.
12.
Finally, he submits that at the time when the NOC was
granted, and the petrol pump was installed, there was no legal
DHARAM VIR
2026.07.09 09:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-36319-2025
-5-
impediment, or any notification, or guidelines issued by any competent
authority prohibiting installation of a petrol pump at the site in question.
13.
It is also contended that there is no prayer whatsoever, in the
instant petition for framing guidelines for installation of Retail Outlets,
for the areas which are not covered under the notification issued by the
State Government.
14.
This Court has heard the rival submissions as made on behalf
of the parties concerned, and has perused the entire case file.
15.
The entire argument, as made by learned senior counsels for
the parties concerned, hinges upon applicability of aforesaid two
notification/policies/instructions
(dated
27.10.2020
and
dated
04.09.2020). Therefore, the first question which arises for consideration
is, whether the said notifications/instructions are applicable to the facts of
the present case. If the answer is in the affirmative, the second question
would be, whether the restriction of maintaining a distance of 300 metres
would operate as a bar to respondent No.8 establishing the Retail Outlet.
16.
In order to answer the first query, lets have a glimpse upon
the notification dated 27.10.2020, as issued by the Haryana Public Works
Department (PWD). The first paragraph of the notification assumes
relevance, at this stage, which is extracted hereinafter:“No. 01/08/2020-B&R(W). In supersession of the earlier notification
dated 13.10.2020 issued vide No. 575-RII-19, 406-RII20/Tech/Roads/21155/Guidelines for access permission /152824152878/2020 by the Engineer-in-Chief PWD (B&R), the Governor of
Haryana is pleased to issue new guidelines regarding setting up of the
Roadside Fuel Stations in the State of Haryana on State Highways
(SHs), Major District Roads (MDRs), Other District Roads (ODRs) &
Village Road (VRs). Therefore, the following Norms/Guidelines are
DHARAM VIR
2026.07.09 09:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-36319-2025
-6-
hereby notified for issuance of NOC by the concerned Executive
Engineer for access, location & layout of Roadside Fuel Stations in the
State of Haryana.”
17.
A perusal of the above makes it vividly clear that the said
notification is made applicable to the setting up of Roadside Fuel Stations
in the State of Haryana, on State Highways (SHs), Major District
Roads (MDRs), Other District Roads (ODRs) and Village Road
(VRs). In the instant case, it is not under dispute that the petrol pump
operated by respondent no.8, is not abutting to any of the aforesaid
mentioned roadsides. Rather, it is abutting a road which is carved out,
and maintained by the Industrial Department, which is now HSIIDC.
18.
During the course of arguments, this Court has put a specific
query to learned senior counsel for the petitioner, as to whether, he is
armed with any notification to substantiate that the site in question is
abutting to any notified roadsides, to which he answered in negative.
Therefore, this Court has no hesitation to conclude that the
notification dated 27.10.2020, is not applicable at all, to the facts of the
instant matter, and, consequently, does not create any legal impediment to
the grant of NOC for installation of the Retail Outlet.
19.
Now coming to the policy/instructions dated 04.09.2020
(Annexure P-54), issued by the Principal Secretary to Government of
Haryana, Town and Country Planning Department. The said policy carries
a specific applicability clause, and according to clause 1(c) thereof, the
policy shall be applicable to submission of all applications received after
the date 04.09.2020 for grant of CLU permission for establishment of
DHARAM VIR
2026.07.09 09:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-36319-2025
-7-
Retail Outlet for intended purpose only. Clause 1(b) of the policy
(supra) further provides that policy shall apply to the allotment of land of
Government entities by sale or lease through the mechanism of e-auction
for the sole purpose of setting up of Retail Outlets. The relevant clause is
extracted hereinafter:“1. Applicability:
(a) This policy shall be applicable to all Government entities in the
State of Haryana and shall supersede all existing policies of
Government entities in so far as that relate to allotment of land for
retail outlets.
(b) This policy shall be applicable to the allotment of land of
Government entities by sale or lease through the mechanism of eauction for the sole purpose of setting up of Retail Outlets.
(c) The policy shall apply to submission of all applications received
after the date 04.09.2020 for grant of CLU permission for
establishment of Retail Outlet for the intended purpose only.”
20.
On a bare perusal of the above, makes it abundantly clear
that it does not create any legal embargo, requiring the authority to ensure
compliance of policy (supra), for the purpose of granting NOC to
respondent no.8, for the reason: that the site in question was allotted to
the predecessor-in-interest of respondent no.8, way back in 1949; the
Change of Land Use (CLU) for conversion of land from that of industrial
to commercial use, was granted way back in 2009. Therefore, it is neither
the case of allotment of land after the policy (supra), came into operation,
nor the case of grant of CLU permission after 04.09.2020.
21.
In view of the above, the policy/notification dated
04.09.2020, is also not applicable in the instant case.
22.
While summing up the above discussion, this Court is of the
considered view that neither the notification dated 27.10.2020 (Annexure
P-9) issued by the Haryana Public Works Department, nor the
DHARAM VIR
2026.07.09 09:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-36319-2025
-8-
policy/instructions dated 04.09.2020 (Annexure P-54), as issued by the
Town and Country Planning Department are applicable to the facts of the
present case. The petrol pump site in question neither abuts any road
covered under the notification dated 27.10.2020 nor does the case fall
within the ambit of the policy dated 04.09.2020, as the allotment of land,
as well as the grant of Change of Land Use (CLU), had taken place much
prior to the coming into force of the said policy. Consequently, the
restriction regarding maintenance of a minimum distance of 300 metres
between two Retail Outlets, as contemplated under the aforesaid
notification/policy, cannot be pressed by the petitioner. Accordingly, both
the questions framed hereinabove are answered against the petitioner and
in favour of the respondents.
23.
Now the next question arises for consideration, as to
whether, in absence of any notification/instructions/statutory guidelines,
the NOC granted to respondent no.8, can be struck down by taking
guidance from the notification issued by NHAI and Haryana Public
Works Department. The answer, in the considered opinion of this Court,
has to be in negative. The authority concerned is required to examine the
request for grant of NOC on the basis of applicable statutory provisions
and enforceable notifications. The competent authority has duly
examined the matter on the touchstone of the applicable legal provisions,
and only thereafter, had granted the NOC.
DHARAM VIR
2026.07.09 09:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-36319-2025
24.
-9-
The reliance placed upon by learned senior counsel for the
petitioner, on the judgment rendered in Indian Oil Corporation's case
(supra), is also mis-placed. A reading of the said judgment does not
surface that the Hon'ble Supreme Court directed that, in the absence of
any specific statutory guideline, the IRC guidelines must necessarily be
followed.
25.
In view of the above discussion, this Court does not find any
merit in the instant petition, which is consequently, dismissed.
26.
All pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of
accordingly.
July 03, 2026
(KULDEEP TIWARI)
JUDGE
dharamvir
Whether speaking/reasoned.
Whether Reportable.
DHARAM VIR
2026.07.09 09:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
:
:
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review