The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. Accordingly, the impugned termination letter dated 11th July, 2024 to the extent it debars the petitioner from participating in bids in respect of projects being tendered by the Railways, Firozpur Cantt is hereby quashed.
20. The interim order dated 5th August, 2024 shall continue till the appeal/representation filed by the petitioner before the respondent no.4 is decided.
21. The writ petition is disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision: 30th January, 2026
+
W.P.(C) 10713/2024, CM APPL. 44128/2024, CM APPL. 71743/2024
& CM APPL. 68268/2025
M/S VPSSR FACILITIES
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Pankaj Kumar Singh and Ms.
Bimla Sharma, Advocates.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Sanjib Kumar Mohanty and Mr.
Sarvesh P. Shrivastava, Advocates for
UoI.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT BANSAL
AMIT BANSAL, J. (Oral)
1.
The present writ petition has been filed seeking the following reliefs:-
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
20:19:05
W.P.(C) 10713/2024
2.
At the outset, Mr. Pankaj Kumar Singh, counsel appearing on behalf
of the petitioner, submits that the petitioner is confining his challenge in the
present writ petition only to the extent that the petitioner has been debarred
from future bid/tenders conducted by the respondent/Railways.
3.
The petitioner, being the successful bidder, was awarded a Contract
by the Railways for performance of services/work for “Mechanized cleaning
of coaches of primary trains along with provisions of On Board
Housekeeping Services (‘OBHS’) in trains including toiletries in AC
coaches and depot complex cleaning at Coaching Depot, Amritsar (ASR) for
period of 3 years (1095) days” on “Outcome Basis” and the work was
started by the petitioner from 1st July, 2022.
4.
The petitioner deposited the requisite Performance Guarantee in the
form of Bank Guarantee vide No. 04522IGL0000522 dated 21st June, 2021
for a value of Rs. 38,82,331/- in favour Sr. Divisional Finance Manager,
Northern Railway, Firozpur Cantt. The contract was to be governed by the
General Conditions of Contract for Services dated January, 2018, along with
latest amendments, by the Ministry of Railways, Government of India
(‘GCC’).
5.
During the execution of the contract, the petitioner was issued
performance notices by the respondents, to which the petitioner provided
explanations and hence, no action was taken by the respondent no.4.
6.
On 2nd July, 2024, another performance notice under Clause 7.4 of the
GCC was given by respondent no.4 (Annexure P-14), giving the petitioner
seven (7) days’ time to commence/improve the services. The notice further
provided that in the event the petitioner committed default, action would be
taken under Clause 7.4 of the GCC to terminate the contract. The relevant
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
20:19:05
W.P.(C) 10713/2024
extracts from the aforesaid notice are set out below:“You are hereby given 07 days' notice in terms of clause 7.4 of General
condition of contract to commence/improve the service to make good
the default. failing which further action as provided in clause 7.4 of
General condition of contract viz. to terminate your contract and
complete the balance services without your participation will be taken.
If your performance does not improve, on expiry of this period, a notice
for termination of the above contract shall be issued to you under which
your contract shall stand rescinded and the services under this contract
will be carried out independently without your participation and your
performance guarantee shall also be encashed/forfeited and
consequences which may please be noted.”
[emphasis supplied]
7.
The aforesaid notice was replied to by the petitioner on 8th July, 2024,
giving an explanation on the issues raised in the notice.
8.
A termination notice dated 11th July, 2024 (Annexure P-1) was issued
by the Senior Divisional Mechanical Engineer, Northern Railways, Firozpur
Cantt/respondent no.4 (‘termination letter’), terminating the contract of the
petitioner as well as debarring the petitioner from participating in the bids
for work tendered by the Railways for a period of two years. For the sake of
convenience, the said termination letter is set out below:-
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
20:19:05
W.P.(C) 10713/2024
9.
Against the said termination letter, the petitioner filed an appeal on
13th July, 2024 before Senior Divisional Mechanical Engineer, Northern
Railways, Firozpur Cantt/respondent no.4. The said appeal is stated to be
pending.
10.
Mr. Singh submits that the debarment order passed by the respondents
is ex facie illegal as the same was passed without giving any Show Cause
Notice to the petitioner that showed the intention of the respondents to
debar/blacklist the petitioner. It is further stated that in the notices issued by
the respondent no.4, there was no contemplation of debarment or
blacklisting.
10.1 In this regard, counsel has relied upon the judgments of the Supreme
Court in Gorkha Security Services v. Government (NCT of Delhi) & Ors.,
(2014) 9 SCC 105 (‘Gorkha Security Services’) and UMC Technologies
Pvt. Ltd. v. Food Corporation of India & Anr., (2021) 2 SCC 551 (‘UMC
Technologies’).
11.
Counter affidavit is stated to have been filed on behalf of respondents.
11.1 However, the same is not on record.
11.2 Photocopy of the same is handed over by the counsel for the
respondents and the same is taken on record.
12.
Mr. Sanjib Kumar Mohanty, counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondent, submits that the respondent has acted strictly in terms of the
provisions of the GCC. It is further submitted that repeated notices were sent
to the petitioner complaining about the quality of services being rendered by
the petitioner. However, the petitioner failed to improve their services.
Hence, the impugned termination letter dated 11th July, 2024 was issued by
the respondent no.4.
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
20:19:05
W.P.(C) 10713/2024
13.
The present petition came up for hearing on 5th August, 2024, when,
while issuing notice, this Court directed that no adverse action shall be taken
against the petitioner.
14.
The law with regard to blacklisting/debarment of an entity has been
elucidated by the Supreme Court in various judgments. The Supreme Court
in Gorkha Security Services (supra) has made the following observations
with regard to blacklisting of persons from government contracts:“Necessity of serving show-cause notice as a requisite of the
principles of natural justice
16.
It is a common case of the parties that the blacklisting has
to be preceded by a show-cause notice. Law in this regard is firmly
grounded and does not even demand much amplification. The
necessity of compliance with the principles of natural justice by giving
the opportunity to the person against whom action of blacklisting is
sought to be taken has a valid and solid rationale behind it. With
blacklisting, many civil and/or evil b consequences follow. It is
described as “civil death” of a person who is foisted with the order of
blacklisting. Such an order is stigmatic in nature and debars such a
person from participating in government tenders which means
precluding him from the award of government contracts.
***
***
***
Contents of the show-cause notice
21.
The central issue, however, pertains to the requirement of
stating the action which is proposed to be taken. The fundamental
purpose behind the e serving of show-cause notice is to make the
noticee understand the precise case set up against him which he has to
meet. This would require the statement of imputations detailing out
the alleged breaches and defaults he has committed, so that he gets an
opportunity to rebut the same. Another requirement, according to us,
is the nature of action which is proposed to be taken for such a
breach. That should also be stated so that the noticee is able to point
out that proposed action is not warranted in the given case, even if the
defaults/breaches complained of are not satisfactorily explained.
When it comes to blacklisting, this requirement becomes all the more
imperative, having regard to the fact that it is harshest possible
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
20:19:05
W.P.(C) 10713/2024
action.
22.The High Court has simply stated that the purpose of show-cause
notice is primarily to enable the noticee to meet the grounds on which
the a action is proposed against him. No doubt, the High Court is
justified to this extent. However, it is equally important to mention as
to what would be the consequence if the noticee docs not satisfactorily
meet the grounds on which an action is proposed. To put it otherwise,
we are of the opinion that in order to fulfil the requirements of
principles of natural justice, a show-cause notice should meet the
following two requirements viz:
(i) The material/grounds to be stated which according to the
department necessitates an action;
(ii) Particular penalty/action which is proposed to be taken. It is this
second requirement which the High Court has failed to omit.
We may hasten to add that even if it is not specifically mentioned in
the show-cause notice but it can clearly and safely be discerned from
the reading thereof, that would be sufficient to meet this requirement.
15.
The aforesaid judgment was followed by the Supreme Court in UMC
Technologies. The relevant extracts from the said judgment are set out
below:“19. In light of the above decisions, it is clear that a prior show-cause
notice granting a reasonable opportunity of being heard is an essential
element of all administrative decision-making and particularly so in
decisions pertaining to blacklisting which entail grave consequences
for the entity being blacklisted. In these cases, furnishing of a valid
show-cause notice is critical and a failure to do so would be fatal to any
order of blacklisting pursuant thereto.
***
***
***
21. Thus, from the above discussion, a clear legal position emerges that
for a show-cause notice to constitute the valid basis of a blacklisting
order, such notice must spell out clearly, or its contents be such that it
can be clearly inferred therefrom, that there is intention on the part of
the issuer of the notice to blacklist the noticee. Such a clear notice is
essential for ensuring that the person against whom the penalty of
blacklisting is intended to be imposed, has an adequate, informed and
meaningful opportunity to show cause against his possible blacklisting.
***
***
***
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
20:19:05
W.P.(C) 10713/2024
25. The mere existence of a clause in the bid document, which
mentions blacklisting as a bar against eligibility, cannot satisfy the
mandatory requirement of a clear mention of the proposed action in the
show-cause notice. The Corporation's notice is completely silent about
blacklisting and as such, it could not have led the appellant to infer that
such an action could be taken by the Corporation in pursuance of this
notice. Had the Corporation expressed its mind in the show-cause notice
to blacklist, the appellant could have filed a suitable reply for the same.
Therefore, we are of the opinion that the show-cause notice dated 10-42018 does not fulfil the requirements of a valid show-cause notice for
blacklisting. In our view, the order of blacklisting the appellant clearly
traversed beyond the bounds of the show-cause notice which is
impermissible. in law. As a result, the consequent blacklisting order
dated 9-1-2019 cannot be sustained.”
[emphasis supplied]
16.
In light of the aforesaid judgments by the Supreme Court, it is no
longer res integra that before blacklisting a person from Government
tenders, a prior Show Cause Notice has to be given to the entity to enable it
to put forth with its defence. The Show Cause Notice must clearly state the
intention to blacklist the entity so that it can put forth his defence. It has
further been observed that decisions of blacklisting entail grave
consequences on the entity being blacklisted and therefore, issuance of
Show Cause Notice is critical.
17.
When the facts of the present case are analysed in light of the
aforesaid legal position, it is clear that in the present case respondents have
proceeded to blacklist the petitioner without issuance of any Show Cause
Notice indicating that the respondents intend to blacklist/debar the
petitioner. A reading of the aforesaid notice dated 2nd July, 2024 does not
suggest that an action of blacklisting/debarment is contemplated against the
petitioner. In fact, the aforesaid notice of 2nd July, 2024 states that the
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
20:19:05
W.P.(C) 10713/2024
respondents propose to terminate the contract under Clause 7.4 of the GCC.
18.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, the action of the respondents is
clearly opposed to the principles of natural justice and the dicta of the
Supreme Court judgments discussed above.
19.
Accordingly, the impugned termination letter dated 11th July, 2024 to
the extent it debars the petitioner from participating in bids in respect of
projects being tendered by the Railways, Firozpur Cantt is hereby quashed.
20.
The interim order dated 5th August, 2024 shall continue till the
appeal/representation filed by the petitioner before the respondent no.4 is
decided.
21.
The writ petition is disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
22.
All pending applications stand disposed of.
AMIT BANSAL, J
JANUARY 30, 2026
Vivek/-
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
20:19:05
W.P.(C) 10713/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review