Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010605342016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3330]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE EIGHTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE TARLADA RAJASEKHAR RAO
WRIT PETITION No. 23710/2016
BETWEEN:
1. M/S. VGR RESTAURANT & BAR, ANAKAPALLI, REP. BY ITS
MANAGING PARTNER, V.GANESWARA RAO, S/o. LATE ADI
NARAYANA, AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS, OCC:BUSINESS, R/O.
D.NO.19-2-81,
81,
V.J
NAIDU
STREET,
ANAKAPALLI,
VISAKHAPATNAM DISTRICT.
2. SMT. V.ADI LAXMI,, W/O. V.GANESWARA RAO, AGED ABOUT
39 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS, PARTNEI OF M/S. VGR
RESTAURANT & BAR, ANAKAPALLI, R/O. D.No.19
D.No.19-2-81, V.J
NAIDU STREET, ANAKAPALLI, VISAKHAPATNAM DISTRICT
...PETITIONER(S)
AND
1. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, RE
REVENUE
VENUE (EXCISE - II)
DEPARTMENT, SECRETARIAT, HYDERABAD. REP. BY ITS
PRL. SECRETARY
2. THE COMMISSIONER OF PROHIBITION AND EXCISE,
GOVERNMENT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT VIJAYAWADA.
3. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF PROHIBITION AND,
EXCISE, VISAKHAPATNAM, VISAKHAPATNAM DISTRICT.
4. THE
PROHIBITION
AND
EXCISE
SUPERINTENDENT,
ANAKAPALLE, VISAKHAPATNAM DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. O MANOHER REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR PROHIBITION (AP)
2. GP FOR PROHIBITION EXCISE (AP)
The Court made the following:
ORDER:
The 4th respondent has issued notice in RC No.272/2014/A1, dated
16.6.2016, directing the petitioners herein to pay the arrear amount of
Rs.3,80,000/- by way of challan immediately and to submit the same in the
office of the 4th respondent otherwise, necessary further proceedings will be
initiated against the petitioners basing on the material available on the
record. The reason for issuing the said notice is that the petitioners are
granted 2B license under the name and style of M/s. V.G.R. Restaurant and
Bar with license No.13/2006-07 dated 25.01.2007 under Rule 4 of A.P.
Excise [Amendment of License of selling by Bar and conditions license]
Rules, 2005, and the said license was granted on the partnership firm, later
it was converted into proprietary concern by retiring one of its partner
namely Smt. V. Adi Lakshmi, without the sanction of the Commissioner.
And the APBCL Depot was issuing liquor stock in the name of proprietary
concern only and deducting income tax on PAN No. (AAUPV2652H)
allotted to its proprietor Sri V. Ganeswar Rao.
Since, conversion of
partnership firm into proprietary concern amounts to transfer of licene, 10%
of the license fee (Rs.38,00,000/-) for such transferring amounting to
Rs.3,80,000/- is to be collected.
2.
The petitioners herein submitted representation 30.06.2016 stating
that originally bar license was issued in the name of M/s. V.G.R.
Restaurant and Bar, partnership firm, in which Sri P. Mutyalanaidu and
Y.V. Satyanarayana were partners, later on, in the due course of
business, new partners V. Ganeswararao and V. Adilakshmi were
entered into business and P. Mutyalanaidu and Y.V. Satyanarayana
were retired, accordingly there was change in the partners and not in
partnership. Since then, the partnership business in the name and style
of M/s.V.G.R. Restaurant & Bar, continuing till date with partners
V. Ganeswara Rao and V. Adi Lakshmi, without any change.
3.
Only, the APBCL depot which had collected the PAN number of
partner and deposited the TCS in his PAN erroneously. Collecting and
entering the PAN of partner instead of firm PAN, does not amounts to
change in partnership, as noted in the notice issued and therefore
prayed to drop action initiated to collect the amount.
4.
The 4th respondent-Prohibition and Excise Superintendent vide
impugned proceedings dated 09.07.2016, directed to pay an amount of
Rs.3,80,000/- by challan immediately, after dissatisfied with the reply
submitted by the petitioners dated 30.06.2016.
The said notice was
assailed in the present Writ Petition on the ground that the impugned
proceedings dated 09.07.2016 is without considering explanation
submitted by the petitioners, which is illegal, arbitrary and violation of
principles of natural justice.
5.
Giving of reasons is a judicial discipline either by quasi-judicial or
judicial orders, to make known that there has been proper and due
application of mind to the issue before the authority. Non consideration
of the representation amounts to violation of principles of natural justice.
Rules 17(4) and 17(5) of Andhra Pradesh Excise (Grant of License of
Selling by Bar and Conditions of License) Rules, 2005, apply only one of
the partners withdraws or expires, resulting in the change of firm status
from partnership to proprietary concern due to transfer of license.
It is
further submitted that in the present case, none of the clauses have any
application and as on the date, the 2nd petitioner is continuing as partner
of the firm. Merely because, the APBCL is deducting the income tax on
PAN belonging to the 1st petitioner instead of partnership firm, cannot be
a ground to issue the impugned proceedings. And the partnership firm
has got PAN and instead of collecting the PAN of the firm, they have
collected PAN of the 1st petitioner and deducting the amount and the
same does not amount to change in partnership firm as stated in the
notice.
And both notices dated 09.07.2016 and 16.06.2016 without
issuing proper notice to the petitioners, calling for explanation and even
after submitting explanation without considering it, passing the impugned
order is not legal and the same is arbitrary and in violation of principles
of natural justice. Hence, prayed to set aside the impugned notice dated
09.07.2016.
6.
The 4th respondent has filed, the counter affidavit and it is stated
that during the auditing held by the Accountant General Office, Andhra
Pradesh and Telangana for the years 2011-12, 2012-13 and 2013-14,
the irregularity has been noticed in respect of M/s. V.G.R. Restaurant
and Bar, that the license was issued in the name and style of M/s.
V.G.R. Restaurant, partnership firm in which Sri P. Mutyalanaidu S/o.
Appalanaidu and Sri Y.V. Satyanarayana s/o. Appalaswamy were
partners and the bar license was transferred to a partnership firm in
which Sri V. Ganeswara Rao and Smt. V. Adi Lakshmi, were partners.
Further, it was noticed that bar license which was transferred to a
partnership firm was converted into proprietary concern by retiring one of
its partner namely Smt. V. Adi laxmi, without the sanction of the
Commissioner, APBCL depot was issuing liquor stock in the name of
proprietary concern only and deducting income tax on PAN numbers
(AAUPV2652H) allotted to its proprietor Sri V. Ganeswara Rao, since
conversion of partnership firm into proprietary concern amounts to
transfer of license, 10% of the licence fee (Rs.38,00,000/-) for such
transfer, amounting to Rs.3,80,000/- is to be collected.
7.
It is further stated that as per the tax audit report filed under
Section 44AB of Income Tax Act, 1961, income tax returns filed for the
business running in the name of Sri V. Ganeswara Rao. Hence, it is
very clear that the partnership firm was converted into proprietary
concern and the licensee is liable to pay transfer fee of Rs.3.80 Lakh. It
is further stated that the explanation offered by the petitioners is not
satisfactory and hence directed the petitioner No.1 to pay the demand of
Rs.3,80,000/- which is legal. Hence, prayed to dismiss the Writ Petition.
8.
Heard learned Senior Counsel Sri O. Manoher Reddy for OMR
Law Firm for the petitioners and learned Government Pleader for the
respondents.
9.
It is known law that the partners of the partnership firm have to
mandatorily obtain PAN distinct from the individual PAN of its personnel
for filing income tax returns of the partnership firm.
Though, the
partnership firm has obtained the PAN, for whatever reason, as per the
invoice of APBCL and income tax returns indicate that the business was
running in the name of Sri V. Ganeswara Rao. The tax that filed under
Section 44AB of Income Tax Act, 1961 and the audit report indicates
that the business was running in the name of Sri V. Ganeswara Rao. It
clearly indicates that the firm is not paying income tax.
10.
Learned senior counsel had drawn the attention of this Court and
referred the renewal endorsement issued by the Superintendent, Excise,
Anakapally and stated that as per the renewal endorsement, the
partnership firm is continuing and there is no such violation of Rule 17(4)
and (5) of the Rules to treat the conversion of the partnership firm into
proprietary concern that does not amounts to transfer of license. No
reasonable opportunity was given by the 4th respondent to show cause
against the proposed action; that the impugned order does not state the
reasons why the explanation offered rebutting the contentions raised in
the impugned order. Hence, prayed to allow the Writ Petition by setting
aside the impugned notice dated 09.07.2016.
11.
On careful perusal of the impugned order, there is no discussion
or reasons given in the impugned order (except saying that not
satisfactory) for not accepting the explanation.
There are a slew of
judgments for the aforesaid proposition. This Court quotes a judgment
of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Union of India and others v.
Prakash Kumar Tondon1
“the order removing trustees without considering explanation and
without assigning reasons for the non-acceptance of the
explanation vitiated the order of Government removing/dismissing
the trustees.”
12.
After giving careful thought to the arguments advanced by the
petitioners’ counsel and respondents’ counsel, the respondents have not
issued any show-cause notice and called for explanation and the
respondents have not considered the explanation and no reasons are
given in the impugned notice dated 09.07.2016 and the endorsement
that was issued by the Prohibition and Excise Superintendent, indicates
that the firm is ongoing existence and not considering the explanation as
2009 (2) SCC 541.
argued by the learned senior counsel for the petitioners, amounts to
violation of principles of natural justice.
13.
As it is essential requisite to consider the representation, this issue
has to be addressed by the respondents, hence, the Writ Petition stands
allowed by setting aside the impugned proceedings of the 4th respondent
dated 09.07.2016.
However, the respondents are not precluded or
barred from initiating fresh proceedings by due process of law to the
petitioners. There shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel thereto, Interlocutory Applications pending, if any,
shall stand closed.
Date: 18.02.2026
Harin
__________________________________
JUSTICE TARLADA RAJASEKHAR RAO
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE TARLADA RAJASEKHAR RAO
W.P.No. 23710 OF 2016
Date: 18-02-2026
Harin
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review