Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010662422025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3529]
WEDNESDAY, THE FOURTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE R RAGHUNANDAN RAO
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D.SEKHAR
WRIT PETITION NO: 34261/2025
Between:
1. M/S. V R NIRMAN PRIVATE LTD, REPRESENTED BY ITS
MANAGING DIRECTOR, SHRI CHERUVU RAMAKOTAIAH, 1ST
FLOOR, 50-22-11, VARAPURNA NILAYAM, T P T COLONY, NEAR
GANESH BABU CHILDRENS HOSPITAL,
SEETHAMMADHARA,
VISAKHAPATNAM, ANDHRA PRADESH, 530013.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE
ASSISTANT
COMMISSIONER
CENTRAL
TAXES,
VISAKHAPATNAM NORTH CGST DIVISION,
D. NO. 10-50-22,
SIRIPURAM LANE,, 0PP. WNS MAIN GATE, VISAKHAPATNAM - 530
003.
2. THE SUPERINTENDENT OF CENTRAL TAX, ASSELMETTA RANGE,
VISAKHAPATNAM NORTH CGST DIVISION,
D. NO. 10-50-22,
SIRIPURAM LANE, 0PP. WNS MAIN GATE, VISAKHAPATNAM - 530
003.
3. THE SUPERINTENDENT OF CENTRAL TAX, ARC SECTION,
VISAKHAPATNAM NORTH CGST DIVISION
D. NO. 10-50-22,
SIRIPURAM LANE, 0PP. WNS MAIN GATE, VISAKHAPATNAM - 530
003.
4. UNION OF INDIA, DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE, REPRESENTED BY
ITS SECRETARY (REVENUE), NORTH BLOCK, NEW DELHI.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased toPleased to issue a writ of mandamus or any other writ, direction or
order declaring the proceedings of the 1st Respondent in rder-in-Original No.
139/2023- 24/ST/AC/NORTH/DSRB (DIN No. 20240355YJ000005330C)
dated 27.03.2024 for the period from 01st April 2015 to 30th June 2017
confirming the service tax demand of Rs. 49,25,653/- and consequential
recovery notice issued vide C. No. V/4/006/2024-25-ARC/617 dated
14.10.2025 for recovery of the demand confirmed in the Order-ln- Original
No. 139/2023-24/ST/AC/ NORTH/DSRB (DIN No. 20240355YJ000005330C)
dated 27.03.2024 as being arbitrary, unconstitutional, time barred and
contrary to the provisions of the Finance Act, 1994, and the rules made
thereunder and is violative of Article 19(1)(g), 265 and 300A of the
Constitution of India and set aside the same. b. And to pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to stay the operation of the proceedings of the 1st Respondent in
Order-in-Original No. 139/202324/ST/AC/NORTH/DSRB (DIN No.
20240355YJ000005330C) dated 27.03.2024 for the period from 01st April
2015 to 30th June 2017 and consequential recovery notice issued vide C. No.
V/4/006/2024-25 -ARC/617 dated 14.10.2025 in the interest of justice and
pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. ANIL KUMAR BEZAWADA
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. JOSYULA BHASKARA RAO (SR. SC FOR CBIC)
The Court made the following Order:
The petitioner, who is in the business of executing work contracts,
had been awarded certain work contracts by M/s. CPWD. The turnover
relating to the said contracts for the period April-2014 to March-2015 was
taken up for the assessment for service tax under the provisions of the
Finance Act, 1994. The said proceedings, which had been initiated by the
Assistant Commissioner of Central Taxes, Visakhapatnam North CGST
Division, was dropped by way of an Order, dated 30.03.2019. In this Order,
the Assistant Commissioner took the view that the construction works carried
out by the petitioner as a sub contractor of the Ms. CPWD related to the
construction of structures etc, in the Acharya Nagarjuna University, Central
University of Tamil Nadu and Indian Maritime University, Chennai. The
Assistant Commissioner had thereupon taken note of exemption notification
No.25/2012-ST, dated 20.06.2012 and had held that the main contract work
executed by M/s. CPWD would be exempted from sales tax by virtue of entry
No.12 in this notification. Thereafter, the Assistant Commissioner had given a
finding that even services by a sub contractor, provided to another contractor
whose services are exempt, would also have to be exempted by virtue of entry
No.29(h) in the notification, dated 20.06.2012. On this basis, the Assistant
Commissioner dropped all further proceedings, by way of an Order dated
30.03.2019. Aggrieved by this order, the department had moved an appeal
bearing No.01/2019(VSP)ST(D), before the Commissioner (Appeals), Guntur,
central tax & customs. The Commissioner (Appeals) dismissed the appeal,
filed by the department, by an Order dated 23.01.2020. In this order, the
Commissioner took the view that entry No.29(h) read with entry No.12(a) of
the notification, dated 20.06.2012, would exempt the petitioner from being
taxed for the service tax on the contracts executed by the petitioner. Apart
from this, the Commissioner (Appeals) also took the view that since the
CPWD was a main contractor which was eligible for exemption under the
entry No.12(a) & 12(c) and the petitioner would also be exempt, by virtue of
entry No.29(h) of the notification, dated 20.06.2012.
2.
The Assistant Commissioner of Central Taxes again initiated the
assessment proceedings, for sales tax, for the period 2015-16 and 2016-17.
These proceedings were initiated in relation to the contracts executed by the
petitioner as sub contractor of M/s.CPWD, which was treated as the main
contractor. The petitioner, after receipt of the show-cause notice issued by the
Assistant Commissioner, had contended that the transactions in question
relate to the transactions which had already been considered in the earlier
year and that the proceedings cannot be taken further in view of the
observations and findings of the Assistant Commissioner as well as the
Commissioner (Appeals) in the earlier round of assessment.
3.
The Assistant Commissioner, however passed an order of
assessment, bringing to tax, the turnovers of the petitioner, relating to the
execution of work contracts in that period. The Assistant Commissioner held
that no material had been placed before the Assistant Commissioner to
demonstrate that the contracts executed by the petitioner are related only to
contracts for the Government or Government authorities or local bodies and
that these contracts were executed through M/s.CPWD. The Assistant
Commissioner had thereafter, held that the turnovers of the petitioner would
be liable to be taxed, as no material has been placed before the Assistant
Commissioner, regarding the nature of the works executed by the petitioner.
4.
Aggrieved by this Order, dated 27.03.2024, the petitioner has
approached this Court by way of the present Writ Petition.
5.
Sri P. Veera Reddy, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf
of Sri Anil Kumar Bezawada, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner,
would assail the said order on two grounds:I.
Learned Senior Counsel would contend that the Assistant
Commissioner did not have the discretion to take up these issues
again after the decision of the Commissioner (Appeals), dated
23.01.2020 and relied upon the Judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India, in the case of Union of India & Ors Vs.
Kamlakshi Finance Corporation Limited 1.
II.
Learned Senior Counsel would also contend that the Assistant
Commissioner, in the impugned order, had given a specific
finding that the works executed by the petitioner were works
executed as sub contractor to M/s.CPWD. In such circumstances,
the Assistant Commissioner could not have arrived at any finding,
that the non-filing of the documents by the petitioner was
1992 Supp (1) SCC 443
sufficient to hold that the petitioner had not demonstrated that
these transactions are exempted transactions.
6.
Sri Josyula Bhaskar Rao, learned Standing Counsel for CBIC,
appearing for the respondents, would on the other hand contend that the
findings for the earlier assessment period are not binding and would not
amount to res judicata, for subsequent years, under the taxation law. He
would further submit that the Assistant Commissioner had distinguished the
turnovers, under the impugned assessment proceedings, from the turnovers
relating to the earlier period. He would submit that this differentiation is based
on the fact that the petitioner had not placed any material before the Assistant
Commissioner to show that the transactions in the present period are identical
or similar to the transactions of the previous year.
7.
The question of exemption arises on account of the notification
dated 20.06.2012. The entry No.12 of this notification reads as follows:12. Services provided to the Government, a local authority or a
governmental authority by way of construction, erection,
commissioning, Installation, completion, fitting out, repair,
maintenance, renovation, or alteration ofa) 4[***];
b) a historical monument, archaeological site or remains of
national importance, archaeological excavation, or antiquity
specified under the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological
Sites and Remains Act, 1958 (24 of 1958);
c) 1[***];
d) canal, dam or other Irrigation works;
e) pipeline, conduit or plant for (i) water supply (ii) water
treatment, or (iii) sewerage treatment or disposal; or
f) 2[***];
3[12A. Services provided to the Government, a local authority or a
governmental authority by way of construction, erection,
commissioning, installation, completion, fitting out, repair,
maintenance, renovation, or alteration of-
a) a civil structure or any other original works meant
predominantly for use other than for commerce, Industry, or
any other business or profession,
b) a structure meant predominantly for use as (i) an educational,
(ii) a clinical, or (iii) an art or cultural establishment; or
c) a residential complex predominantly meant for self-use or the
use of their employees or other persons specified in the
Explanation 1 to clause (44) of section 65B of the said Act;
under a contract which had been entered into prior to the 1st March,
2015 and on which appropriate stamp duty, where applicable, had
been paid prior to such date:
Provided that nothing contained in this entry shall apply on or after
the 1st April, 2020;]
8.
Other relevant entry is entry No.29(h) which reads as follows:“Service by the following persons in respective capacitiesa)
b)
c)
d)
e)
f)
sub-broker or an authorised person to a stock broker;
authorised person to a member of a commodity exchange;
1[***];
2[***];
3[***];
selling agent or a distributor of SIM cards or recharge coupon
vouchers,
g) business facilitator or a business correspondent to a banking
company with respect to accounts in its rural area branch;)
(ga)
any person as an intermediary to a business facilitator
or a business correspondent with respect to services mentioned
in clause(g).
(gb)
business facilitator or a business correspondent to an
insurance company in a rural area; or]
h) sub-contractor providing services by way of works contract to
another contractor providing works contract services which are
exempt;”
9.
The findings of the Assistant Commissioner, in the impugned Order
is that the turnover, considered in the impugned order arise out of the services
provided by the petitioner to M/s. CPWD.
10.
The works carried out by M/s. CPWD, as set out in the order itself
in paragraph Nos.8.1 & 8.2, would show that these works related to Kendriya
Vidyalaya, Nagakudi, Tamil Nadu, as well as certain works executed for the
Andhra Pradesh Endowment Department in relation to certain temples. Entry
No.12, in the notification, dated 20.06.2012, states that all services provided to
the Government or a local authority or a Government authority in relation to
structures meant predominantly for use by an educational establishment
would be exempt. M/s.CPWD had executed works for Kendriya Vidyalaya,
which would be a Governmental authority for the construction of a school
building which can only be used for an education purpose. Similarly, the
construction carried out for the Andhra Pradesh Endowments department
would squarely fall within the exemption granted under the entry No.12 of the
notification, dated 20.06.2012.
11.
Apart from this, the question of whether the
Assistant
Commissioner could have raised these issues in a subsequent year remains.
The Judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Union of
India & Ors Vs. Kamlakshi Finance Corporation Limited had considered a
similar issue where the assessing authority sought to reopen the issues which
had already been determined by the Collector (Appeals) in an earlier period.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, while dealing with this issue, had held as
follows:“6. Sri Reddy is perhaps right in saying that the officers were not
actuated by any mala fides in passing the impugned orders. They
perhaps genuinely felt that the claim of the assessee was not tenable
and that, if it was accepted, the Revenue would suffer. But what Sri
Reddy overlooks is that we are not concerned here with the
correctness or otherwise of their conclusion or of any factual mala
fides but with the fact that the officers, in reaching their conclusion,
by-passed two appellate orders in regard to the same issue which
were placed before them, one of the Collector (Appeals) and the
other of the Tribunal. The High Court has, in our view, rightly criticised
this conduct of the Assistant Collectors and the harassment to the
assessee caused by the failure of these officers to give effect to the
orders of authorities higher to them in the appellate hierarchy. It
cannot be too vehemently emphasised that it is of utmost importance
that, in disposing of the quasi-judicial issues before them, revenue
officers are bound by the decisions of the appellate authorities. The
order of the Appellate Collector is binding on the Assistant Collectors
working within his jurisdiction and the order of the Tribunal is binding
upon the Assistant Collectors and the Appellate Collectors who
function under the jurisdiction of the Tribunal. The principles of judicial
discipline require that the orders of the higher appellate authorities
should be followed unreservedly by the subordinate authorities. The
mere fact that the order of the appellate authority is not "acceptable"
to the department- in itself an objectionable phrase and is the subject
matter of an appeal can furnish no ground for not following it unless
its operation has been suspended by a competent court. If this
healthy rule is not followed, the result will only be undue harassment
to assessees and chaos in administration of tax laws.
7. The impression or anxiety of the Assistant Collector that, if he
accepted the assessee's contention, the department would lose
revenue and would also have no remedy to have the matter rectified
is also incorrect. Section 35-E confers adequate powers on the
department in this regard. Under sub-section (1), where the Central
Board of Direct Taxes come across any order passed by the Collector
of Central Excise with the legality or propriety of which it is not
satisfied, it can direct the Collector to apply to the Appellate Tribunal
for the determination of such points arising out of the decision or
order as may be specified by the Board in its order. Under subsection (2) the Collector of Central Excise, when he comes across
any order passed by an authority subordinate to him, if not satisfied
with its legality or propriety, may direct such authority to apply to the
Collector (Appeals) for the determination of such points arising out of
the decision or order as may be specified by the Collector of Central
Excise in his order and there is a further right of appeal to the
department. The position now, therefore, is that, if any order passed
by an Assistant Collector or Collector is adverse to the interests of the
Revenue, the immediately higher administrative authority has the
power to have the matter satisfactorily resolved by taking up the issue
to the Appellate Collector or the Appellate Tribunal as the case may
be. In the light of these amended provisions, there can be no
justification for any Assistant Collector or Collector refusing to follow
the order of the Appellate Collector or the Appellate Tribunal, as the
case may be, even where he may have some reservations on its
correctness. He has to follow the order of the higher appellate
authority. This may instantly cause some prejudice to the Revenue
but the remedy is also in the hands of the same officer. He has only
to bring the matter to the notice of the Board or the Collector so as to
enable appropriate proceedings being taken under Section 35-E(1) or
(2) to keep the interests of the department alive. If the officer's view is
the correct one, it will no doubt be finally upheld and the Revenue will
get the duty, though after some delay which such procedure would
entail.”
12.
In the light of these observations and in view of the fact that the
Assistant Commissioner itself had given findings relating to the nature of the
works executed by the petitioner, it would have to be held that the impugned
order, dated 27.03.2024, passed by the Assistant Commissioner would have
to be set aside. Accordingly, this Writ Petition is disposed of, setting aside the
impugned Order, dated 27.03.2024, passed by the Assistant Commissioner of
Central Taxes.
As a sequel, pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall
stand closed.
________________________
R. RAGHUNANDAN RAO, J
________________
T.C.D. SEKHAR, J
Date: 04.02.2026
BSM
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE R. RAGHUNANDAN RAO
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D.SEKHAR
WRIT PETITION No.34261 of 2025
04-02-2026
BSM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review