Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 08th July 2026.
Pronounced on: 06th August 2026.
Uploaded on: 07th August 2026.
+
MAC.APP. 951/2018
M/S TRIVENI ROAD CARRIERS PVT LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. S.N. Parashar, Mr. Ritik
Singh, Advocates.
versus
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO LTD & ORS .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Abhinav Jain, Advocate for
Respondent no.1.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
%
ANISH DAYAL, J.
1.
This appeal has been filed by the owner of offending vehicle
challenging recovery rights granted against them in favour of respondent
no.1/Insurance Company by way of impugned award dated 24th July
2017 passed by Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (‘MACT/Tribunal’),
Karkardooma Court, Delhi in MACT No. 15110/2015, where MACT has
awarded compensation of Rs. 2,19,808/- along with interest at the rate of
9%.
The Incident
2.
The accident occurred on 17th January 2012, where respondent
no.3/injured claimant was riding a bicycle towards his home from Pappu
Colony Seemapuri. When he reached near J & K Bus Stop, near Dilshad
Garden, a goods carrier truck bearing No. DL-1-GB-3815 (hereinafter,
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 951/2018
15:02:15
‘offending vehicle’) driven by respondent no.2/driver and owned by
appellant/owner hit respondent no.3/injured claimant from behind. He
was removed to GTB Hospital, Delhi and as a result of the accident, he
sustained injuries on his right ear and grievous injuries upon his head
and upper back.
Impugned Award
3.
As regards the issue of negligence, MACT held that the accident
had occurred due to rash and negligent driving of respondent no.2/driver
and awarded compensation to respondent no.3/injured claimant.
4.
While deciding the issue of liability, MACT noted that there was a
valid insurance policy issued by respondent no.1/Insurance Company. A
defence had been raised by respondent no.1/Insurance Company that the
driver/respondent no.2 of the offending vehicle was not holding a proper
and effective driving licence.
5.
In this regard, respondent no.1/Insurance Company examined Sh.
Amit Kapoor, Senior Divisional Manager (‘R3W1’) who deposed that
respondent no.2/driver was driving the offending vehicle which was
insured by respondent no.1/Insurance Company. The driving licence had
been exhibited as R3W1/1. The verification report provided by the
Investigation Officer (‘IO’), exhibited as R3W1/2 stated at point ‘A’ that
the driving licence had not been issued by Motor Vehicles Department at
Mathura, U.P. Later on, an application had been moved by respondent
no.2/driver who provided another driving licence, Exhibit R3W1/3,
which had a verification report at point ‘B’ showing that the driving
licence issued on 16th August 2011 was a valid licence.
6.
Considering that the testimony of R3W1 remained uncontroverted
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 951/2018
15:02:15
and unimpeached, MACT held that there was a breach of the terms and
conditions of the insurance policy, therefore, granting right of recovery
to respondent no.1/Insurance Company.
Submissions on behalf of appellant
7.
Mr. S.N. Parashar, counsel for appellant/owner, has challenged
the impugned award on the grant of recovery rights in favour of
respondent no.1/Insurance Company. He submitted that the driving
license produced by respondent no.2/driver during the verification was a
genuine license and the same was taken note of by the MACT.
8.
Mr. Parashar, drew attention of this Court to the application
issued by SI Vikas Kumar, PS, Seema Puri, on 10th February 2012 to
Licensing Authority, M.V. Department, Mathura (U.P.) seeking
verification of license no. 166/5/M107 issued on 22nd November 2007
and valid up to 16th February 2012 (hereinafter, ‘license no.1’).
9.
He also drew the Court's attention to the driving license No.
1051/OR/SKNO/08 valid from 16th August 2011 to 15th August 2014.
(hereinafter, ‘license no.2’). The driving license was issued under the
name of Saroj Kumar s/o Ram Snehi by the Licensing Authority-Sant
Kabir Nagar, U.P.
10.
Mr. Parashar, counsel for appellant/owner, stated that the driver
had produced license no.2 before the appellant/owner and therefore, they
were not aware of a previous license having been issued.
11.
Drawing reference to license no.2, he stated that the licensing
authority had verified the said license and it had also been presented
before the MACT at a later stage, therefore, the MACT erred by not
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 951/2018
15:02:15
considering license no.2, which was, in fact, the valid driving license
alleged to be issued on 23rd May 2000 and was valid from 16th August
2011 till 15th August 2014.
Submissions on behalf of respondent no.1
12.
Mr. Abhinav Jain, counsel for respondent no.1/Insurance
Company stated that the driving license presented at the time of accident
was a fake license and further submitted that the defence of due
diligence taken by appellant/owner before the MACT does not satisfy
the standard of care that should be taken by a transport carrier.
13.
Mr. Jain, added that the threshold of verification for a transport
company is different from an individual, therefore, the stand taken by
appellant/owner that they had verified the driving license may not be
enough to discharge them from their liability. The onus of verifying the
driving license and the credentials of a driver is more for a transport
company like the appellant/owner, than it is for an individual owner.
Analysis
14.
In order to appreciate the contentions raised by the parties, it
would be apposite to provide a chronological sequence of events.
15.
The accident occurred on 17th January 2012 and the IO
verification took place on 10th February 2012, after which the Detailed
Accident Report (‘DAR’) was filed on 13th July 2012 and converted into
a claim petition on 21st July 2012. An application was moved on behalf
of respondent no.2/driver on 1st September 2012 for bringing on record
the valid driving license i.e. license no.2. The written statement/reply to
the DAR was filed by the driver and owner on 6th December 2012.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 951/2018
15:02:15
16.
It is pertinent to note that on the date of accident, the driving
license was seized by the IO and a seizure memo was prepared which
records the seizure of license no.1 from respondent no.2/driver. The said
license was sent by the IO for verification on 10th February 2012 and a
reply was received by the Mathura Authority on 2nd March 2012
confirming that the driving license was fake and no records of the same
were found in their system.
17.
Moreover, after the said verification, a report was filed by the
police on 13th July 2012, stating that an additional offence of forgery
under Section 471 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 (‘IPC’) against
respondent no.2/driver, was added to the FIR on the ground of fake
license. The report stated that the accused-driver was arrested and during
the investigation, the police had taken into possession and verified the
offending vehicle’s Registration Certificate (‘RC’), Insurance and
Fitness Certificate. The driving license was also verified and was found
to be fake.
18.
An application was filed by respondent no.2/driver for bringing on
record the valid driving license, i.e., license no.2. It was also stated that
respondent no.2/driver had a safety training certificate for safe
transportation of hazardous goods, issued by Industrial Safety & Health
Advancement Council of India which was valid up to 2nd October 2012.
19.
The said driving license is extracted as under for ease of reference:
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 951/2018
15:02:15
20.
The verification by the licensing authority has been provided at
point ‘B’. It is noted that the license no.2 was issued from Sant Kabir
Nagar Licensing Authority, U.P. and was filed by respondent no.2/driver
of the offending vehicle, which was duly verified.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 951/2018
15:02:15
21.
Appellant/Owner had filed a written statement before the MACT,
however, no evidence was led by them stating that while engaging the
driver, they had visibility of license no.2 and had clearly verified the
same or taken the driver’s driving test or carried out any other process in
order to prove their due diligence in respect of verification of the driving
license.
22.
While Mr. Parashar, counsel for appellant/owner, stated that they
had taken the defence that they had verified the driving license, however,
no specification as regards the fake or genuine driving license was
presented by them.
23.
In any event, as per the Detailed Accident Report (‘DAR’), license
no.1 had been produced, which was found to be fake. Considering that
the appellant/owner is a commercial carrier, the burden of due diligence
is of a higher level, since an entity which is operating a commercial fleet
has to adopt stricter standards in order to verify the drivers who are
driving their vehicles.
24.
This aspect has been considered in detail by this Court in United
India Insurance Co Ltd v. Sarjo & Ors, 2026:DHC:5182, whereby the
Court was adjudicating the issue of owner’s liability in case of fake
driving license, in an appeal filed by the Insurance Company seeking
recovery rights against the owner. The Court allowed the appeal and
granted recovery rights against the owner-Delhi Transport Corporation.
It was held that public entities operating fleets of buses, taxis, and
similar vehicles ought to exercise greater caution and bear a higher
responsibility in verifying the authenticity of driving license than private
entities. Therefore, higher standard of due diligence is expected of them.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 951/2018
15:02:15
Relevant findings of the Court are extracted as under:
“32. In the opinion of this Court, the extent of due
diligence, which a private owner can or must exercise,
as compared to that which a public authority
(employing a fleet of vehicles) or a commercial
operator, (operating a fleet of vehicles) must exercise,
is fundamentally different.
33. A private employer may not have the administrative
machinery at its command to seek physical verification,
at least prior to 2015 (when the Parivahan facility
came into existence or when it became fully
operational and accessible). However, a commercial
fleet operator or a State Authority operating a fleet of
buses, taxis or transport vehicles has vast
administrative machinery at its command. The
responsibility is much greater considering that such
vehicles carry members of the public who travel on the
assurance that they will be safe in the said vehicles.
34. It would, therefore, be incumbent upon such
entities to ensure that the drivers operating such
vehicles, whether carrying a private consumer or the
public at large in transport vehicles, have undergone a
complete verification process, beyond merely taking a
driving test, so as to verify the authenticity of their
licences.
35. In the present case, an effort was made by the DTC
to issue a letter to the Mathura Authority for
verification of the licence. However, they did not wait
for the response. Even if the response had not been
received in time, the DTC machinery could have taken
several further steps to ensure proper verification.
However, it chose not to do so. Had the Mathura
Authority responded, even with some delay, the DTC
would have become aware at that very stage that the
driver was carrying a fake licence. This is apart from
the fact that, as noted earlier, ex facie the licence
appeared to be fake on the basis of the dates endorsed
therein.”
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 951/2018
15:02:15
(emphasis added)
25.
In the present case, appellant/owner was a commercial carrier and
no evidence was placed before the MACT in order to prove and
substantiate their due diligence. The very fact that a second license is
produced subsequently, does not insulate them from liability.
26.
A reply which was filed to the DAR, on behalf of driver and
owner, which also does not find any mention regarding the possession of
the fake license no.1. Quite otherwise, it merely states that the accident
was caused due to the negligence of respondent no3/injured claimant.
27.
It was also stated that respondent no.2/driver was appointed after
conducting a driving test under different road and traffic conditions and
after seeing the driving licence.
28.
On the other hand, respondent no.1/Insurance Company in their
written statement had taken a specific plea relating to the fact that
respondent no.2/driver was not holding a proper authentic driving
licence and the verification report found the driving licence to be fake.
29.
As regards the issue of recovery rights granted in favour of
respondent no.1/Insurance Company, reliance may be placed upon the
decision of Supreme Court in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Lehru
& Ors. (2003) 3 SCC 338 and National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Geeta
Bhatt & Ors. (2008) 12 SCC 426, which mandates the grant of recovery
rights in cases where breach stands established.
30.
Relevant finding of the Supreme Court in Lehru (supra) is
extracted as under:
“20. When an owner is hiring a driver he will therefore
have to check whether the driver has a driving licence.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 951/2018
15:02:15
If the driver produces a driving licence which on the
face of it looks genuine, the owner is not expected to
find out whether the licence has in fact been issued by
a competent authority or not. The owner would then
take the test of the driver. If he finds that the driver is
competent to drive the vehicle, he will hire the driver.
We find it rather strange that insurance companies
expect owners to make enquiries with RTOs, which are
spread all over the country, whether the driving licence
shown to them is valid or not. Thus where the owner
has satisfied himself that the driver has a licence and is
driving competently there would be no breach of
Section 149(2)(a)(ii). The insurance company would
not then be absolved of liability. If it ultimately turns
out that the licence was fake, the insurance company
would continue to remain liable unless they prove that
the owner/insured was aware or had noticed that the
licence was fake and still permitted that person to
drive. More importantly, even in such a case the
insurance company would remain liable to the
innocent third party, but it may be able to recover from
the insured. This is the law which has been laid down
in Skandia [(1987) 2 SCC 654] , Sohan Lal
Passi [(1996) 5 SCC 21 : 1996 SCC (Cri) 871]
and Kamla [(2001) 4 SCC 342 : 2001 SCC (Cri)
701] cases. We are in full agreement with the views
expressed therein and see no reason to take a different
view.”
(emphasis added)
31.
Relevant findings of the Supreme Court in Geeta Bhatt (supra)
are extracted as under:
“7. An owner of the vehicle is bound to make
reasonable enquiry as to whether the person who is
authorised to drive the vehicle holds a licence or not.
Such a licence not only must be an effective one but
should also be a valid one. It should be issued for
driving a category of vehicle as specified in the Motor
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 951/2018
15:02:15
Vehicles Act and/or Rules framed thereunder.
……
16. We, therefore, are of the opinion that interest of
justice shall be subserved if the appellant is directed to
pay the awarded amount in favour of Respondents 1 to
5 with liberty to recover the same from the owner and
the driver of the vehicle, Respondents 6 and 7 in an
appropriate proceeding in accordance with law.”
(emphasis added)
32.
The Supreme Court in a recent judgment delivered on 30 th July
2026, discussed the issue of liability of Insurance Company, in cases
where the driving license in invalid. The Supreme Court in Reliance
General Insurance Company Ltd. v. Om Prakash & Ors. 2026 INSC
767, detailed the importance of driving license being an official
document, which is issued by the competent authority, subject to
satisfaction of requirements. In such cases, where the validity of a
driving license is in question, it is pertinent for the official authority to
conclusively establish whether the document is valid or not. Observing
that the authority did not have complete records of the status of driving
license, thereby, making it unclear whether the license held by the driver
was valid or not, the Supreme Court allowed the appeal of Insurance
Company and granted recovery rights. Relevant findings of the Court are
extracted as under:
“16. Here only we may add that the owner has not
entered the witness box either to say whether on the
date of the accident the driver had a valid license or
not, or to say that he had taken steps to ensure that the
driver’s license was renewed after it had expired.
…
18. Following the dictum above, the appeal is allowed.
The appellant insurer cannot be held liable to make
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 951/2018
15:02:15
good the award. The final burden shall be on both the
employer and the driver. In the order issuing notice,
we had directed that the amount as computed be
released in favour of the claimants. In view of the
above discussion, we hold the principle of ‘pay and
recover’ to be applicable in this case. The appellantinsurer shall therefore be at liberty to take steps in
accordance with law.
19. This Court cannot be oblivious to the fact that
asking a driver or an owner to pay such a large
amount is a humongous burden upon them. It may
throw into disarray, their entire lives all because the
driver and the owner did not take adequate precaution
to ensure that there was no break in the validity of the
driving license. Had that been done, the burden would
not have fallen upon them, and the appellant-insurer
would have been bound to honour the award. In our
view, this underscores the importance of the driving
license. It is a document that certifies the ability to
drive on the road, and so it stands to reason that all
drivers should have it.”
(emphasis added)
33.
Accordingly, in view of the above, the appeal is dismissed.
34.
Recovery rights granted in the impugned award are upheld.
35.
Statutory deposit, if any, be refunded to appellant/owner.
36.
Pending applications are rendered infructuous.
37.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
AUGUST 06, 2026/RK/sp
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 951/2018
15:02:15
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review