Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 13th JANUARY, 2026
IN THE MATTER OF:
+
ARB.P. 1897/2025
M/S THEME ENGINEERING SERVICES PVT. LTD. .....Petitioner
Through:
Ms. Nandadevi Deka, Mr. Arunabha
Ganguli, Mr. Shashwat Pratyush, Ms.
Shubhra Sharma and Mr.Sourav
Sharma, Advs.
versus
NATIONAL HIGHWAYS AUTHORITY OF INDIA .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Santosh Kumar, SC with Mr.
Ritik Dwivedi, Mr. Adithya Ramani
and Mr. Devansh Malhotra, Advs. for
R-1.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD
JUDGMENT
1.
This Petition has been filed under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 seeking appointment of an Arbitrator to adjudicate
upon the disputes which have arisen between the parties under the
Consultancy Contract Agreement dated 24.09.2019.
2.
It is stated that under the said Agreement, the Petitioner herein was to
provide Supervision Consultancy Services for construction supervision of
Balance work of 4-laning of Ranchi-Rargaon-Mahulia section from KM
114.000 to km 277.500 of NH-33 in the State of Jharkhand. It is stated that
disputes arose between the parties and the Respondent issued Order dated
17.12.2020 debarring the Petitioner for a period of two years. It is stated that
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:39:31
ARB.P. 1897/2025
the debarment Order was challenged by the Petitioner herein by filing
W.P.(C) 1173/2021 before this Court. It is stated that this Court vide Order
dated 23.05.2023 quashed the debarment Order. The said Order was
challenged by the Respondent by filing SLP (C) No. 4741/2021, before the
Apex Court. The said SLP was dismissed by the Apex Court vide Order
dated 24.03.2021.
3.
It is pertinent to mention that the General Conditions of Contract
(GCC) Agreement dated 24.09.2019 contains a dispute resolution clause and
the same reads as under:
“8. Settlement of Disputes
8.1 Amicable Settlement
The Parties shall use their best efforts to settle
amicably all disputes arising out of or in connection
with this Contract or the interpretation thereof.
8.2 Dispute Settlement
Any dispute between the Parties as to matters arising
pursuant to this Contract which cannot be settled
amicably within thirty (30) days after receipt by one
Party of the other Party's request for such amicable
settlement may be submitted by either Party for
settlement in accordance with the provisions specified
in the SCC.”
4.
Clause 8.2 of the Special Conditions of Contract (SCC) provides for
adjudication of disputes by way of arbitration and the same reads as under:
“8.2 Disputes shall be settled by arbitration in
accordance with the following provisions:
8.2.1 Selection of Arbitrators
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:39:31
ARB.P. 1897/2025
Each dispute submitted by a Party to Arbitration shall
be heard by a sole arbitrator. NHAI shall within 30
days propose names of five (5) Arbitrators from the list
of Arbitrators maintained by SAROD (Society for
Affordable Redressal of Disputes) and Consultant shall
within 30 days select one name from the list of five and
the name so selected by the Consultant shall be the
Sole Arbitrator for the matter in dispute. In case NHAI
delays in providing the list of 5 names, President,
SAROD will provide 5 names within 30 days of receipt
of reference from aggrieved party in this regard. In
case the Consultant falls in selecting one from the list
of five, President, SAROD shall select one from the list
of five provided by NHAl within 30 days of receipt of
reference from aggrieved party in this regard.
8.2.2 Rules of Procedure
Arbitration proceedings shall be conducted in
accordance with the procedures of the Arbitration and
Conciliation (Amendment) Act, 2015 of India unless
the Consultant is a foreign national/ firm, where
arbitration proceedings shall be conducted in
accordance with the rules of procedure of arbitration
of the United Nations Commission on International
Trade Law (UNCITRAL) as in force on the date of this
Contract
8.2.3 Substitute Arbitrator
If for any reason an arbitrator is unable to perform his
function, a substitute shall be appointed in the same
manner as the original arbitrator,
8.2.4 Qualifications of Arbitrators The list of five and
the sole arbitrator selected pursuant to Clause 8.2.1
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:39:31
ARB.P. 1897/2025
hereof shall be expert(s) with extensive experience in
relation to the matter in dispute.
8.2.5 Miscellaneous
In any arbitration proceeding hereunder:
(a) Proceedings shall, unless otherwise agreed by the
parties be held in
Delhi, (b) The English language shall be the official
language for all purposes;
(c) The decision of sole arbitrator shall be final and
binding and shall be enforceable in any court of
competent jurisdiction, and the Parties hereby walve
any objections to or claims of immunity in respect of
such enforcement; and.......”
5.
It is stated that after the SLP was dismissed, the Petitioner sent a letter
dated 07.10.2023 to the Respondent detailing the claim for damages and
financial loss incurred by the Petitioner due to unlawful debarment of the
Petitioner. In the said letter, the Petitioner also made it clear that if the
claims of the Petitioner are not settled by the Respondent, the Petitioner will
invoke Arbitration in terms of Clause 8.2 of the SCC for adjudication of the
disputes. Since the claims of the Petitioner were not settled by the
Respondent, the Petitioner invoked Arbitration vide notice dated 09.12.2023.
6.
Vide letter dated 28.12.2023, the Respondent agreed for settlement of
disputes by way of conciliation. In the said communication, it was
specifically mentioned that since the parties are now aiming to settle the
disputes amicably through conciliation, the arbitration proceedings be kept
in abeyance.
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:39:31
ARB.P. 1897/2025
7.
As evident from the letter dated 15.02.2024, the conciliation
proceedings began between the Petitioner and the Respondent. However,
material on record does not disclose that the conciliation proceedings
succeeded in settling the disputes. Therefore, the Petitioner once again sent a
Notice dated 25.07.2025 under Section 21 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 invoking Arbitration. It is stated that since the
Respondents failed to refer the disputes to Arbitration, the Petitioner has
approached this Court by filing the present Petition.
8.
Learned Counsel appearing for the Respondent contends that the
claims raised by the Petitioner are for damages and financial loss incurred
by the Petitioner on account of debarment of the Petitioner and, therefore,
the same is not arbitrable as the claims do not arise from the Contract
Agreement in question. He relies on the Judgment of the Apex Court in
BSNL v. Telephone Cables Ltd., (2010) 5 SCC 213, to substantiate his
contention. Learned Counsel for the Respondent has also raised objections
regarding limitation. He, therefore, states that the present Petition is not
maintainable.
9.
The Contention of the learned Counsel for the Respondent cannot be
accepted in view of the settled law that the referral Court under Section 11
of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996, has to only examine the prima
facie existence of an arbitration agreement and the determination of the
substantive rights, maintainability of claims, and the issue of limitation etc.,
should be left to the Arbitral Tribunal. The Apex Court in Interplay Between
Arbitration Agreements under Arbitration, 1996 & Stamp Act, 1899, In re,
(2024) 6 SCC 1, has observed as under:“165. The legislature confined the scope of reference
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:39:31
ARB.P. 1897/2025
under Section 11(6-A) to the examination of the
existence of an arbitration agreement. The use of the
term “examination” in itself connotes that the scope of
the power is limited to a prima facie determination.
Since the Arbitration Act is a self-contained code, the
requirement of “existence” of an arbitration
agreement draws effect from Section 7 of the
Arbitration Act. In Duro Felguera [Duro Felguera,
S.A. v. Gangavaram Port Ltd., (2017) 9 SCC 729 :
(2017) 4 SCC (Civ) 764] , this Court held that the
Referral Courts only need to consider one aspect to
determine the existence of an arbitration agreement —
whether the underlying contract contains an
arbitration agreement which provides for arbitration
pertaining to the disputes which have arisen between
the parties to the agreement. Therefore, the scope of
examination under Section 11(6-A) should be
confined to the existence of an arbitration agreement
on the basis of Section 7. Similarly, the validity of an
arbitration agreement, in view of Section 7, should be
restricted to the requirement of formal validity such
as the requirement that the agreement be in writing.
This interpretation also gives true effect to the
doctrine of competence-competence by leaving the
issue of substantive existence and validity of an
arbitration agreement to be decided by Arbitral
Tribunal under Section 16. We accordingly clarify
the position of law laid down in Vidya Drolia [Vidya
Drolia v. Durga Trading Corpn., (2021) 2 SCC 1 :
(2021) 1 SCC (Civ) 549] in the context of Section 8
and Section 11 of the Arbitration Act.
166. The burden of proving the existence of arbitration
agreement generally lies on the party seeking to rely
on such agreement. In jurisdictions such as India,
which accept the doctrine of competence-competence,
only prima facie proof of the existence of an
arbitration agreement must be adduced before the
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:39:31
ARB.P. 1897/2025
Referral Court. The Referral Court is not the
appropriate forum to conduct a mini-trial by allowing
the parties to adduce the evidence in regard to the
existence or validity of an arbitration agreement. The
determination of the existence and validity of an
arbitration agreement on the basis of evidence ought
to be left to the Arbitral Tribunal. This position of law
can also be gauged from the plain language of the
statute.
167. Section 11(6-A) uses the expression “examination
of the existence of an arbitration agreement”. The
purport of using the word “examination” connotes
that the legislature intends that the Referral Court
has to inspect or scrutinise the dealings between the
parties for the existence of an arbitration agreement.
Moreover, the expression “examination” does not
connote or imply a laborious or contested inquiry. [
P. Ramanatha Aiyar, The Law Lexicon (2nd Edn.,
1997) 666.] On the other hand, Section 16 provides
that the Arbitral Tribunal can “rule” on its
jurisdiction, including the existence and validity of an
arbitration agreement. A “ruling” connotes
adjudication of disputes after admitting evidence from
the parties. Therefore, it is evident that the Referral
Court is only required to examine the existence of
arbitration agreements, whereas the Arbitral Tribunal
ought to rule on its jurisdiction, including the issues
pertaining to the existence and validity of an
arbitration agreement. A similar view was adopted by
this Court in Shin-Etsu Chemical Co. Ltd. v. Aksh
Optifibre Ltd. [Shin-Etsu Chemical Co. Ltd. v. Aksh
Optifibre Ltd., (2005) 7 SCC 234]”
(emphasis supplied)
10.
Similarly, the Apex Court in SBI General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Krish
Spinning, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1754, has observed as under:-
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:39:31
ARB.P. 1897/2025
“122. Once an arbitration agreement exists between
parties, then the option of approaching the civil court
becomes unavailable to them. In such a scenario, if the
parties seek to raise a dispute, they necessarily have to
do so before the arbitral tribunal. The arbitral
tribunal, in turn, can only be constituted as per the
procedure agreed upon between the parties. However,
if there is a failure of the agreed upon procedure, then
the duty of appointing the arbitral tribunal falls upon
the referral court under Section 11 of the Act, 1996. If
the referral court, at this stage, goes beyond the scope
of enquiry as provided under the section and examines
the issue of “accord and satisfaction”, then it would
amount to usurpation of the power which the parties
had intended to be exercisable by the arbitral tribunal
alone and not by the national courts. Such a scenario
would impeach arbitral autonomy and would not fit
well with the scheme of the Act, 1996.
*****
125. We are also of the view that ex-facie frivolity and
dishonesty in litigation is an aspect which the arbitral
tribunal is equally, if not more, capable to decide upon
the appreciation of the evidence adduced by the
parties. We say so because the arbitral tribunal has the
benefit of going through all the relevant evidence and
pleadings in much more detail than the referral court.
If the referral court is able to see the frivolity in the
litigation on the basis of bare minimum pleadings, then
it would be incorrect to doubt that the arbitral tribunal
would not be able to arrive at the same inference, most
likely in the first few hearings itself, with the benefit of
extensive pleadings and evidentiary material.”
11.
Since it is well-settled that referral courts should normally follow the
policy of „when in doubt, refer‟ and in view of the fact that disputes have
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:39:31
ARB.P. 1897/2025
certainly arisen between the parties, this Court is inclined to appoint an
Arbitrator to adjudicate upon the disputes between the parties.
12.
Unless the claims of the Petitioner are clearly barred by limitation, it
is always open for the learned Arbitrator to adjudicate on the disputes
between the parties. In any event, the Order of debarment was quashed by
this Court on 23.05.2023 and, therefore, it cannot be said that the claim of
the Petitioner is ex-facie bad. However, without observing anything on the
merits of the case, and in view of the fact that disputes have arisen between
the parties and there is an Arbitration Clause in the Contract Agreement anc
conciliation proceedings have failed, this Court appoints, Mr. Ranjit Kumar,
Senior Advocate (Mob. No: 9810184723) as the Sole Arbitrator to
adjudicate upon the disputes between the parties.
13.
The arbitration would take place under the aegis of the Delhi
International Arbitration Centre (DIAC) and would abide by its rules and
regulations. The learned Arbitrator shall be entitled to fees as per the
Schedule of Fees maintained by the DIAC.
14.
The learned Arbitrator is also requested to file the requisite disclosure
under Section 12(2) of the 1996 Act within two weeks of entering on
reference.
15.
All rights and contentions of the parties in relation to the
claims/counter-claims are kept open, to be decided by the learned Arbitrator
on their merits, in accordance with law.
16.
It is made clear that nothing in this order shall be construed as an
expression of this Court on the merits of the contentions of the parties.
17.
It is further made clear that the observations made in this Order are
squarely limited to the appointment of an Arbitrator. Needless to say, it is
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:39:31
ARB.P. 1897/2025
open for the Respondent to urge its contention regarding arbitrability etc.
before the Arbitrator.
18.
The petition stands allowed in the above terms, along with pending
application(s), if any.
SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD, J
JANUARY 13, 2026
Rahul
Signed By:HARIOM
SINGH KIRMOLIYA
17:39:31
ARB.P. 1897/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review