Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
*THE HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
*THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE N.TUKARAMJI
AND
*THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
+W.P.Nos.20397 of 2025, 26393 of 2024, 15821, 15975, 19150, 19170, 19388, 19894, 19900,
20001, 20090, 20101, 20125, 20196, 20404, 20409, 20427, 20473, 20528, 20599, 20625, 20653,
20798, 21005, 21024, 21060, 21114, 21466, 21642, 21853, 22081, 22326, 22395, 22490, 22562,
22577, 22582, 22588, 22806, 23297, 23308, 23347, 23395, 23466, 23475, 23504, 23524, 23545,
23623, 23730, 23761, 23785, 23831, 23833, 23906, 24014, 24069, 24196, 24218, 24230, 24349,
24354, 24402, 24420, 24513, 24632, 24808, 24812, 24816, 24818, 24833, 25208, 25257, 25271,
25279, 25317, 25337, 25339, 25340, 25361, 25382, 25384, 25385, 25387, 25395, 25406, 25413,
25496, 25529, 25562, 25671, 25710, 25726, 26012, 26046, 26085, 26210, 26229, 26236, 26248,
26280, 26298, 26300, 26475, 26536, 26553, 26566, 26570, 26617, 26641, 26643, 26659, 26759,
26822, 26887, 27122, 27165, 27204, 27214, 27232, 27249, 27304, 27317, 27323, 27349, 27360,
27678, 27683, 27736, 27770, 28065, 28304, 28513, 28618, 28644, 28761, 28775, 28801, 28846,
28906, 28954, 29146, 29313, 29504, 29507, 29688, 29692, 29696, 29908, 29926, 29932, 29935,
29951, 30090, 30104, 30158, 30166, 30184, 30222, 30247, 30382, 30481, 30571, 30843, 30846,
30847, 30928, 30935, 30948, 31032, 31383, 31406, 31408, 31410, 31419, 31428, 31432, 31504,
31880, 31904, 31909, 31911, 32387, 32498, 32535, 32660, 33099, 33147, 33495, 33749, 33768,
34129 and 34134 of 2025
% Dated: 30.09.2026
Reserved on: 15.07.2026
Pronounced on:
30.09.2026
Uploaded on:
02.10.2026
# Gudla Vanaja and others.
…Petitioners
vs.
$ Assistant Commissioner (ST),
Saroor Nagar-I Circle, Telangana and others.
…Respondents
! Counsel for the petitioners:
Ms. Yammanuru Siri Reddy, Mr. A.V.A. Siva Kartikeya,
Mr. M. Naga Deepak, Mr. Venkatram Reddy Mantur,
Mr. Jai Kishan Solanki, Mr. Santosh Sagar Kapilvai,
Mr. K.P. Amarnath Reddy, Mr. Dandu Suresh Babu,
Mr. Gouraram Rajashekar Reddy, Mr. S.V. Pranav Ram,
Mr. T. Pradyoth, Mr. S. Suri Babu, Mr. B. Krishna Reddy,
Mr. E. Rakesh Reddy, Mr. Shaik Jeelani Basha, Mr. P. Srikanth
Rao, Mr. Karan Talwar, Mr. Raja Shekar Rao Salvaji,
Mr. P. Bharath Nandan, Mr. Dantu Srinivas, Mr. Ch. Samson
Babu, Mr. P. Venkata Prasad, representing M/s. P.V. Prasad
Associates, Mr. J. Dheeraj Reddy, Mr. Upadhyay Raghavender,
Mr. Goondla Venkateswarlu, Mr. B.Srinivas, Mr. Mohd. Ismail
Khan, Mr. Srinarayan Toshniwal, Mr. V. Veeresham,
Mr. C.Sanjeeva Rao, Mr. Karthik Ramana Puttamreddy,
Mr.
G.N.G.
Shankar,
Mr.
Vedantam
Sriramnivas,
Mr. Nishanth Rao K N, Mr. Hari Kishan Kudikala,
Mr. K. Sudhakar Reddy, Mr. Aitharaju Venkateshwarlu,
Mr. Pullabhotla VLS Sri Chakrapani, Mr. M.V.L. Narasimha Rao,
Mr. G. Narendra Chetty, Mr. Nagendra Prasad, Mr.Mohammed
Mukhairuddin, Mr. Muktinutalapati Ramachandra Murthy,
Mr. G.R.S. Akhileswar, Mr. V. Aneesh, Mr. V. Rajeshwar Rao,
Mr. Singam Srinivasa Rao, Mr. M. Umashankar, Mr. Ravi Sankara
Reddy.P and Mr. Kohir Bhaskar Reddy.
^ Counsel for the respondents:
Mr. A. Sudarshan Reddy, learned Advocate General duly assisted
by Mr. Swaroop Oorilla, learned Special Government Pleader for
State Tax and Mr. K.Sai Akarsh, learned Assistant Government
Pleader for State Tax appears for the State.
Mr. B. Narasimha Sharma, learned Additional Solicitor General of
India and Mr. Dominic Fernandes, learned Senior Standing
Counsel for the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs,
assisted by Ms. B.N.Pravalika Goud, Ms. T.Shivani Reddy and
Mr.B.Praneeth, appear for Goods and Services Tax Network.
Mr. D.Raghavendra Rao, learned Senior Standing Counsel for
Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs appears for Central
Tax Department.
Learned counsel Mr. Hemanth Kumar Vemuri appears for Karur
Vysya Bank.
Learned counsel Mr. N. Praveen Reddy, learned counsel
Mr. Sudharshan Narahari and learned counsel Mr. G.Kalyan
Chakravarthy appear for ICICI Bank.
Mr. N.Bhujanga Rao, learned Deputy Solicitor General of India,
Mr. K. Arvind Kumar, learned Senior Standing Counsel,
Mr. Janardhan Goud Sunkari, learned Central Government Senior
Counsel, Sri B.Jithender, learned Central Government Counsel,
Mr. A.S.Vasudevan, learned counsel, Mr. A. Kranthi Kumar
Reddy, learned counsel, Mr. Pulimamidi Shashidhar Reddy,
learned counsel, Ms. B.Kavita Yadav, learned Senior Standing
Counsel for Central Government and Mr. Kalvala Sanjeev, learned
counsel appear for Union of India.
< Gist:
> Head Note:
? Cases referred
1.
2.
3.
4.
[2025] 142 GSTR 608 (Telangana)
[2025] 137 GSTR 620 (Telangana)
(2009) 11 SCC 244
WP (C) No.16532 of 2025, CM Appl.67713/2025 & CM Appl.67714/2025, dated
31.10.2025
5. 1992 Supp 1 SCC 471
6. (1996) 7 SCC 613
7. (2022) 1 Centax 289
8. (2025) 29 Centax 394 (Mad)
9. [2025] 181 taxmann.com 888 : 2025 (12) TMI 1598 – Allahabad High Court
10. 2024 (1) TMI 1434 – Rajasthan High Court : 2025 (95) G.S.T.L. 264 (Raj)
11. (2023) 12 Centax 198 (AP)
12. 2005 (186) E.L.T. 266 (S.C.)
13. 2007 (209) E.L.T. 161 (S.C.)
14. (2026) 38 Centax 90 (S.C.)
15. AIR 2015 Gujarat 1
16. AIR 1965 SC 1636
17. 2025 (2) TMI 1091 – Kerala High Court
18. (1975) 45 Comp Cas 43
19. 2010 SCC OnLine Bom 516
20. R/Special Leave Application No.2699 of 2025, dated 20.06.2025
21. R/Special Civil Application No.8125 of 2024, dated 20.03.2025
22. (2024) 18 Centax 490 (Ori.)
23. (2007) 2 SCC 230
24. W.P.No.4005 of 2025, dated 20.02.2025
25. W.P.No.14874 of 2025, dated 26.09.2025
26. W.P.No.1363 of 2026, dated 31.01.2026
27. (1998) 2 SCC 44
28. (2025) 32 Centax 130 (Telangana)
29. 1950 SCC 205
30. (2011) 6 SCC 508
31. 2025 Supreme (Online) (Mad) 49709
32. AIR 1954 SC 340
33. (2015) 8 SCC 519
34. AIR 1959 SC 93
35. (2002) 1 SCC 633
36. (1999) 8 SCC 266
37. [1986] 59 Comp Cas 548 : (1986) 1 SCC 264
38. 2025 (34) Centax 442 (Del)
39. 2025 (31) Centax 224 (Del)
40. 2025 (31) Centax 158 (Del)
41. [2023] 112 GSTR 149 (Bom)
42. (1999) 4 SCC 575
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE N.TUKARAMJI
AND
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
W.P.Nos.20397 of 2025, 26393 of 2024, 15821, 15975, 19150, 19170, 19388, 19894, 19900,
20001, 20090, 20101, 20125, 20196, 20404, 20409, 20427, 20473, 20528, 20599, 20625, 20653,
20798, 21005, 21024, 21060, 21114, 21466, 21642, 21853, 22081, 22326, 22395, 22490, 22562,
22577, 22582, 22588, 22806, 23297, 23308, 23347, 23395, 23466, 23475, 23504, 23524, 23545,
23623, 23730, 23761, 23785, 23831, 23833, 23906, 24014, 24069, 24196, 24218, 24230, 24349,
24354, 24402, 24420, 24513, 24632, 24808, 24812, 24816, 24818, 24833, 25208, 25257, 25271,
25279, 25317, 25337, 25339, 25340, 25361, 25382, 25384, 25385, 25387, 25395, 25406, 25413,
25496, 25529, 25562, 25671, 25710, 25726, 26012, 26046, 26085, 26210, 26229, 26236, 26248,
26280, 26298, 26300, 26475, 26536, 26553, 26566, 26570, 26617, 26641, 26643, 26659, 26759,
26822, 26887, 27122, 27165, 27204, 27214, 27232, 27249, 27304, 27317, 27323, 27349, 27360,
27678, 27683, 27736, 27770, 28065, 28304, 28513, 28618, 28644, 28761, 28775, 28801, 28846,
28906, 28954, 29146, 29313, 29504, 29507, 29688, 29692, 29696, 29908, 29926, 29932, 29935,
29951, 30090, 30104, 30158, 30166, 30184, 30222, 30247, 30382, 30481, 30571, 30843, 30846,
30847, 30928, 30935, 30948, 31032, 31383, 31406, 31408, 31410, 31419, 31428, 31432, 31504,
31880, 31904, 31909, 31911, 32387, 32498, 32535, 32660, 33099, 33147, 33495, 33749, 33768,
34129 and 34134 of 2025
Dated: 30.09.2026
Reserved on: 15.07.2026
Pronounced on:
Uploaded on:
30.09.2026
02.10.2026
WRIT PETITION No.20397 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010402922025
Between:
Gudla Vanaja
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST),
Saroor Nagar-I Circle, Telangana and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26393 of 2024
CNR No. HBHC010512422024
Between:
M/s.Naskon Associates LLP
…Petitioner
and
The Deputy Commissioner of State Tax,
Madhapur Division, Hyderabad and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.15821 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010296482025
Between:
M/s.Sai Earth Movers
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, Department of Revenue (CT),
Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Hyderabad and 4 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.15975 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010319422025
Between:
Lakshmi Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
The State Tax Officer (GST)(ST), Karimnagar-II Circle,
Karimnagar Division, Telangana and 5 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.19150 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010378432025
Between:
Mahadevan & Co
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Commercial Taxes Department,
Basheerbagh-Nampally I Circle,
Abids, Hyderabad – 500 001, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.19170 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010373302025
Between:
M/s.Mahalaxmi Electricals
…Petitioner
and
State Tax Officer, Ferozguda Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, Hyderabad and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.19388 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010344922025
Between:
M/s.Rasun Exports Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The State Tax Officer, Khairatabad-Somajiguda-2 Circle,
Hyderabad, 8th Floor, B-Block, Mayur Complex, Abids,
Hyderabad – 500 001, Telangana and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.19894 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010391052025
Between:
M/s.Shiva Sai Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Saroor Nagar-III Circle,
Commercial Tax Department, Government of Telangana,
Hyderabad and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.19900 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010392942025
Between:
Venkata Subbaraya Choudary Maddukuri
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Revenue, (Commercial Taxes Department),
Dr. B.R.Ambedkar Telangana Secretariat, Saifabad,
Hyderabad – 500 022 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.20001 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010392642025
Between:
Pavan Electrical and Sanitation
…Petitioner
and
The State Tax Officer (GST)(ST),
Madhapur 8 Circle, Madhapur Division, and 4 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.20090 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010393182025
Between:
M/s.Tanmayi Aircon
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Commercial Taxes, Secretariat, Hyderabad and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.20101 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010395652025
Between:
M/s.Cisne for Arts and Entertainments LLP
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary to Government,
Revenue (CT-II) Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.20125 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010397712025
Between:
M/s.Ahmed Traders
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Bodhan and Nizamabad-III Circle,
Nizamabad and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.20196 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010398362025
Between:
M/s.Pragati Road Carriers
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, Department of Revenue (CT)
rep. by its Principal Secretary, Secretariat, Hyderabad,
Telangana and another
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.20404 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010399622025
Between:
Harini Ganti
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary to Government,
Revenue (CT-II) Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.20409 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010359692025
Between:
M/s. Siva Sai Ganesh Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
The Deputy Commissioner (ST-5), Enforcement Wing-II,
HOD, Telangana and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.20427 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010402952025
Between:
Gudla Vanaja
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Saroor Nagar-I Circle,
Saroor Nagar, Telangana and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.20473 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010315752025
Between:
M/s.Satyanarayana Reddy Kandimalla
…Petitioner
and
The Deputy Commissioner (ST)-IV, Enforcement Wing-1,
CT Complex, Nampally, Hyderabad and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.20528 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010401872025
Between:
Krishna Clothings
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Malakpet-II, Charminar,
Telangana, Hyderabad and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.20599 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010397322025
Between:
M/s.Cisne for Arts and Entertainments LLP
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary to Government,
Revenue (CT-II) Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.20625 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010399742025
Between:
Harini Ganti
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary to Government,
Revenue (CT-II) Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.20653 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010401362025
Between:
R. Balarami Reddy and Co.
…Petitioner
and
Appellate Joint Commissioner (ST) (FAC),
Secunderabad Division, Hyderabad, 5th Floor,
CT Complex, Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 4 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.20798 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010284422025
Between:
M/s.Srinidhi Power Solutions
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Revenue (CT-II)
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad, Telangana and another
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.21005 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010415392025
Between:
M/s.Srinidhi Power Solutions
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Revenue (CT-II)
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad, Telangana and another
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.21024 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010284942025
Between:
M/s.Srinidhi Power Solutions
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Revenue (CT-II)
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad, Telangana and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.21060 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010414982025
Between:
M/s. Maks FMS India Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Lad Bazar,
Charminar, State of Telangana, Hyderabad and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.21114 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010417082025
Between:
Geetha Kirana General Stores
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (GST)(ST),
IDA Gandhi Nagar/Hyder Nagar-I,
Hyderabad Rural Division, T.G., and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.21466 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010412472025
Between:
M/s. Raja Ram Agencies
…Petitioner
and
State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Commercial Taxes, Secretariat, Hyderabad and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.21642 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010422282025
Between:
Salapi Consultants Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Hyderguda-Ashok Nagar Circle,
Abids, Hyderabad – 01, Telangana and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.21853 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010417802025
Between:
M/s. Sri Venkateswara Gas Agency
…Petitioner
and
State of Telangana, Rep. by its Secretary, Commercial Tax Department,
Government of Telangana, Hyderabad and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.22081 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010436432025
Between:
Vasu Katakam
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Keesara,
Malkajgiri, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.22326 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010294772025
Between:
Terminus Kg Ventures Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Deputy Commissioner of State Tax, STU-2,
Punjagutta Division, Mayur Kushal Complex,
Beside Chermas, Abids, Hyderabad–500 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.22395 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010443482025
Between:
Fortuna Identity Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Commercial Taxes Department 6,
Madhapur, Telangana and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.22490 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010426282025
Between:
M/s.Ragi & Ragi Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST),
Mahankali Street – R.P. Road, Secunderabad
and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.22562 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010446122025
Between:
M/s.Export Cargo Packagings
…Petitioner
and
The Deputy Commissioner (ST), Enforcement Wing-1,
CCT, Hyderabad and 5 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.22577 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010446312025
Between:
Planet Sigma Embedded Systems Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (State Tax),
Office of the Assistant Commissioner (ST),
Hydernagar-II, Hyderabad Rural, 3rd Floor,
East Wing, Gaganvihar Building, Nampally,
Hyderabad – 500 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.22582 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010446302025
Between:
Planet Sigma Embedded Systems Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (State Tax),
Office of the Assistant Commissioner (ST),
Hydernagar-II, Hyderabad Rural, 3rd Floor,
East Wing, Gaganvihar Building, Nampally,
Hyderabad – 500 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.22588 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010426342025
Between:
M/s. Vinci Global Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Madhapur – 8 Circle,
Madhapur Division, Hyderabad and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.22806 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010450232025
Between:
M/s. Minttu Sarna
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner of State Tax,
Basheerbagh – Nampally Circle, Abids Division,
Old Kakatiya Hotel Building, 3rd Floor, Nampally,
Hyderabad – 500 001 and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.23297 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010450062025
Between:
M/s. Minttu Sarna
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner of State Tax,
Basheerbagh – Nampally Circle, Abids Division,
Old Kakatiya Hotel Building, 3rd Floor, Nampally,
Hyderabad – 500 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.23308 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010460982025
Between:
M/s. Sony Electronics
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Nagarkurnool – Jadcherla,
Nalgonda, Telangana and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.23347 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010450342025
Between:
M/s. Minttu Sarna
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner of State Tax,
Basheerbagh – Nampally Circle, Abids Division,
Old Kakatiya Hotel Building, 3rd Floor, Nampally,
Hyderabad – 500 001 and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.23395 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010460932025
Between:
M/s. Sony Electronics
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Nagarkurnool – Jadcherla,
Nalgonda, Telangana and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.23466 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010463092025
Between:
M/s.Swastik Agencies
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Saroornagar – I,
Saroornagar Division, Nampally, Hyderabad and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.23475 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010460632025
Between:
Mohammed Tabrez Uddin
…Petitioner
and
The Union of India, rep. by its Secretary (Finance),
Ministry of Finance, North Block,
New Delhi – 110 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.23504 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010450322025
Between:
M/s. Minttu Sarna
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner of State Tax,
Basheerbagh – Nampally Circle, Abids Division,
Old Kakatiya Hotel Building, 3rd Floor, Nampally,
Hyderabad – 500 001 and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.23524 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010463082025
Between:
M/s.Swastik Agencies
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Saroornagar – I,
Saroornagar Division, Nampally, Hyderabad and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.23545 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010463972025
Between:
M/s.RK Traders
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Division – Warangal,
Circle – Kothagudem I, Door No.3-2-44, 2nd Floor,
Near Hanuman Temple, Vidyanagar Colony,
Kothagudem – 507 101, Telangana and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.23623 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010465682025
Between:
M/s.Austrazen Bio Pharmaceuticals Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Saroornagar – 1 Circle,
Saroornagar Division, Hyderabad and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.23730 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010470802025
Between:
M/s. UHC Lifesciences
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner ST, Nacharam – 1 Circle,
Malkajgiri Division, 12th Floor, South Wing,
Gaganvihar, Nampally, Hyderabad-500001 and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.23761 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010470472025
Between:
M/s.Sikhwal Metal
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner of State Tax,
Afzalgunj – Maharajgunj Circle, Charminar Division,
8th Floor, Gaganvihar Building, Nampally,
Telangana, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.23785 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010472132025
Between:
Smt. Suneetha Pantham
…Petitioner
and
The Appellate Joint Commissioner (ST),
Hyderabad Rural Division, 5th Floor, CT Complex,
Nampally, Hyderabad and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.23831 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010432112025
Between:
M/s. Laxmi Ganapathi Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner ST, Warangal Urban – II Circle,
Warangal Division, House No.23-6-163/1, 3rd Floor,
CTO Office Complex, Behind Vishal Mart, Hunter Road,
Warangal – 506 002, and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.23833 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010470642025
Between:
M/s.Sikhwal Metal
…Petitioner
and
State Tax Officer, Afzalgunj – Maharajgunj Circle, Charminar Division,
8th Floor, Gaganvihar Building, Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001,
Telangana and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.23906 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010473072025
Between:
M/s.Anucon Engineering Projects Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (State Tax), Hydernagar – I Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, Hyderabad and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.24014 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010473182025
Between:
M/s.Sikhwal Metal
…Petitioner
and
State Tax Officer, Afzalgunj – Maharajgunj Circle, Charminar Division,
8th Floor, Gaganvihar Building, Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001,
Telangana and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.24069 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010477742025
Between:
M/s. Inter City Transport Company
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Fatehnagar Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, Hyderabad, Telangana and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.24196 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010478352025
Between:
M/s. Inter City Transport Company
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Fatehnagar Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, Hyderabad, Telangana and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.24218 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010465722025
Between:
M/s. Soni Transport Solutions
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (State Taxes),
Fatehnagar Circle, Hyderabad Rural Division,
Hyderabad and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.24230 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010478372025
Between:
M/s. Inter City Transport Company
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Fatehnagar Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, Hyderabad, Telangana and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.24349 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010478392025
Between:
M/s.A K Traders
…Petitioner
and
Deputy Commissioner (State Tax)-IV, Enforcement Wing – 1,
Office of the Chief Commissioner of State Tax, 3rd Floor, MJ Road,
Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.24354 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010478232025
Between:
M/s. Inter City Transport Company
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Fatehnagar Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, Hyderabad, Telangana and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.24402 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010481072025
Between:
Highbrow Production Services Pvt Ltd
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner of State Tax, Madhapur Division,
Madhapur - 2 Circle, Nampally, Hyderabad–500 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.24420 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010477972025
Between:
M/s. Inter City Transport Company
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Fatehnagar Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, Hyderabad, Telangana and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.24513 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010485772025
Between:
M/s. Gupta Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
The State Tax Officer, O/o Assistant Commissioner ST,
Charminar Circle, Charminar Division, 9th Floor,
Gaganvihar Building, Nampally, Hyderabad and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.24632 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010432122025
Between:
M/s. Siddivinayaka Distributors
…Petitioner
and
The Deputy Commissioner ST, Sangareddy STU Circle,
Nizamabad Division, H.No.4-8-85/10/B, Manjeera Pipe Line Road,
Sangareddy – 502001 and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.24808 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010492542025
Between:
M/s. 2E Smart Solutions LLP
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Madhapur-8 Circle,
1st Floor, Gagan Vihar Building, Opp. Gandhi Bhavan,
Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.24812 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010491132025
Between:
M/s. Harish Medical and General Stores
…Petitioner
and
The Appellate Joint Commissioner (ST), Secunderabad Division,
Nampally, Hyderabad and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.24816 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010261152025
Between:
M/s. Gayatri Silver Merchant
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner ST, FAC, Nirmal Circle,
Adilabad Division, H.No.7-2-83/57-1, Near Post Office,
Indiranagar, Nirmal, Telangana – 504106 and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.24818 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010492442025
Between:
M/s. KP Constructions
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (FAC), Wanaparthy Circle, Plot Nos.4,5,6 and 7,
Near 1st Railway Gate, Kurnool Road, Gadwal, Jogulamba Gadwal (D),
Telangana – 508207 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.24833 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010265282025
Between:
M/s.Jaiveer Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Vanasthalipuram-1 Circle,
Saroornagar Division, Hyderabad and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25208 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010497492025
Between:
M/s.Sri Chakra Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Jeedimetla-II Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Range, Telangana and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25257 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010499932025
Between:
M/s.Care Food Products
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Malkajgiri-I Circle,
Saroor Nagar Division, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25271 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010499512025
Between:
M/s.Care Food Products
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST),Malkajgiri-I Circle,
Saroor Nagar Division, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25279 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010504372025
Between:
Reva Medical Institute Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner of State Tax, Punjagutta Division,
Jubilee Hills 4 Circle, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25317 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010499312025
Between:
M/s.Care Food Products
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Malkajgiri-I Circle,
Saroor Nagar Division, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25337 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010499482025
Between:
M/s.Care Food Products
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Malkajgiri N-I Circle,
Malkajgiri Division, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25339 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010499732025
Between:
M/s.Care Food Products
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Malkajgiri -I Circle,
Saroor Nagar Division, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25340 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010499972025
Between:
M/s.Care Food Products
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner of State Tax, Malkajgiri - I Circle,
Saroor Nagar Division, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25361 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010497922025
Between:
M/s. T.F.Technologies
…Petitioner
and
Union of India, rep. by its Secretary, Ministry of Finance,
Department of Revenue, North Block, New Delhi – 110 001 and 5 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25382 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010505712025
Between:
M/s. Polar Auto & Engineering Industries Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The State Tax Officer (ST), Sangareddy – II Circle,
Nizamabad Division, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25384 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010506132025
Between:
M/s. Polar Auto & Engineering Industries Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Sangareddy – II Circle,
Nizamabad Division, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25385 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010505512025
Between:
M/s.Bhavani Traders
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Vengal Rao Nagar-I Circle,
Panjagutta Division, Telangana and 4 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25387 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010506562025
Between:
M/s. Polar Auto & Engineering Industries Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The State Tax Officer (ST), Sangareddy – II Circle,
Nizamabad Division, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25395 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010504402025
Between:
Reva Medical Institute Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner of State Tax, Punjagutta Division,
Jubilee Hills 4 Circle, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25406 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010506682025
Between:
M/s. Chemic Life Sciences Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Commercial Taxes, Secretariat, Hyderabad and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25413 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010499462025
Between:
M/s.Care Food Products
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner of State Tax, Malkajgiri - I Circle,
Saroor Nagar,Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25496 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010509002025
Between:
M/s.Mahadev Marketing
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Abids Circle,
Abids Division, and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25529 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010508412025
Between:
M/s.Sri Banbhori Impex
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, Department of Revenue (CT),
rep. by its Principal Secretary, Secretariat,
Hyderabad, Telangana and another
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25562 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010508972025
Between:
Barret Commodity Traders Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Keesara-1, Malkajgiri Division,
Medchal-Malkajgiri District, Telangana and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25671 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010505342025
Between:
M/s.PCS Computers
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Saroornagar – II,
Saroornagar Division, Nampally, Hyderabad and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25710 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010513572025
Between:
M/s.Balaji Automobiles
…Petitioner
and
The Appellate Joint Commissioner (ST),
Secunderabad Division, Hyderabad and 4 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.25726 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010505782025
Between:
M/s.Bhavani Traders
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Vengal Rao Nagar-I Circle,
Panjagutta Division, Telangana and 4 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26012 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010505332025
Between:
M/s.PCS Computers
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Saroornagar – II,
Saroornagar Division, Nampally, Hyderabad and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26046 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010497072025
Between:
M/s.Care Food Products
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Malkajgiri-I Circle,
Saroor Nagar Division, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26085 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010513162025
Between:
Sravanthi Fertilizer
…Petitioner
and
The State Tax Officer (State Tax), Office of the Assistant Commissioner (ST),
Wanaparthy, Nalgonda Division, Plot Nos.4,5,6 and 7,
Near 1st Railway Gate, Kurnool Road, Gadwal – 508207,
Jogulamba Gadwal (D) and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26210 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010500352025
Between:
M/s. Sri Padmavathi Agencies
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST)(FAC), Wanaparthy @ Gadwal Circle,
Nalgonda Division, Telangana and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26229 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010497472025
Between:
M/s.Sri Chakra Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Jeedimetla-II Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Range, Telangana and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26236 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010499882025
Between:
M/s.Care Food Products
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Malkajgiri-I Circle,
Saroor Nagar Division, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26248 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010523852025
Between:
M/s.GBP Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Vanasthalipuram Circle 1,
Saroor Nagar Division, Hyderabad, Telangana and 4 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26280 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010524222025
Between:
M/s.GBP Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Vanasthalipuram Circle 1,
Saroor Nagar Division, Hyderabad, Telangana and 4 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26298 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010521632025
Between:
M/s. S S Steels
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner ST, Nacharam-1 Circle,
Malkajgiri Division, 12th Floor, South Wing, Gagan Vihar,
Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26300 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010521762025
Between:
M/s. S S Steels
…Petitioner
and
The State Tax Officer-1, Nacharam-1 Circle,
Malkajgiri Division,12th Floor, South Wing, Gagan Vihar,
Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26475 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010527932025
Between:
M/s.Eprheromone IPM Solutions
…Petitioner
and
The State Tax Officer-1, Malkajgiri-2 Circle, Malkajgiri Division,
M-4 Block, Manoranjan Complex, Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001
and 5 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26536 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010497142025
Between:
Prakash Sirvi
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Nacharam-2 Circle,
Malkajgiri Division, 5th Floor, East Wing, Gagan Vihar,
Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26553 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010529322025
Between:
M/s.Eprheromone IPM Solutions
…Petitioner
and
The State Tax Officer-1, Malkajgiri-2 Circle,
Malkajgiri Division, M-4 Block, Manoranjan Complex,
Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 4 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26566 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010529352025
Between:
M/s.Eprheromone IPM Solutions
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Malkajgiri-II Circle,
Malkajgiri Division, M-4 Block, Manoranjan Complex,
Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 4 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26570 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010530042025
Between:
M/s. Harshitha Granites and Minerals
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (State Tax),
Warangal Urban III, Warangal and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26617 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010521862025
Between:
M/s. S S Steels
…Petitioner
and
The State Tax Officer-1, Nacharam-1 Circle,
Malkajgiri Division,12th Floor, South Wing, Gagan Vihar,
Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26641 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010530602025
Between:
M/s. Siva Sai Ganesh Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ENFT), Enforcement,
HOD, Hyderabad and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26643 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010497562025
Between:
M/s.Sri Chakra Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Jeedimetla-II Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Range, Telangana and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26659 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010530052025
Between:
M/s. Harshitha Granites and Minerals
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (State Tax),
Warangal Urban III, Warangal and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26759 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010525582025
Between:
M/s. Premier Ethanols Pvt Ltd
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Gandhinagar Circle,
Secunderabad Division, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26822 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010530792025
Between:
M/s.Srinivasa Corporation
…Petitioner
and
Appellate Joint Commissioner of State Tax, Secunderabad Division,
5th Floor, CT Complex, Nampally, Hyderabad and 5 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.26887 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010409112025
Between:
M/s. Paramount Pharmachem LLP
…Petitioner
and
State Tax Officer, Hydernagar – 2 Circle, Hyderabad (Rural) Division,
Hyderabad, Telangana and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.27122 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010540742025
Between:
M/s.Vasireddy Sreeharsha
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Khammam-II Circle,
Warangal Division, No.10-6-179/6, Near Sri PV Narsimha Rao Park,
Burhanpuram, Khammam, Khammam District,
Telangana – 507 001 and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.27165 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010541522025
Between:
Jayanthi Nagam
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (State Tax), Hydernagar – 1 Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, 3rd Floor, Gaganvihar, Nampally, Hyderabad,
and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.27204 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010542642025
Between:
M/s.Sri Mukambica Projects Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Malkajgiri-II Circle,
Malkajgiri Division, Hyderabad, Telangana and 4 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.27214 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010540852025
Between:
M/s.Sri Balaji Medical Fancy and General Stores
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Khammam-II Circle,
Warangal Division, No.10-6-179/6, Near Sri PV Narsimha Rao Park,
Burhanpuram, Khammam, Khammam District,
Telangana – 507 001 and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.27232 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010541512025
Between:
Jayanthi Nagam
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (State Tax), Hydernagar – 1 Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, 3rd Floor, Gaganvihar, Nampally,
Hyderabad, and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.27249 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010540792025
Between:
M/s.Vasireddy Sreeharsha
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Khammam-II Circle,
Warangal Division, No.10-6-179/6, Near Sri PV Narsimha Rao Park,
Burhanpuram, Khammam, Khammam District,
Telangana – 507 001 and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.27304 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010543222025
Between:
M/s.MVD Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Vidyanagar Circle,
Secunderabad Division, Telangana and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.27317 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010543132025
Between:
SSV Sri Power Technologies and Services
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Saroornagar,
Hyderabad – 500 001 and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.27323 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010544092025
Between:
M/s. Systems Group
…Petitioner
and
The Deputy Commissioner (State Tax) (STU-II),
Panjagutta Division, Hyderabad and 5 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.27349 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010541122025
Between:
M/s.Supertech Solutions
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner, Vengalraonagar Circle,
Panjagutta Division, Hyderabad and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.27360 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010544002025
Between:
M/s. Systems Group
…Petitioner
and
The Deputy Commissioner (State Tax) (STU-II),
Panjagutta Division, Hyderabad and 6 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.27678 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010545422025
Between:
M/s. Systems Group
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner of State Tax, Jubilee Hills – I Circle,
Panjagutta Division, Hyderabad and 6 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.27683 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010543442025
Between:
M/s.Professional Waterproofing AP
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Jeedimetla – I Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, Hyderabad and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.27736 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010551982025
Between:
M/s.New Sai Tirumala Automobiles
…Petitioner
and
The Appellate Joint Commissioner (ST), Secunderabad Division, 5 th Floor,
CT Complex, Nampally, Hyderabad, Telangana and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.27770 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010540192025
Between:
Sri Raghavendra Auto Agencies
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (State Taxes), Vanasthalipuram – I Circle,
Saroornagar Division, Nampally, Hyderabad and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.28065 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010559082025
Between:
M/s.Enzen Global Solutions Pvt Ltd
…Petitioner
and
Appellate Joint Commissioner (ST), Punjagutta Division, 5th Floor,
CT Complex, Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.28304 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010564222025
Between:
M/s.Supermix Infra Concrete
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Vanasthalipuram – I Circle,
Saroornagar Division, Telangana and another.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.28513 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010567392025
Between:
M/s.Unique Infra Engineers Pvt Ltd
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner ST, Hydernagar – III Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, 5th Floor, South Wing, Gagan Vihar Building,
Opp. Gandhi Bhavan, Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.28618 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010567362025
Between:
M/s.Divya Marketing
…Petitioner
and
The Deputy State Tax Officer, O/o The Joint Commissioner (ST),
Charminar Division, Gagan Vihar Building, Nampally,
Hyderabad – 500 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.28644 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010566312025
Between:
M/s.Dhev Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Keesara – I Circle,
Malkajgiri Division, Hyderabad and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.28761 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010570662025
Between:
M/s.Balaji Metals
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Srinagar Colony II Circle,
Panjagutta Division, Hyderabad, Telangana and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.28775 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010563762025
Between:
M/s.Supermix Infra Concrete
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Vanasthalipuram – I Circle,
Saroornagar Division, Telangana and another.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.28801 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010567332025
Between:
M/s.Divya Marketing
…Petitioner
and
The Deputy State Tax Officer, O/o The Joint Commissioner (ST),
Charminar Division, Gagan Vihar Building, Nampally,
Hyderabad – 500 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.28846 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010567382025
Between:
M/s.Unique Infra Engineers Pvt Ltd
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner ST, Hydernagar – III Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, 5th Floor, South Wing, Gagan Vihar Building,
Opp. Gandhi Bhavan, Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.28906 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010571452025
Between:
M/s.Morbido Merchandise Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
Office of the State Tax Officer-II (FAC), MG Road-SD Road Circle,
Begumpet Division, Hyderabad and another
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.28954 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010574362025
Between:
M/s.Bhavana Earth Movers
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Fatehnagar Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, Hyderabad and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.29146 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010577582025
Between:
M/s.AAI Mathaji Hardware Electricals Paints and Sanitary
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Vanasthalipuram – I Circle,
Saroornagar Division, M4 Block, Manoranjan Complex, MJ Road,
Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.29313 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010581022025
Between:
M/s.Sai Venkata Print and Pack
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Jeedimetla – 1 Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, Hyderabad, Telangana and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.29504 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010586492025
Between:
M/s.Amara Labs Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary to Government,
Revenue (CT-II) Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad and another
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.29507 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010586402025
Between:
M/s.Amara Labs Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary to Government,
Revenue (CT-II) Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad and another
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.29688 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010589332025
Between:
M/s.Janapriya Township Pvt Ltd
…Petitioner
and
Deputy Commissioner (ST), STU-2, Abids Division,
Hyderabad, Telangana and another
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.29692 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010584742025
Between:
M/s.Esha Agri Seeds Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Vanashalipuram – I Circle,
Saroornagar Division, Telangana and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.29696 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010585792025
Between:
M/s.Mohan Choudary Seancha
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Vanashalipuram – II Circle,
Saroornagar Division, Exhibition Gate Road, Nampally,
Hyderabad – 500 001 and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.29908 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010589352025
Between:
M/s.Janapriya Township Pvt Ltd
…Petitioner
and
Deputy Commissioner (ST), STU-2, Abids Division,
Hyderabad, Telangana and another
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.29926 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010593892025
Between:
M/s.Kosher Pharmaceutical Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner State Tax,
Madhapur-IV Circle, Hyderabad and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.29932 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010593692025
Between:
M/s.Kosher Pharmaceutical Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner State Tax,
Madhapur-IV Circle, Hyderabad and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.29935 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010594392025
Between:
M/s.Kosher Pharmaceutical Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner State Tax,
Madhapur-IV Circle, Hyderabad and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.29951 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010593932025
Between:
M/s.Kosher Pharmaceutical Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner State Tax,
Madhapur-IV Circle, Hyderabad and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.30090 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010591662025
Between:
M/s.Sitarama Transport
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST) FAC, Vanasthalipuram-II Circle,
Saroornagar Division, 5th Floor, Old Kakatiya Building Hotel,
(Opp. A.P.Furniture), Nampally, Hyderabad 500001 and 5 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.30104 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010596322025
Between:
M/s.Sai Durga Agri Mechanisation Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Deputy Commissioner (ST), Warangal STU2, Warangal,
Telangana and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.30158 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010597952025
Between:
M/s.Saanvi Denters & Painters
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Hydernagar-III Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, Hyderabad and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.30166 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010597992025
Between:
M/s.Saanvi Denters & Painters
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Hydernagar-III Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, Hyderabad and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.30184 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010585962025
Between:
M/s.Sri Venkatesh Fibre Corporation
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Commercial Taxes,
Secretariat, Hyderabad and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.30222 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010596972025
Between:
M/s.Suryamitra Infratech India Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Commercial Taxes,
Secretariat, Hyderabad and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.30247 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010591432025
Between:
M/s.Sitarama Transport
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST) FAC, Vanasthalipuram-II Circle,
Saroornagar Division, 5th Floor, Old Kakatiya Building Hotel,
(Opp. A.P.Furniture), Nampally, Hyderabad 500001 and 5 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.30382 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010602152025
Between:
M/s.Sri Venkateshwara Fertilisers
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Sangareddy-II Circle,
Nizamabad Division, H.No.4-8-85/10/B, Manjeera Pipe Line Road,
Sanga Reddy, Sanga Reddy District, Telangana – 502001 and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.30481 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010604202025
Between:
M/s.Invision
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Commercial Taxes,
Secretariat, Hyderabad and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.30571 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010606062025
Between:
M/s.Sri Durga Motors
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (State Tax), Ferozguda,
Hyderabad Rural Division, Hyderabad and another
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.30843 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010610742025
Between:
M/s.EDOC Life Sciences Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Vidyanagar Circle,
# 9th Mayurkushal Complex, Near Gunfoundry, Abids,
Hyderabad – 500 001 and another.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.30846 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010611452025
Between:
Shree Bhagwathi Timber Corporation
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (GST)(ST), Rajendranagar-II Circle,
Saroor Nagar Division, Telangana and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.30847 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010609262025
Between:
Pentagon Logistics Pvt Ltd
…Petitioner
and
The Appellate Joint Commissioner of State Tax, Secunderabad Division,
5th Floor, C.T.Complex, Nampally, Hyderabad and 3 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.30928 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010613102025
Between:
M/s.SA Industries
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Hydernagar-III Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.30935 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010613162025
Between:
M/s.SA Industries
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Hydernagar-III Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.30948 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010613212025
Between:
M/s.SA Industries
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Hydernagar-III Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.31032 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010611412025
Between:
M/s.M.A.Iron Traders
…Petitioner
and
The Appellate Joint Commissioner (ST),
Secunderabad Division, Hyderabad and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.31383 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010622162025
Between:
M/s.Shanmugha Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Jeedimetla-II Circle, Hyderabad Rural
Division, 7th Floor, East Wing, Gaganvihar Building, Opp.Gandhi Bhavan,
Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.31406 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010622142025
Between:
M/s.Sangam Furnitures
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Vanasthalipuram-I Circle,
Saroornagar Division, North Wing, 7th Floor, Gaganvihar Complex,
Opp.Gandhi Bhavan, Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.31408 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010622102025
Between:
M/s.Shanmugha Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Jeedimetla-II Circle, Hyderabad Rural
Division, 7th Floor, East Wing, Gaganvihar Building, Opp.Gandhi Bhavan,
Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.31410 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010622892025
Between:
M/s.Sangam Furnitures
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Vanasthalipuram-I Circle,
Saroornagar Division, North Wing, 7th Floor, Gaganvihar Complex,
Opp: Gandhibhavan, Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001, and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.31419 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010622412025
Between:
M/s.Bhavana Earth Movers
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Fatehnagar Circle,
Hyderabad Rural Division, Hyderabad and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.31428 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010620682025
Between:
M/s.Raj Industries
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner, Nacharam-II Circle, Malkajgiri Division,
5th Floor, East Wing, ‘Gagan Vihar Complex’, Opp: Gandhi Bhavan,
M.J.Road, Nampally, Hyderabad, Telangana – 500001 and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.31432 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010622652025
Between:
M/s.Sangam Furnitures
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Vanasthalipuram-I Circle,
Saroornagar Division, North Wing, 7th Floor, Gaganvihar Complex,
Opp:Gandhi Bhavan, Nampally, Hyderabad – 500 001 and 4 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.31504 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010623962025
Between:
M/s.RTS Group of Construction
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Commercial Taxes, Secretariat, Hyderabad and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.31880 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010622612025
Between:
M/s.Invilogic Software Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Madhapur-II Circle, Madhapur Division,
4th Floor, Gagan Vihar Building, Opposite Gandhi Bhavan, Nampally,
Hyderabad – 500 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.31904 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010622812025
Between:
M/s.Invilogic Software Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Madhapur-II Circle, Madhapur Division,
4th Floor, Gagan Vihar Building, Opposite Gandhi Bhavan, Nampally,
Hyderabad – 500 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.31909 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010622912025
Between:
M/s.Invilogic Software Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Madhapur-II Circle, Madhapur Division,
4th Floor, Gagan Vihar Building, Opposite Gandhi Bhavan, Nampally,
Hyderabad – 500 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.31911 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010622032025
Between:
M/s.Invilogic Software Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Madhapur-II Circle, Madhapur Division,
4th Floor, Gagan Vihar Building, Opposite Gandhi Bhavan, Nampally,
Hyderabad – 500 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.32387 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010643022025
Between:
M/s.Syndy Pharma
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Nacharam 2 Circle,
Malkajgiri Division, Nampally, Hyderabad and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.32498 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010644882025
Between:
Raghuram Reddy Paduru
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Commercial Taxes, Secretariat, Hyderabad and another
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.32535 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010645052025
Between:
M/s.Jaireh Industries
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Keesara-I Circle,
Saroor Nagar, Malkajgiri Division, Hyderabad and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.32660 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010649082025
Between:
M/s Swastik Enterprises
…Petitioner
and
The State Tax Office, Warangal, Warangal Urban-1, O/o Assistant
Commissioner (ST), Warangal, Telangana – 506002 and another
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.33099 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010656352025
Between:
M/s.Rayalaseema Steels Re-Rolling Mills Private Limited
…Petitioner
and
Assistant Commissioner (ST), STU-2 Charminar,
Charminar Division, Hyderabad and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.33147 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010657702025
Between:
M/s.DRP-Gunaa Team Works
…Petitioner
and
Deputy Commissioner (ST)-5, Enforcement Wing-2, O/o Commissioner of
Commercial Taxes, Nampally, Hyderabad, Telangana and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.33495 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010664872025
Between:
Chinna Raj Gajapathi @ M/s.CR.Gajapathi
…Petitioner
and
The Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Commercial Taxes Department,
Government of Telangana, Hyderabad and another
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.33749 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010669832025
Between:
Nihar Constructions
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner of State Tax, Mehdipatnam 1 Circle,
Charminar Division, Gaganvihar Building, MJ Road, Nampally,
Hyderabad, Telangana – 500 001 and 3 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.33768 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010669272025
Between:
M/s.Venkataramana Lorry Transport and Transport Contractor
…Petitioner
and
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Commercial Taxes,
Secretariat, Hyderabad and 2 others.
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.34129 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010678622025
Between:
M/s.Technochem Engineering Corporation
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant Commissioner (ST), Hyderabad Rural DC Office,
Hyderabad Rural Division, Hyderabad, Telangana and 2 others
…Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.34134 of 2025
CNR No. HBHC010677692025
Between:
M/s.Sree Techno Packages
…Petitioner
and
The Assistant/Deputy Commissioner (ST), Hyderabad Rural Division,
IDA Gandhinagar Circle, 2nd Floor, North Wing, Gaganvihar Building,
Opp.Gandhi Bhavan, Nampally, Hyderabad -500 001 and 4 others
…Respondents
COMMON ORDER
(PER THE HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH )
These writ petitions have been referred to the Full Bench by order
dated 12.06.2026 passed by the learned Division Bench of this Court for
an authoritative pronouncement in view of the decision in Bigleap
Technologies and Solutions Private Limited vs. State of Telangana1
on the issue of unsigned orders/show cause notices. In view of the fact
that involves a substantial and novel question of law and also statutory
interpretation that has far reaching systemic consequences, it requires to
be heard by a larger forum.
2.
The issue which needs to be answered is whether the impugned
documents such as show cause notices or adjudication orders are
unsigned documents within the meaning of the Central Goods and
Services Tax Act, 2017 (for brevity, ‘CGST Act’)/Telangana Goods and
Services Tax Act, 2017 (for brevity, ‘TGST Act’)/Integrated Goods and
Services Tax Act, 2017 (for brevity, ‘IGST Act’) read with the
Information Technology Act, 2000 (for brevity, the IT Act), and as such,
are nullity in the eye of law.
3.
Learned counsel for the parties have made extensive arguments
during the proceedings on this reference. They have also referred to the
provisions of the CGST Act and the Central Goods and Services Tax
[2025] 142 GSTR 608 (Telangana)
Rules, 2017 (for brevity, ‘CGST Rules’) which are in pari materia with
the provisions of the TGST Act and the Telangana Goods and Services
Tax Rules, 2017, which are relevant for understanding the present legal
issue. They have also referred to the provisions of the Information
Technology Act, 2000 as amended and the Information Technology
(Certifying Authorities) Rules, 2000 and the Digital Signature (End
Entity) Rules, 2015 in support of their submissions. Learned counsel for
both the parties have relied upon a number of judgments to buttress their
submissions.
4.
Sri Karan Talwar, learned counsel for the petitioner in
W.P.No.20653 of 2025, advanced extensive arguments, leading this
batch of writ petitions on behalf of all the petitioners. Sri A.V.A.Siva
Kartikeya, Nodal Counsel; Sri Muktinutalapati Ramachandra Murthy,
Sri P.Venkat Prasad, Sri M.Naga Deepak, Sri K.P.Amarnath Reddy,
Ms. Y.Siri Reddy, Sri Goondla Venkateswarlu, Sri P.Srikanth Rao,
Sri Shaik Jeelani Basha, Sri V.Aneesh, Sri G.R.S.Akhileswar and
Sri V.Veeresham, learned counsel for the petitioners, have made
additional points in their respective writ petitions.
5.
Sri A.Sudarshan Reddy, learned Advocate General assisted by
Sri Swaroop Oorilla, learned Special Government Pleader and Sri K.Sai
Akarsh, learned Assistant Government Pleader for the State Tax has
made extensive submissions on behalf of the State.
Sri B.Narasimha Sharma, learned Additional Solicitor General of
India has made submissions on behalf of the Goods and Services Tax
Network (GSTN).
Sri Dominic Fernandes, learned Senior Standing Counsel for the
Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC), assisted by
Ms. B.N.Pravalika Goud, Ms. T.Shivani Reddy and Sri B.Praneeth made
submissions on behalf of the GSTN.
6.
GST Network, which was impleaded as a party at the instance of
the Court when the proceedings were pending before the learned
Division Bench, has filed counter affidavit and the additional counter
affidavit to bring on record their stand on the working of the GST
Network.
7.
Sri Y.Anil Kumar, Joint Commissioner, State Tax Department
and Sri Pintulal Choudhary, Chartered Accountant, State Tax
Department have demonstrated the working of the GSTN System before
the learned Division Bench.
8.
Sri Harsh Agarwal, Vice President, Architecture, GSTN, has
made live demonstration to explain the working of the GST system and
the manner and procedure by which the notices/orders under Chapter
XVIII – demands and recovery of the CGST Rules are electronically
authenticated and uploaded on the common portal. Sri Rajeev J.Tripathi,
Vice President, Legal, GSTN also appeared in virtual mode.
9.
The submissions made by learned counsel for both parties are
being referred to hereinafter.
Submissions of the learned counsel for the petitioners:
A. The impugned show cause notice and assessment order being
unsigned are non est in law and thereby liable to be set aside:
10.
Sri Karan Talwar, learned counsel for the petitioner in
W.P.No.20653 of 2025, has led the arguments on behalf of the
petitioners in this reference. He has questioned the reference made to the
Full Bench by the order dated 12.06.2026 passed by the Division Bench
of this Court. It has been submitted that the referral order does not show
reasons for making this reference to the Full Bench.
It does not
specifically point to any divergent opinion of Coordinate Benches
necessitating a reference to the Full Bench. Secondly, in view of the
judgment rendered by the Coordinate Bench of this Court in Bigleap
Technologies (supra), there was no need to refer the matter to the Full
Bench. He has drawn the attention of this court to the discussion made
at paras 25 to 49 in the judgment of Bigleap Technologies (supra).
11.
On the merits of the case, he has made the following
submissions:
-
The impugned show cause notices and orders are invalid as the
actual body of the notices/orders attached to Form GST DRC-01
and DRC-07 do not contain any physical or digital signature.
Absence of signature renders such notices/orders non-est in the eye
of law.
-
That the issue stands settled by the Division Bench judgments of
the Telangana High Court in M/s. Bigleap Technologies (supra)
and M/s. Silver Oak Villas LLP vs. Assistant Commissioner
(ST)2, wherein it was held that unsigned notices/orders are legally
unsustainable. That the Department can always initiate fresh
proceedings by issuing duly signed notices/orders. Therefore, no
prejudice would be caused to the Revenue.
-
That authentication by signature is a mandatory legal requirement
and cannot be treated as an “impossible act”. The Department's
reliance on the decision in Binani Zinc Limited vs. Kerala State
Electricity Board3 (para 35) is stated to be misplaced because
signing a notice/order is a simple statutory requirement which the
authorities are duty bound to comply with.
-
That the respondents have not argued that the judgment in
M/s. Bigleap Technologies (supra) is per incuriam or sub silentio.
Since no appeal/review has been filed against M/s. Silver Oak
Villas LLP (supra) and no stay has been granted in the SLP
[2025] 137 GSTR 620 (Telangana)
(2009) 11 SCC 244
against M/s. Bigleap Technologies (supra), the said judgments
continue to bind the authorities and must be followed.
-
The State GST Authorities contend that Rule 26(3) of the CGST
Rules applies only to registration matters under Chapter III.
Therefore,
signatures
are
not
mandatory
for
assessment
notices/orders. The petitioners submit that this contention was
specifically rejected in M/s. Bigleap Technologies (supra), which
held that unsigned notices/orders are invalid independently of Rule
26(3) of the CGST Rules.
-
The respondents further argued that the notices/orders are
authenticated because they are uploaded through the GST portal
using officer login credentials embedded with digital signatures.
The petitioners submit that this argument has also been rejected in
M/s. Bigleap Technologies (supra). That the GSTN Advisory
itself recognizes digital signature affixation as an additional
mandatory requirement.
-
Mere login through a DSC-enabled portal does not amount to legal
authentication. No statutory provision, notification, or Standard
Operating Procedure (SoP) has been produced to establish that
embedded login credentials are equivalent to affixing a digital
signature on the actual document.
-
The petitioners rely upon Sections 3, 3A and 5 of the Information
Technology Act, 2000 and Rules 4 and 5 of the Information
Technology (Certifying Authorities) Rules, 2000 (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the Certifying Authorities Rules’) to contend that a
valid digital signature must be affixed to the electronic record itself
so that its authenticity and integrity can be independently verified.
-
Even by using methods prescribed under Second Schedule,
authentication by means of digital signature shall comply with
Rules 3 to 12 of the Digital Signature (End Entity) Rules, 2015,
(hereinafter referred to as ‘the End Entity Rules’) insofar they
relate to creation, storage and verification of digital signature.
-
That under the statutory scheme governing digital signatures, the
electronic record must carry the digital signature along with the
Digital Signature Certificate and details such as date and time of
signing. Without such affixation, the assessee cannot verify
whether
the
document
was
genuinely
signed
or altered
subsequently.
-
Reliance is also placed on Rule 4(4) of the End Entity Rules,
which mandates that contextual information like date and time
must form part of the digital signature. Hence, absence of visible
signature and timestamp violates the statutory framework
governing electronic authentication.
-
That the contention that authenticity can be verified by utilizing
RFN is without any statutory basis to deem it to be form of
authentication. Further, even upon feeding RFN details, it does not
show up the name and designation of the officer or the time at
which the login was done, or any details at all with reference to
affixation of digital signature.
-
The petitioners further rely on Section 73 of the Bharatiya Sakshya
Adhiniyam, 2023 to contend that verification of a digital signature
is possible only when the signature is actually affixed to the
electronic record.
-
That GSTN itself admitted in its counter affidavit that the
functionality for affixing DSC on notices/orders was introduced
only subsequently and rolled out for adjudicating authorities on
17.01.2025. Therefore, notices/orders issued prior thereto without
signatures are liable to be set aside. GSTN has also admitted that
affixation of PAN-based DSC on all notices/orders is mandatory.
According to the petitioners, this admission itself disproves the
State GST Authorities contention that mere portal login is
sufficient authentication.
-
That the plea of "technical glitches" is vague and unsupported by
any technical reports or documentation. It is argued that the
authorities were aware of the requirement and could have either
upgraded their software or physically signed the notices/orders.
-
That in several cases the authorities had in fact issued physically
signed or digitally signed notices/orders. Hence, the selective
absence of signatures in other cases remains unexplained and
arbitrary.
-
That continued issuance of unsigned notices/orders even after the
judgment dated 14.03.2024 in M/s. Silver Oak Villas LLP (supra)
amounts to violation of judicial discipline and deliberate disregard
of binding precedent.
-
The contention that authenticity can be verified through RFN is
also challenged on the ground that RFN has no statutory
recognition as a mode of authentication and does not disclose the
officer's identity, designation or time of signing.
-
The petitioners distinguish the Delhi High Court judgment in
M/s. Swarn Cosmetics (India) vs. Union of India and Others4
by contending that it did not consider the binding provisions of the
Information Technology Act or earlier High Court judgments
dealing with unsigned notices/orders.
-
That the impugned notices and orders are liable to be set aside. It is
submitted that there is no loss or prejudice to the Revenue since
they are given liberty to carry out the assessment once again in
issuing the show cause notice and orders.
-
In view of the judgments of the Supreme Court in M/s. M.M.
Rubber and Company Limited vs. The Deputy Director5 and
WP (C) No.16532 of 2025, CM Appl.67713/2025 & CM Appl.67714/2025, dated
31.10.2025
1992 Supp 1 SCC 471
Kilasho Devi Burman vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, W.B6,
such notices/orders issued without signatures are held to be invalid,
the same will not get immunity in the teeth of sub-sections (1) and
(2) of Section 160 of the CGST Act.
-
That unsigned notices/orders are not valid notices/orders as it is
well settled that in such a situation the conditions precedent to the
exercise of jurisdiction have not been satisfied.
(a) An assessee cannot be expected to comply with show cause
notice/order, as it is not authenticated by way of a signature. The
signature column was left blank. The assessee does not know whether it
is genuine or not since the law as also the practice is that signature must
be there on the communication;
(b) The signature shows it is the jurisdictional officer and not
some other officer, who has issued/passed the notice/order;
(c) Affixation of signature is an indicia that the proper officer
has applied his/her mind to the show cause notice/order.
(d) The date on which the signature is affixed also shows whether
the notice/order is passed within the limitation period or not.
(e) Till notice/order is signed, it can be withdrawn by the proper
officer. If a reply is given to an unsigned show cause notice, the
departmental officer can withdraw the show cause notice, saying it is
unsigned.
(1996) 7 SCC 613
B. DRC-01 and DRC-07 are not mere summaries and must also be
signed:
-
The issue that DRC-01 and DRC-07 are not mere summaries and
must also be signed is concluded in favour of the assessees in
Bigleap Technologies (supra). Rule 142 (1) and (5) of CGST
Rules mandates that a summary in Form DRC-01/DRC-07 must
accompany the notice/order. The said Form itself mandates a
signature column. Hence, the submission of the respondents that
there is no mandate for signature in the Act/Rules is incorrect.
When a signature is not required in Forms, such as Form GST
DRC-01B etc., the intention of the law makers is clearly spelt out
therein, apart from not having an earmarked column for the
signature. It is further submitted that Rule 142(5) of the CGST
Act provides that the DRC-07 must “specify the amount of tax,
interest and penalty”. The order and the DRC-07 constitute an
integrated whole, since it is the DRC-07, that is mandated to
quantify the exact amount of tax, interest and penalty payable. It
is submitted that DRC-07 forms the basis for creation of liability
in the Electronic Liability Ledger under Section 49(7). It is only
after a demand is reflected in the Electronic Liability Ledger that
the payments made can be appropriated towards demand raised.
Further, all appeals filed on the GST portal require mentioning of
the DRC-07 reference number. Appropriation of pre-deposit
towards appeals can also be done only once the DRC-07 is
properly generated. He relied on Rule 142(5) to show the
necessity of DRC-07 in the context of creation and payment of
liabilities as also filing of appeals.
-
That 31st Agenda of the GST Council, dated 22.12.2018,
describes how DRC-07 is issued for interest liability. Relevant
paragraph is extracted as under:
12. Amendment to sub-rule (5) of Rule 142
12.1 While self-assessed tax is posted in the Liability Register on filing
of return, interest liability which has not been declared in the return or
paid by the registered person is not posted to the ledger. Whereas, subsection (12) of Section 75 of the CGST Act provides for recovery of
interest due on the unpaid self-assessed tax, if any. Further, in cases
where the taxpayer makes payment of due tax and interest as per an
adjudication order, further interest is also liable to be paid for the period
from the date of order till the date of actual payment. In order to post the
interest liability in the Liability Register, an order is required to be
issued.
-
53rd GSTC Agenda, dated 22.06.2024, describes process flow
after order is passed and DRC-07 is uploaded. The relevant current
mechanism/process flow is as below:
(i) when an adjudication order or an appeal is issued and a
summary is uploaded in the system vide FORM GST DRC-07 or FORM
GST APL-04, as the case may be, demand is created and a debit entry is
posted in the Electronic Liability Ledger Part II (ELL-II) of the taxpayer.
-
Dispensing with the requirement of signature would make the
prescription in the DRC-07 otiose. It computes the liability for an
assessee, and unless authenticated, no party can be expected to
rely on it.
C. Service of Notice/Order on portal:
-
That the impugned notices/orders have only been uploaded on the
GST common portal and have not been served in any other mode.
The contention of the respondents that uploading on the portal
constitutes sufficient service is incorrect. There is no statutory
provision obligating assessees to continuously verify several links
on the common portal to ascertain if there are any
notices/orders/communications.
-
That the phrase “tendered” cannot at all apply to making
available on the portal”, since the phrase has a definite
connotation in law of offering personally to an addressee whether
the addressee accepts or rejects. It is also submitted that “giving”
and “tendering” have been used interchangeably in Section
169(1)(a) of the CGST Act.
-
That the decision of the Madras High Court in Pandidorai
Sethupathi Raja vs. Superintendent of Central Tax7 relied on
by the respondent State GST Authorities, wherein it is held that
uploading on the GST portal amounts to tendering in terms of
Section 169(2) of the CGST Act is per incuriam for not
considering the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court on the
meaning of the word ‘tendering’ in the context of service.
(2022) 1 Centax 289
-
That the position becomes even more clear when contrasted with
Section 153 of the Customs Act, 1962, where in Section 153(2),
it provides that the date of uploading would be deemed to be the
date of service.
-
As the notices/orders uploaded online would be online
communications, they would constitute “electronic record(s)” and
in this regard Section 13(2) of the IT Act would be relevant.
-
That determination of the time of receipt of an electronic record
is important. Sub-section (2) lays down the condition for the time
of receipt of an electronic record for (a) a designated computer
resource and (b) a non-designated computer resource.
-
Clause (a) of the aforesaid sub-section (2) states a situation where
the addressee has already designated a computer resource for the
purpose of receiving electronic records, the receipt occurs at the
time when the electronic record enters the designated computer
resource. When the originator sends the electronic record to a
non-designated computer resource, receipt occurs at the time
when the electronic record is retrieved by the addressee. It
presumes that the originator has a prior knowledge of the
addressee’s designated computer system.
-
The respondents (State GST) rely on the Single Bench decision in
Poomika Infra Developers vs. State Tax Officer 8 for the
proposition that because an assessee has been provided a
username and password on the common portal, the common
portal would constitute a “designated computer resource” for the
taxable person as well. It was therefore held that the date on
which the order is uploaded in the portal, is the date the
communication is received in terms of Section 13(2)(i) of the IT
Act. The common portal has been treated as a designated
computer resource for Department as well as taxable person
inasmuch as the taxable person is given an unique login ID and
password to enable them to have access to the portal. He has
further submitted that the Hon’ble High Court has not considered
the dictionary/lexical meaning of the word “designated” or the
background material behind Section 13(2) of the IT Act. The
interpretation taken is contrary to the plain meaning of Section
13(2) of the IT Act.
-
That it can be seen from the Preamble to the IT Act that it is
based on the UNCITRAL Model Law on Electronic Commerce.
-
That Section 13(2) of the IT Act is based on Article 15 of the said
UN Model Law on Electronic Commerce. The only difference
(2025) 29 Centax 394 (Mad)
between Section 13(2) and Article 15(2) is that the latter refers to
‘information system’ as opposed to a ‘computer resource’.
-
Learned counsel has placed reliance on Section 144B of the
Income Tax Act and submitted that no such parallel provisions
have been enacted in CGST Act or the CGST Rules. It is
submitted that the period of limitation would therefore commence
only when the notices/orders were actually retrieved from the
GST Portal as opposed to the date of upload.
-
In order to substantiate his submission on the point that making a
document available on common portal does not amount to
tendering of the document, learned counsel has referred to the
decision of the Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court in
M/s. Bambino Agro Industries Limited vs. State of Uttar
Pradesh9, wherein the provisions of Section 13(2) of the
Information Technology Act have been dealt with at paras 92 to
96, 103 and 104.
D.
There is no delay in approaching this Hon’ble Court and the
decision in Assistant Commissioner (CT), LTU, Kakinada vs. Glaxo
Smith Kline Consumer Health Care Limited [(2020) 19 SCC 681] is
not a bar to the relied prayed for:
-
That the impugned notices/orders were only uploaded on the GST
Portal. No other mode of service was adopted. In some cases, the
[2025] 181 taxmann.com 888 : 2025 (12) TMI 1598 – Allahabad High Court
petitioners having come to know about the uploading from other
sources have approached this Hon’ble Court directly. In some
other cases, the petitioners have approached the appellate
authority first, who has rejected the first appeal on the ground of
delay and have thereafter approached this Hon’ble Court.
However, the petitioners challenged the impugned show cause
notices/orders since they are unsigned and non est vitiating the
entire proceedings as without jurisdiction. The principle of
merger does not apply since the first appellate order is not on
merits and was never admitted and rejected merely on the ground
of delay. Thus, the delay can be condoned. In any event, a writ of
certiorari can be issued against the impugned notices/orders even
if the appellate remedy were not exercised, where there is
violation of principles of natural justice or the order is without
jurisdiction.
-
That a notice has been straightaway issued without first following
the procedure under Section 61 of the CGST Act and Rule 99 of
the CGST Rules involving issuance of Form ASMT-10 notice.
This submission is not made where there was independent
material, based on information obtained or audit/investigation
done by the department officials, prior to issuance of a show
cause notice under Section 73/74 of the CGST Act.
-
He has placed reliance on the decision of the Rajasthan High
Court in Goverdhandham Estate Private Limited vs. Union of
India10 (paras 23 to 25), wherein it was held that the jurisdiction
under Section 73 could be invoked only after complying with the
mandate of Section 61 and not otherwise.
-
That the mandatory procedure under Rule 142(1) of the CGST
Act has not been followed and Sl.No.6(i) of the Notification
No.79/2020-CT, dated 15.10.2020 is liable to be struck down as
unconstitutional. In support of his submission, he has placed
reliance on the Division Bench Judgment of this Court in New
Morning Star Travels vs. Deputy Commissioner11 (paras 15 to
17).
12.
Sri Karan Talwar, learned counsel for the petitioner in
W.P.No.20653 of 2025 has submitted that the vires of Notification
No.79/2020 making the issuance of Form DRC-01A has also been
challenged as unconstitutional. He has made elaborate submissions on
the aforesaid points and prayed that if these arguments fail, this Court
may balance the equities by remanding the matters to the proper officer
on suitable terms as may be deemed fit and proper by this Court.
13.
Sri Muktinutalapati Ramachandra Murthy, learned counsel for
the petitioner in W.P.No.26822 of 2025, apart from the above
2024 (1) TMI 1434 – Rajasthan High Court : 2025 (95) G.S.T.L. 264 (Raj)
(2023) 12 Centax 198 (AP)
submissions has pointed out that the impugned order does not quote the
Document Identification Number (DIN). He has referred to the circulars
dated 23.12.2019 and 05.11.2019 (P1 and P2) issued by CBIC and the
circular dated 04.11.2019 (P3) issued by the Government of Telangana
which adopts the circulars of CBIC for the purpose of implementation of
the TGST Act. According to the petitioner, the circulars are binding on
the Revenue as per Section 168 of the CGST Act. If the document or
order does not contain a DIN, it cannot be relied upon. He submits that
the CBIC issued a circular on 09.06.2025 only wherein it has been stated
that wherever RFN is shown on the document available on the common
portal, DIN is not required. However, the circular could operate
prospectively. Therefore, the orders issued prior to that ought to have
reflected the DIN without which it cannot be relied upon.
14.
Learned counsel Sri P.Venkat Prasad appearing for the petitioner
in W.P.No.22326 of 2025 and other connected cases, submitted a brief
note by referring to the counter affidavit earlier filed by the
Commissioner of Central Taxes and Customs, Central Excise & Service
Tax, Medchal GST Commissionerate, Hyderabad in W.P.No.21072 of
2024, and the latter counter affidavit filed by the Deputy Commissioner
of Central Taxes and Customs, Central Excise & Service Tax, Medchal
GST Commissionerate, Hyderabad in W.P.No.10295 of 2025. He
submits that the averments advanced by the GSTN in its counter
affidavit are manifestly inconsistent with the earlier statements made in
the prior counter affidavit. Such contradictory pleadings materially
impair the credibility of the respondents’ case and render the GSTN’s
present contentions inherently unreliable. It does not lie on the part of
the Revenue to take a contrary stand in the present batch of cases against
the judgment rendered in Bigleap Technologies (supra) on the same
issue of unsigned show cause notices/orders. He refers to Birla
Corporation Limited vs. Commissioner of Central Excise 12 and
Commissioner of Central Excise, Hyderabad vs. Novapan Industries
Limited13. He has referred to the facts of W.P.No.22326 of 2025 and
made twofold submissions. One, that the procedure prescribed under
Section 65 of the CGST Act has not been followed before initiating
proceedings under Section 73/74 of the CGST Act. He refers to Adani
Power Limited vs. Union of India14 (paras 23 to 25). Secondly, he has
placed reliance upon Circular No.31/05/2018-GST dated 09.02.2018
which requires a designated officer only to initiate proceedings above
the value of Rs.2.00 crores i.e., Additional Commissioner or Joint
Commissioner of Central Excise, since the Government of Telangana
has followed the circular of the CBIC as per its own circular dated
04.11.2019. The impugned proceedings would be hit by lack of
jurisdiction on the part of the proper officer.
2005 (186) E.L.T. 266 (S.C.)
2007 (209) E.L.T. 161 (S.C.)
(2026) 38 Centax 90 (S.C.)
15.
Sri M.Naga Deepak, learned counsel for the petitioner in
W.P.No.26393 of 2024 and other connected cases, has submitted
additional written submissions. He has, inter alia, made the following
points. That reference of this matter to the Full Bench was neither
necessary nor proper in the eye of law (see Suo Motu vs. Gujarat High
Court Advocates Association15 (paras 9 and 10)). He submits that the
counter affidavit of the GSTN which refers to the backend JSON file
system which cannot be a substitute to furnish a digitally signed
document to the taxpayer. According to him, in certain instances such as
in DRC-07, dated 16.06.2025, the respondents have admitted that the
document was uploaded by the clerk which amounts to not only misuse
of the authority of the officer, but reflects the infirmity in the working of
the GSTN system. He relies upon Keshav Mills Company Limited vs.
CIT16. Learned counsel also submits that the Department having
acquiesced with the decision rendered in Bigleap Technologies (supra)
cannot be allowed to take a contrary stand in the present batch of cases.
16.
Learned counsel Sri K.P.Amarnath Reddy, appearing for the
petitioner in W.P.No.19170 of 2025 has submitted that the Assistant
Commissioner in some cases has issued multiple notices without
application of mind simply upon the forwarding of the e-mail by the
Commercial Taxes Commissioner and Joint Commissioner and further
AIR 2015 Gujarat 1
AIR 1965 SC 1636
to the Assistant Commissioner of the format prepared by the Indian
Institute of Technology – Madras. However, this assertion is not borne
from the record.
17.
Learned counsel Ms.Y.Siri Reddy, learned counsel for the
petitioners in W.P.No.20397 of 2025 and other connected cases, has
taken a plea that the show cause notice was not properly served, as it
was uploaded on the additional notices tab. She relied upon a decision
in M/s.Ramanattu Motor Corporation vs. State of Kerala17, where
such order uploaded in the additional notices tab was set aside and the
matter was remanded. According to the learned counsel, all these
matters relate to mostly the tax period 2017-18 to 2020-21 and are
related to small time taxpayers who do not have the proper device or
support of a qualified Chartered Accountant to carry out the
compliances required under the GST regime insofar as the filing of
returns or even in adjudication proceedings are concerned.
18.
Learned counsel Sri Goondla Venkateswarlu appearing for the
petitioner in W.P.No.22806 of 2025 and connected cases has reiterated
the submissions made by the other counsels on the points of unsigned
and lack of effective service of notice. He further submitted that under
Section 81 of the Information Technology Act, there is no overriding
effect of the provisions of the Information Technology Act over the
provisions of the CGST Act. None of the documents in the writ petitions
2025 (2) TMI 1091 – Kerala High Court : (2025) 28 Centax 232 (Ker)
reflect digital signature. He has also adopted the submissions of learned
counsel Sri Karan Talwar on the application of the relevant rules in the
manner prescribed which have not been followed by the GSTN. As such
the documents not containing the digital signature cannot be treated as
valid documents for the purposes of levying the demand upon the
petitioners. He has also taken the plea of absence of DIN in these
documents in violation of the circular dated 04.11.2019 issued by the
Government of Telangana. According to him, the earlier decisions
rendered without noticing these circulars need to be revisited.
Additionally, it is submitted that in W.P.No.24349 of 2025, the penalty
under Section 122 of the CGST Act has not been imposed by a proper
officer as per the circular dated 27.10.2025 issued by the CBIC.
Moreover, proper time has not been given to respond to the show cause
notice.
19.
Based on these submissions, learned counsel for the petitioners
have prayed that the reference may be answered in favour of the legal
position upheld by this Court in the case of Bigleap Technologies
(supra) on the question of unsigned documents i.e., show cause notices
or orders. This Full Bench may be pleased not to hold otherwise.
Submissions of Sri A.Sudarshan Reddy, the learned Advocate
General for the State:
20.
Sri A.Sudarshan Reddy, learned Advocate General appearing for
the State, has, inter alia, made the following submissions:
-
A reading of the several provisions of the CGST Act in
conjunction to the Information Technology Act would show that
digital signature is not required on the documents such as show
cause notice or adjudication orders covered under Chapter XVIII
of CGST Rules.
-
Section 2(26) of the CGST Act defines ‘common portal’. The
Central Government, under Section 146 of the CGST Act, may,
on the recommendations of the Council, notify the Common
Goods and Services Tax Electronic Portal for facilitating
registration, payment of tax, furnishing of returns etc., and for
carrying out such other functions and for such purposes as may
be prescribed.
-
He has also referred to the definition of ‘document’ in Section
2(41), the ‘proper officer’ under Section 2(91) and such other
definition clauses.
-
That in none of the pleadings, the petitioners have made any
allegation that the proper officer has not issued the show cause
notices/orders. Therefore, in the absence of pleadings, such a plea
should not be entertained in the eye of law. For example, in
W.P.No.20397 of 2025, the name and designation of the proper
officer is reflected both in the show cause notice issued under
Section 73 and also in the order-in-original. He submits that the
petitioners have not shown any prejudice on this count as all the
show cause notices/orders referred to the RFN or reference
number and name and designation of the officers. All these
documents have been downloaded from the common portal.
-
The contention of some of the writ petitioners on non-application
of mind by issuing multiple notices/orders and uploading on the
same day is a ground which can be taken in an appeal.
-
That Section 25 of Chapter VI of the CGST Act provides the
procedure for registration. In contrast, the issuance of show cause
notices and orders in an adjudication proceedings are carried out
in Chapter XVIII of the CGST Rules which use the expression
‘electronically’ uploaded through the common portal.
-
The Legislature has conceived of communication of the show
cause notices/orders in the adjudication proceedings governed
under Chapter XVIII of the CGST Rules electronically through
the common portal.
-
That the reliance placed upon the Forms on the part of the
petitioners where the expression ‘signature’ is used in connection
with the Forms prescribed under Chapter XVIII of the CGST
Rules could not amount to supplanting the Rules, as Forms are
only subservient to Rules.
He relies upon Vasudev
Ramchandra Shelat vs. Pranlal Jayanand Thakar 18 and CIT
vs. Apar Industries Limited19 for this proposition.
-
He has adverted to the next contention of the petitioners that the
documents such as show cause notices/orders have not been
properly served on the writ petitioners. In this regard he has
referred to Section 169(1) of the CGST Act and submitted that
making these documents available on the common portal
amounts to service. Apart from that, e-mail and text message is
sent to the taxpayer when the document is uploaded on the
common portal.
-
Learned Advocate General has referred to Sections 2(g), 2(p), 2q,
2(ta), 2(zg), 3, 3A, 34 and 35 of the IT Act. He has placed strong
reliance on the decision of the Division Bench of Gujarat High
Court rendered in Radhe Enterprise vs. Assistant Commissioner
of State Tax, Unit 6720 on the plea of unsigned wherein several
decisions rendered by different courts have been referred to
including that of this Telangana High Court. The Division Bench
has discarded the plea raised by the petitioners that the documents
were unsigned. He has also referred to the decision in M/s. Vishwa
Enterprise vs. State of Gujarat21 (paras 7 and 8) and M/s. Swarn
(1975) 45 Comp Cas 43
2010 SCC OnLine Bom 516
R/Special Leave Application No.2699 of 2025, dated 20.06.2025
R/Special Civil Application No.8125 of 2024, dated 20.03.2025
Cosmetics (India) (supra) (paras 4, 7, 10 and 11). Relevant
paragraphs of M/s. Swarn Cosmetics (India) (supra) are as under:
“10. Further, upon direction of the Court, Mr. Sumit K. Batra, ld.
Counsel for the Department has handed over a short note, explaining the
process followed by the proper officers while issuing any order or show
cause notice. The said process, as explained on behalf of the Department
is as follows:
i. All orders and notices issued by tax authorities are uploaded
electronically to the common portal and authenticated using a Digital
Key/Signature which contains the credentials of the proper officer
including his name, designation and jurisdiction.
ii. As per the mandate of Rule 26(3) of the CGST Rules, 2017, all
notices, certificates, and orders are to be issued electronically. Such
service of notices, certificates and orders is made available to the
taxpayer by uploading the same on the GST portal.
iii. A proper officer can log in to the GST portal by using his/her Digital
Key/Signature followed by a system generated OTP which is sent by the
GST portal to the registered mobile number of the proper officer.
iv. It is only after such authentication that the proper officer permits the
system to generate the document (e.g., Show Cause Notices in FORM
GST DRC-01, Orders in FORM GST DRC-07) and the same is stored
with the proper officer's digital signature in the system.
Hence, the note filed on behalf of the Department clearly states that even
though the PDF documents downloaded from the GST portal may not
show a physical signature impression, but it is generated only after a
thorough authentication of the proper officer.
11.
Thus, this Court is of the view that the argument raised by the
Petitioner with respect to the impugned order and SCN being unsigned is
untenable. Thus, insofar as the issue of signatures on the impugned order
and impugned SCN is concerned, since the SCNs and orders are now
uploaded through the GST portal only through the digital key of the
concerned officer, as also because the orders and SCNs bear the name of
the officer and the designation of the officer, the authenticity and
genuinity of the order cannot be disputed, unless there is a misuse of the
digital key.”
-
Learned Advocate General has questioned the stand of the
petitioners while referring to proceedings where the proper officer
has dropped the demand. The orders-in-original there also only
refer to the name, designation and the digital signature of the
proper officer. Those orders have not been questioned by the
petitioners on the plea of unsigned.
-
He has questioned the maintainability of the writ petitions in the
light of the ratio rendered in Glaxo Smith Kline Consumer
Health Care Limited (supra) (paras 14, 18, 19, 22, 23), Laxmi
Construction vs. State Tax Officer, CT & GST, Circle, Barbil22
(paras 6 and 9) and Poomika Infra Developers (supra) (para 5.1
to 5.10) on the same issue wherein the principle i.e., dura lex sed
lex rendered in Raghunath Rai Bareja vs. Punjab National
Bank23 also has been relied upon.
-
That a purposive interpretation has to be accorded to the provisions
of the CGST Act to make it workable.
-
According to him, the petitioners have not been able to show any
prejudice on the count of the documents being allegedly unsigned
for this Court to entertain the plea.
-
He, therefore, submits that this Court may authoritatively lay down
the correct position in law, as there have been conflicting
judgments on the question of unsigned by different smaller
Benches of the jurisdictional High Courts.
(2024) 18 Centax 490 (Ori.)
(2007) 2 SCC 230
Live demonstration by GSTN:
-
On the directions of this Court, a live demonstration of the working
of the GST Network has been made by Sri Harsh Agarwal, Vice
President, Architecture, GSTN. He has also referred to the stand of
the GSTN contained in its additional counter affidavit filed on
25.02.2026 on the working of GST Network. Sri Harsh Agarwal
during the course of the demonstration of the GST Network
common portal submitted that the process of issuance of notices
and orders by the proper officer is undertaken only after the proper
officer gets onboarded on the system by using Digital Signature
Certificate issued by the certifying authority. The use of Digital
Signature Certificate ensures integrity and authenticity of the
document by use of public and private key. It creates a hash
function by the method of asymmetric cryptography which is
tamper proof and immutable. The proper officer applies his digital
signature using the hash value by his private key and thereby
issues the show cause notices/orders in accordance with the
provisions of Sections 3A and 13 of the Information Technology
Act. He has also referred to Section 119 of the Bharatiya Sakshya
Adhiniyam, 2023, to submit that there is a presumption of
regularity of the official acts done by the proper officer while
issuing notices/orders through the common portal.
Submissions of Sri B.Narasimha Sharma, learned Additional
Solicitor General of India, appearing for GSTN:
21.
Sri B.Narasimha Sharma, learned Additional Solicitor General of
India, appearing for GSTN, supported the working of the GST regime
through the common portal operated by GSTN. He, inter alia, submitted
as under:
-
That the notices/orders are under Section 73/74 of the CGST Act
are served in the prescribed form by making it available on the
common portal in terms of Section 169(1)(d) of the CGST Act.
-
The issue involved in the present batch of matters before the Full
Bench of this Court is not whether the document is signed or not,
it is that the notice/order does not show the signature in physical
form.
-
That Rule 26(3) of the CGST Rules also prescribes issuance of
document electronically with digital signature or through
e-signature or verified by any other mode of sign or verification
as notified by the board. It relates to Chapter III-Registration and
not Chapter XVIII of the CGST Rules.
-
The decision in M/s. Silver Oak Villas LLP (supra) relies upon
Rule 26(3) of the CGST Rules, which is in relation to Chapter III
under the heading ‘Registration’, whereas the decision in Bigleap
Technologies (supra) does not approve of the view taken in
M/s. Silver Oak Villas LLP (supra) on the application of Rule
26(3) of the CGST Rules to the issuance of show cause
notices/orders under Chapter XVIII – Demands and Recovery in
an adjudication proceedings.
-
As per the definition clause of the Information Technology Act,
the digital signature is included in the electronic signature. The
word ‘electronically’ is used in the Information Technology Act
in Section 2(p) and 2(ta). The GST Network complies with the
requirement of Sections 3 and 3A read with the Second Schedule
of the Information Technology Act in the matter of authentication
of electronic records for affixation of digital signature.
-
That there is a legal presumption of regularity of official acts or
the judicial proceedings under Section 114(e) of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872 or Section 119(e) of the Bharatiya Sakshya
Adhiniyam, 2023. Moreover, no prejudice has been caused to the
taxpayer who can avail the remedies provided under the statute.
Therefore, a purposive construction has to be applied to the
CGST Act in conjunction with the provisions of the Information
Technology Act while dealing with this challenge.
-
He has referred to the decision in M/s. Sahithi Marketers vs. the
Superintendent
of Central
Tax,
Karimnagar
(Urban)
Range24, wherein this court held that even if DRC-07 did not
contain any signature, no prejudice is caused to the petitioner.
W.P.No.4005 of 2025, dated 20.02.2025
Similar is the view rendered by the High Court of Andhra
Pradesh at Amaravati in Sahiti Agencies vs. the Assistant
Commissioner of Central Tax and Central Excise25 and M/s.
Pedda Masthan Enterprises vs. the Assistant Commissioner
ST, Chittoor III Circle, Chittoor26. He has also referred to the
decision of the Gujarat High Court in Radhe Enterprise (supra)
(paras 33 to 35) and M/s.Swarn Cosmetics (India) (supra) relied
upon by the learned Advocate General.
-
Sections 4 and 5 of the Information Technology Act under
Chapter III provide that if the information is authenticated by
means of electronic signature affixed in such manner as is
prescribed, it has a legal recognition of a valid signature on the
document. Section 5 of the Information Technology Act,
therefore, provides legal recognition of documents authenticated
through electronic means which satisfies the requirements of
signature notwithstanding anything contained in any such law.
Since the GST regime works on an online mechanism through the
common portal, Section 5 of the IT Act provides legal
recognition
to
such
documents
generated
and
electronically through the common portal by the Revenue.
W.P.No.14874 of 2025, dated 26.09.2025
W.P.No.1363 of 2026, dated 31.01.2026
served
-
That the entire working of the GSTN is explained in the
additional affidavit of the GSTN. Therefore, this Court may
proceed to answer the issue by upholding the working of the
GSTN specifically in the context of the issue involved in this
reference on unsigned documents alleged by the petitioners and
hold that these documents have been electronically authenticated
in conformity with the requirement of law. Therefore, the
decision rendered by the learned Division Bench in Bigleap
Technologies (supra) and other decisions on this point by this
Court and other jurisdictional Courts be held as not laying the
correct position of law.
Submissions of Sri Dominic Fernandes, learned Senior Standing
Counsel for CBIC on behalf of GSTN:
22.
Sri Dominic Fernandes, learned Senior Standing Counsel for
CBIC, has addressed this Court on behalf of the GSTN.
-
He has vehemently argued that the reference to the Full Bench
was necessary on this issue.
-
He has pointed out to the conflicting Division Bench judgments
of this Court in M/s. Silver Oak Villas LLP (supra) (para 9),
M/s. Sahithi Marketers (supra) and Bigleap Technologies
(supra) (para 28).
-
That the decisions in M/s. Sahithi Marketers (supra) and
Bigleap Technologies (supra) were by the same Bench, but
conflicting points of view have been taken on the question of
unsigned. He submits that whenever this Court has the occasion
to doubt the decision of the Coordinate Bench, the right course is
to refer the matter to the Full Bench instead of taking a
conflicting point of view by a coram of the same Bench.
-
In support of this proposition, he placed reliance upon a decision
passed in Usha Kumar vs. State of Bihar27. He has read the
referral order and pointed out that it contains sufficient reasons.
-
The learned Division Bench of this Court has, after due
deliberations and after hearing the parties at length, felt it
necessary to refer the matter in view of the conflicting decisions
cited before it by the Coordinate Benches of this Court for an
authoritative pronouncements on the issue involved.
-
The present batch of cases are on the issue whether the show
cause notices and orders in adjudication proceedings govern
Chapter XVIII – Demands and Recovery of the CGST Rules and
made available on the common portal operated by the GST
Network by the proper officer after onboarding it by using Digital
Signature Certificate can be treated as an unsigned document to
declare them as null and void. It is submitted that in none of the
(1998) 2 SCC 44
earlier decisions rendered by this Court, GSTN was made a party,
though its presence was necessary. The entire working of the
GST regime is maintained and operated by the GSTN. He
submits that none of the previous Benches had the benefit of
demonstration of the working of the common portal by the GSTN
authorities on the question of unsigned documents. He submits
that the judgment in Bigleap Technologies (supra) has treated the
advisory of GSTN as not having any statutory backing. However,
none of these notices or orders can be rendered invalid if in
substance they are electronically authenticated by the proper
officer by onboarding the system by using Digital Signature
Certificate issued by the certifying authority and by use of its
private and public key.
-
He has made additional submissions on merits by referring to
Section 146 of the CGST Act which provides for working of the
GST regime through the common portal.
-
He also refers to Section 160 of the CGST Act which provides
that no assessment, re-assessment, adjudication and other
proceedings shall be invalid or deemed to be invalid merely by
reason of any mistake, defect or omission therein if, in substance,
they are in conformity with or according to the intents, purposes
and requirements of the CGST Act or any existing law.
-
Sub-section (2) provides that the service of any notice, order or
communication shall not be called in question, if the notice, order
or communication, as the case may be, has already been acted
upon by the person to whom it is issued or where such service has
not been called in question at or in the earlier proceedings
commenced, continued or finalised pursuant to such notice, order
or communication.
-
That
RFN
is
a
valid
authentication
mechanism
for
communications on or through the portal. This position has been
clarified by the GSTN through the Circular No.249/06/2025GST, dated 09.06.2025.
-
RFN is a distinct number to a document which can be duly
verified by the taxpayer through the procedure prescribed on the
common portal. This has been adequately shown in the
demonstration performed by the GSTN through the proceedings
of this court.
-
The demonstration has also shown that in case a notice or order is
required to be sent by post, the proper officer has to physically
sign it.
-
He has rebutted the contention of learned counsel Sri P.Venkat
Prasad relied upon in the earlier affidavit filed in the case of
Water Tech Engineers vs. Assistant Commissioner of CGST28
by submitting that the said affidavit was not by the GSTN, but by
their backend office i.e., Automation of Central Excise and
Service Tax (ACES). As such, the petitioners cannot draw any
mileage by trying to point out a contradiction in the stand filed in
the affidavit in Water Tech Engineers (supra) with the stand of
GSTN filed in the present proceedings.
23.
Learned Senior Standing Counsel for CBIC also submitted a
compilation containing the Forms which require a signature as compared
to a digital signature.
Reply submissions of learned counsel for the petitioners:
24.
Learned counsel Sri P.Srikanth Rao appearing for the petitioner
in W.P.No.20528 of 2025, in reply, has submitted that merely making
available the documents on the common portal as per Section 169(1)(d)
of the CGST Act does not amount to service through the common
portal. Therefore, it should not amount to service upon the company as it
was not required to constantly keep a watch on the portal.
25.
Sri Karan Talwar, learned counsel for the petitioner in
W.P.No.20653 of 2025 and connected cases, has drawn the attention of
this Court to the Agenda for 15th GST Council Meeting, dated
03.06.2017, at paras 9.1 to 9.3 wherein the recommendation of GST
(2025) 32 Centax 130 (Telangana)
council regarding common portal is made. He submits that the word
“common” has been used, as the portal is common to all such tax
regimes i.e., CGST, TGST and IGST, being operable through the portal.
He has also referred to the Report of the Comptroller and Auditor
General of India under the Information Technology Act, which has
recommended the department to ensure digital signature functionality to
ensure proper working of the GST regime.
-
That as per the respondents, after 07.01.2025, the systems are not
showing the digital signature.
-
The tabular chart containing relevant particulars of present writ
petitions supplied by the respondents especially at serial Nos.7
and 13 are of the year 2025, but they are not showing digital
signature. Therefore, the GSTN’s version that the system is
foolproof and digital signature compliant after 06.01.2025 is not
correct. Even the demonstration by the TGST did not show
physical signature or digital signature in the show cause
notice/order though required as per the statutory Form.
-
That the GSTN has not produced the JSON file to prove that the
physical document received at the taxpayer’s end has the backend
file maintained in the common portal.
-
Learned counsel submits that if a question of jurisdiction is
involved, prejudice is not required to be proved by the
petitioners. He submits that whether there is a conflict between
the Rules and Forms, the Supreme Court in CIT (Ag) v. Keshab
Chandra Mandal29, at paras 21 to 27 held that signature of
assessee was mandatory.
-
That the judgments of Gujarat and Bombay High Courts cited by
the learned Additional Solicitor General of India are per curiam
as they do not refer to the Supreme Court judgments or the
Information Technology Act. The decision of the M/s. Silver
Oak Villas LLP (supra) rendered by the learned Division Bench
of this Court though is in relation to Rule 26(3) of the CGST
Rules but it reiterates that the orders must be signed. The decision
in M/s. Sahithi Marketers (supra) on the other hand only dealt
with the Form i.e., DRC-07.
26.
Sri M.Naga Deepak, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
in W.P.No.26393 of 2025 and other connected matters has in the course
of his submissions tried to make a point that in some of the cases the
plea that the portal reflects the document in respect of which
e-mail has been sent to the taxpayer does not match. Learned counsel
submits that the respondents state that the signature is in the JSON, but
it is not visible in the document. He submits that after logging into the
portal and downloading the order, the PDF will not allow even to edit.
1950 SCC 205
This is the nature of the authentication, the Information Technology Act
mandates.
27.
Sri Shaik Jeelani Basha learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner in W.P.No.20473 of 2025 and other connected cases has taken
the plea of absence of DIN and also multiple orders having been issued
for the same tax period. He submits that if certain acts are forbidden by
law, it cannot be done indirectly. In support of his submission, he relies
upon Noida Entrepreneurs Association vs. Noida30 (para 25). He has
also rebutted the plea of delay and laches on the part of the petitioners
on the ground that the documents are unsigned.
28.
Sri A.V.A.Siva Kartikeya, learned counsel submits that the
GSTAT office which has been constituted now is rejecting the
registration of appeals on the ground that the orders are unsigned. The
department does not give reasons as to why some orders are shown as
signed and others are unsigned.
29.
Sri V.Aneesh, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner in
W.P.No.28906 of 2025 submits that the discrepancy in the procedure in
relation to audit proceedings under Section 65 of the CGST Act before
initiation of proceedings under Section 73/74 of the CGST Act has not
been answered, though there are judgments by this Court on the point.
30.
Ms. Y.Siri Reddy, learned counsel who is also appearing in the
lead matter, submits that the digital signature should contain the
(2011) 6 SCC 508
signature, name, time and date, which evidently is not visible when
downloaded at the taxpayer’s end.
31.
Sri G.R.S.Akhileswar, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner in W.P.No.27317 of 2025 has relied upon the decision of the
Madras High Court in N Star Foods and Beverages vs. Commercial
Tax Officer, Pongalur Assessment Circle31, and submits that the
proper officer should issue notices by other modes also, as otherwise it
would be an empty formality.
32.
Sri V.Veeresham, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner in
W.P.No.23730 of 2025 and other connected matters, in support of the
submission that “no prejudice” is no answer to a nullity, has relied on
the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in M.M.Rubber and
Company (supra), Kiran Singh vs. Chaman Paswan32, Dharampal
Satyapal Ltd. vs. DCCE33, Baru Ram vs. Prasanni34, Commissioner
of Income Tax, Mumbai vs. Anjum M.H.Ghaswala35 and Chandra
Kishore Jha vs. Mahavir Prasad 36. According to him, Rule 142 of the
CGST Rules under Chapter XVIII mandates a signature, which has not
been followed in these cases.
2025 Supreme (Online) (Mad) 49709
AIR 1954 SC 340
(2015) 8 SCC 519
AIR 1959 SC 93
(2002) 1 SCC 633
(1999) 8 SCC 266
Discussion and Analysis:
33.
The maintainability of the reference has been questioned by
learned counsel for the petitioners on the ground that the referral order
does not frame the questions required to be answered. It does not
indicate any conflict of decisions rendered by coordinate benches which
require the matter to be referred to the Full Bench. In this regard, it is
also submitted that the Hon’ble Chief Justice does not authorize making
a reference in his administrative capacity as held by the Gujarat High
Court in Suo Motu vs. Gujarat High Court Advocates Association
(supra) (para 9).
34.
This plea has been strongly rebutted by learned Advocate General
and also the learned Senior Standing Counsel for the CBIC. It has been
pointed out that there are three conflicting decisions by three Coordinate
Benches of this Court i.e., Silver Oak Villas LLP (supra), M/s.Sahithi
Marketers (supra) and Bigleap Technologies (supra). In Bigleap
Technologies (supra), a Division Bench of this Court held that the
contrary view taken on the issue of DRC-07 having no signature without
considering Chapter XVIII – Demands and Recovery of the CGST
Rules and the prescribed Form is per incuriam.
35.
The learned Division Bench in Bigleap Technologies (supra)
accepted the submission of the State that unsigned document will not be
hit by Rule 26(3) of the CGST Rules, under Chapter III, which deals
with Registration.
36.
In the above backdrop, learned Division Bench, before which
these judgments were cited, deemed it fit to refer the matter to the Full
Bench for an authoritative pronouncement on the subject after recording
that the matters were heard at length and reserved for orders. The
referral order specifically indicates that there was due deliberation after
the matters were heard at length.
37.
The referral order refers to the decision of the learned Coordinate
Bench of this Court in Bigleap Technologies (supra) which indicates
that the Coordinate Division Benches have taken conflicting view on the
issue of unsigned. Moreover, the previous Coordinate Division Benches
of this Court did not have the benefit of the Live Demonstration of the
working of the GSTN portal by technical experts of the GSTN, who
elaborately explained the process from the stage of onboarding of
officers on the common portal till the issuance of orders. Before the
Coordinate Division Bench in Bigleap Technologies (supra), an
advisory of the GSTN was only produced by the GST Department,
which the Court found to be at best an internal communication between
departmental authorities.
38.
Upon hearing learned counsel for the parties, this Court finds that
in view of conflict in the decisions rendered by different Coordinate
Benches of this Court, the matter has been referred to the Full Bench for
an authoritative pronouncement. Instead of doubting the correctness of
the judgments rendered by co-equal Benches of this Court, such as in
Silver Oak Villas LLP (supra), M/s.Sahithi Marketers (supra) and
Bigleap Technologies (supra), the learned Division Bench thought it
proper to refer the matter to the Full Bench. In the case of Bigleap
Technologies (supra), the learned Division Bench, on the applicability
of Rule 26(3), had taken a view contrary to what was held in Silver Oak
Villas LLP (supra) and held it to be per incuriam.
39.
In such a situation, the proper course for the learned Division
Bench was to refer the matter to the Full Bench, instead of taking a
conflicting point of view by coram of the same strength as held in the
case of Usha Kumar (supra). The relevant para of the said decision is
extracted as under:
“3. In the impugned judgment of a Division Bench of the Patna High
Court (Hon'ble Aftab Alam and A.N. Trivedi, JJ.) dated 1-5-1995, the
Division Bench has taken a view which is different from the view taken
by the two earlier Division Benches of the same High Court. The
judgment itself sets out that normally the matter should have been
referred to a larger Bench; but this may further delay the matter and
hence the Division Bench was proceeding with its judgment. This course
which is taken by the Division Bench has created obvious difficulties.
Judicial discipline requires that if two Division Benches of the same
High Court take different views, the matter should be referred to a larger
Bench. One Division Bench cannot ignore or refuse to follow the
decision of an earlier Division Bench of the same Court and proceed to
give its decision contrary to the decision given by the earlier Division
Bench. If it is inclined to take a different view, a request should be made
to the Chief Justice to refer the same to a Full Bench. Even the purpose
of saving time has not been served in the present case. The decision has
merely generated these appeals which are filed in view of the conflicting
views taken by two Division Benches. The State has also come in appeal
before us. All the parties are agreed that the appropriate course would be
to refer the matter to the Full Bench of the Patna High Court. All these
appeals are, therefore, remanded to the High Court of Patna. The Chief
Justice of that High Court may constitute a Full Bench for deciding all
issues which were raised before the Division Bench in the impugned
judgment. Although the departure from the earlier decisions of the
Division Bench may not be on all issues raised before the Court, since
the appeals are being remanded to the High Court, it is desirable that the
Full Bench, in considering all these matters, deals with all the issues
which were raised and considered by the Division Bench in the
impugned judgment.”
Therefore, we are of the opinion that there is no infirmity in the
referral order.
Analysis on Merits:
40.
Be it indicated at the outset that the present batch of writ petitions
essentially relate to the adjudication proceedings under Sections 73 and
74 under Chapter XV - Demands and Recovery of the CGST Act and
under Chapter XVIII - Demands and Recovery under the CGST Rules,
which prescribe the procedure and Forms for issuance of notice and
order of demands pursuant to adjudication proceedings. In the
interpretative process of relevant provisions, reference has also been
made to Rule 26 under Chapter III – Registration, of the CGST Rules.
Reference to the relevant provisions of the IT Act is also necessary since
the GST regime functions in the digital manner through a common
platform across the country.
41.
The CGST Act, the TGST Act and the IGST Act were enacted
pursuant to the amendment in the Constitution by the Constitution (One
Hundred and First Amendment) Act, 2016, whereby Articles 246A and
279A were brought into Constitution. It introduced the concept of
cooperative federalism in creating a unified tax regime of supply of
goods or services or both at each stage of supply chain ranging from
manufacture or import to the retail level. Pursuant thereto, the GST Acts
both at the Centre and the States were brought into force with effect
from 01.07.2017. Several existing taxes, such as Central Excise Tax,
Service Tax, Central Sales Tax, similarly State Government taxes like
Value Added Tax, Luxury Tax, Purchase Tax etc., which had a
cascading effect with no provision for set off and resulted in a plethora
of non-tariff barriers like octroi, entry tax, check posts etc., which hinder
free flow of trade throughout the country and entails high compliance
cost for taxpayers were subsumed in the GST regime which proposes a
single tax on supply of goods or services or both at each stage of supply
chain ranging from manufacture or import to the retail level. It intended
to broaden the tax base as well as improve tax compliance. It also
provided for anti-profiteering clause to ensure that business passes on
the benefits of reduced tax incidence on goods or services or both to the
consumers. The CGST Act also provided for smooth transition of
existing taxpayers to new Goods and Services Tax regime. The tax
system on goods and services was facing certain difficulties, which have
been explained in the Statement of Objects and Reasons to the CGST
Act, as under:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
There is cascading of taxes as taxes levied by the Central
Government are not available as set off against the taxes being
levied by the State Governments;
Certain taxes levied by the State Governments are not allowed
as set off for payment of other taxes being levied by them;
The variety of Value Added Tax Laws in the country with
disparate tax rates and dissimilar tax practices divides the
country into separate economic spheres; and
(iv)
42.
The creation of tariff and non-tariff barriers such as octroi, entry
tax, check posts etc., hinder the free flow of trade throughout
the country. Besides that, the large number of taxes create high
compliance cost for the taxpayers in the form of number of
returns, payments etc.
Therefore, it proposed that the tax being levied by the Central
Government or the State Governments on the supply of goods or
services were to be converged into goods and services tax which is
proposed to be a dual levy where the Central Government will levy and
collect taxes in the form of central goods and services tax and the State
Government will levy and collect tax in the form of state goods and
services tax on intra-State supply of goods or services or both. In view
of the above reasons, the Central legislation, namely the Central Goods
and Services Tax Act, 2017 was introduced conferring power upon the
Central Government for levying goods and services tax on the supply of
goods or services or both which takes place between States to simplify
and harmonise the indirect tax regime in the country. It was expected to
reduce cost of production and inflation in the economy thereby making
the Indian trade and industry more competitive, domestically as well as
internationally. Due to the seamless transfer of input tax credit from one
stage to another in the chain of value addition, there is an in-built
mechanism in the design of goods and services tax that would
incentivize tax compliance by taxpayers. It was intended to broaden the
tax base, and result in better tax compliance based on a robust
information technology infrastructure.
43.
The Statement of Objects and Reasons of the CGST Act,
provides an insight into the introduction of a unified tax regime
throughout the country in respect of goods and services:
(a) to levy tax on all intra-State supplies of goods or services or both
except supply of alcoholic liquor for human consumption at a rate to
be notified, not exceeding twenty per cent as recommended by the
Goods and Services Tax Council (the Council);
(b) to broad base the input tax credit by making it available in respect of
taxes paid on any supply of goods or services or both used or
intended to be used in the course or furtherance of business;
(c) to impose obligation on electronic commerce operators to collect tax
at source, at such rate not exceeding one per cent of net value of
taxable supplies, out of payments to suppliers supplying goods or
services through their portals;
(d) to provide for self-assessment of the taxes payable by the registered
person;
(e) to provide for conduct of audit of registered persons in order to
verify compliance with the provisions of the Act;
(f) to provide for recovery of arrears of tax using various modes
including detaining and sale of goods, movable and immovable
property of defaulting taxable person;
(g) to provide for powers of inspection, search, seizure and arrest to the
officers;
(h) to establish the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal by the
Central Government for hearing appeals against the orders passed by
the Appellate Authority or the Revisional Authority;
(i) to make provision for penalties for contravention of the provisions
of the proposed Legislation;
(j) to provide for an anti-profiteering clause in order to ensure that
business passes on the benefit of reduced tax incidence on goods or
services or both to the consumers; and
(k) to provide for elaborate transitional provisions for smooth transition
of existing taxpayers to goods and services tax regime.
44.
Similar other State legislations were enacted across the country
by the State Legislatures. The Union Territories Goods and Services Tax
Act, 2017 and the IGST were enacted by the Parliament. All these Acts
were rolled out and brought into effect from 01.07.2017. It is, therefore,
pertinent to understand the working of the GST regime by reading the
relevant provisions of the CGST Act and the Information Technology
Act in order to answer the legal issue involved in the present reference.
45.
For convenience sake, the relevant provisions of the CGST Act as
are in pari materia to the TGST Act, which have been relied upon by the
learned counsel for the parties, are being extracted as under:
Section 26. Deemed registration.— (1) The grant of registration or the
Unique Identity Number under the State Goods and Services Tax Act or
the Union Territory Goods and Services Tax Act shall be deemed to be a
grant of registration or the Unique Identity Number under this Act
subject to the condition that the application for registration or the Unique
Identity Number has not been rejected under this Act within the time
specified in sub-section (10) of Section 25.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (10) of
Section 25, any rejection of application for registration or the Unique
Identity Number under the State Goods and Services Tax Act or the
Union Territory Goods and Services Tax Act shall be deemed to be a
rejection of application for registration under this Act.
Section 73. Determination of tax pertaining to the period up to
Financial Year 2023-24, not paid or short paid or erroneously
refunded or input tax credit wrongly availed or utilised for any
reason other than fraud or any wilful-misstatement or suppression
of facts.— (1) Where it appears to the proper officer that any tax has not
been paid or short paid or erroneously refunded, or where input tax credit
has been wrongly availed or utilised for any reason, other than the reason
of fraud or any wilful-misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax,
he shall serve notice on the person chargeable with tax which has not
been so paid or which has been so short paid or to whom the refund has
erroneously been made, or who has wrongly availed or utilised input tax
credit, requiring him to show cause as to why he should not pay the
amount specified in the notice along with interest payable thereon under
Section 50 and a penalty leviable under the provisions of this Act or the
rules made thereunder.
(2) The proper officer shall issue the notice under sub-section (1) at
least three months prior to the time limit specified in sub-section (10) for
issuance of order.
(3) Where a notice has been issued for any period under sub-section
(1), the proper officer may serve a statement, containing the details of tax
not paid or short paid or erroneously refunded or input tax credit wrongly
availed or utilised for such periods other than those covered under subsection (1), on the person chargeable with tax.
(4) The service of such statement shall be deemed to be service of
notice on such person under sub-section (1), subject to the condition that
the grounds relied upon for such tax periods other than those covered
under sub-section (1) are the same as are mentioned in the earlier notice.
(5) The person chargeable with tax may, before service of notice
under sub-section (1) or, as the case may be, the statement under subsection (3), pay the amount of tax along with interest payable thereon
under Section 50 on the basis of his own ascertainment of such tax or the
tax as ascertained by the proper officer and inform the proper officer in
writing of such payment.
(6) The proper officer, on receipt of such information, shall not serve
any notice under sub-section (1) or, as the case may be, the statement
under sub-section (3), in respect of the tax so paid or any penalty payable
under the provisions of this Act or the rules made thereunder.
(7) Where the proper officer is of the opinion that the amount paid
under sub-section (5) falls short of the amount actually payable, he shall
proceed to issue the notice as provided for in sub-section (1) in respect of
such amount which falls short of the amount actually payable.
(8) Where any person chargeable with tax under sub-section (1) or
sub-section (3) pays the said tax along with interest payable under
Section 50 within thirty days of issue of show cause notice, no penalty
shall be payable and all proceedings in respect of the said notice shall be
deemed to be concluded.
(9) The proper officer shall, after considering the representation, if
any, made by person chargeable with tax, determine the amount of tax,
interest and a penalty equivalent to ten per cent. of tax or ten thousand
rupees, whichever is higher, due from such person and issue an order.
(10) The proper officer shall issue the order under sub-section (9)
within three years from the due date for furnishing of annual return for
the financial year to which the tax not paid or short paid or input tax
credit wrongly availed or utilised relates to or within three years from the
date of erroneous refund.
(11) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (6) or subsection (8), penalty under sub-section (9) shall be payable where any
amount of self-assessed tax or any amount collected as tax has not been
paid within a period of thirty days from the due date of payment of such
tax.
(12) The provisions of this section shall be applicable for
determination of tax pertaining to the period up to Financial Year 202324.
Section 74. Determination of tax pertaining to the period up to
Financial Year 2023-24, not paid or short paid or erroneously
refunded or input tax credit wrongly availed or utilised by reason of
fraud or any wilful-misstatement or suppression of facts.—
(1) Where it appears to the proper officer that any tax has not been paid
or short paid or erroneously refunded or where input tax credit has been
wrongly availed or utilised by reason of fraud, or any wilfulmisstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax, he shall serve notice
on the person chargeable with tax which has not been so paid or which
has been so short paid or to whom the refund has erroneously been made,
or who has wrongly availed or utilised input tax credit, requiring him to
show cause as to why he should not pay the amount specified in the
notice along with interest payable thereon under Section 50 and a penalty
equivalent to the tax specified in the notice.
(2) The proper officer shall issue the notice under sub-section (1) at
least six months prior to the time limit specified in sub-section (10) for
issuance of order.
(3) Where a notice has been issued for any period under sub-section
(1), the proper officer may serve a statement, containing the details of tax
not paid or short paid or erroneously refunded or input tax credit wrongly
availed or utilised for such periods other than those covered under subsection (1), on the person chargeable with tax.
(4) The service of statement under sub-section (3) shall be deemed to
be service of notice under sub-section (1) of Section 73, subject to the
condition that the grounds relied upon in the said statement, except the
ground of fraud, or any wilful-misstatement or suppression of facts to
evade tax, for periods other than those covered under sub-section (1) are
the same as are mentioned in the earlier notice.
(5) The person chargeable with tax may, before service of notice
under sub-section (1), pay the amount of tax along with interest payable
under Section 50 and a penalty equivalent to fifteen per cent of such tax
on the basis of his own ascertainment of such tax or the tax as
ascertained by the proper officer and inform the proper officer in writing
of such payment.
(6) The proper officer, on receipt of such information, shall not serve
any notice under sub-section (1), in respect of the tax so paid or any
penalty payable under the provisions of this Act or the rules made
thereunder.
(7) Where the proper officer is of the opinion that the amount paid
under sub-section (5) falls short of the amount actually payable, he shall
proceed to issue the notice as provided for in sub-section (1) in respect of
such amount which falls short of the amount actually payable.
(8) Where any person chargeable with tax under sub-section (1) pays
the said tax along with interest payable under Section 50 and a penalty
equivalent to twenty-five per cent of such tax within thirty days of issue
of the notice, all proceedings in respect of the said notice shall be
deemed to be concluded.
(9) The proper officer shall, after considering the representation, if
any, made by the person chargeable with tax, determine the amount of
tax, interest and penalty due from such person and issue an order.
(10) The proper officer shall issue the order under sub-section (9)
within a period of five years from the due date for furnishing of annual
return for the financial year to which the tax not paid or short paid or
input tax credit wrongly availed or utilised relates to or within five years
from the date of erroneous refund.
(11) Where any person served with an order issued under sub-section
(9) pays the tax along with interest payable thereon under Section 50 and
a penalty equivalent to fifty per cent of such tax within thirty days of
communication of the order, all proceedings in respect of the said notice
shall be deemed to be concluded.
(12) The provisions of this section shall be applicable for
determination of tax pertaining to the period up to Financial Year 202324.
Explanation 1.—For the purposes of Section 73 and this section,—
(i)
the expression “all proceedings in respect of the said notice”
shall not include proceedings under Section 132;
(ii)
where the notice under the same proceedings is issued to the main
person liable to pay tax and some other persons, and such proceedings
against the main person have been concluded under Section 73 or
Section 74, the proceedings against all the persons liable to pay penalty
under Sections 122 and 125 are deemed to be concluded.
Section 146. Common Portal.—The Government may, on the
recommendations of the Council, notify the Common Goods and
Services Tax Electronic Portal for facilitating registration, payment of
tax, furnishing of returns, computation and settlement of integrated tax,
electronic way bill and for carrying out such other functions and for such
purposes as may be prescribed.
Section 160. Assessment proceedings, etc., not to be invalid on
certain grounds.— (1) No assessment, re-assessment, adjudication,
review, revision, appeal, rectification, notice, summons or other
proceedings done, accepted, made, issued, initiated, or purported to have
been done, accepted, made, issued, initiated in pursuance of any of the
provisions of this Act shall be invalid or deemed to be invalid merely by
reason of any mistake, defect or omission therein, if such assessment, reassessment, adjudication, review, revision, appeal, rectification, notice,
summons or other proceedings are in substance and effect in conformity
with or according to the intents, purposes and requirements of this Act or
any existing law.
(2) The service of any notice, order or communication shall not be
called in question, if the notice, order or communication, as the case may
be, has already been acted upon by the person to whom it is issued or
where such service has not been called in question at or in the earlier
proceedings commenced, continued or finalised pursuant to such notice,
order or communication.
Section 169. Service of notice in certain circumstances.—(1) Any
decision, order, summons, notice or other communication under this Act
or the rules made thereunder shall be served by any one of the following
methods, namely:—
(a)
by giving or tendering it directly or by a messenger
including a courier to the addressee or the taxable person or
to his manager or authorised representative or an advocate or
a tax practitioner holding authority to appear in the
proceedings on behalf of the taxable person or to a
person regularly employed by him in connection with the
business, or to any adult member of family residing
with the taxable person; or
(b)
by registered post or speed post or courier with
acknowledgement due, to the person for whom it is
intended or his authorised representative, if any, at his
last known place of business or residence; or
(c)
by sending a communication to his e-mail address provided at
the time of registration or as amended from time to
time; or
(d)
by making it available on the common portal; or
(e)
by publication in a newspaper circulating in the locality
in
which the taxable person or the person to whom it is issued is
last known to have resided, carried on business or personally
worked for gain; or
(f)
if none of the modes aforesaid is practicable, by affixing it
in some conspicuous place at his last known place of business
or residence and if such mode is not practicable for any
reason, then by affixing a copy thereof on the notice board of
the office of the concerned officer or authority who or
which passed such decision or order or issued such
summons or notice.
(2) Every decision, order, summons, notice or any communication
shall be deemed to have been served on the date on which it is tendered
or published or a copy thereof is affixed in the manner provided in subsection (1).
(3) When such decision, order, summons, notice or any
communication is sent by registered post or speed post, it shall be
deemed to have been received by the addressee at the expiry of the
period normally taken by such post in transit unless the contrary is
proved.
Common Portal:
46.
As per Section 146 of the CGST Act, the Government on the
recommendation of the Council, has notified the Common Goods and
Services Electronic Portal for facilitating registration, payment of tax,
furnishing of returns, computation and settlement of integrated tax,
electronic way bill and for carrying out such other functions and for
such purposes as may be prescribed.
47.
In exercise of the powers conferred by Section 146 of the CGST
Act read with Section 20 of the IGST Act, the Central Government, vide
Notification No.4/2017 – Central Tax, dated 19.06.2017, notified
‘www.gst.gov.in’ as the Common Goods and Services Tax Electronic
Portal for facilitating registration, payment of tax, furnishing of returns,
computation and settlement of integrated tax and electronic way bill.
Subsequently, in supersession of the said notification, i.e., Notification
No.4/2017 – Central Tax, dated 19.06.2017, the Central Government,
vide Notification No.9/2018 – Central Tax, dated 23.01.2018 notified
‘www.gst.gov.in’ as the Common Goods and Services Tax Electronic
Portal for facilitating registration, payment of tax, furnishing of returns
and
computation
and
settlement
of
integrated
tax
and
‘www.ewaybillgst.gov.in’ as the Common Goods and Services Tax
Electronic Portal for furnishing electronic way bill. For the purpose of
the said notification, ‘www.gst.gov.in’ means the website managed by
the Goods and Services Tax Network and ‘www.ewaybillgst.gov.in’
means the website managed by the National Informatics Centre,
Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, Government of
India.
48.
The common portal functions as the electronic portal for
facilitating the working of the GST regime including the assessment,
re-assessment, adjudication, review, revision, appeal, rectification,
notice, summons or other proceedings in conformity with the relevant
the provisions of the CGST Act and the Rules framed thereunder.
49.
Section 169 provides for the method of service of notice of
decisions, orders, summons, notice or other communication under the
Act or the Rules, by any one of the methods enumerated under subclauses (a) to (f) of sub-section (1) thereof. Sub-clause (d) of Section
169(1) provides that any such decision, order, summons, notice or
communication under the Act or the Rules, shall be served by making it
available on the common portal.
50.
The controversy herein is whether the show cause notice and the
communication of the assessment order are digitally signed in the
manner prescribed under the Act and the Rules framed thereunder. An
argument has also been raised that the requirement of signature is
mandatory in the Forms framed under the relevant Rules, which has not
been complied with. Therefore, the show cause notices or the
assessment orders or summary of the orders are nullity in the eye of law.
This issue, therefore, is required to be dealt with in the light of the
relevant provisions of the CGST Act and the CGST Rules read with the
provisions of the Information Technology Act, 2000.
51.
The Information Technology Act, 2000 provides for legal
recognition for transactions carried out by means of electronic data
interchange and other means of electronic communication, commonly
referred to as ‘electronic commerce’, which involve the use of
alternatives to paper-based methods of communication and storage of
information, to facilitate electronic filing of documents with the
Government agencies and further to amend the Indian Penal Code, 1860,
the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 and the Banker’s Books Evidence Act,
1891 and the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934 and for matters connected
therewith or incidental thereto. It was enacted in the background of the
resolution of the General Assembly of the United Nations dated
30.01.1997 which adopted the Model Law on Electronic Commerce
adopted by the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law
(UNCITRAL). Therefore, it was considered necessary to give effect to
the said resolution and to promote efficient delivery of Government
services by means of reliable electronic records. With such a rapid
growth in electronic commerce, it became imperative for governments
to regulate online behaviour. The Information Technology Act was
enacted to provide a comprehensive enactment to govern online
commerce. The preamble of the Information Technology Act gives a
glimpse of the objects for which it is enacted.
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
Legal recognition of e-commerce through functional
equivalence;
Uniformity of the law applicable to the e-commerce;
Promote electronic filing and efficient government services;
(iv)
52.
Amending statutes incidentally connected with the Acts such as
Indian Penal Code, 1860, Indian Evidence Act, 1872, the
Banker’s Books Evidence Act, 1891, the Reserve Bank of India
Act, 1934 and for matters connected therewith or incidental
thereto.
The Information Technology Act is divided into 13 Chapters.
Chapter I relates to Preliminary provisions, i.e., short title, extent,
commencement and application and the definitions of various terms
used throughout the Act. Chapter II – Authentification of electronic
records and Electronic Signature ((Sections 3 and 3A). Chapter III Electronic Governance (Sections 4 to 10A) provides Statutory
Recognition of Digital Signatures and Electronic Records as well as
framework for use of electronic records and digital signatures in
government and its agencies. With the insertion of Section 10A,
contracts concluded through electronic means are also recognized as
valid and enforceable contracts. Chapter IV (Sections 11 to 13) deals
with Attribution, Acknowledgement and Dispatch of Electronic
Records, which are extremely important when general contractual
principles are applied to electronic transactions. Chapter V relates to
Secure Electronic Records and Secure Electronic Signatures (Sections
14 to 16) which provides for procedure for keeping electronic signatures
secure and the power to set such procedures upon the Central
Government taking into account the factors such as nature of the
transaction, level of sophistication of the parties with reference to their
technological capacity and the cost of alternative procedures. Chapter VI
provides for Regulation of Certifying Authorities (Sections 17 to 34)
laying down the appointment, functions, powers and obligations of
Certifying Authorities which are vested with such authority while
issuing Digital Signature Certificates. Chapter VII deals with Electronic
Signature Certificates (Sections 35 to 39). Chapter VIII provides for
Duties of Subscribers (Sections 40 to 42), the issuing of a Digital
Signature Certificate and the various duties of subscribers which include
the generation of a key pair, the acceptance of the Digital Signature
Certificate and the control of the private key. Chapter IX provides for
Penalties, Compensation and Adjudication (Sections 43 to 47). Chapter
X relates to Cyber Regulations Appellate Tribunal (Sections 48 to 64)
and Chapter XI relates to Offences (Sections 65 to 78) and penal
imprisonment for such contraventions. Chapter XII, introduced with
effect from 27.10.2009 by the Information Technology (Amendment)
Act, 2008, substitutes old Section 79 and provides for exemption to
Intermediaries from Liability in certain cases. Chapter XIIA provides for
Examiner of Electronic Evidence (Section 79A) appointed by the
Central Government for an expert opinion on electronic form evidence
i.e., relating to information stored or transmitted in electronic form.
Chapter XIII contains Miscellaneous Provisions (Sections 80 to 94). The
four Schedules contain various amendments that are necessitated in
other statutes. For the purpose of this reference, Second Schedule which
makes amendments to the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 by introducing to
admit the electronic records as evidence is relevant.
53.
The Information Technology (Amendment) Act, 2008 made
substantial changes to the earlier enactments. Section 2 of the
Amendment Act has substituted the words “digital signature” for the
words “electronic signature” in 18 Sections, including the relevant subsections as well. Further, Section 3A has been inserted in the
Information Technology Act which enumerates the requirements to be
fulfilled by any form of electronic signatures to be considered reliable
and sanctioned by the Central Government. Sections 15 and 16 prescribe
conditions for securing electronic signatures as well as providing the
Central Government the power to prescribe security procedures and
practices for them by making Rules.
54.
The relevant provisions of the Information Technology Act, 2000
as are applicable to understand the working of the GST regime are being
extracted hereunder:
2(a) “access” with its grammatical variations and cognate expressions
means gaining entry into, instructing or communicating with the logical,
arithmetical, or memory function resources of a computer, computer system or
computer network;
(d) “affixing electronic signature” with its grammatical variations and
cognate expressions means adoption of any methodology or procedure by a
person for the purpose of authenticating an electronic record by means
of electronic signature;
(f) “asymmetric crypto system” means a system of a secure key pair
consisting of a private key for creating a digital signature and a public key to
verify the digital signature;
(g) “Certifying Authority” means a person who has been granted a
licence to issue a electronic signature Certificate under Section 24;
(k) “computer resource” means computer, computer system, computer
network, data, computer data-base or software;
(p) “digital signature” means authentication of any electronic record by a
subscriber by means of an electronic method or procedure in accordance with
the provisions of Section 3;
(q) “Digital Signature Certificate” means a Digital Signature Certificate
issued under sub-section (4) of Section 35;
(t) “electronic record” means data, record or data generated, image or
sound stored, received or sent in an electronic form or micro film or computer
generated micro fiche;
(ta) “electronic signature” means authentication of any electronic record
by a subscriber by means of the electronic technique specified in the Second
Schedule and includes digital signature;
(tb) “Electronic Signature Certificate” means an Electronic Signature
Certificate issued under Section 35 and includes Digital Signature Certificate;
(x) “key pair”, in an asymmetric crypto system, means a private key and
its mathematically related public key, which are so related that the public key
can verify a digital signature created by the private key;
(y) “law” includes any Act of Parliament or of a State Legislature,
Ordinances promulgated by the President or a Governor, as the case may be,
Regulations made by the President under Article 240, Acts enacted as
President’s Act under sub-clause (a) of clause (1) of Article 357 of the
Constitution and includes rules, regulations, bye-laws and orders issued or made
thereunder;
(zb) “prescribed” means prescribed by rules made under this Act;
(zc) “private key” means the key of a key pair used to create a digital
signature;
(zd) “public key” means the key of a key pair used to verify a digital
signature and listed in the Digital Signature Certificate;
(ze) “secure system” means computer hardware, software, and procedure
that(a) are reasonably secure from unauthorised access and misuse;
(b) provide a reasonable level of reliability and correct operation;
(c) are reasonably suited to performing the intended functions; and
(d) adhere to generally accepted security procedures;
(zg) “subscriber” means a person in whose name the Electronic Signature
Certificate is issued;
(zh) “verify” in relation to a digital signature, electronic record or public
key, with its grammatical variations and cognate expressions means to
determine whether—
(a)
the initial electronic record was affixed with the digital
signature by the use of private key corresponding to the
public key of the subscriber;
(b)
the initial electronic record is retained intact or has been
altered since such electronic record was so affixed with the
digital signature.
3. Authentication of electronic records.—(1) Subject to the provisions
of this section, any subscriber may authenticate an electronic record by affixing
his digital signature.
(2) The authentication of the electronic record shall be effected by the
use of asymmetric crypto system and hash function which envelop and
transform the initial electronic record into another electronic record.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this sub-section, “hash function”
means an algorithm mapping or translation of one sequence of bits into another,
generally smaller, set known as “hash result” such that an electronic record
yields the same hash result every time the algorithm is executed with the same
electronic record as its input making it computationally infeasible—
(a)
to derive or reconstruct the original electronic record from
the hash result produced by the algorithm;
(b)
that two electronic records can produce the same hash result
using the algorithm.
(3) Any person by the use of a public key of the subscriber can verify the
electronic record.
(4) The private key and the public key are unique to the subscriber and
constitute a functioning key pair.
3A. Electronic Signature.—(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in
Section 3, but subject to the provisions of sub-section (2), a subscriber may
authenticate any electronic record by such electronic signature or electronic
authentication technique which—
(a)
is considered reliable; and
(b)
may be specified in the Second Schedule.
(2) For the purposes of this section any electronic signature or electronic
authentication technique shall be considered reliable if—
(a)
the signature creation data or the authentication data are,
within the context in which they are used, linked to the
signatory or, as the case may be, the authenticator and to no
other person;
(b)
the signature creation data or the authentication data were, at
the time of signing, under the control of the signatory or, as
the case may be, the authenticator and of no other person;
(c)
any alteration to the electronic signature made after affixing
such signature is detectable;
(d)
any alteration to the information made after its
authentication by electronic signature is detectable; and
(e)
it fulfils such other conditions which may be prescribed.
(3) The Central Government may prescribe the procedure for the purpose
of ascertaining whether electronic signature is that of the person by whom it is
purported to have been affixed or authenticated.
(4) The Central Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette,
add to or omit any electronic signature or electronic authentication technique
and the procedure for affixing such signature from the Second Schedule:
Provided that no electronic signature or authentication technique shall be
specified in the Second Schedule unless such signature or technique is reliable.
(5) Every notification issued under sub-section (4) shall be laid before
each House of Parliament.
4. Legal recognition of electronic records.—Where any law provides
that information or any other matter shall be in writing or in the typewritten or
printed form, then, notwithstanding anything contained in such law, such
requirement shall be deemed to have been satisfied if such information or matter
is—
(a) rendered or made available in an electronic form; and
(b) accessible so as to be usable for a subsequent reference.
5. Legal recognition of electronic signature.—Where any law provides
that information or any other matter shall be authenticated by affixing the
signature or any document shall be signed or bear the signature of any person,
then, notwithstanding anything contained in such law, such requirement shall be
deemed to have been satisfied, if such information or matter is authenticated by
means of electronic signature affixed in such manner as may be prescribed by
the Central Government.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this section, “signed”, with its
grammatical variations and cognate expressions, shall, with reference to a
person, means affixing of his handwritten signature or any mark on any
document and the expression “signature” shall be construed accordingly.
13. Time and place of despatch and receipt of electronic record:- (1)
Save as otherwise agreed to between the originator and the addressee, the
despatch of an electronic record occurs when it enters a computer resource
outside the control of the originator.
(2) Save as otherwise agreed between the originator and the addressee, the time
of receipt of an electronic record shall be determined as follows, namely:—
(a) if the addressee has designated a computer resource for the purpose of
receiving electronic records,—
(i) receipt occurs at the time when the electronic record enters the designated
computer resource; or
(ii) if the electronic record is sent to a computer resource of the addressee that is
not the designated computer resource, receipt occurs at the time when the
electronic record is retrieved by the addressee;
(b) if the addressee has not designated a computer resource along with specified
timings, if any, receipt occurs when the electronic record enters the computer
resources of the addressee.
(3) Save as otherwise agreed to between the originator and the addressee, an
electronic record is deemed to be despatched at the place where the originator
has his place of business, and is deemed to be received at the place where the
addressee has his place of business.
(4) The provisions of sub-section (2) shall apply notwithstanding that the place
where the computer resource is located may be different from the place where
the electronic record is deemed to have been received under sub-section (3).
(5) For the purposes of this section,—
(a) if the originator or the addressee has more than one place of business, the
principal place of business, shall be the place of business;
(b) if the originator or the addressee does not have a place of business, his usual
place of residence shall be deemed to be the place of business;
(c) “usual place of residence”, in relation to a body corporate, means the place
where it is registered.
17. Appointment of Controller and other officers.— (1) The Central
Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, appoint a Controller of
Certifying Authorities for the purposes of this Act and may also by the same or
subsequent notification appoint such number of Deputy Controllers, Assistant
Controllers, other officers and employees as it deems fit.
(2) The Controller shall discharge his functions under this Act subject to
the general control and directions of the Central Government.
(3) The Deputy Controllers and Assistant Controllers shall perform the
functions assigned to them by the Controller under the general superintendence
and control of the Controller.
(4) The qualifications, experience and terms and conditions of service of
Controller, Deputy Controllers, Assistant Controllers, other officers and
employees shall be such as may be prescribed by the Central Government.
(5) The Head Office and Branch Office of the office of the Controller
shall be at such places as the Central Government may specify, and these may
be established at such places as the Central Government may think fit.
(6) There shall be a seal of the Office of the Controller.
18. Functions of Controller.— The Controller may perform all or any
of the following functions, namely:–
(a)
exercising supervision over the activities of the Certifying
Authorities;
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
(g)
(h)
(i)
(j)
(k)
(l)
(m)
(n)
certifying public keys of the Certifying Authorities;
laying down the standards to be maintained by the Certifying
Authorities;
specifying the qualifications and experience which employees of
the Certifying Authority should possess;
specifying the conditions subject to which the Certifying
Authorities shall conduct their business;
specifying the contents of written, printed or visual materials and
advertisements that may be distributed or used in respect of
Electronic Signature Certificate and the public key;
specifying the form and content of a Electronic Signature
Certificate and the key;
specifying the form and manner in which accounts shall be
maintained by the Certifying Authorities;
specifying the terms and conditions subject to which auditors may
be appointed and the remuneration to be paid to them;
facilitating the establishment of any electronic system by a
Certifying Authority either solely or jointly with other Certifying
Authorities and regulation of such systems;
specifying the manner in which the Certifying Authorities shall
conduct their dealings with the subscribers;
resolving any conflict of interests between the Certifying
Authorities and the subscribers;
laying down the duties of the Certifying Authorities;
maintaining a data base containing the disclosure record of every
Certifying Authority containing such particulars as may be
specified by regulations, which shall be accessible to public.
30. Certifying Authority to follow certain procedures.—Every
Certifying Authority shall,—
(a)
(b)
(c)
(ca)
(cb)
(d)
make use of hardware, software and procedures that are secure
from intrusion and misuse;
provide a reasonable level of reliability in its services which are
reasonably suited to the performance of intended functions;
adhere to security procedures to ensure that the secrecy and
privacy of the electronic signatures are assured;
be the repository of all Electronic Signature Certificates issued
under this Act;
publish information regarding its practices, Electronic Signature
Certificates and current status of such certificate; and
observe such other standards as may be specified by regulations.
35. Certifying Authority to issue Electronic Signature Certificate.—
(1) Any person may make an application to the Certifying Authority for the
issue of a Electronic Signature Certificate in such form as may be prescribed by
the Central Government.
(2) Every such application shall be accompanied by such fee not
exceeding twenty-five thousand rupees as may be prescribed by the Central
Government, to be paid to the Certifying Authority:
Provided that while prescribing fees under sub-section (2) different fees
may be prescribed for different classes of applicants.
(3) Every such application shall be accompanied by a certification
practice statement or where there is no such statement, a statement containing
such particulars, as may be specified by regulations.
(4) On receipt of an application under sub-section (1), the Certifying
Authority may, after consideration of the certification practice statement or the
other statement under sub-section (3) and after making such enquiries as it may
deem fit, grant the Electronic Signature Certificate or for reasons to be recorded
in writing, reject the application.
Provided that no application shall be rejected unless the applicant has
been given a reasonable opportunity of showing cause against the proposed
rejection.
55.
of
As per Section 2(1)(a) “access” aims to include all nomenclatures
“access”
including
“grammatical
variations
and
cognate
expressions” and it does not merely mean to gain entry. It includes
“instructing or communicating” with respect to “the logical,
arithmetical, or memory function resources of a computer, computer
system or computer network”. The term ‘access’ finds mention in
Section 2(1)(ze)(a), the definition for a ‘secure system’.
56.
Section 2(1)(d) defines ‘affixing electronic signature’ which is
analogous to signing paper with ink or leaving a fingerprint. The
purpose it serves is to indicate to the reader, that the document is from
the proper party and has not been tampered with. It shall, for all
purposes in law, complement and substitute for any required seal, stamp,
countersign or other distinctive mark. It will have the same effect as
putting the required signature to acts or documents written. This Section
which now reads as ‘affixing electronic signature’ has been amended
where, all references to ‘digital signatures’ was substituted by
‘electronic signatures’.
57.
The term ‘appropriate government’ in Section 2(1)(e) also finds
mention in Section 70, where the ‘appropriate government may declare
a computer, computer system or computer network to be a protected
system.’
58.
‘Asymmetric crypto system’ in Section 2(1)(f) means ‘a system of
a secure key pair consisting of a private key for creating a digital
signature and a public key to verify the digital signature.’
59.
The ‘Certifying Authority’ as defined in Section 2(1)(g), is a
body, either public or private, that seeks to fill the need for trusted third
party services in electronic commerce by issuing electronic signature
certificate that attest to some fact about the subject of the certificate.
The certificate which is issued by the certifying authority is a computer
based record as to the connection between the private key and the
corresponding public key. Subscribers can then disseminate the
certificates to third parties who may wish to communicate with the
subscriber. The certifying authority authenticates digital signatures by
registering key pairs to individuals. When approached, the certifying
authority verifies the integrity of the key pair and links the signature
back to the registered owner.
60.
Section 2(1)(p) defines “digital signature” as a “means of
authentication”, as specified in Section 3. Though this definition
remained untouched, Section 2(1)(ta) and (tb) have been introduced
which
define
‘electronic
signature’
and
‘Electronic
Signature
Certificate’ by the Information Technology (Amendment) Act, 2008.
Electronic signature means authentication of any electronic record by a
subscriber by means of the electronic technique specified in the Second
Schedule and includes digital signature. Therefore, the concomitant is
that the insertion of definition ‘Electronic Signature Certificate’ issued
under Section 35 includes Digital Signature Certificate.
61.
Section 2(1)(za) defines ‘originator’ as a person who sends,
generates, stores or transmits any electronic message or causes any
electronic message to be sent, generated, stored or transmitted to any
other person but does not include an intermediary. Doubts as to whether
an electronic message is attributable to the ‘originator’ are dealt with in
Chapter IV of the Information Technology Act.
62.
The private key is defined under Section 2(1)(zc) as the key of a
key pair which is used to create a digital signature. Public key is defined
under Section 2(1)(zd) as the key of a key pair used to verify a digital
signature and listed in the Digital Signature Certificate.
63.
Chapter II provides for Digital Signature and Electronic
Signature. Section 3 provides for authentication of electronic records.
Cryptography is often referred to as the art and science of keeping
messages secure. Encryption means the ‘the reversible transformation of
data from the original to a difficult-to-interpret format as a mechanism
for protecting
its
confidentiality,
integrity and
sometimes its
authenticity’. Encryption uses a cryptographic algorithm and a key
recipient uses a key to decode the message back into its original form.
Section 3(2) states that the authentication of the electronic record shall
be effected by the use of asymmetric crypto system and hash function. It
therefore becomes necessary to understand the technical background of
these functions. The process of ‘asymmetric cryptography’ commences
when the source, using a ‘private key’ encrypts the message and
signature with a password and sends it to the recipient. The resulting
encryption is the digital signature or hash result, which is unique to each
document and thus, produces a new hash result or signature with each
transmission. After receiving the document, the recipient runs a program
and de-crypts the sender’s document and signature by using the ‘public
key’, which is publicly available online to the encrypting private key.
The program then compares the private key with the public key to
determine if the document sent has been altered since its original
transmission. If unaltered, the two keys will match and the recipient can
be reasonably confident that the subscriber actually executed the
document.
64.
Section 3(3) states that by the use of a public key the subscriber
can verify the electronic record. Therefore, the message can be sent
through standard channels by anyone who has the public key, but can
only be read by the intended recipient, the holder of the private key.
Section 3(4) states that the private key and the public key are unique to
the subscriber and constitute a functioning key pair.
65.
The question now arises as to how electronic signature provides
trustworthy proof we need. The answer to this apprehension is
Certification Authority, which is a trusted third party that acts as a
repository of public keys and authenticates the relationship between a
particular public key and its supplier.
66.
The authentication of the electronic record shall be effected by
the use of asymmetric crypto system. Hash function is further explained
under the Certifying Authorities Rules, which provides that to sign an
electronic record or any other item of information, the signer shall first
apply the hash function in the signer’s software, the hash function shall
compute a hash result of standard length which is unique for all practical
purposes to the electronic record. The signer’s software transforms the
hash result into a digital signature using signer’s private key and the
resulting digital signature shall be unique to both electronic record and
private key used to create it. The digital signature shall be attached to its
electronic record and stored or transmitted with its electronic record.
The aforementioned process shows that the first step in creating a digital
signature is to create a mathematical summary of the document to be
signed and known as ‘hash function’, which is an algorithm that creates
an ic representation of the original message in the form of a standard
length hash value. The hash value is much smaller than the original
message, but is unique to that message. The next step in creating a
digital signature requires the signer of the message, to transform the
message’s unique hash value and original electronic message into an
electronic value by using a private key. The resulting electronic value is
unique to the signer, because it is created as a combination of the
original message’s unique hash value and the signer’s unique private
key. Thus, a digital signature can be summarized as the electronically
signed hash value of the signer’s message created by the signer’s private
key and electronically attached to the message. Once the message is
electronically signed by the signer, it is transmitted to the recipient along
with the signer’s public key. Thus, there are three components of a
digital signature (a) the sender’s public key; (b) the hash value of the
message; and (c) the authorizing certificate.
67.
The process for authentication is prescribed under Rule 5 of the
Certifying Authority Rules. The first step in verifying a digital signature
requires the recipient to apply to the received message, the same hash
function used to create the original message’s hash value. If the two
hash values match identically, then message authentication is
accomplished and the recipient is assured that the message has not been
altered from its original form. The second step in verifying a digital
signature requires the recipient of the message to determine whether the
original message was digitally signed by the signer’s private key. The
recipient will know that the original message was signed by the signer’s
private key because the signer’s public key, transmitted to the recipient
along with the original message, will only verify a digital signature
created by the signer’s private key. Therefore, the digital signature is
considered valid only if both the hash function and private key are
verified by the recipient.
68.
Certifying Authorities provide the information and surety that the
person signing with the private key is who he purports to be and that no
one other than the holder of the private key has written the message. In
other words, this security service assures the recipient that only the
sender could have created the message. Furthermore, it assures him of
the authenticity of the sender’s message. Integrity means that the
contents of the sender’s message arrive at the recipient just as they were
sent. By using the private and public keys, there is security that the
message has not been changed or altered, in any way from the time the
holder of the private key applied his signature and sent the message.
This security service assures that the message is concealed and secure
and has not been altered. Confidentiality gives surety that only the
sender and receiver can understand the message. Ideally, if an outside
party, a third party, intercepted the message, this security service would
prevent the intruder from understanding it. Confidentiality can only be
provided with “electronic signatures” and not “digital signatures”.
Encryption technology allows electronic signatures to provide this
service.
That
is,
encryption
mathematically
scrambles
the
communication so that only the sender and recipient can unscramble and
understand the original message. The other security service provided by
electronic signatures is non-repudiation. Just as with written signatures,
this service provides that the sender is willing to be bound to the
document and therefore, the transaction or contract. It is logical to say
that it is even harder for a signer of an electronic signature to repudiate
his or her willingness to be bound to the document. It is unlikely that
anyone other than the signatory could have signed and sent the digitally
signed document. The physical security of encryption means that the
document must have been signed with the sender’s/signatory’s private
key. Essentially, the security service that non-repudiation assures is that
the sender of the message cannot deny sending the message to the
person who received it.
69.
Section 3A – Electronic signature was introduced by Information
Technology (Amendment) Act, 2008. The Legislature with a view to
maintain balance between the competing interests of security and
neutrality inserted Section 3A which provides legal recognition of other
forms of electronic signatures on the satisfaction of certain prerequisites.
70.
Section 3A(1) prescribes two basic conditions to be fulfilled, for
an electronic signature or electronic authentication technique at par with
the authentication effected through a digital signature. The first of which
contained under Section 3A(1)(a) is with respect to the reliability of the
electronic signature. The specifics of the reliability to qualify as a valid
electronic signature are further set out under Section 3A(2)(a) of the
Act. The Section contains certain characteristics which should be
present in such a technology. These characteristics are:Firstly, that the signature to be produced should be unique and
should be linked to the signatory;
Secondly, there is a requirement of confidentiality, secrecy and
sole control of the signatory over the signature;
Thirdly, any changes to the electronic signature after such a
signature is affixed should be detectable;
Fourthly, after affixing such a signature to the data, if there are
changes in the data, then such changes should be detectable;
The fifth and the final requirement is a residuary clause which
states that, it should fulfil such other conditions which may be
prescribed. Up till now, there have been no Rules which have been
framed under Section 3A of the Act.
71.
Section 4 relates to legal recognition of electronic records. The
purpose behind enacting various electronic commerce statutes can
briefly be stated as creating legal recognition for electronic records,
electronic signatures and electronic contracts and ensuring that the
medium in which a record, signature, or contract is created, presented or
retained does not affect its legal significance. Section 4 sets forth the
fundamental premise of the IT Act, namely that the medium in which a
record, signature or contract is created, presented or retained does not
affect its legal significance and functional equivalence, because the
substantive law governing the underlying transaction may require nonelectronic records or signatures. Thus the Section achieves its purpose
by simply overriding the substantive law on these requirements. The
Section contains two prerequisites before legal recognition may be
impaired to electronic records, which are that the electronic record
should be:
(a) rendered or made available in an electronic form; and
(b) accessible so as to be usable for a subsequent reference.
72.
The first requirement is fulfilled when the electronic record is
within the meaning of section 2(1)(r) of the Act. The second
requirement is satisfied when the record is catalogued or made available.
The rationale behind the second requirement is that electronic data is
intangible and by its very nature transient, thus it is expedient to require
it to be available for future reference. Electronic record has been held to
be documentary evidence under Section 3 of the Indian Evidence Act,
1872. Sections 65A and 65B were introduced in the Indian Evidence
Act, vide Act No.21 of 2000, with effect from 17.10.2000, to deal with
the admissibility as evidence of electronic records. The contents of
electronic record are to be proved in accordance with the provisions of
Section 65B. Sections 62 and 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam,
2023 (BSA) are in pari materia with Sections 65A and 65B of the
former Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
73.
Section 5 of the IT Act prescribes legal recognition of electronic
signatures. Before the Section was amended by Amendment Act, 2008,
the earlier version of the section promoted a highly regulatory and
prescriptive standard, granting functional equivalence only to digital
signatures. Section 5 now by recognizing electronic signatures in place
of digital signatures make a marked difference in its approach by
adopting technology neutrality. This is also accompanied by the
explanation to the section which couches the term, “signed” and
“signature”, in a plenary context, including its grammatical and cognate
variations. The prerequisites which must be satisfied for the application
of the section are – (a) a law should require that information, matter or
document shall be signed or bear the signature of a person; (b) an
electronic signature is affixed in place of such signature; and (c) the
electronic signature is affixed in a manner prescribed by the central
government. Thus, if the Bureau decides to affix a digital signature to its
order, the mere factum that the statute from which it derives its power
does not expressly provide for affixing a digital will not impart, any
defect to its order.
74.
Section 6 relates to use of electronic records and electronic
signatures in Government and its agencies. Section 6(2) provides for the
appropriate government to frame rules for the prescription of (a) the
manner and format in which such electronic records shall be filed,
created or issued; (b) the manner or method of payment of any fee or
charges for filing, creation or issue any electronic record under clause
(a). The Central Government pursuant to this has framed the Information
Technology (Use of Electronic Records and Digital Signatures) Rules,
2004.
75.
It is relevant to refer to Second Schedule attached to the IT Act
and also the relevant provisions of the Certifying Authorities Rules and
the End Entity Rules and are extracted as under:
THE SECOND SCHEDULE
[See sub-section (1) of Section 3A]
ELECTRONIC SIGNATURE OR ELECTRONIC AUTHENTICATION
TECHNIQUE AND PROCEDURE
Sl.
No.
(1)
1.
Description
(2)
e-authentication
technique
Aadhaar or
e-KYC services
Procedure
using
other
(3)
Authentication of an electronic record by eauthentication Technique which shall be done by—
(a) the applicable use of e-authentication, hash, and
asymmetric crypto system techniques, leading to
issuance of Digital Signature Certificate by
Certifying Authority
(b) a trusted third party service by subscriber's key
pair-generation, storing of key pairs and creation of
digital signature provided that the trusted third
party shall be offered by the certifying authority.
The trusted third party shall send application form
and certificate signing request to the Certifying
Authority for issuing a Digital Signature Certificate
to the subscriber.
(c) Issuance of Digital Signature Certificate by
Certifying Authority shall be based on eauthentication, particulars specified in Form C of
Schedule IV of the Information Technology
(Certifying Authorities) Rules, 2000, digitally
signed verified information from Aadhaar or other
e-KYC services and electronic consent of Digital
Signature Certificate applicant.
(d) The manner and requirements for e-authentication
shall be as issued by the Controller from time-totime.
(e) The security procedure for creating the subscriber's
key pair and other e-KYC services] shall be in
accordance with the e-authentication guidelines
issued by the Controller.
(f) The standards referred to in Rule 6 of the
2.
e-authentication
technique and procedure
for
creating
and
accessing
subscriber's
signature key facilitated
by trusted third party
Information Technology (Certifying Authorities)
Rules, 2000 shall be complied with, in so far as
they relate to the certification function of public key
of Digital Signature Certificate applicant.
(g) The manner in which the information is
authenticated by means of digital signature shall
comply with the manner and standards specified in
Rules 3 to 12 of the Digital Signature (End entity)
Rules, 2015 in so far as they relate to the creation,
storage, and verification of Digital Signature.
Authentication of an electronic record by eauthentication technique which shall be done by—
(a) the applicable use of e-authentication, hash and
asymmetric crypto system techniques leading to
issuance of Digital Signature Certificate by
Certifying Authority, provided that Certifying
Authority shall ensure the subscriber identity
verification, secure storage of the keys by trusted
third party and subscriber's sole authentication
control to the signature key.
(b) Identity verification of Digital Signature Certificate
applicant shall be in accordance with the Identity
Verification Guidelines issued by Controller from
time-to-time.
(c) The requirement to operate as trusted third party
shall be specified under e-authentication guidelines
issued by the Controller.
(d) a trusted third party shall
i) facilitate Identity verification of Digital
Signature Certificate applicant;
ii) establish secure storage for subscriber to have
sole control for creation and subsequent usage
of subscriber's signature key by sole
authentication of subscriber;
iii) facilitate key pair-generation, secure storage of
subscriber's signature key and facilitate
signature creation functions;
iv) facilitate the submission of DSC application
form and certificate signing request to the
Certifying Authority for issuing a Digital
Signature Certificate to the DSC applicant, and
v) facilitate revocation of Digital Signature
Certificate and destruction of subscriber's
signature key.
(e) Issuance of Digital Signature Certificate shall be
based on verification of credentials of Digital
Signature Certificate applicant by Certifying
Authority as per the provisions of the Information
Technology Act and Rules made thereunder.
(f) The manner and requirements for authentication
and storage of keys shall be as issued by the
Controller from time-to-time under e-authentication
guidelines
(g) The security procedure for creating the subscriber's
key pair shall be in accordance with the eauthentication guidelines issued by the Controller.
(h) The standards referred to in Rule 6 of the
Information Technology (Certifying Authorities)
Rules, 2000 shall be complied with, in so far as
they relate to the certification function of public key
of Digital Signature Certificate applicant.
(i) The manner in which information is authenticated
by means of digital signature shall comply with the
manner and standards specified in Rules 3 to 12 of
Digital Signature (End entity) Rules, 2015 in so far
as they relate to the creation, storage and
verification of Digital Signature.
The Information Technology (Certifying Authorities) Rules, 2000:
3. The manner in which information be authenticated by means of Digital
Signature.—A Digital Signature shall,—
(a)
be created and verified by cryptography that concerns itself with
transforming electronic record into seemingly unintelligible
forms and back again;
(b)
use what is known as “Public Key Cryptography”, which
employs an algorithm using two different but mathematical
related “keys” - one for creating a Digital Signature or
transforming data into a seemingly unintelligible form, and
another key for verifying a Digital Signature or returning the
electronic record to original form, the process termed as hash
function shall be used in both creating and verifying a Digital
Signature.
Explanation.—Computer equipment and software utilizing two such
keys are often termed as “asymmetric cryptography”.
4. Creation of Digital Signature.—To sign an electronic record or any
other item of information, the signer shall first apply the hash function in
the signer's software; the hash function shall compute a hash result of
standard length which is unique (for all practical purposes) to the
electronic record; the signer's software transforming the hash result into a
Digital Signature using signer's private key; the resulting Digital
Signature shall be unique to both electronic record and private key used
to create it; the Digital Signature and the digital signature certificate
attached to its electronic record shall be stored or transmitted along with
its electronic record.
5. Verification of Digital Signature.—The verification of a Digital
Signature shall be accomplished by computing a new hash result of the
original electronic record by means of the hash function used to create a
Digital Signature and by using the public key and the new hash result,
the verifier shall check—
(i)
if the Digital Signature was created using the corresponding
private key; and
(ii)
if the newly computed hash result matches the original result
which was transformed into Digital Signature during the signing
process. The verification software will confirm the Digital
Signature as verified if:—
(a) the signer's private key was used to digitally sign the electronic
record, which is known to be the case if the signer's public key was used
to verify the signature because the signer's public key will verify only a
Digital Signature created with the signer's private key; and
(b) the electronic record was unaltered, which is known to be the case if
the hash result computed by the verifier is identical to the hash result
extracted from the Digital Signature during the verification process.
5-A. Verification of Digital Signature Certificate.—(a) The selfsigned certificate generated by the Controller, which begins the trust
chain for the public key infrastructure, shall be used to verify the
authenticity of the public key certificate of the licensed certifying
authorities;
(b) the public key certificate of the licensed certifying authorities
shall be used to verify the authenticity of the digital signature certificate
issued to the subscribers;
(c) the certificate revocation list maintained by the licensed
certifying authorities shall be checked to confirm whether the certificate
is valid or whether it has been revoked under Section 38 of the Act;
(d) while verifying the validity of a digital signature the
corresponding digital signature certificates should chain up through the
public key certificate of the issuing certifying authority to the self-signed
certificate of the Controller and if any of the certificates in the trust chain
is not trusted the signature will not be verified.
The Digital Signature (End Entity) Rules, 2015:
3. Manner of authentication of information by means of digital
signature.—A digital signature shall,—
(a) be created and verified by cryptography which concerns with
transforming electronic record into seemingly unintelligible forms;
(b) use Public Key Cryptography, which employs an algorithm using two
different but mathematical related keys; one key (called the private key)
for creating a digital signature and another key (called the public key) for
verifying a digital signature;
(c) use an hash function for creating and verifying a digital signature
which required to make digital signature generation and verification
efficient.
4. Creation of digital signature.—(1) The signatory shall, while
signing an electronic record or any other item of information, first apply
an hash function in the signatory's hardware or software.
(2) The hash function shall produce a hash result.
(3) The signatory's hardware or software shall then transform the
hash result into a digital signature using signatory's private key and
signature algorithm.
(4) The contextual information like date and time, shall be then
made part of the digital signature.
(5) The counter signatures or parallel signatures or both may also be
applied to electronic record.
(6) The following information may also be a part of signature,—
(a) the signatory's public key signature certificate(s);
(b) the public key certificate(s) of the licensed Certifying Authorities
which used to verify the authenticity of the digital signature certificate
issued to the signatory;
(c) the self signed certificate generated by the Controller used to verify
the authenticity of the public key certificate of the licensed Certifying
Authorities;
(d) the certificate revocation list(s) maintained by the licensed Certifying
Authorities, and the controller which is used to check whether the digital
signature certificate has been revoked under Section 38 of the Act;
(e) online certificate status protocol responder certificates and online
certificate status protocol responses that may be used in lieu of certificate
revocation list.
(7) To create long term valid digital signature,—
(a) a timestamp shall be applied initially to the signed data including the
certificates and revocation information;
(b) ensure that initial time stamp shall cover all the data and signature(s);
(c) a nested time stamp option shall be used to ensure signature validity
past the time stamping service provider's (tssp) key or algorithm expiry
where the nesting of time stamps implies that a subsequent time stamp
shall be applied to the prior time stamp;
(d) signature(s) and time stamps may be embedded in the data itself or
stored separately as standalone.
5. Verification of digital signature.—(1) The verification of a
digital signature shall be accomplished by computing a new hash result
of the original electronic record by means of the hash function used to
create a digital signature and by using the public key and the new hash
result, the verifier shall check—
(a) if the digital signature was created using the corresponding private
key and shall be applicable for parallel and counter signatures applied on
the electronic record, if present;
(b) the time when the digital signature was created.
(2) To verify counter signature, the signature on electronic record
and thereafter signature on previous signature serially shall be verified.
(3) To verify parallel signature, signature on electronic record shall
be verified independently.
(4) To verify long term signature, the initial timestamp and all
subsequent time stamp applied on the each prior timestamp shall be
verified.
6. Verification of Digital Signature Certificate.—(1) The self
signed certificate generated by the Controller, which begins the trust
chain for the public key infrastructure, shall be used to verify the
authenticity of the public key certificate of the licensed Certifying
Authorities.
(2) The public key certificate of the licensed Certifying Authorities
shall be used to verify the authenticity of the digital signature certificate
issued to the subscribers.
(3) The certificate revocation list maintained by the licensed
Certifying Authorities shall be checked to confirm whether the certificate
of the licensed Certifying Authorities is valid or whether it has been
revoked under Section 38 the Act.
(4) While verifying the validity of a digital signature the
corresponding digital signature certificate shall chain up through the
public key certificate of the issuing Certifying Authority to the self
signed certificate of the Controller and if any of the certificates in the
trust chain is not trusted the signature shall not be verified.
(5) The Digital Signature Certificate shall be verified with respect to
time of signature created.
(6) The chain of certificates shall be verified in accordance with the
standards specified in Rule 7.
(7) If the certificate validity is less than one hour, the checking of
revocation list shall not be required.
76.
Having referred to the manner of authentication of electronic
records as prescribed under the IT Act, it is now pertinent to refer to the
method and the procedure prescribed under Chapter XVIII of the CGST
Rules, which relates to Demands and Recovery. Rule 26 under Chapter
III – Registration, often referred to by the parties and the decisions cited
by them are also noticed hereinbelow. The relevant Rules are extracted
hereinafter:
CHAPTER III
REGISTRATION
Rule 26. Method of authentication.- (1) All applications,
including reply, if any, to the notices, returns including the details of
outward and inward supplies, appeals or any other document required to
be submitted under the provisions of these rules shall be so submitted
electronically with digital signature certificate or through e-signature as
specified under the provisions of the Information Technology Act, 2000
(21 of 2000) or verified by any other mode of signature or verification as
notified by the Board in this behalf:
(2) Each document including the return furnished online shall be
signed or verified through electronic verification code(a) in the case of an individual, by the individual himself or
where he is absent from India, by some other person
duly authorised by him in this behalf, and where the
individual is mentally incapacitated from attending to his
affairs, by his guardian or by any other person
competent to act on his behalf;
(b) in the case of a Hindu Undivided Family, by a Karta and
where the Karta is absent from India or is mentally
incapacitated from attending to his affairs, by any other
adult member of such family or by the authorised
signatory of such Karta;
(c) in the case of a company, by the chief executive officer
or authorised signatory thereof;
(d) in the case of a Government or any Governmental
agency or local authority, by an officer authorised in this
behalf;
(e) in the case of a firm, by any partner thereof, not being a
minor or authorised signatory thereof;
(f) in the case of any other association, by any member of
the association or persons or authorised signatory
thereof;
(g) in the case of a trust, by the trustee or any trustee or
authorised signatory thereof; or
(h) in the case of any other person, by some person
competent to act on his behalf, or by a person authorised
in accordance with the provisions of section 48.
(3) All notices, certificates and orders under the provisions of this
Chapter shall be issued electronically by the proper officer or any other
officer authorised to issue such notices or certificates or orders, through
digital signature certificate or through e-signature as specified under the
provisions of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (21 of 2000) or
verified by any other mode of signature or verification as notified by the
Board in this behalf.
Chapter XVIII
DEMANDS AND RECOVERY
Rule 142. Notice and order for demand of amounts payable
under the Act.— (1) The proper officer shall serve, along with the
(a) notice issued under Section 52 or Section 73 or Section
74 or Section 74A or Section 76 or Section 122 or Section
123 or Section 124 or Section 125 or Section 127 or Section
129 or Section 130, a summary thereof electronically
in FORM GST DRC-01,
(b) statement under sub-section (3) of Section 73 or sub-section
(3) of Section 74 or sub-section (3) of Section 74-A, a
summary thereof electronically in FORM GST DRC-02,
specifying therein the details of the amount payable.
(1-A) The proper officer may, before service of notice to the
person chargeable with tax, interest and penalty, under sub-section (1) of
Section 73 or sub-section (1) of Section 74 or sub-section (1) of Section
74-A, as the case may be, communicate the details of any tax, interest
and penalty as ascertained by the said officer, in Part A of FORM GST
DRC-01-A.
(2) Where, before the service of notice or statement, the person
chargeable with tax makes payment of the tax and interest in accordance
with the provisions of sub-section (5) of Section 73 or clause (i) of subsection (8) of Section 74-A, as the case may be, or tax, interest and
penalty in accordance with the provisions of sub-section (5) of Section
74 or clause (i) of sub-section (9) of Section 74-A], or where any person
makes payment of tax, interest, penalty or any other amount due in
accordance with the provisions of the Act, whether on his own
ascertainment or, as communicated by the proper officer under sub-rule
(1-A), he shall inform the proper officer of such payment in FORM GST
DRC-03 and an acknowledgement, in FORM GST DRC-04 shall be
made available to the person through the common portal electronically.
(2A) Where the person referred to in sub-rule (1-A) has made
partial payment of the amount communicated to him or desires to file
any submissions against the proposed liability, he may make such
submission in Part B of FORM GST DRC-01-A, and thereafter the
proper officer may issue an intimation in Part-C of FORM GST DRC01A, accepting the payment or the submissions or both, as the case may
be, made by the said person.
(2B) Where an amount of tax, interest, penalty or any other
amount payable by a person under Section 52 or Section 73 or Section
74 or Section 74-A or Section 76 or Section 122 or Section 123 or
Section 124 or Section 125 or Section 127 or Section 129 or Section
130, has been paid by the said person through an intimation in FORM
GST DRC-03 under sub-rule (2), instead of crediting the said amount in
the electronic liability register in FORM GST PMT-01 against the debit
entry created for the said demand, the said person may file an application
in FORM GST DRC-03A electronically on the common portal, and the
amount so paid and intimated through FORM GST DRC-03 shall be
credited in Electronic Liability Register in FORM GST PMT-01 against
the debit entry created for the said demand, as if the said payment was
made towards the said demand on the date of such intimation made
through FORM GST DRC-03:
Provided that where an order in FORM GST DRC-05 has been
issued in terms of sub-rule (3) concluding the proceedings, in respect of
the payment of an amount in FORM GST DRC-03, an application in
FORM GST DRC-03A cannot be filed by the said person in respect of
the said payment.
(3) Where the person chargeable with tax makes payment of tax
and interest under sub-section (8) of Section 73 or under clause (ii) of
sub-section (8) of Section 74-A, as the case may be, or tax, interest and
penalty under sub-section (8) of Section 74 or under clause (ii) of subsection (9) of Section 74-A, as the case may be, within the period
specified therein, or where the person concerned makes payment of the
amount referred to in sub-section (1) of Section 129 within seven days of
the notice issued under sub-section (3) of that section but before the
issuance of order under the said sub-section (3), he shall intimate the
proper officer of such payment in FORM GST DRC-03 and the proper
officer shall issue an intimation in FORM GST DRC-05 concluding the
proceedings in respect of the said notice.
(4) The representation referred to in sub-section (9) of Section 73
or sub-section (9) of Section 74 or sub-section (6) of Section 74-A] or
sub-section (3) of Section 76 or the reply to any notice issued under any
section whose summary has been uploaded electronically in FORM GST
DRC-01 under sub-rule (1) shall be furnished in FORM GST DRC-06.
(5) A summary of the order issued under Section 52 or Section 62
or Section 63 or Section 64 or Section 73 or Section 74 or Section 74-A
or sub-section (12) of Section 75 or Section 75 or Section 76 or Section
122 or Section 123 or Section 124 or Section 125 or Section 127 or
Section 129 or Section 130 shall be uploaded electronically in FORM
GST DRC-07, specifying therein the amount of tax, interest and penalty,
as the case may be, payable by the person concerned.
(6) The order referred to in sub-rule (5) shall be treated as the
notice for recovery.
(7) Where a rectification of the order has been passed in
accordance with the provisions of Section 161 or where an order
uploaded on the system has been withdrawn, a summary of the
rectification order or of the withdrawal order shall be uploaded
electronically by the proper officer in FORM GST DRC-08.
Rule 142A. Procedure for recovery of dues under existing
laws. - (1) A summary of order issued under any of the existing laws
creating demand of tax, interest, penalty, fee or any other dues which
becomes recoverable consequent to proceedings launched under the
existing law before, on or after the appointed day shall, unless recovered
under that law, be recovered under the Act and may be uploaded
in FORM GST DRC-07A electronically on the common portal for
recovery under the Act and the demand of the order shall be posted in
Part II of Electronic Liability Register in FORM GST PMT-01.
(2) Where the demand of an order uploaded under sub-rule (1) is rectified
or modified or quashed in any proceedings, including in appeal, review or
revision, or the recovery is made under the existing laws, a summary
thereof shall be uploaded on the common portal in FORM DRC-08A and
Part II of Electronic Liability Register in FORM GST PMT-01 shall be
updated accordingly.
Rule 142-B. Intimation of certain amounts liable to be
recovered under Section 79 of the Act.—(1) Where, in accordance with
Section 75 read with Rule 88-C, or otherwise, any amount of tax or
interest has become recoverable under Section 79 and the same has
remained unpaid, the proper officer shall intimate, electronically on the
common portal, the details of the said amount in FORM GST DRC-01D,
directing the person in default to pay the said amount, along with
applicable interest, or, as the case may the amount of interest, within
seven days of the date of the said intimation and the said amount shall be
posted in Part-II of Electronic Liability Register in FORM GST PMT-01.
(2) The intimation referred to in sub-rule (1) shall be treated as the
notice for recovery.
(3) Where any amount of tax or interest specified in the intimation
referred to in sub-rule (1) remains unpaid on the expiry of the period
specified in the said intimation, the proper officer shall proceed to
recover the amount that remains unpaid in accordance with the provisions
of Rule 143 or Rule 144 or Rule 145 or Rule 146 or Rule 147 or Rule 155
or Rule 156 or Rule 157 or Rule 160.
Rule 145. Recovery from a third person.— (1) The proper
officer may serve upon a person referred to in clause (c) of sub-section
(1) of Section 79 (hereafter referred to in this rule as “the third person”), a
notice in Form GST DRC-13 directing him to deposit the amount
specified in the notice.
(2) Where the third person makes the payment of the amount
specified in the notice issued under sub-rule (1), the proper officer shall
issue a certificate in Form GST DRC-14 to the third person clearly
indicating the details of the liability so discharged.
Rule 151. Attachment of debts and shares, etc.—(1) A debt
not secured by a negotiable instrument, a share in a corporation, or other
movable property not in the possession of the defaulter except for
property deposited in, or in the custody of any court shall be attached by a
written order in Form GST DRC-16 prohibiting—
(a) in the case of a debt, the creditor from recovering the debt and the
debtor from making payment thereof until the receipt of a further order
from the proper officer;
(b) in the case of a share, the person in whose name the share may be
standing from transferring the same or receiving any dividend thereon;
(c) in the case of any other movable property, the person in possession
of the same from giving it to the defaulter.
(2) A copy of such order shall be affixed on some conspicuous part of
the office of the proper officer, and another copy shall be sent, in the case
of debt, to the debtor, and in the case of shares, to the registered address
of the corporation and in the case of other movable property, to the
person in possession of the same.
(3) A debtor, prohibited under clause (a) of sub-rule (1), may pay the
amount of his debt to the proper officer, and such payment shall be
deemed as paid to the defaulter.
Rule 152. Attachment of property in custody of courts or
Public Officer.— Where the property to be attached is in the custody of
any court or Public Officer, the proper officer shall send the order of
attachment to such court or officer, requesting that such property, and any
interest or dividend becoming payable thereon, may be held till the
recovery of the amount payable.
77.
A careful reading of Rule 142, which provides for notice and
order for demand of amounts payable under the Act, shows a discernible
conspicuous distinct method of issuance of notice in the prescribed form
or summary thereof electronically uploaded on common portal. Rule
142(1)(a) states that the proper officer shall serve along with the notice
issued
under
different
Sections
along
with
summary
thereof
electronically in Form GST DRC-01, and as per 1(b) the statement and
a summary thereof in Form GST DRC-02 specifying the details of the
amount payable. Rule 2B specifies that where an amount of tax, interest,
penalty or any other amount payable by a person has been paid by the
said person through an intimation in Form GST DRC-03 under sub-rule
(2), instead of crediting the said amount in the electronic liability
register in Form GST PMT-01 against the debit entry created for the
said demand, the said person may file an application in Form GST
DRC-03A electronically on the common portal, and the amount so
paid and intimated through Form DRC-03 shall be credited in Electronic
Liability Register in Form GST PMT-01 against the debit entry created
for the said demand, as if the said payment was made towards the said
demand on the date of such intimation made through Form GST DRC03. Rule 142(4) states that the representation referred to in sub-section
(9) of Section 73 or sub-section (9) of Section 74 or sub-section (6) of
Section 74-A or sub-section (3) of Section 76 or the reply to any notice
issued under any section whose summary has been uploaded
electronically in FORM GST DRC-01 under sub-rule (1) shall be
furnished in FORM GST DRC-06. Rule 142(5) states that a summary of
the order issued under Section 52 or Section 62 or Section 63 or Section
64 or Section 73 or Section 74 or Section 74-A or sub-section (12) of
Section 75 or Section 75 or Section 76 or Section 122 or Section 123 or
Section 124 or Section 125 or Section 127 or Section 129 or Section 130
shall be uploaded electronically in FORM GST DRC-07, specifying
therein the amount of tax, interest and penalty, as the case may be,
payable by the person concerned. Rule 142A specifies that a summary
of order issued under any of the existing laws creating demand of tax,
interest, penalty, fee or any other dues which becomes recoverable
consequent to proceedings launched under the existing law before, on or
after the appointed day shall, unless recovered under that law, be
recovered under the Act and may be uploaded in FORM GST DRC07A electronically on the common portal for recovery under the Act.
Rule 142B states that where, in accordance with Section 75 read with
Rule 88-C, or otherwise, any amount of tax or interest has become
recoverable under Section 79 and the same has remained unpaid, the
proper officer shall intimate, electronically on the common portal. As
per Rule 145, the proper officer may serve upon a person referred to in
clause (c) of sub-section (1) of Section 79 (hereafter referred to in this
rule as “the third person”), a notice in Form GST DRC-13 directing him
to deposit the amount specified in the notice. As per rule 152, where the
property to be attached is in the custody of any court or Public Officer,
the proper officer shall send the order of attachment to such court or
officer, requesting that such property, and any interest or dividend
becoming payable thereon, may be held till the recovery of the amount
payable.
78.
The method and the procedure prescribed under Chapter XVIII of
the Rules conspicuously does not refer to any digital signature to be
affixed in the relevant forms. It is further discernible that the service of
notice of a third person under Rule 145 in Form DRC 13 and other
provisions, such as Rules 146 and 147 relating to recovery through
execution of a decree etc., and recovery by sale of movable or
immovable property do not speak of service of notice or issue of order
electronically in the prescribed forms. Similar is the position under
Rules 151, 152, 153, 155 and 156, Rule 158 refers to filing of an
application for payment of tax and other amounts in instalments by a
taxable person in Form GST DRC-20.
79.
Reference has often been made to Rule 26 which occurs under
Chapter III – Registration. The method of authentication under Rule
26(3) does refer to issuance of notices, certificates and orders under the
provisions of this Chapter electronically by the proper officer or any
other officer authorized through digital signature certificate or through
e-signature as specified under the provisions of the Information
Technology Act, 2000 or verified by any other mode of signature or
verification as notified by the Board in this behalf. This rule also does
not restrict the notice, certificate or order to be issued electronically
through digital signature certificate. It can be through e-signature under
the provisions of the IT Act or verified by any other mode of signature
or verification as notified by the Board in this behalf. The Rule 26(3) is
applicable to notices, certificates and orders under the provisions of this
Chapter i.e., Registration and cannot be borrowed or applied to Chapter
XVIII which relates to ‘Demands and Recovery’ and which prescribes
the method and procedure for service of notices or orders or summary
thereof electronically in the prescribed forms.
80.
In order to make the distinction clear, it is also pertinent to refer
to some of the other Rules which consciously prescribe other modes of
signature or verification. A tabular chart hereinbelow would further
elucidate the method by which these notices or orders or demands have
to be served electronically.
Sl.
No.
Rules
1.
Central Goods and
Services Tax Rules,
Rule
3.
Intimation
composition levy
for
sub-rule
Relevant Extract
(1) and
(3)
(1) Any person who has been granted registration on a provisional basis under clause (b) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 24 and who opts to pay tax
under Section 10, shall electronically file an intimation in Form GST CMP-01, duly signed or verified through electronic verification
code, on the common portal, either directly or through a Facilitation Centre notified by the Commissioner, prior to the appointed day, but not
later than thirty days after the said day, or such further period as may be extended by the Commissioner in this behalf:
Xxx xxx
(3) Any registered person who opts to pay tax under Section 10 shall electronically file an intimation in Form GST CMP-02, duly signed or
verified through electronic verification code, on the common portal, either directly or through a Facilitation Centre notified by the
Commissioner, prior to the commencement of the financial year for which the option to pay tax under the aforesaid section is exercised and
shall furnish the statement in Form GST ITC-03 in accordance with the provisions of sub-rule (4) of Rule 44 within a period of sixty days
from the commencement of the relevant financial year:
Provided that any registered person who opts to pay tax under Section 10 for the Financial Year 2020-21 shall electronically
file an intimation in Form GST CMP-02, duly signed or verified through electronic verification code, on the common portal, either directly
or through a Facilitation Centre notified by the Commissioner on or before 30th day of June, 2020 and shall furnish the statement in Form
GST ITC-03 in accordance with the provisions of sub-rule (4) of Rule 44 up to the 31st day of July, 2020.
of
(3)
(3) The registered person who intends to withdraw from the composition scheme shall, before the date of such withdrawal, file
an application in Form GST CMP-04, duly signed or verified through electronic verification code, electronically on the common portal.
8.
Application for
registration
(4)
(4) Using the reference number generated under sub-rule (3), the applicant shall electronically submit an application in Part B
of Form GST REG-01, duly signed or verified through electronic verification code, along with the documents specified in the said Form at
the common portal, either directly or through a Facilitation Centre notified by the Commissioner.
10.
Issue
of
registration certificate
(4) and
(5)
6.
Validity
composition levy
(4) Every certificate of registration shall be duly signed or verified through electronic verification code by the proper officer
under the Act.
(5) Where the registration has been granted under sub-rule (5) of Rule 9, the applicant shall be communicated the registration
number, and the certificate of registration under sub-rule (1), duly signed or verified through electronic verification code, shall be made
available to him on the common portal, within a period of three days after the expiry of the period specified in sub-rule (5) of Rule 9.
12.
Grant
of
registration to persons
required to deduct tax
at source or to collect
tax at source
(1)
(1) Any person required to deduct tax in accordance with the provisions of Section 51 or a person required to collect tax at
source in accordance with the provisions of Section 52 shall electronically submit an application, duly signed or verified through electronic
verification code, in Form GST REG-07 for the grant of registration through the common portal, either directly or through a Facilitation
Centre notified by the Commissioner.
13.
Grant
of
registration to nonresident taxable person
(1) and
(4)
(1) A non-resident taxable person shall electronically submit an application, along with a self-attested copy of his valid
passport, for registration, duly signed or verified through electronic verification code, in Form GST REG-09, at least five days prior to the
commencement of business at the common portal either directly or through a Facilitation Centre notified by the Commissioner:
xxx
(4) The application for registration made by a non-resident taxable person shall be duly signed or verified through electronic
verification code by his authorised signatory who shall be a person resident in India having a valid Permanent Account Number.
14.
Grant
of
registration to a person
supplying
online
information
and
database access or
retrieval services from
a place outside India
to non-taxable online
recipient or to a person
supplying
online
money gaming from a
place outside India to a
person in India
(1)
(1) Any person supplying online information and database access or retrieval services from a place outside India to a nontaxable online recipient or any person supplying online money gaming from a place outside India to a person in India shall electronically
submit an application for registration, duly signed or verified through electronic verification code, in Form GST REG-10, at the common
portal, either directly or through a Facilitation Centre notified by the Commissioner.
14-A
Option for
taxpayers
having
monthly output tax
liability
below
threshold limit
17. Assignment of
Unique
Identity
Number to certain
special entities
19.
Amendment of
registration
(5)
(5) The registered person who intends to withdraw from the option availed under sub-rule (1), shall file an application, in
FORM GST REG-32, duly signed or verified through electronic verification code on the common portal, either directly or through a
Facilitation Centre notified by the Commissioner:
xxx
(1)
(1) Every person required to be granted a Unique Identity Number in accordance with the provisions of sub-section (9) of
Section 25 may submit an application electronically in Form GST REG-13, duly signed or verified through electronic verification code, in
the manner specified in Rule 8 at the common portal, either directly or through a Facilitation Centre notified by the Commissioner.
(1)
(1) Where there is any change in any of the particulars furnished in the application for registration in Form GST REG-01 or
Form GST REG-07 or Form GST REG-09 or Form GST REG-10 or in the intimation furnished by the composition taxpayer in FORM GST
CMP-02 or for Unique Identity Number in Form GST REG-13, either at the time of obtaining registration or Unique Identity Number or as
amended from time to time, the registered person shall, within a period of fifteen days of such change, submit an application, duly signed or
verified through electronic verification code, electronically in FORM GST REG-14, along with the documents relating to such change at the
common portal, either directly or through a Facilitation Centre notified by the Commissioner:
xxx
24.
Migration of
persons
registered
under the existing law
(2)(a)
(2)(a) Every person who has been granted a provisional registration under sub-rule (1) shall submit an application electronically
in Form GST REG−26, duly signed or verified through electronic verification code, along with the information and documents specified in
the said application, on the common portal either directly or through a Facilitation Centre notified by the Commissioner.
26.
Method
authentication
(1), (2)
and (3)
(1) All applications, including reply, if any, to the notices, returns including the details of outward and inward supplies, appeals
or any other document required to be submitted under the provisions of these rules shall be so submitted electronically with digital signature
certificate or through e-signature as specified under the provisions of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (21 of 2000) or verified by
any other mode of signature or verification as notified by the Board in this behalf.
(2) Each document including the return furnished online shall be signed or verified through electronic verification code—
xxx
(3) All notices, certificates and orders under the provisions of this Chapter shall be issued electronically by the proper
officer or any other officer authorised to issue such notices or certificates or orders, through digital signature certificate or through esignature as specified under the provisions of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (21 of 2000) or verified by any other mode of
signature or verification as notified by the Board in this behalf.
(q) and
proviso
(q) signature or digital signature of the supplier or his authorised representative;
xxx
Provided also that the signature or digital signature of the supplier or his authorised representative shall not be
46. Tax invoice
of
required in the case of issuance of an electronic invoice in accordance with the provisions of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (21
of 2000):
(h) and
proviso
49. Bill of supply
(h) signature or digital signature of the supplier or his authorised representative:
xxx
Provided also that the signature or digital signature of the supplier or his authorised representative shall not be required in
the case of issuance of an electronic bill of supply in accordance with the provisions of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (21 of 2000).
50. Receipt voucher
(k)
51. Refund voucher
(k)
(k) signature or digital signature of the supplier or his authorised representative.
52. Payment voucher
(j)
(j) signature or digital signature of the supplier or his authorised representative.
53. Revised tax invoice
and credit or debit
notes
(1)(j) and
(1A)(i)
54.
Tax invoice in
special cases
(1)(f), (2)
and (4)
(1) An Input Service Distributor invoice or, as the case may be, an Input Service Distributor credit note issued by an Input
Service Distributor shall contain the following details—
xxx
(f) signature or digital signature of the Input Service Distributor or his authorised representative:
xxx
(2) Where the supplier of taxable service is an insurer or a banking company or a financial institution, including a non-banking
financial company, the said supplier may issue a consolidated tax invoice or any other document in lieu thereof, by whatever name called for
the supply of services made during a month at the end of the month], whether issued or made available, physically or electronically whether or
not serially numbered, and whether or not containing the address of the recipient of taxable service but containing other information as
mentioned under Rule 46:
Provided that the signature or digital signature of the supplier or his authorised representative shall not be required in
the case of issuance of a consolidated tax invoice or any other document in lieu thereof in accordance with the provisions of the Information
Technology Act, 2000 (21 of 2000).
xxx
(4) Where the supplier of taxable service is supplying passenger transportation service, a tax invoice shall include ticket in any
Form, by whatever name called, whether or not serially numbered, and whether or not containing the address of the recipient of service but
containing other information as mentioned under Rule 46:
Provided that the signature or digital signature of the supplier or his authorised representative shall not be required in
the case of issuance of ticket in accordance with the provisions of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (21 of 2000).
xxx
55. Transportation of
goods without issue of
invoice
(1)(ix)
(1) For the purposes of—
xxx
the consigner may issue a delivery challan, serially numbered not exceeding sixteen characters, in one or multiple series, in lieu
of invoice at the time of removal of goods for transportation, containing the following details, namely—
xxx
(ix) signature.
56.
Maintenance of
accounts by registered
persons
(15)
(15) The records under the provisions of this Chapter may be maintained in electronic Form and the record so maintained shall
be authenticated by means of a digital signature.
83. Provisions relating
to a goods and services
tax practitioner
(10)(b)
(10) The goods and services tax practitioner shall—
xxx
(b) affix his digital signature on the statements prepared by him or electronically verify using his credentials.
106. Form and manner
of appeal to the
Appellate
Authority
for Advance Ruling
(3)(b)
(3) The appeal referred to in sub-rule (1) or sub-rule (2), the verification contained therein and all the relevant documents
accompanying such appeal shall be signed,—
xxx
(b) in the case of an applicant, in the manner specified in Rule 26.
108. Appeal to the
Appellate Authority
(2)
(2) The grounds of appeal and the Form of verification as contained in Form GST APL-01 shall be signed in the manner
specified in Rule 26.
110. Appeal to the
Appellate Tribunal
(3)
(3) The appeal and the memorandum of cross objections shall be signed in the manner specified in rule 26.
111. Application to the
Appellate Tribunal
(3)
(3) The appeal and the memorandum of cross objections shall be signed in the manner specified in rule 26.
114. Appeal
High Court
the
(2)
(2) The grounds of appeal and the Form of verification as contained in Form GST APL-08 shall be signed in the manner
specified in Rule 26.
117.
Tax or duty
credit carried forward
under any existing law
or on goods held in
stock on the appointed
day.
(1)
(1) Every registered person entitled to take credit of input tax under Section 140 shall, within ninety days of the appointed day,
submit a declaration electronically in Form GST TRAN-1, duly signed, on the common portal specifying therein, separately, the amount of
input tax credit of eligible duties and taxes, as defined in Explanation 2 to Section 140, to which he is entitled under the provisions of the said
section:
xxx
139. Inspection, search
and seizure
(5)
(5) The officer seizing the goods, documents, books or things shall prepare an inventory of such goods or documents or books
or things containing, inter alia, description, quantity or unit, make, mark or model, where applicable, and get it signed by the person from
whom such goods or documents or books or things are seized.
81.
to
(k) signature or digital signature of the supplier or his authorised representative:
xxx
(1) A revised tax invoice referred to in Section 31 shall contain the following particulars, namely—
xxx
(j) signature or digital signature of the supplier or his authorised representative.
(1A) A credit or debit note referred to in Section 34 shall contain the following particulars, namely:—
xxx
(i) signature or digital signature of the supplier or his authorised representative.
Wherever the rule making authority has thought it necessary to
apply Rule 26, it has consciously used ‘prescribed the manner as
specified in Rule 26’. Such as under Rule 106 – ‘Form and manner of
appeal to the Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling’ requires
verification of the appeal and the relevant documents in case of an
application to be signed in the manner specified in Rule 26.
82.
The petitioners have referred to the Forms prescribed under
Chapter XVIII. The Forms i.e., GST DRC-01, DRC-01A, DRC-02,
DRC-05, DRC-07, DRC-07A, DRC-08, DRC-08A, DRC-09, DRC-10,
DRC-11, DRC-12, DRC-13, DRC-14, DRC-16, DRC-17, DRC-18,
DRC-19, DRC-21, DRC-22, DRC-23, DRC-25, contain, at the bottom,
the Signature, Name, Designation, whereas, Forms - GST DRC-01B,
DRC-01C, DRC-03, DRC-03A, DRC-06, DRC-20 and DRC-22A
contain Signature of Authorised Signatory. In GST DRC-15, at the
bottom, it has ‘Proper Officer/Specified Officer’.
83.
The procedure prescribed under Chapter XVIII i.e., issuance of
Notice or demand or summary thereof electronically on the common
portal does not specifically require the digital signature to be inscribed
on the document.
84.
Whether, on this background in the statutory rules under Chapter
XVIII, inscription of signature or digital signature as contained in the
Forms have to be read as mandatory in the absence of which the notice
or order would be invalid or nullity?
85.
The operation of the GST regime through common portal as
notified by the Government in terms of Section 146 for facilitating
registration, payment of tax, furnishing of returns, computation and
settlement of integrated tax, electronic way bill and for carrying out such
other functions and for such purposes as may be prescribed and its
functioning, is governed by the provisions of the Information
Technology Act, 2000 as have been referred to in detail in the foregoing
part of this discussion.
86.
It is trite to say that Forms do not override legislation. This has
been succinctly explained in Vasudev Ramchandra Shelat (supra) and
referred to in the judgment rendered by the learned Division Bench of
the Bombay High Court in Apar Industries (supra), rendered by Dr.
D.Y.Chandrachud, as His Lordships then was. It is apposite to extract
the exposition of law relied therein as under (paras 37 and 38):
Forms do not override legislation:
37. On behalf of the Revenue reliance was sought to be placed on
the provisions of the form appended to the Income Tax Rules, as it
obtained prior to the amendment to Section 234B. Schedule G which
deals with the statement of taxes, inter alia, provided for the computation
of interest under Section 234B after adjusting tax deducted/collected at
source and advance tax from the tax payable. Under the form, the tax
credit to be allowed under Section 115JAA was to be reckoned after
computing the interest liability under Section 234B. The form has since
been amended after the amendment brought about by the insertion of
substituted Explanation 1 to Section 234B. As amended the form now
requires credit under Section 115JAA to be taken into account prior to
computing the interest leviable under Section 234B.
38. A form provided by a rule making authority which is a
delegate of the legislature cannot override a statutory provision. Forms
are subservient to legislation. Forms are intended to facilitate the
implementation of legislation. Forms cannot supplant legislation. The
principle of law was stated in felicitous language in the judgment of the
Supreme Court in Life Insurance Corporation of India vs. Escorts
Limited37. The court observed as follows (page 609 of 59 Comp Cas):
“Surely, the form cannot control the Act, the Rules or the directions.
As one learned judge of the Madras High Court was fond of saying ‘it
is the dog that wags the tail and not the tail that wags the dog’. We may
add what this Court had occasion to say in Vasudev Ramchandra Shelat
vs. Pranlal Jayanand Thakar [1975] 45 Comp Cas 43, 54 (SC).
[1986] 59 Comp Cas 548 : (1986) 1 SCC 264
‘The subservience of substance of a transaction to some rigidly
prescribed form required to be meticulously observed, savours of
archaic and outmoded jurisprudence’.”
87.
The forms being the subservient to legislation cannot override the
statutory provision. They are intended to facilitate the implementation of
legislation and cannot supplant legislation. The subservience of
substance of a transaction to some rigidly prescribed form required to be
meticulously observed, reflects an archaic and outmoded jurisprudence,
as observed in Vasudev Ramchandra Shelat (supra).
88.
This being the legal position, the requirement of inscription of
signature in the prescribed forms cannot override or supplant the Rules,
under which they are prescribed.
89.
This, therefore, now takes us to the method and procedure
employed by the Goods and Services Tax Network (GSTN) through
which the notices or orders or summary thereof under Chapter XVIII are
served electronically through the common portal.
90.
Be it indicated herein that GSTN is officially authorized to
operate the common portal GST Network for effective functioning of
the GST regime. Its presence is not only proper but also necessary to
explain the functioning of the system as per the requirements of the IT
Act. However, it was not a party in any of the decided cases, as per the
stand of the GSTN officials, on the question of service of unsigned
documents, i.e., notices or demands or summary thereof under Chapter
XVIII of the CGST Rules. It is in course of the present proceedings,
recognizing the importance of role of GSTN, at the instance of the
Court, they have been made parties.
91.
GSTN has, for the first time, in such a matter undertaken a live
demonstration of the working of the common portal as to how orders,
demands, summary thereof etc., are electronically uploaded at the end of
the proper officer and received and responded through the common
portal by the taxpayer. The GSTN has explained the working of Digital
Signature Certificate in GST System (including technical aspect of
Digital Signature) vis-a-vis the issuance of Notices/Orders by the
officer/Proper officer, as extracted hereunder:
“3(A)
Working of Digital Signing Certificate in GST System vis-à-vis
compliance of the relevant provisions of the IT Act 2000:
I.
Onboarding of the officer to the GST System:
1. An officer is onboarded to the GST System, and provided access to required
statutory functions, based upon administrative directions from the respective tax
administration - State or CBIC through a mandatory streamlined and pre-defined
validation procedure.
2. After successful validation, the GST System creates a unique user ID for the
officer the user ID is combination of validated first and last name of the officer
and a 2-digit number. These credentials of the officer are validated against the
third-party government sources like CBDT before being accepted in the GST
System.
3. The officer is subsequently required to create a password of their choice on the
GST System.
II.
Composition of Digital Signature Certificate (DSC):
1.
A Digital Signature Certificate ('DSC' herein) is an electronic
certificate issued to an individual officer (referred as "subscriber" herein) by a
licensed Certifying Authority (referred as 'CA' herein) under the Information
Technology Act, 2000 and the rules framed thereunder. The Class-3 DSC is a
component of a Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) trust model and binds a standard
verified officer's identity (Name and PAN) to a cryptographic public key through
the CA's digital signature. This is in accordance with Section 3 of the IT Act.
2.
It is submitted that the above DSC is stored and used through a
hardware cryptographic token (commonly referred to as a USB "dongle"). The
token is a secure cryptographic device that holds:
(a)
The certificate (including the public key and identity attributes) and;
(b)
The corresponding private key in protected storage.
The USB dongle is protected by PIN known only to the holder of this USB
dongle.
It is important to mention that the private key is designed to be non-exportable
from the token. The token is unlocked for signing operations by entering a
PIN/Password known only to the DSC holder; without this PIN, the device will
not perform signature operations.
3. It is further submitted that the DSC includes the below details required for
verification by relying parties (GST System in this context):
a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
f.
subscriber's identity attributes (Name & PAN)
the subscriber's public key,
certificate serial number,
the issuing CA's identity,
the validity period (Not Before/Not After), and
the CA's digital signature over the certificate. The CA's signature
allows any verifier to validate that the certificate has not been altered
and was issued by that CA.
It is submitted that in the GST System context, the certificate is read from the
USB dongle using client-side service called "emSigner". This service is capable
of working with the USB dongle using standard cryptographic interfaces,
enumerates available certificates present in the token, and exposes certificate
metadata (including subject identity and PAN as encoded in the certificate) for
selection and validation. The GST System is able to detect the certificate and
perform the signature operation subsequently.
4.
It is again submitted that every such digitally signed notice/order is
created using the private key contained in the USB dongle and is verifiable using
the public key contained in the signed record. Further the DSC is uniquely
identifiable by its serial number and issuing Certifying Authority. Any signed
transaction can therefore be traced to the specific certificate used, and the
verification process can demonstrate whether the signature corresponds to the
certificate and whether that certificate was valid (i.e., within its validity period
and not revoked) at the relevant time.
5.
It is submitted that Certificate status (valid/revoked/
suspended/expired) is determined using the Certifying Authority's revocation
mechanisms. GST System allows a DSC to be used only if it has not been
revoked at the time of signing by the officer, thereby mitigating risks arising
from lost tokens, compromised keys, or administrative revocation.
III.
Public / Private Keys
1.
Each DSC is associated with a cryptographic key pair: a private key
and a public key that are mathematically linked. The private key is held securely
within the hardware token (USB dongle) and is intended to be used only by the
subscriber (officer). The public key is embedded within the DSC and is intended
to be shared for verification.
2.
Further, in a digital signature operation implemented in the GST
System, the officer's private key is used to sign and produce a digital signature
value, including the public key, for the notice / order JSON. The private key is
confined within the USB dongle. The public key from the digital signature value
is used to verify the signature and confirm:
(a) integrity-whether the signed content was altered after signing, and
(b) authenticity-whether the signature corresponds to the private key paired
with the public key in the certificate.
A detailed illustration containing/explaining the aforesaid process is as under:
IV.
Registration of DSC
1.
The officer is required to use a PAN based class-3 DSC to issue any
notice/order in the GST System. For such purpose, the officer is first required to
register a DSC that qualifies the below conditions:
(a)
Issued by one of the valid Certifying Authorities (CA)
(b)
Is based on the Name & PAN of the officer
(c)
Is of class-3 category
(d)
Is not revoked by the issuing authority at the time of registration
2.
Accordingly, the officer is required to insert their DSC device (USB
dongle) in their computer and enter PIN number known only to the
DSC holder.
3.
Post PIN validation the unique identity of the officer is validated with
the credentials of the officer that is embedded in the USB Dongle.
4.
The certificate is registered in the GST System against the officer's
identity for future use in issuing notice / orders.
5.
The GST System will only allow this registered certificate for this
officer to issue notice/orders.
V.
Login to the GST System - Authentication and Authorisation
As a pre-requisite for taking any action on the GST System, the officer/proper
officer has to undergo authentication & authorisation process as described
below:
(1)
The authentication requires the officer to log in to the GST System by
using either their physical class-3 PAN based digital signature (DSC), or
password, and OTP with their unique user ID.
(2)
After successful authentication of officer, the GST System also
validates if the officer has been designated to discharge the statutory duty. It is
submitted that it is only after successful 'authentication' and 'authorization', the
officer/proper officer is enabled to issue notices/orders. More so, the
officer/proper officer is required to complete the due diligence of the case and
complete the details in the notified 'Form' of the required notice or order on the
GST System. It is at the cost of repetition reiterated that no notice/ order can be
issued without affixing the officers DSC credentials. The system will not permit
such issuance of notice/order without DSC.
3(B).
1.
Process of Issuing Notices / Orders by the Proper Officers
It is submitted that the issuance of notices/ orders in the GST System by
the officer/ proper officer consists of two step processes:
1.
Creation of Notices/Orders in the System:
(i) Once the details are completed, the officer must affix their DSC
(used at the time of authentication) to finalise order issuance
process in the system.
(ii) The GST System creates an immutable digital record (JSON) of
this order, creates a 'hash' and maps a unique order identifier with
the DSC used by the officer. This serves as a non-repudiation
mechanism as well as audit record for future references. This step
completes the process of creating the notice or order in the
backend system.
2.
Serving to taxpayer:
(i) The system creates a multi-channel alert for the taxpayer in form
of email, SMS and a notification on the GST Common Portal.
(ii) The system generates PDF from the digital record (JSON) of
notice /order for reference of taxpayer, which the officer issued by
affixing their DSC, for consumption/readability of the taxpayer.
A detailed illustration containing/explaining the aforesaid process is as under:
It is noteworthy that the PDF is generated by the system by replicating the digital
notices/orders issued by the officer/proper officer as per the procedure detailed
above. The traceability of the officer's digital signature (DSC) is maintained by
the GST System. Furthermore, the system prints officer's name, designation and
jurisdiction automatically on the PDF based on the issuing officer details.
Further, it is also important to note that a notices/order can only become
available on the GST Portal if officer/proper officer issues the same by
adhering to the above-mentioned process. In other words, the availability of
the notice/order on the GST System can be treated as authentic under the GST
Law/rules made thereunder. Hence, it is stated that while all notices/orders
issued by the proper officers on the GST System are duly signed using DSC, the
PDF is generated by the system for readability of taxpayers.
A detailed illustration containing/explaining the aforesaid process is as under:
92.
It is stated that when a notice or order is issued by the proper
officer after affixing their DSC, the GST System generates a hash of
the immutable digital record (JSON) using a secure hash algorithm.
This mechanism ensures data integrity, tamper detection, and content
immutability. The digital signature is applied to this hash value using
the officer's private key, in accordance with the provisions of Section 3,
3-A and Section 13 of the IT Act.
93.
The GSTN states that GST System maintains comprehensive
audit records for all digitally signed notices and orders in their JSON
format. These records include the unique order or notice identifier, hash
value, DSC serial number, unique identifier of signing officer in the
GST System, and creation date timestamp. Audit records are immutable
and securely retained to support, traceability, accountability, and nonrepudiation. These electronic records constitute legally admissible
evidence in accordance with Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act,
1872 and Section 4 of the IT Act, and enable independent verification of
the authenticity and integrity of issued notices or orders by law
enforcement agencies.
94.
In the above background explained by the GSTN of working of
the GST system, it is to be seen whether as per requirements of the
CGST Act, Chapter XV–Demands and Recovery relating to adjudication
proceedings and the CGST Rules, 2017 under Chapter XVIII –
Demands and Recovery, the procedure followed by the GSTN and the
proper officers conform to the provisions of the IT Act. Whether the
show cause notices or adjudication orders under this Chapter are
electronically authenticated while uploading them on the common
portal?
95.
As per the elaborate discussion made in the previous paragraphs
on the provisions of the IT Act, Section 3 of Chapter II of the IT Act
provides for authentication of electronic records. As per Section 2(1)(p),
the digital signature is a means of authentication as specified in Section
3. Whereas Section 2(1)(ta) and (tb) defines electronic signature and
electronic
signature
certificate.
Electronic
signature
means
authentification of any electronic record by a subscriber by means of the
electronic technique specified in Second Schedule and includes digital
signature. The electronic signature certificate issued under Section 35
includes digital signature certificate. Private key is defined under
Section 2(1)(zc) as the key of a key pair used to create a digital signature
and public key is defined in Section 2(1)(zd) as the key of a key pair
used to verify a digital signature and listed in the digital signature
certificate. Section 3(2) provides that the authentication of electronic
record shall be effected by the use of asymmetric crypto system and
hash function. The process of ‘asymmetric cryptography’ commences
when the source using a ‘private key’ encrypts the message and
signature with a password and sends it to the recipient. The resulting
encryption is the digital signature or hash result, which is unique to each
document and thus, produces a new hash result or signature with each
transmission.
96.
As per working of the GSTN, an officer onboards the GST
system and is provided access to undertake statutory functions through a
mandatory streamline and pre-defined validation procedure. After
successful validation, the GST system creates a unique user ID for the
officer which is a combination of first and last name of the officer and a
2-digit number. These credentials of the officer are validated against the
third party government sources like CBDT before being accepted in the
GST system. The Digital Signature Certificate (DSC) is an electronic
certificate issued to an individual officer by a licensed Certifying
Authority under the IT Act, 2000 and the Rules framed thereunder.
97.
The DSC key used by the tax officers in the State of Telangana is
procured from Telangana Technology Services (TGTS). It is the nodal
agency for procurement of hardware, software, networking components
and other IT goods and services on behalf of various government
departments of the State. M/s.e-Mudra is the Certifying Authority and
service provider for Digital Signature Certificates. The tax officers login
into the Common Portal using their Digital Signature Certificate Key.
98.
After login into the common portal, the proper officer updates
necessary details like year, section, act wise tax amounts, due date to
reply, grounds etc., to generate reference number for the said show
cause notice/order. After uploading the attachment to the said show
cause notice/order, he uses the command ‘SIGN’ for their DSC key by
giving their private key, whereafter a message pops up in green colored
font that the DSC has been properly attached and the notice reference
number or order reference number has been generated. Notice or order
are mailed to taxpayer and also made available on his dashboard.
99.
The question is whether the electronic signature provides
trustworthy proof. The Certification Authority acts as a repository of
public keys and authenticates the relationship between a particular
public key and its supplier. As per GSTN, the Class-3 is a component of
a Public Key Infrastructure trust model and binds a standard verified
officer’s identity (Name and PAN) to a cryptographic public key
through the Certifying Authority’s digital signature. As per Section 3(2),
the authentication of electronic record shall be effected by the use of
asymmetric crypto system. The Certifying Authorities Rules provides
that to sign an electronic record or any other item of information, the
signer shall first apply the hash function in the signer’s software, the
hash function shall compute a hash result of standard length which is
unique for all practical purposes to the electronic record. The signer’s
software transforms the hash result into a digital signature using signer’s
private key and the resulting digital signature shall be unique to both
electronic record and private key used to create it. The digital signature
shall be attached to its electronic record and stored or transmitted with
its electronic record. This process shows that the first step in creating a
digital signature is to create a mathematical summary of the document to
be signed and known as ‘hash function’, which is an algorithm that
creates an ic representation of the original message in the form of a
standard length hash value. The hash value is much smaller than the
original message, but is unique to that message. The next step in
creating a digital signature requires the signer of the message, to
transform the message’s unique hash value and original electronic
message into, an electronic value by using a private key. The resulting
electronic value is unique to the signer, because it is created as a
combination of the original message’s unique hash value and the
signer’s unique private key. Thus, a digital signature can be summarized
as the electronically signed hash value of the signer’s message created
by the signer’s private key and electronically attached to the message.
Once the message is electronically signed by the signer, it is transmitted
to the recipient along with the signer’s public key.
100.
The process for authentication is prescribed under Rule 5 of the
Certifying Authorities Rules, 2000. The first step in verifying a digital
signature requires the recipient to apply to the received message, the
same hash function used to create the original message’s hash value. If
the two hash values match identically, then message authentication is
accomplished and the recipient is assured that the message has not been
altered from its original form. The second step in verifying a digital
signature requires the recipient of the message to determine whether the
original message was digitally signed by the signer’s private key. The
recipient will know that the original message was signed by the signer’s
private key because the signer’s public key, which was transmitted to
the recipient along with the original message, will only verify a digital
signature created by the signer’s private key. Therefore, the digital
signature is considered valid only if both the hash function and private
key are verified by the recipient.
101.
Certifying Authorities provide the information and surety that the
person signing with the private key is he who purports to be and that no
one other than the holder of the private key has written the message. It
ensures integrity of the contents of the sender’s message at the recipient
end just as they were sent. By using the private and public keys, it is
assured that the message has not been changed or altered.
Confidentiality gives surety that only the sender and receiver can
understand the message. Confidentiality can only be provided with
‘electronic signatures’ and not with ‘digital signatures’. Encryption
technology allows electronic signatures to provide this service.
102.
The Digital Signature Certificate is stored and used through a
hardware cryptographic token, commonly referred to as a USB dongle,
which holds (a) the certificate (including the public key and identity
attributes) and (b) the corresponding private key in protected storage.
The USB dongle is protected by PIN known only to the holder of the
USB dongle. The private key is designed to be non-exportable from the
token. The token is unlocked for signing operations by entering a
PIN/Password known only to the DSC holder, without this PIN, the
device will not perform signature operations. The DSC includes the
details required for verification by relying parties – (a) subscriber’s
identity attributes (Name & PAN), (b) the subscriber’s public key,
(c) certificate serial number, (d) the issuing Certifying Authority’s
identity, (e) the validity period and (f) the CA’s digital signature over
the certificate.
103.
Every such digitally signed notice/order is created using the
private key contained in the USB dongle and is verifiable using the
public key contained in the signed record. The DSC is uniquely
identifiable by its serial number and issuing Certifying Authority. Any
signed transaction can therefore be traced to the specific certificate used.
The verification process can demonstrate whether the signature
corresponds to the certificate and whether that certificate was valid at
the relevant time. The GST system allows a DSC to be used only if it
has not been revoked at the time of signing by the officer. Each and
every DSC is associated with a cryptographic key pair: a private key and
a public key that are mathematically linked. The private key is held
securely within the hardware token (USB dongle) and is intended to be
used only by the subscriber or proper officer. The public key is
embedded within the DSC and is intended to be shared for verification.
104.
In the working of GST system, as noted above, the officer is
required to use a PAN based Class-3 DSC to issue any notice/order
through the common portal by first registering the DSC that qualifies the
conditions that it is issued by a valid certificate, based on the Name and
PAN of the officer, is of class-3 category and has not been revoked by
the issuing authority at the time of registration. After insertion of the
DSC device (USB dongle) in their computer and entering PIN number
known only to the DSC holder, the identity of the officer is validated.
The GST system allows this registered certificate for this officer to issue
notice/order. After successful authentification of officer, the GST
system validates if the officer has been designated to discharge the
statutory duty. Only after successful authentification and authorization,
the proper officer is enabled to issue notices/orders and complete the
details in the notified ‘form’ of the required notice or order on the GST
system. As such, without affixing the DSC credentials of the officers as
a pre-requisite for log in to the GST system, no notice or order can be
issued. Once the details are completed, the officer affixes his DSC used
at the time of authentification to finalise order issuance process in the
system. The GST system creates an immutable digital record (JSON) of
this order, creates a ‘hash’ and maps a unique order identifier with the
DSC used by the officer. This serves as a non-repudiation mechanism as
well as audit record for further references. This step completes the
process of creating the notice or order in the backend system.
105.
The Second Schedule under Sl. No.1 provides for procedure for
electronic signature or electronic authentification technique, as referred
to above. It provides that e-authentification using Aadhaar and other eKYC services. Sl. No.2 provides for e-authentication technique. It is a
procedure for creating and accessing subscriber’s signature key
facilitated by trusted third party, i.e., the certifying authority. The
certifying authority shall issue Digital Signature Certificate based on
verification of the credentials of Digital Signature Certificate applicant
as per the provisions of the IT Act and the Rules made thereunder. The
manner and requirement for authentification and storage of keys shall be
as issued by the Controller from time to time under e-authentification
guidelines, so should be the security procedure for creating the
subscriber’s key pair. The manner under clause (g) at Sl.No.1, in which
information is authenticated by means of digital signature should
comply with the manner and standards specified in Rules 3 to 12 of the
Digital Signature (End Entity) Rules, 2015 in so far as they relate to the
creation, storage and verification of digital signature. It is, therefore,
proper to refer to the relevant rules under the Digital Signature (End
Entity) Rules, 2015.
106.
Rule 3 provides for the manner of authentication of information
by means of digital signature, which shall (a) be created and verified by
cryptography which concerns with transforming electronic record into
seemingly unintelligible forms; (b) use Public Key Cryptography, which
employs an algorithm using two different but mathematical related keys;
one key (called the private key) for creating a digital signature and
another key (called the public key) for verifying a digital signature;
(c) use an hash function for creating and verifying a digital signature
which required to make digital signature generation and verification
efficient.
107.
As per Rule 4, the signatory shall, while signing an electronic
record or any other item of information, first apply an hash function in
the signatory’s hardware or software. The hash function shall produce a
hash result. The signatory’s hardware or software shall then transform
the hash result into a digital signature using signatory’s private key and
signature algorithm. The contextual information like date and time shall
be then made part of the digital signature. Rule 5 provides for
verification mechanism for verification of digital signature. Rule 6
provides for verification of digital signature certificate. Rule 7 provides
for digital signature standards applicable for different activities
associated with signature functions, which include cryptographic hash
function, encryption and digital signature etc. The technique and manner
of authentification employed by the GSTN for onboarding of a proper
officer by use of the digital signature certificate as explained in their
additional counter affidavit and discussed above and examined in the
light of the above provisions conform to the manner and the technique
provided under the Second Schedule of the IT Act and the Digital
Signature (End Entity) Rules, 2015.
108.
The authentification is by creation of a hash value through a
cryptographic system and use of digital signature certificate by the
certifying authority. The manner of authentification of information is in
accordance with Rules 3 and 4 of the End Entity Rules as explained
above.
The
contention
of
the
petitioner
that
the
electronic
authentification of the notices/orders does not conform to the technique
and procedure prescribed under the Second Schedule of the IT Act and
the End Entity Rules, therefore, does not merit acceptance.
109.
Once the notice or order is created in the system, it is served to
the taxpayer through a multi-channel alert in the form of email, SMS
and a notification on the GST Common Portal. At this stage, the system
generates PDF (Protected Document Format) from the digital record
(JSON) of notice/order for reference of taxpayer for consumption/
readability of the taxpayer. The issue raised herein is on the absence of
visible digital signature on the PDF on such notice or order or summary
of the notice or order issued in the prescribed Forms under Chapter
XVIII of the CGST Rules. The proper officer has to fulfil the conditions
prescribed under Section 3A(1) of the IT Act for an electronic
authentification technique to be at par with authentification effected
through a digital signature. The proper officer onboards the GST system
after validation of its authenticity by using the DSC and entering the
PIN/password known only to the DSC holder. Thereafter only, the
officer is allowed to discharge the statutory duty and issue notices/
orders.
110.
During the course of the submissions and based upon certain
clarification dated 21.03.2024, digital signature on the pdf document
available at the recipient end was being introduced to ensure taxpayer
confidence. However, because of software issues in the State Tax
Department, it appears that it could not be effectively implemented. It
appears the GSTN has been working on this aspect of attending to the
taxpayer’s grievance in order to increase taxpayer’s confidence in the
working of the system. As held hereinabove, mere absence of a physical
signature or digital signature on the show cause notices or orders
covered under Chapter XVIII of the CGST Rules would not render it
invalid or nullity in the eye of law, as they are electronically
authenticated in the manner and procedure prescribed under the IT Act
and the Rules made thereunder and made available through the common
portal.
111.
During the course of the reply submissions, learned counsel for
the petitioner, Sri Karan Talwar had also adverted to an Audit report,
where the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India had
commented upon the functioning of the common portal and on the issue
of digitally signed document. However, this Court has categorically held
hereinabove that show cause notices or orders under Chapter XVIII of
the CGST Rules, being electronically authenticated and made available
on the common portal are in consonance with the provisions of the IT
Act and the Rules. Therefore, the reliance placed on the Audit Report,
would not denude the validity of such notices or orders properly
authenticated in an electronic manner by the proper officers and
uploaded on the common portal.
112.
It is evident that the access to the common portal is permissible
only to a proper officer having a DSC issued by the License Certifying
Authority and protected by a PIN known only to the holder of the USB
dongle. Similarly, a taxpayer who is registered under the CGST Act and
is provided a user name and id can only access the system. The system is
not an open platform available to be used by anyone else other than the
proper officer or subscriber in whose name the electronic signature
certificate is issued, at one end and the taxpayer or the recipient at the
other end.
113.
The taxpayer registered under the CGST Act can only access the
system through his user ID and password. Therefore, the authenticity of
the electronic record transmitted to the taxpayer through its common
portal cannot be doubted.
114.
The verification of digital signature by the recipient as Rule 5 of
the Certifying Authorities Rules by computing a new hash result of the
original electronic record by means of the hash function used to create a
digital signature by using the public key is not required in the working
of the common portal under the GST system, where access is
permissible only to a proper officer and to a registered taxpayer, who is
provided a user id to access the system. The verification of digital
signature in terms of Rule 5 of the Certifying Authorities Rules is
intended to apply in cases such communication is made on open
platform through electronic means and not in a case of this secure
platform, such as common portal by the GSTN for working of the GST
system in terms of the provisions of the Act and the Rules framed
thereunder. The common portal is a digital public infrastructure
maintained by the GSTN following all the security protocols. It is not a
business to business digital infrastructure. Therefore, the procedure for
verification at the recipient end as contended by the petitioners is not
required as only a registered taxpayer can access through its user id and
password.
115.
This electronic record is documentary evidence under Section 3
of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 or BSA 2023. A presumption is
attached to an electronic record or an electronic signature under Section
86 of the BSA, 2023 or Section 85B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. It
provides that in any proceeding involving a secure electronic record, the
Court shall presume unless contrary is proved that the secure electronic
record has not been altered since the specific point of time to which the
secure status relates. Similarly with the secure electronic signature, the
Court shall presume unless the contrary is proved that the secure
electronic signature is affixed by subscriber with the intention of signing
or approving the electronic record. As per Section 87/85C of the
BSA/Evidence Act, the court shall presume unless contrary is proved
that the information listed in an Electronic Signature Certificate is
correct. Further Section 90/88A of the aforesaid Acts accords
recognition to electronic messages. It provides that the Court may
presume that an electronic message forwarded by the originator through
an electronic mail server to the addressee to whom the message purports
to be addressed corresponds with the message as fed into his computer
for transmission, but the Court shall not make any presumption as to the
person by whom such message was sent. For the purposes of this
section, the expressions ‘addressee’ and ‘originator’ shall have the same
meanings respectively assigned to them in clause (b) and (za) of subsection (1) of Section 2 of the IT Act, 2000. Section 119 of the BSA/
Section 114 of Evidence Act, provides that the Court may presume the
judicial and official acts have been regularly performed.
116.
Therefore, in the light of the working of the GST system as
explained above in the light of the provisions of the IT Act, 2000 and the
manner of electronic authentication of notices/orders issued under
Chapter XVIII of the CGST Rules do lead to the irresistible conclusion
that the contention of the petitioners that these notices/orders are not
digitally signed does not merit acceptance. Presence of digital signatures
is not a requirement on the documents covered under Chapter XVIII of
the CGST Rules. The State has taken a stand that in none of the
pleadings of the writ petitions, the petitioners have made any allegation
that proper officer has not issued the show cause notice/orders.
Therefore, in the absence of pleadings such a plea cannot be entertained
in the eye of law. The petitioners’ plea that ‘signature’ in the forms
prescribed under Chapter XVIII of the Rules is a mandatory requirement
is not the correct understanding of the legal position.
117.
Forms are subservient to the rules and cannot supplant the rules.
The ratio rendered in Vasudev Ramchandra Shelat (supra), followed
by the Bombay High Court in Apar Industries (supra), has been
referred to in the foregoing part of this judgment.
118.
The petitioners have failed to rebut the presumption attached to
the electronic record created in discharge of official function by any
pleading or proof to that effect. The case of the petitioners based upon
the contention that the PDF format does not contain the visible digital
signature of the proper officer is untenable in law. These notices/orders
are served upon the taxpayer by way of electronic authentication
through the Common Portal. The admission of the State Tax Authorities
in some cases that the notices/orders did not bear the digital signature
may be on account of the ignorance of the working of the GST system.
Wherever the legislature and the rule making authority have deemed it
proper for issuance of any such document or order in any other form, the
same has been duly prescribed under different Chapters. A tabular chart
of the Rules under different chapters and the documents/notices/orders
to be issued thereunder have been furnished hereinbefore which goes to
show as to how the rule making authority has consciously provided for
different modes of authentification under different Chapters of the
Rules. Therefore, when Chapter XVIII of the CGST Rules provides for
issuance of notices/orders by electronic authentification through the
Common Portal, the requirement of a visible digital signature cannot be
read or imported into it. They cannot be treated as invalid or nullity in
the eye of law as they do not contain a digital signature. In none of the
earlier proceedings in the decided cases, the working of the GST system
was explained and demonstrated as GSTN was not a party. For a proper
understanding of the working of the GST system the presence of GSTN
was therefore felt absolutely necessary. The elaborate working of the
GST system as explained above was not placed before the learned
Division Benches which rendered the decisions earlier such as Silver
Oak Villas LLP (supra), Sahithi Marketers (supra) and Bigleap
(supra). The notices/orders issued under Chapter XVIII of the CGST
Rules are required to be electronically authenticated in the manner
prescribed. Absence of a digital signature on the pdf version in the
Forms such as DRC-01, DRC-01A, DRC 07 as contended by the
petitioners would not render them invalid or nullity in the eye of law.
Therefore, the contention of the petitioners that DRC-01 and DRC-07
not being mere summaries must also be signed cannot be accepted, if
they are electronically authenticated by the proper officer after
onboarding the system by using digital signature certificate issued by the
certifying authority.
119.
Under the scheme of the CGST Act, the common portal is a
designated computer resource for both department as well as taxable
person. Section 2(1)(ze) defines secure system, which means computer
hardware, software and procedure that (a) are reasonably secure from
unauthorized access and misuse; (b) provide a reasonable level or
reliability and correct operation; (c) reasonably suited to performing the
intended functions and (d) adhere to generally accepted security
procedures. The common portal notified under Section 146 of the CGST
Act fulfils all these ingredients and can be termed as a secure system
which is secure from unauthorized access and misuse and provides
reasonable level of reliability and correct operation and are performing
the intended functions of the GST system. GSTN has in its affidavit also
assured that it adheres to the accepted security procedures. The
Information Technology (Security Procedure) Rules, 2004 provides for
the mechanism by which electronic record shall be deemed to be a
secure electronic record for the purposes of the Act if it has been
authenticated by means of a secure digital signature. The manner and
procedure for creation of the secure electronic record by use of a secure
digital signature as shown by the GSTN through the live demonstration
and the averments made in their counter affidavits appear to be in
conformity with Security Procedure Rules, 2004.
120.
The taxable person is given a unique login ID and password to
enable them to have access to the portal. No person other than the
taxable person, in whose name GST registration has been granted, can
access the common portal. It is the exclusive platform for functioning of
the GST regime operated by the GST Network notified by the Central
Government on the recommendation of the GST Council.
On service of Show Cause Notice/order:
121.
The petitioners have not assailed the provisions of Section 169 of
the CGST Act which provides for service of notice in certain
circumstances. Section 169 provides for service of decision, order,
summons, notice or other communication under the Act or the Rules
thereunder by anyone method prescribed under sub-clauses (a) to (f) of
sub-section (1) thereof, which are to be disjunctively read in view of the
expression ‘or’ used after each of these clauses. Under Section
169(1)(d), uploading of the show cause notice or order under Chapter
XVIII of the CGST Rules on the common portal, amounts to service of
notice or order. The date on which the order is uploaded in the common
portal is the date the communication is received in terms of Section
13(2)(i) of the IT Act. In terms of Section 13 of the IT Act, if the
addressee, i.e., the taxable person had designated a computer resource
for the purpose of receiving electronic records i.e., common portal,
receipt occurs at the time when the electronic record enters the
designated computer resource. It is not shown by the petitioners that any
other computer resource is designated for service of the show cause
notice/order other than the Common Portal. In case, the electronic
record is sent to a computer resource other than the designated computer
resource, receipt occurs when the electronic record is retrieved by the
addressee. The contention of the petitioners that the term ‘designated’
used in Section 13(2) of the IT Act, as compared to ‘information system’
used in Article 15(2) of the UNICTRAL Model Law on Electronic
Commerce, has the same meaning, does not merit acceptance. In support
of this submission, the petitioners have referred to Section 144B of the
Income Tax Act to contend that no such parallel provisions exist in the
CGST Act or the CGST Rules. Therefore, the period of limitation would
commence only when the notices/orders were actually retrieved from the
GST Portal as opposed to the date of upload. Such an argument does not
fit in the statutory scheme and the architecture created under the CGST
Act for service of notice or order through the common portal by means
of electronic authentication and on being made available on the common
portal. The legislature has consciously provided for the mode and
manner of service of notice or order under the GST regime, which
cannot be questioned by drawing analogy from the different statutory
mechanism provided under other Act such as under Section 144B of the
Income Tax Act or Section 153 of the Customs Act. In our opinion, the
decision of the Allahabad High Court in M/s.Bambino Agro Industries
(supra) that making of a document available on common portal does not
amount to tendering of the document is not the correction interpretation
of the statutory regime for service of notice in terms of Section
169(1)(d) of the CGST Act read with the provisions of Section 13(2) of
the IT Act. The Legislature has consciously used the word ‘service
under sub-section (1)(d) by making such notices/orders available on the
common portal, which is distinct from the expression ‘tendering’ used in
the same sub-section (1)(a) or sub-section (2). Once it has been held that
the show cause notice or order has been electronically authenticated and
uploaded on the common portal it cannot be treated as invalid or nullity
in the eye of law. Such assessment, re-assessment or adjudication
proceedings cannot be invalidated or deemed to be invalid by reason of
the alleged defect or omission of the visible digital signature on the
Forms prescribed. They, in substance, would be in conformity with the
intent, purpose and requirement of CGST Act as provided under Section
160 of the CGST Act. Moreover, if such notice or communication has
been acted upon by the person to whom it is issued or has not been
called in question or the earlier proceedings, which have commenced
and finalized pursuant thereto, it is not open for the taxable person or the
petitioners to question the service of such notice or order of
communication in terms of Section 160(2) of the CGST Act. It has been
indicated in the foregoing paragraphs that under Chapter XVIII,
Demands and Recovery of the CGST Rules, the Legislature has made
conscious provision for service of notice or order through post where the
proper officer has to physically sign it, such as under Rules 145, 146,
147, 151 to 156 of the CGST Rules. The reference to Rule 26 under
Chapter III, Registration, to contend that such notice, certificate or order
issued under Chapter XVIII, Demands and Recovery is required to be
issued
electronically
through
digital
signature
certificate
is
misconceived. The mode of authentication under Rule 26(3) refers to
issuance of notice, summons or order under the provisions of that
Chapter III, i.e., Registration, which is distinct and different from the
Rules prescribed under Chapter XVIII, Demands and Recovery, which
require issuance of notice or order by means of electronic authentication
through the common portal. There has been divergence of views on the
applicability of Rule 26(3) of the CGST Rules on the notice or order
issued under Chapter XVIII relating to demands and recovery between
the learned Division Benches of this Court in M/s.Silver Oak Villas
LLP (supra) and M/s.Bigleap Technologies (supra) (para 28). Such
divergence of views by co-equal Benches of this Court, therefore,
necessitated an authoritative pronouncement by a Larger Bench of this
Court. The learned Division Bench, therefore, referred the matter to
Larger Bench instead of taking any contrary view on the subject matter.
122.
The working of the GST regime and the manner of issuance in
service of notices or orders, in particular under Chapter XVIII, Demands
and Recovery, has been extensively demonstrated by the GSTN during
the proceedings of these cases. The live demonstration made by the
GSTN indicating the step by step method of onboarding of the officer to
the GST system through digital signature certificate and use of public
and private keys for authentication and authorization while login to the
GST system for issuance of notices or orders by the proper officer and
service to taxable person through multi-channel alert in the form of
email, SMS and a notification on the GST common portal leave no room
of doubt that not only does the mechanism ensure data integrity, tamper
detection and content immutability by use of asymmetric cryptographic
method by creation of hash value but also shows that the notices or
orders could not be uploaded on the common portal by any unauthorized
person other than the proper officer. There is a presumption of regularity
of such official acts and creation of electronic records attached under the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872 and the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023.
These electronic records constitute legally admissible evidence in terms
of Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act and Section 4 of the IT Act
and enable independent verification of the authenticity and integrity of
issuance of notices or orders by the proper officers. The petitioners have
failed to rebut the presumption. Only in a case where a demonstrable
abuse of the mechanism is made out by the aggrieved taxable person,
can the regularity of such proceedings be questioned and examined by
the court of law. Mere unsubstantiated allegation, therefore, could not
displace the rebuttable presumption attached to such official acts.
123.
The petitioners have also taken a plea that there is no delay in
approaching the court. The decision in Glaxo Smith Kline Consumer
Health Care Limited (supra) is not a bar to the relief prayed for. This
submission is based upon the contention that the impugned notice and
order were uploaded on the GST portal and no other mode of service
was adopted. If the show cause notices or orders are unsigned, they are
non est in the eye of law and the entire proceedings is without
jurisdiction. Even in cases where the appellate authority has rejected the
appeal on grounds of delay, the principle of merger would not apply in
such circumstances. However, as held hereinabove, the service of notice
or order by way of electronic authentification of the proper officer
through the common portal meets the requirement of the provisions of
the CGST Act in such adjudication proceedings, read with the Rules
under Chapter XVIII ‘Demands and Recovery’. The notices or orders
cannot be held to be invalid or nullity in the eye of law. Therefore the
bar of limitation for approaching the writ court as held in the case of
Glaxo Smith Kline Consumer Health Care Limited (supra) would be
attracted. The contention of the petitioners does not merit acceptance.
124.
Revenue has also contended that the purpose of Rule 142(1A) of
the CGST Rules is to put the taxpayer to notice so that he can pay the
tax upon upon show cause notice being issued. The learned Division
Bench of this Court in M/s.Goldstone Infra (supra) has held that the
decision rendered by the Andhra Pradesh High Court in M/s.New
Morning Star Travels (supra) has been rendered sub silentio as it has
not taken into consider the ‘prejudice’ test i.e., as to whether the nonissuance of such intimation led to any prejudice in the facts and
circumstances of the case. Since this issue involves alleged violation of
principles of natural justice, the validity of such order has to be decided
on the touchstone of ‘prejudice’. The unamended Rule 142(1A) of the
CGST Rules used the expression ‘shall’ which was amended with effect
from 15.10.2020 with the word ‘may’. The expression ‘shall’ under the
unamended provision did not refer to any mandatory consequences
which would arise in the case of non-service of intimation in DRC-01A
prior to the issuance of the show cause notice. In the absence of such
consequences arising of non-compliance thereof, each case has to be
decided on the test of ‘prejudice’ caused to the taxpayer on non-service
of the intimation in Form GST DRC-01A. Therefore, the interpretation
on the Rule 142(1A), before and after amendment, having been rendered
by the learned Division Bench holding the field, the said contention does
not require to be answered in the present reference.
125.
The petitioners have additionally raised some other grounds in
some of the writ petitions inter alia (i) that the impugned order does not
quote the Document Identification Number (DIN) and as such, cannot be
relied upon; and (ii) that the circulars dated 05.11.2019 and 23.12.2019
issued by CBIC requiring DIN on such documents were adopted by the
Government of Telangana as per Circular dated 04.11.2019. The
circulars are binding on the Revenue as per Section 168 of the CGST
Act. It is also stated that CBIC has issued a circular on 09.06.2025,
wherein it has been stated that wherever RFN is shown on the document
available on the common portal, DIN is not required. The said circular
operates prospectively. Therefore, the orders issued prior thereto ought
to have reflected the DIN otherwise it cannot be relied upon. It is no
doubt true that the impugned orders should quote the DIN or the RFN in
the absence of which it cannot be relied upon. The circular issued by the
CBIC and adopted by the Government of Telangana in this regard are
binding on the Revenue as per Section 168 of the CGST Act. Therefore,
such impugned orders which do not quote the DIN number or RFN
number are not fit to be relied upon. It is necessary to extract the
Circular as under:
Circular No.249/06/2025-GST
F. No. GST/INV/DIN-Utility/2022-23
Government of India
Ministry of Finance
Department of Revenue
(Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs)
New Delhi, Dated 09-06-2025.
Subject: Generation and quoting of Document Identification
Number (DIN) Number (DIN) on any communication issued by the
officers of the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC)
to tax payers and other concerned persons – reg.
Attention is invited to Board's Circular No. 122/41/2019- GST dated
05thNovember 2019 and 128/47/2019-GST dated 23.12.2019, which were issued
for implementation of decision regarding Generation and Quoting of Document
Identification Number (DIN), initially on specified documents and subsequently
expanded to all communications (including e-mails) sent to taxpayers and other
concerned persons by any office of CBIC. This was done with a view to leverage
technology for greater accountability and transparency in communications with
the trade/ taxpayers/ other concerned persons.
2.
It has been brought to the notice of the Board that the documents and
summary generated through the common portal of GST always bear a Reference
No. (RFN), which is verifiable through the portal (at https://
services.gst.gov.in/services/verifyRfn). On verification, the portal provides
details of the document such as Date of RFN generation, Date of issuing the
Document, Module, Type of Communication and Name of the Office issuing the
Document.
3.
Reference, in this regard, is also invited to Section 169(1)(d) of the CGST
Act, 2017, which provides that any decision, order, summons, notice or other
communication shall be served by making it available on the common portal.
Further vide Instruction No. 4/2023-ST dated 23.11.2023, CBIC emphasised
on strict compliance of rule 142 of CGST Rules and directed to ensure that
summary of Show Cause Notices in Form GST DRC-01 and summary of
the Order-in-Original in Form GST DRC-07 should be served electronically on
common portal / uploaded electronically on the common portal.
4.
In light of the above, quoting DIN on such communications generated
through the common portal of GST, which already bear RFN, results into two
different electronically generated verifiable unique numbers namely RFN & DIN
on the same communication, which renders quoting of DIN on such
communication unnecessarily.
5.
It is therefore clarified that for communications via common portal (in
compliance with Section 169 of the CGST Act, 2017) having verifiable
Reference Number (RFN), quoting of Document Identification Number (DIN) is
not required and such communication bearing RFN is to be treated as a valid
communication.
6.
To the above extent, Circular No.122/41/2019-GST dated 05thNovember
2019 and 128/47/2019-GST dated 23.12.2019 issued by the Board,
stands modified.
Dr. Abhishek Chandra Gupta
Date: 09-06-2025
E mail - gstinv-cbic@gov.in
To,
All Pr. Chief Commissioners/Chief Commissioners, CGST Zones/ CGST &
Customs Zones,
All Principal Directors General/Directors General under CBIC.
DDM for incorporating appropriate information/link for taxpayers for
verification of documents containing RFN, at DIN verification portal.
The webmaster, CBIC for uploading on official website.
126.
The contention of the petitioners that the circular dated
09.06.2025 operates prospectively only is not made out from a reading
of the said circular. It only says that wherever RFN is shown on the
document available on the common portal, DIN is not required. The
document should reflect either the DIN number or RFN number. In the
absence of either of them, the order would not be a valid order in the eye
of law.
127.
RFN is a valid authentification mechanism for communications
on or through the portal as clarified by the GSTN through the Circular
dated 09.06.2025. RFN is a distinct number to a document which can be
duly verified by the taxpayer through the procedure prescribed on the
common portal. This has been adequately shown in the live
demonstration performed by GSTN during the proceedings of these
cases.
128.
In the individual writ petitions, either RFN or DIN is quoted in
show cause notice, summary of the show cause notice, attachment to the
show cause notice, order, summary of the order or the attachment to
order. Therefore, the impugned orders in the respective writ petitions
cannot be held to be invalid on that ground.
129.
In W.P.No.22326 of 2025 and other connected cases, learned
counsel Sri P.Venkat Prasad has taken a plea that in the counter affidavit
filed earlier in W.P.No.21072 of 2024 decided on 22.04.2024 by the
Commissioner of Central Taxes and Customs, Central Excise & Service
Tax, Medchal GST Commissionerate, Hyderabad, whereas the counter
affidavit in W.P.No.10295 of 2025 was filed by the Deputy
Commissioner of Central Taxes and Customs, Central Excise & Service
Tax, Medchal GST Commissionerate, Hyderabad. The averments
advanced by the GSTN in its counter affidavit have inconsistencies with
the earlier statements made in its prior counter affidavit. Such
contradictory pleadings materially impair the credibility of the
respondents’ case and render the contentions raised by the GSTN now
inherently unreliable.
130.
This contention of the petitioner is rebutted by learned counsel
for the GSTN Sri Dominic Fernandes by submitting that the said
affidavit was not filed by the GSTN, but by their backend office., i.e.
Automation of Central Excise and Service Tax (ACES). As such, the
petitioners cannot draw any mileage by trying to point out a
contradiction in the stand filed in the affidavit in Water Tech
Engineers (supra) with the stand of GSTN filed in the present
proceedings. In this regard, it is pertinent to note that in Water Tech
Engineers (supra), the GSTN was not a party, whereas in the present
batch of writ petitions, GSTN has been impleaded as a party by order of
this Court. It has, for the first time, appeared in such proceedings before
this Court and filed counter affidavit. Therefore, the contention of the
petitioners cannot be accepted and used to deny the GSTN to take an
informed stand on the working of the GST system on the issues involved
in these cases.
131.
The petitioners have also questioned the validity of invocation of
jurisdiction under Section 73 of the CGST Act when proceedings under
Section 61 had already been initiated and explanation had also been
provided
by
the
petitioners
by
relying
upon
the
case
of
Goverdhandham Estate Private Limited (supra). Since this reference
is on the question of unsigned document i.e., notices or orders under
Chapter XVIII of the CGST Rules, this Court is of the considered view
that there is no necessity to render any opinion on the issue by this
Bench. It is left open for the petitioners to raise it in an appropriate
proceeding before the appropriate forum/court of law.
132.
Another contention has been raised by the petitioner that the
procedure prescribed under Section 65 of the CGST Act has not been
followed before initiating proceedings under Section 73 or 74 of the
CGST Act. He relies on Adani Power Limited (supra) (paras 23 to 25).
He has also placed reliance on circular dated 09.02.2018 issued by CBIC
which requires a designated officer only to initiate proceedings above
the value of Rs.2.00 crores, since the Government of Telangana has
followed the circular of CBIC by its circular dated 04.11.2019. The
impugned proceedings will be hit by lack of jurisdiction on the part of
the proper officer.
133.
This Court is of the considered view that the plea of non-
compliance of the procedure prescribed under Section 65 of the CGST
Act is open to be agitated in an appropriate proceeding before the
appropriate forum as this reference is confined to answer on the issue of
unsigned documents.
134.
An argument has also been raised by Sri K.P.Amarnath Reddy,
learned counsel appearing in W.P.No.19120 of 2025, that the Assistant
Commissioner, respondent No.1 has accepted issuance of multiple
notices without application of mind simply upon forwarding of the email
by the Commercial Taxes Commissioner and Joint Commissioner and
further to the Assistant Commissioner on the format prepared by the
Indian Institute of Technology, Madras. It is the statement of the
respondent No.1, Assistant Commissioner which creates doubt as to
manner and method employed in uploading such notices within a short
time without application of mind. In our view, contention on possible
misuse of the powers of the proper officers is open to be raised before
the appropriate forum/court where it can be examined on facts. It,
therefore, is not required to be dealt with in the present reference.
135.
Ms. Y.Siri Reddy, learned counsel for the petitioner in
W.P.No.20397 of 2025 has taken a plea that the show cause notice was
not properly served as it was uploaded on the Additional Notices tab
before the clarification Note on the GST portal. She has relied upon the
decision of M/s.Ramanattu Motor Corporation (supra) where such
order uploaded in the Additional Notices tab was set aside and the
matter was remanded. The respondent State has in its reply stated that
the GST Portal has clarified it in the 16.01.2024 by appending a ‘Note’
under the heading ‘Additional Notices’ in the GST Portal, which is as
under:
“Note:
1. Following Notices/Orders issued by tax authorities are available
under “Notices and Orders”.
Notices/Orders/Intimations pertaining to registration including
new registration, amendment, cancellation, revocation and other
communications.
Notices issued by System to return defaulters in Form GSTR3A.
Notices pertaining to Return module comprising GST DRC-01B
and GST DRC-01C.
Summary of assessment orders issued in Form GST DRC-07
where notices and other proceedings were held offline.
2.
Following Notices/Orders issued by tax authorities are available
under “Additional Notices and Orders”.
Notices/Orders pertaining modules Advance Ruling, Appeal,
Assessment/Adjudication, Audit, Enforcement, Prosecution and
Compounding, Recovery, LUT etc.
3. Notices/Orders pertaining to Refund module will be shown under
case details page of respective ARN of refund. Please navigate to
‘Services User Services My application’ and select ARN under
Application Type as ‘REFUNDS’.”
136.
Relying upon the same judgment of Ramanattu Motor
Corporation (supra), learned counsel for the State has submitted that
uploading of notices and orders in Additional Notices tab of GST Portal
is valid service in view of the Note appended to the GST Portal. Further,
the moment the notices and orders are uploaded in the GST Portal,
automatically the same are also sent to the registered email of the
concerned assessee/dealer. As such, their contention that the
assessee/dealer could not see Additional Notices tab and also not
received the notice or order is untenable. Similarly, in the case of
Karlon Retail Limited vs. Sales Tax Officer38 at paragraphs 9 and 10,
it has been held that the contention that the Additional Notices tab in the
GST Portal is not visible and accessible to the assessee has been
negatived. Similar view has been taken in Chirag Garg vs.
Commissioner of State Tax, Delhi GST39 and in HM Traders vs.
Goods and Services Tax Officer40.
137.
It appears from the perusal of the decisions in Ramanattu Motor
Corporation (supra), Chirag Garg (supra) and HM Traders (supra),
that a consistent view on the show cause notices uploaded on the
Additional Notices tab, prior to changes made to the GST portal on
16.01.2024 when Additional Notices tab was visible therein. The
petitioners could not notice it on account of lack of clarity whether the
notices of adjudication or determination would be posted in the
Additional Notices tab. In the case of Ramanattu Motor Corporation
(supra) and HM Traders (supra), the matter was remanded to the
2025 (34) Centax 442 (del)
2025 (31) Centax 224 (Del)
2025 (31) Centax 158 (Del)
authorities. The learned Court in Ramanattu Motor Corporation
(supra) and Chirag Garg (supra) was also of the opinion that the plea of
notice in ‘Additional Notices Tab’ would not be tenable in cases where
the show cause notice or order is subsequent to 16.01.2024.
138.
Since the reference is confined to the issue of unsigned
documents and there is no apparent conflict of views on the instant issue
of service of notice on Additional Notices and Orders tab, prior to the
Note inserted in the GST portal on 16.01.2024, it would be open for the
petitioners in matters where such show cause notices or orders were
uploaded on the Additional Notices and Orders tab, prior to 16.01.2024,
to raise it in an appropriate proceeding before the appellate forum/court
of law.
139.
This Court is of the view that when the GST Portal contains a
Note which clearly indicates that following notices/orders issued by the
tax authorities are available under ‘Additional Notices or Orders’ i.e.,
notices or orders pertaining modules of Advance Ruling, Appeal,
Assessment/Adjudication,
Audit,
Enforcement,
Prosecution
and
Compounding, Recovery, LUT etc, the plea that the show cause notice
issued after 16.01.2024 was not properly served is not tenable in law. In
terms of Section 169(1)(d) of the Act, service of notice or order is
complete on making it available on the common portal. If the common
portal itself indicates by way of a note that such notices/orders are
available under the additional notices and orders tab, the taxpayer cannot
feign ignorance of service of such notice or order through the common
portal.
140.
Sri G.Venkateswarlu appearing in W.P.No.22806 of 2025 has
taken a plea that the Information Technology Act does not have an
overriding effect over the provisions of the CGST Act as per Section 81
thereof. Therefore, the summary of the show cause notice in DRC-01
and summary of order in DRC-07 which do not show any visible digital
signature are not inconsonance with the provisions of the CGST Act and
the Rules framed thereunder including Rule 26(3) of the CGST Rules.
This contention has been dealt with in depth while answering the issue
of unsigned documents, i.e., those notices/orders under Chapter XVIII,
Demands and Recovery of CGST Rules, which have been electronically
authenticated and made available through the common portal. Therefore,
this contention does not hold good any more.
141.
Learned counsel Sri Venkateswarlu has also taken a plea in
W.P.No.24349 of 2025 that the penalty under Section 122 of the CGST
Act has not been imposed by a proper officer as per circular dated
27.10.2025 issued by the CBIC. Such a plea is open to be raised before
the appropriate forum/court and is not required to be answered by this
Bench in this reference.
142.
In the background of the detailed discussion and analysis made
hereinabove, on the issue of unsigned show cause notices/orders, the
judgments relied upon by the petitioners are dealt with hereinafter.
The Judgments relied upon by the petitioners:
143. A perusal of the decision in Silver Oak Villas LLP (supra)
would show that the department had admitted that the document is
neither physically nor digitally signed. The learned Division Bench
referred to the decisions including Ramani Suchit Malushte vs. Union
of India41 (supra) and came to the conclusion that Rule 26(3) of the
CGST Rules is applicable to orders under Section 73 of 74 of the CGST
Act. Ramani Suchit Malushte (supra) was pertaining to cancellation of
GST registration covered under Chapter III of the CGST Rules.
Therefore, Rule 26(3) was applied. However, in Bigleap Technologies
(supra), another coordinate Division Bench of this Court held that “the
unsigned documents under Section 73 or 74 of the CGST Act under the
substantive provisions of Demands and Recovery will not be hit by Rule
26(3) of the CGST Rules. It held that the contrary view taken by the
Court about DRC-07 having no signature without considering the above
Rule and prescribed Form must be held to be per incuriam. As such,
there were conflicting views on the application of Rule 26(3) between
the two Division Benches in the aforesaid decisions.
144.
In the case of M/s.Sahithi Marketers (supra), the same
coordinate Division Bench which decided the Bigleap Technologies
(supra) proceeded to hold that DRC-07 is only a summary of order and
[2023] 112 GSTR 149 (Bom)
even if it does not contain any signature, it will not cause any prejudice
to the petitioner.
145.
In Bigleap Technologies (supra) decided on 28.02.2025,
however had taken a view relying upon the decisions of Baru Ram
(supra) and Anjum M.H.Ghaswala (supra) that if the law prescribes a
thing to be done in a particular manner, the same must be done in the
same manner and other methods are forbidden. Therefore, in order to
translate Demands and recovery into reality, the Rules were introduced
and the Rules are pregnant with statutory Forms for effectively
exercising the power, which require a signature.
146.
In batch of writ petitions led by Bigleap Technologies (supra),
the petitioners had challenged the legality, validity and propriety to the
show cause notices and final orders on the ground of being unsigned.
The learned Division Bench of this Court recorded that although the
impugned show cause notices and final orders were placed on the portal,
they do not contain physical or digital signatures of the proper officer, as
fairly admitted by the learned Special Government Pleader for State
Tax. In the light of this undisputed factual position, Bigleap
Technologies (supra) proceeded to hold that M/s.Silver Oak Villas
LLP (supra) based on a Bombay High Court decision in Ramani Suchit
Malushite (supra), which dealt with registration and not on demands
and recovery under Chapter XVIII of the CGST Rules as per incuriam.
In the said case, since GSTN was not a party, the working of the GST
regime through the common portal could not be extensively
demonstrated and explained, like in the present batch of cases under
reference. In Bigleap Technologies (supra), the learned Division Bench
proceeded on an impression that if the digital signature was not visible
in the form prescribed under the Rules, they have to be held invalid and
cannot get immunity in terms of Section 160 of the Act in view of the
judgment rendered in M.M.Rubber (supra) and Kilasho Devi (supra).
This aspect of the matter has been dealt with in detail while discussing
on the issue of unsigned documents in the earlier part of this judgment.
In Bigleap Technologies (supra), the learned Court proceeded on an
understanding that the Forms are mandatory in nature in view of the
expression ‘shall’ used in every sub-rule of Rule 142 of the CGST
Rules. However, as held hereinabove Forms are only subservient to the
Rules and cannot supplant them as per the ration in Apar Industries
(supra).
147.
The manner and procedure of electronic authentification of
notices and orders through the common portal by the proper officer
under Chapter XVIII of the CGST Rules has been held to be a valid
means of authentification of electronic record which fulfils the
ingredients of Section 3, 3A and 5 of the IT Act. The advisory of the
GSTN dated 25.09.2024 was placed before the learned Division Bench
in Bigleap Technologies (supra), which held that the existence of
signature is a statutory requirement in the Forms. In the said
proceedings, the respondents/State Tax Officials had taken a plea that
the signature of the officer who passed the order should be there.
Though the learned Court referred to Sections 3 and 5 under Chapter II
of the IT Act, which deal with digital signature and electronic signature,
but it proceeded on the basis that the statutory forms prescribed under
the CGST Act and the CGST Rules and Section 3 of the IT Act make it
obligatory for the proper officer to put his signature. However, this view
is not correct as every such document i.e., notice or order under Chapter
XVIII of the CGST Rules are electronically authenticated as per the
requirement of Sections 3, 3A and 5 of the IT Act explained in detail in
the earlier part of this judgment. Therefore, absence of digital signature
on the Forms would not render them invalid. Section 5 of the IT Act
provides for legal recognition of electronic signatures and further
explains that the terms ‘signed’ and ‘signature’ would with its
grammatical variations and cognate expressions ‘shall’ be construed
accordingly.
148.
The learned Advocate General and the learned Additional
Solicitor General of India, both have relied upon the recent decision of
the Gujarat High Court judgments in M/s.Vishwa Enterprise (supra)
and Radhe Enterprise (supra) and the Delhi High Court judgment in
M/s.Swarn Cosmetics (India) (supra), which have held that the show
cause notices/orders are uploaded through the GST portal only through
the digital key of the officer. The contention that they were not signed
either digitally or physically, was not acceptable. Here also, the
petitioners have not brought on record anything to show that these
documents have not been obtained from the common portal or from
some other source.
149.
The contention of the petitioners that uploading of notices/orders
on the Common Portal cannot be construed as service, as the taxpayer is
not expected to keep on looking at the portal every time does not appeal
to reason. The reason being that various provisions of the CGST Act,
such as furnishing of returns under Chapter IX, claims of refund under
Chapter XI, filing of self-assessment returns under Chapter XII, scrutiny
of returns and audit proceedings under Chapter XIII, all require the
taxpayer to be diligent and vigilant. Otherwise the taxpayer is liable to
face the legal consequences arising thereof, including levy of interest
and penalty. A legal duty is therefore cast upon the taxpayer to make
these compliances through the Common Portal by exercise of due
diligence.
150.
Petitioners have also relied upon the cases of M.M.Rubber
(supra), Kilasho Devi Burman (supra) and Keshab Chandra Mandal
(supra) and referred to in Bigleap Technologies (supra) also, on the
proposition that an unsigned assessment order lacks legal validity. The
contention of the petitioners proceeds on the premise that the relevant
notice or order under Chapter XVIII, Demands and Recovery, were
invalid in the absence of a digital signature or a physical signature as per
the prescribed Forms. However, in the light of the view expressed by
this Court in the present reference, such a plea pales into insignificance
as notices or orders covered under Chapter XVIII of the CGST Rules are
required to be electronically authenticated through the common portal.
Such electronic form is undertaken only by affixation of the digital
signature certificate using the private key by the proper officer after
onboarding the portal, proper authentification and authorisation. Such
notices or orders made available on the common portal through the
electronic authentication have the legal recognition as per Section 5 of
the IT Act. Therefore, the contention of the petitioners that these
documents are invalid in the absence of a visible digital signature or
physical signature does not hold good in the eye of law.
151.
The decision of Union of India vs. Harish Chandra Goswami42
relied upon by the petitioners does not further the plea raised by the
petitioners on the same issue.
152.
The petitioners have also placed reliance upon the case of
M/s.ASP Traders (supra) on the question of service of notice in terms
of Section 169(1)(d) of the CGST Act and the expression ‘tendered’
used in Section 169(2) of the Act. Reference is also made to Section
153(2) of the Customs Act, wherein it expressly provides that the date of
upload shall be treated as the date of service, which is not specified
under Section 169 of the CGST Act. This issue has also been answered
(1999) 4 SCC 575
in the foregoing paragraphs by this Court by referring to Section 13(2)
of the Information Tax Act. Therefore, the petitioners cannot draw any
assistance from the said decisions.
153.
The plea raised by the petitioners on availability of statutory
appellate remedy and expiry of limitation prescribed under the taxing
statutes, in view of the decision rendered in Glaxo Smith Kline
Consumer Health Care Limited (supra) while entertaining the writ
petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution of India having
adequately been dealt with in the foregoing paragraphs need no
repetition.
Conclusion:
154.
As an upshot of the detailed analysis and discussion made
hereinabove, after dealing with the provisions of the CGST Act, CGST
Rules, particularly Chapter XVIII of the CGST Rules, the provisions of
the Information Technology Act read with Second Schedule, Certifying
Authorities Rules and End Entity Rules, the decisions relied upon by
learned counsel for the parties and the manner and procedure by which
the show cause notices and orders under Chapter XVIII of the CGST
Rules are electronically authenticated and made available on the
common portal, the plea of the petitioners that in the absence of any
visible digital signature thereupon, they are invalid or nullity in the eye
of law is not correct. It is, therefore, held that the presence of the digital
signature on the Forms is not the requirement on the documents covered
under Chapter XVIII of the CGST Rules. The contention of the
petitioners that these documents are not digitally signed as provided
under the Forms does not merit acceptance. The show cause notices and
orders electronically authenticated by the proper officer and uploaded on
the common portal are valid documents in the eye of law. That these
show cause notices and/or orders on being made available on the
common portal amount to valid service in terms of Section 169(1)(d) of
the CGST Act. However, absence of DIN or RFN on any of these
documents would render it invalid. The period of limitation to avail
statutory remedy or to make other compliances would run from the date
on which the show cause notice or order is uploaded in the common
portal. The contrary view taken in the decisions relied upon by the
petitioners on this issue, such as in Bigleap Technologies (supra) do not
lay down the correct position of law.
155.
Having held so, since the writ petitions have remained pending
for considerable length of time and the challenge in these writ petitions
relying upon the plea of unsigned document has failed, the petitioners
are allowed liberty to avail the statutory remedy of appeal within a
period of two weeks from today. Needless to say, it is open for the
petitioners to raise such other grounds of law and facts as have been left
open while answering this reference in any such appeal in accordance
with law.
156.
The Reference is answered accordingly.
157.
All the writ petitions are disposed of in terms of the observations
and directions made hereinabove. There shall be no order as to costs.
Miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed.
______________________________________
APARESH KUMAR SINGH, CJ
______________________________________
N.TUKARAMJI, J
______________________________________
G.M.MOHIUDDIN, J
30.09.2026
Pln/vs
Note: LR copy be marked.
(By order)
Pln/vs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review