Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:19897
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(L) No. 4649 of 2022
M/s. Tata Pigments Limited, an existing Company incorporated under
the Companies Act, having its registered office at Sakchi, Boulevard,
Jamshedpur, P.O. Bistupur, P.S. Bistupur, Town Jamshedpur, District
East Singhbhum and having its Plant at Jugsalai Jamshedpur, P.O. &
P.S. Jugsalai, District East Singhbhum, through its authorized
signatory, namely, Mrs. Navneet Kaur Bhatia, aged about 36 years,
wife of Gagan Deep Singh Bhatia, Resident of Gaushala Road P.O. &
P.S Jugsalai Town- Jamshedpur, District East Singhbhum.
…
…
Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand through the Secretary, Department of
Labour, Employment, Training and Skill Development, Government
of Jharkhand, having its office at Nepal House, Doranda, P.O. & P.S.
Doranda, District Ranchi.
2. The Special Secretary, Department of Labor, Employment,
Training and Skill Development, Government of Jharkhand, having its
office at Shram Bhawan, Doranda, P. O & P.S. Doranda, DistrictRanchi. Employees' State Insurance Corporation through its Director,
at Regional office, Namkum, P.O & P.S- Namkum, District- Ranchi.
3. The Regional Director, Employees' State Insurance Corporation,
Jharkhand, P.O. & P.S. Namkum, Town & District Ranchi.
4. Deputy Director, Employees' State Insurance Corporation, at
Regional Office, Namkum P.O. & P.S. Namkum, District Ranchi.
5. Assistant Director (Ins. IV), Employees' State Insurance
Corporation, having its office at Regional Office, Namkum, P.O. &
P.S. Namkum, District Ranchi.
6. S.S.O. Inspection Division, Employees' State Insurance
Corporation, Jamshedpur Division, P.O. Golmuri, P.S. Golmuri,
Town Jamshedpur, District East Singhbhum.
…
…
Respondents
With
W.P.(L) No. 4650 of 2022
M/s. Tata Pigments Limited, an existing Company incorporated under
the Companies Act, having its registered office at Sakchi, Boulevard,
Jamshedpur, P.O. Bistupur, P.S. Bistupur, Town Jamshedpur, District
East Singhbhum and having its Plant at Jugsalai Jamshedpur, P.O. &
P.S. Jugsalai, District East Singhbhum, through its authorized
signatory, namely, Mrs. Navneet Kaur Bhatia, aged about 36 years,
wife of Gagan Deep Singh Bhatia, Resident of Gaushala Road P.O. &
P.S Jugsalai Town- Jamshedpur, District East Singhbhum.
…
…
Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand through the Secretary, Department of
Labour, Employment, Training and Skill Development, Government
2026:JHHC:19897
of Jharkhand, having its office at Nepal House, Doranda, P.O. & P.S.
Doranda, District Ranchi.
2. The Special Secretary, Department of Labor, Employment,
Training and Skill Development, Government of Jharkhand, having its
office at Shram Bhawan, Doranda, P.O & P.S. Doranda, DistrictRanchi. Employees' State Insurance Corporation through its Director,
at Regional office, Namkum, P.O & P. S- Namkum, District- Ranchi.
3. The Regional Director, Employees' State Insurance Corporation,
Jharkhand, P.O. & P.S. Namkum, Town & District Ranchi.
4. Deputy Director, Employees' State Insurance Corporation, at
Regional Office, Namkum P.O. & P.S. Namkum, District Ranchi.
5. Assistant Director (Ins. IV), Employees' State Insurance
Corporation, having its office at Regional Office, Namkum, P.O. &
P.S. Namkum, District Ranchi.
6. S.S.O. Inspection Division, Employees' State Insurance
Corporation, Jamshedpur Division, P.O. Golmuri, P.S. Golmuri,
Town Jamshedpur, District East Singhbhum.
…
…
Respondents
--CORAM :HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Amit Kumar Das, Senior Advocate
Mr. Shivam Utkarsh Sahay, Advocate
For the ESIC
: Mr. Ashutosh Anand, Advocate
For the State
: Ms. Priti Priyamvada, AC to GP-V
[in W.P.(L) No. 4649 of 2022]
: Mr. Krishna Kr. Bhatt, AC to SC-I
[in W.P.(L) No. 4650 of 2022]
--22/06.07.2026
Heard the learned counsels appearing on behalf of the parties.
2.
W.P.(L) No. 4649 of 2022 has been filed for the following
reliefs:
“i. For issuance of writ/ order/ direction of an appropriate
nature for quashing of the demand notice dated 29.08.2022 vide
Ref. No. 60000010710000306 / Bima -IV and further quashing the
letter dated 29/08/2022 as contained in Letter No.
60000010710000306 / Bima -IV (Annexure-6 series) wherein
directions have been issued upon the petitioners to comply with
the demand notice dated 29.08.2022, failing which legal actions
will be initiated against the petitioners.
ii. For issuance of an appropriate writ/order/direction, including
writ of certiorari for quashing of the order contained in Memo
No. 718 dated 06-05-2022 (Annexure-3) passed by the Secretary,
Department of Labour, Employment, Training and Skill
Development, Government of Jharkhand-Respondent no.1,
whereby and where under, the application filed by the petitioner
for exemption in terms of the provision of Sections 87 and 88 read
2026:JHHC:19897
with Section 91A of the Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948 has
been rejected for the period 1.1. 2022 to 31.12.2022.
iii. Your Lordship may further be pleased to stay the demand
notice dated 29.08.2022 vide Ref. No. 60000010710000306 /
Bima -IV during the pendency of the instant writ petition.
iv. For issuance of an appropriate writ, order or direction,
directing the respondents not to proceed with the matter in
pursuant to order dated 06.05.2022;
and/or
v. For any other writ(s)/order(s)/direction(s) as this Hon’ble
Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of
the case for doing conscionable justice to the Petitioner.”
3.
W.P.(L) No. 4650 of 2022 has been filed for the following
reliefs:
“i. For issuance of writ/order/ direction of an appropriate nature
for quashing of the demand notice dated 29.08.2022 vide Ref. No.
60000010710000306/ Bima-IV and further quashing the letter
dated 29/08/2022 as contained in Letter No. 60000010710000306
/ Bima -IV (Annexure-6 series) wherein directions have been
issued upon the petitioners to comply with the demand notice
dated 29.08.2022, failing which legal actions will be initiated
against the petitioners.
ii. For issuance of an appropriate writ/order/direction, including
writ of certiorari for quashing of the order contained in Memo
No. 719 dated 06-05-2022 (Annexure-3) passed by the Secretary,
Department of Labour, Employment, Training and Skill
Development, Government of Jharkhand-Respondent no.1,
whereby and where under, the application filed by the petitioner
for exemption in terms of the provision of Sections 87 and 88 read
with Section 91A of the Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948 has
been rejected for the period 1.1.2021 to 31.12.2021.
iii. Your Lordship may further be pleased to stay the demand
notice dated 29.08.2022 vide Ref. No. 60000010710000306 /
Bima -IV during the pendency of the instant writ petition.
iv. For issuance of an appropriate writ, order or direction,
directing the respondents not to proceed with the matter in
pursuant to order dated 06.05.2022;
and/or
v. For any other writ(s)/order(s)/direction(s) as this Hon’ble
Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of
the case for doing conscionable justice to the Petitioner.”
4.
Learned Senior counsel for the petitioner in both the cases
submits that the impugned order rejecting the claim for exemption
2026:JHHC:19897
passed Sections 87 and 88 read with Section 91A of the Employees'
State Insurance Act, 1948 (hereinafter referred to as the “Act of
1948”) are almost identical except for the period to which they relate.
In W.P.(L) No. 4650 of 2022 the period involved is January, 2021 to
December, 2021 and in W.P.(L) No. 4649 of 2022 the period involved
is January, 2022 to December, 2022.
5.
The learned Senior counsel for the petitioner has produced copy
of orders contained in Memo No. 652 dated 28.03.2025 which is
related to the period January, 2025 to December, 2025 and memo no.
2187 dated 26.12.2025 related to the period from January, 2026 to
December, 2028. However, the memo no. 2187 dated 26.12.2025
reveals at the top that it is for the period from 01.01.2026 to
31.12.2026, but at the bottom it mentioned that it is related to the
period of three years i.e., from 01.01.2026 to 31.12.2028. The learned
counsel is unable to explain the inconsistency in the memo no. 2187
dated 26.12.2025 but it is not in dispute that currently, the petitioner is
enjoying the exemption.
6.
Learned Senior counsel for the petitioner has submitted that a
detailed order has been passed with respect to grant of exemption for
the period of 2025 wherein the terms and conditions of employment
have been considered and exemption has been extended. So far as the
impugned orders in both these writ petitions are concerned, same
terms and conditions of employment have become the reason for
rejection of claim for exemption, except for one item i.e., extended
sickness benefit.
7.
The learned Senior counsel submits that it is surprising that for
same terms and conditions of employment, the concerned authority of
the state government responsible for taking decision on the point of
grant of exemption is taking different view for different years as
different persons are holding the post from time to time. This has
created a situation of chaos and there is complete uncertainty in the
mind of the parties as to whether the terms and conditions of
employment of the employees of the petitioner company are in
consonance with the requirement under the provisions of the aforesaid
2026:JHHC:19897
Act of 1948 to avail the benefit of exemption. The learned Senior
counsel has also submitted that the orders of different years are also
not being placed before the authority so that an appropriate view could
be taken.
8.
Learned counsel for the respondent- ESIC has submitted that
the exemption would essentially depend upon the terms and conditions
of arrangement of medical and other facilities made between Tata
Main Hospital (TMH) /Tata Steel Limited and the present petitioner
and each year may have different arrangements and therefore, each
case has to be examined in terms of the arrangement between
TMH/Tata Steel Limited and the petitioner and in the light of the
terms and conditions of employment of the employees/benefits
extended to ex-employees.
9.
However, from the perusal of the impugned orders passed in the
present cases, it appears that no reference has been made with respect
to the terms and conditions of the arrangement between the petitioner
and TMH/Tata Steel Limited.
10.
Learned counsels for the State are unable to justify different
views taken by the authority with respect to the same service
conditions and it is not in dispute that there is no consideration of the
arrangement between the petitioner and TMH/Tata Steel Limited
while passing the impugned orders. They have also perused the
aforesaid two orders which have been produced by the learned Senior
counsel for the petitioner(s) contained in Memo No. 652 dated
28.03.2025 and memo no. 2187 dated 26.12.2025 whereby exemption
has been extended to the petitioner, though for different periods.
11.
The learned counsels for the state submit that the matter may
be remanded so that appropriate order may be passed with respect to
the periods involved in the present cases as well. The learned
Counsels have submitted that all the relevant materials for the
purposes of deciding the claim for exemption for each period be
directed to be produced by the petitioner including the terms and
conditions of arrangement between the petitioner and TMH/Tata Steel
Limited with respect to the employees/ex-employees of the petitioner.
2026:JHHC:19897
12.
After hearing the learned counsels for the parties, this Court
finds that different view is being taken by the respondent no. 2 from
time to time for different years with respect to entitlement of
exemption under the aforesaid Act of 1948, although apparently, the
employees in the petitioner- company are governed by the same terms
and conditions of employment and it has become difficult to reconcile
different orders. However, at the same time, there can be no dispute
that the terms and conditions of arrangement for extending medical
and other benefits to employees/ex-employees of the petitioner
between TMH/Tata Steel Limited and the petitioner, as may be
applicable from time to time, also has a bearing with respect to the
claim for exemption.
13.
In view of the orders contained in Memo No. 652 dated
28.03.2025 and memo no. 2187 dated 26.12.2025 as produced by the
learned senior counsel for the petitioner during the course of hearing,
whereby exemption has been extended for the years 2025/2026 after
considering some of the heads of service conditions regarding medical
benefits and refusal to extend the benefits of exemption for the periods
2021 and 2022 involved in these cases under the same heads of
service conditions regarding medical benefits (except one),
the
impugned orders in these two writ petitions being inconsistent with
the aforesaid two orders granting exemption for different periods
cannot be sustained in law. As mentioned above, the learned counsels
for the respondents are also not able to reconcile inconsistent orders
during the course of arguments.
14.
In aforesaid circumstances, this Court is of the considered view
that the respondent no. 2 should consider the matter afresh and
examine the case of exemption of the petitioner for the period
involved in these writ petitions in the light of various orders with
respect to claim for exemption of the petitioner passed from time to
time and also in the light of the terms and conditions of employment
of the employees /ex-employees of the petitioner and the terms and
conditions of extension of benefit by TMH/Tata Steel Limited to the
employees/ex-employees of the petitioner.
2026:JHHC:19897
15.
In order to enable the respondent no. 2 to pass a fresh order
with respect to the periods involved in these writ petitions, the
impugned order contained in Memo No. 718 dated 06.05.2022
[Annexure-3 to W.P.(L) No. 4649 of 2022 (period - 2022) ] and order
contained in Memo No. 719 dated 06.05.2022 [Annexure-3 to W.P.(L)
No. 4650 of 2022 (period- 2021)] are set-aside.
16.
Accordingly, the petitioner and the concerned officers of the
ESIC are directed to appear before the respondent no. 2 on 22nd July,
2026 at 11:00 a.m. with all the relevant records and the entire records
of this case by filing a representation before the respondent no. 2.
17.
The respondent no. 2 shall decide the applications seeking
exemption for the period 2021 and 2022 strictly in accordance with
law taking into consideration the provisions of the aforesaid Act of
1948 and the rules framed thereunder and other materials including
the materials as indicated above after himself granting an opportunity
of hearing to the parties and pass a speaking order within a period of
three months from the date of appearance of the parties. All the
contentions of the parties are kept open.
18.
The order to be passed by the respondent no. 2 be
communicated to the parties through speed post and also through email, and the e-mail id and the contact number be furnished by the
parties to the aforesaid authority on 22nd July, 2026 itself.
19.
At this, learned Senion counsel for the petitioner has submitted
that if so required, the authority may also issue notice to Tata Steel
Limited/TMH as their agreement will fall directly into consideration
and it is they who are providing the medical facilities through an
arrangement.
It is sufficient to observe that if the aforesaid authority so requires, he
may call upon Tata Steel Limited/TMH to explain the position.
20.
In order to ensure that there is no gap, the respondent no. 2 may
call upon the parties to file their written submissions.
21.
It is relevant to note that the petitioner has filed different writ
petitions for different periods out of which two writ petitions have
2026:JHHC:19897
been disposed of; they are W.P.(C) No. 2808 of 2005 decided on
22.06.2026 and W.P.(C) No. 6957 of 2016 decided on 18.06.2026.
In W.P.(C) No. 2808 of 2005, following has been held:
Period 10/1996 to 12/1999
No application was filed seeking
exemption. The petitioner cannot
escape the liability for this period.
Period 2000
The
application
exemption
is
seeking
required
to
be
considered. The petitioner and
ESIC were directed to appear on
13th
July,
before
the
authority.
Period 2001
The
application
exemption
is
seeking
required
to
be
considered. The petitioner and
ESIC were directed to appear on
13th
July,
before
the
authority.
Period 2002-2004
Application
seeking
exemption
has been rejected vide order dated
23.07.2005 for the period 2002
and vide order dated 14.05.2007
for the period 2003 to 2004. The
orders refusing to grant exemption
were not challenged in the said
writ petition and they attained
finality.
W.P.(C) No. 6957 of 2016
W.P.(C) No. 6957 of 2016 is related to the period 2011 to 2014. Vide
order dated 18.06.2026 passed in the said writ petition, the application
seeking exemption has been directed to be considered and the parties
to appear on 08th July, 2026.
22.
These writ petitions are disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
2026:JHHC:19897
23.
Pending interlocutory application, if any, is closed.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
Date of Order:06.07.2026
Pankaj
Date of Uploading: 08.07.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review