Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3300 I
il
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO: 26652 OF 2025
Between:
t\4/s.. Sukhii ?p,C"-tq LLP, Plot No.59, Sagar Society Road No.2, Banjara Hills
Hydera-b-ad - 500 034 And also at Plot No.31, Sy.No. 404 Uppal Bhagayath; phase-ll
!Opa1 Mandal, Ir/ledchal [l4alkajgiri District S00'039 Rep By its Des-ignated partner
Sri. KandaySrinivasulu, aged 60 years Rio. Plot No. t4S, Road No. 10-C, MLA-MP
Colony, Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad 500 033.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. Union of lndia, Represented by its Principal Secretary FS Department of
Financial Services Ministry of Firiance, Govdrnment of lndia New Delhi
2. The Governor Reserve Bank of lndia, Shahid Bhagat Singh Road, Mumbai
3. Banking Ombudsman, C/o Reserve Bank of lndia, No. 6-1-56, Secretariat
Road Saifabad, Hyderabad 500004
4 HDfC Bank Limited, Yousufguda Branch Ground Floor, H.No. B-32-31M l62lc1 , Women's Co-operative Housing Society Sreekrishna Nagar
Cross Roads, Yousufguda, Hyderabad-500045 Repreiented by its Brarich
Manager
5. Axis Bank Limited, Srinagar colony Branch Hyderabad
6. M/s Corvine Chemicals and Pharmaceuticals Pvt. Ltd., Having its registered
office at Plot No. '135-E, Kohlar lndustrial Area Bidar, Karnatika ne-p by lts
Executive Director, Mahareddy Revanth Reddy
7. Goutham Bacha, S/o Srinivasulu Bacha, Aged 27 years, Occ Business, R/o
Flat No. 21, Canton Park, Petbasheerbad- Opp. j.J. Garden, eutbullipur,
Hyderabad 500055
B. G.Venkata Sri Maithreya, S/o.G.K.Naidu, Aged about 38 years, Occ:
Advocate, Rl/o.Flat No.302, Green Rich Residericy, Uppal Bhagayath,'Uppal,
Hyderabad 500039
Respondent No.8 impleaded as per C.O.dt.09.01.2026 in l.A.No.3/2025.
...RESPONDENTS
,
,4
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, Order or Direction, more particularly, one in the nature of
WRIT OF MAIJDAMUS declaring the inaction on the part of Respondents No. 4
AND 5 in imple menting the change of authorized signatory of the Current Account
of the Petitioner in HDFC Bank, Yousufguda, Hyderabad branch bearing No.
5921849999SS9 and in Axis Bank, Srinagar Colony Branch, Hyderabad being
Current Account No. 923020068233936 as per Board Resolution dated
2111212024 as illegal, arbitrary, colourable exercise of power and violative of
provisions of tre RBI Guidelines and declare the Order of the 3rd Respondent
dated 25-08-21)25 as nonest in law and consequently direct the Respondents
Nos. 4 and 5 to forthwith implement the change of the authorized signatory of the
Current Accourrt of the Petitioner in HDFC Bank bearing No. 592'1849999999 and
in Axis Bank, Srinagar Colony Branch, Hyderabad being Current Account No.
923020068233936 as per Board Resolution dated 2111212024.
lA NO: 2 OF 2C25
Petition under Section 15'l CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit fil:d in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the Respondent No.4 to forthwith implement the change of the authorized
signatory of thr; Petitioner for the Current Account No. 5921849999999 in HDFC
Bank, Yousuflluda branch, Hyderabad as per the Board Resolution dated
21.12.2024.
A NO: 1 OF 2C25
Petition .rnder Section '151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit fil,ad in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the Respondent No.5 to forthwith implement the change of the authorized
signatory of tht-, Petitioner Current Account No 923020068233936 of Axis Bank,
Srinagar Colony branch, Hyderabad as per the Board Resolution dated
21.12.2024.
Counsel for the Petitioner : MS.MANJARI S GANU
c o u n s e I ro r t h e Re s po n o'
"'
*
il' S'*tX ,[i[it"650[R[ ff -.
L
Counsel for the Respondent No.2 &3 : M/s.N.LEGAL
Counsel for the Respondent No.5 :
--
Counsel for the Respondent No.4 : SMT.MUWA SRI LAKSHMI
Counsel for the Respondent No.6&7 : SRI B.SRINARAYANA
The Court made the following: ORDER
E-
I
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
EION'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION No. 26652 OF 2025
09.O\.2026
Betweerr:
M / s Suk hii Projects LLP
Rep. by its Designated Partner
Sri Kancay Srinivasulu
. Petitioncr
Ar-rd
Union of India,
Rep. by its Principal Secretary FS,
Department of Financial Services,
Ministry of Finance, New Delhi
and others
. Respondet-rts
ORDER:
.
This Writ Petition questions the inaction of
Respondents 4 and 5 in effecting change in authorised
signatories of the current account of petitioners' hrm in their
banks, irs per the Board Resolution dated 2l l2-2O24. A
direction is sought to Respondents 4 and 5 to impiement the
change firrthwith. The grievance of petitioner is that respondent
banks h ave refused to honour and implement a valid board
resolution duly passed in accordaace with the LLp Agreement
and con irmed by the Arbitral Award. The impugned refusal
lacks aur.hority of law, violates the LLP's contractual autonomy,
?
and infringes upon Articles 14, 19 (1) (g) and 300-A of the
Constitution. Petitioner further challenged the ordcr of the 3'd
respondent dated 25-O8 2025 as illegal and arbitrary.
2.
The brief facts of the case are, petitioner is a limited
liabilify partnership lirm for purchase and development of
lands, construction of flats thereof, residential and commercial
complex or complexes either singly or jointly or in partnership,
comprising olfices for sale or sell use or for earning rental
earning thereon by letting out individual units in such units.
The {irm also intends to purchase any movablc or immovable
property including industrial, commercial, residential or farm
lands, plots, buildings, houses, apartments' flats or areas
within the limits of Municipal Corporation etcctera and to divide
the same into suitable plots and. to rent or sell the plots for
buildings, constructing residential houses, bungalows, business
premises, colonies etcetera.
2.1.
Petitioner is stated to have acquired certain lands
for various developmental activities and the subject matter is
with regard to development ol land at Uppal Bhagayat wherein
17O flats have been constructed in an area around 6425 sq.
yards. The construction activity was started in 2022 and
completed and most of the units have been pre-booked by the
-1
prospecr.ive buyers and they have entered into various
agreements initially' whereas certain agreements have been
entered after construction was completed. During pendency of
execution ol' sale agreements, some of the partners of petitioncr,
i.e. ResJronclents 6 and 7, who were not partners in the initial
LLP Agreement were introduced as partners, by virtue of
supplementary Agreement dated 08-O 1-2 O22, by adopting most
ol the Clauses of the primary LLP Agreement. To substantiate
their contention that if a majority passes an issue, it becomes
binding. Petitioner relied upon the following Clauses 60 and 61
of primary LLP Agreement:
"
Clause 60: The matters discussed in the hrm meeting shall
be dcci,led bv a resolution passed by a majority partners present rn
person or through authorised reprresentative and each partner shall
-have orie vote (matters to be
by a resolution passed b_r a
.decided
majoritr nurnber of the partners who are more specihcatly described in
the Sch':riule 2 annexed thereto). All the partners are required to vote.
Clause 61: The matters shall be decided by a resolution by
all partllers present in person or through authorised representative and
in this regard each partner shall have one vote (matters to be decided by
a resolution passed by all partners which are more specifically described
in Scherlule 3 annexed thereto). All the partners are required to vote.
2.2.
Petitioner further stated that original Clause 10 of
LLP partnership Agreement was replaced by another clause
which re nds as under:
"
Current Account can be opened with any Bank as agreed by
all the Partners or majority of the Partners. All the cheques of the banks
can be signed bv any of the parties/partners to this agreement herein
abovc mentioned."
The aLrove mentioned Clause 1O is substituted [t
the supplemcntary agreement as follows
It is expressly agreed that the Bank Accounts oI the LLP
shall be operated jointly by Mr' Srinivasulu Kandav along with Mr'
"
Ramesh Kanday or Goutha#iBacha."
2.3.
Petitioner clarihed that the subsequent Clause 10
which was incorporated clarifred the above. [t is further stated,
the above Clause was modified uide Board Resolution dated
jointly
18- 1 l-2O23 whereby the 7n respondent also rx'ould be
operating the bank accounts of petitioner along with Mr'
Srinivasulu Kanday and Mr. Rasresh Kanday' Despite the 7th
respondent been authorised to sign the cheques along n'ith
others, for the reasons best known to him, he started acting
detrimental to the interests of petitioner flrm'
2.4 .
While things stood thus, Respondents 6 and 7
initiated arbitration proceedings against petitioner and othqv
designated partners. The Arbitral Tribunal passed the Arvafd on
l2-O8-2O25. Petitioner referred to paras 123, 124, 125, 127,
128, 13O & 131 of the Award to refute the allegations made by
Respondents 6 and 7, as baseleSs.
2.5.
Subsequentll,, petitioner has taken a decision by a
Board Rt:solution dated 21-12-2024 to re-implement the original
Clause 4 of the supplementary Agreement dated 08-O1-2022.
Further, petitioner stated that the latest developments cropped
up, after the Board Resolution dated 2l-12-2024 was conveyed
to Respondents 4 and 5 banks, which, instead of honouring the
Board Resolution, strangely informed the designated partners
and petit,ioner that their request for updating the records, with
newly authorised signatory to operate petitioner's accounts,
cannot be acceded to, since it is not accompanied by either the
unanimous authorisation of the partners or binding directive
addressed to the 4th Respondent bank from the Tribunal, Court
or any othcr compctent authority. Respondent No. 5 informed
petitione- ukle letter dated 19-O8-2O25 that they cannot accede
to their wish to update their bank records enabling a newlyauthorisr:d signatory to operate the bank account and advised
them to :;ubmit fresh Board Resolution signed by alt designated
partners. Petitioner contended .that left with no option, t1-ey
made a complaint to the Ombudsman but the sarne was
rejected in a mechanical manner and a non-speaking order was
passed uide proceedings dated 25.O8.2025.
3.
Respondents 6 and 7 filed counter and also
synopsis stating that LLP was incorporated on O5.12.2OO9
under the LLP Act 2018 with Rs.1,00,0OO/ as share capital.
Initially, LLP was formed with two share-holders i.e. K.
Srinivasulu and K. Santosh with shares of 50% each i-e.
Rs.5O,OOO/ each. Petitioner LLP obtained loan of Rs-25 crores
from the 6th respondent company under MoU dated 13.12-2021,
as per which other covenants a) amount including interest
totalling Rs.45 crores was to be paid on 12-06.2024; and
b) further the 6e respondent coinpany shall be inducted as a
partner with 4oolo share in the LLP. To the said MOU,
lind
were inducted
Respondents 6 and,7 companies
four others
as partners uide supplementary Agreement dated 08 Ol 2022,
totalling eight partners.
3.i.
The contribution/share of the 6e respondent
company was 4O%o; Rs.40,00O/- out of Rs.25 crores was
adjusted towards contribution/ share of the 6th Respondent
Company and balance of Rs.24,99,6O,OOO/- (25,OO,00,0OO/LESS 4O,OO0) was deemed to be the loan extended to Petitioner
LLP by the 6th Respondent Company as per Clause 5O of the
I
LLP Agr,:ement and Section 66 of the LLp Act, 2OOg.
3.2.
Similarly, wrth rcspect to the 7e Respondent, out of
Rs.4.80 crores paid to Petitioner LLp, Rs. 15,OOO/- was adjusted
towards his share / r:ontribution and balance Rs.4,79,g5,000/ was deetned to be loan as stated a,bove. The gist and crr.rx of the
submissions narrated by these respondents reflect that they are
in minoriq, and thr: remaining partners belong to the other
group o: that they are in majority. Taking advantage of the
number:;, petitioner passed Resolution as tailor-made. The
Resolutions which petitioner relied upon is detrimental to the
interests o[ Respondents 6 and 7, therefore, they were not
informed about the meeting. Subsequently, they were informed
ttirough an e-mail of the Board Resolution. . It is further
contendr d that Resolutions were forwarded to the bank without
their kntwledge and rightly respondent banks have rejected
their proposal, therefore, the accounts of the lirm were frozen.
Even the complaint to the Ombudsman fetched the same results
since the issue involvecl in the resolution pertains to the finance
and the interests of the partners are involved. It is not a case
where, ar; stated by petitioner, the consent of respondents was
required expressly me ntioned in the schedule such as
E
dissolution, change of capital structure but does not include
operation of the bank accounts.
3.3.
Respondents also stateci that the Ombudsman, re'
the 3.d Respondent, by proceedings dated 25-08-2o25 impugned
in this Writ Petition, held that "if such disputes are pending
between the partners and are not resolved by the appropriate
forum, such a complaint or representation by the Petitioner LLP
or others is not maintainable." Further, the contents in the
petition of the petitioner are the subject matter of COP No' 15O
of 2025 before the Principal Special Court in the Cadre of the
District Judge for Trial and Disposal o[ Commercial Disputes'
City Civil Court at HYderabad.
3,4.
With regard to the Award passed by the Arbitrator
and the time for challenge, respondents stated that the issue or
dispute is said to be pending and therefore, falls within Para
1O(2[bxii) of the said Scheme. Resting on the issue of Arbitral
Award, Respondents stated that their written arguments dated
l8.O7 .2025 were not even referred to by the lrarned Arbitrator,
leave alone considering them and thus, violating Sections 18,
24, 33 arid 28, 31 (3), 34 (2) (iii) of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act 1996' This is a patent illegality in the Award
q
and therefore, liablc to be set aside under Section 3a (2) (e) of
the 199 3 Act.
3.5.
Responrlents 6 and 7 further contended that Writ
Petition is not malntainable against respondent banks to whom
a direction was sought to permit petitioner to operate the frozen
accounts to deal u,ith financial affairs of the firm.
4.
Heard Ms. Manjari S. Ganu, learned counsel for
petitionor, Ms. N.V. R. Rajya Lakshmi, learned Central
Governntent Star-rding Counsel on behalf of Respondent No.l,
M/s N. Legal, learnt:d counsel on behalf of Respondents 2 and
Smt. Muwa Sri Lakshmi, learned counsel on behalf of
Respoircent No.4 and Sri B. Srinarayana, learned counsel on
behalf oi'Respondents 6 and 7
5.
In support of his contentions, learned counsel relied
on the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Siemens
Engineering & ManuJacturing Co. a. (Jnion of Indiat,
Harban;slal Sahnia o. Indidn Oil Corporationz arrd that of
Allahabad High Cotrrt in Prooieu Constructions Lirnited. a.
Union o.f Indios.
' l tezo.y z sr:c et t
'1u oo:) z sr:c toz
' zoz-s agc.to8:: oB
ia
t0
6.
From a perusal of the documents and after hearing
counsel of both the parties and on a consideration of facts of the
case, it is to be seen, the issue involved is between partners of
LLP and it is not related to Respondent banks, as contended by
petitioner. Further, respondent banks are not
the
instrumentalities of State as per Article 12 of the Constitution'
t
I
I
The Hon'ble SLpremc Court in Federal Bo,nk Ltd. V. Sagar
Thoma.*, hetd that no rvrir- is maintainable against the private
banks since banks have their ou'n resources to raise funds and
the Board of Directors are elected by the shareholders like any
I
other privale company in banking business- Mere regulatory
supervisory role of the State doer: not confer the status of State
on private banks under Article I 2 of the Constitution'
.
With regard to exercise of
extraordinary
discretionary power under Article 226, there must be a violation
of a statutory right or violation of Fundamental Rights and since
there is no such violation in the case on hand, the writ petition
is failed and dismissed. Furthermore, the order of the
Ombudsman is a speaking order and the observations by it are
tenable. Therefore, the issue involved in the Writ Petition cannot
be agitated under Art.226 of the Constitution. Not only that,
(\
o
(zoo:t) io scc 733
1-\_
ll
there ar: disputed questions of fact u.hich cannot be decided by
this Cou rt. 'l'he Writ Petition is thcrefore, liable to be dismissed.
8.
The Writ Pcrition is accordingly, clismissed.
Hou,ever, pctitioner is at liberty to approach thc appropriale
legal forr,rm to ventilirlc their grievance. No costs.
q.
Consequently, the miscellancous Applications, if
any shall stand closr.d.
SD/.MOHD. ISMAIL
,TRUE COPY//
\
DEPUry REGISTRAR
L_---.SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. One CC to MS.MANJARI S.GANU, Advocate. [OPUC]
2. One CC to Ms.N.V.R.RAJYA LAKSHMI, SC for Central Government. [OPUCI
4. One CC to SMT.MUWA SRI LAKSHtvtt, Advocate. [OPUC]
5. One CC to SRI B.NARAYANA, Advocate. [OPUC]
6. Two CD Copies.
8SK
BS \4-
HIGH COTJRT
DATED:0{110112026
$'lr..
S
oo
t ? J A}i 2tl?[
*
*
SFAT
ORDER
WP.No.26652 of 2025
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUTCOSTS
-rt{^
D
Y'#
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review