Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 29TH DAY OF AUGUST, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE LALITHA KANNEGANTI
WRIT PETITION NO. 36205 OF 2024 (GM-CPC)
C/W
WRIT PETITION NO. 34714 OF 2025 (GM-CPC)
IN WP No. 36205/2024
BETWEEN:
M/S SUCO SOUHARADHA SAHAKARI BANK LTD
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR,
HEAD OFFICE AT SUCO BHAVAN,
MOKA ROAD,
BELLARI-583 103
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI.JAYAKUMAR S.PATIL, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI.VIDYAVATHI M. KOTTUR SHETTAR, ADVOCATE)
Digitally
signed by
SUVARNA T
Location:
HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
AND:
RAMESH HEGDE
S/O MAHABALESHWAR HEGDE,
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
OCCUPATION FINANCIAL ADVISOR,
R/O NO.377/6,
‘SHIVAGIRI’, 2ND FLOOR,
4TH MAIN, 8TH CROSS,
P J EXTENSION,
DAVANAGERE-577 002
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI.S.S.NAGANAND, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI.RAVI G. SABHAHIT, ADVOCATE)
-2HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO SET
ASIDE THE IMPUGNED ORDER DATED: 06.11.2024 PASSED BY
THE PRL. DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE, DAVANAGERE, IN
IA NO. 1 IN COM. O.S NO. 95/2023 AS PER ANNEXURE-A.
IN WP NO. 34714/2025
BETWEEN:
M/S SUCO SOUHARADHA SAHAKARI
BANK LTD.,
REPRESENTED BY ITS
MANAGING DIRECTOR,
HEAD OFFICE AT SUCO BHAVAN,
MOKA ROAD,
BELLARI -583 103
...PETITIONER
(BY SRI.JAYAKUMAR S.PATIL, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI.VIDYAVATHI M. KOTTUR SHETTAR, ADVOCATE)
AND:
RAMESH HEGDE
S/O MAHABALESHWAR HEGDE,
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: FINANCIAL ADVISOR
R/O 377/6, 'SHIVAGIRI',
2ND FLOOR, 4TH MAIN,
8TH CROSS, P.J. EXTENSION,
DAVANGERE- 577 002
...RESPONDENT
(BY (BY SRI.S.S.NAGANAND, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI.RAVI G. SABHAHIT, ADVOCATE)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 227 OF
THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT OF
CERTIORARI OR ANY OTHER APPROPRIATE WRIT, AND SET
ASIDE THE IMPUGNED ORDER DATED 18.10.2025 PASSED BY
THE PRINCIPAL DISTRICT AND SESSIONS COURT, IN I.A. NO.3
-3HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
FILED UNDERORDER VII RULE READ WITH SECTION 20 AND
SECTION 151 OF THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908 IN
COM. O.S.95/2023 VIDE ANNEXURE A.
THESE WRIT PETITIONS HAVING BEEN HEARD AND
RESERVED
ON
19.08.2026,
COMING
ON
FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDER THIS DAY, THE COURT
PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM:
HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE LALITHA KANNEGANTI
CAV ORDER
W.P.No.36205/2024
arises
out
of
an
order
dated
06.11.2024, passed on I.A.No.1 filed by the defendant under
Section 151 CPC in Com O.S.No.95/2023, by the Principal
District and Sessions Judge, Davanagere, whereby the trial
Court has rejected the application as it was filed beyond
limitation.
2.
In the very same suit, i.e., Com O.S. No. 95/2023,
IA No.3 is filed under Order VII Rule 10 read with Section 20
and 151 of the CPC. That was also rejected by the order dated
18.10.2025. Questioning that order, W.P. No. 34714/2025 is
filed.
3.
Since both the writ petitions arise out of the
common suit, this Court is disposing of the writ petitions by
way of a common order.
-4HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
4.
This Court is referring to the fact in I.A.No.3 in
Com.O.S.No.95/2023. The facts of the case are that the
Petitioner herein is an Urban Co-operative Bank, registered
under the Karnataka State Souharda Sahakari Act, 1997, and
licensed by the RBI, established in 1995 and operating 29
branches in Karnataka, with an area of operation covering the
entire state. The petitioner Bank and the respondent entered
into an ‘Investment Portfolio Management Services’ agreement
dated 29.06.2016. In respect to the said agreement when
disputes arose, the respondent herein has filed O.S.No.95/2003
on 18.12.2023 against the petitioner for the relief of recovery
of the financial advisory fee of Rs. 86,82,568/- at the rate of
18% interest per annum, among other reliefs. It is stated that,
initially they were under the mistaken belief that the written
statement in the suit had already been filed, later the petitioner
realized the error and filed IA No.1 under Section 151 CPC
along with the written statement on 05.06.2024. The trial Court
rejected IA No.1 by order dated 06.11.2024 on the ground that
the written statement was filed beyond the statutory period.
Questioning that, the petitioner has filed WP No.36205/2024.
-5HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
5.
The petitioner filed IA No.3 under Order VII Rule 10
read with Section 20 and Section 151 CPC. It is the specific
case of the defendant that the nature of the work undertaken
by the plaintiff and the claims made in the suit do not fall
within the purview of the definition of a commercial dispute
under Section 2(1)(c) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. The
scope of the plaintiff’s work was limited to providing guidance
and recommendations, and at no point did the plaintiff exercise
control or authority over the defendant’s business or financial
operations.
Therefore,
the
plaintiff’s
claim
for
alleged
outstanding due does not pertain to any of the defined nature
of relationships, as contemplated under the Act. The suit is
essentially for the recovery of an amount and does not fall
under Section 2(i) of the Commercial Courts Act. It is further
stated that the defendant's registered head office is situated at
SUCO Bhavan, Moka Road, Ballari, and that all operations,
correspondence, and transactions pertaining to the plaintiff's
alleged services were handled exclusively by the head office.
The agreement on which the plaintiff has filed the present suit
was also executed at Bellary. The commercial suit is instituted
-6HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
at Davanagere, which does not have territorial jurisdiction
under Section 20 of the CPC. The plaintiff’s interaction, if any,
was solely with the defendant’s head office in Bellary. There
was no communication, transaction, or engagement with the
defendant’s Davangere branch in relation to the plaintiff’s
services. It is the case that Section 20 of the CPC makes it
explicit that the suit is to be filed in a court where the
defendant resides, carries on business, or where the cause of
action arises, wholly or in part. It is stated that no cause of
action
has
arisen
at
Davangere.
Hence,
the
courts
at
Davangere have no jurisdiction.
6.
The plaintiff filed objections to the application. It is
stated that the dispute is commercial dispute. The claim of the
plaintiff
pertains
to
an
agreement
to
provide
consultancy/advisory services to the defendant Bank, which
squarely falls within the purview of Section 2(1)(c)(x) of the
Commercial Courts Act, 2015. The plaintiff has sought recovery
of Rs.86,82,586/-, which is far above the prescribed limit of
Rs.3,00,000/- under Section 2(1)(i) of the Act. It is stated that
the defendant has wrongly invoked Order VII Rule 10 of the
-7HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
CPC, which deals with the return of the plaint for want of
jurisdiction. However, the defendant has failed to establish that
the court lacks jurisdiction. Section 6 of the Commercial Courts
Act clearly provides that all commercial disputes above the
specified value shall be heard by the Commercial Courts, and
therefore the court has exclusive jurisdiction.
7.
The trial Court has observed that the suit was filed
on 21.12.2023. As per the plaint averments, the plaintiff has
described himself as a certified financial planner offering
Investment Portfolio Management Services under the name and
style Mrs. Hegde Financial Planning Services, Davangere.
Further, the plaintiff is said to be the proprietor of the said
concern. To find out what exactly the nature of the work based
on the documents would be the agreement that has been
enclosed in the above suit. The first agreement, as per the
plaint, executed between the plaintiff and defendant is dated
29.06.2016. The defendant is the Chief Executive Officer, M/s
SUCO Souhardha Sahakari Bank Ltd., Ballari. This agreement
dated 29.06.2016 is said to be true, as per paragraph No. 3 of
the written statement. The agreement has been enclosed in the
-8HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
list of documents furnished by the plaintiff. In this agreement,
the name of the plaintiff is referred to as the investment
advisor, and the defendant as the bank. It is further stated in
the agreement that the investment advisor is a certified
financial planner offering Investment Portfolio Management
Services and that the bank seeks investment advice to
maximize earnings. The court has observed that the nature of
the advice of converting existing investments into tradable lots,
and service charges based on the profits generated or the
benchmark
yield,
whichever
is
higher.
Such
terms
and
conditions fall within the definition of commercial disputes
under Section 2(1)(c) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. This
means that the charge/fee or consultancy, such payments are
straight from the profits of the business task. In this case,
there is banking business, and it falls under disputes envisaged
under the Commercial Courts Act. Hence, the Court has come
to the conclusion that the grounds stated in the IA to return the
plaint under Order VII Rule 10 of the CPC are not made out in
the present set of facts and that there are no grounds to return
the plaint.
-9HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
8.
Learned Senior Counsel, representing the learned
counsel for the petitioner, submits that the trial Court failed to
consider the submission on the issue of territorial jurisdiction,
and even the findings on the ground of the jurisdiction that the
dispute
is
not
a
commercial
dispute
was
not
properly
appreciated by the trial court. It is submitted that when the
head office of the petitioner is situated at Ballari, the
agreement
was
entered
into
at
Ballari,
and
all
service
correspondents pertain to Ballari, the Davangere court lacks
territorial jurisdiction to entertain the suit. It is stated that the
trial court, without applying its mind, mechanically passed the
impugned order without assigning cogent or substantial reasons
and without properly appreciating the law relating to territorial
jurisdiction under Section 20 of the CPC. The Court failed to
take into consideration the fact that, as per Section 6 of the
Commercial Courts Act, commercial disputes ought to be
instituted in accordance with Sections 16 and 20 of the CPC.
The trial court ignored the explanation to Section 6, which
mandates that territorial jurisdiction must be determined in
accordance with the provision. It is submitted that the
- 10 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
respondent's claim for recovery of service fees does not give
rise to any cause of action within the jurisdiction of the
Davangere court, and that the plaint ought to have been
returned for presentation before the competent court at Ballari
in accordance with Order VII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil
Procedure. It is submitted that the court has failed to give any
reasons, and the order impugned needs to be set aside.
9.
Learned Senior counsel representing the learned
counsel for the respondent submits that the court has rightly
dismissed the application. It is submitted that both the
applications are liable to be dismissed. It is submitted that the
plaintiff is at Davangere. He is giving advises by way of emails
from Davangere to the bank at Ballari. Hence, part of the cause
of action has arisen at Davangere, and the trial court has
rightly discussed how this amounts to a commercial dispute.
Learned Senior Counsel has relied on the judgment of the Coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of M/s Vasudeva Rao
& Sons and Another Vs. Smt. Prathiba Devi1. He relied on
paragraph Nos.8, 25 and 27, which read as under:
ILR 2015 KAR 415
- 11 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
“8. To the query by the Court as to how an
application is maintainable even without a
written statement being filed, it was argued
that, the question of jurisdiction can be raised
at any stage of the proceedings. The Court is
bound to consider such question of jurisdiction
and therefore, non filing of the written
statement
cannot
be
held
against
the
defendant.
25. In view of the above, the application filed
under Order VII Rule 10 CPC by the defendants
without filing the written statement was not
maintainable and it ought to have been
rejected in limine without wasting the precious
time of the Court in considering the rival
contentions.
27. In this case, no written statement is filed,
but an application is filed for return of plaint for
presentation before the proper Court. After
termination of the tenancy, the defendants
have been in possession of the property
without paying rent and are interested only in
dragging on the proceedings endlessly. As the
Courts are tolerating this conduct, the entire
judicial system is being ridiculed. It is high time
that the Courts act more responsibly and be
alert in enforcing the mandatory provisions
which are intended to facilitate speedy disposal
of the civil cases and restore the confidence of
the society and litigant public in particular, in
the administration of justice.”
10.
Relying on this, it is submitted that the court has
rightly dealt with both applications, which have been rightly
rejected, and no interference is called for and both the writ
petitions have to be dismissed.
- 12 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
11.
Having heard the learned Senior Counsel on either
side, perused the material on record. In the light of the
contentions raised by the respective parties, the following
issues fall for consideration before this Court:
i. Whether the dispute between the
parties is a commercial dispute within the
meaning of the Commercial Courts Act,
2015?
ii. Whether the Commercial Court at
Davangere has territorial jurisdiction to
entertain the suit?
iii. Whether sending emails and issuing a
notice from Davangere would constitute a
part of the cause of action?
iv.
What is the effect of the written
statement having been filed beyond 120
days?
12.
The
first
issue
is
whether
the
dispute
is
a
commercial dispute. The nature of a dispute has to be gathered
from the transaction between the parties and the relief claimed
in the suit. In the present case, the transaction arises out of an
Investment Portfolio Agreement. The defendant is a bank. The
plaintiff was engaged to render services relating to the
management
of
the
bank's
investment
portfolio
and
to
maximize the bank's earnings from such investments. The
claim for money is directly based on the services said to have
- 13 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
been rendered under that agreement. Section 2(i)(c) of the
Commercial Courts Act,2015
gives a broader meaning to the
expression commercial disputes. It includes disputes arising
from ordinary transactions of bankers, financiers, and traders,
and disputes arising out of investments, agreements, financial
services, and agreements relating to the provision of services.
The present dispute does not arise out of an ordinary private
transaction
between
two
individuals.
It
arises
from
a
professional arrangement concerning the management of a
bank's investment portfolio. The commercial character of the
transaction is therefore apparent. The fact that the defendant
disputes the amount payable or its liability does not alter the
nature of the underlying transaction. The dispute arising out of
the investment portfolio agreement between the plaintiff and
the defendant bank is a commercial dispute within the meaning
of Section 2(i)(c) of the Commercial Courts Act. Accordingly,
the issue is answered in favor of the respondent and against
the petitioner.
13.
The next issue is whether the suit could have been
instituted before the Commercial Courts at Davangere. This
- 14 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
question has to be considered with reference to Section 20 of
the CPC. A suit may be instituted where the defendant resides
or carries on business, or where the cause of action wholly or in
part arises. In the present case, three facts are not in serious
dispute. First, the defendant bank is situated at Ballari. Second,
the investment portfolio agreement was entered into at Ballari.
Third, the services contemplated in the agreement were
required to be rendered at Ballari. These are not incidental
circumstances. They constitute the very foundation of the
commercial relationship between the parties. The plaintiff's
right to claim money arises out of the agreement. The
agreement
was
entered
into
at
Ballari.
The
obligation
undertaken by the plaintiff was also required to be performed
at Ballari. The defendant against whom the money is claimed is
situated at Ballari. Thus, the essential and material facts
constituting the cause of action are connected with Ballari.
There must be material facts forming part of the cause of
action within Davangere before jurisdiction can be assumed by
the court at Davangere. The plaint does not disclose any such
- 15 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
material contractual event at Davangere. The material and
substantial part of the cause of action has arisen at Ballari.
14.
Then the next issue is effect of emails sent from
Davangere. The principal circumstances relied upon by the
plaintiff to confer jurisdiction on Davangere are that emails and
notices
are
sent
from
Davangere.
Merely
because
a
communication is sent from a particular place, that place does
not automatically become part of the cause of action. The test
is whether the fact relied upon is a material, essential, or
integral fact which the plaintiff would have to establish in order
to succeed in the suit. The plaintiff is required to establish the
agreement,
the
rendering
of
service,
approval
of
the
contractual liability, and failure of the defendant to make
payment. The place from which the plaintiff subsequently
chooses to send an email does not constitute an essential fact
for establishing any of these matters. The position can be
tested in a simple manner. Even if the averment that the
emails were sent from Davangere is removed altogether from
the
plaint,
the
plaintiff's
claim
for
recovery
under
the
agreement would remain complete. That itself demonstrates
- 16 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
that sending emails from Davangere is not an integral part of
the
cause
of
action.
The
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
has
consistently held that the fact relied upon for territorial
jurisdiction must have a real nexus with the dispute. Even
though a small fraction of the cause of action is sufficient, that
fraction must nevertheless form a material or integral part of
the cause of action. Mere communication originating from a
particular place does not satisfy the requirement. In view of the
above discussion, the defendant Bank is at Bellary, the
agreement was entered at Bellary, and the services were
required to be rendered at Bellary. The claim for payment
arises out of these services. Hence, this Court is of the view
that no material part of the cause of action had taken place
within the Commercial Court at Davangere. The plaint therefore
requires to be returned for presentation before the court having
territorial jurisdiction. Hence, issue Nos.2 & 3 are answered
against the respondent. Accordingly, the writ petition that is
filed in W.P.No.34714/2025 is allowed by setting aside the
order
dated
18.10.2025,
passed
on
I.A.No.3
in
- 17 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
Com.O.S.No.95/2023 by Prl. District and Sessions Judge,
Davanagere.
15.
Coming to issue No.4, the written statement was
filed beyond 120 days and the Court had rejected the same.
This is a commercial suit. It is settled law, in the light of the
judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in SCG Contracts (India)
Pvt. Ltd. Vs. K.S. Chamankar infrastructure Pvt. Ltd and Ors.,2
that the outer limit of 120 days is mandatory. However, this
Court
has
to
consider
this
application
in
light
of
the
consequences of the return of the plaint. This Court has already
found that the Commercial Court at Davanagere lacks territorial
jurisdiction and that the plaint has to be returned under Order
VII Rule 10 CPC. Once a plaint is returned and presented before
the Court having jurisdiction, the legal consequences of such
presentation have to be governed by Order VII Rule 10 and
10A of CPC. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has recognized that
the presentation of a returned plaint before the competent
court is not to be mechanically equated with the continuation of
every procedural step taken before the Court that lacks
jurisdiction. Therefore, having held that the Davanagere Court
(2019) 12 SCC 210
- 18 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
lacks territorial jurisdiction, it is unnecessary for this Court to
issue any further direction to that court to either receive or
reject the written statement. The legal finding that the
transaction is a commercial dispute and that the commercial
court has to apply the procedure as contemplated under the
Act. The effect of the presentation of the returned plaint and
the stage at which the written statement is to be considered
shall be dealt with by the competent Commercial Court in
accordance with law. In that view of the matter, this Court is
passing the following:
ORDER
i.
The order dated 18.10.2025, passed on
I.A.No.3 in Com.O.S.No.95/2023 by Prl.
District and Sessions Judge, Davanagere,
is
set
aside.
Accordingly,
the
W.P.No.34714/2025 is allowed.
ii.
The plaint has to be presented before the
Competent Commercial Court at Ballari.
After such presentation, it is left to the
Competent
Court
to
determine
the
written statement in accordance with law.
- 19 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:46908
WP No. 36205 of 2024
C/W WP No. 34714 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010748112024
Accordingly, the W.P.No.36205/2024 is
disposed of.
iii.
All I.As. in these petitions shall stand
closed.
SD/(LALITHA KANNEGANTI)
JUDGE
PKN
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 6
*AK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review