Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3300 I
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITIO N NO: 32597 OF 2025
Between:
M/s. Sirpur Paper Mills Limited, Sirpur-Kaghaznagar, Kumaram Bhe-e.m
Asifabad District, Rep. by its Chief Manager - Legal, K.N.Sesha Gopal, S/o.
Late KNS Murthy, Aged about 62 years, Fl/o.Hyderabad.
...PETITIONER
AND
State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Department of Labour,
Secretariat, Hyderabad.
The Commissioner of Labour, Government of Telangana, Aniaiah Bhavan,
Chikkadpally, Hyderabad.
3. The Joint Commissioner of Labour, Government of Telangana, Warangal,
Warangal District.
4. The Deputy Commissioner of Labour, Government of Telangana, Adilabad,
Adilabad District.
5. The General Secretary, Sirpur Paper Mills Workers Union (.[egd,No.E-53)'
Kagaznagar, Sirupur, Khagaznagar, Kumarambheem Asifabad District'
6. The General Secretary, Telugunadu Sirpur Paper Mills Karmika Parishad,
Kagaznagar (Regd.Nb. E-734), Kagaznagar, Sirupur, Khagaznagar,
Kumarambheem Asifabad District.
7. The Sirpur Paper Mills Employees Union, Kagaznagar, Reg.No. E-966'
Kagazndgar, Sirupur, Khagaznagar, Kumarambheem Asifabad District.
B. The General Secretary, Sirpur Paper Mills Employees Sa1-9, Kagaznagar
(Reg.No .E-1028), Kigaznagar, Sirupur, Khagaznagar, Kumarambheem
Asifabad District.
9. The Sirpur Paper Mills Staff Employees Union, Kagaznagar,-Reg. E-1311,
Kagaznigar, Sirupur, Khagaznagar, Kumarambheem Asifabad District.
1O.The General Secretary, Sirpur Paper Mills National Workers Association,
Kagaznaga( Regd. No. E-1425), Kagaznagar, Sirupur, Khagaznagar,
Kumarambheem Asifabad District.
1'l .The General Secretary, Sirpur Paper Mills Telugunadu Karmika Parishad,
Kagaznagar (Regd. No.E-2093), Kagaznagar, Sirupur, Khagaznagar,
Kumarambheem Asifabad District.
1 2.
The Ge,neral Secretary, SirPur Paper Mills Workers and Staff Union,
Kagaznergar, (Reg.No.E-2294),
Kagaznagar, Sirupur,
Khagaznagar,
Kumararnbheem Asifabad District
13.The Prersident, Sirpur Paper Mills National Staff Associatio-n, Kagaznagar
(Regd.No.E-2297), Kagainagar, Sirupur, Khagaznagar, Kumarambheem
Asifabad District.
14.Sirpur F'aper Mills Employees Protection Union, Kagaznagar (Regd No-E23bl ), N.agaznagar, Sirupur, Khagaznagar, Kumarambheem Asifabad District.
1s.The G€,neral Secretary, Sirpur Paper Mills Mazdoor Union, Kagaznagar
(Regd.Nlo.E-2510), Kagaznagar, Sirupur, Khagaznagar, Kumarambheem
AsifabarJ District. The General Secretary,
16.The Pn:sident, SPM Staff Welfare Association, Reg. No., Kagaznagar E27 06, Kagaznagar, Sirupur, Khagaznagar, Kumarambheem Asifabad District.
17.The Ge;neral Secretary, Telangana SPM Employees Union, Kagaznagar
Regd. No.E-2735, Kagaznagar, Sirupur, Khagaznagar, Kumarambheem
Asifaba,l District.
1B.The Gr>neral Secretary, Sirpur Paper Mills Telangana Workers Union,
Kagaznagar (Regd.No.E-2863), Kagaznagar, Sirupur, Khagaznagar,
Kumara mbheem Asifabad District.
19.The G3neral Secretary, SPM Permanent and Casual Workers Union,
Kagaznagar, Reg.No.48/DCL-ADB, Kagaznagar, Sirupur, Khagaznagar,
Kumararmbheem Asifabad District.
...RESPONDENTS
Petitiorr under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstance,s stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ of Mandamus or any other appropriate Writ, Order or
Orders, Direction or Directions to declare the action of the Respondents 3 and 4
in proceedingl to conduct Secret Ballot Election to determine the majority union
under the Code of Discipline in the petitioner factory vide Letter No.4/390/2024,
d1.22.10.202t1 as arbitrary, unreasonable and illegal and to set aside the said
letter and to issue a consequential direction to the Respondents 3 and 4 not to
proceed in any manner to conduct Secret Ballot Election to decide the majority
union in the petitioner factory until the disqualification incurred by the unions is
decided in accordance with the provisions of the Trade Unions Act.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the Respondents 3 and 4 not to proceed in any manner in furtherance to
the letter No.A/390/2024, dt.22.10.2024 issued by the 4th Respondent proposing
to conduct Secret Ballot Election to determine the majority Union under the Code
of Discipline in the petitioner factory, pending disposal of the Writ Petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SMT VEDULA CHITRALEKHA
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 to 4: GP FOR LABOUR
Counsel for the Respondent No.S: SRI B.JITHENDER
Gounsel for the Respondent No.7: SRI M.SHANKAR
Counsel for the Respondent No.15: SRI ABID HUSSAIN
Counsel for the Respondent No.8, 14 & 17: SRI POCHAIAH DORISHETTI
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
H:ON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION No. 32597 OF 2O25
o,9.oL.20/26
Between:
M/s Sirpur Paper Mills Ltd.,
Sirpurkzrgaznagar
Petitioner
And
State of Telangana,
Rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Departrrrent of Labour and others
Respondents
ORDER:
Petitioner, one of the oldest paper mills in the
country. originally established during 1939-1940 in the then
backward area of Adilabad District, with commercial production
having commenced in 1942 at Sirpur Kagaznagar. They are
engaged in manufacture of various kinds of paper and paper
boards, having market presence even outside India. It is stated
that petitioner provides employment to nearly 85O regular staff
and
"vo;:kers
and about 1,400 contract workers. A full-fledged
township comprising schools, markets, police station,
recreati,rnal facitities and hospitals was developed primarily for
the ben,:fit of employees of petitioner.
aU' #
1.
1.
It is contended that for reasons beyond the control
of the then management, petitioner company became a sick
industrial unit and its net worth was erocled. or.r,ing to severe
lack of working capital, petitioner stopped its operations in
2014. Thereafter, operational creditors initiated proceedings
under Section 9 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016,
which were admitted by the National Company Law Tribunal
and registered as CP (lB) No. 5219 /HDBl2Ot7. A resolution
plan submitted by the Resolution Professional and approved by
the Committee of Creditors came to be sanctioned by NCLT by
order dated 19.07.2018. Pursuant thereto, the management of
petitioner company was taken over by J.K. Paper, and the
company is presently being operated strictly in accordance with
the approved resolution plan.
L.2.
It is stated, prior to suspension of operations in
2014, as many as 15 trade unions were functioning in petitioner
factory. The factory remained non-functional for more than four
years and during this prolonged closure period, trade unions
also became defunct. According to petitioner, most of these
trade unions faited to submit annual returns from 2OOg up to
2023 and also did not comply with the statutory requirements
under the Trade Unions Act, 1926, including payment of
necessary fees to the Registrar of Trade Unions, thereby
/
/
J
rendering their registrations invalid. It is further stated that
after revival of the unit pursuant to NCLT-approved resolution
plan, pr:titioner entered into a Memorandum of Settlement
under Section 12(3) read with Section 18(1) of the Industrial
Disputesr Act, 1947 with the representatives of the Works
Committee. The said settlement was signed in the presence of
and atte ste<l by the Joint Commissioner of Labour, Warangal,
on 03.O 1 .2023. The settlement, according to petitioner, has
statutoqr force and is valid till 31.03.2026. [t is contended that
the saicl scttlement governs various service conditions and
grievance redressal mechanisms for workmen during its
subsistence.
1.3.
Petitioner states that when one of the trade unions
requeste'd the Deputy Commissioner of Labour, Adilabad, to
recognize a union by conducting a secret ballot election, the
said atrthority addressed the letter dated 22.LO.2024 to
petitiont:r seeking information regarding trade unions
functior ing in the factory. Petitioner replied to the said
commurrication on 28.10.2024, informing the authority that
trade urrions which existed prior to closure of factory in 2Ol4
had fail,:d to file annual returns and comply with the provisions
of the L926 Act, therefore, according to petitioner, there was no
validly-<:xisting trade union in the factory.
j
l
I
,{
1.4.
It is contended that thereafter, the Joint
Commissioner of Labour, Warangal, addressed letter dated
25.O3.2O25 calling upon petitioner to furnish details regarding
strength of employees before closure of factory and after
reopening. Petitioner submitted the requisite information on
OI.O4.2O25 and also brought to the notice of the authority the
clauses contained in the resolution plan approved by the NCLT.
It is further stated that the Joint Commissioner of Labour,
Warangal, again addressed letter dated O8-O4.2O25 seeking
copies of the NClT-approved resolution plan, details of amounts
paid to workmen towards final settlement under the resolution
plan, and copies of closure orders, if any, passed by the
Government. Petitioner furnished the said information uide
letter dated 18.04.2025 and requested the Authorit5r to act
strictly in accordance with the provisions of the 1926 Act.
1.5.
Petitioner states that thereafter, the Deputy
Commissioner of Labour, Adilabad was appointed as Returning
Officer by proceedings dated 09.1O.2025. Subsequently,
petitioner received letter dated 22.10.2025 from the Deputy
Commissioner of Labour, Adilabad, st5rling himself as Returning
Officer, informing that meeting was fixed on 28.10.2025 in his
office for the purpose of conducting secret ballot election to
determine the majority union under the Code of Discipline in
-ijd
petitione:: factory. The said letter was also circulated to all the
trade un ions calling upon them to send two representatives
each.
1.6.
Petitioner contends that the decision of the official
responde'nts to proceed with the conduct of secret ballot election
is arbitrary, erroneous and illegal. Respondent trade unions
have fail,:d to submit annual returns for more than a decade, as
evidenced by information obtained under the Right to
Information Act, and have thereby incurred disqualification
under the Act. Despite this being repeatedly brought to the
notice o[ respondent auihorities, no determination has been
made rel3arding the status or validity of the said trade unions. It
is furtht:r contended that settlement dated 03.01.2023 entered
into uncer Section 12(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 is
presentl'y in florce till 3L.O3.2O26 and has statutory force.
During r;ubsistence of the said settlement, initiation of elections
to decide the majority union is, according to petitioner, wholly
unneces sary and unjustified.
L.7 .
Petitioner states that factory remained closed
between 2Ol4 and 2018 due to accumulated losses and was
revived only pursuant to the resolution plan sanctioned by the
NCLT. lrt this critical stage of revival, conducting trade union
election's would create serious dif{icutties in day-to-day
./
administration, adversely affect labour relations, disrupt mill
production, and impede the implementation of the resolution
plan. It is apprehended that such developments may thror,r,
petitioner back into losses and jeopardize the rehabilitation of
the industrial unit.
1.8.
It is further pleaded that unless respondent
authorities first decide the issue of disqualilication allegedly
incurred by the trade unions on account of non-filing of annual
returns for several years, they cannot proceed with election
process. Proceeding with elections without such determination
would, according to petitioner, result in disturbed industrial
relations. Petitioner alleges that the proposal to conduct
elections has been brought about under extraneous influence
and is intended to upset the streamlined functioning of the
revived factory. It is asserted that petitioner's interest is
dependent on successful implementation of NClT-approved
resolution plan and that any creation of human resource
problems at this stage would be detrimental to the survival of
the unit.
2.
Respondents 1 to 4 filed a common counter affidavit
through Respondent No.4 contending that writ petition is not
maintainable either in law or on facts. It is admitted that
petitioner company became a sick industrial unit and stopped
/
/
its activities in 2aA and that operational creditors initiated an
Application under Section 9 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy
Code, 2016 for corporate insolvency resolution, which was
admitterl by NCLT. Petitioner company was taken over by M/s
J.K. Paller pursuant to the resolution plan approved by NCLT
and that the company is presently being run under the said
resolution plan. It is also admitted, prior to suspension of
operations in 2014, there were 15 trade unions functioning in
petitionr:r factory. The mill remained non-functional for more
than forrr years and during this period, the trade unions also
became defunct and that most of the trade unions did not file
annual returns from 2oo9 to 2023 as required under section 28
of the Act read with Rule 18 of the Andhra Pradesh Trade Union
Regulations, 1927.
3.
It is admitted that petitioner entered into a
Memore.ndum of settlement under section 12(31 read with
Section 18(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, L94z with the
represe:rtatives of the works committee and that the said
settlemr:nt was signed by the Joint commissioner of Labour,
warangal, on 03.01.2023. It is admitted that the settrement is
valid up to 3l.03.2026 and has statutory force under the
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. It is contended that Respondent
No.17 submitted a representation to the Deputy commissioner
of Labour, Adilabad, seeking conduct of a secret ballot election
for recognition of a trade union. The Deputy Commissioner of
Labour, being the Deputy Registrar under the provisions of the
1926 Act, is duty bound to conduct secret.ballot election to
verify the majority union under the Code of Discipline.
3.1.
It is stated that in discharge of the said statutory
duff, the Deputy Commissioner of Labour addressed a letter to
petitioner company seeking information regarding the trade
unions functioning in the mitl. Petitioner replied on 28.10.2024
stating that trade unions which existed prior to closure of the
factory in 2014 had failed to file annual returns, did not comply
with the provisions of the Trade Unions Act, and had therefore,
lost their certificates of registration, and that no valid trade
union existed in the factory. The Joint Commissioner of Labour,
Warangal, addressed letter dated 25.03.2025 calling upon
petitioner to submit details regarding the strength of employees
before closure of the factory and after reopening, which
information was furnished by the petitioner on Ol .O4.2O25.
3.2.
It is further stated that the Joint Commissioner of
Labour, Warangal, addressed another letter dated Oa-O4.2O25
calling upon petitioner to submit copies of the resolution plan
approved by the NCLT, details of amounts paid to workmen
towards final settlement under the resolution plan, and copies
j
(/
I
t
I
t
I
I
of clos'-rre orders passed by the Government. Petitioner
submitt,:d the said information uide letter dated 18.04.2025 and
requestt:d the Authority to act in accordance with the provisions
of the Trade Unions Act. Vide Proceedings Memo No.
B/68312024 dated Og.lO.2025, the Deputy Commissioner of
Labour, Adilabad, was appointed as Returning Officer to
conducl verification under the Code of Discipline in the
petition,:r company.
3.3.
It is stated that pursuant thereto, the Deputy
Commis;sioner of Labour addressed letrer dated 22.10.2025 to
petition:r requiring attendance at a meeting on 28.1O.2025 and
issued r;imilar communications to all trade unions. It is denied
that thr: decision to conduct secret ballot election to determine
the majcrity union is arbitrary, erroneous or illegal. The purpose
of conducting such election is to maintain industrial peace and
good industrial relations between management and workmen
and thrtt it will not cause any disturbance to petitioner. It is
specifically contended that there is no clause in the settlement
entered into under Section 12(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act,
1947 llrohibiting the conduct of secret ballot election to
determine the majority union.
3.4.
Respondent Nos. I to 4 deny the contention of the
petitioner that failure of trade unions to submit annual returns
l0
for several years results in automatic cancellation of
registration. It is contended that there is no provision under the
1926 Act providing for cancellation of registration merely on
account of non-filing of annual returns It is asserted that
Section 28 of the Trade Unions Act, 1926 mandates filing of
annual returns but does not provide for cancellation of
registration as a consequence of default. Respondent Nos. 1 to 4
further contend that Section 10 of the Trade Unions Lct, L926
alone governs cancellation or withdrawal of registration and that
such cancellation can be effected only on the grounds specified
therein and only after issuing prior notice of not less than two
months to the concerned trade union and following due
procedure.
3:5.
It is contended that non-filing of annual returns
does not automatically result in de-recognition or cancellation of
registration and that the contention of the petitioner to the
contrary is not in accordance with the provisions of the 1926
Act. Sections 5, 8 and 10 of the Act, 1926 clearly establish the
legal framework for the existence, registration and continuation
of trade unions and that the object and intention of the Act is
welfare of employees. It is contended that for the welfare of
employees, the existence of trade unions and conduct of
elections is necessary and required. It is asserted that the
/
/
----;,-_.
ll
ground l:aken by petitioner that merely because rinnual returns
were nct filed, elections should not be conducted, is
unsustainable in law and that the authorities are following the
procedure prescribed under the Act and the Rules.
3.6.
Respondents I to 4 further contended that in the
absence of any provision prohibiting the conduct of elections,
the authorities are empowered to proceed in accordance with
law for the u,elfare of the State and people at large, in
consonance with the directive principles of State policy under
the Coestitution of India. It is denied that the official
respondents are acting under the influence of local politicians. It
is contended that the action taken is strictly in accordance with
statutory provisions and within jurisdiction. Respondents 1 to 4
conclude that the contention of petitioner that failure to hle
annual returns for over a decade would result in de-recognition
and consequently bar conduct of elections is incorrect and
contranr to the Trade Unions Act, 1926.
4.
Respondent No.S filed counter contending that the
writ petition is wholly misconceived, devoid of merit and liable to
be disnrissed in limine, being untenable both on facts and in
law. It is stated, Writ Petition has been filed with a malicious
intention to mislead this court and to misuse the process of law
for the purpose of obstructing the respondent g=T^_:1t
.
a:l
t2
offrcials, particularly Respondents 2 and 4, from discharging
their statutory duty of conducting trade union elections. It is
contended that the object of the writ petition is to deprive the
workmen of the petitioner factory of their constitutional,
statutory and legal rights to form trade unions and to
democratically elect a union of their choice for collective
bargaining to secure better terms and conditions of service. tt is
further contended that the writ petitioner has not f,rled any
authorization to institute the present writ petition.
It is stated that company had been continuously
4.1.
incurring losses from 2OO7 onwards, but the management made
no effort whatsoever to effect a turnaround until 2014.
Petitioner management abruptly and suddenly closed the
factory operations in 2Ol4 without issuing any notice and
without obtaining permission from the State Government. No
application seeking permission for closure was submitted to the
Government. [t is further contended that petitioner approached
the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR)
and the Government of Telangana seeking a revival package or
financial assistance only after closure of operations, and that
had the management taken timely steps during the initial years
when accumulated losses were still within manageable limits,
suspension of operations could have been avoided'
/
/
l3
4.2.
Respondent No.5 contends that due to sheer
negligerce of petitioner management, accumulated losses
mounte,l to several hundred crores of rupees. Alter closing the
factory, top-ranking officers of petitioner compan]/ left the town
under covcr of darkness, rendering about i,5OO regular
employr:cs and an equal number of contract labourers jobless
overnight, thereby affecting nearly 3,000 families. During the
period ol closure of about 46 months, the employees and
n,orkme n rvere neither retrenched nor laid off. Tlll 22.IO.2016,
when krnder banks led by IDBI seized and sealed the factory
premise s, the employees were allowed to mark attendance, yet
were nct paid salaries or even subsistence allowance despite not
being fcrrmally retrenched or laid off. Respondent No.5 contends
that nc, enquiry was conducted by the Government into the
reasons for closure of such a major industrial establishment or
into thr: non-payment of salaries and wages to the workmen,
resultirg in the then management of the petitioner company
remainjng unaccounted and unpunished for the alleged illegal
closure.
4.3.
It is further contended that Respondent No.3
addresr;ed letters dated 25.03.2025 and O8.O4.2O25 calling
upon petitioner management to submit closure orders, if any,
issued b-y the Government, however, Petitioner failed to submit
t4
any such document and deliberately avoided responding to this
issue in its reply letters dated OI.O4.2O25 dated 18.04.2025.
From the above conduct, it is evident that the erstwhile
management of petitioner company had closed down its
operations illegally, without notice and without obtaining
permission from the Government. With regard to takeover of
petitioner company by M/s J.K. Paper, Respondent No.S
contends that ever since reopening of the factory in August
2018, the present management has been indulging in illegal
acts and unfair labour practices. Though the resolution plan
approved by the NCLT does not provide for downsizing of the
workforce and no notice was issued for reduction of manpower,
the management drastically reduced the workers' strength and
dld not allow about 26O workmen to resume duty'
It is contended that the said 260 workmen were
4.4.
neither retrenched nor assigned any reason for being denied
resumption of dury and that they and their families have been
facing Severe financial hardship for more than eleven years;
extrerqely low basic wages and dearness allowance are being
paid to the workmen who were allowed to join drty, despite the
legal requirement that such wages be on par with those
prevailing in other major paper and paperboard establishments
in the region. It is further contended that the monthly
/
/
.€
l5
production bonus has been reduced to about half of what was
being paid prior to closure. It is alleged, the electricit5r
allowanr:e and thc number of earned leave days have been
unilaterrlly reduced by the management. It is also contended
that the canteen, where breakfast and lunch were supplied to
r,r,orkmen prior to closure, has been illegally kept closed even
though more than seven years have elapsed since reopening of
the factrlry.
4.5.
Respondent No.S states that petitioner company
remained closed from 27.o9.2014 to o1.08.2018, i.e. for about
46 months. The allegation made by petitioner that trade unions
operatir,g in the company became defunct during this period
and thal most of the unions did not submit annual returns from
2oo9 to 2023 is categorically denied as false and baseless. It is
contended that petitioner has vaguely alleged that 'most of the
unions'did not submit annual returns without specifying the
number or identity of such unions. It is further contended that
the alle,3ation regarding non-payment of fees to the Registrar of
Trade Lnions is meaningless, as no fee is required to be paid to
the Registrar once a trade union is registered. Respondent No.5
asserts that he has continuously submitted annual returns up
to the year 2023 and that the allegations made by petitioner are
intendel to tarnish the image of the trade unions operating in
t./.
I
\
t6
t\
the company. Respondent No.S challenges the validity of the
settlement dated 03.01.2023 entered into between petitioner
management and representatives of the Works Committee,
contending that settlement is illegal, ab initio uoid and liable to
be quashed. It is contended that a Works Committee under the
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 is empowered only to promote
good relations and comment on matters of common interest and
cannot deal with terms of employment, which fall exclusively
within the domain of trade unions.
It is contended that in an industrial establishment
4.6.
where a registered trade union exists, any settlement touching
upon terms of employment must be entered into only with the
trade union and not with any other body. It is further contended
that the settlement was entered into r,r'ith a fragmented Works
Committee comprising only a portion of its members, which is
legally impermissible, as a statutory body must act as a whole.
Respondent No.S further contends that petitioner management
influenced members of the fragmented Works Committee, who
had no authority to enter into such settlement, and thereby
deprived the workmen of fair and legitimate terms of
employment. It is alleged that the Joint Commissioner of
Labour, Warangal, despite being aware of the legal position and
existence of trade unions, acted itlegally by af{-rxing his
/
i
t7
signature and official seal to the said settlement, 'uvhich has no
legal or statutory force.
4.7.
Responclent No.S states that information regarding
rcgistere,l trade unions and their annual returns is available
rvith the Deputy Commissioner of Labour, Adilabad, in his
capacity as Registrar o[ Trade Unions, therefore it was
unnecessary to seek such information from the employer. It is
contendr:d that petitioner's reply dated 28.10.2024 to the letter
clated 2').1O.2024 is false, misconceived and unwarranted' It is
asserted that filing of annual returns is a legal formality
between registered trade unions and the Registrar of Trade
Unions and that the employer has no role whatsoever in this
process. It is contended that petitioner had no authority to
assume thc role of an investigating agency and declare that
trade trnions hacl lost their registration or ceased to exist'
Respondent No.S states that the Deputy commissioner of
Labour, Adilabad, was duly appointed as Returning Oflicer by
the Co:nmissioner of Labour and that letter dated 22.10'2025
clearly states such appointment. tt is contended that the said
Ietter rvas not issued suddenly, as correspondence regarding
conduc:t of elections had been ongoing since 22.10.2024.
4.g.
It is contended that petitioner management has
deliberately raised false and baseless allegations and created
l8
hurdles in order to delay the election process and to falsely
project that no valid trade union exists in' the company.
Respondent No.5 further states that petitioner's reliance on
information obtained under the Right to Inforrhation Act is
misplaced. The letter of Public Information officer dated
25.O9.2024 clearly states that fifteen trade unions are existing
in the company and that copies of annual returns filed from
2Ol3 to 2023 would be supplied on payment of prescribed
charges. It is contended that even in cases of non-submission of
annual returns or other violations, disqualihcation or
deregistration of a trade union is never automatic and can occur
only after due process under tlrre 1926 Act. Petitioner never filed
any Application before the Registrar of Trade Unions seeking
cancellation of registration of any union.
Respondent No.5 asserts that apprehension of
4.9.
petitioner that conduct of elections would disrupt mill
production, labour relations or implementation of the resolution
plan is wholly unfounded and reflects an anti-labour and anti-
union mindset. Trade unions are lawful bodies constituted
under the Trade Unions Act and that workmen enjoy a
fundamental right to association under the Constitution. It is
contended that labour is a basic factor of production and that
petitioner is attempting to stall elections because recognition of
/
I
t9
a trade uaiotr rnould subject its illegal and anti-labour practices
to scrutiny. It is also contended, petitioner has not exhausted
the alternative statutory remedy of approaching the Registrar of
Trade Unions, therefore cannot invoke the extraordinary
jurisdicticn oI this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution'
4.10.
It is contended that trade union elections were last
conductt,d in the petitioner company in 2O13 and that more
than tlvclve years have elapsed '*'ithout recognition of any
union, even though more than seven years have passed since
reopenirg of the factory. It is concluded that Writ Petition has
been file cl solely to deprive workmen of their fundamental right
to association and to restrain trade unions from exercising their
statutory rights.
5:RespondentNo.Tfiledcounterdenyingthe
averments of Writ Petition. It is stated that petitioner challenged
only tht: Ietter addressed by the 4u' respondent but not against
any orrlers, thus filing the Writ Petition without any filing
objecticns to the said letter is premature and misconceived'
Even in the event o f passing any orders by the official
respontlent.s by exercising their statutory powers also, effective
alternative remedies are available under the Industrial Disputes
Act arrd Trade Unions Act, thus the Writ Petition is not
maintainable in the eye of law. In this context, Respondent No'7
relied on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Ndtional Fertilizers Ltd. o. P.K.Khdnttd7, wherein it was held
that 'learned counsel appearing on behatf of the respondent
sought to take us through the enquiry officer's report to
contend that the disciplinary authority had not correctly
appreciated the objections taken by the respondent to the
report. That is normally not a plea which is available as a
ground for judicial review (see Indian oil corpn. Ltd. a. Ashok
Kumar Aroral. Nevertheless, it would be open to the
respondent to raise all such grounds before the Appellate
Authority, who should deal with the same.'
It is also stated, by letter dated 25.09.2024 issued
5.1.
by the 4th respondent, eight trade unions have fiIed annual
ieturns ancl copies are available to that effect from the period
2OL3 to 2023, but petitioner has suppressed the said facts and
they filed replies to the Labour Department on 28.10.2025 after
filing the writ Petition without disclosing pendency of the
present Writ Petition. This constitutes fraud, misrepresentation
and suppression of material facts. In this context, Respondent
No.7 relied on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme court in
K.D.Sharmr v. 9AII? wherein it was held that 'It is therefore,
' (zoos) 7 scc 597
lzooay l2 scc 481
/
/
2t
of utmo,st necessity that the petitioner approaching the rvrit
court m.rst come ,*'ith clean hands, put forward all the facts
before t,re court rvithout concealing or suppressing anything
and see[: an appropriate relief. If there is no candid disclosure of
relevant and material facts or the petitioner is guilty of
misleading the court, his petition may be dismissed at the
threshold without considering the merits of the claim.'
6.
Respondent No. 15 also filed a counter affidavit
contending that he is the General Secretary of Sirpur Paper
Mills Mirzdoor Union, Kagaznagar, bearing Registration No. E25LO, a:rd that he is well-acquainted with the facts of the case.
It is stzrted that petitioner seeks to quash lawful proceedings
initiatecl by Respondent Nos. 3 and 4, namely the labour
authoril:ies, for conducting secret ballot elections under the
Code o[ Discipline to determine the majority representative
union, which is a statutory process mandated for maintaining
industr al harmony. It is contended that the action of the
labour authorities in initiating the process of secret ballot
elections is in consonance with Section 9 of the Industrial
Disputr:s Act, L947 read with the Code of Discipline, and is
intended to secure the right of workmen to collective bargaining
as gua::anteed under Article 19(1)(c) of the Constitution. It is
further contended that petitioner's allegations regarding trade
b
unions being defunct and the alleged disruption to
implementation of the resolution plan under the Insolvency and
Bankruptcy Code, 2016 are unsubstantiated and contrary to
settled law, as recognition of trade unions canlot be indefinitely
stalled after revival of the industrial establishment.
6.1.
It is stated, Respondent No. 15 and other trade
unions duly complied with the notice issued by the Deputy
Commissioner of Labour in November 2024 and submitted all
required details, annual returns and acknowledgements within
the stipulated time, namely by O3.11.2024. Historical practice
since Ig78 in petitioner factory demonstrates that biennial
secret ballot elections and triennial wage settlements with
recognized trade unions were the norm, and that this
dstablished practice was disrupted only due to the illegal
closure of the mill between 2014 and 2018. It is asserted that
no deregistration of any trade union has taken place and that,
even after revival of the factory, elections for union recognition
have remained overdue. It is contended, petitioner's reliance on
the settlement dated 03.O1 .2O2g purportedly entered into under
Section 1S(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 with a Works
Committee is misplaced. Such a settlement cannot substitute
statutory recognition of a trade union under the Code of
J
Discipline and cannot override the rights of workmen
guaranl-eed under the Industrial Disputes Act.
6.2.
Respondent No. 15 states that workmen of Sirpur
Paper I\4ills are undergoing scverc hardship due to the absence
of a r'lcognized trade union; they are being denied basic
amenities such as a proper canteen, annual leave and job
securihr, creating an atmosphere of fear and insecurity. Prior to
illegal closure of factory in20 13, there were about 1,05O regular
workerr;, 4OO staff members and 1,600 contract workers
employ,:d in petitioner factory. After revival of the factory,
petitioner management provided employment only to about 397
regular workers, 360 staff members and approximately 84O plus
650 contract workers, and that even thereafter around 100
workerri are still awaiting reinstatement. It is further stated, on
the one: hand, petitioner management has not permitted several
regular workers to resume their regular duties, and on the
other, it is raising objections alleging that trade unions do not
have 1tl0 members or lOo/o of the total existing workforce, that
unions are defunct, and that annual returns were not
submitted, which conduct is stated to be unfair and unjustified.
6.3.
It is contended that though production resumed
about s;even years ago, elections for recognition of trade unions
have not been conducted since then. Absence of a reco gnized,
!
I
I
t
union has left workmen without any legitimate lorum to present
grievances or negotiate with the management. [t is asserted that
informal worker committees formed by employees have failed to
secure constructive recognition from the management and that
workers continue to function under fear and insecurity due to
lack of union protection. It is also stated, failure of the
management to provide basic amenities such as a minimum
comfortable canteen and the d.enial of previously enjoyed annual
leave have aggravatecl the distress of the 'uyorkers- Despite a
memorandum submitted by Respondent No. l5 to the Deputy
commissioner of LaboLlr, A.clitabacl. highlighting these
grievances, no tangible response or intervention has occurred
for a period of about three months. It is contended that
cbnducting secret ballot elections is essential to facilitate
collective bargaining and to prevent industrial unrest and the
delay in conducting elections violates Article 43 of the
Constitution of India, which mandates living wages and decent
conditions of work for labour.
It is contended that union elections promote stable
6.4.
labour relations and in fact aid implementation of the resolution
plan rather than hindering it. It is asserted that the [nsolvency
and Bankruptcy code, 2016 prioritizes revival through
operational continuity and that labour laws operate
/
\
/
concurrently with insolvency proceedings without any conflict.
The lett.er dated 22.10.2025 issued by the labour authorities
merely schedules a preliminary meeting and constitutes a
procedu.ral step well within their jurisdiction.
7.
Heard Smt. Vedula Chitalekha, learned counsel for
petitioner, Iearned Government Pleader for Labour on behalf of
Respon,lents 1 to 4, Sri B. Jithender, learned counsel for
Respon,lent No.5, Sri M. Shankar, learned counsel for
Respon,lent No.7, Sri Abid Hussain, learned counsel for
ResponCent No.15, Sri Pochaiah Dorishetti, learned counsel for
ResponCents 8, 14 and 17.
8.
The principal issue that falls for consideration is
whether the action of the respondent labour authorities in
proceeciing to conduct a secret ballot election to determine the
majorit'y representative trade union under the Code of Discipline
is arbitrary, illegal, without jurisdiction or otherwise vitiated so
as to warrant interference by this Court in exercise of its
extraorCinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution
of Indie-.
9.
At the outset, it is not in dispute that multiple
trade unions are registered in relation to petitioner
establir;hment and that a representation was submitted by one
such registered trade union seeking recognition through a
secret ballot election. It is also not in dispute that the Deputy
Commissioner of Labour, Adilabad, was duly appointed as the
Returning officer/verification officer by the competent
authorily, namely the commissioner of Labour, and that the
impugned communication clated 22.1o.2025 merely schedules a
meeting on 28.10.2025 as a preliminary step in the verification
process contemplated under the Code of Discipline'
The fulcrum of petitioner's challenge rests on the
10.
assertion that respondent trade unions have failed to file annual
returns for several years and that such non-filing has resulted
in automatic cancellation of registration or de-recognition,
thereby disabling the labour authorities from proceeding with
the election process. This Court is unable to accept the said
cbntention. A plain and conjoint reading of the provisions of the
Trade Unions Act, 1926, particularly Sections 8, 1O and 28,
does not support the theory of automatic cancellation or derecognition on account of non-filing of annual returns. Section
28 mandates the filing of annual returns by registered trade
unions; however, the Act does not prescribe automatic cessation
of registration as a consequence of default. Section 1O of the Act
specifically governs withdrawal or cancellation ef registration
and clearly stipulates the grounds on which such cancellation
may be effected, the authority competent to do so, and the
/
/
requirernent of prior notice and adherence to the principles of
natural justice.
i.
Admittedly, no order has been passed by the
Registrurr of Trade Unions cancelling or withdrawing registration
of any of the respondent trade unions. It is also not the case of
petitioner that any application seeking cancellation of
registration was liled before the Registrar of Trade Unions and
adjudicated upon. In the absence of any such determination by
the conrpetent statutory authority, this Court cannot presume
that rer;pondent trade unions stand disqualified or have ceased
to exisl: in the eye of law. The submission of petitioner that
labour authorities were bound to first determine the alleged
disqualification of the trade unions before initiating the election
process, cannot be accepted. Unless and until registration of a
trade u.nion is cancelled in accordance with Section 1O of the
Trade Unions Act, L926, the union continues to exist as a
registered trade union and is entitled to participate in the
statutory process of verification and recognition under the Code
of Disc. pline.
12.
Existence of a settlement dated 03.O1 .2023 entered
into urrder Section 12(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act, Lg47,
though having statutory force for the period of its operation,
does not operate as a bar on .the conduct of a secret ballot
I
t
t
\
.:l::.:
:
:. i
election for the purpose of d.etermining the majority
representative union. The settlement governs the matters agreed
upon therein, but it does not extinguish or override the
statutory mechanism for recognition of trade unions,
particularly when the settlement itself does not contain any
clause prohibiting or deferring such elections'
13.
The apprehension expressed by petitioner that
conduct of elections would distr-rrb industrial peace, adversely
affect day-to-day operations, impede implementation of the
resolution plan approved by the National Company Lau'
Tribunal, or jeopardize the revival of the unit is speculative and
unsupported by any tangible material. on the contrary, the very
object of the Code of Discipline and the process of secret ballot
election is to promote orderly industrial relations, provide a
legitimate and democratic representative mechanism for
workmen, and ensure industrial harmony'
L4.Theallegationsofextraneousinfluenceormala
are bald and
fides on the part of the labour authorities
unsupported by €Lny cogent material. The record indicates that
the authorities have acted within the bounds of their statutory
duties and in accordance with the procedure contemplated
under the Trade Unions Act, L926, the Industrial Disputes Act,
tg47 and the Code of Discipline. This Court also finds that the
/
issues :aised by petitioner, particularly relating to compliance
by trade unions with statutory requirements, filing of annual
returns and their continued existence, involve disputed
questio es of fact. Such issues are requi
be examined and
adjudicated by the competent statutory authorities under the
Tracle Llnions Act, 1926 and are not amenable to determination
in procr:edings under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
15.
i
i
i
I
I
I
i
Petitioner has an efficacious statutory remedy
availab e in law to approach the Registrar of Trade Unions, if so
advised, for appropriate relief in accordance with the provisions
of the 'lrade unions Act, 1926. without availing or exhausting
a
I
I
I
I
i
such rr:medy, they petitioner cannot seek to invoke the writ
jurisdiction of this court to stall a statutory process undertaken
J
I
by the labour authorities. In the totality of the circumstances,
this ccurt is of the considered view that action of the
respontlent labour authorities in proceeding to conduct a secret
i
I
I
l
ballot t:lection to determine the majorit5r representative union
under t.he code of Discipline does not suffer from arbitrariness,
illegality or lack of jurisdiction. consequently, no case is made
out for interference by this court under Article 226 of the
Constitution.
16.
,
For the aforesaid reasons, this Court holds that
writ Pr:tition is devoid of merit. The action of the respondent
I
{--t
labour authorities in proceeding with the process of conducting
a secret ballot election to determine the maiority representative
trade union under the Code of [riscipline cel"nnot be said to be
arbitrary, unreasonable, illegal or without jurisdictionAccordingly, the Writ Petition is dismissed' It is
L7.
made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion on the
merits of the rival claims, allegations or defences available to the
parties before the competent statutory authorities. All such
claims, allegations and defences shzr.ll be considered
independently by
the competent authorities strictly
accordance with
law, without being influenced bY any
1n
observations made in this order. No costs.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
18.
ahy shall stand closed.
SD/. C. DEEPIKA
REGISTRAR
/TRUE COPY/
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. One CC to SMT VEDULA CHITRALEKHA' Ad
2. One CC to SRI B.JITHENDER, Advocate [OPUC]
3. One CC to SRI M.SHANKAR, Advocate [OPUCI
4. One CC to SRI ABID HI.JSSAIN, Advocate [OPUC]
IoPUCI
5.oneCCtoSRlPocHAlAHDoR|SHETT|,Advocate[oPUc]
of Telangana at
6. Two ccs to GP FOR LABOUR, High court for the state
Hyderabad TOUTI
7. Two CD CoPies
BSR
w
u
HIGH GOURT
DATED:09/01 12026
1 HES
(}
0 5 rrB 202fi
C)
ORDER
WP.No.3l2597 of 2025
DISMISSIING THE WRIT PETITION,
WITHOU'T COSTS
b 0\
t
*
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review