Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:42015 )1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No. 5590/2023 a/w CWP Nos. 5106, 5455 to
5461, 5591 to 5593, 5654, 5655, 5894, 5895, 5961,
6099, 6157, 6158,6190, 6191, 6245, 6248, 6278, 6286,
6287, 6314, 6722 to 6725, 7074, 8922/ 2023, 814,2243,
4245, 4247, 4401, 4524, 4903, 5656, 7048, 7065, 8131,
9609,
9616,
9617,
9444,
9645,10149/2024,
2423,3716/2025 and CWP No. 576/2026
Reserved on: 16.09.2026
Date of Decision: 29.09.2026
Uploaded on: 29.09.2026
_________________________________________________________
1.
CWP No. 5590/2023
Pradeep Thakur
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
2.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 5106/2023
M/s B.K. Liquor and others
…..Petitioners
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
3.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 5455/2023
M/s Himalyan Associates
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…..Respondents
( 2026:HHC:42015 )2
4.
CWP No. 5456/2023
M/s Rajinder Singh
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
5.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 5457/2023
M/s Rajat Thakur
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
6.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 5458/2023
M/s Star Wine Traders
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
7.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 5459/2023
M/s Vivek Baldev & Company
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
8.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 5460/2023
M/s Rajat Kapoor
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…..Respondents
( 2026:HHC:42015 )3
9.
CWP No. 5461/2023
M/s Rahul Kapoor
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
10.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 5591/2023
Yashpal Sharma
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
11.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 5592/2023
Manoj Sharma
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
12.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 5593/2023
Shamsher Singh
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
13.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 5654/2023
Sh. Anant Ram Verma
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…..Respondents
( 2026:HHC:42015 )4
14.
CWP No. 5655/2023
M/s D.S. Flights
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
15.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 5894/2023
Bhupesh Kumar Janartha
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
16.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 5895/2023
Agara Devi
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
17.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 5961/2023
M/s A.V. Enterprises
…..Petitioner.
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…..Respondents
18.
CWP No. 6099/2023
Gourav Mahajan
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…..Respondents
( 2026:HHC:42015 )5
19.
CWP No. 6157/2023
Hans Raj Mehta
…..Petitioner.
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
20.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 6158/2023
M/s Dhruv Singh
…..Petitioner.
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
21.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 6190/2023
M/s Lekh Ram & Company
…..Petitioner.
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
22.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 6191/2023
M/s S.S. Wine
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
23.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 6245/2023
Pradeep Barotra
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…..Respondents
( 2026:HHC:42015 )6
24.
CWP No. 6248/2023
M/s Mannat Enterprises
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
25.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 6278/2023
M/s Rakesh Kumar Chadha
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
26.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 6286/2023
M/s Gurmail Singh and others
…..Petitioners
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
27.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 6287/2023
M/s VRS Wine
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
28.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 6314/2023
M/s Bhavya Enterprises
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…..Respondents
( 2026:HHC:42015 )7
29.
CWP No. 6722/2023
Nirmal Singh
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
30.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 6723/2023
Jarnail Singh
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
31.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 6724/2023
Subhash
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
32.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 6725/2023
Bhupinder Kaur
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
33.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 7074/2023
M/s Nand Lal
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…..Respondents
( 2026:HHC:42015 )8
34.
CWP No. 8922/2023
M/s Rakesh Kumar Chadha
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
35.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 814/2024
M/s Manali Wine Traders
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
36.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 2243/2024
M/s Rajesh & Company
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
37.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 4245/2024
M/s Ashu Spirits
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
38.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 4247/2024
M/s Narender Kumar & Meera Thakur
…..Petitioners
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…..Respondents
( 2026:HHC:42015 )9
39.
CWP No. 4401/2024
M/s Narender Kumar & Meera Thakur
…..Petitioners
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
40.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 4524/2024
Mrs. Charanjeet Kaur
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
41.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 4903/2024
M/s Rajesh and Company
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…..Respondents
42.
CWP No. 5656/2024
M/s Solan Wines
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…..Respondents
43.
CWP No. 7048/2024
M/s Alcoprime Distilleries Pvt. Ltd.
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…..Respondents
44.
CWP No. 7065/2024
M/s Parvesh Kumar and Company
…..Petitioner
( 2026:HHC:42015 )10
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
45.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 8131/2024
M/s Star Wine Traders
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
46.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 9609/2024
Hans Raj Mehta
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…..Respondents
47.
CWP No.9616 /2024
Bhupinder Kaur
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
48.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 9617/2024
Jarnail Singh
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
49.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 9644/2024
M/s Nirmal Singh & others
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…..Respondents
( 2026:HHC:42015 )11
50.
CWP No. 9645/2024
M/s Lekh Ram and Company
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
51.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 10149/2024
Agara Devi
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh
52.
…..Respondent
CWP No. 2423/2025
M/s Alcoprime Distilleries Pvt. Ltd
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
53.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 3716 /2025
M/s Friends Wine
…..Petitioner
Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
54.
…..Respondents
CWP No. 576/2026
M/s Shere-Punjab & Company
Vs.
…..Petitioner
( 2026:HHC:42015 )12
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
…..Respondents
Coram:
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Yogesh Jaswal, Judge
Whether approved for reporting?1 Yes.
For the petitioner(s):
Mr. Arvind Sharma, Senior Advocate, with Mr.
Anil Kumar God, Ms. Shrutika Chauhan, Mr.
Ajay Vaidya, Mr. Hamender Singh Chandel, Mr.
Virbahadur Verma, Mr. Satish Kumar, Mr.
Goverdhan Lal Sharma, Ms. Soma Thakur, Mr.
Chander Shekhar Thakur and Mr. Shubham
Sood, Advocates, for the petitioner(s), in the
respective petitions.
For the respondents:
Mr. Vishal Mohan, Senior Advocate, with Mr.
Sushant Keprate, Additional Advocate General,
for the respondent-State, in all the petitions.
Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge:
As common issues of facts and law are involved in these
petitions and as all the matters were heard together, therefore, they are being
disposed of vide a common judgment.
2.
For the purpose of facts, as agreed, this Court shall be
primarily referring to the submissions made in terms of the pleadings in CWP
No. 5590 of 2023, titled Pradeep Thakur Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh and
others, for reference to the relevant Annexures.
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?
( 2026:HHC:42015 )13
3.
The case of the petitioners is that in the month of March,
2023, the Department of State Taxes and Excise, Government of Himachal
Pradesh, issued State Excise Policy in the form of Announcements for the
Allotment of Retail Excise Vends by Auction-Cum-Tender for the year 202324. A copy of the said Announcements is appended with the petition as
Annexure P-2. In terms of these Announcements, the licenses, as mentioned
in Clause 2.1 of Chapter-II thereof, were to be granted/allotted by way of
Auction-Cum-Tender process for the year 2023–24, on the terms and
conditions as prescribed in the said Chapter. It was mentioned in Clause 2.5
thereof that the details of location of each retail vend/unit, reserve price, the
minimum guaranteed quota of liquor fixed for each vend/unit and other levies
as may be applicable, shall be available with the officer mentioned therein,
In-charge of the District, who shall display the same on the office notice
board for the information of the intending tenderers/bidders, one day before
the first day fixed for the receipt of the tenders. As per Clause 2.16 thereof,
the District In-Charge was to fix the minimum reserve price of each unit/vend
based on the minimum guaranteed quota. It was also mentioned therein that
the annual License Fee of a particular vend/unit shall finally be determined
based on the highest bid offered by successful tenderer/bidder. In terms of
Clause 4.3 of Chapter IV of the said Announcements, the licensee was
required to lift 100% of the Minimum Guaranteed Quota prescribed in respect
of Country Liquor and IMFS for the vends/units allotted to the licensee. It was
( 2026:HHC:42015 )14
also mentioned therein that the licensee shall be liable to pay penalty on the
un-lifted quota falling short of 80% of the MGQ for the concerned quarter,
which shall be payable latest by 5th day of the end of the quarter and for the
last quarter by 10th March, 2023. It was further mentioned therein that the
penalty shall be levied at the rate of ₹150/- per proof litre on IMFS and ₹50/per proof litre on Country Liquor on such un-lifted quota falling short of 80%
of MGQ. However, if the licensee succeeds in lifting 80% of the annual MGQ
in the subsequent quarters, any penalty deposited previously on short-lifting
below 80% of the annual MGQ shall be adjusted against the license
fee/penalty due for the last quarter of the year 2023–24.
4.
It is further the case of the petitioners that thereafter, the
Collector Excise-Cum-Additional Commissioner, State Taxes and Excise,
Grade-1 (South Zone), Himachal Pradesh issued Communications to the
Deputy Commissioners of the State Taxes and Excise of the District
concerned, like Annexure P-3, dated 13.03.2023, which was issued to
Deputy Commissioner, State Taxes and Excise, Shimla, in terms whereof,
the minimum quota was fixed both with regard to Indian Made Foreign Liquor
and Country Liquor. According to the petitioners, in the light of the minimum
quota which was so fixed, they submitted their tenders as per the Excise
Policy Announcements.
5.
Their
grievance
is
that
thereafter,
unilaterally,
Commissioner of State Taxes and Excise, Himachal Pradesh, issued
( 2026:HHC:42015 )15
communication dated 27.03.2023, which is appended with CWP No. 5590 of
2023, as Annexure P-4, on the subject: "Proposal for approval of revised
quota of Excise Units/Vends on the value determined as per Auction-CumTender for the year 2023–24", and in terms thereof, the Minimum
Guaranteed Quota of IMFL and Country Liquor was arbitrarily enhanced as
from the one which was earlier communicated.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioners have primarily
argued that the bids were made by the petitioners in the light of the
Minimum Guaranteed Quota, as was earlier made public by the Authority
concerned to the proposed participants like Annexure P-3 appended with
CWP No. 5590 of 2023 and obviously the tenders which were submitted
and the rates that were quoted by the petitioners, were in the light of the
Minimum Guaranteed Quota as was fixed therein. Learned counsel
submitted that the unilateral enhancement of the Minimum Guaranteed
Quota vide communication Annexure P-4 dated 27.03.2023 is completely
arbitrary, discriminatory and not sustainable in the eyes of law.
Accordingly, the prayer of the petitioners is for quashing of communication
Annexure P-4 dated 27.03.2023 and for issuance of a direction that
Minimum Guaranteed Quota be fixed as per the original Minimum
Guaranteed Quota announced by the Department. In all the cases, this is
the sole contention that was raised on behalf of the petitioners.
( 2026:HHC:42015 )16
7.
It is again observed by the Court that in all the cases,
this was the only contention raised by the petitioners and besides the
grievance that the Minimum Guaranteed Quota was arbitrarily enhanced
by the Department in terms of Annexure P-4, which action of the
respondents, as per the petitioners, was bad in law, no other point was
urged by any learned counsel on behalf of the petitioners before this Court.
Though in some of the petitions, the petitioners have assailed the demand
and the orders, which have been raised by the respondents qua the
payment of penalty for not lifting the Minimum Guaranteed Quota,
however, no independent arguments were addressed on the legality of the
said orders and it was urged that the fate thereof was dependent upon the
primary relief qua the legality of Annexure P-4, dated 27th March, 2023.
8.
On the other hand, Mr. Vishal Mohan, learned Senior
Counsel, who appeared for the State, while justifying the act of the
Department on the strength of the Excise Announcements Annexure P-2
in CWP No. 5590 of 2023, submitted that the Department was vested with
the power of changing the Minimum Guaranteed Quota. He submitted that
after the Excise Announcement was made and the Minimum Guaranteed
Quota was made public, bids were submitted by the petitioners and other
similarly situated persons and after taking into consideration said bids, in
terms of the powers conferred upon the Department, communication dated
( 2026:HHC:42015 )17
27th March, 2026 (Annexure P-4) was issued, issuance whereof was within
the domain of the Department. Learned Senior Counsel argued that
otherwise also, the present writ petitions are not maintainable on the
ground of acquiescence and estoppel. He submitted that herein, after the
Excise Policy was announced for the year 2023–24, the Minimum
Guaranteed Quota both for IMFL as well as Country Liquor was issued by
the Department for all the Districts and the vends concerned. On the basis
thereof, the petitioners submitted their bids. Before the receipt of the bids
of the petitioners, Communication dated 27th March, 2023 (Annexure P-4)
was issued. None of the petitioners objected to the issuance of Annexure
P-4 at the relevant time. Thereafter, i.e., after the issuance of Annexure P4, the bids of the petitioners were accepted by the Department and at that
time also, none of the petitioners either agitated against Annexure P-4
before the Department or before any appropriate Court of law. The
acceptance of their bids was unconditional on their behalf and no one
lodged any protest of any kind at that stage also qua Annexure P-4. He
submitted that thereafter, after the bids of the petitioners were accepted,
they commenced the trade in terms of the Excise Policy and contracts
entered into between the Department and the petitioners. It was after a
lapse of three-four months that the petitioners either represented seeking
relaxation of the implementation of the Annual Excise Announcement on
the differential of the minimum reserve price/minimum reserve quota or
( 2026:HHC:42015 )18
approached the Court in this regard. He submitted that as the life of the
contract awarded to the petitioners is one year, it was after one-third of the
contract period was over that the petitions were filed before this Court. He
argued that as earlier, the contracts were entered into by the petitioners
without any protest and as the entering into of the contract by the
petitioners with the respondent-Department after the issuance of Annexure
P-4 without any protest demonstrated their acquiescence to Annexure P4, therefore, now they are estopped from filing the present writ petitions.
He accordingly submitted that all these petitions deserve to be dismissed
on this ground alone. Learned Senior Counsel also submitted that the
demand and the orders, which have been passed qua recovery of the
penalty for not lifting the Minimum Guaranteed Quota and also the
forfeiture of the amount of FDRs. etc. of some of the petitioners is also
justified, because all this was the out-come of Annexure P-4, dated
27.03.2023.
9.
In rebuttal, learned counsel for the petitioners submitted
that as the petitioners had approached the Court within a span of threefour months of the award of the tender to them, it cannot be said that the
petitions were hit on the ground of delay. They also submitted that there
was no acquiescence on the part of the petitioners to Annexure P-4,
because they were earlier also protesting with the Department in this
( 2026:HHC:42015 )19
regard and they were assured that care thereof will be taken at the
appropriate stage. Learned counsel also argued that in fact, it was on
account of the incessant rains which hit the State in the year 2023, which
hit the trade of liquor badly, that the petitioners were initially forced to take
up the matter with the Authorities and then to approach this Court.
Accordingly, they submitted that in the light of these facts, as the petitions
are maintainable, the same be allowed as prayed for.
10.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and have
also carefully gone through the pleadings on record.
11.
At random, we are quoting the reliefs prayed for in some
of the petitions before us alongwith their filing dates. Out of the total writ
petitions which were listed before us, more than 30 were filed in the year
2023, about 18 were filed in the year 2024 and the remaining have been
filed in the years 2025 and 2026. We will refer to three writ petitions filed in
the year 2023, three, which were filed in the year 2024 and one each, which
were filed in the years 2025 and 2026, as far as the reliefs prayed for
therein are concerned.
12.
In CWP No. 5590 of 2023, titled Pradeep Thakur Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh and others, which is being treated as a lead
( 2026:HHC:42015 )20
case, as agreed, the petitioners have, inter alia, prayed for the following
reliefs:“A.
That an appropriate writ, order or
direction may kindly be issued to quash the
"Enhanced Quota" fixed by the respondents as
per letter dated 27.03.2023 (Annexure P-4) and
the Annual Minimum Guarantee Quota (MGQ)
as fixed vide letter dated 13.03.2023 (Annexure
P-3) may please be directed to be restored for
all intends and purposes.
B.
Without prejudice to the above, in
the event this Hon'ble Court finds that any of the
terms and conditions continue to stand in the
way of grant of relief as prayed in A. above,
then by way of abundant caution and for the
sake of completeness, that too in the alternative
it is prayed that in terms of clause 4.3 of the
Excise Announcements 2023-24, this Hon'ble
Court may be pleased to declare that only the
Annual MGQ fixed prior to the conduct of
Auction-cum-Tender should alone be taken into
consideration for the purpose of applying the
said clause for the purpose of imposition of
penalty provided therein and not the Enhanced
Quota'.”
This writ petition has been filed on 18th August, 2023.
( 2026:HHC:42015 )21
13.
CWP No. 6245 of 2023, titled Pradeep Barotra Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh and others was filed on 2nd September, 2023
and therein, the petitioner has, inter alia, prayed for the following reliefs:“A.
That an appropriate writ, order or
direction may kindly be issued to quash the
"Enhanced Quota" fixed by the respondents as
per letter dated 27.03.2023 and the tabulated
list (Annexure P-5) and the Annual Minimum
Guarantee Quota dated (MGQ) as fixed vide
tabulated list 14/15.03.2023 (Annexure P-4)
may please be directed to be restored for all
intends and purposes.
B.
Without prejudice to the above, in
the event this Hon'ble Court finds that any of the
terms and conditions continue to stand in the
way of grant of relief as prayed in A. above,
then by way of abundant caution and for the
sake of completeness, that too in the alternative
it is prayed that in terms of clause 4.3 of the
Excise Announcements 2023-24, this Hon'ble
Court may be pleased to declare that only the
Annual MGQ fixed prior to the conduct of
Auction-cum-Tender should alone be taken into
consideration for the purpose of applying the
said clause for the purpose of imposition of
( 2026:HHC:42015 )22
penalty provided therein and not the Enhanced
Quota'.
14.
CWP No. 6248 of 2023, titled M/s Mannat Enterprises
Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh and others was filed on 1st September,
2023 and therein, the petitioner has, inter alia, prayed for the following
reliefs:“A.
That an appropriate writ, order or
direction may kindly be issued to quash the
"Enhanced Quota" fixed by the respondents as
per letter dated 27.03.2023 and the tabulated list
(Annexure P-5) and the Annual Minimum
Guarantee Quota dated (MGQ) as fixed vide
tabulated list 14/15.03.2023 (Annexure P-4) may
please be directed to be restored for all intends
and purposes.
B.
Without prejudice to the above, in
the event this Hon'ble Court finds that any of the
terms and conditions continue to stand in the
way of grant of relief as prayed in A. above, then
by way of abundant caution and for the sake of
completeness, that too in the alternative it is
prayed that in terms of clause 4.3 of the Excise
Announcements 2023-24, this Hon'ble Court
may be pleased to declare that only the Annual
MGQ fixed prior to the conduct of Auction-cum-
( 2026:HHC:42015 )23
Tender should alone be taken into consideration
for the purpose of applying the said clause for
the purpose of imposition of penalty provided
therein and not the Enhanced Quota'.
15.
Similarly, in CWP 10149 of 2024, titled Agara Devi Vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh and others, the date of filing is 11th July, 2024
and the petitioner therein has, inter alia, prayed for the following reliefs:“A.
An
appropriate
writ,
order
or
direction may kindly be issued to quash the
impugned demand notice dated 25.06.2024
(Annexure P-6) issued by the respondent
Deputy Commissioner of State Taxes and
Excise, Shimla and to grant refund of the amount
of Rs. 58,29,115 paid by the petitioner as per
Bank DD dated 29.06.2024 ((Annexure P-7),
with interest.”
16.
In CWP 9644 of 2024, titled M/s Nirmal Singh Vs. State
of Himachal Pradesh and others, the date of filing is 6th September, 2024
and the petitioner therein has, inter alia, prayed for the following reliefs:“a)
That the order dated 13.10.2023,
Annexure P-4 (typed Copy at Annexure P-4/T).,
passed by the respondent No. 3, as affirmed
vide order dated 20.01.2024, Annexure P. 6,
( 2026:HHC:42015 )24
passed by the respondent No. 2, may be held
illegal and quashed and set aside.
b)
That an appropriate writ, order or
direction may please be issued to the
respondents to quash all the actions taken or
subsequent proceedings initiated against the
petitioner on the basis of the impugned orders.
c)
The respondents may be directed
to refund to the petitioner an amount of Rs.
41,39,667/- which has been recovered by the
respondents by forfeiting the FDR of the
petitioner kept as security with the department
and the respondents may be directed pay
interest @9% P.A. on the said amount till its
actual payment to the petitioner.”
17.
In CWP 9645 of 2024, titled M/s Lekh Ram and
Company Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh and others, the date of filing is
6th September, 2024 and the petitioner therein has, inter alia, prayed for
the following reliefs:“(i)
That the order dated 13.10.2023,
Annexure P-4 (typed copy at Annexure P-4/T),
passed by the respondent No. 3, as affirmed vide
order dated 20.01.2024, Annexure P-6, passed
by the respondent No. 2, may be held illegal and
quashed and set aside.
( 2026:HHC:42015 )25
(ii).
That an appropriate writ, order or
direction
may
please
be
issued
to
the
respondents to quash all the actions taken or
subsequent proceedings initiated against the
petitioner on the basis of the impugned orders.
(iii).
The respondents may be directed
to refund to the petitioner an amount of Rs.
64,01,948/- which has been recovered by the
respondents by forfeiting the FDR of the
petitioner kept as security with the department
and the respondents may be directed pay
interest @ 9% P.A. on the said amount till its
actual payment to the petitioner.
18.
In CWP 3716 of 2025, titled M/s Friends Wine Vs. State
of Himachal Pradesh and others, the date of filing is 17th March, 2025 and
the petitioner therein has, inter alia, prayed for the following reliefs:“A.
That an appropriate writ, order or
direction may kindly be issued to quash demand
letter dated 21-01-2025 (annexure P-8), order or
direction may kindly be issued to quash the "
Enhanced Quota" fixed by the respondents as
per
Annexure P-6 and the Annual Minimum
Guarantee Quota (MGQ) as fixed vide letter
Annexure P-5 may please be directed to be
implicated for all intends and purposes.
( 2026:HHC:42015 )26
B.
Without prejudice to the above, in
the event this Hon'ble Court finds that any of the
terms and conditions continue to stand in the
way of grant of relief as prayed in A. above, then
by way of abundant caution and for the sake of
completeness, that too in the alternative it is
prayed that in terms of clause 4.3 of the Excise
Announcements 2023-24, this Hon'ble Court
may be pleased to declare that only the Auctioncum-Tender
should
alone
be
taken
into
consideration for the purpose of applying the
said clause for the purpose of imposition of
penalty provided therein and not the 'Enhanced
Quota'.
C.
retain
That respondents be directed not to
petitioner
and
its
partners
from
participating in excise auction for not lifting
enhanced MGQ (Annexure P-6) and to comply
order date 21-08-2023 passed in CWP No 5590
of 2023 and in connected matters.”
19.
In CWP 576 of 2026, titled M/s Shere-Punjab &
Company Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh and others, the date of filing is
29th December, 2025 and the petitioner therein has, inter alia, prayed for
the following reliefs:-
( 2026:HHC:42015 )27
“A.
That an appropriate writ, order or
direction may kindly be issued to quash the
"Enhanced Quota" fixed by the respondents as
enhanced by Annexure P-6 and the Annual
Minimum Guarantee Quota (MGQ) as fixed
vide Annexure P-5 may please be directed to
be restored for all intends and purposes and
demand notice dated 17-12-2025 (annexure P8) be quashed and set aside.
B.
Without prejudice to the above, in
the event this Hon'ble Court finds that any of the
terms and conditions continue to stand in the
way of grant of relief as prayed in A. above,
then by way of abundant caution and for the
sake of
completeness, that too in the
alternative it is prayed that in terms of clause
4.3 of the Excise Announcements 2023-24, this
Hon'ble Court may be pleased to declare that
only the Annual MGO should alone be taken
into consideration for the fixed prior to the
conduct of Auction-cum-Tender purpose of
applying the said clause for the purpose of
imposition of penalty provided therein and not
the Enhanced Quota'.”
20.
Thus, from a perusal of these writ petitions, what is
demonstrative is that primarily the petitioners have assailed the
enhancement of the Minimum Guaranteed Quota and the subsequent
( 2026:HHC:42015 )28
demand notices and in certain cases, the orders which have been passed
against them by the Authorities concerned qua the demand notices issued
to them in the proceedings initiated for the recovery of the license fee due
from them, on account of their non-lifting of the Minimum Guaranteed
Quota and also forfeiture of their FDRs. However, crux of the matter
remains that the foundation of the grievance of the petitioners is the
enhancement of the Minimum Guaranteed Quota.
21.
The chronology, as is evident from the petitions filed
before us, is that the Excise Policy was announced by the Excise
Department for the year 2023-2024 vide Annexure P-2, appended with
CWP No. 5590 of 2023, which was approved vide Government Letter
dated 07.03.2023. In terms of this Excise Policy, the Commissioner of
State Taxes and Excise-Cum-Financial Commissioner (Excise), Himachal
Pradesh, reserved the right to sell all or any of the licenses by allotment or
by auction or by private contract or by calling tenders or by draw of lots or
by any other arrangement which he may consider expedient in the interest
of revenue and for the said purpose, the mode of grant of licenses was
liable to be changed by the Commissioner whenever necessary before the
actual grant of the license. It was also mentioned in the Policy that the
Commissioner could also modify the procedure contained in the terms and
conditions of the Excise Policy to give effect to such mode of grant of
( 2026:HHC:42015 )29
license after determining Fixed License Fee, excise duties or any other
levy in such manner as the Authority deemed fit. It was also mentioned in
the Excise Policy that all allotments of the vends/units license shall be
subject to the confirmation of the Commissioner, who reserved the right to
reject any allotment without assigning any reason for the same. The details
of the licenses were mentioned in Chapter-II, which were to be
granted/allotted by way of Auction-Cum-Tender process for the year 202324. The distribution of these vends was to be granted/allotted throughout
the State as per the Policy Announcement contained in the document itself.
Minimum Guaranteed Quota and Annual Fixed License Fee was dealt with
in Chapter-IV of the said Excise Policy.
22.
This was followed by the disclosure of the Minimum
Guaranteed Quota both for the Indian Made Foreign Liquor as well as
Country Liquor District-wise and communication dated 13.03.2023 issued
in this regard relating to District Shimla is appended as Annexure P-3 with
CWP No. 5590 of 2023. Similarly, the Minimum Guaranteed Quotas were
approved for all Districts, as was jointly submitted by the parties before this
Court.
23.
It was thereafter that the bids were submitted by the
petitioners in response to the Excise Policy, taking of course into
( 2026:HHC:42015 )30
consideration the Minimum Guaranteed Quota, which was so approved
and displayed for each District by the Excise Department.
24.
After the petitioners had submitted their tenders, the
respondents issued the impugned Communication dated 27th March, 2023
(Annexure P-4), enhancing the Minimum Guaranteed Quota, both for
Indian Made Foreign Liquor as well as country liquor.
25.
Now incidentally, when this Minimum Guaranteed Quota was
enhanced by the Department vide Annexure P-4 on 27.03.2023, none of
the petitioners before this Court objected thereto. The bids of the
petitioners were accepted by the Department for different Districts and
Units, for which they had submitted their bids, in the light of Annexure P-4,
dated 27.03.2023, in terms whereof, the Minimum Guaranteed Quota
stood enhanced.
26.
In between the acceptance of the bid of the petitioners
and issuance of Annexure P-4 dated 27.03.2023, there was no objection
raised to this enhanced Minimum Guaranteed Quota by any of the
petitioners nor any of them approached this Court against the alleged
unilateral increase in the Minimum Guaranteed Quota.
27.
In fact, even after the bids of the petitioners were
accepted by the Department, no formal protest was lodged by any of the
( 2026:HHC:42015 )31
petitioners that the acceptance of their bids, in the light of the alleged
enhanced Minimum Guaranteed Quota, was under protest as far as the
petitioners were concerned and that they reserve their right to agitate the
issue before appropriate Court of law.
28.
This act of the petitioners obviously demonstrates that
after they had submitted their respective bids and thereafter, when the
Minimum Guaranteed Quota was enhanced by the Department, they
acquiesced to the same by not objecting thereto and accepted the
finalization of their bids, knowing fully well that the Minimum Guaranteed
Quota, as was held out earlier, stood modified by the Department in terms
of notification dated 27th March, 2023 (Annexure P-4).
29.
Not only this, after the acceptance of their respective
bids, the petitioners, as the Court was informed, deposited the amount etc.,
which they were to deposit with the Department, as per the Excise Policy
and the formal agreements were entered between the parties and
commenced the business of selling of the liquor.
30.
It is thereafter that these writ petitions have been filed,
some in the months of July/August, 2023 and some much later thereafter.
31.
Therefore, in the backdrop of the said conduct of the
parties, wherein, none objected to the act of the Department of enhancing
( 2026:HHC:42015 )32
the Minimum Guaranteed Quota vide Communication dated 27th March,
2023 (Annexure P-4 dated),
obviously, the only inference that can be
drawn is that the petitioners did not object thereto, as they were not
aggrieved by the same.
32.
Non-challenge thereto at the appropriate time, amounts
to their acquiescence to the said notification.
33.
Even after the bids of the petitioners were accepted by
the Department, which was in the last week of March 2023, which is not in
dispute, none of the petitioners immediately came to the Court objecting to
this enhancement in the minimum guaranteed quota. They acquiesced to
the acceptance of their bids on the said revised minimum guaranteed
quota, acted upon it and commenced their respective businesses in the
vends, which were allotted to them.
34.
They did not lodge any protest thereto in the month of
April, i.e., the first month of coming into force of the Excise Policy or even
in the month of May, but as observed hereinabove, accepted the terms and
conditions and continued to undertake the business of selling liquor. It is
only thereafter in the month of July/August 2023, that the petitioners started
coming to the Court, assailing the enhancement of the Minimum
Guaranteed Quota, when they failed to lift the Minimum Guaranteed Quota.
( 2026:HHC:42015 )33
35.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Rajasthan State
Industrial Development and Investment Corporation and another Vs.
Diamond & Gem Development Corporation Limited and another, (2013) 5
Supreme Court Cases 470 has been pleased to observe that a party
cannot be permitted to “blow hot-blow cold”, “fast and loose” or “approbate
and reprobate”. Where one knowingly accepts the benefit of a contract, or
conveyance, or of an order, he is estopped from denying the validity of, or
the binding effect of such contract, or conveyance, or order upon himself.
Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed that this Rule is applied to ensure
equity, however, it must not be applied in such a manner so as to violate
the principles of what is right and of good conscience.
36.
Similarly, in State of Punjab and others Vs. Dhanjit Singh
Sandhu, (2014) 15 Supreme Court Cases 144, Hon’ble Supreme Court has
been pleased to hold as under:“22.
The doctrine of "approbate and
reprobate" is only a species of estoppel, it implies
only to the conduct of parties. As in the case of
estoppel it cannot operate against the provisions
of a statute. (Vide CIT v. V. MR. P. Firm Muar.)
23.
It is settled proposition of law that
once an order has been passed, it is complied
with, accepted by the other party and derived the
benefit out of it, he cannot challenge it on any
( 2026:HHC:42015 )34
ground. (Vide Maharashtra SRTC v. Balwant
Regular Motor Service.) In R.N. Gosain v.
Yashpal Dhir this Court has observed as under:
(SCC pp. 687-88, para 10)
"10.
Law does not permit a person to both
approbate and reprobate. This principle is based
on the doctrine of election which postulates that
no party can accept and reject the same
instrument and that 'a person cannot say at one
time that a transaction is valid and thereby obtain
some advantage, to which he could only be
entitled on the footing that it is valid, and then turn
round and say it is void for the purpose of securing
some other advantage'."
37.
It is settled law that a citizen has no fundamental right to
trade or business in liquor as a beverage and activities which are res extra
commercium cannot be carried on by any citizen and the State can prohibit
completely trade or business in potable liquor since trade or business in
liquor as a beverage is res extra commercium.
38.
A Five-Judge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Khoday Distilleries Ltd. and others Vs. State of Karnataka and others,
(1995)1 Supreme Court Cases 574, has been pleased to hold the following
as far as the trade of res extra commercium is concerned:“60.
We may now summarise the law on
the subject as culled from the aforesaid
decisions:(a)
The rights protected by Article 19(1)
are not absolute but qualified The qualifications
( 2026:HHC:42015 )35
are stated in clauses (2) to (6) of Article 19. The
fundamental rights guaranteed in Article 19(1)(a)
to (g) are, therefore, to be read along with the
said qualifications. Even the rights guaranteed
under the Constitutions of the other civilized
countries are not absolute but are read subject
to the implied limitations on them. Those implied
limitations are made explicit by clauses (2) to (6)
of Article 19 of our Constitution.
(b)
The right to practice any profession
or to carry on any occupation, trade or business
does not extend to practicing a profession or
carrying on an occupation, trade or business
which is inherently vicious and pernicious, and is
condemned by all civilized societies. It does not
entitle citizens to carry on trade or business in
activities which are immoral and criminal and in
articles or goods which are obnoxious and
injurious to health, safety and welfare of the
general public, i.e., res extra commercium,
(outside commerce). There cannot be business
in crime.
(c)
Potable liquor as a beverage is an
intoxicating and depressant drink which is
dangerous and injurious to health and is,
therefore,
an
article
which
is
res
extra
commercium being inherently harmful. A citizen
has, therefore, no fundamental right to do trade
( 2026:HHC:42015 )36
or business in liquor. Hence the trade or
business in liquor can be completely prohibited.
(d)
Article
of
the
Constitution
considers intoxicating drinks and drugs as
injurious to health and impeding the raising of
level of nutrition and the standard of living of the
people and improvement h of the public health.
It, therefore, ordains the State to bring about
prohibition of the consumption of intoxicating
drinks which obviously include liquor, except for
medicinal purposes. Article 47 is one of the
directive principles which is fundamental in the
governance of the country. The State has,
therefore, the power to completely prohibit the
manufacture, sale, possession, distribution and
consumption of potable liquor as a beverage,
both because it is inherently, a dangerous article
of consumption and also because of the directive
principle contained in Article 47, except when it
is used and consumed for medicinal purposes.
(e)
For the same reason, the State can
create a monopoly either in itself or in the agency
created by it for the manufacture, possession,
sale and distribution of the liquor as a beverage
and also sell the licences to the citizens for the
said purpose by charging fees. This can be done
under Article 19(6) or even otherwise.
( 2026:HHC:42015 )37
(f)
For the same reason, again, the
State can impose limitations and restrictions on
the trade or business in potable liquor as a
beverage which restrictions are in nature
different from those imposed on the trade or
business in legitimate activities and goods and
articles
which are
res commercium.
The
restrictions and limitations on the trade or
business in potable liquor can again be both
under Article 19(6) or otherwise. The restrictions
and limitations can extend to the State carrying
on the trade or business itself to the exclusion of
and elimination of others and/or to preserving to
itself the right to sell licences to do trade or
business in the same, to others.
(g)
When the State permits trade or
business in the potable liquor with or without
limitation, the citizen has the right to carry on
trade or business subject to the limitations, if
any, and the State cannot make discrimination
between the citizens who are qualified to carry
on the trade or business.
(h)
The State can adopt any mode of
selling the licences for trade or business with a
view to maximise its revenue so long as the
method adopted is not discriminatory.
(i)
The State can carry on trade or
business in potable liquor notwithstanding that it
is an intoxicating drink and Article 47 enjoins it to
( 2026:HHC:42015 )38
prohibit its consumption. When the State carries
on such business, it does so to restrict and
regulate production, supply and consumption of
liquor which is also an aspect of reasonable
restriction in the interest of general public. The
State cannot on that account be said to be
carrying on an illegitimate business.
(j)
The mere fact that the State levies
taxes or fees on the production, sale and income
derived
from
potable
liquor
whether
the
production, sale or income is legitimate or
illegitimate, does not make the State a party to
the said activities. The power of the State to raise
revenue by levying taxes and fees should not be
confused with the power of the State to prohibit
or regulate the trade or business in question. The
State exercises its two different powers on such
occasions. Hence the mere fact that the State
levies taxes a and fees on trade or business in
liquor or income derived from it, does not make
the right to carry on trade or business in liquor a
fundamental right, or even a legal right when
such trade or business is completely prohibited.
(k)
The State cannot prohibit trade or
business in medicinal and toilet preparations
containing liquor or alcohol. The State can,
however, b under Article 19(6) place reasonable
restrictions on the right to trade or business in
the same in the interests of general public.
( 2026:HHC:42015 )39
(l)
Likewise, the State cannot prohibit
trade or business in industrial alcohol which is
not used as a beverage but used legitimately for
industrial purposes. The State, however, can
place reasonable restrictions on the said trade or
business in the interests of the general public
under Article 19(6) of the Constitution.
(m)
The restrictions placed on the trade
or business in industrial alcohol or in medicinal
and toilet preparations containing liquor or
alcohol may also be for the purposes of
preventing their abuse or diversion for use as or
in beverage.”
39.
This Court is of the considered view that as the petitioners
acquiesced to the enhancement of the Minimum Guaranteed Quota by the
Department by not protesting to the enhancement thereafter in terms of
Annexure P-4 dated 27th March, 2023, they are estopped from filing and
maintaining these writ petitions.
40.
The vends in issue are allotted to a successful party for a
period of one year from the month of April of the year concerned up to the
31st March of the forthcoming year. Thus, the life of the acceptance of the
bid of the successful bidder is twelve months.
41.
In the present case, the petitions have been filed by the
petitioners in the month of July, 2023 and thereafter against the
( 2026:HHC:42015 )40
enhancement of the Minimum Guaranteed Quota, which was done by the
Department in the month of March 2023. Thus, there is a delay of three and
a half months, at least, in assailing this act of the State, which period,
according to us, in the peculiar facts of this case, is fatal.
42.
Though, at the first blush, the filing of a writ petitions
against a notification issued by the Government just after three months of its
issuance does seem to be a challenge with due diligence, but herein, as the
life of the vend allotted to the petitioners is twelve months, this means that
the petitions were filed before this Court, assailing the enhancement of the
Minimum Guaranteed Quota by the State after one-third of the period of the
licenses was over.
43.
In other words, if we construe that the vend was allotted
to the petitioners for a period of 100 years, then the petitioners approached
this Court assailing the enhancement in the Minimum guaranteed quota
undertaken by the Government after about 30 years as from the date of the
enhancement under challenge and also from the date when the bids of the
petitioners were accepted.
44.
Therefore, in a case where the life period of the tender
itself is twelve months, approaching a Court of law after one-third of the
currency of the license is over, obviously amounts to delay.
( 2026:HHC:42015 )41
45.
No plausible explanation was given by the petitioners as
to why there was no challenge to the increase in the Minimum Guaranteed
Quota at the time when the same was done by the Government.
46.
The contention of the learned counsel, generally was,
that at the relevant time, taking into consideration the business as it was, the
petitioners were under the bona fide belief that they would be in a position to
lift the Minimum Guaranteed Quota. They submitted that as later on, on
account of natural calamities etc., they were not able to lift the Minimum
Guaranteed Quota, it was in these circumstances that they approached the
Court of Law seeking the setting aside of the enhancement of the quota.
47.
This Court is of the considered view that not challenging
the enhancement of the Minimum Guaranteed Quota immediately after the
enhancement was done by the Department, which enhancement was before
the bids of the petitioners were accepted, has to be construed that the
petitioners were not indeed aggrieved by the said enhancement in the
Minimum Guaranteed Quota, otherwise, at least some amongst them should
and would have approached the Court at the relevant time. They approached
the Court only after they were unable to lift the minimum guaranteed quota.
This, according to us, is no reason to entertain belated petitions, wherein the
petitioners are otherwise barred from assailing the notification on account of
their own act of acquiescence and estoppel.
( 2026:HHC:42015 )42
48.
Therefore, in light of above discussions, as according to
us, these petitions are not maintainable, as the petitioners are estopped by
their act of acquiescence and are hence estopped from filing these petitions,
the same are dismissed. Same is the fate of other petitions also, in which,
the petitioners have assailed the notice and subsequent orders passed by
the Authorities, as all of them owe their foundation to Notification dated
27.03.2023 (Annexure P-4), with which, the Court has not interfered in these
petitions. Interim orders, if any, stand vacated. Pending Miscellaneous
applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
(Ajay Mohan Goel)
Judge
(Yogesh Jaswal)
Judge
September 29, 2026
(bhupender)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review