Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 17TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE K.S. HEMALEKHA
WRIT PETITION NO.35361 OF 2024 (GM-MM_S)
BETWEEN:
1.
M/S. SHAKTHI ENTERPRISES
SHOP NO.1, BATHIYAPPA BUILDING,
DEVASANDRA MAIN ROAD,
AYYAPPA NAGAR,
BENGALURU - 560036
REPRESENTED BY ITS PROPRIETOR
SRI. R. BASAVARAJU.
2.
M/S. PRABHA EARTH MOVERS
NO.23, OPP. ASHWATH KATTE ROAD,
DEVASANDRA, K.R. PURAM,
BENGALURU - 560036
REPRESENTED BY ITS PROPRIETOR
SRI. R. SRINIVASA.
MAHALAKSHMI B M
Location: High Court
of Karnataka
…PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. BHAT GANAPATHY NARAYAN (GANAPATHY BHAT),
ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
DEPARTMENT OF MINES AND GEOLOGY
VIKASA SOUDHA,
-2HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
DR. B.R. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI
BENGALURU - 560001
REPRESENTED BY ITS
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY.
2.
THE DIRECTOR
DEPARTMENT OF MINES AND GEOLOGY
KHANIJA BHAVAN,
RACE COURSE ROAD,
BENGALURU - 560001.
3.
THE SENIOR GEOLOGIST
DEPARTMENT OF MINES AND GEOLOGY,
CHIKKABALLAPURA DIVISION
CHIKKABALLAPURA DISTRICT - 562101.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. NILOUFER AKBAR, AGA)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT OF
CERTIORARI OR ANY APPROPRIATE ORDER BY QUASHING THE
IMPUGNED REJECTION ORDER DATED 22.11.2024, BEARING
SL.NO.GA.BHU.E/UNI.NICHI/KA.GA.GU-285/2024-25/4650,
AS
PER
ANNEXURE-W, ISSUED IN FAVOUR OF THE PETITIONER NO.1,
ISSUED BY THE RESPONDENT NO.3 AND ETC.
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING,
THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE
and
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE K.S. HEMALEKHA
-3HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
ORAL ORDER
(PER: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE K.S. HEMALEKHA)
1.
The petitioners are assailing the separate orders dated
22.11.2024 passed by the Deputy Director, Department of Mines
and Geology [DMG], Chikkaballapura District, whereby the quarry
leases granted in their favour have been cancelled on the premise
that the proprietors of the petitioners belong to the Hindu Undivided
Family [HUF] and that the quarry leases held by them, when taken
together, exceed the permissible ceiling of 10 acres prescribed
under Rule 15 of the Karnataka Minor Mineral Concession Rules,
1994 [KMMC Rules].
2.
The brief facts leading to the filing of the present petition are
that the DMG issued separate notifications dated 08.03.2019
granting quarry leases in favour of the petitioners in respect of
lands in Sy. No.2 of Purabyrenahalli Village, Shidlagatta Taluk,
Chikkaballapura District.
Under the said notification, petitioner
No.1, M/s. Shakthi Enterprises was granted a quarry lease over 10
acres under Quarry Lease No.285 [QL-285], whereas petitioner
No.2, M/s. Prabha Earth Movers was granted a quarry lease over 8
-4HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
acres 22 guntas under Quarry Lease No.284 [QL-284]. The
respective quarry lease deeds for extraction of building stone were
thereafter executed on 27.07.2022 for a period of twenty years.
According to the petitioners, the grants were preceded by requisite
No Objection Certificates [NOC], joint inspection, environmental
clearance and other statutory approvals.
3.
During the course of quarry operations, the petitioners claim
to have discovered ornamental granite, "grey granite", a specified
minor mineral, within their respective leased areas. They
accordingly
submitted
applications
/
representations
dated
19.10.2022 seeking inclusion of the newly discovered mineral in
their existing quarry leases under Rule 3-E of the KMMC Rules.
The case of the petitioners is that the applications were not for the
grant of fresh quarry leases, but for the inclusion of a mineral
discovered during the subsistence of valid existing leases, for
which Rule 3-E of the KMMC Rules provides a specific mechanism.
4.
As the applications were not considered, the petitioners
approached this Court in WP No.25108/2022 (GM-MMS). By order
dated 02.01.2023, this Court directed the Senior Geologist to
-5HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
consider the petitioners' representation within the stipulated period.
Pursuant thereto, the Senior Geologist considered the applications
and on 21.03.2023, forwarded the proposals to the DMG with
recommendations for approval under Rule 3-E of the KMMC Rules.
Since no decision was taken thereafter, the petitioners, along with
others, again approached this Court in WP No.22321/2023 (GMMMS). By Order dated 09.10.2023, this Court observed that the
applications could not be kept pending ad infinitum and directed the
Director, DMG to take a decision on the recommendations dated
21.03.2023 made by the Senior Geologist, within an outer limit of
six weeks and thereafter, to forward the papers to the State
Government to further process the matter.
5.
In the interregnum, Mr. Ravi Kumar, Member of Legislative
Assembly Shidlaghatta lodged a complaint dated 18.07.2023
before the Minister for Mines and Geology, alleging that the quarry
lease had been granted to members of the same family / relatives.
The complaint was referred for enquiry to the Joint Director, DMG
South Zone, Mysore. Pursuant thereto, reports dated 03.10.2023
and 02.01.2024 came to be submitted. The petitioners rely upon
the said reports to contend that, though the two proprietors are
-6HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
brothers, they belong to separate nuclear families, their joint family
having already been divided under a family partition arrangement,
"Panchayath Parikath" dated 25.04.2010.
6.
While the applications under Rule 3-E of the KMMC Rules
were still awaiting a final decision, a show-cause notice dated
22.10.2024 was issued proposing cancellation of the existing
quarry leases on the ground that the petitioners belonged to the
same family and that their aggregate quarry holdings exceeded the
ceiling contemplated under Rule 15 (1) of the KMMC Rules. The
petitioners submitted their replies dated 04.11.2024, relying, inter
alia, upon the Panchayat Parikat dated 25.04.2010, the earlier
proceedings and orders of this Court. The explanation offered by
the petitioners was not accepted. By separate orders dated
22.11.2024, QL-285 held by M/s. Shakthi Enterprises, petitioner
No.1 and QL-284 held by M/s. Prabha Earth Movers, petitioner
No.2 were cancelled essentially on the premise that the proprietors
were members of a HUF and that their aggregate holding
exceeded the permissible ceiling of 10 acres under Rule 15 (1)
read with Rule 15 (3) of the KMMC Rules. The authority
consequently treated the grants in excess of the prescribed ceiling
-7HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
as invalid under Section 19 of the Mines and Minerals
(Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 [MMDR Act].
Submissions:
7.
The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners primarily
contends that the quarry leases were independently granted upon
the completion of the statutory process and had remained in force
from 27.07.2022. According to the petitioners, what was pending
before the authority was not an application for the grant of another
or fresh quarry lease, but an application under Rule 3-E of the
KMMC Rules, seeking inclusion of ornamental granite discovered
within the very same leased areas. It is emphasized that the Senior
Geologist had already examined the applications and pursuant to
the earlier order of this Court in W.P. No.25108/2022 (GM-MMS),
had recommended the same for approval on 21.03.2023. It is the
grievance of the petitioners that, instead of taking the proceedings
under Rule 3-E of the KMMC Rules to their logical conclusion in
terms of the order dated 09.10.2023 passed by this Court in W.P.
No.22321/2023 (GM-MMS), the authorities reopened the validity of
the existing leases merely based on a subsequent complaint.
-8HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
Reasons and conclusions:
8.
The controversy, therefore, lies in a narrow compass;
whether the existing quarry leases, which had already been
independently granted to the petitioners for building stone, could
subsequently be cancelled by invoking Rule 15 (1) of the KMMC
Rules on the premise that the proprietors of the two petitioners,
belonged to the HUF.
9.
Rule 15 of the KMMC Rules deals with the maximum area for
which a quarry lease or prospecting licence may be granted. The
relevant portion of the KMMC Rules, as it stood after the 2016
amendment, reads as follows:
"15. Maximum Area for which a quarrying
lease or Prospecting license may be granted.-(1) No
person shall acquire in respect of any minor mineral in
the State.(a)
One or more prospecting licenses covering a
total area of more than five hundred acres;
(b)
One or more quarrying leases covering a total
area of more than fifty acres for the purpose of Mineral
based industries and ten acres in case of other
purposes; and"
10.
Rule 15 (3) of the KMMC Rules reads as under:
-9HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
“(3) For the purpose of determining the total area
referred to in sub-rule (1), the area held under a quarrying
lease or composite license by a person as a member or
partner of a company or corporation or firm or Hindu
undivided family or a Co-operative Society shall be
deducted from the area referred to in sub-rule (1) so that
sum total of the area held by such person, under a quarry
lease or prospecting cum quarrying lease, whether as such
member or partner, or individually, may not, in any case,
exceed the total area specified in sub-rule (1)."
11.
Rule 15 (3) provides that, for determining the total area, the
area held by a person as a member or partner of a company,
corporation, firm, HUF or a Co-operative Society has to be taken
into account with the area held by such person individually, so that
the aggregate area does not exceed the ceiling under Rule 15 (1)
of the KMMC Rules.
12.
Thus, what assumes relevance for the application of Rule 15
(3) is not merely the relationship between the two lease holders,
but whether the quarry leases held by them are liable to be
aggregated in terms of the circumstances specifically contemplated
under the said provision.
13.
In the present case, the impugned orders proceed essentially
on the premise that R. Basvaraju and R. Sreenivas are brothers
- 10 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
and, therefore, members of the same HUF and consequently
aggregate the areas covered under QL Nos.285 and 284 for the
purpose of applying the ceiling prescribed under Rule 15 (1) of the
KMMC Rules.
14.
At the outset, it is material to note that the petitioners were
granted quarry leases independently. The leases were executed on
27.07.2022 for a period of twenty years. The applications dated
19.10.2022 did not seek any additional extent of land. What was
sought was the inclusion of "ornamental granite", stated to have
been discovered within the areas already covered by the subsisting
leases. Indeed, the Senior Geologist had acted upon these
applications pursuant to the order dated 02.01.2023 passed by this
Court in WP No.25108/2022 (GM-MMS), and forwarded the same
on 21.03.2023 with his recommendation for approval. The
translated copy of the relevant portion of the recommendation is set
down below:
"As per all above mentioned facts, the Technical
Officers of this office as they by conducting spot inspection
dt: 08-11-2022 as per their report issued by them, that in
view of found grey granite mining ores in the occasion of
running quarry lease work by the contractors/lease holders
in the above said leased area; and hence in view of report
given as it may be considered for including grey granite
- 11 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
marble as per Rule-3-E of KMMCR 1994, in the said quarry
leased area; and hence in view of submitted the concerned
records as per Rules for inclusion of gray granite marble
stone sub-mining quarry lease as per Rule-3-E of KMMCR
Amendment Rules, 2023 made to KMMCR 1994; hence it is
submitted claiming for further action in the matter and for
your kind perusal it is hereby submitted the proposal along
with report of actual facts; regarding to be issued an
approval in this connection to be inclusion of grey granite
marble stone in the said leased area in this regard."
15.
The matter did not rest there. When the recommendation
remained unattended, the petitioners approached this Court for the
second time in W.P. No.22321/2023. By order dated 09.10.2023,
the Director was specifically directed to take a decision on the
recommendation dated 21.03.2023 within six weeks and thereafter
forward the papers to the Government. The relevant portion of the
order in the aforesaid writ petition is extracted below :
"3.
Having heard the learned counsel for the
parties and having perused the petition papers, we are
inclined to accept the submission made on behalf of the writ
petitioners inasmuch as applications of the kind cannot be
kept pending consideration ad infinitum, at the whims and
fancies of the officials. Ours being a welfare State as
ordained by the Constitution, the authorities have to act in a
reasonable way and within the reasonable period. When,
already the recommendations are sent by the Senior
Geologist way back on 21.03.2023, the authorities namely,
the 2nd respondent Director has to process the same
immediately and submit the papers to the portals of the first
respondent Government at the earliest. way That would
enure not only to the benefit of the petitioners but to the
State and the society as well.
- 12 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
4.
xxx
xxx
xxx
In the above circumstances, this petition is disposed
off with a direction to the 2nd respondent Director of Mines
and Geology to take the decision on the recommendations
dated 21.03.2023 submitted by the Senior Geologist within
an outer limit of six weeks and thereafter to submit the
papers to the 1st respondent Government to further process
the matter as expeditiously as possible. All contentions are
kept open."
16.
Thus, what remained for the authorities was consideration of
the recommendation in accordance with law, with all contentions
having been kept open. It was in the course of this process that the
complaint regarding the petitioners being members of the same
family came to be lodged. Significantly, the material placed on
record indicates that an enquiry was in fact undertaken by the Joint
Director, DMG. The petitioners specifically rely upon the reports
dated 03.10.2023 and 02.01.2024 to contend that they were found
to belong to separate nuclear families. The translated copy of
relevant
extracts
from
the
reports
dated
03.10.2023
02.01.2024 submitted by the Joint Director are extracted below:
Report dated 03.10.2023
"10. Sri R Srinivas Partner of M/s Prabha Earth Movers of
Stone quarry lease No: 284 and Sri R Basavaraju Partner of
Shakthi Enterprises of Stone Quarry Lease No: 285 are
children of Sri Ramaswamy V and Padmavathi it has found
from the Family Tree document submitted with stone quarry
and
- 13 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
lease application. They have informed that they will
establish Stone crusher in Sy No: 17 after sanction of the
stone quarry lease. The stone quarry lease has been
sanctioned to said in total 18-22 acre area. During the
enquiry it has found from the documents it has found that sri
R Srinivas and Sri R Basavaraju belong to nuclear families.
The statements and documents are enclosed"
Report dated 02.01.2024
Sl.
No.
Clarification Points
Clarification
In the report submitted
by
Joint
Director
Department of Mines
and Geology South
Zone Geology about
complaint
of
Honourable MLA by
conducting enquiry on
date; 3-10-2023 it has
found that the aid has
come conclusion that
even though lessees
belongs to same family,
but they are all nuclear
families
As per the documents
submitted by lessees it
has found that they
/belong to Nuclear Family.
1. Smt J G Kavitha and Sri
Nanjappa
belong
to
separate families.
2. Smt D Shantha, Sri D
Srinivas,
Sri
D
Govindaraju and sri D
Krishna are mother and
children. As per the
documents it has found
that their joint family has
bene
divided
through
Partition
Deed dated:
3. Sri R Basavaraju and
Sri R Srinivas are siblings.
As per the documents it
has found that Joint family
has been divided as
Nuclear Family through
Partition Deed. The
documents submitted by
all the 08 lessees are
enclosed in Annexure-01
- 14 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
to 08.
In the report submitted Not applicable
by Director, Department
of Mines and Geology
on date: 19-10-2023,
even
though
the
lessees
belongs
to
same family, are of
Joint family, since it will
not fall under Rule
15(3), so joint family
members can have
lease for maximum 1000 acre as per Tile
15(1).
In
the
affidavit
submitted
by
the
lessees that have not
referred to the aspect
that to deny that they
are members of Hindu
undivided family.
Apart from this in report
it has not given clear
opinion by examining
along with statutory
documents.
The
lessees
have
submitted the affidavit on
date: 19-12-2023 and 2212-2023
that
about
Nuclear family. As per the
documents and affidavits
submitted by lessees, it
has found that they belong
to Nuclear Family.
It is required once again
mention
about
complaint
given
regarding sanction of
stone quarry lease to
family/relatives
Joint
Director South Zone
has informed that they
are nuclear family and
Director in the report
that Joint Family.
It is required to examine
about interpretation of
As per the documents and
affidavits submitted by all
the 08 lessees, on date:
19-12-2023 and 22-122023 that they are .. ....
nuclear families.
The Rule 15(1) of KMMCR
has been examined. As
- 15 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
the Rule 15(1) of
KMMCR in respect of
sanction
of
Stone
quarry lease to said
lessees.
per the documents and
affidavits submitted by all
the 08 lessees, Smt J G
Kavitha and Sri Nanjappa
belong to different families
and are nuclear family.
From the documents it has
found that remaining 06
lessees have divided as
Nuclear families prior to
submission of application
to Department of Mines
and Geology for sanction
of the stone quarry lease
(emphasis supplied)
17.
Nevertheless, the impugned orders proceed substantially on
the premise that R. Basavaraju and R. Sreenivas are brothers and
consequently, treat their quarry holdings cumulatively for the
purpose of applying Rule 15. The explanation founded upon the
Panchayath Parikath dated 25.04.2010 has been discarded
principally on the ground that sufficient documentary evidence of
the partition had not been furnished.
18.
The learned Additional Government Advocate seeks to
sustain the impugned orders by contending that Panchayath
Parikath relied upon by the petitioners is an unregistered document
and does not establish disruption of the HUF. It is submitted that
the enquiry conducted by the Joint Director disclosed that R.
- 16 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
Basavaraju and R. Sreenivas belonged to the same family and
therefore, their aggregate quarry holdings exceeded the ceiling of
10 acres contemplated under Rule 15 of the KMMC Rules. It is
submitted that, on this basis, Section 19 of the MMDR Act has
been invoked to contend that mining concession granted in excess
of the permissible limit is void.
19.
This, in substance, is also the reasoning reflected in the
impugned orders. Pursuant to the complaint lodged, an enquiry
was conducted by the Joint Director and reports were submitted,
which have been extracted supra, recording that R. Basvaraju and
R. Srinivas were members of a separate nuclear families, their
family having been divided under a partition deed. Thus, even the
very issue which subsequently formed the foundation for the
impugned action had been the subject matter of an enquiry by the
Department and a report had already been submitted in that
regard.
20.
Despite the aforesaid material, the applications remained
pending. Thereafter, show-cause notices dated 22.10.2024 were
issued proposing cancellation of the quarry leases on the premise
- 17 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
that the proprietors of the two petitioners belonged to the same
HUF and that their aggregate holdings exceeded the ceiling
prescribed under Rule 15 (1) of the KMMC Rules. The explanation
offered by the petitioners about the partition and the earlier enquiry
was also not duly considered. The impugned orders were passed
notwithstanding that the Department had before it not only the
recommendation of the Senior Geologist dated 21.03.2023, but
also the subsequent enquiry reports of the Joint Director dated
03.10.2023 and 02.01.2024, recording that the two proprietors
constituted separate nuclear families. The impugned orders,
however, proceed on the contrary premise that they constituted
one family, which is unsustainable.
21.
In view of the foregoing reasons, the impugned orders dated
22.11.2024 are set aside.
22.
The respondent No.2-Director, DMG is directed to take a
decision on the petitioners' pending applications under Rule 3-E of
the KMMC Rules seeking inclusion of the newly discovered "grey
granite" in the existing quarry leases, having regard to the
recommendations dated 21.03.2023, the earlier order of this Court
- 18 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51284-DB
WP No. 35361 of 2024
CNR: KAHC010753582024
in W.P No.22321/2023 (GM-MMS) and the material emerging from
the enquiry reports dated 03.10.2023 and 02.01.2024, within an
outer limit of six weeks from date.
23.
The petition is accordingly allowed.
Sd/(VIBHU BAKHRU)
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sd/(K.S. HEMALEKHA)
JUDGE
MBM
List No.: 2 Sl No.: 10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review