Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 16th JULY, 2026
IN THE MATTER OF:
+
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026 & I.A. 3245/2026
M/S SDB CONSULTANTS PVT. LTD.
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr Akshay Joshi and Mr. Sameer
Abhyankar, Advocates
versus
SMC PNEUMATICS (I) PVT . LTD.
Through:
.....Respondent
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD
JUDGMENT
1.
The present Petition has been filed under Section 34 of the Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1996 [“Arbitration Act”], against the Arbitral Award
dated 27.09.2025 passed by the learned Sole Arbitrator, whereby the
Petitioner was held entitled to recover a sum of Rs. 4,48,316/- along with
interest at the rate of 18% per annum w.e.f. 20.07.2014 till realization
[“Impugned Award”].
2.
A brief factual background borne out from the material on record is as
under:
(i)
The Petitioner is a company incorporated under the Companies
Act, 1956, engaged in the business of architects, engineering
and project management, having an industry experience of over
60 years, while the Respondent is engaged in the business of
manufacturing.
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
(ii)
The Respondent, in relation to the project of constructing a
factory and office at Plot No. D-107 to 112, Phase II Extension,
Sector 84, Noida, Gautam Budh Nagar, Uttar Pradesh [“the
Project”], approached the Petitioner for providing professional
services. For this purpose, the parties entered into an
Architectural,
Engineering,
Project
Management
and
Consultancy Agreement dated 23.08.2012 [“the Contract”].
(iii)
Under and as per Part 1 and Part 2 of the Contract, the
Petitioner was supposed to inter alia supervise the construction
of the Respondent‟s factory and office at the Project Site, assist
in finalizing drawings and selecting a contractor. The Petitioner
was also obligated to assist and advice the Respondent in the
tender process and thereafter, select an appropriate contractor
for carrying out the works at the Project Site. Further, as per the
Clause 10 of the Contract, the duties and obligations of the
Petitioner would continue for 12 months after the date of
completion of the Project, as per the completion certificate
issued by the authority. Clause 10 of the Contract reads as
under:
(iv)
“The duties and obligation of SDB shall commence
with the signing of this Agreement and shall
continue for a period of 12 months after the date
of completion of Project as per completion
certificate issued by the authority.”
After a detailed discussion, the Contract Price was set at INR 31
Lakhs, which was mentioned in Clause 3 of the Contract.
Payment of the Contract Price was governed by Clauses 4 and 5
of the Contract, which read as under:
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
S.
Stage of Project
Payment
No.
Due
1. Along with contract
10%
2. Submission of layout drawings,
10%
detailed elevation drawings, corp.
drawings and obtain approval from
Local Authorities
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Completion
of
construction
documentation listed in clause II of
detailed Scope of work including
tender documents.
Completion of structure and brick
work
Completion of Electrical, Plumbing
& HVAC work
On virtual completion including
landscaping
At completion (on obtaining
Certification of completion from the
local authorities, submission of asbuilt drawings & documentation in
soft & hard certified format, final
settlement of accounts of contractors
& handing over of complete site to
SMC Pneumatics.)
After Twelve months of completion.
Total (Rupees Thirty One Lacs only)
10%
20%
10%
20%
15%
5%
100%
5. The payment will be made on the basis of the
above-agreed stages against bills submitted by
SDB from time to time. The service tax shall be
extra as applicable.”
(v)
About six months later, the Respondent chose to award the
Contract to M/s Rohan Builders (India) Pvt. Ltd. [“the
Contractor”] vide an Agreement dated 14.02.2013, in terms of
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
which the Project was to be completed by 31.08.2013, i.e.,
within six months from the date of the Agreement. The
Petitioner‟s role was to supervise the construction work being
undertaken by the Contractor and it was agreed that this role
would also cease by 31.08.2013.
(vi)
During the pendency of the construction works, the plan for
construction of a guest room on the second floor of the new
building was changed to ground floor of the existing building,
in accordance to which, the Petitioner issued revised drawings.
Certain other drawing and design changes were carried out
during the course of construction, for which admittedly, the
Petitioner ensured to issue revised drawings and sought the
Respondent‟s approval.
(vii) Material on record indicates that certain delay was brought
upon by the Contractor in performance of its obligations, for
which the Respondent levied Liquidated Damages to the tune of
approximately INR 55 Lakhs.
(viii) Subsequently, the Petitioner withdrew its Site Engineer from the
Project Site on or around 07.06.2014, when the construction
works were yet to be completed, meaning thereby, that no
completion certificate was issued. Notwithstanding the same
and prior to withdrawing its Site Engineer in June 2014, the
Petitioner under Clause 3 of the Contract, raised a bill dated
04.04.2014 for a sum of INR 17,41,580/-, alleging that the
entire work assigned to it under the Contract was completed and
therefore, 100% of the payment under the Contract became due
and payable. On the contrary, the Petitioner raised another bill
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
dated 11.04.2014, as per which it claimed payment of fee only
for the first four (4) stages as specified under Clause 4 of the
Contract.
(ix)
On 20.06.2014, the Petitioner invoked the arbitration clause
under the Contract, being aggrieved inter alia by the nonpayment of bills by the Respondent. The arbitration clause,
being Clause 11 of the Contract, reads as under:
“11. All questions and disputes under this
Agreement shall be submitted for adjudication to
Mr. D.C. Sidana, Director (Operations) of
company, and a representative of SDB shall be
dealt with in accordance with the provisions of
Indian Arbitration Act, 1996. The courts as Delhi
alone shall have jurisdiction in all connected
matters.”
(x)
When no response was received from the Respondent, the
Petitioner approached this Court by way of a petition under
Section 11 of the Arbitration Act bearing ARB. P. 552/2014.
This Court, vide Order dated 26.05.2015 appointed Sh. Rajesh
Kumar, learned ADJ (Retd.) to adjudicate upon the disputes
between the parties. Later, on account of the demise of the
above-named, this Court vide Order dated 24.08.2017 passed in
a petition under Sections 14 and 15 of the Arbitration Act, being
O.M.P (T) COMM. 59/2017, appointed the learned Sole
Arbitrator herein to adjudicate upon the disputes.
(xi)
The Petitioner filed its Statement of Claims on 01.09.2015,
claiming an amount of INR 84,91,827/- along with future
interest. On the other hand, the Respondent came to file its
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
Statement
of
Defence
along
with
Counter-Claims
on
12.10.2015, for an amount of INR 6,23,67,500/-.
(xii) The following issues were framed by the erstwhile arbitrator, on
which basis the learned Sole Arbitrator adjudicated the disputes:
“Issue No. 1. Whether claimant completed the
project in terms of clause 10 of the Agreement
dated 23.08.2012? OBP.
A. Whether Claimant is entitled to an amount of
Rs.177,41,480/- towards its invoice dated
04.04.2014? OPC.
B. Whether Claimant is entitled to an amount of
Rs.60,67,440/- towards its supplementary
bill/invoice dated 01.06.2014? OPC.
C. Whether Claimant is entitled to interest on the
amounts claimed? if so, at what rate and for
what period?
D. Whether
Respondent
is
entitled
to
Rs.1,54,35,000/- on account of loss due to
delay in completion of construction project?
OPR.
E. Whether
Respondent
Rs.38,00,000/- towards
production floor? OPR.
is
entitled
to
cost of relaying
F. Whether
Respondent
is
entitled
to
Rs.4,31,32,500/- towards loss of profit due to
relaying of floor? OPR.
G. Whether Respondent is entitled to future
interest @ 18% p.a. till the date of actual
payment? OPR.
H. Relief.”
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
(xiii) After the completion of pleadings, evidence and oral arguments,
the learned Sole Arbitrator passed by the Impugned Award,
dismissing all the counter-claims of the Respondent and partly
allowing the claims of the Petitioner to the extent of INR
4,48,316/- with interest at the rate of 18% p.a. w.e.f. 20.06.2014
till realization.
3.
Against the Impugned Award, the Petitioner has raised the following
grounds, specifically against the Issues No. 1, A and B being awarded in
favor of the Respondent:
(i)
Despite uncontroverted evidence of prolonged delays, admitted
changes in scope, and Respondent having deposited TDS, the
learned Sole Arbitrator allowed the Petitioner‟s claims only to a
nominal extent of INR 4,48,316/- with interest, rejecting the
substantial monetary claims without proper appreciation of
contractual provisions and material evidence on record.
(ii)
The learned Sole Arbitrator failed to read the terms of the
Contract in a manner that is reasonable, equitable and instead
read it in a manner that flouted business common-sense.
(iii)
The learned Sole Arbitrator, while dealing with Claim A raised
as per the Bill dated 04.04.2014, though noted the fact that
Respondent accepted the invoice and paid the TDS, ignored the
said bill, payment of TDS on it by Respondent and the
admissions regarding completion of building, but took note of
another invoice which was issued on request of Respondent for
a stage prior to completion, this bill was a sub part of the
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
holistic bill dated 04.04.2014 on which TDS was paid by the
Respondent.
(iv)
It is submitted that the above errors render the Impugned Award
in violation of the public policy of India and vitiated by patent
illegality on its face.
4.
In support of its arguments, learned Counsel for the Petitioner has
relied upon the judgment of the Apex Court in DMRC Ltd. v. Delhi Airport
Metro Express (P) Ltd., (2024) 6 SCC 357 and a judgment rendered by a
Division Bench of this Court in Jindal Rail Infrastructure Limited v. Union
of India & Anr., [FAO (OS) COMM 196/2022].
5.
Evidently, the Petitioner lays a limited challenge to the Impugned
Award, adjudication of which, in the opinion of this Court, did not warrant
issuance of a notice to the Respondent. Resultantly, the matter was reserved
on 06.07.2026 after hearing the oral arguments advanced by the learned
Counsel for the Petitioner.
6.
Before dealing with the merits of the case, this Court deems it fit to
recall the contours within which an application under Section 34 of the
Arbitration Act can be adjudicated upon, with specific emphasis on the
parameters of challenge based on „public policy‟ and „patent illegality‟.
7.
It is trite law that a challenge to the arbitral award can only be on the
grounds provided under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act. The award should
not be interfered with until the conclusion arrived at is perverse. Proceedings
under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act cannot be equated with appellate
jurisdiction and the court cannot reappreciate evidence. Accordingly,
interference by the court is limited to the grounds specified under the
Arbitration Act, including violation of public policy, fundamental principles
of Indian law or patent illegality going to the root of the matter. Mere errors
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
of law or reassessment of evidence do not justify setting aside an arbitral
award. Reference is made of the Judgment of the Apex Court in MMTC Ltd.
v. Vedanta Ltd., (2019) 4 SCC 163, wherein the following observations were
made:
“11. As far as Section 34 is concerned, the position is
well-settled by now that the Court does not sit in
appeal over the arbitral award and may interfere on
merits on the limited ground provided under Section
34(2)(b)(ii) i.e. if the award is against the public policy
of India. As per the legal position clarified through
decisions of this Court prior to the amendments to the
1996 Act in 2015, a violation of Indian public policy, in
turn, includes a violation of the fundamental policy of
Indian law, a violation of the interest of India, conflict
with justice or morality, and the existence of patent
illegality in the arbitral award. Additionally, the
concept of the “fundamental policy of Indian law”
would cover compliance with statutes and judicial
precedents, adopting a judicial approach, compliance
with the principles of natural justice, and Wednesbury
[Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd. v.
Wednesbury Corpn., (1948) 1 KB 223 (CA)]
reasonableness. Furthermore, “patent illegality” itself
has been held to mean contravention of the substantive
law of India, contravention of the 1996 Act, and
contravention of the terms of the contract.
12. It is only if one of these conditions is met that the
Court may interfere with an arbitral award in terms of
Section 34(2)(b)(ii), but such interference does not
entail a review of the merits of the dispute, and is
limited to situations where the findings of the
arbitrator are arbitrary, capricious or perverse, or
when the conscience of the Court is shocked, or when
the illegality is not trivial but goes to the root of the
matter. An arbitral award may not be interfered with if
the view taken by the arbitrator is a possible view
based on facts. (See Associate Builders v. DDA
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
[Associate Builders v. DDA, (2015) 3 SCC 49 : (2015)
2 SCC (Civ) 204] . Also see ONGC Ltd. v. Saw Pipes
Ltd. [ONGC Ltd. v. Saw Pipes Ltd., (2003) 5 SCC 705]
; Hindustan Zinc Ltd. v. Friends Coal Carbonisation
[Hindustan Zinc Ltd. v. Friends Coal Carbonisation,
(2006) 4 SCC 445] ; and McDermott International Inc.
v. Burn Standard Co. Ltd. [McDermott International
Inc. v. Burn Standard Co. Ltd., (2006) 11 SCC 181] )
13. It is relevant to note that after the 2015 Amendment
to Section 34, the above position stands somewhat
modified. Pursuant to the insertion of Explanation 1 to
Section 34(2), the scope of contravention of Indian
public policy has been modified to the extent that it
now means fraud or corruption in the making of the
award, violation of Section 75 or Section 81 of the Act,
contravention of the fundamental policy of Indian law,
and conflict with the most basic notions of justice or
morality. Additionally, sub-section (2-A) has been
inserted in Section 34, which provides that in case of
domestic arbitrations, violation of Indian public policy
also includes patent illegality appearing on the face of
the award. The proviso to the same states that an
award shall not be set aside merely on the ground of an
erroneous application of the law or by reappreciation
of evidence.
14. As far as interference with an order made under
Section 34, as per Section 37, is concerned, it cannot
be disputed that such interference under Section 37
cannot travel beyond the restrictions laid down under
Section 34. In other words, the court cannot undertake
an independent assessment of the merits of the award,
and must only ascertain that the exercise of power by
the court under Section 34 has not exceeded the scope
of the provision. Thus, it is evident that in case an
arbitral award has been confirmed by the court under
Section 34 and by the court in an appeal under Section
37, this Court must be extremely cautious and slow to
disturb such concurrent findings.”
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
8.
Reference is also made to the judgment of the Apex Court in OPG
Power Generation (P) Ltd. v. Enexio Power Cooling Solutions (India) (P)
Ltd., (2025) 2 SCC 417, wherein the following discussion regarding how
the term „patent illegality‟ is to be construed:
“Patent illegality
65. Sub-section (2-A) of Section 34 of the 1996 Act,
which was inserted by the 2015 Amendment, provides
that an arbitral award not arising out of international
commercial arbitrations, may also be set aside by the
Court, if the Court finds that the award is visited by
patent illegality appearing on the face of the award.
The proviso to sub-section (2-A) states that an award
shall not be set aside merely on the ground of an
erroneous application of the law or by reappreciation
of evidence.
66. In ONGC Ltd. v. Saw Pipes Ltd., (2003) 5 SCC
705, while dealing with the phrase “public policy of
India” as used in Section34, this Court took the view
that the concept of public policy connotes some matter
which concerns public good and public interest. If the
award, on the face of it, patently violates statutory
provisions, it cannot be said to be in public interest.
Thus, an award could also be set aside if it is patently
illegal. It was, however, clarified that illegality must go
to the root of the matter and if the illegality is of trivial
nature, it cannot be held that award is against public
policy.
67. In Associate Builders v. DDA, (2015) 3 SCC 49,
this Court held that an award would be patently illegal,
if it is contrary to:
(a) substantive provisions of law of India;
(b) provisions of the 1996 Act; and
(c) terms of the contract [See also three-Judge Bench
decision of this Court in State of Chhattisgarh v. SAL
Udyog (P) Ltd., (2022)2 SCC 275].
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
The Court clarified that if an award is contrary to the
substantive provisions of law of India, in effect, it is in
contravention of Section 28(1)(a) of the 1996 Act.
Similarly, violating terms of the contract, in effect, is in
contravention of Section 28(3) of the 1996Act.
68. In Ssangyong Engg. & Construction Co. Ltd. v.
NHAI, (2019)15 SCC 131 this Court specifically dealt
with the 2015Amendment which inserted sub-section
(2-A) in Section 34 of the1996 Act. It was held that
“patent illegality appearing on the face of the award”
refers to such illegality as goes to the root of matter,
but which does not amount to mere erroneous
application of law. It was also clarified that what is not
subsumed within “the fundamental policy of Indian
law”, namely, the contravention of a statute not linked
to “public policy” or “public interest”, cannot be
brought in by the backdoor when it comes to setting
aside an award on the ground of patent illegality [See
Ssangyong Engg. &Construction Co. Ltd. v. NHAI,
(2019) 15 SCC 131]. Further, it was observed,
reappreciation of evidence is not permissible under this
category of challenge to an arbitral award [See
Ssangyong Engg. & Construction Co. Ltd. v. NHAI,
(2019) 15 SCC 131].”
9.
Now, this Court shall deal with the objections raised by the Petitioner
against the findings in the Impugned Award.
10.
The very first contention of the Petitioner is that the Contract
stipulated a completion period of 6 months and thereafter, the 12-month
defect liability period would commence. On this argument, the learned Sole
Arbitrator observed that there was no document which would support this
stand of the Petitioner, as Clause 10 of the Contract merely stated that the
duties and obligations shall commence with the signing of the Contract and
continue for a period of 12 months after the date of completion of Project as
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
per the completion certificate issued by the authority. To arrive at this
conclusion, the learned Sole Arbitrator relied upon the examination of the
Claimant‟s Witness – CW-1 as well as the cross-examination of
Respondent‟s Witness – RW-1, who corroborated the position that there was
no explicit 6-month timeline under the Contract. In particular, the learned
Sole Arbitrator referred to the Question No. 56 put to RW-1, which is being
extracted below fir reference:
“Q 56
Is it correct that the claimant had
suggested that the construction of the building would
take about one year?
A
Yes.”
11.
The learned Sole Arbitrator also observed that since Clause 10 of the
Contract remained unamended even after the Agreement with the Contractor
was executed, there is no merit in the 6-month completion period argument
of the Petitioner. This entire conclusion was also buttressed by Sections 91
and 92 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1862, to observe that the version of
„understood between the parties‟ was not only unproved but would also be
inadmissible on account of being an oral understanding.
12.
With the above conclusion that no 6-month completion period was
prescribed under the Contract, the learned Sole Arbitrator undertook to
adjudicate Issue No. 1, as to whether the Petitioner completed the Project in
terms of Clause 10 of the Contract. The nail was put into this issue against
the Petitioner on the very fact that the Petitioner withdrew its Site Engineer
from the Project Site on or around 07.06.2014, in addition to the fact that
even the Bill dated 11.04.2014 raised by the Petitioner was only till Stage 4
as envisioned in Clause 4 of the Contract. As such, Issue No. 1 was decided
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
against the Petitioner to conclude that the Petitioner failed to complete the
Project in terms of Clause 10 of the Project.
13.
It is evident that apart from the repeated averment of the Petitioner,
there is no material on record to show that the completion period of the
Project was 6 months. Clause 10 merely states that the duties and obligations
shall commence with the signing of the Contract and continue for a period of
12 months after the date of completion of Project as per the completion
certificate issued by the authority. No other provision in the Contract deals
with the completion period. In any event, the fact that the Petitioner
withdrew its Site Engineer on or around 07.06.2014, a position which the
Petitioner admitted in its Letter dated 10.06.2014, is enough to show that the
Project was virtually abandoned by the Petitioner. Relevant part of the Letter
dated 10.06.2014 is being extracted below:
“
xxx
Please refer to your E-mail dated June 7th 2014
drawing our attention to the withdrawal of our Site
Engineers from site.
It may please be noted that we had no alternate but to
take this step, after you have failed to respond to our
requests from time to time release our professional fees
which becomes payable in accordance with our
agreement for Architectural and Engineering Services.
xxx”
14.
Accordingly, this Court sees no reason to interfere with the above-
discussed findings of the learned Sole Arbitrator, having been based
squarely on the appreciation of the evidence, interpretation of the terms of
the Contract between the parties as well as supported by applicable legal
provisions.
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
15.
The next issue being Issue No. A was to determine whether the
Petitioner was entitled to an amount of INR 17,41,480/- towards the Invoice
dated 04.04.2014. This issue was framed by the learned Sole Arbitrator on
the basis of Claim No. 1 raised by the Petitioner, alleging that the entire sum
of INR 31 lakhs became due and payable on part of the Respondent. Details
of the Invoice dated 04.04.2014 is being extracted below:
“Professional fee for Construction of New Factory
Building and Office at D107 to 112, Phase-II Extn,
Sector 84, Noida.
Total fees due under Clause No.3 of our Rs. 31,00,000.00
agreement.
Fee now due on Completion of Work Rs. 31,00,000.00
@100%
Add Service Tax @12.36%
Rs. 3,83,160.00
-------------------
Less Amount already Received vide
Cheque No.108697 dated 24.08.2012or Rs. 3, 10,000. 00
Rs.2,79,000.00 TDS deduct Rs.31,000.00
Less Payment received through NIFT in
ICICI on 30.03.2013 for Rs.6,61,453.00 Rs. 7, 34,948.00
TDS deduct Rs. 73,495.00
Less Payment received through NIFT in
ICICI on 27.03.2014or Rs.6,96,632.00 Rs.6,96,632.00
including TDS
-----------------Balance Now Due
Rs.17,41,580
(Rupees Seventeen lakhs Forty One Thousand Five
Hundred Eighty Only).”
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
16.
The learned Sole Arbitrator observed that for adjudication of this
Issue No. A, the factum of 100% completion of works had to be established.
For this purpose, the learned Sole Arbitrator took note of the Letter dated
10.06.2014 sent by the Petitioner to the Respondent as well as the
Petitioner‟s Statement of Claims. In particular, it referred to Paragraph No.
32 of the Statement of Claims, which is being extracted below:
“32. That since the Respondent and its contractor
had failed to complete the construction and the
Respondent had failed to clear the professional fees
of the Claimant, it was left with no other alternate but
to withdraw its Site Engineer from the Site on or
around 07.06.2014. Further, Claimant vide its letter
dated 10.06.2014 informed the Respondent inter alia
that despite the building being far from complete, at
the asking of the Respondent, it had issued completion
drawings to the Respondent for submission to Local
authorities; despite the incompetency of the contractor,
Respondent was ready to take up the final bill of the
contractor for payment whereas it had refused to pay
the Claimant and the payment towards A the same have
been held up without any reason. That inspite of
insulting,
inhuman,
unethical
and
highly
unprofessional attitude towards the Claimant, it
continued to extend full cooperation with the
Respondent, however, the Respondent had held up the
professional charges liable to be paid to the Claimant.
In the circumstances, the Claimant requested the
Respondent to make the payment of its bill for
supplementary services within seven days, failing
which it would be restrained to take all steps stipulated
and permissible by law.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
17.
The learned Sole Arbitrator held that since the Petitioner itself
claimed that Stages 1 to 4 under Clause 4 were completed and on this basis,
raised the Invoice/Bill dated 04.04.2014, only an amount of INR 20,89,896/Signature Not Verified
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
would be due and payable by the Respondent. He further calculated the total
balance due after subtracting amounts already paid, as INR 3,48,316/-. The
learned Sole Arbitrator further notes that this Bill dated 04.04.2014 was
produced by the Respondent itself and it was nowhere denied by the
Respondent that the Petitioner had not completed the first four stages as
enumerated in Clause 4 of the Contract. On this basis, the learned Sole
Arbitrator partially decided Issue No. A in favor of the Petitioner, by holding
the Petitioner as entitled to recover the sum of INR 3,48,316/- from the
Respondent.
18.
The above decision of the learned Sole Arbitrator appears to be
reasonable and sound, as even though the Petitioner raised a bill on the basis
of having completed all the stages under Clause 4, there is enough material
on record to show admission on part of the Petitioner itself that the Project
could not be completed. As such, no interference is warranted in the decision
of the learned Sole Arbitrator on Issue No. A.
19.
The last challenge laid by the Petitioner is against the decision of the
learned Sole Arbitrator on Issue No. B, which was framed to determine
whether the Petitioner was entitled to an amount of INR 60,67,440/- towards
it supplementary bill/invoice dated 01.06.2014 or not. Details of the said bill
are extracted below:
“For redesigning the total scheme after
issuing G.F.C. Drawings
Rs. 9,00,000.00
Providing multiple Solutions / Options
of different areas after issuing G.F.C.
Drawings
Rs. 9,00,000.00
Re-drawing of all G.F.C. Drawings
after revision of total scheme.
Rs. 15,00,000.00
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
Supervising the building beyond
agreeable date of completion @ Rs.
60,000.00 per month for ten months
Providing project management of
building beyond agreeable date of
completion @ Rs. 90,000.00 per month
for ten months Cost of Maintaining the
records of building beyond agreeable
date of completion @ Rs.60,000.00 per
month for ten months
Rs. 9,00,000.00
Rs. 6,00,000.00
------------------
Total Supplementary Fee due till date
Rs. 54,00,000.00
Add Service Tax@12.36%
Rs. 6,67,440.00
------------------Rs. 60,67,440.00”
Total amount due till date
20.
Rs. 6,00,000.00
The learned Sole Arbitrator at the very outset noted that the first three
items enumerated in the above bill were for allegedly doing work beyond
the agreeable date of completion for 10 months, despite the Contract not
having specified any date of completion at all. Apart from this, the learned
Sole Arbitrator also noted that there were several changes in the design and
drawings by the Respondent, which were timely acted upon by the
Petitioner. While opposing this Issue, the Respondent took support of Clause
6 of the Contract, to argue that the Petitioner cannot claim any amounts for
deviations. Clause 6 of the Contract reads as under:
“The company shall consider all sketches, drawings,
specifications proposal reports, agreement or other
documents before inviting bids, laid before them by
SDB and shall if considered necessary intimate in due
and proper time to SDB all such deviation sought to be
made from the original scheme and the same shall be
carried out and implemented without any extra cost by
SDB well in time so as not to delay the work.”
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
21.
The learned Sole Arbitrator observed that Clause 6 cannot aid the
Respondent, since it was an admitted position that the deviations in design
and drawings were done during the pendency of the Contract and not before
inviting bids, as is provided for in Clause 6 extracted above. In addition, the
learned Sole Arbitrator referred to the examination of the Petitioner‟s as well
as Respondent‟s witness examinations, which indicated clearly that several
deviations were made during the pendency of the Contract. For this reason,
the learned Sole Arbitrator awarded the Petitioner an amount of INR 1 lakh,
for the extra work carried out by the Petitioner on account of the deviations.
22.
This Court finds itself in agreement with the in-depth analysis done
by the learned Sole Arbitrator on Issue No. B, for the reason of it being
based on the contractual provisions, evidence and the rival submissions of
the parties. No patent illegality on the face of this portion of the Impugned
Award is made out, and this Court does not deem it fit to go into the
question as to whether the award of INR 1 lakh to the Petitioner is sufficient
or not.
23.
A careful and comprehensive perusal of the Impugned Award
demonstrates that the learned Sole Arbitrator has examined the pleadings,
documentary material, correspondence exchanged between the parties, and
the evidence led in support of their respective claims and assertions. The
Impugned Award reflects due consideration of the relevant facts and
surrounding circumstances germane to the disputes.
24.
The Impugned Award reflects a plausible and reasoned interpretation
of the contract and an evaluation of evidence within the jurisdiction of the
learned Sole Arbitrator. It is well settled that a court exercising limited
supervisory jurisdiction under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act cannot reSignature Not Verified
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
appreciate evidence or substitute its own interpretation of contractual clauses
where the view taken by the learned Sole Arbitrator is a possible and
reasonable one.
25.
Viewed in its entirety, the Impugned Award reflects a reasoned and
structured adjudication of the disputes by the learned Sole Arbitrator within
the confines of the contractual terms agreed upon by the parties, the material
placed on record, and the jurisdiction vested in the learned Sole Arbitrator.
The Impugned Award demonstrates due application of mind to the
pleadings, evidence, and relevant contractual provisions.
26.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the Petitioners have failed to establish any ground under Section
34(2) or Section 34(2A) of the Arbitration Act warranting interference with
the Impugned Award.
27.
Accordingly, the present Petition, along with pending Application(s),
if any, stands dismissed.
SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD, J
JULY 16, 2026
Rahul/AP
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
17:21:11
O.M.P. (COMM) 70/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review