Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 20.07.2026
Date of Decision: 24.07.2026
Uploaded on: 24.07.2026
+
CRL.M.C. 5408/2014
M/S ROSMARINE SHIPPING PVT LTD
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Manish Gandhi, Mr. Rolly Dixit
and Mr. Sanjeev Beniwal, Advs.
versus
M/S CLUTCH AUTO LTD & ORS
Through: None.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
.....Respondents
JUDGMENT
MADHU JAIN, J.
1.
The present petition has been filed under Section 482 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Cr.P.C.’) assailing the
judgment dated 25.07.2014 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge
in Criminal Revision No. 56/2014, whereby the order dated 10.12.2013
passed by the learned Metropolitan Magistrate in Complaint Case titled
Rosmarine Shipping Pvt. Ltd. v. Clutch Auto Ltd. & Ors., dismissing the
complaint filed by the petitioner under Section 200 Cr.P.C., came to be
affirmed.
Brief Facts:
2.
The petitioner, M/s Rosmarine Shipping Pvt. Ltd. (hereinafter referred
to as the ‘petitioner’), is a private limited company engaged in the business
of freight forwarding and shipping services. The present petition has been
instituted through its Director, Shri Rajesh Bhatia, who is stated to have
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:21:12
CRL.M.C. 5408/2014
been duly authorised by a Board Resolution dated 02.06.2010.
3.
It is the case of the petitioner that during February–March, 2005,
respondent No.1, M/s Clutch Auto Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as the
‘respondent company’), acting through respondent Nos.2 to 4, approached
the petitioner for transportation and shipping of used machinery purchased
from M/s Daikin Clutch Corporation, USA (hereinafter referred to as
‘Daikin USA’). Pursuant thereto, the parties entered into a commercial
arrangement whereby the petitioner was to undertake transportation of the
machinery from the United States to the factory premises of the respondent
company at Faridabad, including customs clearance and allied logistics
services.
4.
According to the petitioner, the parties agreed that the respondent
company would pay service charges equivalent to 9% of the Free on Board
(FOB) value of the shipment, in addition to the transportation charges. It is
the petitioner's case that the agreed FOB value was understood to include the
value of the machinery as well as the costs incurred towards dismantling,
packaging, handling and delivery of the machinery to the shipping company.
The petitioner relies upon an e-mail communication dated 17.03.2005 in
support of the aforesaid arrangement.
5.
It is further the case of the petitioner that the machinery was
transported under House Bill of Lading No. ITC50409 dated 28.04.2005,
and that it completed the transportation and customs-related formalities in
terms of the arrangement between the parties. The cargo is stated to have
remained with the Customs Department between 23.08.2005 and 01.10.2005
for assessment of customs duty and verification of the declared FOB value.
6.
According to the petitioner, during the customs proceedings,
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:21:12
CRL.M.C. 5408/2014
respondent No.2 addressed a communication dated 28.09.2005 to the
Commissioner of Customs enclosing another communication purportedly
issued by an official of Daikin USA, stating that the consideration for the
machinery was USD 1,50,000, which included dismantling charges and
other costs incurred up to handing over the machinery to the shipping
company.
7.
The petitioner further alleges that while pursuing recovery of its
service charges, it came across a subsequent communication dated
09.12.2005, on the basis of which it formed the view that the communication
dated 28.09.2005, purportedly issued on behalf of Daikin USA, was not
genuine. According to the petitioner, the subsequent communication
indicated that the machinery had been sold by Daikin USA to the respondent
company on an ‘as is where is’ basis for a consideration of USD 1,50,000,
and that the said amount did not represent the FOB value of the shipment.
8.
The petitioner states that between 2006 and 2010, it addressed several
complaints and reminders to the police authorities alleging commission of
offences by the respondents. It also obtained a handwriting expert's opinion
dated 19.09.2009, which, according to the petitioner, indicated that the
questioned signatures appearing on the impugned communication differed
from the admitted signatures of the concerned official of Daikin USA.
9.
Thereafter, the petitioner instituted a complaint under Section 200
Cr.P.C. along with an application under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. seeking
registration of an FIR against the respondents. The application under Section
156(3) Cr.P.C. came to be dismissed by the learned MM, whereafter the
petitioner led pre-summoning evidence in support of the complaint. During
the course of the pre-summoning evidence, the petitioner examined its
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:21:12
CRL.M.C. 5408/2014
authorised representative as well as a handwriting expert, an official from
the respondents' banker and a customs official, besides placing the relevant
documentary record before the learned MM.
10.
Upon consideration of the complaint and the pre-summoning
evidence, the learned MM dismissed the complaint vide order dated
10.12.2013. Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner preferred Criminal Revision
No. 56/2014, which also came to be dismissed by the learned ASJ vide
judgment dated 25.07.2014. Aggrieved by the aforesaid orders, the
petitioner has preferred the present petition.
Submissions on behalf of the petitioner
11.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the learned MM and
the learned ASJ failed to appreciate that the material placed on record,
including the pre-summoning evidence of the handwriting expert, the
respondents’ banker and the customs official, prima facie disclosed the
commission of cognizable offences by the respondents. He further places
reliance upon the decisions of the Supreme Court in S.W. Palanitkar v.
State of Bihar, (2002) 1 SCC 241, Nirmaljit Singh Hoon v. State of W.B.,
(1973) 3 SCC 753, Vadilal Panchal v. Dattatraya Dulaji Ghadigaonkar,
1960 SCC OnLine SC 79, Chandra Deo Singh v. Prokash Chandra Bose,
1963 SCC OnLine SC 4 and Mohinder Singh v. Gulwant Singh, (1992) 2
SCC 213 to submit that the learned MM and learned ASJ failed to appreciate
the essence of Sections 200 and 202 of the Cr.P.C.
12.
It is submitted that the learned ASJ erred in observing that the
petitioner was entitled to a percentage on the invoice amount of USD
1,50,000 as commission, whereas, according to the petitioner, the agreement
between the parties contemplated payment of 9% of the FOB value of the
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:21:12
CRL.M.C. 5408/2014
shipment.
13.
It is submitted that the learned MM and the learned ASJ failed to
appreciate that the invoice dated 30.03.2005 and the communication dated
28.09.2005, purportedly issued under the signatures of Mr. Kenneth J.
Shunta, were forged. It is further submitted that the communication dated
15.03.2011, issued on behalf of Mr. Kenneth J. Shunta, established that he
had neither issued nor authorised the issuance of the communication dated
28.09.2005.
14.
Learned counsel further submits that the complaint was not filed for
recovery of any amount but disclosed the commission of offences of
cheating, forgery and criminal breach of trust.
15.
It is further submitted that the forged documents were used before the
Customs Authorities, thereby causing wrongful loss to the petitioner as well
as the public exchequer.
16.
It is submitted that the matter was at the stage of issuance of process
and the material placed on record was sufficient to make out a prima facie
case for summoning the respondents. Accordingly, the impugned judgment
and order are liable to be set aside.
Submissions on behalf of the respondents
17.
When the matter was reserved for judgment, none appeared on behalf
of the respondents. The present judgment is, therefore, being rendered on the
basis of the written submissions and the material available on record.
18.
Respondents in his reply submits that the complaint under Section 200
Cr.P.C. was rightly dismissed, which order was rightly affirmed in revision.
19.
It is submitted that the alleged transaction pertains to the year 2005,
whereas the complaint was lodged only in 2010, without any explanation for
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:21:12
CRL.M.C. 5408/2014
the delay of nearly five years. It is further submitted that the petitioner has
neither disclosed when it acquired knowledge of the alleged forgery nor
explained the delay in initiating the proceedings.
20.
It is submitted that the allegation of forgery of the letter dated
28.09.2005 rests solely on the opinion of the handwriting expert, who
compared the disputed signature with scanned photocopies obtained from a
website. It is further submitted that Mr. Kenneth J. Shunta was not
examined, and none of the witnesses examined during pre-summoning
evidence, including the handwriting expert, the Canara Bank official and the
Customs Officer, prima facie establish forgery.
21.
It is submitted that the petitioner admittedly received 9% commission
on the FOB value of USD 1,50,000, and that the dispute pertains only to the
alleged commission on USD 28,800 towards dismantling and packing
charges.
22.
It is submitted that the allegations arise out of the contractual
arrangement between the parties and pertain to recovery of the alleged
commission.
23.
Accordingly, it is submitted that the present petition is devoid of merit
and liable to be dismissed.
Analysis and Findings
24.
Before adverting to the merits of the rival contentions, it is important
to note that the scope of revisional jurisdiction under Section 397 Cr.P.C. is
limited. The Revisional Court is concerned only with examining the
correctness, legality or propriety of the impugned order and to ascertain
whether any patent illegality, jurisdictional error or material irregularity has
crept into the proceedings. It is not expected to substitute its own view
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:21:12
CRL.M.C. 5408/2014
merely because another view may also be possible.
25.
It is equally well settled that at the stage of considering a complaint
under Sections 200 and 203 Cr.P.C., the Magistrate is not required to
undertake a meticulous appreciation of the evidence. The Court is only
required to ascertain whether the material placed before it discloses
sufficient grounds for proceeding against the proposed accused. The
Magistrate is not expected to undertake a meticulous appreciation of the
evidence. Conversely, where the material placed on record does not prima
facie disclose the commission of the alleged offences, the complaint is liable
to be dismissed under Section 203 Cr.P.C.
26.
The judgments relied upon by the learned counsel for the petitioner,
reiterate the settled principles governing proceedings under Sections 200 and
203 Cr.P.C., that at the stage of considering a complaint the Magistrate is
required to examine whether sufficient grounds exist for proceeding and is
not expected to undertake a meticulous appreciation of the evidence. The
said principles are not in dispute. The same has been reiterated by the
Supreme Court in its recent decision Rekha Sharad Ushir v. Saptashrungi
Mahila Nagari Sahkari Patsansta Ltd., 2025 SCC OnLine SC 641, which
reads as under:
“21. While filing a complaint under Section 200 of
CrPC and recording his statement on oath in
support of the complaint, as the complainant
suppresses material facts and documents, he
cannot be allowed to set criminal law in motion
based on the complaint. Setting criminal law in
motion by suppressing material facts and
documents is nothing but an abuse of the process
of law.”
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:21:12
CRL.M.C. 5408/2014
27.
In the present case, the learned MM considered the complaint, the
pre-summoning evidence and the documents placed on record before
concluding that no sufficient grounds were made out for issuance of process.
The learned ASJ, while exercising revisional jurisdiction, independently
examined the record and found no infirmity in the said conclusion. It is also
not in dispute that the alleged transaction pertains to the year 2005, whereas
the complaint came to be instituted only in the year 2010. The record does
not disclose any satisfactory explanation for the delay in initiating the
criminal proceedings.
28.
The principal submissions of the petitioner pertain to the genuineness
of the communication dated 28.09.2005, the alleged forgery of signatures,
the valuation of the shipment and the petitioner's entitlement to additional
commission. These were the very issues examined by the learned MM while
considering the pre-summoning evidence. Upon appreciation of the material
placed on record, the learned MM concluded that no prima facie case was
made out and that the dispute was essentially civil in nature. The learned
ASJ found no infirmity in the said view. The decisions relied upon by the
petitioner lay down settled principles of law. In the facts of the present case,
this Court also finds no patent illegality, perversity or jurisdictional error in
the impugned orders warranting interference under Section 482 Cr.P.C.
Conclusion
29.
Accordingly, this Court finds no merit in the present petition. The
impugned judgment dated 25.07.2014 passed by the learned ASJ, affirming
the order dated 10.12.2013 passed by the learned MM dismissing the
complaint under Section 200 Cr.P.C., does not warrant interference. The
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:21:12
CRL.M.C. 5408/2014
present petition is, accordingly, dismissed.
30.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
MADHU JAIN
(JUDGE)
JULY, 24 2026/Av
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
18:21:12
CRL.M.C. 5408/2014
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review