Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3300 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO: 33804 OF 2024
Between:
1. M/s Readers Stores, lncorporated under the provisions of Office address. C16, lDA, Uppal, Hyderabad -500039, Telangana State.Rep by its Director. lvlr.
Jagan Mohan Reddy, S/o G. Ram Reddy, aged about 50 years, Occ. Director,
M/s Readers Stores lndia Pvt. Ltd.R/o Flat No 202, Venu Mansion,
Saleemnagar, Malakpet, Hyderabad -500036.
2. Readers Shift CFS (SPV), Office address. C-16, lDA, Uppal, Hyderabad 500039, Telangana State. Rep by its Authorised Signatory. Mr. Jagan Mohan
Reddy, S/o G. Ram Reddy, aged about 50 years, Occ. Director, ltl/s Readers
Stores lndia Pvt. Ltd.R/o FIat No. 202, Venu Mansion, Saleemnagar,
Malakpet, Hyderabad - 500036.
3. Mr. Jagan Mohan Reddy, S/o G. Ram Reddy,aged about 50 years, Occ.
Director, [tr1ls Readers Stores lndia Pvt. Ltd.R/o Flat No. 202, Venu Mansion,
Saleemnagar, Malakpet, Hyderabad - 500036.
.....PETITIONERS
AND
1. Telangana State Trade, Promotion Corporation Limited, Hyderabad, ( now
known as TGTPC) Rep by its Chairman with its Regd. Office at 2nd Floor,
Shakkar Bhavan, D. No.5-10-'174, Fathemaidan Road, Hyderabad -500004,
2. General Manager, Telangana State Trade Promotion Corporation Limited,
Fathemaidan Road, Hyderabad.
.....RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed thqrewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate writ, order, or direction more particularly in nature
of a writ of mandamus declaring the action of Respondent Authorities in acting
contrary to the terms of Request for proposal including terms of the Letter of
Award vide Letter of Award vide Ref.APTOC/CFS/M.PallylOandMlLON2023
dt 08/05/2023. thereby not entering/ executing the O and M Contract is arbitrary,
illegal, u nconstitutronal more particularly violative of Article 14 of the Constitution
of lndia, 1950, and Consequently direct the Respondent authorities to comply with
the
terms and conditions of
Letter of
Award vide
Ref.APTOC/CFS/M.Pally/OandM/LOA/2023 dt.0B/05/2023 and thereby execute O
and M contract in favor of Petitioner.
l.A.NO:1 OF 2024
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated an
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
forthwith direct the Respondent No.1 corporation to take steps in furtherance and
in
compliance with
Letter
of
Award
vide
Ref.APTOC/CFS/M.Pally/OandMlLOAl2023 dt.0810512023 including signing of the
O and M conlract in favor of Petitioners.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI N.NAVEEN KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondents : ADDL ADVOCATE GENERAL
The Court made the following ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION No. 33804 OF 2o24
09.ot.2026
Between:
M/s Readers Stores
Rep. by its Director Mr. Jagan Mohan Reddy & others
Petitioners
And
Telangana State Trade Promotion Corporation Limited,
Hyderabad known as TGTPC
Rep. by its Chairman & another
Respondents
ORDER:
The specific case of Petitioners is that Respondent
No.1 Telangana State Trade Promotion Corporation Limited is a
Government of Telangana undertaking and a
State
instrumentality within the meaning of Article 12 of the
Constitution, established with the object of promoting trade,
commerce and industry, including creation and operation of
logistics and trade promotional infrastructure such as
Container Freight Stations, lnland Container Depots, Cold
Storage Plants and Warehouses. Aggrieved by the action of
Respondent No.1 Corporation in acting contrary to the terms
and conditions of the Request for Proposal and the ktter of
-)
Award dated 08.05.2023, and in not entering into or executing
the Operation and Management Contract in their favour, despite
having been declared as successful bidders, petitioners are
before this Court. Such conduct of Respondent No.l is assailed
as arbitrary, illegal, unconstitutional and violative of Article 14
of the Constitution.
1.
1.
Petitioners state that in furtherance of its mandate,
Respondent No. 1 Corporation established a Container Freight
Station, hereinafter referred to as'the Project', at Mamidipally,
Hyderabad, and invited proposals for operating, marketing,
developing and maintaining the said facility.. They issued a
Request for Proposal prescribing the bidding process and
schedule for selection of an Operation and Management
Operator for the Container Freight Station. It was specifically
stipulated therein that the selected bidder would be required to
submit a Detailed Business PIan within four weeks of
acceptance of the Letter of Award. The Request for Proposal
provided that the selected bidder would be responsible for
operating, maintaining and marketing the facility for a
concession period of30 years, in accordance with the provisions
of the Operation and Management Contract proposed to be
I
entered into between contractor and Respondent No. I
Corporation.
1.2.
In response to the Request for Proposal floated by
Respondent No.1 Corporation, Petitioner No.I participated in
the bidding process and submitted its technical bid on
26.09.2022. The said technical bid was evaluated by
Respondent No. 1 and Petitioner No. 1 was declared technically
qualified, thereby entitling it to participate in the hnancial bid
process. Thereafter, Petitioner No.I submitted its financial bid
on 27.O9.2022. Subsequent to negotiations conducted by
Respondent No. I Corporation, Petitioner No. I submitted a
revised financial bid along with a Preliminary Business Plan on
27.03.2023. They were placed before the Board of Respondent
No.
I Corporation and were accepted in the 33.d meeting of the
Board held oil 25.O4.2023. Pursuant to the said acceptance, the
Operation and Management contract of the Container Freight
Station at Mamidipally was awardcd to Petitioners, subject to
certain conditions.
1.3.
Consequent thereto, Respondent No. 1 Corporation
issued lrtter of Award dated 08.O5.2O23 in favour of the
Petitioners, awarding the Operation and Management of the
Container Freight Station at Mamidipally, near Rajiv Gandhi
l
j
I
International Airport. By virtue of the said Letter of Award,
Petitioner No.1 emerged as the successful bidder. It is asserted
that Respondent No. 1 Corporation stipulated, as prerequisites
for execution o[ the Operation and Management Contract, that
Petitioncrs should incorporate a Special Purpose Vehicle jointly
with M/s Shift Logistics, the consortium member, and furnish a
Performance Bank Guarantee. In furtherance of the lrtter of
Award dated 08.05.2023, Petitioners addressed e mail dated
24.O5.2O23 accepting the selection as successful bidder. It is
specifically stated that upon noticing that the Letter of Award
restricted the operation of the facility solely as a Container
Freight Station, u,hich restriction was contrary to the terms of
the Request for Proposal, Petitioners requested amendment of
the Letter of Award. The Request for Proposal permitted use of
the facility lor multiple purposes, including as an Air Freight
Station, Logistics Facility, Bonded Warehouse or domestic
cargo, and that the Petitioners had submitted their bid on that
basis.
1.4.
Petitioners state that the request made vide e mail
dated 24.O5.2O23 was not a rejection of the Letter of Award, but
a request to bring the Letter of Award in conformity with the
tender guidelines and the Request for Proposal. In furtherance
-)
of acceptance of Letter of Award and in compliance with the
prerequisites for entering into the Operation and Management
Contract, Petitioners incorporated a Special Purpose Vehicle
under the provisions ol the Companies Act, 20 13, represented
by Petitioner No.3. Immediately upon incorporation of Special
Purpose Vehicle, Petitioners intimated Respondent No. 1
Corporation of the same and requested confirmation regarding
the quantum and tenure of Performance Bank Guarantee
required to be furnished.
1.5.
Respondent No. I Corporation, in response thereto,
intimated that a Performance Bank Guarantee equivalent to six
months' concession fee, as stipulated in the Request for
Proposal, was required to be furnished. Acting in compliance
with the said requirement, Petitioners furnished a Performance
Security for Rs. 19,50,OOO/ - (Rupees Nineteen Lakhs Fifty
Thousand onlyl uide Bank Guarantee No.6305NDLGOOO06124
dated 2O.O9.2O23 issued by ICICI Bank. It is reiterated that
incorporation of Special Purpose Vehicle and submission o[
Performance Bank Guarantee constituted full and complete
compliance with the prerequisites stipulated by Respondent
No.l for execution of Operation and Management Contract.
Upon such compliance and intimation, Petitioners awaited
execution of the agreement incorporating the proposed
amendments. It
is
alleged that despite repeated
correspondcnces ancl representations addressed by Petitioncrs
seeking performance of obligations under the Request for
Proposal and thc Lettcr of Award, Respondent No.l lailed to
take any steps towards execution of Operation and Management
Contract, thereby committing breach of ils undertaking.
1.6.
[t is contended that Respondent No. 1, having
declarcd Petitioners as successful bidders and having issued
l,etter of Award dared 08.05.2023, failed to adhere to the terms
thereof and failed to perform its obligations even after
Petitioners had complied with all stipulated conditions. Such
actions are assailed as arbitrary, illegal and violative of the
doctrine of iegitirnzrte expcctation. Petitioners assert that they
repeatedlv expressed their willingness and readiness to mobilise
resources and commer-rce operations, particularly after fulfitling
all conditions under the Letter of Award, but Respondent No.1
failed to issuc any communication or take any action. Such
inaction is asserted to be arbitrary and devoid of reason. It is
further contended that the continued inaction of Respondent
No. 1 in adhering to the terms of Request for Proposal and in
performing its obligations, particularly with regard to execution
of the Operation and Management Contract after submission of
the Detailed Business Plan, smacks of mala fi.des on the part oF
the authorities.
1,.7
.
Petitioners assert that it is settled law that a Writ
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution is maintainable to
enforce contractual obligations of the State or its
instrumentalities. Due to the arbitrary action of Respondent
No. 1, Petitioners lost their valuable right to operate and manage
the facitity for the concession period of 30 years. Respondent
No.l, being a State instrumentality under Article 12, has
breached a solemn undertaking by not complying with the
terms of the Irtter of Award and by not coming forward to
execute the Operation and Management Contract, thereby
causing serious prejuclice to Petitioners who had acted upon the
representations and complied with all conditions. The actions of
Respondent No 1 in violating the terms of the l.etter of Award
and in lailing to execute the Operation and Management
Contract, which sets forth the detailed terms and obligations for
operation of the facility, without any communication, are unfair,
unreasonable and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.
1.8.
It is asserted that abandonment of bid process after
awarding contract to the successful bidder is unfounded,
unsupported by law and in excess of statutory authority.
Respondent No.l, being a State under Article 12, is under
constitutional obligation to act farirly even in contractual
matters. Respondent No. l, being a Government undertaking, is
bound to comply with the basic requirements of Article 14 even
in contracts r.r,ith privatc enLities, and that its actions are
subject to standards of reasonableness, fairness and public
interest. It is asserted that due to non-performance of
contractual obligations, particularly after execution of Operation
and Management Contract, handing over of EXIM warehouse,
which is an integral and inseparable part of the Container
Freight Station facility, has also been delayed. It is reiterated
that State entities are not immune from satisfying the tests laid
down under Article 14 of the Constitution and that arbitrary
actions of such entities arc a['*,ays amcnable to judicial review.
2.
Respondcnt No.1 filed a detailed counter opposing
the Writ Petition at the threshold, on the maintainability. It is
specifically contended that Writ Petition seeks to agitate a
purely commercial and private dispute under Article 226 of the
Constitution, which does not arise out of any concluded
contract. It is asserted that the relief sought pertains to
enforcement of alleged contractual obligations and in the
\)
absence of a concluded and executed contract, such disputes
are not amenable to writ jurisdiction. In this regard, reliance is
placed on thc settled principle that Courts must exercise
restraint in interlering in contractual and commercial matters
involving State instrumentalities, unless arbitrariness, mala
fides or perversity is clearly established.
2.1.
[t is contended that issuance of Letter of Award
dated 08.05.2023 does not, by itself, result in a concluded
contract. Contractual obligations arise only upon execution of
Operation and Management Contract, which alone sets out the
detailed rights, duties and obligations of the parties. It is
asserted that Petitioners have misconceived the legal effect of
the Lettcr of Award and mcre acceptance of a bid or issuance of
a Letter of Award cannot fetter the executive or administrative
discretion ol the State to revisit or withdraw from the process in
public intercst, a principle recognised by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Pallaaa Granite Industrtes (India) (P) Ltd. a. tlnion
oJ Indial.
2.2.
lt is stated, Respondent No.l is the absolute owner
of the Container Freight Station at Mamidipally, Ranga Reddy
District, and that in September, 2022, it issued a Request for
' (:ooz) r-s scc ;tr
l0
Proposal for selection of an Operation and Management
Operator lor the said facitity. It is admittcd that Petitioner No. 1,
Readers Storcs lndia Private i-imitcd, submitted its technical bid
on 26.O9.2022, qualified in the technical evaluation, and
thereafter, submitted its hnancial bid, which was opened on
27.O9.2022. Pursuant to negotiations, pe titioners submitted a
revised hnancial bid on 27.O3.2O23 which was placed before the
Board of Respondent No.1 and was accept<:d in the 33'd Board
Meeting held on 25.04.2023. Based on thc approval accorded
by the Board, the General Manager (Asscts & Logistics) issued a
Letter of Award dated 08.05.2023 to petitioner No. 1 declaring it
as the successful bidder. The Letter of Award expressly
incorporated specific conditions governing the proposed
engagement, u,hich were binding and non negotiable unless
approved by the competent authority.
2.3.
It is contendecl that the conditions stipulated in the
Irtter of Award included, inter a1ic, that the lacility sha-lt be
operated only as a Container Fre ight Station and for CPSrelated logistics activities; that an investment of Rs.25 Crores,
as proposed in the Preliminary Business Plan of petitioner No. I
shall be made within five years from t he date of awarding
Operation and Manage ment Contract; audited statements of
I
n
investment shall be submitted every year, failing which the
contract would be Iiable to termination; that exit conditions of
Operation and Management Operator during the contract period
shall be clearly provided for, including forfeiture of investments
in the event o[ voluntary exit; that no other commercial activity
shall be permitted in the premises; and that the CFS property
shall not be mortgaged for raising any loals or advances from
Iinancial institutions or banks.
2.4.
Rcspondent No.1 contends that subsequent to
issuance of Letter of Award dated O8.O5.2023, Readers Stores
lndia Private Limited, by e mail dated 24.05.2O23, rejected the
Letter of Award in its original form, stating that the same was
"not financially viable", and sought amendments to the
conditions imposed thcrcin. According to Respondent No. 1,
such communication clearly indicated that Petitioners were
unwilling to procccd on the terms offered under the Letter of
Award. Petitioners sought amendments by invoking Clause
I . I . 12 ol the Request for Proposal, which permits the selected
bidder, subject to prior u'ritten permission of Respondent No. 1
Corporation and the Customs authorities and compliance with
applicable regulations, to use the facility as an Air Freight
Station, Logistics Facility or Bonded Warehouse. The Board of
I2
\
Respondent No.1 Corporation, in its 34th Board Meeting held on
11.08.2023, accommodated the request o[ Petitioners and
approved amcndmcnt of the usage conditions, thereby
permitting use of the CFS facilily as a Container Freight Station,
Air Freight Station, Logistics Facility and Bonded Warehouse,
demonstrating fairness and flexibitity on the part of the
Respondent Corporation.
2.5.
Despite such accommodation, it is asserted that
Petitioners continued to seek further amendments. By e mail
dated 74.O7.2O23, Petitioners sought moclifications relating to
conditions of usage, hnal invcstmcnt amounts and
commencement of moratorium being made conditional upon
handover of 17,000 square feet of godou,n space. Further, by
letter dated 21.O8.2023, they sought payment of rent at
prevailing market rates for use of godown by Rcspondent No. 1 if
the same was not vacated within six months from signing the
Operation and Management Contract. [t is further contended
that by letter dated 19 .O9 .2023, Petitioners sought -yet another
amendment, requesting that the moralorium should end only
after handover of the trXIM godown lrom the seventh month,
which request was reiterated by e mail dated 24.71.2023.
Respondent No. 1 submits that the Board, in its 36th Board
T
tl
Meeting held on 30.12.2023, considered the aforesaid requests
and accepted certain modifications. However, the Board
consciously did not accept thc request requiring Respondent
No. 1 to
secure alternate godown spacc for storing paper
products within six months of the moratorium period, or to
hand over the EXIM warehouse unconditionally, or to pay
market rent in the event of non,handover.
2.6.
It is contended that under Clause 1.1.9 of the
Request for Proposal, handover of godown space was expressly
made conditionai upon Respondent No.l being able to find an
alternate site for storage of its pape r products division, without
any stipulated timeframe, and that Petitioners were fully aware
of this condition when they participated in the bidding process.
Respondent No.1 further st.rtes that over the preceding three
years, its trade volume had increased more than three-foid,
necessitating continued use ol thc I7,0OO square feet godown
space for storage of its own goods. Rcspondent No.1 had sought
allotment of land from TGI lC for construction of an alternative
godown, but no positive approval had been received, and that
operational constraints compelled Respondent No.l to take
private premises on rent, incurring expenditure of several lakhs
of rupees per month. It is furthcr contended that as per Clause
l-+
2.3.1O of the Request for Proposal, the sclected biddcr n'as
required to incorporate a Special Purpose Vehicle within 3O
days, and thal the Operation anC fulanagement Contract could
be executed only with such Special Purpose Vehicle. According
to Respondent No. I, Readers Stores Inclia Private Limited
neither incorporated nor communicated incorporation of the
Special Purpose Vehicle within the stipulated period.
2.7.
Respondent No.1 also relies on Clause 3.12.8 of the
Request for Proposal, which mandates submission of a
Performance Bank Guarantee equivalent to six months of the
total annual concession fee at the time of signing of the
Operation and Management Contract and renewal of the same
one we ek prior to expiry. Performance Bank Guarantee
furnished by Petitioners expired on 79 .O9.2O24 ancl was not
renewed, even prior to hling of Writ Petition on 29.11.2024,
constituting a clear violation of the tender conditions.
Performance Bank Guarantee is a mandatory prerequisite for
execution of the Operation and Management Contract, and that
mere furnishing or existence of a bank guarantee does not
result in a concluded contract. In this regard, Respondent No. I
stated that Petitioners failed to satisfy essential pre-conditions
under the tender. Despite the aforesaid deficiencies, Petitioners
-t
proceeded to file this Writ Petition. Respondent No. 1 conducted
tender process in a fair and transparent manner,
accommodated Petitioners' requests to the extent permissible,
and that any further modifications sought, which were
unilateral and commercially untenable, werc rightly rejected by
the Board in its 36th meeting.
2.8.
It is further contended that as per Clause 1.1.14,
Operation and Management Contract alone sets forth the
detailed terms and conditions governing the services and
obligations of the contractor, and that issuance of Request for
Proposal or l,etter of Award did not mature into enforceable
contractual obligations. Such limited scope of judicial review in
contractual matters has been reiterated by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Joshi Technologies Intento'tional Inc. u. Union of
India2 and Tata Cellular a. Union of Indloa. Respondent
No. 1 places reliance on Clause 2.7.1 of the Request lor Proposal,
which reserves to it the right to acccpt or reject any bid and to
annul the bidding process and reject all bids at any stage,
without assigning reasons and without incurring any liability. It
is contended that such contractual discretion, when exercised
in public interest, is immune from judicial interfercnce unless
' 1zo rs1 r scc zzt
' ( r994).6sCC 65 r
t6
shown to be arbitrary or mala ftde, as held in Shimnit Utsch
India Private Linlted
a. West Bengal Transport
Infrastructure Deaelopment Corporation Litniteda.
2.9.
It is submitted that the Board of Respondent No I
Corporation, in its 39th meeting held on O3.O9.2O24, after
detailed deliberation, decided to drop the Request for Proposal
and utilise the CFS premises for its crwn requirements,
including the need for additional storage space due to increased
business volumes and establishment of a notebooks conversion
centre approved earlier in the 3l"t Board Meeting held on
28.Og.2022. Despite lapse of Performance Bank Guarantee on
19 .O9 .2024
and delayed incorporation of Special Purpose
Vehicle, Petitioners filed the present Writ
Petition.
Subscquently, pursuant to interim direction dated 1O.12.2024,
the matter u,as placed before the Board again. Respondent No. i
statcs that the Board, in its 4oth meeting held on O7.O1.2O25,
considered the matter and decided to cancel the Request for
Proposal floatecl in 2022, in accordance with the provisions of
the Requcst for Proposal and iaw, on the ground that the entire
CFS premises u,ere required for its own use, including
additional storage requirements, establishment of an lrradiation
' (zo to) o Sec jo3
JI7
/
Plant under a Government of India scheme, establishment of an
E-Commerce Export Hub under the Export Policy of the
Government of India, and othcr activities consistent with the
objectives of lhe Corporation.
2.1O.
It is further stated that the Board resolved that the
decision should be communicated by way of a speaking order,
and accordingly, the decision dated 07 .Ol -2025 was
communicated to Petitioners by letter dated 31.O5.2O25, which
was delivered on 14.06.2025. The decision to cancel the tender
was taken after due deliberation, in public interest, and without
arbitrariness or mola fdes. Judicial interference in such
administrative and contractual decisions is impermissible in
view of the principles laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in Jagdish Mandal u. State o3[ Orisscr and Silppi
Constructions Contrqctors a. Union of India" r.t hich
emphasise judicial restraint and "fair play in the joints" in
contractual matters invoiving State instrumentalities. For all the
aforesaid reasons, Respondcnt No.1 contends that Petitioners
have no enforceable legal right to compel execution of the
Operation and Management Contract.
3.
In the reply affidavit, Petitioners state that
Petitiofitr-?tlo.3 is well acquainted with the facts of the case and
I
\
Iti
is duly authorised to depose on behalf of other Petitioners. They
deny, at the outset, the preliminary objection regarding
mzrintainabilitl, and assert that Writ Petition does not pertain to
a mere private commercial dispute. Petitioners categorically
deny the assertion that e mail dated 24.05.2O23 amounted to
rejection of ktter of Award, Petitioners reiterated almost the
same averments made in the Writ Petition. With regard to the
interim order dated 10.12.2024, it is asserted that Respondent
No.1 acted in utter disregard thereof. Instead of executing the
Operation and Management Contract within the stipulated time,
Respondent No.1 failed to comply, resulting in initiation of
contempt proceedings in C.C. No. 1041 of 2025, which are
pending. Petitioners deny service of the alleged speaking order
dated 31.05.2025 and submit that no such order was served
upon the m in accordance with lau,. Subsequent unilateral
action taken during pendcncy of Writ Petition does not render
the lis infructuous and remain subject to judicial scrutiny.
Petitioners therefore, reiterate that unilateral cancellation of
tender after issuance of Letter of Award is arbitrary, violative of
principles of naturaI justice
I
l{)
4.
Heard Sri N. Naveen Kumar, lcarned counsel for
petitioners and Sri S. Rahul Reddy, learned Special Government
Pleader on behalf of Respondents.
5.
The material facts, which are not in dispute, are
that Respondent No.1 issued a Request for Proposal in
September, 2022 for selection of Operation and Management
Operator for the Container Freight Station at Mamidipally;
Petitioner No.1 participated in the bidding process, the revised
frnancial bid submitted by Petitioner No. 1 on 27.03.2023 was
accepted by the Board of Respondent No.1 in its 33.d meeting
held on 25.04 .2023', and that a [,etter of Award dated
O8.O5.2O23 was issued in favour of Petitioners, containing
specific terms and conditions.
6.
The principal questions that arise for consideration
belore this Court are: (i) whether issuance of Letter of Award
dated O8.O5.2O23, in the facts and circumstances of the present
case, resulted in a concluded and enforceable contract so as to
confer a legal right on Petitioners to seek a mandamus
compelling execution of Operation and Management Contract;
and (ii) whether the subsequent decision of Respondent No. I to
cancel the tender process is vitiated by arbitrariness, mala ftdes
\t
I
:0
(
or violation of Art-icle 14 of the Constitution, warranting
interference under Article 226.
.
A carclul examination of the Request for Proposal
and the Letter of A'a,ard shows that parties clearly contemplated
execution of a formal Operation and Management Contract as a
future event. Clause i.1.14 of the Request for Proposal
expressly provide s that Operation and Management Contract
would set forth the detailed terms
.and
conditions governing the
services and obligations of the contractor for operation of the
facility. lrtter of Au,ard itself did not purport to embody all
contractual terms, but expressly stipulated several conditions
precedent, including incorporation of a Special Purpose Vehicle,
submission and maintenance of
a Performance Bank
Guarantee, and compliance with other requirements, before
execution of Operation and Management Contract.
8.
The structure of the tender documents, read as a
whole, leaves no manner of doubt that Letter of Award was an
intermediate step in the tender process and not the final
contract itself. Letter of Award was intended to signify selection
of the successful bidder, subject to fullilment of stipulated
conditions and execution of the formal Operation and
Maqa!6ment Contract, which alone was to govern the detailed
r.1.
,.,
I
ll
-7
rights and obligations of the parties. In the absence of such
execution, the contractual relationship cannot be said to have
attained finality.
9.
The contemporaneous correspondence placed on
record further reinforces this conclusion. After issuance of
If tter of Award, Petitioners sought amendments to several
conditions, including permitted usage of facility, moratorium
period, investment timelines, and handover of godown and
EXIM warehouse space. These requests were considered by the
Board of Respondent No.1 in its 34th meeting dated 1 1.O8.2O23
and its 36th meeting dated 3O.12.2023, and were partly
acceptcd and partly rejected. The very fact that negotiations
continued on material aspects of the proposed arrangemenl
demonstrates that terms had not attained hnality and that
parties were still in the process of arriving at mutually
acceptable conditions.
10.
The Court is unable to accept the contention of
Petitioners that issuance of Letter of Award, by itself, resulted in
a concluded contract. Acceptance of bid and issuance of Letter
of Alr'ard, when read in the context of the tender conditions,
cannot be equated with execution of a binding contract where
the tender documents themselves contemplate a subsequent
tl
\
J
formal agreement- In such circumstances, the doctrine of
concluded contract cannot be mechanically applied divorced
from the express terms of the Request for Proposal.
11.
Petitione rs placed cmphasis on the doctrine of
'legitimate expectation'. While it is true that issuance of ktter of
Award may give rise to an expectation that the process would
culminate in execution of a contract, such expectation, by itself,
does not crystallise into an cnforceable legal right. 'Legitimate
expectation' cannot override express contractual provisions
reserving discretion to the tendering authori$r, nor can it
compel the State to enter into a contract contrary to its
assessment of public interest. It is also of significance that
Clause 2.7.1 ol the Request for Proposal expressly reserves to
Respondent No. 1 the right to accept or reject any bid and to
annul the bidding process at any stage, without incurring any
liability. Such a clause forms part of the tender conditions to
which Petitioners volun tarily subscribed while participating in
the bidding process. I{aving accepted these conditions,
Petitioners cannot seek to exclude or neutralise the operation of
Clause 2.7.1 after being declared successful bidders.
t2.
The record shows that the Board of Respondent No.
1n
its 39th meeting held on O3.O9.2O24, took a conscious
2i
decision to drop the Request for Proposal and to utilise the CFS
premises for its own requirements, including increased storage
necds arising from enhanccd business volumes and other
proposed projects. Pursuant to the interim directions of this
Court dated 10.12.2024, the matter was reconsidered by the
Board, and in its 40th meeting held on 07.O1.2O25, the Board
reaffirmed its decision to cancel the tender process and resolved
to communicate the same by a speaking order, which was
thereafter issued.
13.
The reasons recorded by the Board for cancellation
of the tender relate to operational exigencies and utilisation of
Respondent No. I's own infrastructure for its institutional
objectives. This Court finds that such reasons cannot be
characterised as extraneous, irrational or perverse. The decision
was taken by the competent authority after deliberation and is
traceable to considerations of public interest and administrative
necessity.
14.
The scope of judicial rcview in matters relating to
contracts and tenders involving State instrumentalities is well
settled. This Court does not sit as an appellate authority over
administrative decisions, nor can it substitute its own view for
that of the tendering authority- Interference under Article 226 is
l-1
'.t
warranted only when the decision-making process is shown to
be vitiated by arbitrariness, mala /ides, bias, irrationality or
violation of statuton' provisions. Mere disagreement with the
decision or assertion of commercial inconvenience does not
justify judicial interve ntion.
15.
[n the present case, Petitioners have not been able
to place any material before this Court to demonstrate that the
decision of Respondent No.1 to cancel the tender process was
actuated by mala fides or was intended to single out Petitioners
lor hostile treatment. The decision applies uniformly to tJle
entire tender process and is not targeted at Petitioners alone.
The contentions relating to incorporation of Special Purpose
Vehicle and furnishing of Performance Bank Guarantee, though
disputed by the parties, do not advance Petitioners' case to the
extent of establishing a concluded contract. Even assuming that
Petitioners complied with certain preconditions, such
compliance cannot override the express requirement of
execution of Operation and Management Contract as the final
step in creation of enforceabie contractual obligations.
16.
The Court is also mindful of the submission
regarding alleged non-compliance with the interim order dated
1O.I2.2O24. The said order directed consideration of Petitioners,
.J/
request in accordance with law. The material on record shows
that the matter was placed before the Board and was
considered, culminating in a reasoned decision. Whether such
decision is agreeable to Petitioners is a different matter;
however, mere dissatisfaction with the outcome does not render
the decision illegal or contemptuous.
17.
Viewed cumulatively, the dispute between the
parties essentially arises out of an unfinalised contractual
process, ongoing negotiations, attd exercise of contractual
discretion reserved under the tender conditions. Such a dispute
falls predominantly within the realm of contractual and
administrative , decision-making and does not raise issues
warranting interference under Article 226 of the Constitution.
This Court, therefore, is of the considered view that Petitioners
failed to establish any enforceable legal right flowing from l€tter
of Award dated O8.O5.2 O23, or any arbitrariness, mala ftdes or
violation of Article 14 in the dccision of Respondent No. 1 to
cancel the tender process. Consequently, no case is made out
for issuance of a writ of mandamus compelling execution of
Operation and Management Contract.
I
2()
-t
{
18.
For all thc aforesaid reasons, this Court holds that
Writ Petition is devcid of merit and does not warrant
interference under Article 226 ol t]ne Constitution.
19.
Accordingly, lhe Writ Petition is dismissed.
However, it is made clcar that this Court has not expressed any
opinion on the merits of any contractual, civil or other remedies
that may be available to Petitioners in accordance with law, and
all such remedies, il any, are left open to be pursued before the
appropriate forum. No costs.
20.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
any shall stand closed.
SD/.C. DEEPIKA
STANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
\
To
1. Two CC's to Advocate General, High Court fo
Hvderabad. (OUT)
z. oire cc to Si?l N.NAVEEN KUMAR, Advocate
3. Two CD CoPies
SA
BS
\y
SECTION OFFICER
State of Telangana at
ucl
HIGH COURT
DATED:0910112026
{ HE c
t)
,t
*
ORDER
WP.No.33804 of 2024
DISMISSING THE W.P
WITHOUT COSTS.
7:
1 f)?fi
\ t fi
r.
-t
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review