Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1.2026:HHC:4311
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
Cr. Revision No.637 of 2025
Date of Decision:25.02.2026
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------M/s Rajat Resorts,The Mall Shimla
.....Petitioner
Versus
[[
M/s Reliable Hospitalities
..…Respondent
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Coram:
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sandeep Sharma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? 1
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------For the Petitioner:
Mr. Shakti Bhardwaj, Advocate.
For the Respondent:
Mr.Jagmohan Singh Chandel, Advocate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Sandeep Sharma, J. (Oral)
Being
aggrieved
and
dissatisfied
with
order dated
07.07.2025 passed by learned Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Court
No.3, Shimla, District Shimla, H.P, whereby the learned Court below
while closing the evidence of the petitioner/complainant has further
proceeded to dismiss the complainant for want of prosecution,
petitioner/complainant has approached this Court in the instant
proceedings filed under Section 442 of the Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023, praying therein to set aside the aforesaid order and
restore the complaint No.280-B of 2020 titled M/s Rajat Resorts vs M/s
Reliable Hospitalities.
2.
Precisely, the grouse of the petitioner as highlighted in the
petition and further canvassed by Sh. Shakti Bhardwaj, learned Counsel
for the petitioner/complainant is
that on account of unavoidable
circumstances, petitioner/complainant was unable to produce his
Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2.2026:HHC:4311
evidence on the given date and in that regard, plausible explanation was
rendered on record but yet learned Court below proceeded to dismiss
the
complaint.
Mr.Shakti
Bhardwaj,
learned
Counsel
for
the
petitioner/complainant submitted that learned Court below taking note of
previous adjournments, if any, taken by the petitioner/complainant, could
have closed the evidence of the petitioner/complainant but in no
circumstance, could have dismissed the complaint, which otherwise was
required to be decided on the basis of other material i.e. pleadings as
well as documentary evidence available on record.
3.
To the contrary, Mr. Jagmohan Singh Chandel, learned
counsel for the respondent/accused, vehemently argued that there is no
illegality in order dated 07.07.2025 because bare perusal of the same
reveals that petitioner had been taking time to lead evidence for last so
many dates. He submitted that since despite sufficient opportunities,
petitioner failed to lead evidence, learned Court below had no option
but to pass impugned order.
Learned Counsel for the respondent
submitted that since petitioner/complainant failed to lead evidence in
support of his complaint, no illegality can be said to have been
committed by the learned Court below while dismissing the complaint,
contents whereof, otherwise only could have been proved by leading
evidence, which petitioner had failed to do.
4.
perused
Though, having heard learned counsel for the parties and
material on record, this Court finds that since
year 2022,
petitioner/complainant had been taking time to produce evidence, but
on one pretext or other, he failed to lead evidence. On 28.11.2024,
3.2026:HHC:4311
learned Court below, while imposing cost of Rs.1500/-granted further
time to produce CWs on 07.07.2025,but unfortunately
even on that
date, no evidence was produced and such learned Court below
proceeded to pass impugned order.
5.
Question which needs to be determined in the case at
hand is that “whether
Court below after closing the evidence of
complainant, could have dismissed the complaint or not.”
6.
Though, this Court is of the view that once learned Court
below had closed the evidence of the petitioner it ought to have decided
the complaint on its merits and certainly it could not have dismissed
complaint.
7.
In terms of Section 143 of the Act, offence under Section
138 of the Act is to be tried summarily and accordingly, procedure for
summons case provided in Chapter XX of the Code of Criminal
Procedure is applicable during the trial initiated on filing a complaint
under Section 138 of the Act. Section 256 of Cr.P.C, specifically deals
with a situation of non-appearance of the complainant or death of the
complainant.
8.
At this stage, it would be apt to take note of Section 256
Cr.P.C, which reads as under:“256. Non-appearance or death of complainant. - (1)
If the summons has been issued on complaint, and on
the day appointed for the appearance of the accused,
or any day subsequent thereto to which the hearing
may be adjourned, the complainant does not appear,
the Magistrate shall, notwithstanding anything
hereinbefore contained, acquit the accused, unless for
some reason he thinks it proper to adjourn the hearing
of the case to some other day:
4.2026:HHC:4311
Provided that where the complainant is represented by
a pleader or by the officer conducting the prosecution or
where the Magistrate is of opinion that the personal
attendance of the complainant is not necessary, the
Magistrate may dispense with his attendance and
proceed with the case.
(2) The provisions of sub-section (1) shall, so far as
may be, apply also to cases where the non-appearance
of the complainant is due to his death.”
9.
Bare reading of aforesaid provision of law provides
discretion to the Magistrate either to acquit the accused or to adjourn the
case for some other day, if he thinks it proper. Proviso to aforesaid
section further empowers the Magistrate to dispense with the
complainant from his personal attendance, if it is found not necessary
and to proceed with the case. If the complainant is represented by a
pleader or by the officer conducting the prosecution, the Magistrate may
proceed with the case in absence of the complainant. When the
Magistrate, in a summons case, dismisses the complaint and acquits the
accused due to absence of the complainant on the date of hearing, it
becomes final and it cannot be restored in view of Section 362 Cr.P.C.
At this stage, it would be profitable to reproduce Section 362 Cr.P.C.,
herein below:362. Court not to alter judgment. -Save as otherwise
provided by this Code or by any other law for the time
being in force, no Court, when it has signed its
judgment or final order disposing of a case, shall alter
or review the same except to correct a clerical or
arithmetical error.”
10.
Having taken note of effect of dismissal of complaint under
Section 138 of the Act, Hon'ble Apex Court in case titled Associated
Cement Co. Ltd. v. Keshvanand, reported in (1998) 1 SCC 687,
5.2026:HHC:4311
elaborately dealt with the scope of Section 256 Cr.P.C, and held that
though, afore Section affords protection to an accused against dilatory
tactics on the part of the complainant, but, at the same time, it does not
mean that if the complainant is absent, the Court can straightway
proceed to acquit the accused in invitum. It has been specifically held in
the afore judgment that power under Section 256 Cr.P.C must be
exercised
judicially
and
fairly
without
impairing
the
cause
of
administration of criminal justice.
11.
Similarly in case titled Mohd. Azeem v. A. Venkatesh,
reported in (2002) 7 SCC 726, Hon'ble Apex Court held that dismissal
of the complaint on account of one singular default in appearance on the
part of the complainant, if permitted would result in failure of justice.
12.
In case titled S.Anand v. Vasumathi Chandrasekar,
reported in (2008) 4 SCC 67, Hon'ble Apex Court
also deprecated
practice of trial Court in dismissing the complaint on account of default
in appearance. In the afore case complaint under Section 138 of the Act
was dismissed by the trial Court exercising the power under Section 256
Cr.P.C on failure of the complainant or her power of attorney or the
lawyer appointed by her to appear in Court on the date of hearing fixed
for examination of witnesses on behalf of the defence. Hon'ble Apex
Court after having considered the provisions of Section 256 Cr.P.C,
observed that Court instead of disposal of a complaint in default, could
have proceeded to decide the matter on merits on the basis of evidence
already adduced on record by the complainant and the statement of
accused recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C.
6.2026:HHC:4311
13.
In yet another case titled N.K. Sharma's case vs. M/S
Accord Plantations Private Limited and another, reported in 2008(2)
Latest HLJ 1249, Co-ordinate Bench of this Court
relying upon
Associated Cement Co. Ltd.'s case (supra), categorically held that
when the Court notices that complainant is absent on a particular day, it
must consider that whether the personal attendance of the complainant
is essential on that day for the progress of the case and also whether the
situation does not justify the case being adjourned to another date due
to any other reason and if the situation does not justify the case being
adjourned, then only Court is free to dismiss the complaint and acquit
the accused, but if the presence of complainant on that day was quite
unnecessary then resorting to the step of axing down the complaint, may
not be a proper exercise of power envisaged under Section 256 Cr.P.C.
14.
Reliance is placed upon the judgment dated 01.03.2023
passed by Hon'ble Apex Court in M/s BLS Infrastructure Limited
versus M/s Rajwanti Singh and others in Criminal Appeal Nos. 657664 of 2023, where in similar facts and circumstances, Hon'ble Apex
Court held that the action of learned Magistrate not justified in straight
away dismissing the complaint(s) and ordering acquittal of the accused
on mere non appearance of the complainant. Relevant paras No.13 and
14 of afore judgment are as under:“13. In the instant case, we notice that there is a
specific averment in the Special Leave Petition(s) that
the appellant had led its evidence in the case and
thereafter had moved an application under Section
311 of the Code to summon and examine further
7.2026:HHC:4311
witnesses. In Paragraph 5(u), it is stated that the trial
court as well as the High Court did not take into
consideration
that
the
complainant’s
cross-
examination had been over in Complaint Case
Nos.621742/16, 621743/16 and 621744/16, and no
cross-examination was sought in other cases. Rather,
CW-1’s
cross-examination
in
the
above
three
complaint cases was adopted. There appears no
specific denial of the aforesaid factual position.
However, we find that neither the High Court nor the
learned Magistrate has taken notice of the aforesaid
position. Both the courts below thus failed to consider
whether in the facts of the case under the proviso to
sub-section (1) of Section 256, the court could
proceed with the matter after dispensing with the
attendance of the
complainant. Further, if the
complainant had not appeared to press the application
under Section 311 of the Code, the learned Magistrate
could have rejected the application under Section 311
of the Code and proceeded with the case on basis of
the available evidence. We are, therefore, of the
considered view that the learned Magistrate was not
justified in straight away dismissing the complaint(s)
and ordering acquittal of the accused on mere
nonappearance of the complainant. The High Court
too failed to take notice of the aforesaid aspects.
Thus, the orders impugned are liable to be set aside.
14.
For the reasons above, the order(s) of the High
Court as well as of the learned Magistrate are setaside. The proceedings shall stand restored to their
original number(s) on the file of the learned Magistrate
and the prosecution shall now proceed from the stage
8.2026:HHC:4311
where it was when the order of acquittal/dismissal of
the complaint(s) was passed.”
15.
Factum of payment, if any, made by the respondent-
accused to the complainant, which has been otherwise seriously
disputed by learned counsel for the petitioner-complainant, cannot be
gone into the instant proceedings, rather same can be ascertained in
the main proceedings filed under Section 138 of the Negotiable
Instruments Act.
16.
Consequently, in view of the detailed discussion made
hereinabove as well as law taken into consideration, the present petition
is allowed, order dated 07.07.2025
is quashed and set aside and
complaint No.280-B of 2020 , titled M/s Rajat Resort vs M/s Reliable
Hospitalities is ordered to be restored, with a direction to learned Court
below to proceed with the trial from the stage, it was dismissed.
17.
Since this Court is convinced
dragging the matter for long,
presence
that petitioner has been
petitioner is directed to cause his
before the Court below
on 16.03.2026 for recording his
statement and thereafter, if prayed for, one date may be given to him for
recording the statements of remaining complainant’ witnesses. In case,
witnesses, if any, are not produced on the date fixed by the Court below
after recording the statement of complainant, Court below shall be at
liberty to pass appropriate orders.
18.
Since, respondent has been unnecessarily dragged into
the present litigation and there is inordinate delay in bringing evidence
on the part of the petitioner/complainant, this Court deems it fit to impose
9.2026:HHC:4311
cost of Rs.5000/-payable to the respondent by the petitioner
on or
before 16.03.2026.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
(Sandeep Sharma)
Judge
February 25, 2026
(meera)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review