Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 27.04.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 12.05.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 12.05.2026
+
W.P.(C) 18715/2025 & CM APPL. 77838/2025
M/S RAIL AUTOCOM TECHNOLOGIES PRIVATE
LIMITED
.....Petitioner
Through: Ms. Aparna Jain, Adv.
versus
UNION OF INDIA, MINSTRY OF
RAILWAYS & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Rohan Jaitley, CGSC &
Mr. Dev Pratap Shahi (GP)
with Mr. Akshay Sharma, Mr.
Varun Pratap Singh & Mr.
Yogya Bhatia, Advs.
Mr. Aman Sharma, Mr. Subhan
Shankar Gogoi, Mr. Akshat
Rathore & Ms. Nidhi Jain,
Advocates for R2
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
1.
The present Petition assails the action of the Respondent No.1
in awarding the bulk quantity under Tender No. 20259002 dated
19.08.2025 [‘Impugned Tender’] for supply, installation and
commissioning of Fog Pilot Assistance Systems [‘FOGPASS’], to
Respondent no. 2 (L1 bidder), to the exclusion of the Petitioner, who
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:11:16
claims to have emerged as the L2 bidder. The Petitioner seeks
quashing of the Impugned Tender, or in the alternative, a direction for
re-tendering or allocation of a portion of the tender quantity in its
favour.
2.
The issue which arises for consideration in the present Petition
is whether a bidder, who claims to be the second lowest (L2) (L8 as
claimed by the official Respondent) in a public procurement process,
and whose quoted price is within a marginal difference of less than
3% from that of the lowest bidder (L1), acquires an enforceable right
to claim allocation of a portion of the tendered quantity on the basis of
a pre-declared “splitting clause” contained in the tender document;
and whether the decision of the procuring authority to award a
predominant portion of the contract to the L1 bidder, without
extending any share to such bidder, is arbitrary or violative of Article
14 of the Constitution of India, so as to warrant interference under
Article 226 of the Constitution.
FACTUAL MATRIX:
3.
In order to appreciate the controversy involved in the present
Petition, the relevant facts, in brief, are required to be noticed.
4.
The Petitioner, a company recognized as a Startup by the
Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade [‘DPIIT’],
as well as a Micro, Small and Medium Enterprise [‘MSME’], is
engaged in the business of manufacturing and supplying signalling
and telecommunication equipment to the Indian Railways.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:11:16
5.
Respondent No.1, through its nodal agency, Patiala Locomotive
Works, issued the Impugned Tender inviting bids for a running
contract for supply, installation and commissioning of FOGPASS,
along with Annual Maintenance Contract (AMC), for a total quantity
of 15,184 units, to be supplied within a stipulated period of 12 months
from the date of issuance of the contract.
6.
The Petitioner participated in the aforesaid tender process.
Upon evaluation of the bids, the Petitioner claims to have been
declared as the second lowest (L2) bidder, its quoted price being
higher by approximately 2.08% than that of Respondent No.2, which
emerged as the lowest (L1) bidder.
7.
The Petitioner’s grievance centres on Clause 2.3.1 of the
Impugned Tender, which provides for splitting of the tendered
quantity amongst eligible bidders depending upon price differential
and other factors, and contemplates a 60:40 distribution between L1
and L2 where the price difference is within 3%.
8.
The tender was finalized and the bulk quantity was awarded to
Respondent No.2. No portion of the tendered quantity was allocated to
the Petitioner.
9.
The Petitioner submitted representations to the Respondents
challenging the allocation; however, no relief was granted. It is not in
dispute that, pursuant to the award, purchase orders have been issued
and execution of the contract has commenced.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:11:16
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES:
10.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner contended that the
Petitioner, being the L2 bidder with a price difference of
approximately 2.08% from the L1 bidder, was entitled to allocation of
40% of the tendered quantity in terms of Clause 2.3.1. It was
submitted that the Respondents have acted arbitrarily in awarding the
entire bulk quantity to Respondent No.2 without adhering to the said
clause. It was further contended that the Petitioner was eligible and
technically capable of executing the contract and ought to have been
considered for allocation. The failure to permit the Petitioner to match
the L1 price is also assailed. Reliance was placed on MSME/start-up
procurement policies to contend that the Petitioner was entitled to fair
consideration. The award of the contract to Respondent No.2 is also
questioned on the ground of alleged deficiencies in its past
performance.
11.
Per contra, learned counsel for the Respondents submitted that
the Petition is not maintainable for want of territorial jurisdiction and
is, in any event, infructuous as the tender process stands concluded
and execution has commenced. It was further contended that
necessary parties have not been impleaded.
12.
On merits, it was submitted that the Petitioner was not the L2
bidder but was ranked significantly lower. The tender distinguishes
between approved and developmental vendors, and the Petitioner,
being a developmental vendor, is not comparable to Respondent No.2.
Even within that category, its quoted rates were substantially higher
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:11:16
than those of other bidders, and therefore it had no entitlement under
Clause 2.3.1. The said clause does not confer any enforceable right
and is subject to various factors including past performance and
capacity. It was contended that the Petitioner’s past performance was
not satisfactory and that the procurement relates to a critical safety
item, justifying award to an approved vendor. Interference at this stage
would disrupt a concluded contract and adversely affect public
interest.
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS :
13.
This Court has considered the submissions advanced on behalf
of the parties and perused the material on record.
Re: Issue (i) Maintainability
14.
The first issue concerns maintainability, including territorial
jurisdiction and alleged infructuousness.
15.
The Respondents object to territorial jurisdiction on the basis of
Clause 2.16 of the Integrated Bid Document, which stipulates that
courts at the place from where the acceptance of tender is issued shall
have jurisdiction. The Letter of Acceptance dated 31.10.2025 and the
consequent contracts were issued and executed at Patiala.
16.
It is settled that jurisdiction cannot be conferred by agreement;
however, where the cause of action substantially arises at a particular
place, such clause assumes relevance. In the present case, the tender
process was undertaken and concluded at Patiala.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:11:16
17.
In these circumstances, a serious objection as to territorial
jurisdiction arises. However, in view of the conclusion on merits, this
Court does not consider it necessary to render a final finding on this
issue.
18.
As regards infructuousness, the tender stands concluded and
execution has commenced. Courts ordinarily refrain from interfering
in concluded contracts. This aspect, however, is considered along with
the merits.
Re: Issue (ii) L2 Status
19.
The Petitioner’s case rests on the assertion that it was the L2
bidder with a price difference of approximately 2.08% from L1.
20.
The record, however, does not support this assertion. The tender
distinguishes between approved and developmental vendors, which
are not comparable categories. It is not disputed that Respondent No.2
is an approved vendor, whereas the Petitioner was a developmental
vendor at the relevant time.
21.
Further, within the category of developmental vendors, the
Petitioner was not the second lowest bidder and was ranked
significantly lower, with higher quoted rates than other bidders,
including M/s Beacon Industries.
22.
The premise that the Petitioner was L2 is therefore factually
incorrect. The invocation of Clause 2.3.1 on this basis is
misconceived.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:11:16
Re: Issue (iii) Enforceable Right
23.
Even otherwise, Clause 2.3.1 does not confer any enforceable
right to claim allocation of a fixed proportion of the tendered quantity.
The relevant clause reads as under:
“2.3 Splitting of tendered quantity:
2.3.1 Tenders with Pre-decided splitting clause specifically mentioned
in SOR (Schedule of Requirements) of tender.
(a) The Purchaser reserves the right to distribute the procurable
quantity on one or more than one of the eligible bidders. Zone of
consideration of such eligible bidders will be the right of the
Purchaser. The zone of consideration will be a dynamic mix of : Inter
se position of firms, Supply performance of the firms, Quantity being
procured, Criticality of item, Lead time for supply of the item, Number
of established suppliers & their capacity etc.
(b) Whenever such splitting of the procurable quantity is made, the
quantity distribution will depend (in an inverse manner) upon the
differential of rates quoted by the bidders (other aspects i.e. Adequate
capacity-cum-capability, Satisfactory past performance of the bidders,
Outstanding order load for the Railway making the procurement,
Quoted delivery schedule vis-à-vis the delivery schedule incorporated
in the tender enquiry etc. being same/similar) in the manner detailed
in the table below:
Price differential between Quantity distribution ratio
L-1 and L-2
between L-1 and L-2
Upto 3%
60:40
More than 3 % and upto 5 65:35
%
More than 5%
At least 65% on the L-1
bidder
It should be noted that L-1 will be the bidder who is technically
suitable for bulk quantity regular order.
(c) In the phrase ‘differential of rates quoted by the bidders’, the
quoted rate would mean:
i.
When no price negotiation has been called for, the original rates
as obtained at the time of tender opening. However, the rate of
the highest eligible bidder within the zone of consideration has
to be per-se reasonable.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:11:16
ii.
When price negotiation has been called for, the reference L-1
rate for assessment of ratio will be the original rate of L-1
bidder (suitable for bulk quantity) as obtained at the time of
tender opening.
(d) If splitting of quantity is required to be done by ordering on
bidders higher than the L- 2 bidder, then the quantity distribution
proportion amongst the bidders will be decided by
transparent/logical/equity based extrapolation of the model as
indicated in the subclause 2.3.1(b)above.
(e) In the cases of inadequate capacity-cum-capability, dissatisfactory
past performance, large quantity of outstanding orders (liquidation of
which will take very long time) etc., the purchaser shall have the right
to distribute the procurable quantity amongst bidders with due
consideration to these constraints and in such a manner that would
ensure timely supply of material in requisite quantity to meet the
needs of operation, maintenance, safety etc. of the Railways,
regardless of inter-se ranking of the bidders and in a fair &
transparent manner with due conformity to the principles of Natural
Justice and Equity.
(f) For cases where the Railways./Production units had entered into
TOT/JV (Transfer of technology/Joint Venture) agreements, the
following clause will be applicable:
“As PLW has entered into TOT/JV agreement with
............................................... No. of firms, they reserve the right to
place orders on all such TOT/JV agreements partners. However, for
ratio/proportion of quantity distribution among such agreement
partners, conditions as detailed in sub-clauses 2.3.1: (b), (c) and (d)
above: shall apply with the exception that the aspect of per-se
reasonability will not be applicable.”
(g) Notwithstanding the above, there can be exceptional situations
where Purchaser may come to a conclusion that splitting is neither
possible nor feasible and/or not desirable in the administrative
interest. In such exceptional situations, Purchaser reserves the right
not to split the quantity despite pre-decided splitting clause in the
tender condition.
24.
A plain reading of the clause shows that splitting of quantity is
not mandatory and is subject to multiple factors, including capacity,
past performance and delivery capability. The indicated 60:40 ratio is
only illustrative and conditional.
25.
The clause also presupposes comparison between similarly
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:11:16
situated bidders. The Petitioner and Respondent No.2, belonging to
different vendor categories, are not comparable. No enforceable right,
therefore, accrues to the Petitioner.
Re: Issue (iv) Judicial Review
26.
The scope of judicial review in contractual matters is limited to
examining arbitrariness, mala fides or perversity in the decisionmaking process. The Court does not sit in appeal over commercial
decisions.
27.
In the present case, no such infirmity is demonstrated. The
decision reflects consideration of relevant factors, including vendor
categorization, past performance and price.
28.
The contention regarding a right to match the L1 price is
without basis. Similarly, reliance on MSME/start-up policies is
misplaced, as such policies operate subject to the terms of the tender.
Re: Delay and Public Interest
29.
It is significant to note that the tender process has already been
concluded, contracts have been signed, and supplies have commenced,
resulting in third-party rights.
30.
Interference at this stage would unsettle a concluded contract
and adversely affect public interest, particularly as the procurement
concerns safety equipment.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:11:16
CONCLUSION:
31.
In view of the above, this Court is of the considered opinion
that the present Petition is devoid of merit.
32.
Accordingly, the present Petition is dismissed. The pending
application also stands closed.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
MAY 12, 2026
jai/pal
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
15:11:16
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review