Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of decision: 21.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010615972025
+
CUSAA 120/2025 & CM APPL. 53151/2025
M/S R. K. LOGISTICS
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Ravi Shekhar Jha, Mr. Raj Datt,
Mr. Chandan& Mr. Mohit Kumar,
Advs.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS
Through:
.....Respondent
Ms. Monica Benjamin, SSC with Ms.
Laiba Arif & Ms. Prerika Narang,
Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AVNEESH JHINGAN
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SHAIL JAIN
AVNEESH JHINGAN, J.(ORAL)
1.
This appeal is filed under Section 130 of the Customs Act, 1962 (for
short ‘the Act’) against the final order no. 59920/2024 dated 23.12.2024
passed by the Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (for brevity
‘the tribunal’) in customs appeal no. 51092/2020.
2.
The brief facts are that the appellant is a proprietorship concern. On
13.11.2014, the proprietor applied for Customs Broker licence (hereinafter
‘the licence’) under the Customs Brokers Licensing Regulations, 2013 (for
brevity ‘2013 Regulations’). The application form was annexed as Annexure
P-5 to the appeal before the tribunal, qualifications mentioned in form are the
Signed By:CHANCHAL
13:04:20
CUSAA 120/2025
MBA degree from Sikkim Manipal University (for short ‘SMU’) and the
graduation degree from Chaudhary Charan Singh University, Meerut (for
short ‘CCSU’). While applying for licence graduation degree was not
enclosed with the application, instead a notarized affidavit was filed stating
that the appellant was a graduate from CCSU. The appellant cleared the
written and oral examination and was granted the licence on 02.11.2016. A
complaint was received on 08.08.2019 in the office of the Commissioner of
Customs, ACC (Import) alleging irregularities in the BA degree of the
appellant from CCSU. On 09.08.2019, the appellant was directed to furnish
an attested copy of the graduation certificate and it was forwarded to CCSU
for verification. On 05.10.2019, a verification report was submitted by CCSU
stating that the details of BA degree and marksheet of the appellant were not
as per the university enrolment and confidential records and that “it seems
otherwise”.
2.1
On 11.10.2019, the licence of the appellant was suspended. Pursuant to
the show cause notice (for short ‘SCN’) issued, the appellant availed the
opportunity for personal hearing and in the representation filed requested for
re-verification of the degree. The suspension was confirmed on 25.10.2019.
The BA degree and marksheet were sent by the respondent to CCSU for reverification. The Vigilance Officer of CCSU in response to the second
verification reiterated the earlier verification report dated 05.10.2019. The
respondent issued SCN dated 27.12.2019 proposing revocation of the licence,
forfeiture of security and levy of penalty. The Assistant Commissioner of the
department was appointed as the Inquiry Officer (for short ‘IO’). The
appellant responded to the SCN on 21.01.2020, personally appeared before
Signed By:CHANCHAL
13:04:20
CUSAA 120/2025
the IO and sought time to produce a duplicate copy of the degree from CCSU.
The written submissions dated 22.02.2020 were filed before the IO. The
report by IO was submitted on 27.03.2020. It was observed that despite being
given an opportunity the appellant failed to prove the genuineness of the
graduate degree and there was infringement of regulations 5(h)(i) & (ii) of the
2018 Regulations.
2.2
The respondent issued notices dated 12.05.2020 and 06.06.2020, the
appellant attended the personal hearing on 17.06.2020 and filed written
submissions rebutting the inquiry report.
2.3
On 01.07.2020, an order under regulations 14 and 17(7) of the 2018
Regulations was passed revoking the licence and forfeiting the security. A
penalty of Rs.50,000/- was also imposed under regulation 18(1) of the 2018
Regulations. The tribunal dismissed the appeal on 23.12.2024 and upheld the
order dated 01.07.2020. Hence, the present appeal.
3.
The following substantial questions of law have been proposed by the
appellant:
“I. Whether the Hon’ble Tribunal failed to appreciate that the
Customs Broker Licensing Regulations, 2013/2018 contain
no provision authorising re-verification of academic
qualifications after grant of licence, and that the
Respondent’s reliance on post-licence “reverification” is
without jurisdiction and contrary to the scheme of the
Regulations?
II. Whether the Hon’ble Tribunal erred in law by upholding
the revocation of the appellant’s Customs Broker Licence
despite the undisputed fact that the Respondent had, at the
time of grant of licence in 2016, already verified and satisfied
itself regarding the appellant’s academic qualifications as
mandated under Regulation5 of the Customs Broker
Signed By:CHANCHAL
13:04:20
CUSAA 120/2025
Licensing Regulations, 2013?
III. Whether the Respondent could invoke the provisions of
the CBLR, 2013/2018 against the Appellant for alleged
discrepancies at the stage when he was merely an applicant
and not yet a Customs Broker, despite the fact that the
Respondent themselves had verified and accepted his
qualifications before issuing the licence?
IV. Whether the Hon’ble Tribunal failed to appreciate that
once the statutory authority had conclusively verified and
accepted the appellant’s eligibility and academic
qualifications before granting the Customs Broker Licence, it
was impermissible in law to re-open or re-verify the same at
a subsequent stage on the basis of an anonymous and
unverified complaint?
V. Whether the reliance placed by the Respondent and upheld
by the Tribunal on an ambiguous, incomplete and
inconclusive report of CCS University dated 05.10.2019,
which neither declared the appellant’s degree fake nor
fabricated, amounts to a perverse finding unsupported by
cogent evidence in the eyes of law?
VI. Whether the Hon’ble Tribunal erred in law in not
considering that the appellant’s Graduation Degree had
already been independently verified and accepted by multiple
reputed institutions, including Sikkim Manipal University
(for MBA), IMT Ghaziabad (for PG Diploma), and NMIMS
(for HR Diploma), thereby conclusively establishing the
validity of the said qualification?
VII. Whether the Hon’ble Tribunal committed an error of law
in not appreciating that the proceedings initiated on the basis
of an anonymous e-mail complaint, which was neither
diarised, nor authenticated, nor traceable to any complainant,
are wholly vitiated and non est in the eyes of law?
VIII. Whether the Respondent, in exercise of powers under
Regulation18 of the Customs Broker Licensing Regulations,
2013/2018, can legally impose penalty more than once where
the maximum penalty prescribed under the Regulations is
Signed By:CHANCHAL
13:04:20
CUSAA 120/2025
₹50,000/-, and whether they can pass repeated order of
forfeiture of the security deposit when the statutory
framework permits forfeiture of security only up to a
maximum of ₹5,00,000/-?
IX. Whether Section 132 of the Customs Act, 1962, which is
confined to false declarations and documents in respect of
import/export shipments and clearance of goods, can be
legally invoked in proceedings relating to verification of
educational qualifications submitted by an applicant for grant
of Customs Broker Licence, when no shipment, goods, or
customs clearance process is involved?
X. Whether the Hon’ble Tribunal erred in law in upholding
the imposition of penalty and forfeiture of security deposit
under Regulation 18 of CBLR, 2018, despite there being no
finding of fraud, suppression, or deliberate misrepresentation
on the part of the appellant?
XI. Whether the impugned order of revocation, forfeiture and
penalty are liable to be set aside as being arbitrary,
disproportionate, and violative of the principles of natural
justice under Articles 14 and19(1)(g) of the Constitution of
India?
XII. Whether the impugned order is sustainable in absence of
proper cross-examination of university authorities or any
opportunity to rebut the adverse material?
XIII. Whether principles of natural justice were violated in
the inquiry and revocation proceedings?
XIV. Whether the Tribunal could have applied 2018
Regulations retrospectively when the application and grant of
license were governed by the 2013 Regulations?”
4.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the appellant in 2010
was granted a BBA degree from Chhatrapati Shahu Ji Maharaj University,
Kanpur (for short ‘CSJMU’) and this was not considered by the tribunal and
the respondent. The contention is that the appellant was not granted an
Signed By:CHANCHAL
13:04:20
CUSAA 120/2025
opportunity to cross-examine the officials of CCSU. The grievance is that the
penalty could not have been invoked after revocation of the licence.
5.
Learned counsel for the respondent defends the impugned order and
contends that the appellant by submitting a forged affidavit with regard to his
graduation obtained the licence in violation of Regulation 5(h) of the 2018
Regulations.
5.1
The submission is that under regulation 5(h) of the 2018 Regulations,
the appellant should be a graduate from a recognised University and has to
possess the qualification specified in clause 5(h)(ii). The levy of penalty is
defended to be in accordance with regulation 18 of the 2018 Regulations and
was independent of the revocation of the licence.
6.
Heard learned counsel for the parties at length and perused the record
with their able assistance.
7.
Before proceeding further, it would be apposite to quote the relevant
portions of regulations 5, 14, 17 and 18 of the 2018 Regulations:
“5. Conditions to be fulfilled by the applicants
(1)…..
(h) an individual applicant or in case the applicant is a firm,
its partner or in the case of a company, its director or an
authorised employee who may handle the Customs work
shall(i) be a graduate from a recognized University; and
(ii) possess a professional degree such as Masters or
equivalent degree in Accounting, Finance or Management,
CA/CS/MBA/LLM/ACMA/FCMA or Diploma in Customs
Clearance work from any Institutes or University recognised
by the Government or is having at least two years’ experience
in transacting Customs Broker work as G-Card holder.
Signed By:CHANCHAL
13:04:20
CUSAA 120/2025
14. Revocation of licence or imposition of penalty
The Principal Commissioner or Commissioner of Customs
may, subject to the provisions of regulation 17, revoke the
license of a Customs Broker and order for forfeiture of part
or whole of security, on any of the following, namely:(a) failure to comply with any of the conditions of the bond
executed by him under regulation 8;
(b) failure to comply with any of the provisions of these
regulations, within his jurisdiction or anywhere else;
(c) commits any misconduct, whether within his jurisdiction
or anywhere else which in the opinion of the Principal
Commissioner or Commissioner of Customs renders him
unfit to transact any business in the Customs Station;
(d) adjudicated as an insolvent;
(e) of unsound mind; and
(f) convicted by a competent court for an offence involving
moral turpitude or otherwise.
17. Procedure for revoking licence or imposing penalty
(1) The Principal Commissioner or Commissioner of
Customs shall issue a notice in writing to the Customs Broker
within a period of ninety days from the date of receipt of an
offence report, stating the grounds on which it is proposed to
revoke the license or impose penalty requiring the said
Customs Broker to submit within thirty days to the Deputy
Commissioner of Customs or Assistant Commissioner of
Customs nominated by him, a written statement of defense
and also to specify in the said statement whether the Customs
Broker desires to be heard in person by the said Deputy
Commissioner of Customs or Assistant Commissioner of
Customs.
(2) The Commissioner of Customs may, on receipt of the
written statement from the Customs Broker, or where no such
statement has been received within the time-limit specified in
the notice referred to in sub-regulation (1), direct the Deputy
Commissioner of Customs or Assistant Commissioner of
Signed By:CHANCHAL
13:04:20
CUSAA 120/2025
Customs, as the case may be, to inquire into the grounds
which are not admitted by the Customs Broker.
(3) The Deputy Commissioner of Customs or Assistant
Commissioner of Customs, as the case may be, shall, in the
course of inquiry, consider such documentary evidence and
take such oral evidence as may be relevant or material to the
inquiry in regard to the grounds forming the basis of the
proceedings, and he may also put any question to any person
tendering evidence for or against the Customs Broker, for the
purpose of ascertaining the correct position.
(4) The Customs Broker shall be entitled to cross-examine
the persons examined in support of the grounds forming the
basis of the proceedings, and where the Deputy
Commissioner of Customs or Assistant Commissioner of
Customs declines permission to examine any person on the
grounds that his evidence is not relevant or material, he shall
record his reasons in writing for so doing.
(5) At the conclusion of the inquiry, the Deputy
Commissioner of Customs or Assistant Commissioner of
Customs, as the case may be, shall prepare a report of the
inquiry and after recording his findings thereon submit the
report within a period of ninety days from the date of issue of
a notice under sub-regulation (1).
(6) The Principal Commissioner or Commissioner of
Customs shall furnish to the Customs Broker a copy of the
report of the Deputy Commissioner of Customs or Assistant
Commissioner of Customs, as the case may be, and shall
require the Customs Broker to submit, within the specified
period not being less than thirty days, any representation that
he may wish to make against the said report.
(7) The Principal Commissioner or Commissioner of
Customs shall, after considering the report of the inquiry and
the representation thereon, if any, made by the Customs
Broker, pass such orders as he deems fit either revoking the
suspension of the license or revoking the license of the
Customs Broker within ninety days from the date of
submission of the report by the Deputy Commissioner of
Signed By:CHANCHAL
13:04:20
CUSAA 120/2025
Customs or Assistant Commissioner of Customs, under subregulation (5):
PROVIDED that no order for revoking the license shall be
passed unless an opportunity is given to the Customs Broker
to be heard in person by the Principal Commissioner of
Customs or Commissioner of Customs, as the case may be.
18. Penalty
(1) The Principal Commissioner or Commissioner of
Customs may impose penalty not exceeding fifty thousand
rupees on a Customs Broker or F-card holder who
contravenes any provisions of these regulations or who fails
to comply with any provision of these regulations.
***
(3) The imposition of penalty or any action taken under these
regulations shall be without prejudice to the action that may
be taken against the Customs Broker or F-card holder or Gcard holder under the provisions of the Customs Act, 1962
(52 of 1962) or any other law for the time being in force.”
8.
It is an admitted fact that the appellant while applying for the licence
had not attached the graduation degree but filed an affidavit to the effect that
he was a graduate from CCSU. The MBA degree from SMU was annexed
with the application. After receipt of the complaint the graduation degree was
sent for verification and on the request of the appellant was again sent for reverification. The verification report of the University stated that the details of
the BA degree and the marksheet were not as per the University enrolment
and confidential records and that “it seems otherwise”.
9.
Under regulation 5(h) of the 2018 Regulations, the appellant to be
eligible to apply for the licence had to possess a graduation degree from a
recognized university and also a professional degree as specified in clause
5(h)(ii). The graduation degree was furnished pursuant to the direction of the
Signed By:CHANCHAL
13:04:20
CUSAA 120/2025
respondent and on verification was found not to be issued by CCSU. The order
dated 01.07.2020 and the order of the tribunal record a concurrent factual
finding that the graduation degree furnished by the appellant was forged. The
contention regarding the BBA degree granted in 2010 from CSJMU was not
raised before the IO, in the revocation proceedings or before the tribunal. The
appeal before this court is on substantial questions of law and questions of
fact cannot be gone into.
10.
The opportunity to cross-examine the officials of CCSU was neither
raised before the IO nor in the revocation proceedings before the
Commissioner of Customs (Airport & General), New Delhi and was not
pressed before the tribunal as is evident from the impugned order. It is not the
pleaded case in the appeal that this issue was pressed before the tribunal but
was not dealt with. Be that as it may, cross-examination is not an unfettered
and absolute right. Reference in this regard be made to the following
judgments:
10.1 The Supreme Court in Kanungo and Co. v. Collector of Customs,
(1973) 2 SCC 438 held as under:
“12. We may first deal with the question of breach of natural
justice. On the material on record, in our opinion, there has
been no such breach. In the show-cause notice issued on
August 21, 1961, all the material on which the Customs
Authorities have relied was set out and it was then for the
appellant to give a suitable explanation. The complaint of the
appellant now is that all the persons from whom enquiries
were alleged to have been made by the authorities should
have been produced to enable it to cross-examine them. In
our opinion, the principles of natural justice do not require
that in matters like this the persons who have given
information should be examined in the presence of the
Signed By:CHANCHAL
13:04:20
CUSAA 120/2025
appellant or should be allowed to be cross-examined by them
on the statements made before the Customs Authorities......”
10.2 The Division Bench of this court in Vallabh Textiles v.
Additional Commissioner Central Tax GST, Delhi East & Ors.,
2025 SCC OnLine Del 2435 held as under:
“15. While cross-examination can be granted in certain
proceedings, if it is deemed appropriate, the right to crossexamine cannot be an unfettered right. This has been so held
recently by this court in Sushil Aggarwal v. Principal
Commissioner of Customs.2 The relevant portion of the
decision reads as under (page 262 in 151 GSTR):
“15. Accordingly, this court is of the opinion that
in order to ensure that there is compliance of
section 138(B) of the Act, though the same cannot
be claimed as an unfettered right in all cases, in the
facts of the present case, both Mr. Sushil Aggarwal
and Mr. Aidasani are afforded an opportunity to
cross-examine Mr. Bhalla… .”
(emphasis supplied)
11.
Regulation 14 of the 2018 Regulations empowers the Principal
Commissioner or Commissioner of Customs to revoke the licence and forfeit
part or whole of the security for failure to comply with the provisions of the
Regulations. In the present case, the finding of non-compliance with the
educational requirements under regulation 5(h)(i) and (ii) has been upheld.
The forfeiture of the security of Rs.5,00,000/- was within the scope of
regulation 14 and was rightly upheld by the tribunal.
12.
The contention that the penalty could not have been invoked after
revocation of the licence lacks merit. Regulation 18 of the 2018 Regulations
provides for imposition of penalty not exceeding Rs.50,000/- on a Customs
Signed By:CHANCHAL
13:04:20
CUSAA 120/2025
Broker having contravened the provision of the regulations or failed to
comply with the provision thereof. Regulation 18(3) of the 2018 Regulations
stipulates that the imposition of penalty or any action taken under the
regulation 18 shall be without prejudice to the action that may be taken against
the Customs Broker under the provisions of the Act or any other law for the
time being in force. The imposition of penalty under regulation 18 is not
contingent upon revocation of the licence. The tribunal rightly upheld the
imposition of penalty.
13.
No substantial question of law is involved in the appeal. The appeal is
dismissed and the order dated 23.12.2024 of the tribunal whereby the order
dated 01.07.2020 was confirmed is upheld.
14.
Pending application stands disposed of.
AVNEESH JHINGAN, J
SHAIL JAIN, J
SEPTEMBER 21, 2026
‘ha’
Reportable: Yes
Signed By:CHANCHAL
13:04:20
CUSAA 120/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review