Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
t 3s00l
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO: 33531 OF 2024
Between:
M/s. Prathima lnfrastructure Limited, Represented bvi ts Managing Director
Smt. B. USHA Rani w/o Srinivas Rao, #213, Road No.1 , Film Nagar, Jubilee
Hills, Hyderabad
...PETITIONER
AND
Northern Power Distribution Company of Tela ngana Ltd, Rep. by its Chairman
and [\ilanaging Director, Corporate office, Nakkalagutta, Hanamakonda,
Warangal
2. The Superintending Engineer Operations, Northern Power Distribution
Company of Telangana Ltd, Operation Circle, Bhadradri Kothgudem.
3. The Divisional Engineer (Operations)(TSNPDCL), Northern Power Distribution
Company of Telangana Ltd, Operation Circle, Kothgudem.
4. The Assistant Divisional engineer, (Operations) (TSNPDCL) Sub Division
Paloncha, B. Kothgudem District.
5. The Assistant Divisional Engineer, (Operations) (TSNPDCL) Mulakalapally
Section, B.Kothgudem District.
6. The Senior Accounts Officer/CO/ TSNPDCL, Kothgudem, B.Kothgudem
District
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a writ or order or direction, more in, the nature of writ of
Mandamus declaring the
Lr.No.SE/OP/BKGM/SAO/AO/JAO(HT)F.No
BKM130/DNo.649124 dated 0011112024 and demanding payment of back bill
arrears as issued by 6th respondent in bill HT SC NO. BKM 130 M/S Pratibha
lnfrastructure ltd. CAT 7 Vol 33 CMD 750 as null and void, illegal arbitrary and
violative of interim order in WP 17083 of 2019 dated 2O10812019 and against the
terms of agreement dated 30/04/2018 and consequently set r ;ide the above said
order of 2nd and 6th respondents with a direct to the 2 respo rdent dismantle the
33KV substation in respect of above mentioned service conne :tion'
lA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the Ci cumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High courl may be pleased to
direct the respondents herein to dismantle 33KV substati,r I in respect of the
petitioners HT SC NO.BKfV 130 located at Sita Rama I i t irrigation proiect,
package 5 at oddu Ramavaram Village in the operation sect ln Mulakalapally of
the operation division kothegudem or in the alternative direcl he respondents not
to collect any minimum charges from the petitioner compz I y in respect of the
above service connection till disposal of this writ petition'
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Between:
1. Northern Power Distribution company of Telangana Ltd tep. by its chairman
and Managing Director, Corporate office, Nakkala(lr tta, HanamaKonda'
Warangal
2. The superintending Engineer Operations, _Northerr. Power Distribution
Company of Telangina Ltd, Operatibn Circle, Bhadradri Lothgudem'
3. The Divisionat Engineer (operations)(TSNPDCL), North: n Power Distribution
Company of Telangana Ltd, Operation Circle' Kothgude r '
4. The Assistant Divisional engineer, (Operations) (TStl ']DCL) Sub Division
Paloncha, B. Kothgudem District.
5. The Assistant Divisional Engineer, (operations) (TSl.\ll 'DCL) Mulakalapally
Section, B.Kothgudem District.
6. The Senior Accounts Officer/CO/ TSNPDCL' Kothrlr dsrn, B Kothgudem
District
...PETITIONERS
AND
M/s. Prathima lnfrastructure Limited, Represented by i s Managing Director
Smt. B. USHA Rani w/o Srinivas Rao, #213, Road No.1 Film Nagar, Jubilee
Hills, Hyderabad
...RESPONDENT
Petition under Section '1 51 CPC praying that in the c rcumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Cor- r may be pleased to
vacate the interim orders passed in l.A. No. 1 of 2024 in W.p. No. 33531 of 2024
dated 05.12.2024 and dismiss the writ petition as devoid of merits.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI K.MANIK PRABHU
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI A.CHANDRA SHAKER, SC FOR NPDCL
The Court made the following: ORDER
/
---
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THl' STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAI AKA
WRIT PETITION No. 33531 OF 2024
o9.o1.2026
Between:
M/s Prathima Infrastructure Limited,
Rep. by its Managing Director,
Smt. B. Usha Rani
Petitioner
And
Northern Power Distribution Company of
Telangana Ltd.,
Rep. by its Chairman and Managing Director,
Warangal & others
k:spondents
ORDER:
Petitioner is stated to be a company r, jch entered
L
into al agreement dated 3O.O4.2O 18 with thr respondent
distribution licensee for supply of electricit5r r r-rder HT-II
category, bearing HT Service Connection No. BKI\[ l30, with a
contracted maximum demand of 750 KVA at Odcirr Ramavaram
Village, Mulakalapally Mandal, Bhadradri Kothagu r em District.
The said supply was granted for establishing anrl operating a
site ofhce and factory at the said location. Fronr the date of
release of service connection, petitioner has l;,r n regularly
paying all monthly power consumption bills without any default.
1.
1.
While so, responde nts, without observing the
principles of natural justice, unilaterally changed the category of
petitioner's service conncction lrom HT-II to HT-VII and
retrospectively assessed consumption charges from the very
date of release of supply, i.e.30.O4.2018. By proceedings dated
25.06.2019 of th€ 4th respondent and consequential power
consumption bill dated 26.07.2019 issued by the 6th
respondent, back billing demand of Rs.34,61,400/- was raised
against petitioner. Aggrieved thereby, they filed Writ Petition No.
17803 of 2019 and this Court by order dated 20.O8.2019,
granted interim suspension of operation of the impugned back
billing demand, subject to petitioner depositing one-third of the
demanded amount within the stipulated time. Petitioner strictly
complied with the said interim order and deposited
Rs.1,5,a7,772/- in trx,o instalments on 11.09.2O19, representing
one-third of the demanded amount. The said interim order
continues to be in force and Writ Petition is still pending
adjudication.
1.2.
It is further contended that subsequently, by letter
dated O 1 .O7.2O2O, respondents themselves revised the earlier
back billing assessment of Rs.34,61,4O0/ -and enhanced the
same to Rs.47,63,316/-, stating that the earlier calculation was
J
incorrect. Even in respect of the revised dema;r l, petitioner
complied with the interim directions of this Court r id paid one-
third of the revised amount, aggregating to Rs.15 . \7 ,772 /-, by
making payments of Rs. 1 I,53,800/- and Rs.4,3li )721 -; thus,
it is asserted that petitioner has scrupulously e r hered to all
interim directions of this Court. Except for the <l sputed back
billing amounts, which are the subject matter ol vVrit Petition
No.178O3 of 2019, petitioner has paid all the re,{ rtar monthly
consumption charges raised by respondents vithout any
arrears
1.3
Petitioner further contends that aj the project
activities were nearing completion and the contra( t rd maximum
demand of 750 KVA was no longer required, it addressed
representation dated 1I.06.2022 to the 2"d respcr ttent seeking
deration or reduction of contracted maximum denr Lr-rcl from 75O
KVA to 300 KVA in respect of HT Service ConnecL cn No. BKM-
130. They were not utilising even 50%o of t r: sanctioned
demand, as most of the project work had .lready been
completed. Despite repeated representations , rldressed to
Respondents 2 and 3, no favourable action was 'i ken; instead,
by ietter dated 27.O8.2O2O, th,e 2"d responder. rejected the
request for deration solely on the ground of pend,r l(ly of arrears
\.
arising out of the disputed back billing, and directed petitioner
to clear the said arrears. Petitioner asserts that it was compelled
to pay excessive monthly charges of about Rs.2,25,OOO/towards the unused surplus load o[ 450 KVA, even though the
actual utilisalion never exceeded 300 KVA. According to
petitioner, denial of deration was not based on any valid or legal
reason, but was a punitive measure adopted by respondents
solely because they approached this Court and obtained interim
protection against illegal back billing.
7.4.
It is further pleaded that all construction and allied
activities at the site were completed by March, 2O2l and that
regular 22O / ll KV pou'er supply to the pump house was
charged by the end of June, 2024. In these circumstances,
petitioner addressed letter dated 29.06.2024 to the 2"d
respondent seeking cancellation of HT service connection artd
dismantling of HT SC No. BKM-130 at Sita Rama Lift Irrigation
Project, Package-S, Oddu Ramavaram Village, as the service was
no longer required. When there was no response, another letter
dated 27.08.2024 was addressed, reiterating the request for
disconnection and dismantling and expressly undertaking to
bear the expenditure involved in dismantling the service
connection.
1.5.
It is stated, despite these repr: ted requests,
respondents did not take steps to disman. I . the seruice
I
i'
;
i
I
I
connection. The service was admittedly rli; ,rnn66.166 on
3O.O8.2O24; however, 33 KV sub_station constru :
belonging to farmers continued to
cd in the land
remz j r
in
Consequently, petitioner addressed yet anoth,: letter
place.
dated
26.1O.2024 to the 2nd respondent. In responr;, thereto,
impugned proceedings dated 06. I I .2024, along i,ith
the
back bill
statement dated 01.O9.2024 was issued. Thotr;,l respondents
admitted in the impugned proceedings that sen r :e connection
was disconnected on 3O.Og.2O24, they directed p;
itioner to pay
or deposit a sum of Rs.43,g4,907. S0/_, inclusivt rf interest
up
to 06. 1 1 .2024, as a pre-condition for dismantlir r 33 KV sub_
,
station which is directly traceable to the ver,, back billing
proceedings u'hich are under suspension by virtut
t[-the interim
order dated 2O.O8.2O19 in Writ petition No.I t.r O3 of
According to petitioner, this action of responden r ;
wilful disobedience of the interim order of this Corr
1.6
amounts to
t.
Petitioner also alleges discrirr i rttion
arbitrariness inasmuch
&S,
2019.
and
rn respect of c her service
connectlons of petitioner with the responcl( r t company,
respondents granted relief of disconnection, derati:
I of load and
dismantling even when back billing disputes were pending. In
the present case alone, such relief is denied without aly
justifiable reason, solely to coerce petitioner into paying
amounts which are under judicial scrutiny. Once petitioner
sought cancellation and dismantling of service connection, the
2"d respondent has no authority either under the Agreement
dated 3O.O4.2O18, the trlectricit5r Act, 2OO3 or the applicable
rules and regulations to extend the agreement or compel the
petitioner to continue the HT service connection. The right of
petitioner to seek cancellation and dismantling flows from the
agreement itself, and there is no provision enabling the
respondents to deny dismantling after completion of work and
termination of contract, especially when the alleged arrears are
stayed by this Court. It is hnally pleaded that Agreement
between petitioner and respondents was only for one year from
30.04.2018, and in terms of Condition No.7 thereof, petitioner
has terminated the Agreement. Upon such termination, the
obligation of respondents is to dismantie the service connection,
and the latter cannot compel petitioner to continue to bear
charges towards contracted maximum demand and minimum
charges.
2.
By order dated 05.12.2024, this Ccr rt granted
interim direction in favour of petitioners.
3-
A detailed counter was filed by the 6' respondent
stating that petitioner company obtained electrjci y supply by
entering into an Agreement dated 30.04.20 18 spe c i ically for the
purpose of construction activities, namely co r struction of
Pumping Station No.2 at Sita Rama Lift Irrig: -ion Project,
Package No.5. The power supply was sanc- rned lor a
'
contracted maximum demand of 750 KVA under F' Category II,
subject to the express condition that the petitione t
'',vould abide
by the General Terms and Conditions of Suppll' I nd the tariff
orders issued by the Telangana State Electricit . Reguiatory
Commission from time to time. It is contende'l one of the
binding conditions under the General Terms and londitions oI
Supply is Clause 5.9.4.2, which governs deration rl contracted
maximum demand and termination of HT agreem. rts. The said
Clause specifically stipulates that a consum: - may seek
reduction of contracted maximum demand or terrl nation of the
HT agreement only after expiry of the minimum >eriod of one
year by giving not less than one month's notice, I rd that upon
termination of HT Agreement, the consumer is [il rle to pay all
sums due under the Agreement as on tJle date ol t :rmination. It
is further stated that the company is also empowered to
terminate the Agreement in the event of violation of terms of the
HT agreement, General Terms and Conditions of Supply or the
applicable statutory provisions, including the Electricity Act,
2OO3 ar,d the AP Electricity Reforms Act, 1998.
3.
1.
It is asserted, petitioner is a construction company
and had applied for electricity connection specihcally for
construction purposes. The supply was therefore, in the nature
of temporary supply. The power supply was sanctioned under
HT Category-Il initially as per the prevailing tariff for the
financial year 2OI8-2O 19, and the demand for such temporary
supply was raised from the date of release of supply, i.e.,
3O.O4.2O18 to 07.06.2019. A demand notice in this regard was
issued on 10.08.2019. Under the Agreement, particularly under
Conditions 8 and 9 thereof, petitioner expressly agreed to pay
maximum demand charges, energr charges, surcharges, meter
rents and other charges in accordance with the tariffs applicable
and the General Terms and Conditions of Supply prescribed by
the company from time to time. Petitioner also agreed that the
company has unilateral authority to vary tariffs, scales of
charges and the General Terms and Conditions of Supply by
special or general proceeding-s, and to enhan) r the rates
chargeable for supply of electricity as per exigencier;
3.2.
Respondents further submit that Tel,r rgana State
Electricify Regulatory Commission, on the pro l rsal of the
distribution licensees, introduced a separate tzr ilf rate for
consumers availing temporary'supply under HT v,> lage for the
lrnarrcial year 2Ol8-2O19. According to responden t ; petitioner
itself requested power supply for construction : :tivit5r, and
therefore, the applicable tariff for temporary supply ,,as liable to
.
be applied. The Divisional Engineer/DpE
Bhadradri
Kothagudem, inspected petitioner's service conne(:l ir>n bearing
SC No. BKM-130 on 07.06.2019 and noticed thrr they were
utilising electricity for construction purposer, including
cons[ruction of canal tunnel works relating to Si.z Rama Lift
Irrlgation Project. Based on the said inspection, it v., s proposed
to convert the service category from HT Catego y -II to HT
Category-Vll, in accordance with the tariff ,r cler dated
27.O3.2O8 issued by the Regulatory Commissi rn for the
Ilnancial year 20 1B-2O 19.
3.3.
Pursuant to the inspection, billing under HT
Category-Vll was proposed instead of HT Catego - -II for the
period from the date of release of supply, i.e. 3C. )4.2018 to
t0
07.06.2019, arrd an amount of Rs.34,61,40O/- was assessed
uide proceedings dated ll .06.2019; the said amount was
lawfully payable by petitioner in terms of the tariff order dated
27.03.2018 and Conditions 8 and 9 of the Agreemenr. As per
CGRF instructions, a suitable reply was submitted and a copy
was also communicated to petitioner. The same procedure of
reclassihcation and back billing was uniformly adopted for all
HT services throughout the State in terms of Clause 2.22 of the
tariff order dated,27.O3.2O18 for the Iinancial year 2O 18- 19. It is
asserted that Rs.34,61,4O0/- was calculated strictly on the
basis of inspection and on the statement of petitioner's
representative admitting that power was being used for
construction purposes. Accordingly, revision of consumption
charges with effect from the date of release of supply till
07 .06.2019 was justif-red.
3.4.
Respondents further state that the category of
petitioner's service was proposed strictly based on the
lnspectron report
of DPE/ADE/OP and that notice of
assessment for the relevant period was issued after due
inspection and a-fter recording the statement of the
representative of petitioner company, who admitted that the
power supply was being used for construction purposes.
K
1l
--.-...-
Respondents admit that petitioner Iiled Writ petiri rn No. 17803
of 2Ol9 challenging the change of category wherr: : this Court
granted an interim order suspending the dema.r I subject to
deposit of one-third of the amount. However, it s contended
that the said Writ Petition does not involve any iss;r r: relating to
disconnection or dismantiing of power supply. , .r:cording to
respondents, petitioner is now seeking permanent dismantling
of service connection without final a judication : - the earlier
demand, which is impermissible.
3.5.
It is further contended that in.tr rit Petition
No. 178O3 of 2019, a counter affidavit and vacate
tay petition
were filed as early as on 04.09.2020, but petitioner has neither
filed reply nor made any effort to get the said ,,rit petition
,
disposed of. Petitioner, being a construction conl rany and a
temporary consumer, would leave the site upon ( ( mpletion of
construction, and if service connection and sul> station are
dismantled at this stage, respondents would be left vithout any
effective means to recover the legaily demanded an r unts which
are the subject matter of the above Writ petition.
3.6.
Considering petitioner's request for lismantling
and the above circumstances, ttle 2"d respondent ca :ulated the
total dues payable as Rs.67,61,3 lTl-, and, after d: lucting the
K'
t2
security deposit of Rs.25,08,840/ -, issued the impugned
proceedings dated 06. 1 1.2024 calling upon petitioner to pay
Rs.43,84,907,50/ -. It is contended that petitioner's request for
deration of load was rightly rejected by proceedings dated
27 .O8.2O2O, clearly stating that unless the outstanding arrears
of about Rs.36.9O lakhs were cleared, the request for deration
could not be considered.
3.7
.
Respondents further contend that petitioner
requested permanent dismantling of service on 05.11.2024 aftet
completion of the project and without clearing substantial
arrears of Rs.67,61,317 /-, after adjusting the security deposit.
The procedure adopted by them is scrupulously in accordance
with law and that even in the case of domestic (LT-l)
connections, dismantling is permitted only when arrears are nil,
as envisaged under Clause 5.9.4.2 of the General Terms and
Conditions of Supply. It is emphatically submitted that
petitioner obtained power supply on a temporary basis and that
unless all sums due as on the date of termination of the
agreement are paid, the HT service connection and the 33 KV
sub-station cannot be dismantled. Respondents further rely
upon the statutory character of the General Terms and
Conditions of Supply and the tariff orders, contending that
l3
reclassification and back biliing were carried rtrr strictly in
accordance with Clause 3_4.1 and Clause 12.3 of Ct neral Terms
and CondiLions of Supply, which expre; ;iy permit
reclassification and retrospective billing in cases of
misclassification or under-billing, subject to thr prescribed
limits.
3.8.
Respondents place reliance on the jud: lent of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Southern Electrtcitg Sr,
oplg Co. of
Orissa Ltd. o. Sri Seetaram Rice Millt, to r r ntend that
unauthorised use of electricity and breach of terrr; of supply
attract statutory consequences and that High Oo rrts should
orclinarily refrain from interfering in assessment >roceedings
under Article 226 of the Constitution. Reliance is als I placed
on
the decision in Hgderabad. Vanaspolthi Ltd. u. ,t P.SEB2, to
emphasise that t.erms and conditions of supply are tatutory
in
nature and binding on the consumer.
3.9.
On the aforesaid premises, responder [s contend
that action taken by them is strictly in conformigr w . h statutory
provisions, tariff orders and binding contractual terr rs;
no violation of principles of natural justice and that
' (2o t2) 2 scc l08
'] (1998) 4 scc 470
there is
1 c.titioner is
t4
atte mpting to evade payment
of iegitimate dues gy filjng
successive writ petitions. Respondents
therefore, state that Writ
Petition ls devoid of merit
and the
same is liable to be
dismissed
In the repiy filed, petitioner reiterates
all the averments made in the writ
denies the stand taken by
and reaffirms
affidavit and specifically
the respondents in the counter
affidavit Petitioner while admitting
execution of
the Agreement,
categorically denies respondents,
assertion that the said
Agreement was entered into
specifically contended that
for construction purposes. It
the power supply was obtained
manufacturing activities at the
is
for
Oddu Ramavaram work site,
namely production of concrete
through batching piants,
fabrication of MS pipes and
steel structures, which fal
under manufacturing activit5r
and not construction. Having
regard to the nature of activities,
classihed under HT_II category
entitled to treat the service
t-t_re service was rightly
initially; respondents are not
connection as temporary,
connection has been in existence
as the
continuously from 30.O4.2O1g
for more than three years, and
framework, the respondents
squarery
under the applicable tariff
cannot retrospectively treat it
as
---
t5
temporary supply nor 1e!y charges at rates
qrplicable to
temporary connections beyond the permissible peli rd.
4.t.
According to petitioner, respondents c rnnot invoke
Ciause 5.9.4.2 to demand payment of amounts ,r hich are sub
judice and recovery of which stands suspendr:r
by judicial
order. It is further asserted that all reg- zlr monthly
consumption charges under HT-II category har : been paid
without default, except the back biiling arnourr s which are
expressly covered by the interim stay. Petitiont:
never used
electricity for any construction work and th I . the entire
consumption was confined to manufacturing act'r il,ies, namely
batching plants, fabrication units, welding machi: :s and allied
operations. It is pointed out that the respondent ; themselves
initially categorised the service under HT-ll afte r '' erihcation of
the nature of activity, and having done so, th.: subordinate
officer could not have unilaterally changed the cz:r :gory to HT-
VII without notice or justihcation and su,) L unilateral
reclassification is contraqr to Condition No.2 of 1l e agreement
dated 30.O4.2018 and violative of principles of nat_ :al justice. It
is further contended that contractual terms ca r not override
binding judicial orders and that the respondent; plea to the
contrary amounts to disregard of the authority of t: s Court.
I
8,.
t6
4.2.
With reference to the inspection dated O7.O6.2019
relied upon by respondents, petitioner categorically denies the
truth and correctness of the allegations contained therein. It is
asserted that the said inspection was conducted without any
prior notice and behind the back of the petitioner, ald therefore
the inspection report is not binding. Petitioner denies that it was
ever involved in construction of canal tunnels of the Sita Rama
Lift Irrigation Project and asserts that such allegations are
baseless, unsupported by evidence and founded on a purported
inspection report rvhich was neither preceded by notice nor
foliowed by an opportunity of explalation. It is contended that
demanding payment of the entire disputed amount for
dismantling the sub-station, despite the subsisting stay order,
is arbitrary, coercive and violative of the rule of law.
4.3.
In reply to the apprehension expressed by the
respondents that dismantling of the sub-station would render
recovery of dues impossible, petitioner contends that such
apprehension is r,r,'holly unfounded. It is asserted that the
petitioner is an established and solvent company with several
ongoing contracts with the respondent corporation itself, having
a registered office and a proven track record of compliance with
contractual obligations. A substantial security deposit of about
G'7
l7
Rs.25,O0,000/ - is already lying with the reslr ,ndents. The
speculative apprehensions regarding recovery car not form the
basis for denial of a legitimate contractual and stzL utory right to
dismantling, especially when the service stancll disconnected
since 30.08.2O24. After disconnection of povr'( I supply, the
no purpose
continued existence of 33 KV sub-station senrr:
except to impose an unjust financial burden
,
n petitioner.
Petitioner is being compelled to pay minimum dt'r .rand charges
of Rs.3,75,000/- per month, in addition to rr :ter charges,
aggregating to about Rs.4,28,O221 -
per m,) rth, without
consuming a single unit of electricity. The pressL re exerted by
land-owning farmers, on whose land the sub-stat ( n is situated,
has subjected petitioner to serious hardship nd potential
,
disputes.
4.4.
Petitioner asserts that respondents cannot deny
dismantling on the ground of non-payment of dis: .rted dues, as
petitioner has undertaken to comply with whate", r orders may
ultimately be passed by this Court in Writ Petiti( r No.178O3 of
2019. It is reiterated that despite repeated .otices dated
r
29.06.2024, 27.O8.2O24 and 26.10.2024 te': rinating the
contract and seeking dismantling, the respondel .s have failed
to act in accordance with the agreement. Peti ioner further
&
t8
assails the inspection report dated ll.O6.2OLg relied upon
by
the respondents, contending that the said report does not
disclose issuance of arry show cause notice prior to
reclassihcation from HT-II to HT_VII. The report merely records
an alleged conclusion that service was used for irrigation project
purposes, without any evidence or reasoning. The petitioner
reiterates that its original application dated 1g.O9.2017 clearly
discloses the nature of work as batching plant, fabrication
unit,
welding machines and illumination systems for camps, and
that
the HT-II category was assigned only after due verification by
the competent authoriqr.
4.5.
Petitioner further points out inconsistencies in the
respondents' stand regarding the date of inspection, contending
that while the counter affidavit refers to inspection on
11.06.2019, the documents now produced show inspection on
07 .06.2019.
It is asserted that the proceedings dated
11.06.2019 were prepared several days later and were
purportedly served on an unnamed and unauthorised person,
who was neither an employee nor an authorised representative
of the petitioner. According to petitioner, no statement was given
by any of its employees on the date of inspection and the report
is a premeditated document intended to coerce payment of
rt!--19
excessive back billing. It
is further contenc( I that the
inspection report does not record any con: 'ete hnding
supported by evidence and proceeds on mere pres l nptions that
power was used for irrigation purposes, despl e: petitioner
having no contract whatsoever with irrigation
<lepartment.
Petitioner reiterates that usage was purely for r.l rnufacturing
activities and does not fall under temporary su[l ly or HT-VII
category. The unilateral change of category anrl direction to
issue back billing without issuing a show car r ;r: notice or
affording an opportunity of hearing is asserted rt be patently
illegal and violative of principles of natural ju s ice. On the
aforesaid grounds, it is prayed that inspection -,-'port dated
ll.06.2019 and the consequential back billing lemands be
rejected as illegai, arbitrary and unsustainable.
5.
Heard Sri K. Manik Prabhu, learne: counsel for
petitioner and Sri A. Chandra Shaker, lear: :d Standing
Counsel for respondents.
6.
Having considered the material on recc rd, it is to be
seen, the issues raised in the present Writ Petition are
inseparably interlinked with the subject matter of Writ Petition
No. 17803 of 2Ol9, as the impugned demand fo:
payment of
back billing arrears as a pre-condition for disrr lntling flows
w-
directly from the proceedings challenged in the said Writ
Petition. It is an admitted position that petitioner was
granted
HT electricity supply under an Agreement dated 30.04.201g
with a contracted maximum demand of 750 KVA. It is also
not
in dispute that service connection was originally categorised as
HT-II after scrutiny of petitioner's application and verification
of
the nature of activity. The subsequent reclassification of service
from HT-II to HT-VII and the consequential back billing were
effected unilatera-lly by respondents on the basis of an
inspection conducted in June, 2019.
The legality of the said reclassihcation and
retrospective
back billing was challenged in Writ petition
No. 17803 of
2Ol9 wherein this Court, by order dated
20.o8.2019, suspended operation of back billing demand
subject to deposit of one-third of the demanded amount. It
is
not disputed that petitioner complied with the said condition
and the interim order remained in force throughout. Upon final
consideration of the pleadings and material in Writ petition
No.17803 of 2019, this Court found that change of category
from HT-ll to HT-VII and the consequential back billing were
effected without issuance of any shou. cause notice, without
affording an opportunity of hearing and in violation of the
2t
principles of natural justice, and accordingly t liowed Writ
Petition No.17803 of 2019.
8,
Once the proceedings giving rise to t h t back billing
demand have been set aside, the very foundatior ll impugned
demand in the present Writ Petition ceases to exir t. [nsistence
of respondents on payment of such back billing lrrears as a
condition precedent for dismantling the servict: r onnection is
therefore, rendered wholly unsustainabie jr
lzrw'. Even
otherwise, it is to be noticed, respondents' relizrtr rr on Clause
5.9 .4.2 of Ge neral Terms and Conditions I
Supply is
misconceived in the facts of the present case. \! rile the said
Clause obligates a consumer to clear sums leg I ly clue upon
termination of the Agreement, it cannot be invo < :d to compel
payment of demands which have been adjudicatr:rI as illegal and
unsustainable . Statutory conditions cannot be irL:rpreted in a
manner that Validates an otherwise unlawful dcr z rLd or defeals
judicial revieu, exercised under Article 226 of thc (l )nstitution.
9.
Respondents' action in withholding c rsmantling of
33 KV sub-station, despite admitted disconnecticr of supply on
30.Oa.2O24, has resulted in continued levy of mir i num demand
charges on petitioner without any consumptior, of clectricity.
Such action is manifestly arbitrary, unrez sonable and
ffi
disproportionate, particularly when petitioner completed its
project, repeatedly sought dismantling, undertaken to bear
dismantling costs and is facing pressure from land_owning
farmers on whose land the sub-station stands erected. The
apprehension expressed by respondents regarding possible
difiiculty in recovery of dues cannot be sustained, especially
when the back billing itself has been held to be illegal and set
aside. In any event, speculative apprehensions cannot override
petitioner's contractual and statutory right to have the service
dismantled after disconnection, nor can they justify continuance
of infrastructure which no longer serves any public or
contractual purpose.
10.
This Court therefore, is of the considered view that
permitting dismantling of service connection and sub_station
causes no prejudice whatsoever to respondents, whereas denial
of such relief results in continuing financial and legal prejudice
to petitioner. Balance of convenience and equity clearly tiits in
favour of petitioner. In the light of the same, the Writ petition
deserves to be allowed.
11,
In the result, the proceedings dated O6.1t.2O24,
and the consequential demand insisting on payment of back
billing arrears as a pre-condition for dismantling of HT Service
Connection No. BKM-13O and the 33 KV sub-stali: r, are hereby
set aside. Respondents are directed to dismant t 33 KV substation and IIT Service Connection No. BKM-130 t Sita Rama
Lilt [rrigation Project, Package-S, Oddu RamiL,; ram Village,
Mulakalapalty Mandal, Bhadradri Kothagudem I strict within
four weeks lrom the date of receipt of a copl' , f this order,
without insisting on payment of disputed back bit ing amounts.
Petitioner shall bear the expenses involved in di ,rnantling, as
already undertaken.
11.1.
lt is further declared that reclL sification of
petitioner's service connection from HT-ll lo HT-VII and
consequential back billing demands, which forrrr J the subject
matter of Writ Petition No.17803 of 2Ol9 ar : illegal and
unsustainablc, and Writ Petition No. 178O3 o- 12019 stands
allowed accordingly. It is clarihed that except to he extent set
aside hcrein, this Court has not expressed any r rinion on any
other independent claims or liabilities, if any, r accordance
with lavr,.
72.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition is alkrrv :r1. No costs.
I
t
Z4
13.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
I
I
any shall stand closed.
i
Sd/.B. REKHA RANI
ISTANT REGISTRA
//TRUE COPY//
To,
1. The Chairman and Managing Director, Northe
of Telangana Ltd, CorPorate office, Nakkalagutta
SECTION OFFICER
r Distribution ComPanY
amakonda, Warangal
No ern Power Distribution
2. The SuP erintending Eng ineer Operations, Bhadra
dri Kothgudem.
Company of Telangana Ltd , Operation Circle,
Divisional Engineer (Operations)(TSNPDC. L)'. Northern
"3. The
a;;;;t;itetantana itd', operation circle, Kothsudem
Power Distribution
4. The Assistant Divisional engineer, (Operations) (TSNPDCL) Sub Division
Paloncha, B. Kothgudem District'
5. The Assistant Divisional engineer, (operations) (TSNPDCL) Mulakalapally
Section, B.Kothgudem District.
6. The Senior Accounts Officer /CO/ TSNPDCL' Kothgudem' B Kothgudem
District
7. One CC to SRI K.MANIK PRABHU, Advocate [OPUCI
8. One CC to SRI A.CHANDRA SHAKER, SC FOR NPDCL [OPUC]
1. 9. Two CD Copies
,i/,',.
,'
BSRYDAN
f
i
E
E
I
I
I
I
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0910112026
fI.ll
,\
13 t',l 2q,;c
*
F
ORDER
WP.No.33531 of 2024
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION,
WITHOUT COSTS
\1
2)
't,
b
(
a
C:
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review