Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010543972022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3529]
TUESDAY, THE THIRD DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE R RAGHUNANDAN RAO
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D.SEKHAR
WRIT PETITION Nos.: 33250 of 2022; 17007, 10609, 10802, 12505, 25314
of 2023; 2856 of 2024; 12421 of 2025; 3694 of 2026
WRIT PETITION NO: 33250/2022
Between:
1. M/S. P.VENUGOPAL NAIDU,, WORKS CONTRACTOR S/O. LATE.
P.VENKATA SUBBAIAH NAIDU, AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS, OCCBUSINESS, 6-7-567/301, SAI PRANEETHA REDDY NILAYAM,
SRIPURAM COLONY, TIRUPATHI, TIRUPATHI -517501, ANDHRA
PRADESH.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. UNION OF INDIA, REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, MINISTRY
OF FINANCE, 4TH FLOOR, A-WING, SHASTRI BHAWAN. NEW
DELHI 110001.
2. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP. BY ITS PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, REVENUE (CT-I) DEPARTMENT,
VELAGAPUDI, AMARAVATHI, GUNTUR DISTRICT, ANDHRA
PRADESH.
3. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER ST, TIRUPATI -I CIRCLE,
CHITTOOR DIVISION, CHITTOOR, SRI BALAJI DISTRICT.
4. THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER, TIRUMALA TIRUPATI DEVASTHANAMS,
RRR, J & TCDS, J
W.P.No.33250 of 2022 & batch
TIRUMALA, TIRUPATI, SRI BALAJI DISTRICT, ANDHRA PRADESH
5. THE CHIEF ENGINEER, TIRUMALA TIRUPATI DEVASTHANAMS,
TIRUPATI, SRI BALAJI DISTRICT.
6. THE CHIEF COMMISSIONER OF STATE TAX, D.NO. 5-59, RK
SPRING VALLEY APARTMENTS, BANDAR ROAD, EDUPUGALLU
VILLAGE, KANKIPADU MANDAL,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA
DISTRICT -521144, ANDHRA PRADESH.
7. M/S TIRUMALA TIRUPATI DEVASTHANAMS, REP. BY ITS
EXECUTIVE OFFICER, TIRUMALA,
TIRUPATI, SRI BALAJI
DISTRICT, ANDHRA PRADESH
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased topleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction particularly in
the nature of Writ of MANDAMUS (i) declaring the inaction on the part of the
Executive Officer, TTD in not considering the representations made by the
Petitioner to it either to pay the enhanced rate of 6 percent as levied by the
GST authorities with penalty and interest or (ii) to give clarification pursuant to
the letter addressed by the Executive Officer , TTD dated 22-04-2018 to the
Chief Commissioner, State GST to grant necessary instructions and to refrain
the Assistant Commissioner (ST), GST Department not to issue any further
communication pursuant to the show cause notice dated 17-09-2022 as he is
also a Government Official who has to wait for the instructions to be issued by
the State GST Chief Commissioner and consequently to direct the Chief
Commissioner to issue instructions accordingly or (iii) to direct the Executive
Officer to pay balance amount of 6 percent along with interest and penalty as
levied in the show cause notice (iv) and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to grant stay directing the Assistant Commissioner (ST), GST not to
proceed further with the show cause notice pending disposal of the writ
petition and pass
RRR, J & TCDS, J
W.P.No.33250 of 2022 & batch
IA NO: 2 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to vacate the interim Orders granted on 11.11.2022 in W.P No.33250
of 2022 in the interests of justice and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to extend the interim orders WP 33250/22 Dt.20/12/23till the
disposal of the writ petition as the Hon?ble Court was pleased to extend the
same time and again, else the Petitioner would be put to serious loss and
hardship.
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. M V J K KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. Y V ANIL KUMAR (Central Government Counsel)
2. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX
3. NVS PRASADA VARMA
RRR, J & TCDS, J
W.P.No.33250 of 2022 & batch
RRR, J & TCDS, J
W.P.No.33250 of 2022 & batch
The Court made the following Common Order:
(per Hon’ble Sri Justice R. Raghunandan Rao)
All these Writ Petitions arise out of questions of rate of tax payable by
contractors, who have executed work contracts for Tirumula Tirupati
Devastanams (TTD), between the period 01.07.2017 to 01.07.2022.
2.
The petitioners herein, who are contractors, contend that they are
liable to pay GST @ 12% from 01.07.2017 to 01.07.2022 and @ 18%
thereafter. The GST Authorities, on the other hand, contend that the rate of
tax remains 18% from 01.07.2022 onwards.
3.
The main contention raised by the petitioners is that Notification
No.11 of 2017, dated 28.06.2017, fixed the rate of GST, on contracts
executed for TTD at 12%. This contention is disputed by the respondent-GST
Authorities.
4.
The GST Act came into force from 01.07.2017. The rate of tax
payable on supply of goods or on supply of services is not stipulated under the
Act. However, such rate of tax is stipulated, by way of notifications, issued
from time to time. The first set of notifications, issued for this purpose, were
Notification Nos.11 of 2017 & 12 of 2017, dated 28.06.2017. Notification
No.11 of 2017 dealt with supply of goods, while Notification No.12 of 2017
dealt with supply of services. The relevant extract of Notification No.11 of
2017 would be S.No.03, which reads as follows:
RRR, J & TCDS, J
W.P.No.33250 of 2022 & batch
Chapter,
Sl.No.
Section or
Rate
Description of Service
(per
Heading
Condition
cent.)
Heading 9954
(i) Construction of a complex,
(Construction
building, civil structure or a
services)
part thereof, including a
complex
or
intended
buyer,
-
building
for
sale
to
a
wholly
or
partly,
except where the entire
consideration
has
been
received after issuance of
completion
where
certificate,
required,
by
the
competent authority or after
its
first
whichever
occupation,
is
earlier.
(Provisions of paragraph 2
of
this
notification
shall
apply for valuation of this
service)
(ii)
Composite supply of
works
contract
-
-
as
defined in clause 119
of section 2 of Central
Goods and Services
Tax Act, 2017.
(iii)
Construction services
other than (i) and (ii)
above.
RRR, J & TCDS, J
W.P.No.33250 of 2022 & batch
5.
This notification prescribes GST @ 9% under the CST Act and
9% under the SGST Act, aggregating to 18%. Notification No.24 of 2017,
dated 21.08.2017, r/w Notification No.20 of 2017, dated 22.08.2017, made
certain changes to Notification No.11 of 2017. By virtue of these notifications,
the rate of tax in relation to the aforesaid entry, in Notification No.11 of 2017,
was reduced from 9% to 6%. This meant that the rate of tax under the CST
would be 6% and the rate of tax under the SGST would be 6%, aggregating to
12%. Another change made, by Notification No.20 of 2017, was to restrict this
reduced rate of 6% to supply made to Government, a local authority or
Governmental authority, subject to conditions stipulated in these notifications.
By Notification No.31 of 2017, dated 13.10.2017, the words <Government, a
local authority or Governmental Authority= were substituted with the words
<Central Government, State Government, Union Territory, a local authority, a
Governmental authority or a Governmental entity=. The terms >Governmental
authority? and >Governmental entity? were defined in the following manner:
<(ix) <Governmental Authority= means an authority or a
board or any other body,(i)
set up by an Act of Parliament or a State
Legislature; or
(ii)
established by any Government, with 90 per cent.
Or more participation by way of equity or control, to carry out any
function entrusted to a Municipality under Article 243 W of the
Constitution or to a Panchayat under Article 243 G of
the Constitution.
RRR, J & TCDS, J
W.P.No.33250 of 2022 & batch
(x) <Government Entity= means an authority or a board or
any other body including a society, trust, corporation,
(i) set up by an Act of Parliament or State Legislature; or
(ii) established by any Government, with 90 per cent. or
more participation by way of equity or control, to carry out a
function
entrusted
by
the
Central
Government,
State
Government, Union Territory or a local authority.=.
6.
It is contended by the petitioners that TTD falls within the
definition of >Governmental entity?. This is disputed by the respondents, who
contend that the requirement of carrying out functions entrusted to a
municipality or a panchayat, by Article 243W and Article 243G, respectively, of
the Constitution of India, is not available, as TTD does not carry out such
functions.
7.
The definition of >Governmental Authority? requires that a body
which is sought to be recognised as governmental authority should fulfil the
following conditions:
1) It should be an authority or a board or any other body.
2) It should have been set up by an Act of Parliament or the State
Legislature, or
3) It can also be established by any Government.
4) A body, which meets the above requirements, should have 90%
participation, by way of equity or control by the Government.
RRR, J & TCDS, J
W.P.No.33250 of 2022 & batch
5) Such a body would also carry out functions which should be
entrusted to a municipality, under Article 243W of the Constitution of
India or to a panchayat, under Article 243G of the Constitution.
8.
As far as a >Governmental entity? is concerned, the following
requirements need to be complied with:
1) It can be an authority, board or any other body, including society,
trust or corporation.
2) It should have been set up by an Act of Parliament of the State
Legislature, or
3) It can be established by any Government.
4) This body should be controlled by the Government, either by way
of 90% equity or 90% control.
5) It should also be carrying out some functions entrusted by the
Central Government, State Government, Union Territory or a
local authority.
9.
The TTD was originally established by way of an Act of the
Legislature of the State of Madras in 1932. This Act, in turn, came to be
repealed by way of the Andhra Pradesh Charitable and Hindu Religious
Institutions and Endowments Act, 1987. The provisions relating to TTD are
contained in Chapter XIV from Sections 95 -131 of the Endowments Act,
1987. Section 96 of the Endowments Act, created a Board, which shall be
RRR, J & TCDS, J
W.P.No.33250 of 2022 & batch
constituted by the Government and would be called a TTD Board. This board,
under Section 97 of the Endowments Act, was set up for running the TTD. The
Board is appointed by the Government, by virtue of Section 96 itself. Under
Section 103, the Government has the power to suspend or remove the
Chairman, or any member of the Board. Section 105 permits the Government
to dissolve the Board itself, if it is satisfied that such dissolution is necessary.
The Executive Officers and all higher authorities, functioning under the Board,
are appointed by the Government. The resolutions passed by the Board are
subject to review by the Government. All major actions of the TTD Board are
sent for ratification to the Government. These provisions clearly demonstrate
that it is the Government of Andhra Pradesh, which has 100% control over the
TTD Board.
10.
The learned Standing Counsel for TTD has also placed before us
G.O.Ms.No.746, dated 02.06.2007 as well as G.O.Ms.No.747, dated
02.06.2007. In G.O.Ms.No.746, the Government has stipulated as under:
<8.
Tirumala Hills area has been notified as a place of
religious importance under Section 5 (1) of the Andhra
Pradesh Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 read with Section 114 of
A.P.
Charitable
and
Hindu
Religious
Institutions
and
Endowments Act, 1987. This effectively places the civic
administration of the Tirumala Hills area in the hands of the
Executive Officer who shall have the authority normally
exercised by a gram panchayat, the Sarpanch, Executive
Officer or Executive Authority thereof under the A.P.
RRR, J & TCDS, J
W.P.No.33250 of 2022 & batch
Panchayat Raj Act, 1994. This special dispensation ensures
that only spiritual and religious activity goes on in the seven
hills area. No elections or political activity is permitted.=
11.
As can be seen from the above extract, the civic administration of
the Tirumala Hills Area is given to the Executive Officer, who shall exercise all
the authority exercised by a Gram Panchayat or Executive Officer or
Executive Authority under the provisions of the Andhra Pradesh Panchayat
Raj Act, 1994. Article 243G of the Constitution of India stipulates certain
functions that could be exercised by a Gram Panchayat, as stipulated in
Schedule II. Schedule II of the Constitution enumerates various functions that
can be carried out by a Gram Panchayat. By virtue of G.O.Ms.No.746, it is the
TTD which would have to carry out these functions. In that view of the matter,
TTD meets the requirement to be categorized as a Governmental Authority, in
the definition set out above.
12.
The TTD would also meet the requirement of Governmental
entity, if it can demonstrate that it is carrying out any function entrusted by the
State Government. G.O.Ms.No.746, in the extract placed above, subsequently
entrusts the functions of Gram Panchayat on the Executive Officers of the
TTD Board, who function under the control of the Board. In the circumstances,
the TTD Board meets the requirement of Government entity also.
13.
The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners have also
sought to rely upon a ruling of the Authority for Advance Ruling, A.P., which
RRR, J & TCDS, J
W.P.No.33250 of 2022 & batch
had held that TTD meets the above requirements of being treated as
Government body or Government entity.
14.
The learned Standing Counsel for the respondents sought to
place reliance upon the ruling of the Authority for Advance Rulings for the
State of Telangana, which had held that the TTD does not meet these
requirements.
15.
This Court does not wish to go into the question inasmuch as
they are issues decided by the authority, which is subordinate to this Court
and such authority cannot be cited before this Court.
16.
The further question that remains before this Court is whether the
reduced rate of 12% would be available to the petitioners even if TTD Board is
treated as a Government entity or a Government authority. The notifications,
relied upon by the petitioners, would show that such reduced rate of tax would
be available only if the works, which have been executed by these petitioners,
are falling within the nature of works stipulated under the notifications. The
question of whether such works meet these requirements is a question of fact
which has not been gone into by the authorities nor can this Court go into
these questions while exercising its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
17.
In the circumstances, it would only be appropriate that all these
matters are remanded back to the respective Assessing Authorities to go into
RRR, J & TCDS, J
W.P.No.33250 of 2022 & batch
the question of whether the works, executed by the petitioners, would be in
the nature of works enumerated in the notifications.
18.
Before parting with the cases, this Court would also make it clear
that the finding of this Court that the TTD Board is a Government authority or
a Government entity, is based on the provisions of the notifications and this
finding shall not be treated as a finding that the TTD is a Government authority
or a Government entity, for other purposes.
19.
It may also be noted that the proceedings are at the stage of
replying to show-cause notices in certain Writ Petitions and the Assessment
orders have been challenged in some Writ Petitions. It also appears that no
intimation has been issued in Form GST DRC-01A in some Writ Petitions. The
details of the stages, at which the petitioners have approached this Court, are
set out below:
Name of the Writ
Petitioner
Date of show
cause notice
issued
(If challenged)
Date of
assessment
Order passed
(If Challenged)
WP 33250
of 2022
M/S. P.VENUGOPAL
NAIDU
17-09-2022
-
WP 17007
of 2023
M/S. B
SREENIVASULU
REDDY AND CO.
17-03-2023
-
WP 2856
of 2024
RAMYA
ENTERPRISES TPT
-
24-05-2022
S. No
Writ
Petition
number
RRR, J & TCDS, J
W.P.No.33250 of 2022 & batch
WP 3694
of 2026
M/S. C
JAGANNATHAM
-
10-12-2025
WP 10609
of 2023
MARUTHI NAIDU
POTTURI
11-04-2023
-
WP 10802
of 2023
MADHAVA PALANI
WORKS
CONTRACTOR
27-02-2023
-
WP 12421
of 2025
SHRI NARASIMHA
REDDY MEDIREDDY
-
Appellate Order
No
ZD3703250131
32Y dated 1103-2025.
Original Order
vide Case Id
DIN3728102385
WP 12505
of 2023
SURI BABU
VEERAVASARAPU
20-02-2023
-
WP 25314
of 2023
M/S. N. BHASKAR
ENTERPRISES
17-09-2022
-
20.
In the circumstances, these Writ Petitions are disposed of, with
the following directions:
1) W.P.Nos.33250 of 2022; 10609, 10802, 12505, 17007 & 25314 of 2023
are disposed of and the matters are remanded back to the respective
Assessing Authorities to give an opportunity of hearing to the
petitioners, in replying to the show-cause notices, issued to the
petitioners/ communications given to the petitioners, as to whether the
RRR, J & TCDS, J
W.P.No.33250 of 2022 & batch
works executed by the petitioners are in the nature of works
enumerated in the notifications.
2) The W.P.Nos.2856 of 2024; 12421 of 2025 And 3694 of 2026 are
disposed of, setting aside the orders of assessment and order-in-appeal
and the matters are remanded back to the Assessing Authorities by
determining whether the petitioners are entitled to the benefit of rate of
tax, in accordance with the provisions of the notifications issued in this
regard.
21.
As can be seen, the notifications granting reduced rate of tax
came into effect only from 13.10.2017, as far as the present cases are
concerned. The exercise that would be carried out by the authorities would be
in relation to the period 13.10.2017 till 01.07.2022. It is further clarified, that
the petitioners would be entitled to claim reimbursement of the differential rate
of GST, from TTD, when the contract provides for reimbursement from TTD.
There shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel, pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand
closed.
________________________
R. RAGHUNANDAN RAO, J
________________
T.C.D. SEKHAR, J
Date:03.03.2026
MJA
RRR, J & TCDS, J
W.P.No.33250 of 2022 & batch
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE R RAGHUNANDAN RAO
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D.SEKHAR
WRIT PETITION Nos.: 33250 of 2022; 17007, 10609, 10802, 12505, 25314
of 2023; 2856 of 2024; 12421 of 2025; 3694 of 2026
(per Hon’ble Sri Justice R. Raghunandan Rao)
Date:03.03.2026
MJA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review