Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
MAC Appeal No. 4 of 2022 with
MAC Appeal No. 5 of 2022
Date of Decision: 19.12.2023
The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.
The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.
Vs.
Vs.
Smti. Rajinder Kaur Diddan
Smti. Rajinder Kaur Diddan
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. A. Khan, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Ms. P. Bhattacharjee, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
COMMON JUDGMENT
1.
Two claim applications were filed before the Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal (MACT), Shillong by the respondent herein as claimant
seeking compensation on account of the death of her husband and also for
injuries sustained by her as a result of a motor vehicle accident which
occurred on 02.05.2003 at about 9:00 a.m. or so at Pahamrioh village on
the GS Road. The said applications were registered as MAC Case No. 3 of
2004 and MAC Case No. 4 of 2004 respectively.
2.
According to the respondent/claimant on that fateful day, she
along with her deceased husband, H.P.S. Diddan, their son Kabeer Singh
Diddan, Shri. Mewalal (Driver) and Shri. Siddharth Maitreya was
travelling in a Maruti van No. MH-04-BD-7260 from Shillong towards
Gauhati on their way to Sikkim, at about 9:00 a.m. on reaching Pahamrioh
village, GS Road the vehicle they were travelling in was hit by one truck
bearing registration No. AS-25-B-5389. The occupants of the van
sustained grievous injuries and were removed to the hospital where her
husband succumbed to his injuries at Narazeth Hospital, Shillong while
she sustained injuries on her person.
3.
A motor vehicle accident having taken place, an FIR dated
01.07.2003 was filed by SI B.K. Mishra before the Officer-in-Charge
Nongpoh Police Station and accordingly, Nongpoh P.S. Case No. 55(07)
2003 under Sections 279/427/304-A IPC was registered against Shri.
Babul Boro the driver of the said truck No. AS-25-B-5389.
4.
In the said claim applications, the insurer of the offending truck,
that is, the Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., the owner and the driver of the
said truck as well as the owner of the Maruti van No. MH-04-BD-7260
were impleaded as Opposite Parties. However, except for the Oriental
Insurance Co. Ltd., the other three opposite parties did not appear to
contest the claim before the Tribunal following which the matter
proceeded exparte against them. The opposite party/appellant herein then
took recourse to the provision of Section 170 of the Motor Vehicle Act,
1988 to take over the defence of the owner and driver respectively, of the
alleged offending vehicle. The written statement was also filed by the
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.
5.
In course of proceedings, the Tribunal framed four issues
touching on the areas of maintainability, negligence, liability for
compensation and whether the claimant is entitled for such compensation.
In the case of injury, another issue was framed as to whether the injuries
sustained was on account of these said accident and whether such injuries
are serious and permanent in nature.
6.
The respondent/claimant then produced nine witnesses to support
her case while the appellant/Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. also produced
one witness as OPW-1. On conclusion of the recording of evidence, the
parties present their respective argument before the Tribunal and on
consideration of such argument the learned Member, MACT, Shillong
vide a common judgment and order dated 30.07.2021 has awarded
compensation of ₹ 21,56,660/- (rupees twenty-one lakh fifty-six thousand
six hundred sixty) only in the case of death in MAC Case No. 3 of 2004
and compensation of ₹ 1,06,228/- (rupees one lakh six thousand two
hundred twenty eight) only in MAC Case No. 4 of 2004. The learned
MACT has also imposed interest @9% p.a. on the awarded amount which
period of interest will run from 13.02.2004 to 20.11.2020.
7.
Being highly aggrieved with and dissatisfied by the said
judgment and award dated 06.08.2021 the appellant/Insurance company
has now approached this Court with this instant appeal with a prayer to set
aside and quash the said impugned judgment and order.
8.
Heard Mr. A. Khan, learned counsel for the appellant who has
submitted that the grievance of the appellant is with the appreciation of
evidence by the learned Tribunal which has not taken into account that the
liability of the appellant/Insurance Company is subject to the terms and
conditions of the policy and Section 147 and 149(2) of the Motor Vehicle
Act, 1988 not being complied with, the appellant is not liable to
indemnify the owner of the Truck.
9.
The learned counsel has also submitted that the learned Tribunal
has failed to take note of the fact that two vehicles were involved in the
said accident and even on perusal of the evidence of the CW-2, the
Investigating Officer (I/O) who has taken up investigation of the criminal
case registered against the driver of the alleged offending truck, evidence
will reveal that the investigation was not taken up properly inasmuch as
there was no sketch map of the place of occurrence prepared, no
photographs of the accident scene were either taken or brought into
evidence. No independent witnesses were produced to confirm the factum
of accident. Instead the I/O had come to the conclusion that the driver was
the party at fault and has, therefore, filed the charge sheet putting the
blame squarely on the shoulders of the driver, which according to the
learned counsel, this aspect of the matter was not taken into account by
the learned Tribunal in course of the proceedings before it and has
therefore, come to a wrong conclusion as far as fastening of liability is
concerned.
10.
On this point, the learned counsel has also submitted that even
the respondent in her evidence as CW-1 has stated in her examination-inchief that the accident occurred when the offending vehicle came from the
opposite direction and dashed against the vehicle they were travelling in.
In this, the possibility of contributory negligence cannot be ruled out and
as such, attributing rash and negligent driving only against the driver of
the said truck could not have been done so by the learned Tribunal,
submits the learned counsel.
11.
On the evidence adduced by the respondent/claimant before the
Tribunal, as regard the injuries sustained by her as a result of the said
accident, the learned counsel has submitted that she has stated in her
evidence that after the accident she was admitted at Nazareth Hospital
where she was treated for her injuries, however, the Investigator of the
appellant/Insurance company who had visited the said hospital confirmed
that she was never admitted at the said hospital but was treated by one Dr.
S.S. Sondhi at his private clinic at Happy Valley, Shillong for minor
injuries. The learned Tribunal has come to a wrong conclusion that the
injuries sustained by the respondent/claimant are serious in nature.
12.
Even on the issue of income of the respondent/claimant, the
learned counsel has submitted that she has stated in her evidence that she
was in receipt of a monthly net income of ₹ 9000/- (rupees nine thousand)
only and that her annual income comes to ₹ 96,228/- (rupees ninety-six
thousand two hundred twenty-eight) only, however, the salary certificate
purportedly issued by the Principal of the school she was teaching at, was
never produced before the Tribunal in the original. She has further stated
that as a result of the injuries sustained, she had gone on leave from the
school for three months for which she received salary only for one month,
but nothing was brought on record that she had indeed been on leave for
the said three months’ period. While computing income on this count, the
learned Tribunal has come to a wrong conclusion for which the amount
awarded in this regard has to be relooked, further submits the learned
counsel.
13.
However, the main thrust of the argument of the learned counsel
for the appellant/insurance company is on the total quantum of
compensation awarded, particularly the interest factor which, according to
the learned counsel has been calculated without considering the peculiar
facts and circumstances of the case between the parties.
14.
The learned counsel has pointed out that the claim for
compensation has proceeded before the Tribunal for more than 17 years
before the impugned award was passed on 30.07.2021. The learned
Tribunal has also imposed interest @ 9% p.a. w.e.f. 13.02.2004 to
20.11.2020 without taking into account that for 17 long years the delay in
the proceedings was mostly caused by the respondent No. 1/claimant. In
fact, since the inception of the claim application, the evidence of the
parties was closed on 27.05.2008 and after hearing the argument of the
parties, the matter was posted for judgment on 17.06.2008. But before the
judgment was pronounced, the respondent No. 1/claimant has filed an
application seeking to adduce further evidence and also for introduction of
additional documents which was allowed by the learned Tribunal. This
has eventually led to the delay in the proceedings till the matter was
finally disposed of as mentioned.
15.
The learned counsel has submitted that this Court in similar cases
where the rate of interest imposed by the Tribunal was about 9% p.a. or
so, the same was reduced to about 6% p.a. To this extent, if the rate of
interest is reduced, the appellant would not have so much of an opposition
as far as the award is concerned since the fact that the death and injury as
a consequence of the said motor vehicle accident is not disputed. That the
respondent is the legal heir of the deceased victim is also not disputed and
in this regard, even the income of the deceased, who was an income tax
payer during his lifetime and as such income of the victim cannot be
disputed. However, the learned counsel has reiterated that it is only on
account of the imposition of the high rate of interest that there is strong
resistance from the part of the appellant.
16.
Ms. P. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the respondent in
response to the submission of the learned counsel for the appellant has
submitted that the award of compensation awarded by the learned
Tribunal suffers from no infirmity inasmuch as the same has been passed
taking into account all aspect of the case of the respondent/claimant.
17.
On the alleged breach of the policy conditions by the insured, the
learned Tribunal has recorded the admission of the appellant/Insurance
Company that the offending vehicle, being number AS-25-B-2389, was
indeed insured with it and the same was valid on the relevant period, that
is, on the date when the accident occurred.
18.
As to the contention that since two vehicles were involved in the
accident, therefore composite negligence cannot be ruled out, the learned
counsel has submitted that evidence would show that the respondent who
is the eye-witness to the accident has clearly stated that the place of
occurrence was on a blind curve when the said offending vehicle came in
a rash and negligent manner overtaking another vehicle as a result of
which the said accident occurred. This only goes to prove that the fault
lies with the driver of the said offending vehicle and not the deceased
husband of the respondent/claimant.
19.
On delay in the proceedings before the Tribunal, which according
to the appellant has resulted in a higher quantum of compensation
awarded to the respondent/ claimant, particularly the alleged imposition of
a high rate of interest which is not well founded under the facts and
circumstances of the case where the cause of delay is attributed to the
respondent/claimant, the learned counsel has submitted that a perusal of
the order sheet will reveal that the alleged delay was caused not only on
the part of the claimant, but also on the part of the opposite
party/Insurance Company. However, taking into consideration the cost of
living and the declining rate of purchasing power, the award as was
passed is reasonable and cannot be faulted. The award of compensation as
well as the interest imposed thereto is therefore, reasonable and the same
may not be interfered with by this Court, further submits the learned
counsel.
20.
With no further argument advanced by the parties, this Court has
duly considered the submission and contention made herein and has also
perused the impugned judgment and award. The evidence adduced by all
the witnesses before the learned Tribunal was also scrutinized to ensure
that proper appreciation of the same has been undertaken by the learned
Tribunal to come to the conclusion it did.
21.
From the materials on record, that there had occurred a motor
vehicle accident on 02.05.2003 at a place called Pahamrioh, on the GS
Road at about 9.00 a.m. or so is not disputed. That in the said accident,
two vehicles were involved, one being a Maruti Van number MH-04-BD7260 driven by the deceased husband of the respondent/claimant and the
other being a truck number AS-25-B-5389 driven by Shri. Babul Boro is
also not disputed.
22.
As a result of such accident, the occupants of the Maruti Van
including the deceased husband of the respondent, herself and other
passengers sustained injuries, serious and grave injuries being sustained
by the deceased husband of the respondent for which he eventually
succumbed to the same and also injuries sustained by the respondent are
also evident.
23.
On the death of her husband and for the injuries sustained by her,
the respondent has filed two separate claim applications before the Motor
Vehicle Claims Tribunal (MACT), Shillong seeking compensation as
claimed therein. However, since both the applications were taken up
together, the cause of action having arisen out of the said singular motor
vehicle accident, common evidence was accordingly adduced.
24.
That the said offending vehicle was duly insured with the
appellant/Insurance Company and was valid at the relevant date of the
accident, has also been proved with no contradiction to such fact, the
liability of the appellant/Insurance Company to indemnify the owner of
the said truck No. AS-25-B-5389 has accordingly been established.
Therefore, the provisions of Section 147 and 149(2) of the MV Act, 1988
have not been violated.
25.
The issue of contributory negligence as far as the action of the
deceased husband of the respondent is concerned is also not a relevant
issue to be considered as evidence has revealed that the accident took
place at a blind curve of the road and the driver of the offending truck was
proceeding at a very high speed and also overtaking another vehicle at
that point of time. Negligence can therefore, be imputed on the action of
the said driver of the said truck.
26.
However, on the contention of the appellant that the learned
Tribunal has come to a wrong finding as to the award of compensation for
the injuries sustained by the respondent/claimant, that is, when a sum of ₹
1,06,228/- (rupees one lakh six thousand two hundred twenty eight) only
was awarded, a perusal of the impugned judgment in this respect would
show that the learned Tribunal has computed the amount, taking into
consideration the annual net salary of the respondent/claimant calculated
at ₹ 9000/- (rupees nine thousand) only per month and an annual salary of
₹ 96,228/- (rupees ninety six thousand two hundred twenty eight) only
and has taken the sum of ₹ 96,228/- (rupees ninety six thousand two
hundred twenty eight) only as well as the actual medical expenses which
amounts to ₹ 10,000/- (rupees ten thousand) only.
27.
This method of computation is not proper as there is no record of
how the pecuniary and non-pecuniary loss has been assessed. In fact, the
learned Tribunal has not even come to any conclusion as to whether the
injuries sustained by the respondent/claimant have resulted in permanent
or partial disability. Be that as it may, it appears that only pecuniary loss
was considered inasmuch as the actual medical expenses was
acknowledged, which comes to ₹ 10,000/- (rupees ten thousand) only and
under non-pecuniary loss, perhaps loss of earning capacity or loss of
future income which was invariably linked to the income derived from the
salary of the respondent/claimant as a school teacher for which the annual
salary of ₹ 96,228/- (rupees ninety six thousand two hundred twenty
eight) only was computed. According to the finding of the learned
Tribunal, the respondent/claimant was absent from school only for one
month or at best only for three months which means that she has joined
her duty soon after.
28.
In all probability, the computation of the compensation on
account of the injuries sustained by the respondent/claimant could be in
this manner, ₹ 10,000/- (rupees ten thousand) only for actual medical
expenses and for non-pecuniary loss for loss of earning capacity, the
amount of ₹ 9000/- x 3 = ₹ 27,000/- (rupees twenty seven thousand) only
that is, the monthly salary multiply by the three month’s period of absence
from the school. The total award under this head will then come to ₹
37,000/- (rupees thirty seven thousand) only. As to the computation of
income of the deceased husband of the respondent/claimant, the appellant
has no quarrel with the amount computed by the learned Tribunal, the
same will therefore, be maintained.
29.
On the issue of delay of the proceedings before the Tribunal,
which according to the learned counsel for the appellant is linked to the
award of interest covering all those years taken up for disposal of the
claim application, the submission of the appellant for reduction of the
amount of interest has to be looked into keeping in mind the provision of
Section 171 of the MV Act, 1988.
30.
Section 171 of the Motor Vehicles Act reads as follows:
“171. Award of Interest where any claim is allowed.– Where
any Claims Tribunal allows a claim for compensation made
under this Act, such Tribunal may direct that in addition to the
amount of compensation simple interest shall also be paid at
such rate and from such date not earlier than the date of making
the claim as it may specify in this behalf.”
31.
In the case of Abati Bezbarauh v. Dy. Director General,
Geological Survey of India & Anr., (2003) 3 SCC, 148, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has spelt out the principle as regard imposition or award
of interest in motor accident cases, the relevant paragraphs of the same,
reproduced herein would also be the guiding factor for this Court to
decide on this issue, the same reads as:
“6. The question as to what should be the rate of interest, in the
opinion of this Court, would depend upon the facts and
circumstances of each case. Award of interest would normally
depend upon the bank rate prevailing at the relevant time.
18. Three decisions were cited before us by Mr. A.P. Mohanty,
learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant, in support
of his contentions. No ratio has been laid down in any of the
decisions in regard to the rate of interest and the rate of interest
was awarded on the amount of compensation as a matter of
judicial discretion. The rate of interest must be just and
reasonable depending upon the facts and circumstances of each
case and taking all relevant factors including inflation, change of
economy, policy being adopted by Reserve Bank of India from
time to time, how long the case is pending, permanent injuries
suffered by the victim, enormity of suffering, loss of future
income, loss of enjoyment of life etc., into consideration. No rate
of interest is fixed under Section 171 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988. Varying rates of interest are being awarded by Tribunals,
High Courts and the Supreme Court. Interest can be granted
even if a claimant does not specifically plead for the same as it is
consequential in the eye of law. Interest is compensation for
forbearance or detention of money and that interest being
awarded to a party only for being kept out of the money which
ought to have been paid to him. No principle could be deduced
nor can any rate of interest be fixed to have a general application
in motor accident claim cases having regard to the nature of
provision under Section 171 giving discretion to the Tribunal in
such matter. In other matters, awarding of interest depends upon
the statutory provisions, mercantile usage and doctrine of equity.
Neither Section 34 CPC nor Section 4-A(3) of the Workmen’s
Compensation Act are applicable in the matter of fixing rate of
interest in a claim under the Motor Vehicles Act. The courts have
awarded the interest at different rates depending upon the facts
and circumstances of each case. Therefore, in my opinion, there
cannot be any hard-and-fast rule in awarding interest and the
award of interest is solely on the discretion of the Tribunal or the
High Court as indicated above.”
32.
Considering the prevailing situation, the rate of inflation and cost
of living index, coupled with the fact that a look at the records of the
proceedings before the Tribunal where delay can be attributed not only to
the respondent/claimant but also to the appellant/Insurance Company, this
Court is of the considered opinion that the rate of interest which is found
reasonable would be 6% p.a. and not 9% p.a. as was imposed by the
learned Tribunal.
33.
Accordingly, these two sets of appeals are hereby disposed of in
the manner as indicated hereinabove, with the award to be paid to the
respondent/claimant within 2 months from today together with interest
@6% p.a. from the date of fling of the claim application till realization of
the same.
34.
The respondent/claimant is also entitled to receive the amount
already deposited by the appellant before this Registry which will be
adjusted with the total amount to be paid to her. Also, any interim relief
received by the respondent/claimant is required to be deducted from the
total amount due and payable to her.
35.
Registry to send back the trial court case records.
36.
Appeals disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
19.12.2023
“Tiprilynti–PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review