Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[ 34881
THURSDAY, THE TWELFTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRIAPARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
WRIT PETITION NO: 35872 OF 2025
Between:
M/s. Open Text Technologies Pvt. Ltd., (Formerly Known.as M_/9 VigneJtg
Softwaie Development lnd-ia Pvt. Ltd.), Unit No. 304, Building No. 14, -3rd
Floor Mindspacd, tt Park, Madhapur, Hyderabad, Telangana - 50008'l
Represented by its Authorized Signatory Mr. Amit Mangal
...'ET'T'ONER
AND
'l
. The Commissioner, Office of the Commissioner of Customs and GST,
Hyderabad Audill Commissionerate, H.No.3-4-1 18/1 NR, lstfloor, Elegant
M'aharaja, Ramanthapur, Hyderabad - 500013 Email. cgst.hydluditl@gov.in, .
2. The Coinmissioner, Office <if the Commissioner of Cential Tax Rangareddy
GST Commissionerate Posneft Bhavan, Tilak Road Ramkote, Hyderabad 500001.
3. The Superintendent, Office of the Superintendent of Central Tax Madhapur
GST Range, H No. 10-3-301 to 303, 4th Floor, Serene Heights, Humayun
Naoar. Masab Tank. Hvderabad - 500028.
4. Th; Superintendent, Oifice of the Superintendent of Central Tax, Kondapur
GST Range, H.No.10-3-301 to 303,4th Floor, Serene Heights, Humayun
Nagar, Masab Tank, Hyderabad - 500028.
5. De[uty Commissioner,-Gachibowli GST Division,4th Floor, H No. 10-3-301 to
303, Serene Heights, Masab Tank, Hyderabad - 500028.
6. Development Co-mmissioner, Madhafur SEZ, 6Q3, Cyber Towers, Hitec City,
Madhapur, Hyderabad.
7. The Uriion of-lndia, Ministry of Finance, North Block, New Delhi - 1 10 001 '
Rep by its
secretary
...RES'.NDENT'
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, Order or Direction, more particularly in the nature of a Writ
of Certiorari quashing the order passed by Respondent No.1 bearing Ref No. OR'
No.12312O21 ADJN(Commr) ST and DIN- 20250856YR000000DODE dated
21nal2125 under section 73 of the Finance Act, 1994 for the tax period 2016- 17
and 2017-18 (upto June 2017) passed in the case of the Petitioner (Exhibit - Pl)
and also the Show Cause Notice .(SCN)' issued by the Respondent No.1 bear,
Or. No. 12312021 - ADJN (COMMR) ST, DlN. 20211056YQ000082348C dated
2211012021 (Exlribit - P3) under section 73 of the Finance Act, 1994 for the tax
petiod2016-17 and2017-18 (upto June 2017).
lA NO: 1 OF 20:!5
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
dispense with the requirement of filing certified copies of the order passed by
Respondent No 1 bearing Ref. No. OR. No.123/2021 ADJN(Commr) ST and DIN20250856YR000000DODE dated 2110812025 under section 73 of the Finance Act,
1994 for the tax period 2016- 17 and 2017-18 upto June 2017) passed in the case
of the Petitioner (Exhibit - Pl) and also the Show Cause Notice ("SCN") issued by
the Respondenl No.1 bearing Or. No. 12312021 - ADJN (COMMR) ST, DlN.
20211056YQ000082348C dated 2211012021 (Exhibit - P3) under section 73 of the
Finance Act, 1994 for the tax period 2016-17 and 2017-18 (upto June 2017).
lA NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filecl in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay
all further proceeding, lncluding penalty and recovery proceedings, arising out of
and being consequential to order passed by the Respondent No.1 bearing Ref No.
OR. N0.123l20i:1 ADJ (Commr) ST and DIN- 20250856YR000000DODE dated
2110812025 undr:r section 73 of the Finance Act, 1994 for the tax Period 2016-17
and2017-18 (upto June 2017).
Counsel for the Petitioner: Ms. LAKSHMI MENON FOR
SRI KAILASH NATH P.S.S
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.{ TO 5: SRI DOMINIC FERNANDES, senior
standing counsel for CBIC
Counsel for the Respondent No.7: SRI N.BHUJANGA RAO, DEPUW
Counsel for the Respondent No.6:
-
SOLICITOR GENERAL OF INDIA
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRT APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTTCE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
WRIT PETITION No. 35872 of 2025
DATED : 12.03.2026
Between
M/s. Open Text Technologies Pvt., Ltd.
R"p., by its Authorized Siognatory Mr. Amit Mangal,
Hyderabad.
Petitioner
AND
The Commissioner,
Office of the Commissioner of Customs and GST,
Hyderabad and 6 others.
. Respondents
ORDER:
Ms. Lakshmi Menon, learned counsel represents Mr. Kailash Nath
P.S.S., learned counsel for the petitioner
Mr. Dominic Fernandes, learned Senior Standing Counsel for Central
Board of Indirect Taxes and Custorns (CBIC) appears for respondent Nos.l to
2.
The petitioner was previously known as lWs. Vignette Softrvare
Developrnent [ndia Private Limited. The change of name in the office of
Registrar of Companies took place vide Certificate dated 22.04.2010. The
petitioner preferred writ petition against order-in-original No.6/2022-23,
t
dated 24.03 2023 relating to the period 2016-17 and 2Ol1-18 (up to June,
Z0l7) inter alia taking a number of, grounds including that the petitioner
company wirs earlier known as M/s. Vignette Software Developrnent India
Private Limjted lnd the shorv cause notice issued to the said company cannot
not be pres5ed into service in the present colnpany. Petitioner also took a
ground that it fatls within the special econotnic zone.
3.
The Coordinate Bench of this Court upon hearing the parties was
pleased to ;et aside the order-in-original dated 24.03.2023 and remit the
matter to thr: salne authority with liberty to the petitioner to f,rle its additional
reply withir 15 days and produce true copy/certified copy of the certificate
issued by ttre Registrar of Companies regarding the change of name before
such authority. The competent authority rvas directed to grant personal
hearing befcrre passing fresh order-in-original in accordance with law.
4.
The ltresent rvrit petition seeks to challenge the fresh order-in-original
dated 21.08.2025 issued under Section 73 of the Central Goods and Services
Tax Act, 2017 for the tax period 2016-17 and 2017 -18 (up to June, 2017) and
also the show cause notice dated 22.10.2021 which rvas the subject matter of
the earlier llroceedings as well. On this aspect, the petitioner contends that
despite sublnission of a detailed representation to respondent No.1 authority,
including ['roof of change of natne, respondent No. I has made certain
observations to the effect that despite the name change, it was the obligation
of the petitioner to bring to the attention of the service tax authorities the
details of the name change under the registration number ending 002.
Respondent No.1 passed the impugned order levying service tax coupled with
interest and penalty on the petitioner company once again.
5.
It is the case of the petitioner that since it is engaged in export of
service and not liable to pay service tax on such services, respondent No.l
ought not to have levied sen,ice tax on them. Petitioner has referred to the
Special F.conomic Zones Act, 2005 and the Special Economic Zones Rules,
2006 framed thereunder demarcating the area of land to be designated as a
Special Economic Zone. The objects of Special Economic Zone (SEZ)
includes promotion of goods and services leading to enhanced economic
activities, investment promotion, development of infrastructure, creation of
ernployment opportunities etc., and the thumb rule in respect of taxation of
exports as always been "to export goods, not taxes". Petitioner has also taken
the plea that the intention of creating such SEZ is to give exemption from levy
of all duties and taxes. The department ought not to have confirmed the
demand against the petitioner on account of mere technical aspect such as
chalge of name. It is further submitted that Form ST-03 returns filed by the
Cornpany clearly shows the gross amounts charged towards the export of the
lnformation Technology Services. The reconciliation of the income declared
in Form ST-03 return, vis-d-vis financial statements submitted to respondent
No.2 vide response letter dated 28.04.2021also makes it clear that petitioner
has no other business income and all the income contained therein only
pertain to t:xport of services which are exempted from service tax. Petitioner
was not allowed to rely upon ST-03 returns during the proceedings because
returns were filed in the name of Open Text Technologies India Private
Limited, vrhereas the proceedings were initiated in the natne of Vignette
Softrvare l)evelopment lndia Private Limited. Such an approach of the
Commissioner was therefore bereft of any logic and catrnot be sustained in the
eye of law. Petitioner has contended that since the demand of tax is without
jurisdictiorr, the writ petition is maintainable. Respondents have identified the
service tar: registration number incorrectly and consequently subjected the
petitioner to service tax obligations twice. Petitioncr has been registered
under the Sen,ice Tax vide registration No.AABCV996lDST00l and has
been regular in filing returns and payment of taxes since inception through
this number only.
6.
Leamed counsel for the petitioner submits that the adjudicating
authority has not applied its mind independently which renders the impugned
order unsur;tainable in law. It is further argued that service tax demand cannot
be solely t,ased on income tax returns. The demand has been raised beyond
the time stipulated.
7.
On the part of the respondent department, learned Senior Standing
Counsel for CBIC submits that the petitioner having obtained the second
service tax registration for a
different premises bearing
No. AADOV9961GST002 failed to amend or update its second registration
I
--'
after the name change resulting in inconsistencies in statutory filings and
departmental records. Based on the petitioner's income tax returns, financial
statements and third party information, the respondents detected undeclared
taxable income relatable to the second registration for rvhich no service tax
returns were filed. Therefbre, a detailed show cause notice was issued and
personal hearing was granted before passing a reasoned order-in-original
confirming the tax interest and penalty. Respondents contend that the SEZ
exemption is conditional, and non-filing of returns amounted to wilful
suppression which is the basis for invocation of the extended period of
limitation. Respondents have also taken a plea that petitioner had statutory
appellate remedy under the Finance Act, 1994. The proceedings have been
conducted after multiple personal hearin_qs.
8.
Learned Senior Standing Counsel for CBIC submits that exemptions
claimed by the petitioner have to be proved on the basis of documents strictly
as per the exemption notifications. He, however, submits that if the matter is
remanded to the adjudicating authority proceedings would be conducted by
\
the Assessing Officer as relatable to the transactions conducted under the first
registration claimed by the petitioner, however, subject to the petitioner
cancelling his second registration in accordance with the relevant provisions
of the Act and the Rules. It seems that the claim of the petitioner also relates
\-*
to the transactions conducted in SEZ concerning exports under the first
registration obtained by it. In that event, the imposition of liability as against
&:-
the petitioner under the second registration would not stand in the eye of law
The impugned order is therefore set aside. However, it is for the petitioner to
place relevant materials once again before the Assessirtg Officer to justifii its
clairn of Nil liability in lieu of exports made rvithin the SEZ under the first
registration. In order to do so, the petitioner should also take steps for
cancellation of' the second registration, otherwise, the same result would
probably once again entail.
9.
The rvrit petition is therefore disposed of by setting aside the impugned
order with a rernand to the adjudicating authority to pass a fresh order after
considering the materials placed by the petitioner in that regard as observed
hereinabovr: and also on cancellation of the second registration. Petitioner
should take steps for cancellation of its second registration bearing
No.AADC\19961DST002 within a strict time frame of four weeks from today
so that the adjudication proceedings can be concluded within a reasonable
tirne preferably within eight weeks thereafter. No order as to costs.
Miscellaneous applications, if any pending, shall stand closed.
SD/.M. OSMAN ALI BAIG
STANT REGISTRAR
,/TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To
1. The Cornmissioner, Office of the Commissioner
ustoms and GST,
, 1st Floor, Elegant
hydauditl@gov.in,
Tax Rangareddy
GST Commissionerate Posnett Bhavan, Tilak Road Ramkote, Hyderabad 500001.
3. The Suprerintendent, Office of the Superintendent of Central Tax Madhapur
GST Range, H No. 10-3-301 to 303, 4th Floor, Serene Heights, Humayun
Nagar, lilasab Tank, Hyderabad - 500028.
4. The Suprerintendent, Office of the Superintendent of CentralTax, Kondapur
GST Range, H.No.10-3-301 to 303, 4th Floor, Serene Heights, Humayun
Nagar, llasab Tank, Hyderabad - 500028.
5. Deputy tlommissioner, Gachibowli GST Division, 4th Floor, H No. 10-3-301 to
303, Serene Heights, Masab Tank, Hydqrabad - 500028.
6. Development commissioner, Madhapur sEZ, 6e3, cyber Towers, Hitec city,
Madhapur, Hyderabad.
7. TF 9^"pr"tary, Union of lndia, tr/inistry of Finance, North Block, New Delhi 110001,
8. One CC to SRI KAILASH NATH p.S.S, Advocate tOpUCl
9. one cc to sRl DoMlNlc FERNANDES, senior st'anding'counselfor CBIC
loPUcl
10.one cc to sRl N.BHUJANGA RAo, DEpury soltctroR GENERAL oF
tNDtA [OPUC]
I I. Two CD Copies
PSK.,
.BS
w
I
t
I
HIGH COURT
DATED:1 210312026
\
ORDER
WP.No.35872 ot 2025
t
o
I
0g
*
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUTCOSTS
p ..q(&
ftft'
't HE SI4
pnrcH
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review