Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3300 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE TWENTY FOURTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO: 27409 OF 2025
Between:
M/s. Omics lnternatioral Pvt. Ltd., Registered Office at '1-90, Plot Nos.20 and 21,
Kavuri.Hills, Hi-Tech C1ty, Hyd.grabad - 500 081, Rgp.by its Auihorized Signatory anri
Administrative Asst., Rohan Kumar Peerukafla sio. P.v.prabhakar R5o, Agie 30
years, R/o.Hyderabad.
..PETITIONER
AND
1. Union of lndia, Rep.by its Under Secretary, Ministry of Commerce and
lndu_stry, Department of commerce, sEZ section, vanijya Bhavan, New Delhi
- 110 001
2. The Board of {ppqovals, Ministry of Commerce and lndustry, Department of
Commerce, SEZ Section, Vanijya Bhavan, New Delhi- 110001.'
3. Jlg-Development Commissioner, Visakhapatnam Special Economic Zone
(vsEz), 8th floor, Parishrama Bhavan, Baiheerbagh, Hyderabad - 500 004.
4. M/s Phoenix Living Spaces Pvt. Ltd., Rep by its Director, yS Viveka
F_nclave,2nd-Floor, Unir No.201 and 2O2Piot No.21-23, Sy No. {
Khajaguda, Hyderabad 500032.
(R4 is impleaded as per Court Order dated 09.10.2025 in l.A.No.2l2D25l
.....RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ or order or direction, more particularly one in nature of
Writ of Mandamus to declare the decision of the 2nd Respondent to de-notify the
entire SEZ area of 4.05 hectares in Sy.No.343 of Ameenpur Village, Patancheru
Mandal, Sanga Reddy District in its 130th Meeting, dt.1&.Ol.ZO2S as
communicated by the 1st Respondent vide letter, dI.O4.OB.ZOZS, is
unconstitutional and arbitrary and ti set aside the same and to direct the
Respondents 1 to 3 to recognize the petitioner as developer of the SEZ in
Sy.No.343 of Ameenpur Village, Patancheru Mandal, Sanga Reddy District in the
place of M s.Phoenix Living Spaces Pvt. Ltd., as Telangana State Government
gave approval in favor of the petitioner wide it's letter dated 06.02.2025.
I.ANO:1 OIF 2025
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affid,avit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the decision of the 2nd Respondent to de-notify the entire SEZ area of
4.05 hecta.es in Sy.No.34318,343tg of Ameenpur Village, Patancheru Mandal,
Sanga Recldy District in its 130th Meeting, dt.18.07.2025 as communicated by
the 1st Respondent vide letter, dt.04.08.2025, pending disposal of the main writ
petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI VEDULA SRINIVAS, REPRESENTING
SRI VEDULA CHITRALEKHA
Counsel fo,r the Respondent Nos.1 to 3 : SRIV.T.KALYAN (SC FOR CENTRAL
GOVT)
Counsel fc,r the lmplead Respondent No.4 : SRI P.PAVAN KUMAR RAO
The Court made the following ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAI{A
2+.O2.20.26
Between:
M/s Omics International Rrt. Ltd.,
Rep. by its Authorised Signatory & Administrative Asst.,
Rohan Kumar Peerukatla
..... Petitioner
And
Union of India,
Rep. by its Under Secretary,
Ministry of Commerce and Industry,
Department of Commerce, SEZ Section,
Vanijya Bhavan, New Delhi
And others
.. Respondents
ORDER:
Petitioner is a Private Limited Company stated to be
a major Open Access Publisher and international conference
organizer. M/s Phoenix Living Spaces Rrt. Ltd. applied for
approval to set up a sector specific SEZ for IT/ITES at
Ameenpur Village, Patancheru Mandal, Medak District. After
processing, the l"t Respondent issued formal approval dated
07.L2.2O16 pursuant to Application dated 25.05.2016.
Petitioner applied on O4.O3.2O17 to be approved as Co-
Developer in the said SEZ and the l"t Respondent approved the
same uide letter dated 3L.O3.2O17 , thereby recognizing
petitio:eer as Co-Developer. Petitioner is stated to have
purchzrsed Acs.l3.OO of land from M/s Phoenix Living Spaces
Pvt. LtC. in Sy.Nos. 34319,343/8 and 343/13 at Rs.S Crore per
acre. ()ut of this, Acs.4.O0 was non-SEZ land and Acs.9.00 was
SEZ land. Additionally, Acs.2.00 were designated for road
access, reflected in registered sale deeds and Co-developer
agreerrrents, at cost of Rs.12 Crore. On 12.OT.2OLT, the
developer notified Rs.5 crore per acre towards Acs.2.oo road
access land and petitioner paid accordingly. The lands were
allocatr:d for development of IT/ITES SEZ and non-SEZ.
1.1.
In 20 18, it is stated, petitioner was presented with
an opportunity by Software Technologr Parks of India (srpl) to
generate 6000 emplo5rment through establishment of 199g seats
under India BPo business promotion scheme. To secure the
venturr: at Ameenpur, petitioner deposited Rs.1.1 crore with
STPI and furnished bank guarantee of Rs.2 crore. The Ministry
of IT&c, Government of Telangana, addressed letter dated
24.o9-2',ol8 to TSIIC allotting Acs.10.0o of land adjacent to
IT/ITEIi sEZ towards non-SEZ purposes for creating 6000 jobs,
.l
which was confirmed by TSIIC as part of Writ Petition No.13476
of 2024 before this Court.
1.2.
The Ministry of i'f&C, Government of Telangana,
addressed letter dated O2.A8.2O24 to TSIIC and HMDA to
authorize petitioner to unclert.ake necessary road maintenance
and beautification in the SEZ area. TSIIC addressed letter dated
27.09.2024 to petitioner regarding request for laying 30 meter
approach road for entry and exit to plots in Sy.No.343,
a
i
i
Ameenpur, agreeing to remove clebris for laying the road. HMDA
:
:
;
I
I
addressed letter dated 27.11.2024 granting permission to
,:
t
t
!
Iu
I
t
undertake 3O meter road repair u,orks at Sy.No.343, Ameenpur,
Sanga Reddy District. Further, the Ministry of IT&C,
$
f
r
.
x
fi
i!
.:
Government of Telangana, uide letter dated 06.O2.2025
addressed to various Governtnent agencies, requested prompt
I
!
processing and approvai o{' ali pending or future applications
related to the IT/ITES SEZ at Ameenpur u'ithin 30 days,
indicating priority for clevelopment aimed at providing nearly
6000 jobs.
1.3.
M/s Phoenix Living Spaces Pvt. Ltd. addressed
Ietter dated 3O.O1.2023 to the 3'd Respondent expressing
decision to quit the SEZ project at Ameenpur and suggesting
conversion of petitioncr from co-Developer to Developer.
petition':r :rddressecl various lettcrs r-o Respondents
seeking rec'gnition as Deveroper of IT/rrES sEZ
The
1 to 3
in S-r,..Nos.
343/8 rrnd 343/9 of Ameenpur Vilrage. The 3.d Respondent
addressed letrer dated 1o.03.2025 ro the Devr:roper
subseqrLently, letter dated rr.o4.2025 to petitioner-
stating that
dues of Rs.3 r,sg,ogz /- were pencling from the Developer
unless r.he same were paid, petitioner,s request could
conside.ed. The Deveroper paid the said amount
and
and
not be
on o2.o6.2o2s
and informed the 3.cr Respondent.
1.4-
Petitioner contends that in vierv of section 1o
of the
special Economic Zones Act, 20os (for short, .the
Act),
Respondents I and 2 ought t. rra'e accepted the
request for
conversl,ln
from Co-Developer tt; Developer, &s petitioner
purchas,:d
the SEZ land, was already recognized as Co_
Develope.r
tid"e letter dated 31.03.2012,
Develope r
expressed intention to quit and recommendecl
petrtioner. It is alreged that stat.utory
"rd frFffii.,uf
scheme contemplates
suspension and transfer of letter of approval
rather than de_
notification of sEZ. However, the 2rd Respondent
Meeting rlated r1.oz.2a25 decided to de-notify
in its 130th
the entire SEZ in
g
sy.Nos.343/8 and 3431g, Afireenpur village, without recording
reasons and without informing petitioner and communicated
the said decision to authorities concerned uid"e letter dated
04.08.2025.
1.5.
Petitioner asserLs that under section 2(g), Developer
includes Co-Developer' and they were recognized as CoDeveloper; they purchased strz and adjacent non-sDz land;
secured STPI approval; receivccl support and directions from
Government of Telangana including letter dated 06.02.2025;
and there is no provision in the Act to de-notify a sEZ except
suspension under section 10. It is alleged that no notice was
I
i
given to petitioner though it is recogniz.ed under the Act. [t is
!
I
I
alteged that the decision ol Responclents 1 and 2 to de-notify the
entire SEZ in Sy.Nos.343/8 and 34319 of Ameenpur Village, is
illegal, arbitrary, contrary to the 2oo5 Act and violative of
principles of natural justice. It is further alleged that the
decision Causes irreparable loss as petitioner invested crores of
rupees for development of Acs.25.O0 of IT/ITES/Residential
projects in Sy.No.343 of Ameenputr Village, obtained necessary
permissions from State Government and agencies, and acted
based op letter dated 06.A2.2025 of Government of Telangana'
I
I
I
i
I
l
j,
t,
l,
I
i
i
I
i
!
i
i
I
(r
2.
This Court by order dated 23.10.2025, granted
interim suspension olAgerncla I'.r:;:: No. 130.13 of the Minutes of
the 13otr, Meeting o[ thc Boarci of Approval for SEZs. held on
18.07.2',025.
3.
The case of Responclents 1 to 3 as put forward in
their count.er is that M/s Phoenix Living Spaces Pvt. Ltd. was
issued formal approval for setting up a sector specific SEZ for
IT/lTEIl at Sy. Nos. 348 /8, 34819 and 348/ 12, communicated
uide Depar-tment of Commercr:. letter clated 07.12.2016. The
approvll ol' the Boarcl of Approvals approving petitioner as CoDevelo;rcr in the said SE,Z $.,iis comrnunicated uide F.No.
l/L7 lr,.ol6-sqz clated 3i.03.2O17. The SEZ of M/s phoenix
Living Spaces Pvt. Ltci. was notifieci by the Government of India
uide Girzette Notification S.O. No. Zl7S(El dated O5.O7.2OlT.
3. 1.
It is further stated, formal approval dated
07.12.'.lOL6 hercl a r.alidity period of three years up to
06.12.2,019 as per Conclition No. I(IIIXLX) of Formal Approval
letter clated 07.1'2.2a16, rvhich stipulated that approval is valid
for thr:e years within n,hich the Developer shall implement the
project and submit project irnplenrentation progress report to
GoverrLment of tndia every six months. condition No. I(lll)(xvii)
re
,4,
.t: /
f
t'
stipulated that normally no extension of validity period of three
years will be considered and request for extension, if any, must
be submitted to the Go,u,ernuent six months before expiry of
approval period for consideration by the Board on merits.
3.2.
[t is stated, Developer did not implement the project
within the validity period of tlrree years as per condition No.
I(lllXix) and did not submit any request to the Government six
months prior to expiry of the approval period as required under
condition No. I(lll)(xvii). The Developer also did not submit any
:
Bond-cum-Legal undertaking as required under Rule 22 of the
SEZ Rules, 2oo6 and as mandated under condition No. I(ilI)(ii)
of the Formal Approval. F'urther, no project implementation
I
progress report was submitted every six months as required
under condition No. I(III)(ix). conseeuently, the validity of Letter
of Approval dated 07.12.2016 expired on O6. L2.2Olg.
3.3.
M/s Phoenix Living Spaces Pvt. Ltd. uid.e letter
dated I 1. I 1 .2a19 applied for full de-norification of their SEZ
along with 'No objection certilicate' from the co-Developer -
petitioner, thereafter, the state Government of Telangana
provided 'NOC' for futl de-notification uid.e letter dated
\y/
i
N
i,
i
I
i
I
?:.
18.01.2,O2O received on 22.01.2L12O. Developer was advised to
pay Cc,st Recovery Charges fronr 2Oi7-18 to 2Ol9-2O (up to
February, 2O2Ol amounting to Rs. i3,48,805 l- uide VSEZ letter
dated Ii1.10.2019. 'I'hc said amouir!- rvas paid by the Developer
only orr O5.O3.2O20 ancl subsequently, Developer u,as issued
letter <lated 29-12.202A direct.ing payment of Cost Recovery
Charges for 2O2O-21 amounting to Rs. i2,5O,22O/-. Reminder-1
was isriued uide VSEZ letter datecl L2.O4.2O21 for payment of
the sairl amount r,vhich remained pencling.
3.4.
While the process of de-notification was under
considr:ration, the Developer iltcl.e letter dated 3O.O I .2023
requesl-ed for change of Co-Devcic'per status of petitioner to
Develolrer stattts. This request t:..;ulcl not be processed as the
validity of formal approval herd already expired on 06.12.2019
and no request for extension o[ r,alidity had been made six
monthr; prior to expirry as rc:quired under Condition No.
I(lll)(xvLi). Further, Derreloper wais again requested to pay Cost
Recoveqr Charges for the periocl 2O2O-21 to 2022-23 uideVSEZ
letters ,Cated 06.06.2024 and 02.0 L.2025.
J
/
/
3.5.
It is stated tirat the Developer subsequently uide
letter dated 2O.O2.2O25 recluested for extension of validity of
flormal approval. Hor,vevcr, since Cost Recovery Charges to the
tune o[ Rs. 31,5g,O871- were pending, the request could not be
processed and several reminclers were issued for payment of
dues and Developer ultimately, paid the pending dues on
02.06.2025. White the request for extension of validity was
under process, Developer ttirleletter dated O2.A7.2025 requested
cancellartion of its earlier Application dated 2O-O2.2O25 for
extension of validity and instead sought full de-notification of its
SEZ with expired validit},,- of Formal Approval, duly submitting
all documents requirerl for lull de-notification as per Ministry of
Commerce letter dated L4-O7.2016, citing internal reasons'
3.6.
tt is submitted that the latest request of the
Developer for futl de-notification of sEZ with expired LoA was
processed, and the Board of Approvals in its 13oth meeting held
on L8.O7.2025 approved cancellation of LoA (Formal Approval)
and de-notification of the entire SEZ area of 4'O5 Ha at Sy' Nos'
34318 and 34319 of M/s Phoenix Living Spaces Private Limited,
IT/ITES SDZ, Ameenpur village, Patancheru Mandal, Medak
District, Telangana. The decision was conveyed by Department
' : ':{.\
r,it
':..8
;:
!0
of cornmerce letter dated o4.o9.2o25. It is further stated that
thouge the Developer hacr eaiiier submitted request dated
3o.01 2023 for transfler o[ Devtlol;rr- status to co-Developer,
the sa.me could not be processecl due to expiry of Formal
Approval on 06.12.2019 and non-pa],,ment of cost Recovery
Charges raised uide VSEZ ieftc:rs dated L2.O4.2O21 and
06.06.2024. After pavment o[ cllres on o2.o6.2o2s, the
Develc,per uide letter datecr o2,.{,7.2(y2s r.r,ithdrew the earlier
requesit for transfer and insteacl st;ught full cle-.otifrcation. The
Board of Approvals approved thc request under Rule g of the
SEZ Rules, 2006 during its l3orh meeting held on lg.oz.2o2s
and nrinutes were circulated uide Department of commerce
letter dated 04.08.2o25. It is c.nre nded that petitioner,s
assertron that the facts warranr recognition of petitioner as
Developer is false, baseless and tri-,ter-rable.
3.7 -
It is stated furthcr tirzrt the Board of Approvals,
being a statut.ory authoritv r-:.nsisting o[ multiple members,
after cue deliberations, approvecl ttrc request of the Developer
for carLcellation of LoA and de-notiiication of the entire SEZ
of 4-0[i Ha ar Sy. Nos. 343/B and ?:+3lg of M/s phoenix
area
Living
spaces' Private Limited, IT/rrES sF;Z, Ameenpur village,
and
!l
r;
recorded the same in minutes circulated uide letter
04.08.2025. There is no requirement under the 2005 Act
dated
or sEZ
Rules, 2006 to inform the Ctl.i}eveloper about such decision.
3.8.
The Boarcl of Approvals' after due deliberations'
accepted the request of ttre Developer for de-notification
as the
request met all the requirenients of the Act and Rules'
It is
nstated that the Board is empowered to cotlsider proposals and
approveorrejectthenlarrcltlrzrtitisnotnecessarytorecord
reasons where the proposai meets statutory requirements'
particularlywhenappror,ingthcproposal.Hence,theallegation
that de-notification \rras dotle without recording reasons is
denied as false, baselc-ss ancl untenable. There is no
provision
requiring intimation to the clo-Developer prior to de-notification
and no 'NOC' flrom co-Developer is required for de-notification'
petitioner uid"e e rrlail dated 15..07.2025 indicated that they
would submit fresh application for sEZ approval, however,
since
the Formal Approval expireri on 06'12'2019 and no valid
dated
extension was in frrrce and the extension request
20.O2.2O25 was withclrawn on O2'OT '2025'
the question of fresh
ApplicationbyCo-Developerdoesnotariseinthecontextofthe
expired LoA
:
:
i
!:
I
I
I
:i,I
I
Fi
3.9-
It is stated that Rulc g oi thc 2006 Rules provides
that the central Governinent rna..,.. un rccommendation of the
Board and on Appllcatio* nri.t<,rc l;\, tl-le Developer, modify,
withdr;rw or rescind the notificzrr.it.rii i,[ a slrecial Econo mic zone
if satisfied, and that the Devcrcpci- slrarl submit application for
withdnrwal of notif,rcation in Frirm c6 to the Development
commrssioner concerned as specilicd i' Annexure III who
forwar<l it
shall
to the Lloarrj ..r,ithin fifteen days with
recomrnendations. The request [or. de-noiification was processed
strictly in accordance rvith Rtrle g. Ir: is stated that SEZ project
was n,t commenced and n0 progress n as reported to the
Government of India everv six rrronttrs as required under
condition No. I(ilr)(ix) of Fr:rnrerr Approvar retter dated
07.12.2',016. The De'eloper did n.L submit any tloncl-cum-Legal
Undertreking under Rule 22 to clairn ch-rt1, or tax
benefits;
therefo-:e, the claim of petitioner r-cgarcling i,rrestment
of crores
of rupees for implementation of sEz is denied as false,
baseless
and untenable.
4'
Petitioner filecr repr-v stating that the 4rh
Respondent - M/s phoenix Living spaces pvt.
It
Ltd. could not
u.ilaterally sought cancerrarion/cie-notification
of the sEZ,
l:j
{.<'
as petitioner had already been granted Co-Developer status uide
Proceedings of the 2nd Respondent dated 31.O3.2O17. Under
Section 2(Sl of the '2005 Act, 'Developer' includes a 'CoDeveloper', therefore, petit-ioner has equal statutory status.
Respondents 1 to 3 coulcl trot have acted on the letter dated
1 1. 1 1 .2OL9 of. the
4th Responcie nt ignoring petitioner. The letter
of the State Government dated 18.O1 .2A2O must be read only as
recording the intention of M/s Phoenix Living Spaces Pvt. Ltd. to
exit the SEZ anct cannot jus;iilr, cltr-notification of the entire SEZ
without reference to petitioner.
4.1.
,j
;
!
t.
i
It is denied that cie-notification was in process when
cost recovery dues lvere dt;manded under letters dated
31.1O.2O19, 29.12.2020 and 12.04.2021 issued by the 3'd
Respondent. The letter dated 3O.01 .2023 of the 4tr' Respondent
shows that it sought change o[ petitioner's status to Developer
upon,deciding to quit the SEZ. Petitioner did not give 'Noc' for
cancellation and expresscd its intention to continue aS
Developer. The 4th. Respondent paid Rs.31,59,087 /- as
demanded under letters d:rted 06.06.2024 and O2.O1.2025
through covering letter dated 02.06.2025- lt had also applied
l4
tj'
extensicn of the Letter of Approval in prescribed Form C-L uide
Ietter da.ted 20.O2.2025
4.2.
Respondents 1 to 3 illegally relied upon the letter
dated O2.O7.2025 of the 4rt, Respoirdent to de-notify the SEZ
without issuing notice to petitioncr. Even if the Act and the
Rules do not expressly provide fc;'r uotice to a Co-Developer, any
action having civil corlseqllenc:es must comply with the
Principl,:s of Natural Justice. Rule 8 does not exclude such
notice. lt is alleged that letter dated O2.O7.2025 rvas created to
defeat Jretitioner's interest. petitioner had purchased lands in
Sy.Nos.l)43l9,343l8 and 343112 from the lancl o\vners and the
4th Responclent never ou,ned thcse lar-rds. The counter affidavit
does nr>t deal with the letter clatecl 17.04.2025 of the 3.d
Respon<lent at Page No.160 of rtre Writ Petition, addressed to
petition,:r stating that the request for change of status to
Developer would be processed aftei- approval by the Board of
Appr:ove,l of extension of validit-v of Forinal Approval and after
payment of Rs.31,59,O87 l- by the 4th Respondent. Despite
payment of dues and Application for extension, Respondents 1
to 3 proceeded to de-noti$ the SllZ relving on the letter dated
o2-Q2.2')25.
i5
fi
lria
l
f
*
;
4.3.ItisfurtherColltenrledthatunderSectionloofthe
Act, the Board must act r,r,here the Developer fails to fulfill
.
obligations under ttrr: L'eticr t:f Approval and cannot
straightaway de-notify thc sFlZ w'hen a co-Developer exists
and
seekschangeofstatus.Theirnpugrredde-notificationis
Natural
thereflore, stated to be violative of the Principles of
Justice, contrary to Section 10 of the Act' arbitrary and
unconstitutional, and iiablc to bc quashed with appropriate
directions
5.HeardSriVeclula-{rinivas,learnedSeniorCounsel
assistedbyMs.VedulaChitralekha,learnedcounselfor
petitioner, Sri V'T' Kai5'an' learned Central Government
Standing counsel and sri P. Pavan Kumar, learned counsel
for
Respondent No'4-
6.
Learned Senior Counsel relied on the judgment of
theHon,bleSupremeCourlinCho:ndrashekharSingha.
state of Jharkhandl wherein it '*'as held that the term 'degree'
states that
is defined under Section 2'21.3]tof the UCiC Act' which
the degree, means the 'BachelrJr's degree" 'Master's
degree'and
the .Doctorate degree,. Thus, the same'*,ould include
I
i
I
I
I
i
i
I
i
i
I
I
i
i
t (zozs) 9 scc74o
within its
lb
\
scop(: and ambit ail three, 'Bachelor,s
clegree,, .Master,s degree,
and e 'Doctorate deqree,.
7.
AdmittedlSr, Formal Ap1.ii-oval rjatcd
valid up ro 06-12.2o19. conditir:'r No.
I(III)(ix) crearly sripulated
implementation within three vears and
monthly progress reports. conclitio, No.
request for extension to be made six
Devel<>per did not compry rvith
i
i
:
I
I
:
I(ur)(xvii) required any
these conditions. No materiar is
rvas granted before
o6'L2'2olg- The LoA therefore, stood cxpired
8'
i:
II
t
t
I
I
I
by efflux of time.
Section 10 0f the 2005 Act deals rvith
Letter of Approvar urhere the Deveroper
,
tI
I
submission of six
months prior to expiry.
placecl to show that any exrensior,
j
functi<>ns or violates terms. The
suspension of
fairs [o discharge
said provision operates when a
valid ['etter of Approvar is subsisti.g.
tn the present case, LoA
had already expired on 06.12.2oLg. There
subsisling approvar capable of siisuension
Section l0
OT.12.2016 was
was thus no
or tra'sfer under
Petitioner's reliance orr Section lO
is therefore
mispla,:ed.
9.
Further, Rule g of tlic SEZ Rules,
the ce'tral Government, on recommendation
on Application made by the Deveh)per,
20O6 empowers
of the Board and
to rvithdraw or rescind
t7
ii
notification of a SEZ. Tire record shows that Developer uide
letter dated A2.O7.2025 sought full de-notification after
withdrawing extension request dated '2A.O2.2O25. The Board
considered the request in its l3oth Meeting dated 18.07.2025
and approved cancellation ancl de-notification. The procedure
under Rule 8 read witkr Ministry of Commerce letter dated
L4.47.2016 was followeci. No violation of statutory procedure is
demonstrated.
10.
The contention ol' petitioner that notice to Co-
Developer is mandatory cannol be accepted in the absence of
any provision under the Act and the Rules requiring such
notice. The relationship between Developer and Co-Developer is
contractual and subject to t.he subsistence of valid Letter of
Approval. Once the LoA expirecl on 06.12.20 19 and was not
extended, petitioner cannot ciaim an independent statutory
right for continuation of SEZ status. The definition under
Section 2(g) including Co-Developer does not confer independent
status divorced from a vali<l LoA.
11.
Petitioner's purchase of lands in Sy.Nos.343/9,
34318 and 343113 and investment of amounts, deposit of
Rs.1.1 Crore with STPI ana furnishing of bank guarantee of
itl
a\'.
Rs.2 Crore, and communications da_ted 24.O9.2OL8,
O2.O8.'.2O24, 27.O9.2A24, 2,7.11.21-)24 ancl O6.O2.2025 issued by
State authorities do r-rt>t o'u,crricie the statutory framework
governing validity of LoA. Admi.rristrative support letters of the
state (]overnment cannot extenr{ or revive an expired Formal
Appror,al issued under the 2005 Act.
12.
The Board of Apprcrr.,arls is a statutory authority. Its
decision clated 18.o7.2a25 aJ;proving de-notification upon
requesl of Developer rvith expired LoA cannot be termed
arbitrary when LoA had lapscci orl 06.12.2019, no timety
extension was sought, and Developer ,ultimately, optecl for denotificzr.tion. The allegation that -tetter clated o2.or.2o25 was
createc to defeat petitioner's intert-:st is unsuppor[ed by material
eviden<:e.
13.
This Court, in exercisc of jurisdiction under Article
226 of the Constitution, does not sit in appeal ovei
administrative decisions taken in accordance with statutory
provisions unless thcre is illegalii-v, irrationality or procedural
impropriety. In the present case, the clecision is traceable to
Rule t, of the SEZ Rules, 20A6, and petitioner has not
establis;hed violation of any manclatory provision.
.t'
t9
I
J
L4.
I
t
I
For the aforesaid reasons, this Court holds that the
&
$
decision of the 2"d Respondent in its 130th Meeting dated
I
i
18.07.2025 approving cancellation of Letter of Approval and de-
notilication of 4.05 Ha in Sy.Nos.343/8 and 34319 of Ameenpur
Village, Patancheru Mandal, Sanga Reddy District, as
communicated uide letter dated O4.A8.2O25, is in accordance
with the Act and Rules, and does not suffer from arbitrariness
or violation of principles of natural justice.
Accordingly, the Writ Pe tition is dismissed. No
15.
costs.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
16.
any shall stand closed.
,i
//TRUE COPY//
To
SECTION OFFICER
1. One CC to SRI VEDULA CHITRALEKHA, Ad
2. One CC to SRI V.T.KAL YAN
3. One CC to SRI P.PAVAN KU
4. Two CD Copies
SA
LS
SD/-C. DEEPIKA
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
rI
Advocate IoPUCI
(oPUC)
HIGH COURT
DATED:2410212020
lb,
HE
t I S
o
0 5 t{AR 2!17fi
*
ORDER
WP.No.27409 of 2025
DISMISSING THE W.P
WITHOUT COSTS.
%
*
z
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review