Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
WP No. 35257 of 2024
RESERVED ON 19 AUGUST 2026
TH
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 25TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE K.S. HEMALEKHA
WRIT PETITION NO.35257 OF 2024 (GM-MM_S)
BETWEEN:
Digitally signed
by
MAHALAKSHMI
BM
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka
M/S. NADEEM MINERALS PVT. LTD.,
A COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER
THE COMPANIES ACT, 2013
HAVING ITS OFFICE AT NO. 59,
BKG SAPPHIRE, 4TH FLOOR,
KUMARA PARK WEST,
BANGALORE- 560020
REPRESENTED BY ITS
AUTHORIZED SIGNATORY
MR. M C DINESH, SENIOR MANAGER - ENVIRONMENT
ALSO ITS BRANCH OFFICE AT
NO.125/B, L.B. COLONY, SANDUR,
BALLARI DISTRICT - 583119.
…PETITIONER
(BY MS. MONICA PATIL, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
THE ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY
TO GOVERNMENT, FOREST,
ECOLOGY AND ENVIRONMENT DEPARTMENT,
M.S. BUILDING, BENGALURU - 560 001.
2.
THE PRINCIPAL CHIEF CONSERVATOR OF FOREST (FC)
ARANYA BHAVAN, 18TH CROSS,
MALLESHWARAM,
BANGALORE - 560003.
-2-
WP No. 35257 of 2024
3.
THE DEPUTY CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS
BELLARI DIVISION, BALLARI
RADIO PARK, OPP. ITI COLLEGE,
MINI ZOO COMPOUND,
BALLARI - 583 101.
4.
THE CHIEF CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS
BALLARI CIRCLE,
NEAR MOTHI TALKIES,
BALLARI - 583 101.
5.
THE SECRETARY,
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
MINISTRY OF FOREST,
ENVIRONMENT & CLIMATE CHANGE
PARYAVARAN BHAVAN,
JORBAGH ROAD,
NEW DELHI - 110 003.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. NILOUFER AKBAR, AGA FOR R-1 TO R-4;
SRI. MALLANGOUD, CGSC FOR R-5)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND
227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT,
ORDER OR DIRECTION IN THE NATURE OF CERTIORARI AND
QUASH THE IMPUGNED DEMAND NOTICE DATED SEPTEMBER 26,
2024 BEARING NO. MI/MNG/NADEEM/ML NO.2526/2020-21 ISSUED
BY THE RESPONDENT NO.3 (ANNEXURE-A) AND ETC.
THIS WRIT PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
FOR ORDERS, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY,
ORDERS WAS PRONOUNCED AS UNDER:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU ,CHIEF JUSTICE
and
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE K.S. HEMALEKHA
-3-
WP No. 35257 of 2024
C.A.V. ORDER
(PER: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE K.S. HEMALEKHA)
1.
The petitioner, M/s. Nadeem Minerals Private Limited [M/s.
NM] has filed the present petition calling in question the demand
notice dated 26.09.2024 [impugned notice] issued by the Deputy
Conservator of Forests, respondent No.3, demanding a sum of
`9,76,75,200/- towards Compensatory Afforestation [CA] charges
in respect of 53.20 hectares of forest land, diverted in its favour for
mining of iron ore under Mining Lease No.2526.
2.
M/s. NM has also sought a direction to respondent Nos.1 to 4
to consider its representations dated 28.10.2024 and 06.11.2024
and to extend the validity of the approval granted under Section 2
of the Forest (Conservation)
Act, 1980 [Act], so as to make it
coterminous with the period of the mining lease as extended under
the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957
[MMDR Act].
Brief facts:
3.
The facts giving rise to the petition may be noted in some
detail. The State Government had forwarded a proposal to the
Government of India seeking prior approval under Section 2 of the
-4-
WP No. 35257 of 2024
Act, called as Van (Sanrakshan Evam Samvardhan) Adhiniyam,
1980 for diversion of 53.20 hectares of forest land in Donimalai
Range, Sandur Taluk, Bellary District for mining of iron ore in
favour of the petitioner.
4.
The Government of India, Ministry of Environment and
Forests,
by
its
communication
dated
18/21.03.2005,
after
considering the proposal of the State Government and the
recommendation of the Advisory Committee, conveyed its inprinciple approval for diversion of the aforesaid extent of forest
land.
5.
Pursuant thereto, M/s. NM identified 53.20 hectares in
Survey No.49 of Harvi Village, Hadagali Taluk, Bellary District for
raising
of
CA.
communication
The
dated
Deputy
Conservator
28.04.2005,
reported
of
Forests
by
the
compliance
furnished by the petitioner. The communication records, amongst
other things, the identification of the aforesaid land and deposit of
`28,83,440/- towards the cost of raising and maintenance of CA,
besides payment of Net Present Value [NPV], other stipulated
charges and demarcation of the diverted forest land.
-5-
WP No. 35257 of 2024
6.
Upon receipt of the compliance report, the Government of
India, Ministry of Environment and Forests, by its communication
dated 27/30.05.2005, conveyed approval under Section 2 of the
Act for diversion of 53.20 hectares of forest land for mining of iron
ore in favour of M/s. NM, subject to the conditions stipulated
therein. One of the said conditions continued to require that CA
over an equivalent extent of non-forest land be raised and
maintained at the project cost and that such land be notified as
reserved forest/protected forest.
7.
The State Government thereafter issued the Order dated
08.08.2005
permitting
diversion
subject
to
the
conditions
enumerated therein. In furtherance thereof, M/.s NM executed the
requisite Agreement with the State Government on 28.07.2006 and
mining lease came to be granted in favour of the diverted forest
land.
8.
The difficulty, however, arose with regard to the land in
Survey No.49 of Harvi Village, which had initially been identified for
CA. According to the respondents, though M/s. NM had deposited
the CA charges in the year 2005, the said land could not ultimately
be transferred and mutated in favour of the Forest Department on
account of issues relating to the revenue records and status of the
-6-
WP No. 35257 of 2024
land. The Additional Deputy Commissioner also declined the
request
for
transfer
of
the
said
land
for
CA
purposes.
Consequently, respondent No.3 called upon M/s. NM to identify
alternative non-forest land for CA. By communication dated
07/18.02.2015, M/s. NM was required to identify a suitable
alternative extent. M/s. NM thereafter identified 44.51 hectares in
Survey No.343 situated in Varavukaval, Challakere Taluk,
Nayakanahatti
Hobli,
Chitradurga
District.
M/s.
NM's
own
communication dated 06.11.2024 refers to the said land being
furnished towards its CA requirement.
9.
For the remaining extent, M/s. NM initially identified land
measuring 12.81 hectares in Kolar District. The said land, however,
could not ultimately be made available on account of the
subsequent action of the revenue authorities. M/s. NM was
therefore repeatedly called upon to identify suitable alternative land
for the balance extent. Eventually, by its communication dated
28.05.2024, M/s. NM identified alternative lands in Koppal District,
Kustigi Taluk, Hanumasagar Hobli, Chandragiri Village bearing Sy.
Nos.17, 19/7/3, 19/8, and 19/18/2 to an extent of 12.23 hectares
and further alternative lands to an extent of 0.687 hectares at Sy.
-7-
WP No. 35257 of 2024
No.42/*/3 situated at Mullur village, Sindhanur Taluk, Turvihal
Hobli, Raichur District.
10.
In the meanwhile, consequent upon the amendment to
Section 8A of the MMDR Act, M/s. NM's mining lease stood
extended and a Supplementary Mining Lease Deed dated
03.07.2020 came to be executed, extending the mining lease upto
18.07.2056.
Relying upon the Central Government Guidelines
dated 01.04.2015 relating to the validity of the forest approval for
mining projects, M/s. NM sought corresponding extension of the
forest clearance so as to make it coterminous with the extended
mining lease.
11.
In the aforesaid circumstances, respondent No.3 issued
impugned demand notice dated 26.09.2024, computing CA
charges for 53.20 hectares at the rate of `18,36,000/- per hectare
and demanding an aggregate amount of `9,76,75,200/-. Aggrieved
thereby M/s. NM submitted representations dated 28.10.2024 and
06.11.2024. As the said representations were not considered, M/s.
NM has approached this Court.
-8-
WP No. 35257 of 2024
Contentions:
12.
The learned counsel appearing for M/s. NM contends that
the
demand
notice
has
been
issued
without
taking
into
consideration the amounts already deposited by M/s. NM in the
year 2005 and the CA activities already undertaken in Survey
No.49 of Harvi Village. It is contended that M/s. NM had complied
with the financial conditions stipulated in the original forest approval
and deposited `28,83,440/- towards CA over the non-forest land,
besides NPV and other charges. It is further contended that M/s.
NM's representations specifically brought to the notice of the
authorities that Survey No.49 had originally been identified and
accepted for the purposes of CA.
It is submitted that, when
subsequently directed to furnish alternative lands, M/s. NM
identified the lands in Chitradurga and Kolar and thereafter, the
balance lands in Koppal and Raichur. According to M/s. NM, these
aspects, including the applicable official memorandum/Government
Order dated 22.08.2023, ought to have been considered before
raising a demand at the presently applicable rate for the entire
53.20 hectares.
13.
Per contra, the learned Additional Government Advocate
submits that mere payment of CA charges in 2005 did not
-9-
WP No. 35257 of 2024
discharge M/s. NM's obligation. The approval specifically required
an equivalent extent of suitable non-forest land to be transferred
and mutated in favour of the Forest Department and CA to be
raised thereon. Survey No.49 could not ultimately be transferred
and mutated as contemplated and was subsequently treated as a
deemed forest. This necessitated identification of alternative CA
land, a fact that is borne out of M/s. NM's own correspondence.
She further submits that M/s. NM itself identified 44.51 hectares in
Chitradurga District and thereafter, identified the balance extent in
Koppal and Raichur District. Therefore, according to the State, M/s.
NM cannot now contend that initial identification of Survey No.49
completely discharged its obligation towards CA.
14.
At this stage, it is relevant to note the order of this Court
dated 09.07.2026.
"1.
After some arguments, the learned Additional
Government Advocate seeks time to file an affidavit as to
what is the state of plantations to the extent of 30 hectares
in Sy. No. 49 of Haravi - Siddapura as is reflected in
Annexure-X, the documents produced by the petitioner.
2.
15.
List on 20.07.2026."
Pursuant to the order of this Court dated 09.07.2026, the
State has filed affidavit submitting that an extent of 30 hectares of
plantation was raised by the Karnataka Forest Department during
- 10 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
the year 2012-2013 under CAMPA Scheme in Sy. No.49 of Haravi
Village, Huvinahadagali Taluk, now Vijayanagar District.
Reasons and conclusions:
16.
There can be no dispute that diversion of 53.20 hectares of
land in favour of M/s. NM was subject to a condition of CA over an
equivalent extent of forest land at the project cost. The letter of the
Government of India, whereby the Central Government agreed inprinciple to the diversion of 53.20 hectares of forest land for mining
iron ore in favour of M/s. NM in Donimalai Range, Sandur Taluk,
Bellary District, Karnataka subject to the fulfillment of following
conditions:
1.
User agency shall carry out immediate transfer and
mutation of equivalent non-forest land in favour of State
Forest Department.
2.
The User Agency shall deposit the cost of raising and
maintaining compensatory afforestation over equivalent nonforest land with the State Forest Department.
3.
The non-forest land for compensatory afforestation
shall be notified by the State Government as RF under
section - 4 or PF under section - 29 of the Indian Forest Act,
1927 or the State Forest Act within a period of 6 months and
Nodal Officer (Forest Conservation) shall report the
compliance.
4.
User Agency shall deposit the Net Present Value
(NPV) of the diverted forest land of 53.20 ha., with the State
Forest Department as per the orders of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court dated 30-10-2002 & 1-8-2003 in I.A No.566 in WP (C)
No.202/1995 and the guidelines issued by this Ministry vide
- 11 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
letter No.5-1/98-FC(Pt-II) dated 18-9-2003 and 22-9-2003 in
this regard.
5.
The user agency shall raise and maintain a Safety
Zone and will also raise and maintain the plantation over an
area one and half times of the extent of the safety zone, over
degraded forest land elsewhere at the project cost.
6.
The State Government shall deposit all the abovementioned funds in form of Fixed Deposits in the name of
concerned DFO/ Nodal Officer of the State, till such time the
CAMPA intimates the Head of Account for deposition of fund.
7.
The User Agency shall demarcate the area by
erecting 4 feet high RCC pillars at the project cost indicating
forward and back bearings and distance between adjacent
pillars on them.
8.
The user agency shall protect the top soil at the
project cost.
9.
Concurrent Reclamation plan shall be executed by the
user agency from the very first year, and an annual report
shall be sent to the Nodal Officer and the Regional CCF.
Bhubaneswar. If it is found from the Annual Report that the
annual programme mentioned in Concurrent Reclamation
Plan is not being adhered to by the user agency, the mining
activities shall remain suspended till such time the annual
programme is completed for that year.
10.
The mining lease shall be coterminus with the current
lease granted under MMDR Act, 1957.
11.
Other standard conditions as applicable in respect of
mining projects shall apply in the instant case also."
17.
Among the conditions so imposed, M/s. NM, the user
agency, was required to transfer and cause mutation of an
equivalent extent of non-forest land in favour of the State Forest
Department; deposit the cost of raising and maintaining CA over
such equivalent non-forest land; deposit the NPV of the entire
- 12 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
diverted forest land measuring 53.20 hectares in accordance with
the orders passed by the Supreme Court and guidelines issued by
the Ministry; ensure that the non-forest land identified for CA was
also required to be notified as a reserved forest under Section 4 or
as a protected forest under Section 29 of the Indian Forest Act,
1927, or under the corresponding State enactment. M/s. NM was
further required to raise and maintain the safety zone and
plantation over an area equivalent to one and a half times of the
extent of safety zone over degraded forest land elsewhere, at the
project cost, apart from demarcating the diverted area by erecting
RCC
pillars
at
its
cost.
The
communication
specifically
contemplated that, upon receipt of the compliance report regarding
fulfillment of the stipulated condition, further approval would follow.
18.
Pursuant to the said in-principle approval, M/s. NM
proceeded to comply with the conditions. This is borne out by a
communication dated 28.04.2005 addressed by the Deputy
Conservator of Forests, Bellary to the Conservator of Forests,
Bellary. The said communication is extracted below:
"No: M1/MNG/BLY/NM/96-97
Encl: four D.Ds. for an amount of 3555940/and safety zone sketch
Office of the
Deputy Conservator of Forests,
Bellary Division, Bellary
- 13 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
Dated 28-04-2005.
Τo,
The Conservator of Forests,
Bellary Division, Bellary
Sir,
Sub:
Diversion of 53.20 ha Forest land for grant of mining
lease of mining of Iron ore favour of M/s. Nadeem
Minerals, Bangalore in D.M. Block, Sandur Taluk,
Bellary Dist.- Reg.,
Ref:
(1)
letter No.8/15/2005 F.C.(MOEF) New Delhi
dated: 21.03.2005 of Government of India
(2)
Letter
No.
FEE-33-FFM-2005
dated:
24.03.2005 of Government of Karnataka
(3)
Your letter No: M1/MNG/CR-64/97-98 dated:
02.04.2005 of Principal Conservator of Forests,
Bangalore
(4)
Your letter No: M1/MNG/CR-64/97-98 date :
06.04.2005
(5)
Assistant Conservator of forests, Bellary letter
dated: 28.04.2005.
(6)
Letter No. Sandur/Nadeem minerals/2005-06
dated: 28.04.2005.
With reference to the above subject, I write to submit
that the additional information as called for by the
Government of India in respect of grant of mining lease of
M/S Nadeem minerals in D.M.Block, Sandur taluk, Bellary
Dist., to an extent of 53.20 ha forest land for taking further
action in this regard.
1)
The lessee has identified 53.20 ha of non-forest land i.e.
C & D Class land in Sy.No.49 of Harvi village Hadagali
Taluk, Bellary Dist., for raising of Compensatory
afforestation and the same is mutated in favour of the
Forest Department.
2)
The lessee has deposited the cost of raising and
maintenance of Compensatory afforestation over an
equivalent non-forest land. The details are as follows.
- 14 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
1) D.D.No. 078534 Dt: 27.04.2005
Rs. 950000.00
2) D.D.No. 078535 Dt: 27.04.2005
Rs. 950000.00
3) D.D.No. 078536 Dt: 27.04.2005
Rs. 983440.00
_________________
Rs. 2883440.00
_________________
Total
The above DDs are purchased in favour of Deputy
Conservator of Forests, Bellary Division, Bellary.
3)
The lessee has deposited the cost of NPV for an extent
of 53.20 ha vide D.D.No. 920/872 Dt: 27.04.2005 for Rs.
37216000/- in favour of Principal Chief Conservator of
Forests, Bangalore.
4)
The lessee has deposited the cost of raising and
maintenance of safety zone area to an extent of 2.95 ha
or 3 ha and also cost of raising and maintenance of the
plantation over an area of one and half times the extent
of the safety zone area @3 haX1.5-4.5 ha and the cost
of fencing to a length of 3923 mtr or 4 Km vide D.D.No.
328992 dt: 25.04.2005 for Rs. 672500/- in favour of the
Deputy conservator of forests, Bellary Division, Bellary.
5)
The user agency has demarcated the area and erected
four feet tall R.C.C. pillars at an interval of 20-25 mtrs.
This is for your kind information and necessary action.
Your faithfully
Sd/Deputy Conservator of Forests,
Bellary Division, Bellary.
1)
19.
Copy submitted along with safety zone sketch to the of
Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Bangalore for
favour of kind information."
It records that M/s. NM had identified 53.20 hectares of non-
forest land in Survey No.49 of Harvi Village, Hadagali Taluk,
Bellary District for raising CA. It further records that M/s. NM had
- 15 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
deposited a sum of `28,83,440/- towards cost of raising and
maintaining CA and had furnished the requisite demand drafts in
favour of the Deputy Conservator of Forests, Bellary. The
communication dated 28.04.2005 further records compliance with
the requirement relating to payment of NPV in respect of the entire
diverted land measuring 53.20 hectares. M/s. NM had also
deposited the amount towards raising and maintenance of the
safety zone over an extent of 2.95 or 3 hectares and towards
raising and maintenance of plantation over an area equivalent to
one and
a half times the safety zone area. A further sum of
`6,72,500/- was deposited in that regard. The diverted area has
also been demarcated on the ground by erecting a four feet high
RCC pillars at an interval of approximately 20 to 25 meters. Thus,
the material on record indicates that the competent Forest Officer
himself reported compliance with the material conditions imposed
under the in-principle approval.
20.
Upon such compliance being reported, the Government of
India, Ministry of Environment and Forests, by communication
dated 27/30.05.2025 conveyed the approval under Section 2 of the
Act for diversion of 53.20 hectares of forest land for mining in
favour of M/s. NM. The final approval also required that the legal
- 16 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
status of the forest land remained unchanged and that CA over an
equivalent extent of non-forest land be raised and maintained at
the project cost. It also reiterated the requirements concerning
notification of CA land, safety zone plantations, NPV, demarcation,
protection of top soil, concurrent reclamation protection of wildlife
and other conditions governing the mining operation. Significantly,
the final approval also stipulated that the lease period could be
coterminous with the current mining lease granted under the
MMDR Act.
21.
Consequent upon the aforesaid approval, the mining lease
came to be executed and registered, and Mining Lease No.2526 in
respect of the said extent of 53.20 hectares was granted with effect
from 19.07.2006.
22.
However, it is evident from the material on record that Survey
No.49 did not ultimately result in the transfer and mutation of the
requisite equivalent extent of non-forest land in favour of the Forest
Department. M/s. NM's own correspondence demonstrates that,
pursuant to the directions of the Forest Department, it proceeded to
identify alternative CA lands. It would be apposite to consider the
representations dated 28.10.2024 and 06.11.2024, which contain
- 17 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
substantially similar words and grounds. We would refer to the
letter dated 28.10.2024, which is extracted below:
"NM-B/PCCF/2024-25/006
Date: 28.10.2024
To,
The Principal Chief Conservator Forests (FC),
Aranya Bhavan,
Malleshwaram,
Banaglore-560 003.
Sub:
Diversion of 53.20 hectare (as per CEC 52.82 ha) of
forest land in Donimalai Block, Sandur Range, Ballari
District, Karnataka State for mining of iron ore (ML
No.2526) in favour of M/s.Nadeem Minerals Private
Limited (Transfer & Deemed extension of FC) - reg
Ref:
1. DCF Ballari (Demand Notice for CA charges) letter
M1/MNG/Nadeem/ML.NO.2526/2020-21 dtd. 26.09.2024
2. Letter from PCCF (FC), Bangalore to The Deputy
Conservator of Forests, Ballari Division, vide letter no.
KFD/HOFF/A5-1 (MNG)/76/2019-FC dated 28.06.2024
3. Our request letter no.NM-B/PCCF/2024-25/001 dated
11.06.2024 to PCCF (FC) regarding Deemed extension
and name change of forest clearance.
4. Our letter to DCF, Ballari dated 28.05.2024
5. PCCF Office Circular regarding Revised CA land safety
zone charges dated 22.08.2023
6. Proceedings of the meeting held under the chairmanship
of Hon'ble Minister of Forest, Food and Civil Supplies
dtd. 29.06.2022 at 11 AM
7. Transfer of Mining Lease No.2526 executed by Director,
Department of Mines and Geology, Bangaluru on
18.05.2022
- 18 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
8. Deemed extension notification No. CI 147 MMM 2020
dated 29.04.2022 from Secretary, Commerce &
Industries, Vikasa Soudha, Bengaluru.
With reference to the above subject matter, we would like to
bring your kind notice that the Department of Mines and
Geology already executed the transfer of the lease deed (both
transfer and deemed extension) on May 18, 2022. Further, we
have requested to the forest department for the transfer and
deemed extension of FC to the forest land over an extent of
53.20 ha. (as per CEC 52.82 ha) in Donimalai Range, Sandur
Taluk, Ballari District, for mining of iron ore (ML No. 2526) in
favor of M/s. Nadeem Minerals Private Limited.
Earlier, we identified the land in Sy. No.49, Haravi Village,
Hadagali Taluk, Ballari District which was accepted by the
Forest Department.
Subsequently, the Forest Department directed us to identify
another suitable area for compensatory afforestation (CA).
Accordingly, we have identified the following land for CA
purposes, in lieu of the forest land diverted for mining activities:
Sl.
No.
Name of the
Division
Village
Sy.
No.
Chitradurga
(Which
is
already
transferred in
the name of
Forest
Department)
Kolar
(Pending for
transfer
to
the
Forest
Department)
Varavukaval,
Challekere
Taluk,
Nayakanahatti
Hobli
Venkatapura,
Kolar Taluk,
Vakkleri Hobli
Maderahalli,
Kolar Taluk,
Vakkleri Hobli.
Total
Extent
(in
Acres)
110.00
Extent
(in Ha.)
44.51
1,41
31.65
12.81
141.65
57.32
91/P1
The aforementioned land was identified and transferred in the
name of the Forest Department, pending the issuance of the PF
notification by the State Government. In the meantime, the land
at Kolar was subsequently cancelled by the Revenue
Department. We have since identified an alternative land in
Kolar District, and the matter was pending with no fault from our
- 19 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
side. This was duly recorded in the proceedings of the meeting
held under the Chairmanship of the Hon'ble Minister for Forest
and Civil Supplies at Aranya Bhavan on 29.06.2022. A copy is
enclosed for your reference.
Due to delay in Kolar District, we Identified and purchased the
land in Chandragiri Village of Koppal District and Mullur village
of Raichur Dist. The details are as under:
Sl. Name of
No.
the
Division
Koppal
Raichur
Location
Sy. No.
Chandragiri
Village,
Kustigi taluk,
Hanumasagar
Hobli,
Koppal Dist.
Mallur Village,
Sindhanur Taluk,
Turvihal Hobli,
Raichur Dist.
Total
17, 19/7/3,
19/8 &
19/18/2
42/*/3
Extent Extent
(in
(in Ha.)
Acres)
30.22 12.230
1.70
0.687
31.92
12.917
These private lands have already been transferred and mutated
in the name of the respective District Forest Offices and are in
the process of being converted under Section 33. This is an
internal process and procedure within the Forest Department,
which is currently pending.
We would like to bring to your attention that all the
compensatory afforestation (CA) land required for M/s. Nadeem
Minerals Pvt. Ltd., with ML No. 2526, totaling 141.92 acres, has
been identified and handed over to the Forest Department. In
this regard, we have already paid the CA charges prior to
receiving Stage-II clearance from the Government of India. We
have also requested your esteemed office and the DCF, Ballari,
to process the application for deemed extension and transfer of
the mining lease.
We were uttershock after receiving the demand notice from the
DCF, Ballari, vide Ref. No.1 dated 26.09.2024, for payment of
Rs.9,76,75,200/- (Rupees Nine Crores Seventy-Six Lakhs
Seventy-Five Thousand Two Hundred Only). They calculated
the rate per hectare at Rs.18,36,000/-. In fact, we do not have
any outstanding CA charges as of date. Additionally, the State
- 20 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
Forest Department has already undertaken compensatory
afforestation and maintenance of plantations in Sy. No.49 of
Haravi village, Hadagali Taluk, Ballari District.
Such being the case, issuing the demand notice again is
not justified. We would also like to bring to your kind
attention that, as per the office circular dated 22.08.2023,
there is no provision for the collection of CA charges
where Stage-Il clearance has already been granted by the
Government of India. This applies only to fresh cases with
in-principal approval, where Stage-II clearance is still
pending. A copy of the office circular is enclosed for your
reference.
Since the DCF office has raised the demand notice, we kindly
request your good office to issue necessary directions to the
DCF, Ballari, to withdraw the unlawful demand notice dated
26.09.2024. Furthermore, we request that the DCF, Ballari, be
directed to submit the proposal for the transfer and deemed
extension of ML No. 2526 over an extent of 53.20 Ha. in favor
of M/s. Nadeem Minerals Private Limited.
We sincerely hope that your esteemed office will take the
necessary steps in the interest of justice and equity.
Thanking You,
Yours faithfully,
For Nadeem Minerals Private Limited
Sd/(Authorised Signatory)"
23.
Therefore, M/s. NM cannot contend that the mere initial
identification of Survey No.49 by itself completely discharged its
obligation to furnish suitable non-forest land for CA. However, there
is, another aspect of the matter which requires consideration.
- 21 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
24.
In the additional affidavit filed by the respondents on
29.07.2026, sworn to by Dr. Basavaraj, son of Naganagouda K., it
is stated at paragraph Nos.6, 7, and 8 as under:
"6. I further submit that the District Level Committee
(DLC) constituted for verifying and classifying deemed
forests vide Government of Karnataka order dated
15.05.2014 has identified and included an extent of 155.24
hectares as deemed Forest in Sy.No.49 of Haravi Village of
Huvinahadagalli Taluk, Vijayanagara District. Further, the
same has been notified as 'Deemed Forest' vide Notification
No. APaJI 185 FAF 2011 dated 05.05.2022 of Government
of Karnataka and these details of Deemed Forest areas
have been submitted in the Affidavit filed before the Hon'ble
Supreme Court of India by the State in W.P.No.202/1995 of
T.N.Godavarman Thirumulpad Union of India and others.
This area is presently under the custody and control of the
Forest Department. Hence, the same cannot be taken as a
compensatory afforestation land in favour of the Petitioner.
The Plantation of 30 Hectares in Sy.No 49 is maintained by
the Forest Department out of the funds.
7.
Photographs evidencing the status of the
Compensatory afforestation done on 30 hectares of land in
Survey No. 49 of Haravi Village, Hoovinahadagali Taluk
now Vijayanagar District is produced herewith. The cost that
was incurred then for this plantation is Rs.18,80,000/documents evidencing the same is produced as
ANNEXURE-R1 to R3.
8.
I humbly submit that only on 16.11.2016 that the
Petitioners handed over 44.31 hectares in Survey No. 343
of Varavu Kaval Village, Chalakere Taluk, Nayakana Hatti
Hobli, Chitradurga District, and 12.81 hectares on
18.05.2024 in Kopal and Raichur Districts for compensatory
afforestation which has to be raised on this 53.20 hectares
of land provided by the petitioners, for which the impugned
demand notice has been issued. Out of compensatory
afforestation charges of Rs.28,83,440/- previously paid by
the petitioner on 25.03.2005 Rs.18,80,000/- will be adjusted
against the revised demand while calculating the balance
amount payable by the petitioner."
(emphasis ours)
- 22 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
25.
It
is
stated
that
Survey
No.49
of
Harvi
Village,
Hoovinahadagali Taluk, Vijayanagar District came to be identified
as a deemed forest and is presently under the custody and control
of Forest Department and therefore, cannot be treated as a nonforest CA land furnished by M/s. NM. The State has also referred to
the plantation having been raised over a portion of Survey No.49.
26.
More importantly, the Annual Plan of Operation under
Compensatory Afforestation Fund Management and Planning
Authority (State CAMPA) of Bellary Division has been produced
along with the affidavit. The Annual Plan of Operation for the year
2011-12, at serial No.17 makes the following reference, which is
extracted below:
Hadagali
30.00 36800
Kumaraswamy
Minerals
Export Bellary,
ML No.2148
Holalu
Sy.No.
11.040 Pit
Planning
Harvi Sy.No.49
M/s. Nadeem Minerals
ML No.2526
27.
Under State CAMPA (Compensatory Afforestation Funds
Management and Planning Authority), in column No.6, it is
mentioned as under:
- 23 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
Sl. Range
No.
Hadagali
Name of Lease Proposed Proposed
the
extemt Area
Ext
Mining
(in lla.)
Company
30.00
Kumaraswamy
Mineral Export,
Bellary ML
No.2142
M/s.
Nadeem
Minerals
28.
Holalu
Sy.No.
Work
executed
area
Plantation
Extent
(in lla.)
Unit
Cost
Rs.
Amount
Model
Holalu
Sy.
No.49
30.00
25870
7.76
Rippingcum -Pit
Planting
Harvi
Sy.
N`o.49
Thus, there is material emanating from the respondents' own
records indicating that the plantation over an extent of 30 hectares
in Survey No.49 was associated with Mining Lease No.2526.
29.
On one hand, M/s. NM's own subsequent correspondence
shows that alternative CA lands were identified by it. On the other
hand, the respondents' own records indicate that the plantation
over 30 hectares in Survey No.49 was associated to M/s. NM's
mining lease. The impugned demand notice is conspicuously silent
on this aspect. It does not indicate whether the said plantation was
undertaken towards the CA obligation of M/s. NM; whether the
amount deposited by M/s. NM was utilized for that purpose, or what
consequence the expenditure, if any, would have while determining
the amount presently payable by M/s. NM. The M/s. NM's
identification of alternative lands also cannot be ignored while
undertaking the actual exercise as to whether, in fact, CA was
- 24 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
undertaken in respect of Survey No.49 and whether the plantation
over 30 hectares in Survey No.49 was utilized. However, the
impugned demand notice, being silent on all these aspects and the
representations submitted by M/s. NM's requiring consideration,
the demand notice is to be treated as a show cause notice and
respondent No.3 to undertake a fresh determination after
considering M/s. NM's representations.
30.
The Authorities shall also consider the applicability and effect
of the Government Order / Official Memorandum dated 22.08.2023,
the amounts already deposited by M/s. NM, the expenditure if any,
already incurred towards CA attributable to M/s. NM's project.
Accordingly, the writ petition is disposed of with the following
directions:
a.
The demand notice dated 26.09.2024 shall be treated
as a show-cause notice.
b.
The representations submitted by M/s. NM shall be
treated as an objection to the show cause notice.
c.
M/s. NM is at liberty to file additional documents,
objections, and material, if any, in support of its
contention.
- 25 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
d.
Respondent
No.3
representations
and
shall
consider
additional
M/s.
material,
NM's
if
any,
together with the relevant departmental CAMPA
records concerning the plantation shown to have been
raised over 30 hectares in Survey No.49 Harvi Village
with reference to Mining Lease No.2526 and also
consider
the
acknowledged
amount
by
paid
respondent
by
the
in
petitioner
letter
dated
28.04.2005.
e.
The entire exercise shall be undertaken after affording
M/s. NM a reasonable opportunity of hearing.
f.
Respondent No.3 shall pass a reasoned and speaking
order dealing with the aforesaid aspects.
g.
The entire exercise shall be completed within a period
of eight weeks from date.
h.
M/s. NM is at liberty to file additional documents for
consideration before the concerned authority and the
request of M/s. NM for extension of the validity of the
forest clearance shall also be considered by the
competent authority in accordance with law.
- 26 -
WP No. 35257 of 2024
The pending interlocutory applications also stand disposed
of.
Sd/(VIBHU BAKHRU)
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sd/(K.S. HEMALEKHA)
JUDGE
MBM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review