Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3300 ]
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYOERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY FIRST DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO: 34632 OF 2025
Between:
1. M/s. Murali Manpower Agencies, Having its registered office at H. No. 7-2503, SRT 282, 1st Floor Sanath Nagar- 500 018, Telangana Rep. by its
Proprietor Muralidhar Chikkala
2. Muralidhar Chikkala, S/o. Chikkala Surya Rao, Aged about 43 years, Occ.
Business, Rl/o. Flat No. 305, Eden C, Lodha Apartments, Sanath Nagar
Hyderabad- 500 018, Telangana
...PETITIONERS
AND
Union of lndia, Rep. by its Secretary, Ministry of Labour and Employment
Shram Shakti Bhawan, Rafi Marg, New Delhi- 110 001
Employees State lnsurance Corporation, Having its office at Panchdeep
Bhawa'n, CIG Marg New Delhi- 110 002 Represented by its Director General
Employees State lnsurance Corporation, Having its regional .office ,at
Panchdeep Bhawan, 5-9-23, Hill Fort Road, Adarsh Nagar, Hyderabad 500063, Telangana Represented by its Regional Director also At Employees
State lnsurance Corporation College and Hospital Sanathnagar,
Sanjeevreddy- 500 038, Hyderabad
4. Tender Evaluation Committee, Employees State lnsr-irance Corporation
Medical College and Hospital Rep. by its Convenor
lsha Protectional Security Guard Pvt. Ltd., Having its registered office at F.
No. S-3, Plot No. 275, Sirbhag Home Sarvadharam Colony, A- Sector, Kolar
Road Bhopal- 462 O42, Madhya Pradesh Having its branch office at P.No.
19120, H. No.3-105/38/fu8, Uday Nagar, Bhavani Nagar, Boduppal,
Medipally, Medchal, Hyderabad - 500 092
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction. more particularly one in
the nature of writ of Mandamus declaring the actions of the Respondents in
awarding Tender daled 28.O8.2025 vide GEMl2O25lBl64l] i045 in favour of the
5th Respondent as being illegal, arbitrary, unjust, unco';titutional apart from
being violative of the Petitioner's rights of legitimate expect,r ion-.
IA NO: 1 oF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the ci :umstances stated rn
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court rr ry be pleased to stay
all consequential actions/proceedings in pursuance of Terr, er dated 28,08.2025
vide GEMl2025l8i6488045 pending disposal of the writ petit )n.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI RAJA SRIPATHI RAO, Serr cr Counsel
for SRI PASHAM MOHITH
counser for the Respondent No'1
'Sxlt"n?,:i
counsel for the Respondent No.2ro,
uflit'i "0,,
' ||,$XtASrESl{ ^/ARLU,
Counsel for the Respondent No.5 : SRI MADAN MOHAN Rl O,
SENIOR COUNSEL for ! Rl M.P.K.ADlryA
The Court made the following: ORDER
'1
h
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON,BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION No. 34632 OF 2o25
2\.OL.2026
Between:
Murali Manpower Agencies
Rep. by its Proprietor
Muralidhar Chikkala
And another
Petitioners
And
The Union of India,
Rep. by its Secretary,
Ministry of Labour & Employment
& others.
. Respondents
ORDER:
Petitioner - M/s Murali Manpower Agencies, a sole
proprietorship concern registered under the provisions of the
Micro, Small and Medium Enterpriscs Act, 2006 is dngaged in
the business of providing manpower services including security
services, housekeeping services and other ancillary services to
various establishments. PetitionErs contend that they have at all
times conducted their business strictly in accordance with the
requirements of law and statutory compliances.
1.1.
lt is contended that in 2023, pursuan Lo the tender
floated by the 3'd Respondent lor providing se, r rity services
across the Enrployees State Insurance Corpor I ion Meclical
Coltcge and Hospital Campus situated at )antrthnagar'
Hyderabad, Telangana, contract was awarded n favour of
Petitioners uide Contract dated 3l -O1.2023 Accordingly,
Petitioners commenced providing security servict: in terms of
the said contract and discharged their obligr r ions to thc
satisfaction of the Respondent authorities. In Janrr t1 2024, thc
3.d Respondent issued proceedings extending t re aforesaid
contract till 31 .03.2024 or till finalisation o[ a ncr contract b1'
the Respondent authorities, whichever was r', rlier. Thus,
Petitroners were existing service providers and s ood already
adjudged technically and financially compe ( nt
by the
Respondent authorities themselves.
I .'2.
It is contended, while Petitioners u't I :'continuing
to render services, the 3'd Respondent floated a iesh Tender
dated 28.08.2025 through the Government e-Mark ( tplacc Portal
for providing sccuri[r services at the Employees St i Le lnsurance
Corporation Medical College and Hospital, I anathnagar,
Hyderabad, for one year with total value of the ccr tract as INR
),2,47,20,021 /
Tender was uploaded on the Clr vernment e
I
i
Marketplace Portal, which is a centralized platform facilitating
on line procurement of goods and services for Government
departments, organizations and public sector undertakings.
Petitioners participated in
the said tender process and
submitted their technical bid on O8.O9.2025.
1.3.
It is the specihc contention of Petitioners that the
2"d Respondent issued binding Guidelines dated 14.11.2024 fot
engagement of contractLral manpower in establishments run by
the Employees State [nsurance Corporation (ESI) which
prescribe the technical eligibiliry criteria evaluation methodolory
and mark break-up to be followed while awarding tenders. Bid
Document dated 28.08.2025 itself makes relerence to and relies
upon the Guidelines dated 14.11..2024, thereby expressly
admitting that the tender process is governed by the said
Guidelines. Consequently, the 3'd Respondent was bound to
strictly adhere to the provisions and framework prescribed
under the said Guidelines r,r,hilc framing thc tender conditions
and while evaluating the bids. Upon opening and scrutiny of the
technicai bids submitted pursuant to the Tender dated
28.O8.2025, the 4rt Respondent Committee shorllisted 15 bids
out of 62; on completion of technical evaluation, the 4m
Respondent Committee furnished its report allocating marks to
(
-\-*'-
the shortlisted bidders, wherein Petitioners were a\ i rclcd 77 out
of 1O0 marks.
7.4.
lt is oontended that one of the techr-rir I I evaluation
parameters under the tender pertained to the av r'zrge annual
turnover of the bidder for the previous three finan': al years' As
per the tender conditions, a bidder was to be awartl c1 10 marks
if the average :rrttrual turnover was above INR 4! 19,00,000/ancl less tl-ran INR 54,97,90,000 l-, and 12 marks 1 the avcrage
annual turnover u'as above INR 59,86,80,000/ - a r cl less than
INR 64,85,7O,00O/-. The average annual turnover .'Petitioners
for the prcvious Lhrec financial years was INR 60 : 5,57,4751
as certified by zL certificate dated 05.09.2025 )espite thc
Petitioncrs' turr)over being far in excess of the ccl lract value,
the 3'd Respou<lcnt awarded only 12 marks under he turnover
criterion. The (iuidelines dated 14.11.2024 permt only three
slabs for turnover-based scoring, namely 1O marl: , 15 marks
and 20 marks. Contrary thereto, Tender clatecl 28'08 2025
introduced ten different slabs ranging from 10 tr 20 marks,
including intermediate slabs such as 11, 12, 13, ll, 16, 17,18
and 19 marks. Petitioners contend that such leviation is
ex facie contrary to the binding Guidelines datt:r t 14 11'2024
and is therefore iliegal
1.5.
It is further contended that the minimum turnover
requirement of INR 49,89,0O,O0O/- and the maximum turnover
limit of INR 99,78,00,O00/- prescribcd under the tender are
grossly disproportionate to the contract value of INR
12,47 ,2O,O21 I -. Petitioners contend that turnover criteria are
intended only to ensure financiai capacity to execute the
contract and must be proportionate. The impugned criteria are
arbitrary, irrational and contrary to the CVC Guidelines
governing public procurement. Under the experience criterion
prescribed, a bidder was entitled to be awarded 20 marks if it
had executed more than [-rve contracts in the relevant tield.
Petitioners stated, six operational contracts executed in the
relevant field, duly supported by Proforma-D and documentary
evidence. Despite submission of six eligible contracts, the 3rd
Respondent awarded only 15 marks instead of the entitled 2O
marks, without any lawful justihcation. Such reduction of
marks is stated to be deliberate and intended to prejudice the
technical evaluation of Petitioners.
|
.6.
Under the guise of prescribing the nature of
documents to be submitted, the 3'd Respondent illegally
introduced an additional eligibiliry condition requiring that only
I
I
li4.
experience certilicates or work ordcrs pertainirr ; to ong()Ing
operational securirY contracts involving depr) :,'mcnI of a
minimum ol 40 outsourced contractual pcrsonnt l per conl ract
would be considcred. Such a condition ltnds lto place in the
Guidelines dated 14. | 1.2024 and is there forc illegal. Even
assuming sltch a condition to be applicabie, P: itioners had
fully complied rvith the same and they had depll d more than
4O personncl undcr all six contrzrcts by engagini relit'vers and
additional manpo\\/er as mandated under labr:r r lar"'s. The
actual deployment always exceeds the numbers nen[ioned in
work orders duc to staLutory requiremenLs relirl i rg to weckly
offs, leave and rclievers.
1.7.
lt is contended that one of the cr;t tracls relied
upon by Respondcnls pertains to Survey of Indi r, uhere the
work order mentions deployment of 34 person' :1. The said
figure represents only the minimum requircm I lt zrnd that
actual deployrrent cxceeded 40 personnel. Thr Responclcnt
authorities wcrc fully aware of this practice. E ven the 2"d
Respondent itself had issued work order for deplt'' ment of 210
personnel for sec-urity services lor 2024 -25 but act I ally required
deployment of 261 personnel to comply with abour larvs,
demonstrating that actual deployment always ,r :ceeds \^'ork
order figures. lt is contended that on 29.1O.2O25, immediately
upon declaration of technical evaluation results, Respondcnt
authorities proceeded to open the linancial bids without
granting a minimum window of forty-eight hours to enable
bidders to seek clarification or redressal of grievances.
Peti[ioncrs therefore, are stated to have addressed e mail dated
29.10.2025 and raised a grievance ticket objecting to the
Lechnical evaluation. After technical evaluaLion, seven bidders
including Petitioners were shortlisted for submission of financial
bids Petitioners contended their hnancial bid quoting a total
amounL of tNR 12,47,19,O81.85/ -.
1.8.
It is contended that five out of the seven shortlisted
bidders, including Petitioners, quoted identical amount of tNR
12,47 ,l9,O8l -85/ - and thus emerged as Hl bidders. Despite the
samc, Rcspondent authorities declared thc 5ft Respondent as
the successful bidder. Pursuant to awarding contract in favour
of Lhe sth Respondent, the 2"'t Respondent issued
Communicalion dated 11.11 .2025 extending Petitioners'
existing contract till 30. I 1.2025. Since hve bidders quoted
identical hnancial bids, the technical score became
determinative. Due to iilegal reduction of marks under the
turnover and experience criteria, Petitioners were awarded only,
70 marks, whereas had the Guidelines datecl 14 11 2024 b<:en
followed, they u-ould have sccurcd gO marks ir| he technical
evaluation.
1.9.
[t is r:ontended that as per Order dart t 23'03'2012
issued by the De vclopment Commissioner' MSM t ' out of the
2O7o annual procurement target earmarked for Mi MEs' a sub
target of 2Ool' is resewed for MSMEs owned by St:lr :duled Cetste
and Schedulcd 'lribe clltrepreneurs' Petitioners : I e an MSME
entiW orvned by individuals belonging to Schedr I li I Caste and
Scheduled Tribe categories and, having emerged z s H[ bidder'
thecontractu'oulclhavebeenaw'ardedintheirlrrourbutfor
the illegal technir:al evaluation The GeM Portal : I ;o considers
additional parameters such as bidder rating and proximity to
the place of selwice. Petitioners hold a S-star ralinq on the GcM
Portal and are situatcd in close proximity to the I SIC Medical
Cbllege and Hosprtal, Sat-rathnagar'
lt is contcncled that the ESIC Hospital (Hvderabad)
Contract Workers Union submitled a Com t aint dated
1.10.
18.O2.2025 befor<: the Central Vigilance Commissit'r against the
5n Respondent zrlleging illegal removal of employce i and illcgal
monetary demands for reinstatement, specihcalJl naming one
Mr. Mahesh, HR Manager o[ the 5s Responc.' nt. Desprte
:\
pendency of such serious allegations, Respondent authorities
proceeded to award the tender in favour of the sft Respondent.
Petitioners therefore, submitted detailed representation dated
.l I .2025 bringing to the notice of Respondent authorities the
illegal conditions imposed in thc Tender dated 28.08.2025. It is
contcnded that in a tender floated on 77.1O.2O25 for the ESIC
Super Specialty Hospital, Respondents followed the Guidelines
dated 14.11.2024 and prcscribed only three turnover slabs,
namely INR 4.25 crores to INR 8.5O crores for 10 marks, INR
8.5O crores to INR 12.75 crores for 15 marks, and above INR
12.75 crorcs f<>r 20 marks. Guidelines dated 14.11.2024
mandate adoption of QCBS with, TOok weightage for nonfinancial parameters and 3O7o for financial parameters, whereas
the Tender clated 28.08.2O25 reverses thc ratio to 30:7O, which
is contrary to the Guidelines and illegal. The stipulation denying
MSME exemptions in the bid document is also illegal.
1.11.
It is contended that Petitioners continue to render
sccurity services and their contract has beeri extended till
31.12.2025, thercby demonstrating their continued technical
and financiai capabitity to execute the work under the
impugned tender. Respondents' contention that objections
raised by the Petitioners are an afterthought is incorrect, as the
t0
ri
illegalify- became apparent only upon declzrr i tion of the
technical evalual-ion. The Petitioners had raisecl i;sues during
the pre-bid stast: nnd by email clatcd 29.1O.2O'2) wttich u'cre
ignored. It is t herefore contended that the r :tiotl of the
,
Respondent authorities in awarding contracl fursuanl. to
Tender dated 28.O8.2025 bearing No. GEM/2021 /B/6444045
in favour of the l)th Respondcnt is arbitrary, illep: I, violative of
Articles 14 and 19 of the Constilution of India, c ltraly to the
doctrine of level playing fie1d and principles of nattt al justice.
By order dated 14.11.2025, this Court lirected both
2.
the parties to mu inLain statu.s quo irt all respects.
Respondent No. 3 filed counte r oppt I ing the Writ
3.
Petition and contending that thc ettlire tender prri I rss pursllitnt
to Tender dated 28.Oa.2025 rv.rs conductt:tI strictly in
accordance with law, in a fair, transparent I rd objective
manner through thc Governmctrl c Markctplac,' Fortal. The
tender process \\'as designed to cnsure t ansparellcy,
competitive pricing and optimal utilisation of :,rblic funds,
particularly in the sensitive sector of healthcare. L is asserled
that there was no irregularity, arbitrariness, bias <t mala ftde in
the tender proccss and Petitioners, being unsucccs;ful biddcrs,
(
ll
o
\
have approached this Court with false, misleading and
exaggerated allegations with an ulterior motive.
3.1.
It is contended that Petitioners, having participated
in the tender process with full knowledge of the tender
conditions, eligibility criteria, evaluation methodolory and
scoring mechanism, are cstopped from subsequently
challenging the same afler being unsuccessful. According to
Respondents, a biddcr ivho has voluntarily accepted tender
conditions zrnd participatecl in the process cannot, after failing
to secure the contract, turn around and question the very
conditions which u,erc unifr.>rmly apptied to all bidders.
3.2.
It is stated, thc scope of judicial review in tender
and contractual matters is extremely limited. Reliance in this
regard is placed on the judgment ol the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in Tata Cellular u. IJnion of Indiat, u'herein it was laid down
that Courts should exercise restraint in administrativeimatters,
should not sit as appellate authorities over tender decisions,
and should interfere only vvhere the decision-making process is
vitiated by arbitrarincss, bias, mala fides or perversity' None of
these grounds are made out in the present case.
' (1994) 6 scc 651
t7
it is contended that public tenders ar : commercial
3.3.
transactions ancl (iovernment must have freerl'l I of contract,
subject only to thc requirement of fairness and rr I sonableness'
Courts lack technical expcrtise to evaluate 1('I r' or decisions
taken by expert committees and that intcl f : cnce at an
advanced stagc of the tender process woulrl i npose heavy
administrative artd ltnancial burdens on the Stat( lnd result in
loss to the publir: exchcquer. The 3'd Responcle n t r ontends that
tender datecl 28.08.2025 u'as governed noL or.r ' by internal
guidelines but primarity by the Manual for Procr rr' ]renr of Non-
Consultancy Services issued by the Dcpartmcnt ol F)xpcnditure,
Ministry of Finance, Government of India, u'hich c:' me into force
with effect from 2O.06.2025 It is asserted that zrs : rr Clause 1 3
of the said Manual, the provisions are bin<lir 1 on Central
Government Ministries, Departments, attached ar t subordinate
offices, autonomous bodies ancl statLltory bodit:s. n'cluding the
Respondent organization.
According to this respondent, the Manual for
3.4 .
Procurement of Non-Consultancy Services expros: ly applies to
outsourcing of services and that the tender in ques ion squarely
falls within its ambit. The Manual provides a i r mprehensive
framework governrng bid invitation, qualifica t on critcria,
1,
W
li
technical evaluation, financial evaluation and Quality-cum-Cost
Based Selection (QCBS) methodolory. The tender document
dated 28.08.2025 clcarly stipulated that bid would be evaluated
on the basis of QCBS methodologr and that the ratio of
technical to financial weightage was fixed at 30:7O in strict
compliance with Clause 4.3.2.4 of the Manual. The said clause
mandates that the maximum r'r'eightage for non-fltnancial
parameters shall not excced 3O'lo. The Respondents assert that
the QCBS ratio adopted in the tcnder is therefore lawful and
valid.
3.5.
It is furthcr contended that Respondent No'3
constituted a Technical Committee in terms of Clause 4.3.2.6 of
the Manual. The said Technical Committee was entrusted with
the task of recommending the lechnical parameters, their
respective weightage, scoring methodolory and minimum
qualifying scores. The recommcndations of the lfechnical
Committee were accepted by the Competcnt Authority and were
duly incorporated into the tender document. Thus, it is
contended that all due procedures prescribed under the Manual
were meticulously followed. Petitioners attended the pre-bid
meeting held on O8.O9.2O25 through their representative and
did not raise any objection whatsoever regarding the QCBS
l4
:+
ratio, turnover criteria or scoring methodolos' rt that stage'
Having failed to object at the pre bid stage and hirr.ng accepLed
the tencter conditions, Petitioners cannot nou' : rallt:nge the
same after being unsuccessful.
3.6.
It is contended that turnovel rcquircmcnt
prescribed under the tender was hxed in ar:tl I'dance rn'ith
Clause 5.1.9.1(c) of the I\4anual for Procurcn r nl of NonConsultancy Services, which permits prescriptrt:r of averagc
annual turnover ranging between three to scr''r' L limcs the
estimated cost ol- the contract. Since contract vlt uc was INR
12,47,2O,O21 l-, the minimum average turnover r"lr: llxed at INR
49,89,0O,0O0/-, which is approximately four timt':' '-he (rontrac[
value. According to the Re spondents, lhe turnov.t re quircment
is thus reasor-urble, proportionate and lau'li I
Ter:hnical
evaluation was carried out strictly in accordance \v I I thc tendcr
conditions. Out of 62 bids receivcd, 15 were sho tliste d alte r
preliminary scrutiny. Thereafter, upon verification -l clor--uments
uploaded on GeM Portal, seven bidders were four r technically
qualified and eight bidders were disqualihecl. 4arks were
awarded to the qr-ralified bidders strictly as per thc n:rrk break-
up stipulated in the tendcr document.
t5
I
3.7.
lt is contended that Petitioners allegation regarding
illegai introduction of turnover slabs is misconceived, as the
mark break-up for average annual turnover was clearly
delineated in Chapter- l, Clause 3(A) of the tender document.
Petitioners, having accepted the said criteria prior to submission
of bids, cannot now contend that the same is illegal or arbitrary.
Under the expericnce criterion, the tender document specifically
required submission of proof of operational (live) c:ontracts in
security services involving deployment of a minimum of 40
outsourced contractual personnel in a single contract. As per
Proforma-D, only hve of the six contracts submitted by the
Petitioners satisfied this criterion and were therefore eligible for
consideration. It is contended that with respect to the sixth
contract relied upon by Petitioners, namely the contract
awarded by the Additional Surveyor Gcneral, NIGST, Survey of
India, Uppal, Hyderabad-500O39, Pctitioners misrepresented
that 40 securify personnel were deployed. However, as per the
actual contract document, the sanctioned manpower was only
34 security personnel. On account o[ such misrepresentation,
Petitioners were rightly awarded only 15 marks instead of 20
under the experience criterion.
t6
3.8.
It is contended that Petitioners I r ve not only
misled Respondent authorities but have also rtternpted to
mislead this Court by suppressing the correct man )owcr figures
contained in the Survey of India contract. ,,ccording to
Respondents, this misrepresentation by itst I
disentitlcs
Petitioners from any equitable relief under Artrc I 226 of the
Constitution of India. The allegation regarding hrL ried opening
of financial bids is baseless. The tender was pro( ( ssecl rrntirely
through GeM Portal, and after completion rf rechnical
evaluation, thc portal automatically proceeds to lre financial
evaluation stage. There is no mandatory requirem, rt undcr thc
GeM framework to provide a 4S-hour windou, lrr grievancc
redressal prior to opening of financial bids. tt is co rtenilcd tlrat
financial evalu:rtion was conducted strictly in at:r r rdanc:e u,ith
the QCBS mcthodologr. The final score was ' )mputed by
normalising thc tt:chnical score and financial score nd applf ing
the prescribed formula, namely F inal Score i( . I Technical
Score)+(O.7 Financial Score). The bidder securinri the highesl
composite scorc \\'as declared successful.
3.9.
It is contended that Petitioners' clt rr ol- having
emerged as H I hidder is misleading, as the ter ( er u,as not
awarded solell,' on the basis of lowest fina r ..:ial quotc.
&,
tl
)
Respondents assert that the 5fr Respondent emerged as the
successlul bidder based on the highest final composite score
under QCBS methodologr and not merely on the basis of
financial bid. It is contended that the Petitioners reliance on
MSME status and SC/ST ownership is misconceived. According
to Respondents, there is no automatlc entitlement to award of
contract merely on the basis of MSME status or rcservation
claims, particularly when the tender conditions expressly
stipulated that no exemptions would be granted. It is conLended
that Respondents are not in a position to verify the authenticity
of GeM Portal ratings and proximity parameters relicd upon by
the Petitioners, as such criteria are determined by GeM
authorities, who are not parties to the present proceedings.
3.1O.
It is contended that the entire tender process was
undertaken strictly in conformity w'ith the prevailing public
procurement guidelines and that the Petitioners' challenge is an
afterthought raised only after they failed to secure thc contract.
Petitioners, having participated in the tender without demur,
lack locus to challenge the tender conditions post facto. Writ
Petition has been filed with an intent to mislead this Court and
to stall the implementation of the tender. It is pointed out that
the existing contract is expiring on 3O.ll.2025 and that
l8
continuation of interim orders would sevcrt I ' affect the
functioning of the hospital and disrupt esse t)li rl healthcare
SCTVlCCS
3. 1 1-
It is contended that Employees Sta te lnsurance
Corporation Medical Coltege and Hospital I :r Cen tral
Government hospital providing essential servicc to patients
and that public interest and continuity of he:rltl-:art: sen'ices
must preva il over private commercial it ttt I :sts of
an
unsuccessful bidder. AnSr delay in commencemcnl )f st:rvices by
the successful bidde r r.r'ould result in irreparabl,l harrn to the
public at large
4.
.
Respondent No.5 filed a detailed cotln,' r con[ending
that Petitione rs have not demonstrated any vio I tion oI ll'rcir
constitutional or fundamentai rights and have fzril,-' I to r:stablish
any public law element justifying invocation of rrrri -iurisdiclior-r.
According to them, Writ Petition is based entircli dn disputed
questions of fact, including technical evaluation, scoring :rnd
ranking, which cannot be adjudicated in writ prt :cedings. On
this ground zrlone, the u,rit petition is stated to bc nis<:onceived
and liable to be dismissed.
4.1.
Respondent No. 5 contends th:.
they are
profcssionally managed private limited company : ;tablishecl in
Z
I
l9
2006 having 18 years of experience in the field of security
services with branch ofhces across 11 States including New
Delhi, Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Gujarat, Jharkhand,
Telangana, Rajasthan, Andhra Pradesh, Chandigarh and
Chhattisgarh. It is further contended that they manage more
than 5,500 security personnel across India and successfully
partnered with more than 100 Central and Statc Government
deparLme nts, with a sustained growth rate of 5O to 8O7o.
4.2.
Respondent No.5 participated in Tender datcd
28.Oa.2025 facilitated by Respondent No.2, for providing
unarmed security services at a healthcare facility for a contract
period of one year, with an estimated bid value of INR
1,24,72,OO,21.441-. They submitted its bid diligentty and
lurnished all documents, certifications and particulars striclly
in accordance with the tender conditions. A total of 62 bidders
participated in the said tender. Upon preliminary scmtiny, i5
bidders were shortlisted and out of those, 7 bidders were found
technically qualihed. It is contended that technical scores o[ 7
qualilred bidders ranged between 70 ard 90 marks. Among
these 7 bidders, top five were placed in Hl category, while the
remaining two were categorized as H2 and H3 respectively,
L
ll
strictly in accordance with the evaluation critt: ia prescribed
under the tender document.
4.3.
It is further contended, Tencl :
Evalui,rtion
Committee short.listed I 5 bidders out of 62 based , ,n verificirtion
of documents uploaded on the Government -Mzrrketplace
Portal. Upon such scrutiny, Respondent No.i was fr>und
technically-compliant and was duly shortlisted zrl: rg with other
eligible bidders. It is asserted that the evaluation vas objective,
uniform and non discriminatory. It is conten( ed that the
challenge raised by Petilioners to the technical cr teria releLting
to average antruztl tLtrnover and mark break-up s\ : tem is wllolly
untenable. Ac<:ording to Respondent No.5, the tt:r I nical criteria
uniformly applied to all 62 bidders and the de,rmination of
eligibility criteria and allocation of marks falls exc. Lsivcll'within
the domain of Respondents 2 to 4. Petrtio Lers, having
participated u,ith ftrll knowledgc ol the criteria, cirrr rbt challt:nge
lhe same after be ing unsuccessful.
4.4.
Respondent No.5 contends that tenrl, r document,
particularly pages 5 and 7, clearly prescribed tlrc methodolory
for awarding marks bascd on the average annual 1r rnover of the
preceding thrce financial years. Petitioners themsr' ,zes admitted
that their avcragc annual turnover was INR 64,85,'z0,O00/-. for
k
t
2.1
which they were rightly awarded 12 marks strictly as per the
tender conditions. The annual turnover of Respondent No.5 is
substantially higher than that of Petitioners, hence they were
rightly awarded 20 marks under the turnover criterion.
Respondent No.3, as thc procuring organization, had absolute
authority to prescribe the tender methodolory and evaluation
parameters. The competent authority constituted a Tender
Evaluation Committce, u,hich applied the prescribed scoring
mcthodologr uniformly to all bidders based on documents
submitted. No deviation or preferential trcatment is alleged or
established.
4.5.
Respondent No.5 disputes Petitioners' claim that
execution of more than f-rve contracts automatically entitles a
bidder to 20 marks. It is contended that tender required
submission of present operational contracts in the relevant field.
While Petitioners submitted six contracts, one was not accepted
by the competent authority. In contrast, Respondent No.5
submitted eight currcntly operational contracts, of which seven
involved deployment of more than forty outsourced contractual
personnel. Respondent No.5 and Petitioners were evaluated
strictly under the same criteria. Respondent No.5, having scored
higher marks under the prescribed parameters and having been
ti
found more suitable, was rightly placed above tht' )etitioners in
the technical evaluation. Respondent No.5 further r ontt:nds that
the lender prescribed separate criteria for total cx terience ernd
experience in Govcrnment, Semi-(iovernment and )ublic Sector
Undertakings. Any company with more than 1() , ears of total
experience r,r,as r:ntitlcd to 15 marks, and any (, mpany urith
more than 10 years of experience in the rek r ant field in
Government, Serni Government or PSUs u,as cr titled to 20
marks. Respondent No.5, being registered irr 2006 and
continuously engaged in the relevant he1d, fully s rtisfied both
criteria and was rightl-y awarded thc corrcsponding narks.
4.6.
It is contcndcd that Respondent No.l, had no role
whatsoever in the processing or e valuation of tl'r,r tcr-rder. The
entire process u,zrs conductcd through the GeM I rrtal, which
automatically progresses through evaluation stail s based on
predefined svstcrn protocols. All evaluatio.r" .,'- d therelbre
independent, objective and transparent. It is adm ,led that five
out of the seven shortlisted bidders, including Pct tioners and
Respondent No.5, quoted an identical financial bid of INR
12,47 ,19,O81.85/ -. Howevcr, Respondent No.5 errt rged as the
successful H 1 bidder on account of securin5l he highest
technical score among the H I bidders and was tlrr:r-r fore ranked
I
I
i
at the top. Respondent No.S secured 90 out of 100 marks in the
technical evaluation, whereas Petitioners secured only 77 marks
and were rightly placed in the H2 category. Petitioners, having
been aware of the tender conditions and having participated
voluntarily, cannot challenge the process merely because the
outcome was unfavourable [o them. Respondent No.5 further
contends that it aiso possesses a valid MSME certificate.
Petitioners' SC/ST MSME status, by itself, cannot override a
technically superior bidder, particularly where technical score is
the prescribed tie breaker and the top bidder is equally MSME
compliant.
4.7 .
It is contended that Petitioners' existing contract,
extended till 30.11.2025, does not create any vested or
legitimate right to secure the new contract. Such extension is
only a stopgap arrangement and cannot be relied upon in a
fresh tender process. Respondent No.S lurther contends that
themselves and Petitioners participated in an earlier tender
dated 21.05.2025 issued by ESIC for providing Healthcare
Sanitation Services. In that tender, Petitioners secured HS rank,
Respondent No.5 secured H2 rank, and the contract was
awarded to BVG India Limited as Hl bidder. It is contended
that the tender dated 21 .O5.2O25 contained the verv same
selection criteria and turnover-based scoring slabs, -anging from
10 to 2O marks, identical lo [he tender datr:c 28.O4.2025.
Despite the uniform application of identical ;ritr:ria, the
Petitioners did not challenge the earlier tcnder anrl havt: chosen
to challenge the present tender only because the c aluation did
not yield a favourablc result.
4.a.
Respondent No.5 places reliance on tl c judgments
of the Hon'ble Suprcme Court in Afcons Infrastttt :ture Ltd. a.
Nagpur Metro Rail Corporation Ltd.2 Jagdist Mandal o.
State of Ortssae and MS Michigan Rubber (In dia) Ltd. u.
State oJ Karnatakaa, to contend that mere disaS;r eemr:nt u,ith
tender evaluation does not warrant judicial inlt, ference and
that courts must defer to the tendering authorit.r L-rnlcss mala
fides, arbitrariness or perversitl, is establishecl. It is finally
contended that Writ Petition is a clear attempt bv i d isgruntled
and unsucr'cssful bidder to dcrail a lawfully r, r r.ilu,led and
transparent tender process on speculative allt:gations.
Respondent No.5 asserts that its selection as Lhc highest
qualifying H I bidder is strictly in conformity u,itl the tender
'1zoto; ro scc a rs
'(2007) l4 scc 5 tl
' lzotz; s scc z ro
t,
conditions and applicable 1aw and that the Writ petition
deserves dismissal.
5.
Heard Sri Raja Sripathi Rao, learned Senior
Counsel on behalf of Sri Pasham Mohith, learned counsel for
petitioners, Sri N. Bhujanga Rao, Iearned Deputy Soiicitor
General on behalf of Respondent No.l, Sri G. Venkateshwarlu,
learned Standing Counsel for Respondents 2 to 4, and Sri
Madan Mohan Rao, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf
of Sri M.P.K. Aditya, learned counsel for Respondent No.5.
6.
At the outsel, the undisputed factual position that
emerges from the record is [hat Tender dated 28.O8.2025 was
admittedly governed by the Guidelines dated 14.11.2024 issued
by the 2"a Respondent [or engagement of contractual manpower
in establishments run by the Employees State Insurance
Corporation. The bid document itself contains a specihc
reference acknowledging the applicability of the said Guidelines.
Having expressly adopted the Guidelines dated 14.1L.2024 as
the governing framework, Respondents were bound to adhere to
the same in letter and spirit while formulating the tender
conditions as well as while undertaking the technical
evaluation
7.
A careful examination of the Guidt lines dated
14.11.2024 reveals that Lhe turnover-based evaluat on criterion
is exhaustively prescribed therein. The Guideliner; consciously
restrict the mark break up for turnover to only -hree slabs,
namely 1O, 15 and 20 marks. The object of such re-' ricted slabs
is clearly to prevent arbitrary gradation, eliminat: subjectivity
and ensure uniformity and fairness in technic.l evaluation
across ESIC establishments. However, in the pl't sent tender
dated 28.08.2025, the 3'd Respondent introduccil as many as
ten different slabs ranging from 1O to 2O marks. T: Ls departure
is not a minor procedural deviation but a substanli ,e alteration
of the evaluation framework prescribed under ,he binding
Guidelines. Significantly, no material has been plac :d on recclrd
by Respondents to demonstrate that any approval, 'elaxation or
deviation from the Guidelines dated 14. ll.2O24 't as obtained
from the competent authority. In the absence of s ' :6 approval,
unilateral introduction of multiple turnover slat,{ bY the 3'd
Respondent clearly ultra uires the Guidelines whi,: r admittedly
govern the tender. Once the Gr,ridelines are held t( be binding,
Respondents cannot seleclively apply or ignore por .ions thereof
to suit the outcome of [he tender process.
(,
t
8.
This Court also finds considerable force in the
contention of Petitioners rvith respect to the turnover
requireme nL prescribed under the tender. The minimum average
annual turnover of INR 49,89,0O,OO0/- has been stipulated for
a contract u.hose total value is only INR 12,47,2O,O2l l-. Such a
requirement is nearly four times the contract value. Even
assuming that the Manual for Procurement of Non-Consultancy
Services rclied upon by Respondents is applicable, the said
Manual itself mandate s that technical criteria must be relevant,
reasonable and proportional to the scope and value of the
contract and should not be framcd in a manner that excludes
otherwise competent bidders.
9.
In the present case, Petitioners demonstrated that
their average annual turnover is far in excess of the contract
value and that they are already perlorming the very same work
as existing service providers. In such circumstances, rfixation of
an excessively high turnover threshold, coupled with an
artihcial gradation of marks, cannot be justified on the
touchstone of proportionality. The principle of proportionality,
which has now become an integral facet o[ Rrtltte t+, stands
clearly violated.
,].
10.
The Court lurther hnds merit in the ch:L lenge to the
experience criterion adopted by Respondcnts. Imp:;ition of :rn
additional requirement that only those operatiot r I r:ontracts
involving deployment of a minimum o[ 4O outsourlc 1 pcrsonnel
per contract r,r,ould be considered for awarding ftr]l r rarks is rtot
traceable either to the Guidelines dated 14. 1 1.201 1 or to any
statutory provision. The Guidelines do not conl( mplate any
such numerical threshold relating to manpowcr :r rcngth in a
single contract.
The material placed on record br Petitione rs,
1.
including wage registers, pay slips and other s[alr. r ]ry recor<ls,
pima facie establishes that actual deployment r lnanpo\\'er
exceeded 40 personnel by accounting for relievers l rd statutory
compliance under labour 1aws. Reliance solely on ll 3 rnanpouer
figures mentioned in work orders, while completelv ignoring the
actual manpower deployed on thc ground, refle, rr r ('1,'ar n()n-
application of nrind and mechanical evaluatrr r
Such an
approach defeats the very purpose of assess r g lr:chnical
capability and experience.
12.
The allegation of misrepresentation lcu rllecl against
Petitioners by Respondents also does not stan( to judicial
!
scrutiny.-Except lbr a bald assertion based on figrrlr s mcntioned
in one work ordcr, no cogent material has been produced to
discredit the documentary evidcnce furnished by Petitioners. On
thc contrary, the contemporaneous wage registers and pay slips
lend credcnce to Petitioners' assertion regarding actual
deployment. In the absence of clear and convincing material, the
serious allegation of misrepresentation cannot be sustained.
13-
The Court also takes note of the fact that in the
prcsent tendcr, hve out of sevcn shortlisted bidders quoted
identical financial bids. In such a scenario, technical evaluation
assumes decisive and determinative significance. When the
outcome of the tender hinges substantially on technical scores,
any iilegality, arbitrariness or deviation lrom prescribed norms
at the stage of technical evaluation vitiates the entire selection
process. Petitioners demonstrated Lhat, but for the illegal
grading and arbitrary denial of marks, and the failure of the
Evaluation Committee to consider their status as an MSME
entily belonging to the SC/ST category despite their emergence
as H 1 bidders, they would have secured substantially higher
technical scores.
L4
It is true that the scope of judicial review in tender
matters is limited and that courts ordinarily refrain from
interfering in commercial decisions of the State. However, it is
equally well-settled that such sell imposed restra 1 t does not
operate as an absolute bar. Where the tender coni i ions or the
evaluation process are found to be arbitrary, dil;, riminatory,
irrational or in direcl contravention of binding gu r t:lines, this
Court would be lailing in its constitutional duty if L declines Lo
intervene.
15.
[n thc present case, cumulative t I 'ect of the
deviations from the
Guidelines dated
I 4 .1 1 .2024 .
disproportionatc turnover requirement, intro luction ol
extraneous eligibility conditions, and mechanical manner in
which the tcchnical evaluation was undertir icn clezrrl-v
demonstrates arbitrariness and violation of the do r rine of levcl
playing held. The Court is also constrained to oI):( rve Lha[ the
Evaluation Committee did not apply its mind to tlL, Pctjtioners'
status as an MSME entity belonging to the S(l ' lT categor],
despite Petitroners having emerged as one anr ,ng thc H I
biclders. The failure to consider such a materi:r I Lnd relev.rn t
aspect, while finalising the technical cvaluatir>n rcnders the
process not only proceduraily flawed but substiur ively unfair.
The tender procoss, therefore, stands vitiated irt the stage of
technical evaluation itself.
3l
16.
This Courl is therefore of the considered view that
the impugned action of Respondents in evaluating the technical
bids and in awarding the tender pursuant to Tender dated
28.O8.2025 cannot be sustained in law. Petitioners have made
out a clear case for interference under Article 226 of Lh.e
Constitution of India.
17.
For the foregoing reasons and in view of the
detailed discussion hereinabovc, this Court holds that the
tcnder conditions as well as the technical evaluation carried out
pursuant to Tender dated 28.Oa.2025 bearing No.
cEMl2025lBl6488045 are in clear derogation of the binding
Guidelines dated 14. l),.2024 issued by the 2"d Respondent. The
deviations in the formulation of eligibility criteria, the arbitrary
manner of technical evaluation, and the failure of the
Evaluation Committee to consider the Petitioners' MSME status
and their belonging to the SC/ST category, despite their position
as H 1 bidders, reflect non-application of mind, lack of
proportionality and institutional unfairness. The impugned
action, therefore, violates the mandate of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India.
18.
In the result, the Writ Petition is allowed. The action
of Respondents in awarding tender pursuant to Tender dated
(
I
2a.Oa.2025 bearing No. GtrM/2O251816488045 in : vour of the
5th Respondent is set aside. Official Respondents:ut directed to
undcrtakr: a fresh technical evaluation o[ thc bic r strictly in
accordance uith the Guidelines dated 14.11.'2t) 14 and in
conformity n,ith tl-re observations and principles lr id clown in
this judgment. Such fresh evaluation shall be com: cted within
a reusonzrblc period of eight weeks from the datc o[ rcceipt of a
copy of this order. No costs.
19.
Conseqnently, the miscellaneous Ap : ications, ii
/
any shall stand closcd.
.PONNA KRISHNA
SD/. t -ANT
REGISTRAR
ASSII;
,-.\ \
//TRUE COPY//
\\
I
SECTION OFFICER
I
To,
Ministry 9f.!lb^o.ur an[tnr
1' The Secretary. Union of lndia,
New Delhi-'110 001
rloyment Shram
iiirr.iiriii**in, n,riMarg,
bt eia 1 e#,ffi
":l:
z ii.iJ iii,"""tdi
"
a tm niWm,T I'J', a'i:' T]
Bhi
at PanchdeeP
off ice
:i:rr::i':"s,*ni[r+il'll'l'*TlrJl"'lail3x't'n't]'
'**i?i"fl
ce
r
ii;o"" ;;i,;;' :50obo 5, r"L-n-{un lgo
5mqloylej
038'
i#pTi"*" dil;;;',";
J
n1
S tat
I
nsu ra n
H6ipi[ai sanatnnasai' Sanjee"' :ddv-500
Hvderabad
lnsurance
commitlge, Employee ; State
4 The convenor, Tender Evaluation
r co t"s" *+5:i353tn:?
il;p;;;il; SRIbqit,
i3"llt Ge reral of lndia' Hish
PASHA
S- ONd CC tO
'
-nr
t
r
6 One CC ro SRt N.BHuilr.ibl'natj, ij;p;tv silicitor
gB"'1,.'3[y3' es state nsura nce
3""[t's..,Ya $it"""J,Ifrff Eamnn:
;
I
Corooration. tOPUCI
8. #5cc'6'6h'i rtr ik.notrvA, Advocate' [oPUC]
9. Two CD CoPies.
,/t .
BSK
ry,.
*1
HIGH COURT
DATED:2110112026
ORDER
WP.No.34632 of 2025
t$
-t
i,,
\. I
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
a
D
v
T}IE S 14
{ Ft8 206
*
z
I
I
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review