Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 22ndSeptember, 2026
%
#
CNR No. DLHC010446942026
+
ARB.P. 1684/2026
M/S MULTI TECH CONSTRUCTION CO.
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Dhiraj Sachdeva, Advocate.
versus
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT, GNCTD
.....Respondent
Through: Ms. Rachita Garg, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE JYOTI SINGH
JUDGEMENT
JYOTI SINGH, J. (ORAL)
1.
This petition is filed on behalf of the Petitioner under Section 11(6) of
the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (‘1996 Act’) seeking
appointment of an Arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes between the parties.
2.
To the extent necessary, the facts are that Respondent invited tenders
for construction of 162 Nos. of additional SPS classrooms in different
schools under the Delhi Government as also for works such as water supply,
sanitary installations, firefighting systems etc. Petitioner’s tender was
accepted and work was awarded with stipulated date of completion being
15.08.2019. As per the Petitioner, the work was delayed due to defaults of
and hindrances by the Respondent, owing to which extensions were granted.
On 20.02.2023, Respondent released payment against the Final Bill but huge
amounts remained outstanding. Petitioner raised demands but the same were
rejected on 13.10.2023. On 20.08.2024, Petitioner sent notice invoking
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
19:55:36
ARB.P. 1684/2026
arbitration under arbitration Clause 25 of GCC. Respondent failed to appoint
the Arbitrator and hence, this petition was filed. Learned counsel for the
Petitioner submits that Clause 25 of GCC provides for reference of disputes
arising out of the contract in question to arbitration and therefore, there can
be no impediment in appointment of the Arbitrator. He, however, questions
the appointment by Chief Engineer, CPWD or if there is no Chief Engineer,
by the Additional Director General of CPWD of the concerned region or
Director General, CPWD, in the absence of the ADG on the ground that this
would amount to unilateral appointment in the teeth of the judgments in
Perkins Eastman Architects DPC and Another v. HSCC (India) Limited,
(2020) 20 SCC 760 and Central Organisation for Railway Electrification
v. ECI-SPIC-SMO-MCML (JV) a Joint Venture Company, 2024 SCC
OnLine SC 3219.
3.
Learned counsel for the Respondent, fairly does not dispute the
existence of the Arbitration Agreement between the parties and
consequently, reference of the disputes. She, however, submits that
appointment of the Sole Arbitrator is the prerogative of the Officer
designated in Clause 25 of GCC and therefore, the appointment ought to be
left to be made in accordance with the said Clause.
4.
It is no longer res integra that the scope of examination in a petition
under Section 11(6) of 1996 Act is confined to a prima facie enquiry of
existence of Arbitration Agreement. In SBI General Insurance Company
Limited v. Krish Spinning, (2024) 12 SCC 1, the Supreme Court delineated
the contours of judicial intervention at the stage of Section 11 of 1996 Act,
observing that the scope of examination is confined to existence of
Arbitration Agreement and the scrutiny does not include a contested or
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
19:55:36
ARB.P. 1684/2026
laborious enquiry, which is to be left to the Arbitral Tribunal and that this
approach serves twofold purposes: (a) allows the Referral Court to weed out
non-existent arbitration agreements; and (b) protects the jurisdictional
competence of the Arbitral Tribunal to rule on the issue of existence under
Section 16, in depth.
5.
The contest in the present petition by the Respondent is with regard to
the Appointing Authority of the Sole Arbitrator as stipulated in Clause 25 of
GCC. For ready reference, Clause 25 is extracted hereunder:“…….. If the Dispute Redressal Committee (DRC) fails to give his
decision within the aforesaid period or any party is dissatisfied with the
decision of Dispute Redressal Committee (DRC), then either party may
within a period of 30 days from the receipt of the decision of Dispute
Redressal Committee (DRC), give notice to the Chief Engineer for
appointment of arbitrator on prescribed proforma as per Appendix XV,
failing which the said decision shall be final binding and conclusive and
not referable to adjudication by the arbitrator. It is a term of contract that
each party invoking arbitration must exhaust the aforesaid mechanism of
settlement of claims/disputes prior to invoking arbitration. (ii) Except
where the decision has become final, binding and conclusive in terms of
Sub Para (i) above, disputes or difference shall be referred for
adjudication through arbitration by a sole arbitrator appointed by the
Chief Engineer, CPWD, in charge of the work or if there be no Chief
Engineer, the Additional Director General of the concerned region of
CPWD or if there be no Additional Director General, the Director
General, CPWD. If the arbitrator so appointed is unable or unwilling to
act or resigns his appointment or vacates his office due to any reason
whatsoever, another sole arbitrator shall be appointed in the manner
aforesaid. Such person shall be entitled to proceed with the reference from
the stage at which it was left by his predecessor. It is a term of this
contract that the party invoking arbitration shall give a list of disputes
with amounts claimed in respect of each such dispute along with the notice
for appointment of arbitrator and giving reference to the rejection by the
Chief Engineer of the appeal. It is also a term of this contract that no
person, other than a person appointed by such Chief Engineer CPWD or
Additional Director General or Director General, CPWD, as aforesaid,
should act as arbitrator and if for any reason that is not possible, the
matter shall not be referred to arbitration at all. It is also a term of this
contract that if the contractor does not make any demand for appointment
of arbitrator in respect of any claims in writing as aforesaid within 120
days of receiving the intimation from the Engineer-in-charge that the final
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
19:55:36
ARB.P. 1684/2026
bill is ready for payment, the claim of the contractor shall be deemed to
have been waived and absolutely barred and the Government shall be
discharged and released of all liabilities under the contract in respect of
these claims. The arbitration shall be conducted in accordance with the
provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of 1996) or
any statutory modifications or reenactment thereof and the rules made
thereunder and for the time being in force shall apply to the arbitration
proceeding under this clause. It is also a term of this contract that the
arbitrator shall adjudicate on only such disputes as are referred to him by
the appointing authority and give separate award against each dispute
and claim referred to him and in all cases where the total amount of the
claims by any party exceeds Rs. 1,00,000/-., the arbitrator shall give
reasons for the award. It is also a term of the contract that if any fees are
payable to the arbitrator, these shall be paid equally by both the parties. It
is also a term of the contract that the arbitrator shall be deemed to have
entered on the reference on the date he issues notice to both the parties
calling them to submit their statement of claims and counter statement of
claims. The venue of the arbitration shall be such place as may be fixed by
the arbitrator in his sole discretion. The fees, if any, of the arbitrator shall,
if required to be paid before the award is made and published, be paid
half and half by each of the parties. The cost of the reference and of the
award (including the fees, if any, of the arbitrator) shall be in the
discretion of the arbitrator who may direct to any by whom and in what
manner, such costs or any part thereof shall be paid and fix or settle the
amount of costs to be so paid.”
6.
The moot question that arises for consideration is whether the
procedure envisaged in Clause 25 of GCC, wherein Chief Engineer/ADG/
DG is empowered to appoint a Sole Arbitrator, is tenable in law and in my
view, this question need not detain the Court as it stands settled in plethora
of judgments. In Perkins (supra), the Supreme Court held that even where
the Managing Director of a party to the Arbitration Agreement does not
himself act as an Arbitrator but is authorised to appoint any other person of
his choice or discretion, considering that he will have an interest in the
outcome of the dispute, he would be disentitled to make the appointment.
The Supreme Court emphasised on: (a) party autonomy; and (b) likelihood
of bias of the appointing authority having interest in the outcome or result of
the dispute and relevant passage is as follows:Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
19:55:36
ARB.P. 1684/2026
“20. We thus have two categories of cases. The first, similar to the one
dealt with in TRF Ltd. [TRF Ltd. v. Energo Engg. Projects Ltd., (2017) 8
SCC 377: (2017) 4 SCC (Civ) 72] where the Managing Director himself is
named as an arbitrator with an additional power to appoint any other
person as an arbitrator. In the second category, the Managing Director is
not to act as an arbitrator himself but is empowered or authorised to
appoint any other person of his choice or discretion as an arbitrator. If, in
the first category of cases, the Managing Director was found incompetent,
it was because of the interest that he would be said to be having in the
outcome or result of the dispute. The element of invalidity would thus be
directly relatable to and arise from the interest that he would be having in
such outcome or decision. If that be the test, similar invalidity would
always arise and spring even in the second category of cases. If the
interest that he has in the outcome of the dispute, is taken to be the basis
for the possibility of bias, it will always be present irrespective of whether
the matter stands under the first or second category of cases. We are
conscious that if such deduction is drawn from the decision of this Court in
TRF Ltd. [TRF Ltd. v. Energo Engg. Projects Ltd., (2017) 8 SCC 377 :
(2017) 4 SCC (Civ) 72] , all cases having clauses similar to that with
which we are presently concerned, a party to the agreement would be
disentitled to make any appointment of an arbitrator on its own and it
would always be available to argue that a party or an official or an
authority having interest in the dispute would be disentitled to make
appointment of an arbitrator.”
7.
The Supreme Court referred to the judgment in TRF Limited v.
Energo Engineering Projects Limited, (2017) 8 SCC 377, where the
Managing Director himself was a named Arbitrator and found him to be
ineligible/incompetent on account of interest he would have in the outcome
of the dispute, observing that similar invalidity would apply, where the
ineligible person appoints another Arbitrator. This principle was reaffirmed
by the Supreme Court in Bharat Broadband Network Limited v. United
Telecoms Limited, (2019) 5 SCC 755. In Proddatur Cable TV Digi Services
v. Siti Cable Network Limited, 2020 SCC OnLine Del 350, this Court held
that the unilateral appointment of the arbitrator by one party to the contract
does not meet the test of impartiality and independence under Section 12(5)
of 1996 Act, relying on the judgment in Perkins (supra).
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
19:55:36
ARB.P. 1684/2026
8.
The instant case is squarely covered by the decision of this Court in
Mahavir Prasad Gupta and Sons v. Government of NCT of Delhi, in
ARB.P. 716/2026, decided on 11.08.2026, where Court was considering a
petition under Section 11 (5) and (6) of 1996 Act and same Arbitration
Clause 25 of GCC, contemplating appointment of Sole Arbitrator by Chief
Engineer, CPWD. Court appointed the Sole Arbitrator holding that official
of a party to the dispute can neither be appointed as an Arbitrator nor
appoint an Arbitrator and this portion of Clause 25 permitting the Chief
Engineer to appoint the Arbitrator is void albeit it will not dent the
substantive agreement between the parties to refer the disputes to arbitration.
Court relied on the judgment of the Supreme Court in Hindustan
Construction Company Limited v. Bihar Rajya Pul Nirman Nigam
Limited and Others, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2578, where the Supreme Court
held that the portion of the arbitration clause which vests exclusive
appointment power in one party must be severed as void and unenforceable.
Therefore, it is now authoritatively settled that unilateral appointment of
Arbitrators by parties interested in the outcome of the dispute is an anathema
to 1996 Act and in such cases, it is incumbent on the Court to appoint an
independent and impartial Arbitrator, when approached for appointment
under Section 11 (6) of 1996 Act.
9.
There can be no quarrel that appointment of Arbitrators by parties to
the dispute will certainly lead to a possibility of bias and as held by the
Supreme Court in CORE (supra), the party appointing the Arbitrator will
have control and will be in a dominating position to chart the course of
action of the arbitration proceedings to the prejudice of the other party.
Unilateral appointment clause is therefore inherently exclusionary and
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
19:55:36
ARB.P. 1684/2026
violates the principles of equal treatment of parties and procedural equality.
The whole objective of taking recourse to arbitration as an alternate dispute
resolution mechanism is impartial resolution of disputes between the parties
and unilateral appointment clauses are in the teeth of this objective. In light
of the wealth of judicial precedents on this subject, Clause 25 of GCC, to the
extent it empowers the Respondent to appoint the Sole Arbitrator is void and
unenforceable albeit to the extent the clause is an expression of the intent of
the parties to arbitrate, it will remain enforceable and valid.
10.
Accordingly, this petition is allowed, appointing Mr. Abhilash
Mathur, Advocate (Mobile No. 9811041536) as the Sole Arbitrator to
adjudicate the disputes between the parties. Arbitral proceedings will be held
under the aegis of Delhi International Arbitration Centre (‘DIAC’). Fee of
the Arbitrator is fixed as per fee schedule under DIAC (Administrative Costs
& Arbitrators’ Fees) Rules, 2018.
11.
Learned Arbitrator shall give disclosure under Section 12 of the 1996
Act before entering upon reference.
12.
It is made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion on the
merits of the case and all rights and contentions of the respective parties are
left open.
13.
It is left open to the Respondent to prefer a counter claim, if any,
before the learned Arbitrator.
14.
Petition is disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
JYOTI SINGH, J
SEPTEMBER 22, 2026
S.Sharma
Digitally Signed
By:KAMAL KUMAR
19:55:36
ARB.P. 1684/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review